{
 "description": "One canonical grade per published protocol (DELTA / PROTECTIVE / ALIGNED / OBSERVED) and a 5-factor control-plane rosette derived deterministically from Pacta's published records (index.json, rpc-pinned.json) and controller facts. A factor the published evidence does not decide is 'n' (not determined); docs-vs-chain parity is 'u' (uncompared) for every RPC-observed protocol. States: g strong, b moderate, a weak, n not determined, u uncompared.",
 "factorCoverage": {
  "emergency": 25,
  "parity": 189,
  "quorum": 168,
  "timelock": 102,
  "upgrade": 44
 },
 "factors": [
  {
   "key": "upgrade",
   "label": "Upgradeability"
  },
  {
   "key": "timelock",
   "label": "Timelock floor"
  },
  {
   "key": "quorum",
   "label": "Signer quorum"
  },
  {
   "key": "emergency",
   "label": "Emergency / freeze scope"
  },
  {
   "key": "parity",
   "label": "Docs-vs-chain parity"
  }
 ],
 "grades": {
  "aligned": {
   "label": "ALIGNED",
   "meaning": "Docs and chain match",
   "protocols": 126
  },
  "delta": {
   "label": "DELTA",
   "meaning": "Docs and chain differ",
   "protocols": 56
  },
  "observed": {
   "label": "OBSERVED",
   "meaning": "Chain pinned; docs not assessed",
   "protocols": 127
  },
  "protective": {
   "label": "PROTECTIVE",
   "meaning": "Chain stronger than documented",
   "protocols": 7
  }
 },
 "protocols": [
  {
   "baskets": [
    "lending_vaults"
   ],
   "category": "Leveraged exposure vaults over tokenized real-world assets, built on Morpho (Ethereum)",
   "chains": [
    "ethereum"
   ],
   "deltas": 0,
   "easAttested": false,
   "evidence": {
    "documented": "3F documentation is linked for reference (https://docs.3f.xyz/). This RPC-pinned record does not compare documentation parameters with the on-chain state.",
    "observed": "ERC1967Factory (0x54F862fa0612A8709F6Dec4A7B39AF015CD4E82E) verified on Ethereum Mainnet at canonical block #26,458,556 (1,887 bytes runtime code). EIP-1967 implementation and admin storage slots are both zero (non-EIP-1967 contract). No owner(), admin(), authority(), curator() or AccessControl admin was readable on the contract.",
    "recordId": "3f-control-plane",
    "surface": "ERC1967Factory · Non-Proxy Bytecode & Controller"
   },
   "factors": [
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "upgrade",
     "label": "Upgradeability",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "Upgrade path not in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "timelock",
     "label": "Timelock floor",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No enforced admin delay in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "quorum",
     "label": "Signer quorum",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No signer quorum in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "emergency",
     "label": "Emergency / freeze scope",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No pause / freeze authority in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "parity",
     "label": "Docs-vs-chain parity",
     "state": "u",
     "value": "Uncompared: documentation not assessed (RPC-observed)"
    }
   ],
   "finding": "ERC1967Factory · Non-Proxy Bytecode & Controller",
   "grade": "observed",
   "gradeLabel": "OBSERVED",
   "name": "3F",
   "pinnedBlock": 26458556,
   "probe": {
    "block_hash": "0xe258bb1cbcc988e2dfdba4ba173f9f8690520dba3647cdcae18e0651822769d2",
    "block_number": 26458556,
    "call_args": [],
    "call_signature": "owner()",
    "chain": "ethereum",
    "check_type": "eth_call",
    "extra_calls": [],
    "id": "3f-control-plane",
    "repro_calldata": "0x8da5cb5b",
    "rpc_env_var": "$ETH_RPC_URL",
    "selector_or_slot": "0x8da5cb5b",
    "target_contract": "0x54F862fa0612A8709F6Dec4A7B39AF015CD4E82E",
    "target_label": "ERC1967Factory"
   },
   "reconciled": false,
   "reconciledFrom": [],
   "reconciledTo": [],
   "records": 1,
   "rosetteAria": "3F control-plane rosette: Upgradeability not determined; Timelock floor not determined; Signer quorum not determined; Emergency / freeze scope not determined; Docs-vs-chain parity uncompared",
   "search": "3f 3f leveraged exposure vaults over tokenized real-world assets, built on morpho (ethereum) 3f 0x54f862fa0612a8709f6dec4a7b39af015cd4e82e",
   "slug": "3f",
   "summary_short": "Non-proxy contract no readable owner or admin; docs not assessed",
   "url": "https://pacta.wtf/protocols/3f/"
  },
  {
   "baskets": [
    "lending_vaults",
    "stable_rwa"
   ],
   "category": "Uncollateralized Credit Money Market (USDC) (Ethereum)",
   "chains": [
    "ethereum"
   ],
   "deltas": 0,
   "easAttested": true,
   "evidence": {
    "documented": "'TimelockController (7d) | Upgrades admin' (docs.3jane.xyz/developers/addresses.md)",
    "observed": "Upgrades admin timelock 0x3D3C41419Ab401cd25055E8f9421D7D96d887885 (Ethereum): getMinDelay() = 604800s (7 d).",
    "recordId": "3jane-lending-timelock-delay-s26",
    "surface": "3Jane Lending Upgrades admin: 7-day minimum delay, as documented"
   },
   "factors": [
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "upgrade",
     "label": "Upgradeability",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "Upgrade path not in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": "3jane-lending-timelock-delay-s26: observed_delay_seconds = 604800",
     "key": "timelock",
     "label": "Timelock floor",
     "state": "g",
     "value": "7d minimum enforced delay across control surfaces"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "quorum",
     "label": "Signer quorum",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No signer quorum in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "emergency",
     "label": "Emergency / freeze scope",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No pause / freeze authority in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "parity",
     "label": "Docs-vs-chain parity",
     "state": "g",
     "value": "Chain matches or is stronger than the documentation"
    }
   ],
   "finding": "3Jane Lending Upgrades admin: 7-day minimum delay, as documented",
   "grade": "aligned",
   "gradeLabel": "ALIGNED",
   "name": "3Jane Lending",
   "pinnedBlock": 26438867,
   "probe": {
    "block_hash": "0x6c477521320837df8611249a255cb7142052874937cddb9fe568f685763458ff",
    "block_number": 26438867,
    "call_args": [],
    "call_signature": "getMinDelay()",
    "chain": "ethereum",
    "check_type": "eth_call",
    "extra_calls": [],
    "id": "3jane-lending-timelock-delay-s26",
    "repro_calldata": "0xf27a0c92",
    "rpc_env_var": "$ETH_RPC_URL",
    "selector_or_slot": "0xf27a0c92",
    "target_contract": "0x3D3C41419Ab401cd25055E8f9421D7D96d887885",
    "target_label": "Upgrades admin timelock"
   },
   "reconciled": false,
   "reconciledFrom": [],
   "reconciledTo": [],
   "records": 1,
   "rosetteAria": "3Jane Lending control-plane rosette: Upgradeability not determined; Timelock floor strong; Signer quorum not determined; Emergency / freeze scope not determined; Docs-vs-chain parity strong",
   "search": "3jane lending 3jane-lending uncollateralized credit money market (usdc) (ethereum) 3jane 0x3d3c41419ab401cd25055e8f9421d7d96d887885",
   "slug": "3jane-lending",
   "summary_short": "3Jane Lending's Upgrades admin acts through a 7-day timelock, as documented",
   "url": "https://pacta.wtf/protocols/3jane-lending/"
  },
  {
   "baskets": [
    "base",
    "lending_vaults"
   ],
   "category": "veNFT-backed lending vault (UUPS) on Base",
   "chains": [
    "base"
   ],
   "deltas": 1,
   "easAttested": true,
   "evidence": {
    "documented": "'40 Acres has completed four independent audits with Sherlock. Smart contracts are immutable and non-upgradeable post-deployment.' (docs.40acres.finance)",
    "observed": "40 Acres proxy 0x87f18b377e625b62c708D5f6EA96EC193558EFD0 (Base): EIP-1967 implementation slot = 0xb43b30c405c61BC330227968635d130994450735; the implementation's proxiableUUID() = the EIP-1967 slot (UUPS), UPGRADE_INTERFACE_VERSION() = '5.0.0'; owner() = 0xfF16fd3D147220E6CC002a8e4a1f942ac41DBD23, a Safe 2-of-3.",
    "recordId": "40-acres-base-upgradeability-s28",
    "surface": "Lending vault proxy: docs call the contracts immutable, but it is an upgradeable proxy"
   },
   "factors": [
    {
     "evidence": "40-acres-base-upgradeability-s28: 40 Acres proxy 0x87f18b377e625b62c708D5f6EA96EC193558EFD0 (Base): EIP-1967 implementation slot = 0xb43b30c405c61BC330227968635d130994450735",
     "key": "upgrade",
     "label": "Upgradeability",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "Upgradeable; the delay gating the upgrade path is not in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "timelock",
     "label": "Timelock floor",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No enforced admin delay in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": "40-acres-base-upgradeability-s28: … 0xfF16fd3D147220E6CC002a8e4a1f942ac41DBD23, a Safe 2-of-3.",
     "key": "quorum",
     "label": "Signer quorum",
     "state": "b",
     "value": "Lowest controlling quorum: 2-of-3"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "emergency",
     "label": "Emergency / freeze scope",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No pause / freeze authority in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "parity",
     "label": "Docs-vs-chain parity",
     "state": "a",
     "value": "Documentation differs from the chain (parameter delta)"
    }
   ],
   "finding": "Lending vault proxy: docs call the contracts immutable, but it is an upgradeable proxy: docs say '40 Acres has completed four independent audits with Sherlock. · chain says 40 Acres proxy 0x87f18b377e625b62c708D5f6EA96EC193558EFD0 (Base): EIP-1967 implementation slot = 0xb43b30c405c61BC330227968635d130994450735;",
   "grade": "delta",
   "gradeLabel": "DELTA",
   "name": "40 Acres (Base)",
   "pinnedBlock": 59025642,
   "probe": {
    "block_hash": "0x8fc618f8e02aa1fd1c3bcf1300fd25e40291a0fcde351bd39ad8cb61781d5e12",
    "block_number": 59025642,
    "call_args": [],
    "call_signature": null,
    "chain": "base",
    "check_type": "eth_getStorageAt",
    "extra_calls": [],
    "id": "40-acres-base-upgradeability-s28",
    "repro_calldata": null,
    "rpc_env_var": "$BASE_RPC_URL",
    "selector_or_slot": "0x360894a13ba1a3210667c828492db98dca3e2076cc3735a920a3ca505d382bbc",
    "target_contract": "0x87f18b377e625b62c708D5f6EA96EC193558EFD0",
    "target_label": "40 Acres vault proxy (UUPS)"
   },
   "reconciled": false,
   "reconciledFrom": [],
   "reconciledTo": [],
   "records": 1,
   "rosetteAria": "40 Acres (Base) control-plane rosette: Upgradeability not determined; Timelock floor not determined; Signer quorum moderate; Emergency / freeze scope not determined; Docs-vs-chain parity weak",
   "search": "40 acres (base) 40-acres-base venft-backed lending vault (uups) on base 40acres 0x87f18b377e625b62c708d5f6ea96ec193558efd0 0xb43b30c405c61bc330227968635d130994450735 0xff16fd3d147220e6cc002a8e4a1f942ac41dbd23",
   "slug": "40-acres-base",
   "summary_short": "Docs call 40 Acres immutable, but an upgradeable proxy sits on chain",
   "url": "https://pacta.wtf/protocols/40-acres-base/"
  },
  {
   "baskets": [
    "base",
    "lending_vaults"
   ],
   "category": "Lending Market (Base)",
   "chains": [
    "base"
   ],
   "deltas": 0,
   "easAttested": true,
   "evidence": {
    "documented": "aave.com/docs (governance): 'The Protocol Emergency Guardian is a 4 of 7 multi-signature wallet consisting of the following signers:' and 'The Protocol Emergency Guardian holds the EMERGENCY_ ADMIN'; ACL Manager docs: 'Holders of this role can pause and unpause the pool or an individual reserve.'",
    "observed": "Protocol Guardian Safe (0x56C1a4b54921DEA9A344967a8693C7E661D72968, v1.3.0): getThreshold() = 4 of 7 owners, the 7 signers listed in the docs; ACLManager 0x43955b0899Ab7232E3a454cf84AedD22Ad46FD33 hasRole(EMERGENCY_ADMIN, Safe) = true, hasRole(POOL_ADMIN, Safe) = false.",
    "recordId": "aave-v3-base-emergency-admin-protocol-guardian-4of7-s19",
    "surface": "EMERGENCY_ADMIN (pause / unpause) = Aave Protocol Guardian 4-of-7 Safe"
   },
   "factors": [
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "upgrade",
     "label": "Upgradeability",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "Upgrade path not in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": "aave-v3-base-payloads-level1-1d-delay-s19: observed_delay_seconds = 86400",
     "key": "timelock",
     "label": "Timelock floor",
     "state": "b",
     "value": "1d minimum enforced delay across control surfaces"
    },
    {
     "evidence": "controller fact: Safe getThreshold()",
     "key": "quorum",
     "label": "Signer quorum",
     "state": "g",
     "value": "Lowest controlling quorum: 4-of-7"
    },
    {
     "evidence": "aave-v3-base-emergency-admin-protocol-guardian-4of7-s19: Protocol Guardian Safe (0x56C1a4b54921DEA9A344967a8693C7E661D72968, v1.3.0): getThreshold() = 4 of 7 owners, the 7 signers listed in the docs",
     "key": "emergency",
     "label": "Emergency / freeze scope",
     "state": "g",
     "value": "Pause / freeze authority scoped behind a multi-signer controller (4-of-N Safe)"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "parity",
     "label": "Docs-vs-chain parity",
     "state": "g",
     "value": "Chain matches or is stronger than the documentation"
    }
   ],
   "finding": "EMERGENCY_ADMIN (pause / unpause) = Aave Protocol Guardian 4-of-7 Safe",
   "grade": "aligned",
   "gradeLabel": "ALIGNED",
   "name": "Aave V3 (Base)",
   "pinnedBlock": 57886975,
   "probe": {
    "block_hash": "0xf88ef5af0e0555ca6b7e28b325f5057163cb52d6ced0f509507613423c6ad277",
    "block_number": 57886975,
    "call_args": [],
    "call_signature": "getThreshold()",
    "chain": "base",
    "check_type": "eth_call",
    "extra_calls": [],
    "id": "aave-v3-base-emergency-admin-protocol-guardian-4of7-s19",
    "repro_calldata": "0xe75235b8",
    "rpc_env_var": "$BASE_RPC_URL",
    "selector_or_slot": "0xe75235b8",
    "target_contract": "0x56C1a4b54921DEA9A344967a8693C7E661D72968",
    "target_label": "Aave Protocol Guardian Safe (Base)"
   },
   "reconciled": false,
   "reconciledFrom": [],
   "reconciledTo": [],
   "records": 2,
   "rosetteAria": "Aave V3 (Base) control-plane rosette: Upgradeability not determined; Timelock floor moderate; Signer quorum strong; Emergency / freeze scope strong; Docs-vs-chain parity strong",
   "search": "aave v3 (base) aave-v3-base lending market (base) aave aave base 0x2dc219e716793fb4b21548c0f009ba3af753ab01 0x43955b0899ab7232e3a454cf84aedd22ad46fd33 0x56c1a4b54921dea9a344967a8693c7e661d72968 0x9390b1735def18560c509e2d0bc090e9d6ba257a 0x9aee0b04504cef83a65ac3f0e838d0593bcb2bc7 0xa238dd80c259a72e81d7e4664a9801593f98d1c5 0xe20fcbdbffc4dd138ce8b2e6fbb6cb49777ad64d",
   "slug": "aave-v3-base",
   "summary_short": "Pause and unpause admin is the Aave Guardian 4-of-7 Safe, as documented",
   "url": "https://pacta.wtf/protocols/aave-v3-base/"
  },
  {
   "baskets": [
    "lending_vaults",
    "stable_rwa"
   ],
   "category": "Blue-Chip Lending & Decentralized Stablecoin",
   "chains": [
    "ethereum"
   ],
   "deltas": 0,
   "easAttested": true,
   "evidence": {
    "documented": "Aave V3 & Governance v3 address book specifies Level 1 Short Executor (1-day execution delay) and 4-of-7 Protocol Guardian Safe.",
    "observed": "ACLManager hasRole(DEFAULT_ADMIN_ROLE, 0x5300A1a15135EA4dc7aD5a167152C01EFc9b192A) = true; PayloadsController (0xdAbad81aF85554E9ae636395611C58F7eC1aAEc5) getExecutorSettingsByAccessControl(1) = (0x5300A1a15135EA4dc7aD5a167152C01EFc9b192A, 86400s / 1d); EMERGENCY_ADMIN held by 4-of-7 Protocol Guardian Safe (0x2CFe3ec4d5a6811f4B8067F0DE7e47DfA938Aa30); GHO (0x40D16FC0246aD3160Ccc09B8D0D3A2cD28aE6C2f) totalSupply = 699,000,000 GHO.",
    "recordId": "aave-v3-gho-acl-manager-and-executor-lvl1",
    "surface": "ACLManager Admin Role, Executor Lvl1 Delay & Guardian Safe"
   },
   "factors": [
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "upgrade",
     "label": "Upgradeability",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "Upgrade path not in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "timelock",
     "label": "Timelock floor",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No enforced admin delay in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": "aave-v3-gho-acl-manager-and-executor-lvl1: … 86400s / 1d); EMERGENCY_ADMIN held by 4-of-7 Protocol Guardian Safe (0x2CFe3ec4d5a6811f4B8067F0DE7e47DfA938Aa30); …",
     "key": "quorum",
     "label": "Signer quorum",
     "state": "g",
     "value": "Lowest controlling quorum: 4-of-7"
    },
    {
     "evidence": "aave-v3-gho-acl-manager-and-executor-lvl1: EMERGENCY_ADMIN held by 4-of-7 Protocol Guardian Safe (0x2CFe3ec4d5a6811f4B8067F0DE7e47DfA938Aa30)",
     "key": "emergency",
     "label": "Emergency / freeze scope",
     "state": "g",
     "value": "Pause / freeze authority scoped behind a multi-signer controller (4-of-7)"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "parity",
     "label": "Docs-vs-chain parity",
     "state": "g",
     "value": "Chain matches or is stronger than the documentation"
    }
   ],
   "finding": "ACLManager Admin Role, Executor Lvl1 Delay & Guardian Safe",
   "grade": "aligned",
   "gradeLabel": "ALIGNED",
   "name": "Aave V3 / GHO",
   "pinnedBlock": 26402160,
   "probe": {
    "block_hash": "0xd04a5e8aa3500c5b60d90c25a810ef28eb9d1bfffadf28f1da58a31ed90582dc",
    "block_number": 26402160,
    "call_args": [
     "0x0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000",
     "0x5300A1a15135EA4dc7aD5a167152C01EFc9b192A"
    ],
    "call_signature": "hasRole(bytes32,address)",
    "chain": "ethereum",
    "check_type": "eth_call",
    "extra_calls": [],
    "id": "aave-v3-gho-acl-manager-and-executor-lvl1",
    "repro_calldata": "0x91d1485400000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000005300a1a15135ea4dc7ad5a167152c01efc9b192a",
    "rpc_env_var": "$ETH_RPC_URL",
    "selector_or_slot": "0x91d14854",
    "target_contract": "0xc2aaCf6553D20d1e9d78E365AAba8032af9c85b0",
    "target_label": "ACLManager"
   },
   "reconciled": false,
   "reconciledFrom": [],
   "reconciledTo": [],
   "records": 1,
   "rosetteAria": "Aave V3 / GHO control-plane rosette: Upgradeability not determined; Timelock floor not determined; Signer quorum strong; Emergency / freeze scope strong; Docs-vs-chain parity strong",
   "search": "aave v3 / gho aave-v3-gho blue-chip lending & decentralized stablecoin gho aave 0x2cfe3ec4d5a6811f4b8067f0de7e47dfa938aa30 0x2f39d218133afab8f2b819b1066c7e434ad94e9e 0x40d16fc0246ad3160ccc09b8d0d3a2cd28ae6c2f 0x5300a1a15135ea4dc7ad5a167152c01efc9b192a 0x7fc66500c84a76ad7e9c93437bfc5ac33e2ddae9 0x87870bca3f3fd6335c3f4ce8392d69350b4fa4e2 0xc2aacf6553d20d1e9d78e365aaba8032af9c85b0 0xdabad81af85554e9ae636395611c58f7ec1aaec5",
   "slug": "aave-v3-gho",
   "summary_short": "ACL admin role, executor delay and Guardian Safe match the docs",
   "url": "https://pacta.wtf/protocols/aave-v3-gho/"
  },
  {
   "baskets": [],
   "category": "Interest-bearing collateral loans minting MIM (Ethereum)",
   "chains": [
    "ethereum"
   ],
   "deltas": 1,
   "easAttested": true,
   "evidence": {
    "documented": "'The 5/10 multisign is composed of:' (docs.abracadabra.money/llms-full.txt)",
    "observed": "Abracadabra Spell Safe 0x5f0DeE98360d8200b20812e174d139A1a633EDd2 (Ethereum): getThreshold() = 5 of getOwners() = 11 owners (Safe v1.3.0); it controls MagicInternetMoneyV1 0x99D8a9C45b2ecA8864373A26D1459e3Dff1e17F3.",
    "recordId": "abracadabra-spell-safe-threshold-s30",
    "surface": "Abracadabra Spell multisig: docs state 5-of-10, the Safe is 5-of-11"
   },
   "factors": [
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "upgrade",
     "label": "Upgradeability",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "Upgrade path not in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "timelock",
     "label": "Timelock floor",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No enforced admin delay in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": "controller fact: Safe getThreshold()",
     "key": "quorum",
     "label": "Signer quorum",
     "state": "g",
     "value": "Lowest controlling quorum: 5-of-11"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "emergency",
     "label": "Emergency / freeze scope",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No pause / freeze authority in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "parity",
     "label": "Docs-vs-chain parity",
     "state": "a",
     "value": "Documentation differs from the chain (parameter delta)"
    }
   ],
   "finding": "Abracadabra Spell multisig: docs state 5-of-10, the Safe is 5-of-11: docs say 'The 5/10 multisign is composed of:' (docs.abracadabra.money/llms-full.txt) · chain says Abracadabra Spell Safe 0x5f0DeE98360d8200b20812e174d139A1a633EDd2 (Ethereum): getThreshold() = 5 of getOwners() = 11 owners (Safe v1.3.0);",
   "grade": "delta",
   "gradeLabel": "DELTA",
   "name": "Abracadabra Spell",
   "pinnedBlock": 26449594,
   "probe": {
    "block_hash": "0xbe263d5b378dcb7c3c4e18bd8e388f0cb2dab1adacd83de2be58c9408b377287",
    "block_number": 26449594,
    "call_args": [],
    "call_signature": "getThreshold()",
    "chain": "ethereum",
    "check_type": "eth_call",
    "extra_calls": [],
    "id": "abracadabra-spell-safe-threshold-s30",
    "repro_calldata": "0xe75235b8",
    "rpc_env_var": "$ETH_RPC_URL",
    "selector_or_slot": "0xe75235b8",
    "target_contract": "0x5f0DeE98360d8200b20812e174d139A1a633EDd2",
    "target_label": "Abracadabra Spell Safe"
   },
   "reconciled": false,
   "reconciledFrom": [],
   "reconciledTo": [],
   "records": 1,
   "rosetteAria": "Abracadabra Spell control-plane rosette: Upgradeability not determined; Timelock floor not determined; Signer quorum strong; Emergency / freeze scope not determined; Docs-vs-chain parity weak",
   "search": "abracadabra spell abracadabra-spell interest-bearing collateral loans minting mim (ethereum) spell 0x5f0dee98360d8200b20812e174d139a1a633edd2 0x99d8a9c45b2eca8864373a26d1459e3dff1e17f3",
   "slug": "abracadabra-spell",
   "summary_short": "Docs state a 5-of-10 multisig; the Abracadabra Spell Safe is 5-of-11",
   "url": "https://pacta.wtf/protocols/abracadabra-spell/"
  },
  {
   "baskets": [],
   "category": "Intent-Based Cross-Chain Settlement",
   "chains": [
    "ethereum"
   ],
   "deltas": 0,
   "easAttested": true,
   "evidence": {
    "documented": "docs.across.to (security model): 'The Across Bond Token is a custom ERC-20 that functions similarly to WETH.' 'ABT has an additional property: it restricts which addresses may propose root bundles to the HubPool.'",
    "observed": "Across Bond Token 0xee1DC6BCF1Ee967a350e9aC6CaaAA236109002ea (Sourcify exact match): proposers(0xf7bAc63fc7CEaCf0589F25454Ecf5C2ce904997c, the current root-bundle proposer) = true, proposers(address(0)) = false; hubPool() = HubPool 0xc186fA914353c44b2E33eBE05f21846F1048bEda; owner() = the HubPool owner Safe 0xB524735356985D2f267FA010D681f061DfF03715.",
    "recordId": "across-protocol-hubpool-abt-proposer-allowlist-s22",
    "surface": "Root-bundle proposals: only allow-listed ABT proposers"
   },
   "factors": [
    {
     "evidence": "across-protocol-hubpool-bond-045-abt-s22: … 0xB524735356985D2f267FA010D681f061DfF03715 (3-of-5, v1.3.0); not a proxy (Sourcify match).",
     "key": "upgrade",
     "label": "Upgradeability",
     "state": "g",
     "value": "Immutable or ownership renounced"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "timelock",
     "label": "Timelock floor",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No enforced admin delay in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": "across-protocol-hubpool-bond-045-abt-s22: … 0xB524735356985D2f267FA010D681f061DfF03715 (3-of-5, v1.3.0); not a proxy (Sourcify match).",
     "key": "quorum",
     "label": "Signer quorum",
     "state": "g",
     "value": "Lowest controlling quorum: 3-of-5"
    },
    {
     "evidence": "across-protocol-hubpool-bond-045-abt-s22: paused() = false",
     "key": "emergency",
     "label": "Emergency / freeze scope",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "Pause / freeze authority present; its holder is not determined"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "parity",
     "label": "Docs-vs-chain parity",
     "state": "g",
     "value": "Chain matches or is stronger than the documentation"
    }
   ],
   "finding": "Root-bundle proposals: only allow-listed ABT proposers",
   "grade": "aligned",
   "gradeLabel": "ALIGNED",
   "name": "Across Protocol (HubPool)",
   "pinnedBlock": 26429396,
   "probe": {
    "block_hash": "0x3fb83aa053c26ac6b98d634858da1b3c23bb65bae7a12f8f14d72d8273e16d71",
    "block_number": 26429396,
    "call_args": [
     "0xf7bAc63fc7CEaCf0589F25454Ecf5C2ce904997c"
    ],
    "call_signature": "proposers(address)",
    "chain": "ethereum",
    "check_type": "eth_call",
    "extra_calls": [],
    "id": "across-protocol-hubpool-abt-proposer-allowlist-s22",
    "repro_calldata": "0x18177497000000000000000000000000f7bac63fc7ceacf0589f25454ecf5c2ce904997c",
    "rpc_env_var": "$ETH_RPC_URL",
    "selector_or_slot": "0x18177497",
    "target_contract": "0xee1DC6BCF1Ee967a350e9aC6CaaAA236109002ea",
    "target_label": "Across Bond Token (ABT)"
   },
   "reconciled": false,
   "reconciledFrom": [],
   "reconciledTo": [],
   "records": 2,
   "rosetteAria": "Across Protocol (HubPool) control-plane rosette: Upgradeability strong; Timelock floor not determined; Signer quorum strong; Emergency / freeze scope not determined; Docs-vs-chain parity strong",
   "search": "across protocol (hubpool) across-protocol-hubpool intent-based cross-chain settlement acx 0xb524735356985d2f267fa010d681f061dff03715 0xc186fa914353c44b2e33ebe05f21846f1048beda 0xee1dc6bcf1ee967a350e9ac6caaaa236109002ea 0xf7bac63fc7ceacf0589f25454ecf5c2ce904997c",
   "slug": "across-protocol-hubpool",
   "summary_short": "Only allow-listed proposers can submit root bundles, as documented",
   "url": "https://pacta.wtf/protocols/across-protocol-hubpool/"
  },
  {
   "baskets": [],
   "category": "Canonical bridge into an institutional settlement chain (Ethereum)",
   "chains": [
    "ethereum"
   ],
   "deltas": 0,
   "easAttested": false,
   "evidence": {
    "documented": "ADI Bridge documentation is linked for reference (https://bridge.adifoundation.ai/docs). This RPC-pinned record does not compare documentation parameters with the on-chain state.",
    "observed": "ADI (0x8B1484d57abBE239bB280661377363b03c89CaEa) verified on Ethereum Mainnet at canonical block #26,458,556 (170 bytes runtime code). EIP-1967 proxy: implementation 0x9cb8142aEBBcdc60AF7c97Af897A67A8f3CA71C2, admin slot zero. No owner(), admin(), authority(), curator() or AccessControl admin was readable on the contract.",
    "recordId": "adi-bridge-control-plane",
    "surface": "ADI · EIP-1967 Proxy & Controller Chain"
   },
   "factors": [
    {
     "evidence": "adi-bridge-control-plane: is_eip1967_proxy = true",
     "key": "upgrade",
     "label": "Upgradeability",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "Upgradeable; the delay gating the upgrade path is not in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "timelock",
     "label": "Timelock floor",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No enforced admin delay in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "quorum",
     "label": "Signer quorum",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No signer quorum in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "emergency",
     "label": "Emergency / freeze scope",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No pause / freeze authority in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "parity",
     "label": "Docs-vs-chain parity",
     "state": "u",
     "value": "Uncompared: documentation not assessed (RPC-observed)"
    }
   ],
   "finding": "ADI · EIP-1967 Proxy & Controller Chain",
   "grade": "observed",
   "gradeLabel": "OBSERVED",
   "name": "ADI Bridge",
   "pinnedBlock": 26458556,
   "probe": {
    "block_hash": "0xe258bb1cbcc988e2dfdba4ba173f9f8690520dba3647cdcae18e0651822769d2",
    "block_number": 26458556,
    "call_args": [],
    "call_signature": "owner()",
    "chain": "ethereum",
    "check_type": "eth_call",
    "extra_calls": [],
    "id": "adi-bridge-control-plane",
    "repro_calldata": "0x8da5cb5b",
    "rpc_env_var": "$ETH_RPC_URL",
    "selector_or_slot": "0x8da5cb5b",
    "target_contract": "0x8B1484d57abBE239bB280661377363b03c89CaEa",
    "target_label": "ADI"
   },
   "reconciled": false,
   "reconciledFrom": [],
   "reconciledTo": [],
   "records": 1,
   "rosetteAria": "ADI Bridge control-plane rosette: Upgradeability not determined; Timelock floor not determined; Signer quorum not determined; Emergency / freeze scope not determined; Docs-vs-chain parity uncompared",
   "search": "adi bridge adi-bridge canonical bridge into an institutional settlement chain (ethereum) adi 0x8b1484d57abbe239bb280661377363b03c89caea 0x9cb8142aebbcdc60af7c97af897a67a8f3ca71c2",
   "slug": "adi-bridge",
   "summary_short": "Upgradeable proxy no readable owner or admin; docs not assessed",
   "url": "https://pacta.wtf/protocols/adi-bridge/"
  },
  {
   "baskets": [
    "stable_rwa"
   ],
   "category": "Funding-Rate Arbitrage Stablecoin (delta-neutral) (Ethereum)",
   "chains": [
    "ethereum"
   ],
   "deltas": 0,
   "easAttested": true,
   "evidence": {
    "documented": "'Ethereum,0x4274cD7277C7bb0806Bd5FE84b9aDAE466a8DA0a,YUSD,setMinter,onlyOwner,0x4Fe78eF65BD8EDDED480efaB030BA680646503c8,Multisig' (raw.githubusercontent.com/Aegis-im/aegis-contracts/master/owners.csv)",
    "observed": "owner() = Multisig 0x4Fe78eF65BD8EDDED480efaB030BA680646503c8 on YUSD 0x4274cD7277C7bb0806Bd5FE84b9aDAE466a8DA0a and on JUSD, AegisConfig, AegisOracle and AegisOracleJUSD (0xc86168d2424d28942EE0866F043c1206bc9E4900, 0x90cCF2C4b3DEe7aeac9AF5950a7C60f89AF1db00, 0x2B4Ad1d479561064cd1C311004Aca93d15041aEc, 0xfA449DC17194Fdaca1dd2237C828938f1917e0E7); hasRole(DEFAULT_ADMIN_ROLE, Multisig) = true on AegisMinting, AegisMintingJUSD and AegisRewards (0xc4df68e592245ca5202fe8b7c438d2b799820fc2, 0xBB0F32D176590faEdC7bc552b7EAD7A86809b520, 0x8aDCFAf1B64Cc514524B80565bCc732273dDEafD), the addresses owners.csv lists. The Multisig is a Safe: getThreshold() = 3 of getOwners() = 5; guard slot empty; getModulesPaginated() lists no module.",
    "recordId": "aegis-yusd-owner-multisig-s34",
    "surface": "YUSD, JUSD, config and oracles owned by the documented Multisig; it is admin of minting and rewards"
   },
   "factors": [
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "upgrade",
     "label": "Upgradeability",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "Upgrade path not in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "timelock",
     "label": "Timelock floor",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No enforced admin delay in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "quorum",
     "label": "Signer quorum",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No signer quorum in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "emergency",
     "label": "Emergency / freeze scope",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No pause / freeze authority in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "parity",
     "label": "Docs-vs-chain parity",
     "state": "g",
     "value": "Chain matches or is stronger than the documentation"
    }
   ],
   "finding": "YUSD, JUSD, config and oracles owned by the documented Multisig; it is admin of minting and rewards",
   "grade": "aligned",
   "gradeLabel": "ALIGNED",
   "name": "Aegis YUSD",
   "pinnedBlock": 26453551,
   "probe": {
    "block_hash": "0x51e9967ffd6a84012d0dad44204d523b8ac43928e69de2801d2e72dbf8767129",
    "block_number": 26453551,
    "call_args": [],
    "call_signature": "owner()",
    "chain": "ethereum",
    "check_type": "eth_call",
    "extra_calls": [],
    "id": "aegis-yusd-owner-multisig-s34",
    "repro_calldata": "0x8da5cb5b",
    "rpc_env_var": "$ETH_RPC_URL",
    "selector_or_slot": "0x8da5cb5b",
    "target_contract": "0x4274cD7277C7bb0806Bd5FE84b9aDAE466a8DA0a",
    "target_label": "YUSD"
   },
   "reconciled": false,
   "reconciledFrom": [],
   "reconciledTo": [],
   "records": 1,
   "rosetteAria": "Aegis YUSD control-plane rosette: Upgradeability not determined; Timelock floor not determined; Signer quorum not determined; Emergency / freeze scope not determined; Docs-vs-chain parity strong",
   "search": "aegis yusd aegis-yusd funding-rate arbitrage stablecoin (delta-neutral) (ethereum) yusd 0x2b4ad1d479561064cd1c311004aca93d15041aec 0x4274cd7277c7bb0806bd5fe84b9adae466a8da0a 0x4fe78ef65bd8edded480efab030ba680646503c8 0x8adcfaf1b64cc514524b80565bcc732273ddeafd 0x90ccf2c4b3dee7aeac9af5950a7c60f89af1db00 0xbb0f32d176590faedc7bc552b7ead7a86809b520 0xc4df68e592245ca5202fe8b7c438d2b799820fc2 0xc86168d2424d28942ee0866f043c1206bc9e4900 0xfa449dc17194fdaca1dd2237c828938f1917e0e7",
   "slug": "aegis-yusd",
   "summary_short": "Aegis contracts are owned and administered by the documented Multisig, as listed",
   "url": "https://pacta.wtf/protocols/aegis-yusd/"
  },
  {
   "baskets": [
    "stable_rwa"
   ],
   "category": "Autonomous DAO Treasury Management (Gauntlet team) (Ethereum)",
   "chains": [
    "ethereum"
   ],
   "deltas": 0,
   "easAttested": false,
   "evidence": {
    "documented": "Aera V3 documentation is linked for reference (https://docs.aera.finance/). This RPC-pinned record does not compare documentation parameters with the on-chain state.",
    "observed": "MultiDepositorVaultFactory (0x29722cC9a1cACff4a15914F9bC274B46F3b90B4F) verified on Ethereum Mainnet at canonical block #26,458,556 (5,465 bytes runtime code). EIP-1967 implementation and admin storage slots are both zero (non-EIP-1967 contract). Direct owner() returns timelock (1 d delay) 0xce75E223E6DbB0503D2B6f55bC5907d1A0372E2B.",
    "recordId": "aera-v3-control-plane",
    "surface": "MultiDepositorVaultFactory · Non-Proxy Bytecode & Controller"
   },
   "factors": [
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "upgrade",
     "label": "Upgradeability",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "Upgrade path not in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": "controller fact: getMinDelay() = 86400s",
     "key": "timelock",
     "label": "Timelock floor",
     "state": "b",
     "value": "1d minimum enforced delay across control surfaces"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "quorum",
     "label": "Signer quorum",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No signer quorum in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "emergency",
     "label": "Emergency / freeze scope",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No pause / freeze authority in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "parity",
     "label": "Docs-vs-chain parity",
     "state": "u",
     "value": "Uncompared: documentation not assessed (RPC-observed)"
    }
   ],
   "finding": "MultiDepositorVaultFactory · Non-Proxy Bytecode & Controller",
   "grade": "observed",
   "gradeLabel": "OBSERVED",
   "name": "Aera V3",
   "pinnedBlock": 26458556,
   "probe": {
    "block_hash": "0xe258bb1cbcc988e2dfdba4ba173f9f8690520dba3647cdcae18e0651822769d2",
    "block_number": 26458556,
    "call_args": [],
    "call_signature": "owner()",
    "chain": "ethereum",
    "check_type": "eth_call",
    "extra_calls": [],
    "id": "aera-v3-control-plane",
    "repro_calldata": "0x8da5cb5b",
    "rpc_env_var": "$ETH_RPC_URL",
    "selector_or_slot": "0x8da5cb5b",
    "target_contract": "0x29722cC9a1cACff4a15914F9bC274B46F3b90B4F",
    "target_label": "MultiDepositorVaultFactory"
   },
   "reconciled": false,
   "reconciledFrom": [],
   "reconciledTo": [],
   "records": 1,
   "rosetteAria": "Aera V3 control-plane rosette: Upgradeability not determined; Timelock floor moderate; Signer quorum not determined; Emergency / freeze scope not determined; Docs-vs-chain parity uncompared",
   "search": "aera v3 aera-v3 autonomous dao treasury management (gauntlet team) (ethereum) aera 0x29722cc9a1cacff4a15914f9bc274b46f3b90b4f 0xce75e223e6dbb0503d2b6f55bc5907d1a0372e2b",
   "slug": "aera-v3",
   "summary_short": "Non-proxy contract controlled by a timelock; docs not assessed",
   "url": "https://pacta.wtf/protocols/aera-v3/"
  },
  {
   "baskets": [
    "base"
   ],
   "category": "Base Liquidity Hub & ve(3,3) DEX",
   "chains": [
    "base"
   ],
   "deltas": 1,
   "easAttested": true,
   "evidence": {
    "documented": "github.com/aerodrome-finance/contracts (README): 'EpochGovernor.sol A simple epoch-based governance contract used exclusively for adjusting emissions.' / SPECIFICATION.md: 'Managed NFTs can be deactivated, a process which prevents the NFT from voting and from receiving deposits (requires emergency council).'",
    "observed": "Voter 0x16613524e02ad97eDfeF371bC883F2F5d6C480A5: emergencyCouncil() = epochGovernor() = AerodromeMigration 0x22a2F7340a3fB4C7C389D91eE954766B12476721 (Sourcify match; MIGRATION_OPEN() = 1792620000), owned by Safe 0x42255e3C2d0b71a0b006243148fdF1a71d054cE0 (3-of-7, v1.5.0, the same 7 signers as the governor Safe 0xE6A41fE61E7a1996B59d508661e3f524d6A32075).",
    "recordId": "aerodrome-finance-base-emergency-council-migration-s21",
    "surface": "Voter emergency council and epoch governor: the AerodromeMigration contract"
   },
   "factors": [
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "upgrade",
     "label": "Upgradeability",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "Upgrade path not in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "timelock",
     "label": "Timelock floor",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No enforced admin delay in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": "aerodrome-finance-base-emergency-council-migration-s21: … 0x42255e3C2d0b71a0b006243148fdF1a71d054cE0 (3-of-7, v1.5.0, the same 7 signers as the …",
     "key": "quorum",
     "label": "Signer quorum",
     "state": "g",
     "value": "Lowest controlling quorum: 3-of-7"
    },
    {
     "evidence": "aerodrome-finance-base-poolfactory-max-fee-3pct-s21: pauser() = feeManager() = Safe 0xE6A41fE61E7a1996B59d508661e3f524d6A32075 (3-of-7, v1.3.0, no modules), also the Voter governor() and the FactoryRegistry …",
     "key": "emergency",
     "label": "Emergency / freeze scope",
     "state": "g",
     "value": "Pause / freeze authority scoped behind a multi-signer controller (3-of-7)"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "parity",
     "label": "Docs-vs-chain parity",
     "state": "a",
     "value": "Documentation differs from the chain (parameter delta)"
    }
   ],
   "finding": "Voter emergency council and epoch governor: the AerodromeMigration contract: docs say github.com/aerodrome-finance/contracts (README): 'EpochGovernor.sol A simple epoch-based governance contract used exclusively for adjusting emissions.' / SPECIFICATION.md: 'Managed NFTs can be deactivated, a process whi… · chain says Voter 0x16613524e02ad97eDfeF371bC883F2F5d6C480A5: emergencyCouncil() = epochGovernor() = AerodromeMigration 0x22a2F7340a3fB4C7C389D91eE954766B12476721 (Sourcify match;",
   "grade": "delta",
   "gradeLabel": "DELTA",
   "name": "Aerodrome Finance (Base)",
   "pinnedBlock": 58203774,
   "probe": {
    "block_hash": "0x619b45ca763563ff11fc3246da1d039a7d0ab2780bedff6cb0428c9290a2cb10",
    "block_number": 58203774,
    "call_args": [],
    "call_signature": "emergencyCouncil()",
    "chain": "base",
    "check_type": "eth_call",
    "extra_calls": [],
    "id": "aerodrome-finance-base-emergency-council-migration-s21",
    "repro_calldata": "0x7778960e",
    "rpc_env_var": "$BASE_RPC_URL",
    "selector_or_slot": "0x7778960e",
    "target_contract": "0x16613524e02ad97eDfeF371bC883F2F5d6C480A5",
    "target_label": "AerodromeVoter"
   },
   "reconciled": false,
   "reconciledFrom": [],
   "reconciledTo": [],
   "records": 2,
   "rosetteAria": "Aerodrome Finance (Base) control-plane rosette: Upgradeability not determined; Timelock floor not determined; Signer quorum strong; Emergency / freeze scope strong; Docs-vs-chain parity weak",
   "search": "aerodrome finance (base) aerodrome-finance-base base liquidity hub & ve(3,3) dex aero veaero 0x16613524e02ad97edfef371bc883f2f5d6c480a5 0x22a2f7340a3fb4c7c389d91ee954766b12476721 0x420dd381b31aef6683db6b902084cb0ffece40da 0x42255e3c2d0b71a0b006243148fdf1a71d054ce0 0x5c3f18f06cc09ca1910767a34a20f771039e37c0 0xe6a41fe61e7a1996b59d508661e3f524d6a32075",
   "slug": "aerodrome-finance-base",
   "summary_short": "Voter emergency council and epoch governor are the AerodromeMigration contract",
   "url": "https://pacta.wtf/protocols/aerodrome-finance-base/"
  },
  {
   "baskets": [
    "base"
   ],
   "category": "Concentrated-Liquidity DEX",
   "chains": [
    "base"
   ],
   "deltas": 0,
   "easAttested": true,
   "evidence": {
    "documented": "Aerodrome PERMISSIONS.md: 'Protocol Team' 'Multisig at [0xE6A41fE61E7a1996B59d508661e3f524d6A32075]' and 'Fee Manager' 'Protocol team'; Slipstream deploy constants (script/constants/Base.json) name the same Safe as poolFactoryOwner and feeManager.",
    "observed": "CLFactory (0x5e7BB104d84c7CB9B682AaC2F3d509f5F406809A) owner() = swapFeeManager() = unstakedFeeManager() = 3-of-7 Safe 0xE6A41fE61E7a1996B59d508661e3f524d6A32075; swapFeeModule() = 0x090b2A6bb475c00e2256e2095A60887cD710803b, unstakedFeeModule() = 0x0AD08370c76Ff426F534bb2AFFD9b5555338ee68, defaultUnstakedFee() = 100000, allPoolsLength() = 3684. Context, not compared: Voter (0x16613524e02ad97eDfeF371bC883F2F5d6C480A5) governor() = the same Safe; emergencyCouncil() = epochGovernor() = AerodromeMigration (0x22a2F7340a3fB4C7C389D91eE954766B12476721, owner() a 3-of-7 Safe v1.5.0), not the security page's Council 0x99249b10593fCa1Ae9DAE6D4819F1A6dae5C013D; the docs announce the 2026 merger into Aero.",
    "recordId": "aerodrome-slipstream-clfactory-team-3of7-s18",
    "surface": "CLFactory owner, swap & unstaked fee managers = Protocol Team 3-of-7 Safe"
   },
   "factors": [
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "upgrade",
     "label": "Upgradeability",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "Upgrade path not in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "timelock",
     "label": "Timelock floor",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No enforced admin delay in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": "aerodrome-slipstream-clfactory-team-3of7-s18: … swapFeeManager() = unstakedFeeManager() = 3-of-7 Safe 0xE6A41fE61E7a1996B59d508661e3f524d6A32075; …",
     "key": "quorum",
     "label": "Signer quorum",
     "state": "g",
     "value": "Lowest controlling quorum: 3-of-7"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "emergency",
     "label": "Emergency / freeze scope",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No pause / freeze authority in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "parity",
     "label": "Docs-vs-chain parity",
     "state": "g",
     "value": "Chain matches or is stronger than the documentation"
    }
   ],
   "finding": "CLFactory owner, swap & unstaked fee managers = Protocol Team 3-of-7 Safe",
   "grade": "aligned",
   "gradeLabel": "ALIGNED",
   "name": "Aerodrome Slipstream (Base)",
   "pinnedBlock": 57842915,
   "probe": {
    "block_hash": "0x7ae27f2be8e931c33ac284c8d5c548c8fd7a68f08e18bb372c70e2ca3b4bd129",
    "block_number": 57842915,
    "call_args": [],
    "call_signature": "owner()",
    "chain": "base",
    "check_type": "eth_call",
    "extra_calls": [],
    "id": "aerodrome-slipstream-clfactory-team-3of7-s18",
    "repro_calldata": "0x8da5cb5b",
    "rpc_env_var": "$BASE_RPC_URL",
    "selector_or_slot": "0x8da5cb5b",
    "target_contract": "0x5e7BB104d84c7CB9B682AaC2F3d509f5F406809A",
    "target_label": "Slipstream CLFactory"
   },
   "reconciled": false,
   "reconciledFrom": [],
   "reconciledTo": [],
   "records": 1,
   "rosetteAria": "Aerodrome Slipstream (Base) control-plane rosette: Upgradeability not determined; Timelock floor not determined; Signer quorum strong; Emergency / freeze scope not determined; Docs-vs-chain parity strong",
   "search": "aerodrome slipstream (base) aerodrome-slipstream-base concentrated-liquidity dex aero slipstream 0x090b2a6bb475c00e2256e2095a60887cd710803b 0x0ad08370c76ff426f534bb2affd9b5555338ee68 0x16613524e02ad97edfef371bc883f2f5d6c480a5 0x22a2f7340a3fb4c7c389d91ee954766b12476721 0x5e7bb104d84c7cb9b682aac2f3d509f5f406809a 0x99249b10593fca1ae9dae6d4819f1a6dae5c013d 0xe6a41fe61e7a1996b59d508661e3f524d6a32075",
   "slug": "aerodrome-slipstream-base",
   "summary_short": "Pool factory owner and fee managers are the 3-of-7 team Safe, as documented",
   "url": "https://pacta.wtf/protocols/aerodrome-slipstream-base/"
  },
  {
   "baskets": [],
   "category": "Self-Repaying Synthetic Loans (ALCX token) (Ethereum)",
   "chains": [
    "ethereum"
   ],
   "deltas": 0,
   "easAttested": true,
   "evidence": {
    "documented": "'The v3 admin Safe (3-of-7) administers the Alchemist' (docs.alchemix.fi/governance/guides/contract-roles)",
    "observed": "Alchemix V3 Safe 0xF56D660138815fC5d7a06cd0E1630225E788293D (Ethereum): getThreshold() = 3 of getOwners() = 7 owners (Safe v1.3.0).",
    "recordId": "alchemix-v3-safe-threshold-f56d66-s31",
    "surface": "Alchemix V3 multisig: 3-of-7 Safe, as documented"
   },
   "factors": [
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "upgrade",
     "label": "Upgradeability",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "Upgrade path not in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "timelock",
     "label": "Timelock floor",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No enforced admin delay in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": "controller fact: Safe getThreshold()",
     "key": "quorum",
     "label": "Signer quorum",
     "state": "g",
     "value": "Lowest controlling quorum: 3-of-7"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "emergency",
     "label": "Emergency / freeze scope",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No pause / freeze authority in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "parity",
     "label": "Docs-vs-chain parity",
     "state": "g",
     "value": "Chain matches or is stronger than the documentation"
    }
   ],
   "finding": "Alchemix V3 multisig: 3-of-7 Safe, as documented",
   "grade": "aligned",
   "gradeLabel": "ALIGNED",
   "name": "Alchemix V3",
   "pinnedBlock": 26450616,
   "probe": {
    "block_hash": "0xd2df7ccb74a6772b51a5597c8f144f5cfae362efeabf193ecfc7c80f8ff37c35",
    "block_number": 26450616,
    "call_args": [],
    "call_signature": "getThreshold()",
    "chain": "ethereum",
    "check_type": "eth_call",
    "extra_calls": [],
    "id": "alchemix-v3-safe-threshold-f56d66-s31",
    "repro_calldata": "0xe75235b8",
    "rpc_env_var": "$ETH_RPC_URL",
    "selector_or_slot": "0xe75235b8",
    "target_contract": "0xF56D660138815fC5d7a06cd0E1630225E788293D",
    "target_label": "Alchemix V3 Safe"
   },
   "reconciled": false,
   "reconciledFrom": [],
   "reconciledTo": [],
   "records": 1,
   "rosetteAria": "Alchemix V3 control-plane rosette: Upgradeability not determined; Timelock floor not determined; Signer quorum strong; Emergency / freeze scope not determined; Docs-vs-chain parity strong",
   "search": "alchemix v3 alchemix-v3 self-repaying synthetic loans (alcx token) (ethereum) alcx 0xf56d660138815fc5d7a06cd0e1630225e788293d",
   "slug": "alchemix-v3",
   "summary_short": "The Alchemix V3 multisig is a 3-of-7 Safe, as its docs state",
   "url": "https://pacta.wtf/protocols/alchemix-v3/"
  },
  {
   "baskets": [],
   "category": "Tokenized Fund Asset Manager (Centrifuge pools) (Ethereum)",
   "chains": [
    "ethereum"
   ],
   "deltas": 0,
   "easAttested": false,
   "evidence": {
    "documented": "Anemoy Capital documentation is linked for reference (https://www.anemoy.io/news/particula-upgrades-jtrsys-rating). This RPC-pinned record does not compare documentation parameters with the on-chain state.",
    "observed": "Janus Henderson Treasury Fund (Tranche) (0x8c213ee79581Ff4984583C6a801e5263418C4b86) verified on Ethereum Mainnet at canonical block #26,458,556 (9,417 bytes runtime code). EIP-1967 implementation and admin storage slots are both zero (non-EIP-1967 contract). No owner(), admin(), authority(), curator() or AccessControl admin was readable on the contract.",
    "recordId": "anemoy-capital-control-plane",
    "surface": "Janus Henderson Treasury Fund (Tranche) · Non-Proxy Bytecode & Controller"
   },
   "factors": [
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "upgrade",
     "label": "Upgradeability",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "Upgrade path not in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "timelock",
     "label": "Timelock floor",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No enforced admin delay in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "quorum",
     "label": "Signer quorum",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No signer quorum in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "emergency",
     "label": "Emergency / freeze scope",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No pause / freeze authority in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "parity",
     "label": "Docs-vs-chain parity",
     "state": "u",
     "value": "Uncompared: documentation not assessed (RPC-observed)"
    }
   ],
   "finding": "Janus Henderson Treasury Fund (Tranche) · Non-Proxy Bytecode & Controller",
   "grade": "observed",
   "gradeLabel": "OBSERVED",
   "name": "Anemoy Capital",
   "pinnedBlock": 26458556,
   "probe": {
    "block_hash": "0xe258bb1cbcc988e2dfdba4ba173f9f8690520dba3647cdcae18e0651822769d2",
    "block_number": 26458556,
    "call_args": [],
    "call_signature": "owner()",
    "chain": "ethereum",
    "check_type": "eth_call",
    "extra_calls": [],
    "id": "anemoy-capital-control-plane",
    "repro_calldata": "0x8da5cb5b",
    "rpc_env_var": "$ETH_RPC_URL",
    "selector_or_slot": "0x8da5cb5b",
    "target_contract": "0x8c213ee79581Ff4984583C6a801e5263418C4b86",
    "target_label": "Janus Henderson Treasury Fund (Tranche)"
   },
   "reconciled": false,
   "reconciledFrom": [],
   "reconciledTo": [],
   "records": 1,
   "rosetteAria": "Anemoy Capital control-plane rosette: Upgradeability not determined; Timelock floor not determined; Signer quorum not determined; Emergency / freeze scope not determined; Docs-vs-chain parity uncompared",
   "search": "anemoy capital anemoy-capital tokenized fund asset manager (centrifuge pools) (ethereum) jtrsy 0x8c213ee79581ff4984583c6a801e5263418c4b86",
   "slug": "anemoy-capital",
   "summary_short": "Non-proxy contract no readable owner or admin; docs not assessed",
   "url": "https://pacta.wtf/protocols/anemoy-capital/"
  },
  {
   "baskets": [
    "stable_rwa"
   ],
   "category": "Overcollateralized euro stablecoin (agEUR) minted from collateral modules (Ethereum)",
   "chains": [
    "ethereum"
   ],
   "deltas": 0,
   "easAttested": false,
   "evidence": {
    "documented": "Angle documentation is linked for reference (https://angle.money/docs). This RPC-pinned record does not compare documentation parameters with the on-chain state.",
    "observed": "ANGLE (0x31429d1856aD1377A8A0079410B297e1a9e214c2) verified on Ethereum Mainnet at canonical block #26,458,556 (10,122 bytes runtime code). EIP-1967 implementation and admin storage slots are both zero (non-EIP-1967 contract). No owner(), admin(), authority(), curator() or AccessControl admin was readable on the contract.",
    "recordId": "angle-control-plane",
    "surface": "ANGLE · Non-Proxy Bytecode & Controller"
   },
   "factors": [
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "upgrade",
     "label": "Upgradeability",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "Upgrade path not in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "timelock",
     "label": "Timelock floor",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No enforced admin delay in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "quorum",
     "label": "Signer quorum",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No signer quorum in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "emergency",
     "label": "Emergency / freeze scope",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No pause / freeze authority in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "parity",
     "label": "Docs-vs-chain parity",
     "state": "u",
     "value": "Uncompared: documentation not assessed (RPC-observed)"
    }
   ],
   "finding": "ANGLE · Non-Proxy Bytecode & Controller",
   "grade": "observed",
   "gradeLabel": "OBSERVED",
   "name": "Angle",
   "pinnedBlock": 26458556,
   "probe": {
    "block_hash": "0xe258bb1cbcc988e2dfdba4ba173f9f8690520dba3647cdcae18e0651822769d2",
    "block_number": 26458556,
    "call_args": [],
    "call_signature": "owner()",
    "chain": "ethereum",
    "check_type": "eth_call",
    "extra_calls": [],
    "id": "angle-control-plane",
    "repro_calldata": "0x8da5cb5b",
    "rpc_env_var": "$ETH_RPC_URL",
    "selector_or_slot": "0x8da5cb5b",
    "target_contract": "0x31429d1856aD1377A8A0079410B297e1a9e214c2",
    "target_label": "ANGLE"
   },
   "reconciled": false,
   "reconciledFrom": [],
   "reconciledTo": [],
   "records": 1,
   "rosetteAria": "Angle control-plane rosette: Upgradeability not determined; Timelock floor not determined; Signer quorum not determined; Emergency / freeze scope not determined; Docs-vs-chain parity uncompared",
   "search": "angle angle overcollateralized euro stablecoin (ageur) minted from collateral modules (ethereum) angle 0x31429d1856ad1377a8a0079410b297e1a9e214c2",
   "slug": "angle",
   "summary_short": "Non-proxy contract no readable owner or admin; docs not assessed",
   "url": "https://pacta.wtf/protocols/angle/"
  },
  {
   "baskets": [],
   "category": "MEV-internalizing hybrid DEX with app-level sequencing (Ethereum)",
   "chains": [
    "ethereum"
   ],
   "deltas": 0,
   "easAttested": true,
   "evidence": {
    "documented": "'Angstrom Hook 0x0000000aa232009084Bd71A5797d089AA4Edfad4 ControllerV1 0x1746484EA5e11C75e009252c102C8C33e0315fD4 Timelock 0x60D41d9708BBEfd29000d1486C6406Ef23526c01' (docs.angstrom.xyz/contracts/deployments)",
    "observed": "Angstrom Hook 0x0000000aa232009084Bd71A5797d089AA4Edfad4 (Ethereum, not a proxy; verified source): storage slot 0 (TopLevelAuth._controller, required by every onlyController configuration and token-pull function) = ControllerV1 0x1746484EA5e11C75e009252c102C8C33e0315fD4, whose ANGSTROM() = the hook and owner() = Timelock 0x60D41d9708BBEfd29000d1486C6406Ef23526c01, an OpenZeppelin TimelockController (verified) with getMinDelay() = 432,000 s that holds its own DEFAULT_ADMIN_ROLE: the three addresses of the deployments page's L1 table, in that control order.",
    "recordId": "angstrom-hook-controller-timelock-s34",
    "surface": "Hook controller = documented ControllerV1; its owner = documented Timelock (5-day min delay)"
   },
   "factors": [
    {
     "evidence": "angstrom-hook-controller-timelock-s34: … 0x0000000aa232009084Bd71A5797d089AA4Edfad4 (Ethereum, not a proxy; verified source): storage slot 0 (TopLevelAuth._controller, …",
     "key": "upgrade",
     "label": "Upgradeability",
     "state": "g",
     "value": "Immutable or ownership renounced"
    },
    {
     "evidence": "angstrom-hook-controller-timelock-s34: observed_delay_seconds = 432000",
     "key": "timelock",
     "label": "Timelock floor",
     "state": "g",
     "value": "5d minimum enforced delay across control surfaces"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "quorum",
     "label": "Signer quorum",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No signer quorum in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "emergency",
     "label": "Emergency / freeze scope",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No pause / freeze authority in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "parity",
     "label": "Docs-vs-chain parity",
     "state": "g",
     "value": "Chain matches or is stronger than the documentation"
    }
   ],
   "finding": "Hook controller = documented ControllerV1; its owner = documented Timelock (5-day min delay)",
   "grade": "aligned",
   "gradeLabel": "ALIGNED",
   "name": "Angstrom",
   "pinnedBlock": 26453551,
   "probe": {
    "block_hash": "0x51e9967ffd6a84012d0dad44204d523b8ac43928e69de2801d2e72dbf8767129",
    "block_number": 26453551,
    "call_args": [],
    "call_signature": null,
    "chain": "ethereum",
    "check_type": "eth_getStorageAt",
    "extra_calls": [],
    "id": "angstrom-hook-controller-timelock-s34",
    "repro_calldata": null,
    "rpc_env_var": "$ETH_RPC_URL",
    "selector_or_slot": "0x0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000",
    "target_contract": "0x0000000aa232009084Bd71A5797d089AA4Edfad4",
    "target_label": "Angstrom Hook"
   },
   "reconciled": false,
   "reconciledFrom": [],
   "reconciledTo": [],
   "records": 1,
   "rosetteAria": "Angstrom control-plane rosette: Upgradeability strong; Timelock floor strong; Signer quorum not determined; Emergency / freeze scope not determined; Docs-vs-chain parity strong",
   "search": "angstrom angstrom mev-internalizing hybrid dex with app-level sequencing (ethereum) angstrom 0x0000000aa232009084bd71a5797d089aa4edfad4 0x1746484ea5e11c75e009252c102c8c33e0315fd4 0x60d41d9708bbefd29000d1486c6406ef23526c01",
   "slug": "angstrom",
   "summary_short": "Angstrom's hook is controlled by the documented ControllerV1 and Timelock",
   "url": "https://pacta.wtf/protocols/angstrom/"
  },
  {
   "baskets": [
    "eth_lst_lrt"
   ],
   "category": "Liquid staking tokens (ankrETH) and decentralized RPC node infrastructure (Ethereum)",
   "chains": [
    "ethereum"
   ],
   "deltas": 0,
   "easAttested": false,
   "evidence": {
    "documented": "Ankr documentation is linked for reference (https://www.ankr.com/docs/). This RPC-pinned record does not compare documentation parameters with the on-chain state.",
    "observed": "Ankr Network (0x8290333ceF9e6D528dD5618Fb97a76f268f3EDD4) verified on Ethereum Mainnet at canonical block #26,458,556 (5,479 bytes runtime code). EIP-1967 implementation and admin storage slots are both zero (non-EIP-1967 contract). No owner(), admin(), authority(), curator() or AccessControl admin was readable on the contract.",
    "recordId": "ankr-control-plane",
    "surface": "Ankr Network · Non-Proxy Bytecode & Controller"
   },
   "factors": [
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "upgrade",
     "label": "Upgradeability",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "Upgrade path not in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "timelock",
     "label": "Timelock floor",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No enforced admin delay in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "quorum",
     "label": "Signer quorum",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No signer quorum in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "emergency",
     "label": "Emergency / freeze scope",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No pause / freeze authority in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "parity",
     "label": "Docs-vs-chain parity",
     "state": "u",
     "value": "Uncompared: documentation not assessed (RPC-observed)"
    }
   ],
   "finding": "Ankr Network · Non-Proxy Bytecode & Controller",
   "grade": "observed",
   "gradeLabel": "OBSERVED",
   "name": "Ankr",
   "pinnedBlock": 26458556,
   "probe": {
    "block_hash": "0xe258bb1cbcc988e2dfdba4ba173f9f8690520dba3647cdcae18e0651822769d2",
    "block_number": 26458556,
    "call_args": [],
    "call_signature": "owner()",
    "chain": "ethereum",
    "check_type": "eth_call",
    "extra_calls": [],
    "id": "ankr-control-plane",
    "repro_calldata": "0x8da5cb5b",
    "rpc_env_var": "$ETH_RPC_URL",
    "selector_or_slot": "0x8da5cb5b",
    "target_contract": "0x8290333ceF9e6D528dD5618Fb97a76f268f3EDD4",
    "target_label": "Ankr Network"
   },
   "reconciled": false,
   "reconciledFrom": [],
   "reconciledTo": [],
   "records": 1,
   "rosetteAria": "Ankr control-plane rosette: Upgradeability not determined; Timelock floor not determined; Signer quorum not determined; Emergency / freeze scope not determined; Docs-vs-chain parity uncompared",
   "search": "ankr ankr liquid staking tokens (ankreth) and decentralized rpc node infrastructure (ethereum) ankr 0x8290333cef9e6d528dd5618fb97a76f268f3edd4",
   "slug": "ankr",
   "summary_short": "Non-proxy contract no readable owner or admin; docs not assessed",
   "url": "https://pacta.wtf/protocols/ankr/"
  },
  {
   "baskets": [
    "stable_rwa"
   ],
   "category": "Collateral management for fully secured onchain credit (Ethereum)",
   "chains": [
    "ethereum"
   ],
   "deltas": 0,
   "easAttested": true,
   "evidence": {
    "documented": "'For successful proposals, there is currently a 7-day timelock to provide all Protocol users time to understand the new parameters and their implications prior to the update.' (docs.anvil.xyz/governance/proposal-process.md); '[AnvilTimelock](https://etherscan.io/address/0x4eeB7c5BB75Fc0DBEa4826BF568FD577f62cad21)' (docs.anvil.xyz/core-contracts/overview.md)",
    "observed": "AnvilTimelock 0x4eeB7c5BB75Fc0DBEa4826BF568FD577f62cad21 (Ethereum; the core-contracts table lists it as the contract that 'Owns the CollateralVault, LetterOfCredit, and PythPriceOracle contracts'): an OpenZeppelin v5 TimelockController (verified source: updateDelay only by the timelock itself, schedule only by PROPOSER_ROLE and never below getMinDelay()), getMinDelay() = 604,800 s. owner() = the timelock on CollateralVault 0x5d2725fdE4d7Aa3388DA4519ac0449Cc031d675f, on the LetterOfCredit proxy 0x14db9a91933aD9433E1A0dB04D08e5D9EF7c4808 (whose EIP-1967 admin is ProxyAdmin 0x12225bB169b38EF8849DD4F5Cc466ae5996e341D, owner() = the timelock), on PythPriceOracle 0xC6f3405c861Fa0dca04EC4BA59Bc189D1d56Ee05 and on the TimeBasedCollateralPool beacon 0x1f00D6f7C18a8edf4f8Bb4Ead8a898aBDd9c9E14. The AnvilGovernorDelegator 0x00e83d0698FAf01BD080A4Dd2927e6aB7C4874c9 has the timelock as its EIP-1967 admin and timelock(); it holds PROPOSER_ROLE (hasRole = true) and the timelock holds its own DEFAULT_ADMIN_ROLE. Role holders cannot be enumerated without event logs; no holder can schedule below the minimum delay. The published primary contract (the ANVL token) has no owner or admin function.",
    "recordId": "anvil-timelock-7-day-as-documented-s37",
    "surface": "AnvilTimelock: getMinDelay() = 604,800 s (7 days), as documented; owns the documented contracts"
   },
   "factors": [
    {
     "evidence": "anvil-timelock-7-day-as-documented-s37: AnvilTimelock 0x4eeB7c5BB75Fc0DBEa4826BF568FD577f62cad21 (Ethereum; the core-contracts table lists it as the contract that 'Owns the CollateralVault …",
     "key": "upgrade",
     "label": "Upgradeability",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "Upgradeable; the delay gating the upgrade path is not in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": "anvil-timelock-7-day-as-documented-s37: observed_delay_seconds = 604800",
     "key": "timelock",
     "label": "Timelock floor",
     "state": "g",
     "value": "7d minimum enforced delay across control surfaces"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "quorum",
     "label": "Signer quorum",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No signer quorum in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "emergency",
     "label": "Emergency / freeze scope",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No pause / freeze authority in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "parity",
     "label": "Docs-vs-chain parity",
     "state": "g",
     "value": "Chain matches or is stronger than the documentation"
    }
   ],
   "finding": "AnvilTimelock: getMinDelay() = 604,800 s (7 days), as documented; owns the documented contracts",
   "grade": "aligned",
   "gradeLabel": "ALIGNED",
   "name": "Anvil",
   "pinnedBlock": 26458556,
   "probe": {
    "block_hash": "0xe258bb1cbcc988e2dfdba4ba173f9f8690520dba3647cdcae18e0651822769d2",
    "block_number": 26458556,
    "call_args": [],
    "call_signature": "getMinDelay()",
    "chain": "ethereum",
    "check_type": "eth_call",
    "extra_calls": [],
    "id": "anvil-timelock-7-day-as-documented-s37",
    "repro_calldata": "0xf27a0c92",
    "rpc_env_var": "$ETH_RPC_URL",
    "selector_or_slot": "0xf27a0c92",
    "target_contract": "0x4eeB7c5BB75Fc0DBEa4826BF568FD577f62cad21",
    "target_label": "AnvilTimelock (OpenZeppelin TimelockController)"
   },
   "reconciled": false,
   "reconciledFrom": [],
   "reconciledTo": [],
   "records": 1,
   "rosetteAria": "Anvil control-plane rosette: Upgradeability not determined; Timelock floor strong; Signer quorum not determined; Emergency / freeze scope not determined; Docs-vs-chain parity strong",
   "search": "anvil anvil collateral management for fully secured onchain credit (ethereum) anvl 0x00e83d0698faf01bd080a4dd2927e6ab7c4874c9 0x12225bb169b38ef8849dd4f5cc466ae5996e341d 0x14db9a91933ad9433e1a0db04d08e5d9ef7c4808 0x1f00d6f7c18a8edf4f8bb4ead8a898abdd9c9e14 0x4eeb7c5bb75fc0dbea4826bf568fd577f62cad21 0x5d2725fde4d7aa3388da4519ac0449cc031d675f 0xc6f3405c861fa0dca04ec4ba59bc189d1d56ee05",
   "slug": "anvil",
   "summary_short": "Anvil's governance timelock is 7 days, as documented",
   "url": "https://pacta.wtf/protocols/anvil/"
  },
  {
   "baskets": [],
   "category": "Decentralized Supercomputer Token Bridge (Ethereum)",
   "chains": [
    "ethereum"
   ],
   "deltas": 0,
   "easAttested": false,
   "evidence": {
    "documented": "AO Bridge documentation is linked for reference (https://docs.arweave.net/). This RPC-pinned record does not compare documentation parameters with the on-chain state.",
    "observed": "Distribution (0xfE08D40Eee53d64936D3128838867c867602665c) verified on Ethereum Mainnet at canonical block #26,458,556 (177 bytes runtime code). EIP-1967 proxy: implementation 0x76488832A88475AF0aC223d8FD4d053177A012cc, admin slot zero. No owner(), admin(), authority(), curator() or AccessControl admin was readable on the contract.",
    "recordId": "ao-bridge-control-plane",
    "surface": "Distribution · EIP-1967 Proxy & Controller Chain"
   },
   "factors": [
    {
     "evidence": "ao-bridge-control-plane: is_eip1967_proxy = true",
     "key": "upgrade",
     "label": "Upgradeability",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "Upgradeable; the delay gating the upgrade path is not in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "timelock",
     "label": "Timelock floor",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No enforced admin delay in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "quorum",
     "label": "Signer quorum",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No signer quorum in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "emergency",
     "label": "Emergency / freeze scope",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No pause / freeze authority in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "parity",
     "label": "Docs-vs-chain parity",
     "state": "u",
     "value": "Uncompared: documentation not assessed (RPC-observed)"
    }
   ],
   "finding": "Distribution · EIP-1967 Proxy & Controller Chain",
   "grade": "observed",
   "gradeLabel": "OBSERVED",
   "name": "AO Bridge",
   "pinnedBlock": 26458556,
   "probe": {
    "block_hash": "0xe258bb1cbcc988e2dfdba4ba173f9f8690520dba3647cdcae18e0651822769d2",
    "block_number": 26458556,
    "call_args": [],
    "call_signature": "owner()",
    "chain": "ethereum",
    "check_type": "eth_call",
    "extra_calls": [],
    "id": "ao-bridge-control-plane",
    "repro_calldata": "0x8da5cb5b",
    "rpc_env_var": "$ETH_RPC_URL",
    "selector_or_slot": "0x8da5cb5b",
    "target_contract": "0xfE08D40Eee53d64936D3128838867c867602665c",
    "target_label": "Distribution"
   },
   "reconciled": false,
   "reconciledFrom": [],
   "reconciledTo": [],
   "records": 1,
   "rosetteAria": "AO Bridge control-plane rosette: Upgradeability not determined; Timelock floor not determined; Signer quorum not determined; Emergency / freeze scope not determined; Docs-vs-chain parity uncompared",
   "search": "ao bridge ao-bridge decentralized supercomputer token bridge (ethereum) ao 0x76488832a88475af0ac223d8fd4d053177a012cc 0xfe08d40eee53d64936d3128838867c867602665c",
   "slug": "ao-bridge",
   "summary_short": "Upgradeable proxy no readable owner or admin; docs not assessed",
   "url": "https://pacta.wtf/protocols/ao-bridge/"
  },
  {
   "baskets": [],
   "category": "Perpetual derivatives trading with an order-book matching engine and cross-margin accounts (Ethereum)",
   "chains": [
    "ethereum"
   ],
   "deltas": 0,
   "easAttested": false,
   "evidence": {
    "documented": "ApeX Pro documentation is linked for reference (https://apex-pro.gitbook.io/apex-pro). This RPC-pinned record does not compare documentation parameters with the on-chain state.",
    "observed": "ApeX Token (0x52A8845DF664D76C69d2EEa607CD793565aF42B8) verified on Ethereum Mainnet at canonical block #26,458,556 (9,190 bytes runtime code). EIP-1967 implementation and admin storage slots are both zero (non-EIP-1967 contract). No owner(), admin(), authority(), curator() or AccessControl admin was readable on the contract.",
    "recordId": "apex-pro-control-plane",
    "surface": "ApeX Token · Non-Proxy Bytecode & Controller"
   },
   "factors": [
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "upgrade",
     "label": "Upgradeability",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "Upgrade path not in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "timelock",
     "label": "Timelock floor",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No enforced admin delay in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "quorum",
     "label": "Signer quorum",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No signer quorum in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "emergency",
     "label": "Emergency / freeze scope",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No pause / freeze authority in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "parity",
     "label": "Docs-vs-chain parity",
     "state": "u",
     "value": "Uncompared: documentation not assessed (RPC-observed)"
    }
   ],
   "finding": "ApeX Token · Non-Proxy Bytecode & Controller",
   "grade": "observed",
   "gradeLabel": "OBSERVED",
   "name": "ApeX Pro",
   "pinnedBlock": 26458556,
   "probe": {
    "block_hash": "0xe258bb1cbcc988e2dfdba4ba173f9f8690520dba3647cdcae18e0651822769d2",
    "block_number": 26458556,
    "call_args": [],
    "call_signature": "owner()",
    "chain": "ethereum",
    "check_type": "eth_call",
    "extra_calls": [],
    "id": "apex-pro-control-plane",
    "repro_calldata": "0x8da5cb5b",
    "rpc_env_var": "$ETH_RPC_URL",
    "selector_or_slot": "0x8da5cb5b",
    "target_contract": "0x52A8845DF664D76C69d2EEa607CD793565aF42B8",
    "target_label": "ApeX Token"
   },
   "reconciled": false,
   "reconciledFrom": [],
   "reconciledTo": [],
   "records": 1,
   "rosetteAria": "ApeX Pro control-plane rosette: Upgradeability not determined; Timelock floor not determined; Signer quorum not determined; Emergency / freeze scope not determined; Docs-vs-chain parity uncompared",
   "search": "apex pro apex-pro perpetual derivatives trading with an order-book matching engine and cross-margin accounts (ethereum) apex 0x52a8845df664d76c69d2eea607cd793565af42b8",
   "slug": "apex-pro",
   "summary_short": "Non-proxy contract no readable owner or admin; docs not assessed",
   "url": "https://pacta.wtf/protocols/apex-pro/"
  },
  {
   "baskets": [
    "lending_vaults"
   ],
   "category": "Robo-advisor running a portfolio of yield farming strategies from one pool (Ethereum)",
   "chains": [
    "ethereum"
   ],
   "deltas": 0,
   "easAttested": true,
   "evidence": {
    "documented": "'The liquidity pool contracts use a proxy pattern for upgradeability.' (docs.apy.finance/smart-contract-integration/liquidity-mining-pool.md)",
    "observed": "APY Finance APYPoolTokenProxy 0xe18b0365D5D09F394f84eE56ed29DD2d8D6Fba5f (Ethereum): EIP-1967 implementation slot = 0xDD0fC21319C4cA133A758f9893028Aac834e8493, admin slot = 0x7965283631253DfCb71Db63a60C656DEDF76234f; upgradeable (EIP-1967 implementation + admin slot (transparent proxy)).",
    "recordId": "apy-finance-upgradeability-e18b03-s28",
    "surface": "APY Finance APYPoolTokenProxy: upgradeable (proxy admin), as documented"
   },
   "factors": [
    {
     "evidence": "apy-finance-upgradeability-e18b03-s28: APY Finance APYPoolTokenProxy 0xe18b0365D5D09F394f84eE56ed29DD2d8D6Fba5f (Ethereum): EIP-1967 implementation slot = 0xDD0fC21319C4cA133A758f9893028Aac834e8493 …",
     "key": "upgrade",
     "label": "Upgradeability",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "Upgradeable; the delay gating the upgrade path is not in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "timelock",
     "label": "Timelock floor",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No enforced admin delay in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "quorum",
     "label": "Signer quorum",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No signer quorum in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "emergency",
     "label": "Emergency / freeze scope",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No pause / freeze authority in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "parity",
     "label": "Docs-vs-chain parity",
     "state": "g",
     "value": "Chain matches or is stronger than the documentation"
    }
   ],
   "finding": "APY Finance APYPoolTokenProxy: upgradeable (proxy admin), as documented",
   "grade": "aligned",
   "gradeLabel": "ALIGNED",
   "name": "APY Finance",
   "pinnedBlock": 26441165,
   "probe": {
    "block_hash": "0x5182be2c61af5f48ed2ec43d3c177dedad257c4e966a7e384120829de73901d9",
    "block_number": 26441165,
    "call_args": [],
    "call_signature": null,
    "chain": "ethereum",
    "check_type": "eth_getStorageAt",
    "extra_calls": [],
    "id": "apy-finance-upgradeability-e18b03-s28",
    "repro_calldata": null,
    "rpc_env_var": "$ETH_RPC_URL",
    "selector_or_slot": "0x360894a13ba1a3210667c828492db98dca3e2076cc3735a920a3ca505d382bbc",
    "target_contract": "0xe18b0365D5D09F394f84eE56ed29DD2d8D6Fba5f",
    "target_label": "APY Finance APYPoolTokenProxy"
   },
   "reconciled": false,
   "reconciledFrom": [],
   "reconciledTo": [],
   "records": 1,
   "rosetteAria": "APY Finance control-plane rosette: Upgradeability not determined; Timelock floor not determined; Signer quorum not determined; Emergency / freeze scope not determined; Docs-vs-chain parity strong",
   "search": "apy finance apy-finance robo-advisor running a portfolio of yield farming strategies from one pool (ethereum) apy 0x7965283631253dfcb71db63a60c656dedf76234f 0xdd0fc21319c4ca133a758f9893028aac834e8493 0xe18b0365d5d09f394f84ee56ed29dd2d8d6fba5f",
   "slug": "apy-finance",
   "summary_short": "The APY Finance APYPoolTokenProxy is upgradeable (proxy admin), as its docs state",
   "url": "https://pacta.wtf/protocols/apy-finance/"
  },
  {
   "baskets": [
    "stable_rwa"
   ],
   "category": "Prime brokerage credit for institutional asset managers (Ethereum)",
   "chains": [
    "ethereum"
   ],
   "deltas": 0,
   "easAttested": false,
   "evidence": {
    "documented": "Arkis documentation is linked for reference (https://docs.arkis.xyz/home). This RPC-pinned record does not compare documentation parameters with the on-chain state.",
    "observed": "AgreementFactory (0xEA623eebd9c5bFd56067e36C89Db0C13e6c70ba8) verified on Ethereum Mainnet at canonical block #26,458,556 (2,304 bytes runtime code). EIP-1967 proxy: implementation 0x9Cd84E2587A78b424eC913Ac3fA23cA810e91776, admin 0x324adD185708E4Cc85546085849a27b9Ba75f0Bb. The EIP-1967 admin slot holds contract ProxyAdmin 0x324adD185708E4Cc85546085849a27b9Ba75f0Bb. That controller is in turn controlled by externally owned account (no code) 0xC0096A2032Cd8ad726181D1399C5F20768037fc1.",
    "recordId": "arkis-control-plane",
    "surface": "AgreementFactory · EIP-1967 Proxy & Controller Chain"
   },
   "factors": [
    {
     "evidence": "arkis-control-plane: AgreementFactory (0xEA623eebd9c5bFd56067e36C89Db0C13e6c70ba8) verified on Ethereum Mainnet at canonical block #26,458,556 (2,304 bytes runtime code). EIP-1967 …",
     "key": "upgrade",
     "label": "Upgradeability",
     "state": "a",
     "value": "Upgradeable with no enforced delay: no timelock in front of upgrades"
    },
    {
     "evidence": "arkis-control-plane: AgreementFactory (0xEA623eebd9c5bFd56067e36C89Db0C13e6c70ba8) verified on Ethereum Mainnet at canonical block #26,458,556 (2,304 bytes runtime code). EIP-1967 …",
     "key": "timelock",
     "label": "Timelock floor",
     "state": "a",
     "value": "0s minimum enforced delay across control surfaces"
    },
    {
     "evidence": "arkis-control-plane: … controller is in turn controlled by externally owned account (no code) 0xC0096A2032Cd8ad726181D1399C5F20768037fc1.",
     "key": "quorum",
     "label": "Signer quorum",
     "state": "a",
     "value": "Lowest controlling quorum: a single key"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "emergency",
     "label": "Emergency / freeze scope",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No pause / freeze authority in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "parity",
     "label": "Docs-vs-chain parity",
     "state": "u",
     "value": "Uncompared: documentation not assessed (RPC-observed)"
    }
   ],
   "finding": "AgreementFactory · EIP-1967 Proxy & Controller Chain",
   "grade": "observed",
   "gradeLabel": "OBSERVED",
   "name": "Arkis",
   "pinnedBlock": 26458556,
   "probe": {
    "block_hash": "0xe258bb1cbcc988e2dfdba4ba173f9f8690520dba3647cdcae18e0651822769d2",
    "block_number": 26458556,
    "call_args": [],
    "call_signature": null,
    "chain": "ethereum",
    "check_type": "eth_getStorageAt",
    "extra_calls": [],
    "id": "arkis-control-plane",
    "repro_calldata": null,
    "rpc_env_var": "$ETH_RPC_URL",
    "selector_or_slot": "0xb53127684a568b3173ae13b9f8a6016e243e63b6e8ee1178d6a717850b5d6103",
    "target_contract": "0xEA623eebd9c5bFd56067e36C89Db0C13e6c70ba8",
    "target_label": "AgreementFactory"
   },
   "reconciled": false,
   "reconciledFrom": [],
   "reconciledTo": [],
   "records": 1,
   "rosetteAria": "Arkis control-plane rosette: Upgradeability weak; Timelock floor weak; Signer quorum weak; Emergency / freeze scope not determined; Docs-vs-chain parity uncompared",
   "search": "arkis arkis prime brokerage credit for institutional asset managers (ethereum) arkis 0x324add185708e4cc85546085849a27b9ba75f0bb 0x9cd84e2587a78b424ec913ac3fa23ca810e91776 0xc0096a2032cd8ad726181d1399c5f20768037fc1 0xea623eebd9c5bfd56067e36c89db0c13e6c70ba8",
   "slug": "arkis",
   "summary_short": "Upgradeable proxy controlled by a contract; docs not assessed",
   "url": "https://pacta.wtf/protocols/arkis/"
  },
  {
   "baskets": [
    "lending_vaults"
   ],
   "category": "Market-making strategy vaults for token issuers, deployed by a meta-vault factory (Ethereum)",
   "chains": [
    "ethereum"
   ],
   "deltas": 0,
   "easAttested": true,
   "evidence": {
    "documented": "'Arrakis implements a 48-hour timelock on upgrades' (arrakis.finance/risks)",
    "observed": "ArrakisMetaVaultFactory 0x820FB8127a689327C863de8433278d6181123982 (Ethereum): manager() = 0x2e6E879648293e939aA68bA4c6c129A1Be733bDA, whose EIP-1967 admin slot holds 0xAf6f9640092cB1236E5DB6E517576355b6C40b7f, a TimelockController with getMinDelay() = 172,800 s. The 5 module beacons whitelisted by the public and private module registries (0xE973Cf1e347EcF26232A95dBCc862AA488b0351b, 0xFf0474792DEe71935a0CeF1306D93fC1DCF47BD9, 0xdf4975A3515168f8c446aD4a2E974B89c64b6A38, 0x022a0C7dc85Fc3fF81f9f8Ef65Ae2813A062F556, 0x1436877899273D748eb433eFd6C437e37D627255) all have owner() = 0xAf6f9640092cB1236E5DB6E517576355b6C40b7f.",
    "recordId": "arrakis-modular-upgrade-timelock-48h-s30",
    "surface": "Manager proxy and module beacons: timelock admin, getMinDelay() 172,800 s"
   },
   "factors": [
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "upgrade",
     "label": "Upgradeability",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "Upgrade path not in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": "arrakis-modular-upgrade-timelock-48h-s30: observed_delay_seconds = 172800",
     "key": "timelock",
     "label": "Timelock floor",
     "state": "g",
     "value": "2d minimum enforced delay across control surfaces"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "quorum",
     "label": "Signer quorum",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No signer quorum in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "emergency",
     "label": "Emergency / freeze scope",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No pause / freeze authority in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "parity",
     "label": "Docs-vs-chain parity",
     "state": "g",
     "value": "Chain matches or is stronger than the documentation"
    }
   ],
   "finding": "Manager proxy and module beacons: timelock admin, getMinDelay() 172,800 s",
   "grade": "aligned",
   "gradeLabel": "ALIGNED",
   "name": "Arrakis Modular",
   "pinnedBlock": 26449594,
   "probe": {
    "block_hash": "0xbe263d5b378dcb7c3c4e18bd8e388f0cb2dab1adacd83de2be58c9408b377287",
    "block_number": 26449594,
    "call_args": [],
    "call_signature": "getMinDelay()",
    "chain": "ethereum",
    "check_type": "eth_call",
    "extra_calls": [],
    "id": "arrakis-modular-upgrade-timelock-48h-s30",
    "repro_calldata": "0xf27a0c92",
    "rpc_env_var": "$ETH_RPC_URL",
    "selector_or_slot": "0xf27a0c92",
    "target_contract": "0xAf6f9640092cB1236E5DB6E517576355b6C40b7f",
    "target_label": "Arrakis TimelockController (manager proxy admin, module beacon owner)"
   },
   "reconciled": false,
   "reconciledFrom": [],
   "reconciledTo": [],
   "records": 1,
   "rosetteAria": "Arrakis Modular control-plane rosette: Upgradeability not determined; Timelock floor strong; Signer quorum not determined; Emergency / freeze scope not determined; Docs-vs-chain parity strong",
   "search": "arrakis modular arrakis-modular market-making strategy vaults for token issuers, deployed by a meta-vault factory (ethereum) arrakis 0x022a0c7dc85fc3ff81f9f8ef65ae2813a062f556 0x1436877899273d748eb433efd6c437e37d627255 0x2e6e879648293e939aa68ba4c6c129a1be733bda 0x820fb8127a689327c863de8433278d6181123982 0xaf6f9640092cb1236e5db6e517576355b6c40b7f 0xdf4975a3515168f8c446ad4a2e974b89c64b6a38 0xe973cf1e347ecf26232a95dbcc862aa488b0351b 0xff0474792dee71935a0cef1306d93fc1dcf47bd9",
   "slug": "arrakis-modular",
   "summary_short": "Arrakis's manager proxy and 5 module beacons upgrade through a 48-hour timelock",
   "url": "https://pacta.wtf/protocols/arrakis-modular/"
  },
  {
   "baskets": [
    "lending_vaults"
   ],
   "category": "Perpetual Exchange Deposit Vault (MEV-free trading) (Ethereum)",
   "chains": [
    "ethereum"
   ],
   "deltas": 0,
   "easAttested": false,
   "evidence": {
    "documented": "Aster Bridge documentation is linked for reference (https://docs.asterdex.com/). This RPC-pinned record does not compare documentation parameters with the on-chain state.",
    "observed": "AstherusVault (0x604DD02d620633Ae427888d41bfd15e38483736E) verified on Ethereum Mainnet at canonical block #26,458,556 (855 bytes runtime code). EIP-1967 proxy: implementation 0x2CC878ac49C3BF8B0f2B053af7845BA6590eEc4f, admin slot zero. DEFAULT_ADMIN_ROLE member is Safe 4-of-7 0x1FE3Fe2Ddd19AB58B0c56054a5AF217Afb27eCEA.",
    "recordId": "aster-bridge-control-plane",
    "surface": "AstherusVault · EIP-1967 Proxy & Controller Chain"
   },
   "factors": [
    {
     "evidence": "aster-bridge-control-plane: is_eip1967_proxy = true",
     "key": "upgrade",
     "label": "Upgradeability",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "Upgradeable; the delay gating the upgrade path is not in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "timelock",
     "label": "Timelock floor",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No enforced admin delay in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": "aster-bridge-control-plane: … zero. DEFAULT_ADMIN_ROLE member is Safe 4-of-7 0x1FE3Fe2Ddd19AB58B0c56054a5AF217Afb27eCEA.",
     "key": "quorum",
     "label": "Signer quorum",
     "state": "g",
     "value": "Lowest controlling quorum: 4-of-7"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "emergency",
     "label": "Emergency / freeze scope",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No pause / freeze authority in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "parity",
     "label": "Docs-vs-chain parity",
     "state": "u",
     "value": "Uncompared: documentation not assessed (RPC-observed)"
    }
   ],
   "finding": "AstherusVault · EIP-1967 Proxy & Controller Chain",
   "grade": "observed",
   "gradeLabel": "OBSERVED",
   "name": "Aster Bridge",
   "pinnedBlock": 26458556,
   "probe": {
    "block_hash": "0xe258bb1cbcc988e2dfdba4ba173f9f8690520dba3647cdcae18e0651822769d2",
    "block_number": 26458556,
    "call_args": [],
    "call_signature": "owner()",
    "chain": "ethereum",
    "check_type": "eth_call",
    "extra_calls": [],
    "id": "aster-bridge-control-plane",
    "repro_calldata": "0x8da5cb5b",
    "rpc_env_var": "$ETH_RPC_URL",
    "selector_or_slot": "0x8da5cb5b",
    "target_contract": "0x604DD02d620633Ae427888d41bfd15e38483736E",
    "target_label": "AstherusVault"
   },
   "reconciled": false,
   "reconciledFrom": [],
   "reconciledTo": [],
   "records": 1,
   "rosetteAria": "Aster Bridge control-plane rosette: Upgradeability not determined; Timelock floor not determined; Signer quorum strong; Emergency / freeze scope not determined; Docs-vs-chain parity uncompared",
   "search": "aster bridge aster-bridge perpetual exchange deposit vault (mev-free trading) (ethereum) aster 0x1fe3fe2ddd19ab58b0c56054a5af217afb27ecea 0x2cc878ac49c3bf8b0f2b053af7845ba6590eec4f 0x604dd02d620633ae427888d41bfd15e38483736e",
   "slug": "aster-bridge",
   "summary_short": "Upgradeable proxy controlled by a 4-of-7 Safe; docs not assessed",
   "url": "https://pacta.wtf/protocols/aster-bridge/"
  },
  {
   "baskets": [
    "eth_lst_lrt",
    "lending_vaults"
   ],
   "category": "Hybrid liquid staking products with real yield (Ethereum)",
   "chains": [
    "ethereum"
   ],
   "deltas": 0,
   "easAttested": true,
   "evidence": {
    "documented": "'The Votium Strategy Contract (ERC1967 proxy) 0x00000069aBbB0B1Ad6975bcF753eEe15D318A0BF' (docs.asymmetry.finance/developers/contracts.md)",
    "observed": "Asymmetry Finance SimpleProxy 0x00000069aBbB0B1Ad6975bcF753eEe15D318A0BF (Ethereum): EIP-1967 implementation slot = 0xb628B1fdbE8C01777aEa2bF3bd386df4Af84e8d3; upgradeable (EIP-1967 implementation exposing upgradeToAndCall (UUPS)).",
    "recordId": "asymmetry-finance-upgradeability-000000-s28",
    "surface": "Asymmetry Finance SimpleProxy: upgradeable (UUPS), as documented"
   },
   "factors": [
    {
     "evidence": "asymmetry-finance-upgradeability-000000-s28: Asymmetry Finance SimpleProxy 0x00000069aBbB0B1Ad6975bcF753eEe15D318A0BF (Ethereum): EIP-1967 implementation slot = 0xb628B1fdbE8C01777aEa2bF3bd386df4Af84e8d3",
     "key": "upgrade",
     "label": "Upgradeability",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "Upgradeable; the delay gating the upgrade path is not in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "timelock",
     "label": "Timelock floor",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No enforced admin delay in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "quorum",
     "label": "Signer quorum",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No signer quorum in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "emergency",
     "label": "Emergency / freeze scope",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No pause / freeze authority in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "parity",
     "label": "Docs-vs-chain parity",
     "state": "g",
     "value": "Chain matches or is stronger than the documentation"
    }
   ],
   "finding": "Asymmetry Finance SimpleProxy: upgradeable (UUPS), as documented",
   "grade": "aligned",
   "gradeLabel": "ALIGNED",
   "name": "Asymmetry Finance",
   "pinnedBlock": 26441165,
   "probe": {
    "block_hash": "0x5182be2c61af5f48ed2ec43d3c177dedad257c4e966a7e384120829de73901d9",
    "block_number": 26441165,
    "call_args": [],
    "call_signature": null,
    "chain": "ethereum",
    "check_type": "eth_getStorageAt",
    "extra_calls": [],
    "id": "asymmetry-finance-upgradeability-000000-s28",
    "repro_calldata": null,
    "rpc_env_var": "$ETH_RPC_URL",
    "selector_or_slot": "0x360894a13ba1a3210667c828492db98dca3e2076cc3735a920a3ca505d382bbc",
    "target_contract": "0x00000069aBbB0B1Ad6975bcF753eEe15D318A0BF",
    "target_label": "Asymmetry Finance SimpleProxy"
   },
   "reconciled": false,
   "reconciledFrom": [],
   "reconciledTo": [],
   "records": 1,
   "rosetteAria": "Asymmetry Finance control-plane rosette: Upgradeability not determined; Timelock floor not determined; Signer quorum not determined; Emergency / freeze scope not determined; Docs-vs-chain parity strong",
   "search": "asymmetry finance asymmetry-finance hybrid liquid staking products with real yield (ethereum) asf 0x00000069abbb0b1ad6975bcf753eee15d318a0bf 0xb628b1fdbe8c01777aea2bf3bd386df4af84e8d3",
   "slug": "asymmetry-finance",
   "summary_short": "The Asymmetry Finance SimpleProxy is upgradeable (UUPS), as its docs state",
   "url": "https://pacta.wtf/protocols/asymmetry-finance/"
  },
  {
   "baskets": [
    "lending_vaults"
   ],
   "category": "Decentralized prediction market platform (Ethereum)",
   "chains": [
    "ethereum"
   ],
   "deltas": 0,
   "easAttested": false,
   "evidence": {
    "documented": "Augur documentation is linked for reference (https://www.augur.net/). This RPC-pinned record does not compare documentation parameters with the on-chain state.",
    "observed": "Reputation (0x221657776846890989a759BA2973e427DfF5C9bB) verified on Ethereum Mainnet at canonical block #26,458,556 (7,860 bytes runtime code). EIP-1967 implementation and admin storage slots are both zero (non-EIP-1967 contract). No owner(), admin(), authority(), curator() or AccessControl admin was readable on the contract.",
    "recordId": "augur-control-plane",
    "surface": "Reputation · Non-Proxy Bytecode & Controller"
   },
   "factors": [
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "upgrade",
     "label": "Upgradeability",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "Upgrade path not in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "timelock",
     "label": "Timelock floor",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No enforced admin delay in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "quorum",
     "label": "Signer quorum",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No signer quorum in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "emergency",
     "label": "Emergency / freeze scope",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No pause / freeze authority in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "parity",
     "label": "Docs-vs-chain parity",
     "state": "u",
     "value": "Uncompared: documentation not assessed (RPC-observed)"
    }
   ],
   "finding": "Reputation · Non-Proxy Bytecode & Controller",
   "grade": "observed",
   "gradeLabel": "OBSERVED",
   "name": "Augur",
   "pinnedBlock": 26458556,
   "probe": {
    "block_hash": "0xe258bb1cbcc988e2dfdba4ba173f9f8690520dba3647cdcae18e0651822769d2",
    "block_number": 26458556,
    "call_args": [],
    "call_signature": "owner()",
    "chain": "ethereum",
    "check_type": "eth_call",
    "extra_calls": [],
    "id": "augur-control-plane",
    "repro_calldata": "0x8da5cb5b",
    "rpc_env_var": "$ETH_RPC_URL",
    "selector_or_slot": "0x8da5cb5b",
    "target_contract": "0x221657776846890989a759BA2973e427DfF5C9bB",
    "target_label": "Reputation"
   },
   "reconciled": false,
   "reconciledFrom": [],
   "reconciledTo": [],
   "records": 1,
   "rosetteAria": "Augur control-plane rosette: Upgradeability not determined; Timelock floor not determined; Signer quorum not determined; Emergency / freeze scope not determined; Docs-vs-chain parity uncompared",
   "search": "augur augur decentralized prediction market platform (ethereum) repv2 0x221657776846890989a759ba2973e427dff5c9bb",
   "slug": "augur",
   "summary_short": "Non-proxy contract no readable owner or admin; docs not assessed",
   "url": "https://pacta.wtf/protocols/augur/"
  },
  {
   "baskets": [
    "lending_vaults"
   ],
   "category": "Yield booster pooling veBAL voting power to lift Balancer LP rewards (auraBAL) (Ethereum)",
   "chains": [
    "ethereum"
   ],
   "deltas": 0,
   "easAttested": true,
   "evidence": {
    "documented": "'Initially consisting of 7 signers (4/7 majority needed).' (raw.githubusercontent.com/aurafinance/aura-docs/main/aura/governance/multisig-composition.md); '0x3Fa73f1E5d8A792C80F426fc8F84FBF7Ce9bBCAC' (raw.githubusercontent.com/aurafinance/aura-docs/main/aura/governance/multisig-rights.md)",
    "observed": "AuraLocker 0x3Fa73f1E5d8A792C80F426fc8F84FBF7Ce9bBCAC (Ethereum, not a proxy; the multisig-rights page links it as a contract the Protocol Multisig administers): owner() = 0x5feA4413E3Cc5Cf3A29a49dB41ac0c24850417a0, a Safe: getThreshold() = 4 of getOwners() = 7; guard slot empty. Its two enabled modules (getModulesPaginated: one complete page, next = the sentinel) were vetted from verified source; each has owner() and safeWallet() = the Safe and exposes only onlyKeeper functions that make a zero-value Call to a fixed (immutable) target, without the Safe owners' signatures: GaugeVoterModule 0x2b5Ac82C5e934407514768CE3e399d9c18381621: voteGaugeWeight(address[],uint256[]) (gauge-weight votes, capped at MAX_WEIGHT() = 2500 per gauge) and setDstChainId(address[],uint16[]) (sets gauges' destination chain ids on the GaugeVoter); ExtraRewardStashModule 0x48e529218743E41F6De5B7E8D552E8173707cE81: setStashExtraReward(pid, token) for tokens the Safe authorized (updateAuthorizedTokens is onlyOwner). Keepers and authorized tokens are set by the Safe. Neither module reaches AuraLocker, the Booster's fees, the VoterProxy, shutdown or the Safe's own owner / threshold / module configuration, so that non-delegated authority needs 4 of 7 signatures; the delegated keeper actions (capped gauge votes, gauge destination chain ids, stash rewards for authorized tokens) do not.",
    "recordId": "aura-protocol-multisig-4-of-7-s36",
    "surface": "AuraLocker owner = Protocol Multisig, 4-of-7 (docs: 4/7); 2 vetted keeper modules"
   },
   "factors": [
    {
     "evidence": "aura-protocol-multisig-4-of-7-s36: … 0x3Fa73f1E5d8A792C80F426fc8F84FBF7Ce9bBCAC (Ethereum, not a proxy; the multisig-rights page links it …",
     "key": "upgrade",
     "label": "Upgradeability",
     "state": "g",
     "value": "Immutable or ownership renounced"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "timelock",
     "label": "Timelock floor",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No enforced admin delay in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "quorum",
     "label": "Signer quorum",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No signer quorum in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "emergency",
     "label": "Emergency / freeze scope",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No pause / freeze authority in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "parity",
     "label": "Docs-vs-chain parity",
     "state": "g",
     "value": "Chain matches or is stronger than the documentation"
    }
   ],
   "finding": "AuraLocker owner = Protocol Multisig, 4-of-7 (docs: 4/7); 2 vetted keeper modules",
   "grade": "aligned",
   "gradeLabel": "ALIGNED",
   "name": "Aura",
   "pinnedBlock": 26455787,
   "probe": {
    "block_hash": "0x4fa7e0b166d674666a68121cfde1ecd9d61d03f101c4fe20f2081610e9f91316",
    "block_number": 26455787,
    "call_args": [],
    "call_signature": "owner()",
    "chain": "ethereum",
    "check_type": "eth_call",
    "extra_calls": [],
    "id": "aura-protocol-multisig-4-of-7-s36",
    "repro_calldata": "0x8da5cb5b",
    "rpc_env_var": "$ETH_RPC_URL",
    "selector_or_slot": "0x8da5cb5b",
    "target_contract": "0x3Fa73f1E5d8A792C80F426fc8F84FBF7Ce9bBCAC",
    "target_label": "AuraLocker (vlAURA)"
   },
   "reconciled": false,
   "reconciledFrom": [],
   "reconciledTo": [],
   "records": 1,
   "rosetteAria": "Aura control-plane rosette: Upgradeability strong; Timelock floor not determined; Signer quorum not determined; Emergency / freeze scope not determined; Docs-vs-chain parity strong",
   "search": "aura aura yield booster pooling vebal voting power to lift balancer lp rewards (aurabal) (ethereum) aura 0x2b5ac82c5e934407514768ce3e399d9c18381621 0x3fa73f1e5d8a792c80f426fc8f84fbf7ce9bbcac 0x48e529218743e41f6de5b7e8d552e8173707ce81 0x5fea4413e3cc5cf3a29a49db41ac0c24850417a0",
   "slug": "aura",
   "summary_short": "Aura's Protocol Multisig is 4-of-7, as documented",
   "url": "https://pacta.wtf/protocols/aura/"
  },
  {
   "baskets": [],
   "category": "Autonomous Liquidity Routing Pools (Autopools) (Ethereum)",
   "chains": [
    "ethereum"
   ],
   "deltas": 0,
   "easAttested": false,
   "evidence": {
    "documented": "AUTOfinance documentation is linked for reference (https://docs.auto.finance/). This RPC-pinned record does not compare documentation parameters with the on-chain state.",
    "observed": "SystemRegistry (0x2218F90A98b0C070676f249EF44834686dAa4285) verified on Ethereum Mainnet at canonical block #26,458,556 (9,299 bytes runtime code). EIP-1967 implementation and admin storage slots are both zero (non-EIP-1967 contract). Direct owner() returns Safe 6-of-11 0x8b4334d4812C530574Bd4F2763FcD22dE94A969B.",
    "recordId": "autofinance-control-plane",
    "surface": "SystemRegistry · Non-Proxy Bytecode & Controller"
   },
   "factors": [
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "upgrade",
     "label": "Upgradeability",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "Upgrade path not in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "timelock",
     "label": "Timelock floor",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No enforced admin delay in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": "autofinance-control-plane: … contract). Direct owner() returns Safe 6-of-11 0x8b4334d4812C530574Bd4F2763FcD22dE94A969B.",
     "key": "quorum",
     "label": "Signer quorum",
     "state": "g",
     "value": "Lowest controlling quorum: 6-of-11"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "emergency",
     "label": "Emergency / freeze scope",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No pause / freeze authority in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "parity",
     "label": "Docs-vs-chain parity",
     "state": "u",
     "value": "Uncompared: documentation not assessed (RPC-observed)"
    }
   ],
   "finding": "SystemRegistry · Non-Proxy Bytecode & Controller",
   "grade": "observed",
   "gradeLabel": "OBSERVED",
   "name": "AUTOfinance",
   "pinnedBlock": 26458556,
   "probe": {
    "block_hash": "0xe258bb1cbcc988e2dfdba4ba173f9f8690520dba3647cdcae18e0651822769d2",
    "block_number": 26458556,
    "call_args": [],
    "call_signature": "owner()",
    "chain": "ethereum",
    "check_type": "eth_call",
    "extra_calls": [],
    "id": "autofinance-control-plane",
    "repro_calldata": "0x8da5cb5b",
    "rpc_env_var": "$ETH_RPC_URL",
    "selector_or_slot": "0x8da5cb5b",
    "target_contract": "0x2218F90A98b0C070676f249EF44834686dAa4285",
    "target_label": "SystemRegistry"
   },
   "reconciled": false,
   "reconciledFrom": [],
   "reconciledTo": [],
   "records": 1,
   "rosetteAria": "AUTOfinance control-plane rosette: Upgradeability not determined; Timelock floor not determined; Signer quorum strong; Emergency / freeze scope not determined; Docs-vs-chain parity uncompared",
   "search": "autofinance autofinance autonomous liquidity routing pools (autopools) (ethereum) autofinance 0x2218f90a98b0c070676f249ef44834686daa4285 0x8b4334d4812c530574bd4f2763fcd22de94a969b",
   "slug": "autofinance",
   "summary_short": "Non-proxy contract controlled by a 6-of-11 Safe; docs not assessed",
   "url": "https://pacta.wtf/protocols/autofinance/"
  },
  {
   "baskets": [
    "lending_vaults"
   ],
   "category": "Yield Product with Real-Time APY (Ethereum)",
   "chains": [
    "ethereum"
   ],
   "deltas": 0,
   "easAttested": false,
   "evidence": {
    "documented": "Avalon Superearn documentation is linked for reference (https://docs.avalonfinance.xyz/). This RPC-pinned record does not compare documentation parameters with the on-chain state.",
    "observed": "AVL (AvalonMintable) (0x5c8D0C48810FD37A0A824D074ee290E64f7A8Fa2) verified on Ethereum Mainnet at canonical block #26,458,556 (2,739 bytes runtime code). EIP-1967 proxy: implementation 0x3228995749610Bea00b59C44F8d1df21C14027F1, admin 0x1792f73b586F3e931B51826195Ff015a23C86009. The EIP-1967 admin slot holds contract ProxyAdmin 0x1792f73b586F3e931B51826195Ff015a23C86009. That controller is in turn controlled by Safe 4-of-5 0xbA7468D7ACcd1Bb2E346a003ab1713C3d8C4Da6d.",
    "recordId": "avalon-superearn-control-plane",
    "surface": "AVL (AvalonMintable) · EIP-1967 Proxy & Controller Chain"
   },
   "factors": [
    {
     "evidence": "avalon-superearn-control-plane: AVL (AvalonMintable) (0x5c8D0C48810FD37A0A824D074ee290E64f7A8Fa2) verified on Ethereum Mainnet at canonical block #26,458,556 (2,739 bytes runtime code). …",
     "key": "upgrade",
     "label": "Upgradeability",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "Upgradeable; the delay gating the upgrade path is not in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "timelock",
     "label": "Timelock floor",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No enforced admin delay in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": "avalon-superearn-control-plane: … controller is in turn controlled by Safe 4-of-5 0xbA7468D7ACcd1Bb2E346a003ab1713C3d8C4Da6d.",
     "key": "quorum",
     "label": "Signer quorum",
     "state": "g",
     "value": "Lowest controlling quorum: 4-of-5"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "emergency",
     "label": "Emergency / freeze scope",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No pause / freeze authority in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "parity",
     "label": "Docs-vs-chain parity",
     "state": "u",
     "value": "Uncompared: documentation not assessed (RPC-observed)"
    }
   ],
   "finding": "AVL (AvalonMintable) · EIP-1967 Proxy & Controller Chain",
   "grade": "observed",
   "gradeLabel": "OBSERVED",
   "name": "Avalon Superearn",
   "pinnedBlock": 26458556,
   "probe": {
    "block_hash": "0xe258bb1cbcc988e2dfdba4ba173f9f8690520dba3647cdcae18e0651822769d2",
    "block_number": 26458556,
    "call_args": [],
    "call_signature": null,
    "chain": "ethereum",
    "check_type": "eth_getStorageAt",
    "extra_calls": [],
    "id": "avalon-superearn-control-plane",
    "repro_calldata": null,
    "rpc_env_var": "$ETH_RPC_URL",
    "selector_or_slot": "0xb53127684a568b3173ae13b9f8a6016e243e63b6e8ee1178d6a717850b5d6103",
    "target_contract": "0x5c8D0C48810FD37A0A824D074ee290E64f7A8Fa2",
    "target_label": "AVL (AvalonMintable)"
   },
   "reconciled": false,
   "reconciledFrom": [],
   "reconciledTo": [],
   "records": 1,
   "rosetteAria": "Avalon Superearn control-plane rosette: Upgradeability not determined; Timelock floor not determined; Signer quorum strong; Emergency / freeze scope not determined; Docs-vs-chain parity uncompared",
   "search": "avalon superearn avalon-superearn yield product with real-time apy (ethereum) avl 0x1792f73b586f3e931b51826195ff015a23c86009 0x3228995749610bea00b59c44f8d1df21c14027f1 0x5c8d0c48810fd37a0a824d074ee290e64f7a8fa2 0xba7468d7accd1bb2e346a003ab1713c3d8c4da6d",
   "slug": "avalon-superearn",
   "summary_short": "Upgradeable proxy controlled by a 4-of-5 Safe; docs not assessed",
   "url": "https://pacta.wtf/protocols/avalon-superearn/"
  },
  {
   "baskets": [
    "lending_vaults",
    "stable_rwa"
   ],
   "category": "Stable-value ether token with a staked yield-bearing version (Ethereum)",
   "chains": [
    "ethereum"
   ],
   "deltas": 0,
   "easAttested": false,
   "evidence": {
    "documented": "Avant avETH documentation is linked for reference (https://docs.avantprotocol.com/). This RPC-pinned record does not compare documentation parameters with the on-chain state.",
    "observed": "avETH (AvantCoin) (0x9469470C9878bf3d6d0604831d9A3A366156f7EE) verified on Ethereum Mainnet at canonical block #26,458,556 (6,253 bytes runtime code). EIP-1967 implementation and admin storage slots are both zero (non-EIP-1967 contract). Direct owner() returns externally owned account (no code) 0xd4d23209aaE8630bf386b7393763a5b7865e57cb.",
    "recordId": "avant-aveth-control-plane",
    "surface": "avETH (AvantCoin) · Non-Proxy Bytecode & Controller"
   },
   "factors": [
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "upgrade",
     "label": "Upgradeability",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "Upgrade path not in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "timelock",
     "label": "Timelock floor",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No enforced admin delay in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": "avant-aveth-control-plane: … (non-EIP-1967 contract). Direct owner() returns externally owned account (no code) 0xd4d23209aaE8630bf386b7393763a5b7865e57cb.",
     "key": "quorum",
     "label": "Signer quorum",
     "state": "a",
     "value": "Lowest controlling quorum: a single key"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "emergency",
     "label": "Emergency / freeze scope",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No pause / freeze authority in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "parity",
     "label": "Docs-vs-chain parity",
     "state": "u",
     "value": "Uncompared: documentation not assessed (RPC-observed)"
    }
   ],
   "finding": "avETH (AvantCoin) · Non-Proxy Bytecode & Controller",
   "grade": "observed",
   "gradeLabel": "OBSERVED",
   "name": "Avant avETH",
   "pinnedBlock": 26458556,
   "probe": {
    "block_hash": "0xe258bb1cbcc988e2dfdba4ba173f9f8690520dba3647cdcae18e0651822769d2",
    "block_number": 26458556,
    "call_args": [],
    "call_signature": "owner()",
    "chain": "ethereum",
    "check_type": "eth_call",
    "extra_calls": [],
    "id": "avant-aveth-control-plane",
    "repro_calldata": "0x8da5cb5b",
    "rpc_env_var": "$ETH_RPC_URL",
    "selector_or_slot": "0x8da5cb5b",
    "target_contract": "0x9469470C9878bf3d6d0604831d9A3A366156f7EE",
    "target_label": "avETH (AvantCoin)"
   },
   "reconciled": false,
   "reconciledFrom": [],
   "reconciledTo": [],
   "records": 1,
   "rosetteAria": "Avant avETH control-plane rosette: Upgradeability not determined; Timelock floor not determined; Signer quorum weak; Emergency / freeze scope not determined; Docs-vs-chain parity uncompared",
   "search": "avant aveth avant-aveth stable-value ether token with a staked yield-bearing version (ethereum) aveth 0x9469470c9878bf3d6d0604831d9a3a366156f7ee 0xd4d23209aae8630bf386b7393763a5b7865e57cb",
   "slug": "avant-aveth",
   "summary_short": "Non-proxy contract controlled by a single key (EOA); docs not assessed",
   "url": "https://pacta.wtf/protocols/avant-aveth/"
  },
  {
   "baskets": [],
   "category": "Cross-Chain Gateway & Interchain Token Service",
   "chains": [
    "ethereum"
   ],
   "deltas": 1,
   "easAttested": true,
   "evidence": {
    "documented": "axelar-contract-deployments (mainnet config, chains.ethereum, linked from docs.axelar.dev): '\"implementation\": \"0x99B5FA03a5ea4315725c43346e55a6A6fbd94098\"' / '\"authModule\": \"0xE3B83f79Fbf01B25659f8A814945aB82186A8AD0\"'",
    "observed": "AxelarGateway 0x4F4495243837681061C4743b74B3eEdf548D56A5: implementation() = 0x16C22cbDD77350b1AC88AdDA344F691c12f41960, authModule() = 0x3d3C73E91B1b0C243f1437F2d8363b1D5B093BD0 (whose owner() is the gateway); the deployment config lists implementation 0x99B5FA03a5ea4315725c43346e55a6A6fbd94098 and auth module 0xE3B83f79Fbf01B25659f8A814945aB82186A8AD0.",
    "recordId": "axelar-network-gateway-auth-module-s25",
    "surface": "Gateway implementation and auth module differ from the deployment config"
   },
   "factors": [
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "upgrade",
     "label": "Upgradeability",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "Upgrade path not in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": "axelar-network-governance-timelock-s25: operator() = 0xc8a8399c3D1207f4e109673be7047604737c1D56 (no contract code), which can run executeOperatorProposal immediately (no delay) for proposals Axelar …",
     "key": "timelock",
     "label": "Timelock floor",
     "state": "a",
     "value": "0s: an operator can execute approved proposals without waiting the timelock delay"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "quorum",
     "label": "Signer quorum",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No signer quorum in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": "axelar-network-its-owner-s25: paused() = false.",
     "key": "emergency",
     "label": "Emergency / freeze scope",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "Pause / freeze authority present; its holder is not determined"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "parity",
     "label": "Docs-vs-chain parity",
     "state": "a",
     "value": "Documentation differs from the chain (parameter delta)"
    }
   ],
   "finding": "Gateway implementation and auth module differ from the deployment config: docs say axelar-contract-deployments (mainnet config, chains.ethereum, linked from docs.axelar.dev): '\"implementation\": \"0x99B5FA03a5ea4315725c43346e55a6A6fbd94098\"' / '\"authModule\": \"0xE3B83f79Fbf01B25659f8A814945aB82186A8AD0\"' · chain says AxelarGateway 0x4F4495243837681061C4743b74B3eEdf548D56A5: implementation() = 0x16C22cbDD77350b1AC88AdDA344F691c12f41960, authModule() = 0x3d3C73E91B1b0C243f1437F2d8363b1D5B093BD0 (whose owner() is the gateway);",
   "grade": "delta",
   "gradeLabel": "DELTA",
   "name": "Axelar Network",
   "pinnedBlock": 26434786,
   "probe": {
    "block_hash": "0xb712439847099ec3e8b1617aafd1bc7ece29e22a88dc4e7c8afcf05e6944d987",
    "block_number": 26434786,
    "call_args": [],
    "call_signature": "authModule()",
    "chain": "ethereum",
    "check_type": "eth_call",
    "extra_calls": [],
    "id": "axelar-network-gateway-auth-module-s25",
    "repro_calldata": "0x64940c56",
    "rpc_env_var": "$ETH_RPC_URL",
    "selector_or_slot": "0x64940c56",
    "target_contract": "0x4F4495243837681061C4743b74B3eEdf548D56A5",
    "target_label": "AxelarGateway (proxy)"
   },
   "reconciled": false,
   "reconciledFrom": [],
   "reconciledTo": [],
   "records": 5,
   "rosetteAria": "Axelar Network control-plane rosette: Upgradeability not determined; Timelock floor weak; Signer quorum not determined; Emergency / freeze scope not determined; Docs-vs-chain parity weak",
   "search": "axelar network axelar-network cross-chain gateway & interchain token service axl axelar axelargateway interchaintokenservice 0x16c22cbdd77350b1ac88adda344f691c12f41960 0x3d3c73e91b1b0c243f1437f2d8363b1d5b093bd0 0x4f4495243837681061c4743b74b3eedf548d56a5 0x7acbae6cba67d78aaf69e47000884ae00f9b2525 0x99b5fa03a5ea4315725c43346e55a6a6fbd94098 0xb5fb4be02232b1bba4dc8f81dc24c26980de9e3c 0xc8a8399c3d1207f4e109673be7047604737c1d56 0xcc940ae49c78f20e3f13f3cf37e996b98ac3ec68 0xe3b83f79fbf01b25659f8a814945ab82186a8ad0",
   "slug": "axelar-network",
   "summary_short": "Deployment config lists an older gateway implementation; 3-day timelock with operator path",
   "url": "https://pacta.wtf/protocols/axelar-network/"
  },
  {
   "baskets": [
    "lending_vaults"
   ],
   "category": "Bitcoin-focused DeFi collective and vault strategies (Ethereum)",
   "chains": [
    "ethereum"
   ],
   "deltas": 0,
   "easAttested": false,
   "evidence": {
    "documented": "Badger DAO documentation is linked for reference (https://badger.com/admin). This RPC-pinned record does not compare documentation parameters with the on-chain state.",
    "observed": "Badger (MiniMeToken) (0x3472A5A71965499acd81997a54BBA8D852C6E53d) verified on Ethereum Mainnet at canonical block #26,458,556 (7,440 bytes runtime code). EIP-1967 implementation and admin storage slots are both zero (non-EIP-1967 contract). No owner(), admin(), authority(), curator() or AccessControl admin was readable on the contract.",
    "recordId": "badger-dao-control-plane",
    "surface": "Badger (MiniMeToken) · Non-Proxy Bytecode & Controller"
   },
   "factors": [
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "upgrade",
     "label": "Upgradeability",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "Upgrade path not in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "timelock",
     "label": "Timelock floor",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No enforced admin delay in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "quorum",
     "label": "Signer quorum",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No signer quorum in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "emergency",
     "label": "Emergency / freeze scope",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No pause / freeze authority in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "parity",
     "label": "Docs-vs-chain parity",
     "state": "u",
     "value": "Uncompared: documentation not assessed (RPC-observed)"
    }
   ],
   "finding": "Badger (MiniMeToken) · Non-Proxy Bytecode & Controller",
   "grade": "observed",
   "gradeLabel": "OBSERVED",
   "name": "Badger DAO",
   "pinnedBlock": 26458556,
   "probe": {
    "block_hash": "0xe258bb1cbcc988e2dfdba4ba173f9f8690520dba3647cdcae18e0651822769d2",
    "block_number": 26458556,
    "call_args": [],
    "call_signature": "owner()",
    "chain": "ethereum",
    "check_type": "eth_call",
    "extra_calls": [],
    "id": "badger-dao-control-plane",
    "repro_calldata": "0x8da5cb5b",
    "rpc_env_var": "$ETH_RPC_URL",
    "selector_or_slot": "0x8da5cb5b",
    "target_contract": "0x3472A5A71965499acd81997a54BBA8D852C6E53d",
    "target_label": "Badger (MiniMeToken)"
   },
   "reconciled": false,
   "reconciledFrom": [],
   "reconciledTo": [],
   "records": 1,
   "rosetteAria": "Badger DAO control-plane rosette: Upgradeability not determined; Timelock floor not determined; Signer quorum not determined; Emergency / freeze scope not determined; Docs-vs-chain parity uncompared",
   "search": "badger dao badger-dao bitcoin-focused defi collective and vault strategies (ethereum) badger 0x3472a5a71965499acd81997a54bba8d852c6e53d",
   "slug": "badger-dao",
   "summary_short": "Non-proxy contract no readable owner or admin; docs not assessed",
   "url": "https://pacta.wtf/protocols/badger-dao/"
  },
  {
   "baskets": [
    "lending_vaults"
   ],
   "category": "Programmable Liquidity Vault",
   "chains": [
    "ethereum"
   ],
   "deltas": 0,
   "easAttested": true,
   "evidence": {
    "documented": "docs.balancer.fi (multisig): 'DAO Multi-sig 0x10A19e7eE7d7F8a52822f6817de8ea18204F2e4f open in new window 6/11 DAO Signers DAO administrative permissions' and 'Ethereum DAO Multisig — Authorizer admin on Mainnet'",
    "observed": "Authorizer 0xA331D84eC860Bf466b4CdCcFb4aC09a1B43F3aE6 (the getActualAuthorizer() of the Vault's AuthorizerWithAdaptorValidation 0x6048A8c631Fb7e77EcA533Cf9C29784e482391e7): getRoleMemberCount(DEFAULT_ADMIN_ROLE) = 1, member 0 = DAO Multi-sig 0x10A19e7eE7d7F8a52822f6817de8ea18204F2e4f, a 6-of-11 Safe (v1.1.1, no modules).",
    "recordId": "balancer-v2-vault-timelock-authorizer-admin-dao-multisig-s21",
    "surface": "Authorizer DEFAULT_ADMIN_ROLE: the 6-of-11 DAO Multi-sig"
   },
   "factors": [
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "upgrade",
     "label": "Upgradeability",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "Upgrade path not in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "timelock",
     "label": "Timelock floor",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No enforced admin delay in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": "balancer-v2-vault-timelock-authorizer-admin-dao-multisig-s21: … 0x10A19e7eE7d7F8a52822f6817de8ea18204F2e4f, a 6-of-11 Safe (v1.1.1, no modules).",
     "key": "quorum",
     "label": "Signer quorum",
     "state": "g",
     "value": "Lowest controlling quorum: 6-of-11"
    },
    {
     "evidence": "balancer-v2-vault-timelock-vault-immutable-pause-expired-s21: Vault 0xBA12222222228d8Ba445958a75a0704d566BF2C8: getPausedState() = (false, 1626633407, 1629225407) - the pause window and buffer period ended before the pin",
     "key": "emergency",
     "label": "Emergency / freeze scope",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "Pause / freeze authority present; its holder is not determined"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "parity",
     "label": "Docs-vs-chain parity",
     "state": "g",
     "value": "Chain matches or is stronger than the documentation"
    }
   ],
   "finding": "Authorizer DEFAULT_ADMIN_ROLE: the 6-of-11 DAO Multi-sig",
   "grade": "aligned",
   "gradeLabel": "ALIGNED",
   "name": "Balancer V2 Vault & TimelockAuthorizer",
   "pinnedBlock": 26427612,
   "probe": {
    "block_hash": "0x1c5ef52eb0b586e49da2a11dc9f905cae4125008dc814d6781f53a142f6555ac",
    "block_number": 26427612,
    "call_args": [
     "0x0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000",
     "0x0"
    ],
    "call_signature": "getRoleMember(bytes32,uint256)",
    "chain": "ethereum",
    "check_type": "eth_call",
    "extra_calls": [],
    "id": "balancer-v2-vault-timelock-authorizer-admin-dao-multisig-s21",
    "repro_calldata": "0x9010d07c00000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000",
    "rpc_env_var": "$ETH_RPC_URL",
    "selector_or_slot": "0x9010d07c",
    "target_contract": "0xA331D84eC860Bf466b4CdCcFb4aC09a1B43F3aE6",
    "target_label": "Balancer V2 Authorizer"
   },
   "reconciled": false,
   "reconciledFrom": [],
   "reconciledTo": [],
   "records": 2,
   "rosetteAria": "Balancer V2 Vault & TimelockAuthorizer control-plane rosette: Upgradeability not determined; Timelock floor not determined; Signer quorum strong; Emergency / freeze scope not determined; Docs-vs-chain parity strong",
   "search": "balancer v2 vault & timelockauthorizer balancer-v2-vault-timelock programmable liquidity vault bal vebal 0x10a19e7ee7d7f8a52822f6817de8ea18204f2e4f 0x6048a8c631fb7e77eca533cf9c29784e482391e7 0xa331d84ec860bf466b4cdccfb4ac09a1b43f3ae6 0xba12222222228d8ba445958a75a0704d566bf2c8",
   "slug": "balancer-v2-vault-timelock",
   "summary_short": "Authorizer admin role is the 6-of-11 DAO multisig, as documented",
   "url": "https://pacta.wtf/protocols/balancer-v2-vault-timelock/"
  },
  {
   "baskets": [],
   "category": "Single-sided liquidity pools with protocol-owned depth (Ethereum)",
   "chains": [
    "ethereum"
   ],
   "deltas": 0,
   "easAttested": true,
   "evidence": {
    "documented": "'MSIG rule 5/7 members must sign for a transaction to be executed.' (docs.bancor.network/about-bancor-network/security-and-audits/multisig-rights.md)",
    "observed": "MSIG Safe 0x7E3692A6D8c34a762079Fa9057AeD87be7e67cb8 (Ethereum): getThreshold() = 5 of getOwners() = 7 owners (Safe v1.1.1).",
    "recordId": "bancor-v3-safe-threshold-7e3692-s31",
    "surface": "MSIG: 5-of-7 Safe, as documented"
   },
   "factors": [
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "upgrade",
     "label": "Upgradeability",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "Upgrade path not in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "timelock",
     "label": "Timelock floor",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No enforced admin delay in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": "controller fact: Safe getThreshold()",
     "key": "quorum",
     "label": "Signer quorum",
     "state": "g",
     "value": "Lowest controlling quorum: 5-of-7"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "emergency",
     "label": "Emergency / freeze scope",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No pause / freeze authority in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "parity",
     "label": "Docs-vs-chain parity",
     "state": "g",
     "value": "Chain matches or is stronger than the documentation"
    }
   ],
   "finding": "MSIG: 5-of-7 Safe, as documented",
   "grade": "aligned",
   "gradeLabel": "ALIGNED",
   "name": "Bancor V3",
   "pinnedBlock": 26450616,
   "probe": {
    "block_hash": "0xd2df7ccb74a6772b51a5597c8f144f5cfae362efeabf193ecfc7c80f8ff37c35",
    "block_number": 26450616,
    "call_args": [],
    "call_signature": "getThreshold()",
    "chain": "ethereum",
    "check_type": "eth_call",
    "extra_calls": [],
    "id": "bancor-v3-safe-threshold-7e3692-s31",
    "repro_calldata": "0xe75235b8",
    "rpc_env_var": "$ETH_RPC_URL",
    "selector_or_slot": "0xe75235b8",
    "target_contract": "0x7E3692A6D8c34a762079Fa9057AeD87be7e67cb8",
    "target_label": "MSIG Safe"
   },
   "reconciled": false,
   "reconciledFrom": [],
   "reconciledTo": [],
   "records": 1,
   "rosetteAria": "Bancor V3 control-plane rosette: Upgradeability not determined; Timelock floor not determined; Signer quorum strong; Emergency / freeze scope not determined; Docs-vs-chain parity strong",
   "search": "bancor v3 bancor-v3 single-sided liquidity pools with protocol-owned depth (ethereum) bnt 0x7e3692a6d8c34a762079fa9057aed87be7e67cb8",
   "slug": "bancor-v3",
   "summary_short": "The Bancor V3 MSIG is a 5-of-7 Safe, as documented",
   "url": "https://pacta.wtf/protocols/bancor-v3/"
  },
  {
   "baskets": [],
   "category": "Canonical OP Stack bridge between Ethereum and Base (L1 contracts behind a ProxyAdmin)",
   "chains": [
    "ethereum"
   ],
   "deltas": 1,
   "easAttested": true,
   "evidence": {
    "documented": "'Authorized to update the L1 Proxy Admin.' (docs.base.org/specifications/reference/configuration, row L1 ProxyAdmin Owner: 0x5a0Aae59D09fccBdDb6C6CcEB07B7279367C3d2A)",
    "observed": "Base L1 ProxyAdmin 0x0475cBCAebd9CE8AfA5025828d5b98DFb67E059E (Ethereum): owner() = Safe 0x7bB41C3008B3f03FE483B28b8DB90e19Cf07595c with getThreshold() = 2 of getOwners() = 2 owners: 0x9855054731540A48b28990B63DcF4f33d8AE46A1 (3-of-6 Safe), 0x20AcF55A3DCfe07fC4cecaCFa1628F788EC8A4Dd (8-of-11 Safe). The address the configuration page names as L1 ProxyAdmin Owner, 0x5a0Aae59D09fccBdDb6C6CcEB07B7279367C3d2A, is a 2-of-2 Safe, not one of those owners.",
    "recordId": "base-bridge-l1-proxyadmin-owner-s29",
    "surface": "L1 ProxyAdmin owner: docs name 0x5a0A…3d2A; owner() is another 2-of-2 Safe"
   },
   "factors": [
    {
     "evidence": "base-bridge-l1-proxyadmin-owner-s29: Base L1 ProxyAdmin 0x0475cBCAebd9CE8AfA5025828d5b98DFb67E059E (Ethereum): owner() = Safe 0x7bB41C3008B3f03FE483B28b8DB90e19Cf07595c with getThreshold() = 2 of …",
     "key": "upgrade",
     "label": "Upgradeability",
     "state": "a",
     "value": "Upgradeable with no enforced delay: upgraded by a Safe directly (a Safe has no delay of its own)"
    },
    {
     "evidence": "base-bridge-l1-proxyadmin-owner-s29: Base L1 ProxyAdmin 0x0475cBCAebd9CE8AfA5025828d5b98DFb67E059E (Ethereum): owner() = Safe 0x7bB41C3008B3f03FE483B28b8DB90e19Cf07595c with getThreshold() = 2 of …",
     "key": "timelock",
     "label": "Timelock floor",
     "state": "a",
     "value": "0s minimum enforced delay across control surfaces"
    },
    {
     "evidence": "base-bridge-l1-proxyadmin-owner-s29: … 0x5a0Aae59D09fccBdDb6C6CcEB07B7279367C3d2A, is a 2-of-2 Safe, not one of those owners.",
     "key": "quorum",
     "label": "Signer quorum",
     "state": "b",
     "value": "Lowest controlling quorum: 2-of-2"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "emergency",
     "label": "Emergency / freeze scope",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No pause / freeze authority in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "parity",
     "label": "Docs-vs-chain parity",
     "state": "a",
     "value": "Documentation differs from the chain (parameter delta)"
    }
   ],
   "finding": "L1 ProxyAdmin owner: docs name 0x5a0A…3d2A; owner() is another 2-of-2 Safe: docs say 'Authorized to update the L1 Proxy Admin.' (docs.base.org/specifications/reference/configuration, row L1 ProxyAdmin Owner: 0x5a0Aae59D09fccBdDb6C6CcEB07B7279367C3d2A) · chain says Base L1 ProxyAdmin 0x0475cBCAebd9CE8AfA5025828d5b98DFb67E059E (Ethereum): owner() = Safe 0x7bB41C3008B3f03FE483B28b8DB90e19Cf07595c with getThreshold() = 2 of getOwners() = 2 owners: 0x9855054731540A48b28990B63DcF4f33d8…",
   "grade": "delta",
   "gradeLabel": "DELTA",
   "name": "Base Bridge",
   "pinnedBlock": 26448221,
   "probe": {
    "block_hash": "0xa7818c0e1b8807aac0c999c2dc9aeeea40b91b4f19b1b76a62ad02d8d17607c8",
    "block_number": 26448221,
    "call_args": [],
    "call_signature": "owner()",
    "chain": "ethereum",
    "check_type": "eth_call",
    "extra_calls": [],
    "id": "base-bridge-l1-proxyadmin-owner-s29",
    "repro_calldata": "0x8da5cb5b",
    "rpc_env_var": "$ETH_RPC_URL",
    "selector_or_slot": "0x8da5cb5b",
    "target_contract": "0x0475cBCAebd9CE8AfA5025828d5b98DFb67E059E",
    "target_label": "Base L1 ProxyAdmin"
   },
   "reconciled": false,
   "reconciledFrom": [],
   "reconciledTo": [],
   "records": 1,
   "rosetteAria": "Base Bridge control-plane rosette: Upgradeability weak; Timelock floor weak; Signer quorum moderate; Emergency / freeze scope not determined; Docs-vs-chain parity weak",
   "search": "base bridge base-bridge canonical op stack bridge between ethereum and base (l1 contracts behind a proxyadmin) basebridge 0x0475cbcaebd9ce8afa5025828d5b98dfb67e059e 0x20acf55a3dcfe07fc4cecacfa1628f788ec8a4dd 0x5a0aae59d09fccbddb6c6cceb07b7279367c3d2a 0x7bb41c3008b3f03fe483b28b8db90e19cf07595c 0x9855054731540a48b28990b63dcf4f33d8ae46a1",
   "slug": "base-bridge",
   "summary_short": "Docs name another L1 ProxyAdmin Owner; owner() is a different 2-of-2 Safe",
   "url": "https://pacta.wtf/protocols/base-bridge/"
  },
  {
   "baskets": [],
   "category": "Token-owned liquidity AMM with guaranteed floor prices (Ethereum)",
   "chains": [
    "ethereum"
   ],
   "deltas": 0,
   "easAttested": false,
   "evidence": {
    "documented": "Baseline Protocol documentation is linked for reference (https://www.baseline.markets/). This RPC-pinned record does not compare documentation parameters with the on-chain state.",
    "observed": "Baseline (BToken) (0x9fDbDE76236998Dc2836FE67A9954eDE456A1D63) verified on Ethereum Mainnet at canonical block #26,458,556 (2,573 bytes runtime code). EIP-1967 implementation and admin storage slots are both zero (non-EIP-1967 contract). No owner(), admin(), authority(), curator() or AccessControl admin was readable on the contract.",
    "recordId": "baseline-protocol-control-plane",
    "surface": "Baseline (BToken) · Non-Proxy Bytecode & Controller"
   },
   "factors": [
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "upgrade",
     "label": "Upgradeability",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "Upgrade path not in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "timelock",
     "label": "Timelock floor",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No enforced admin delay in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "quorum",
     "label": "Signer quorum",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No signer quorum in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "emergency",
     "label": "Emergency / freeze scope",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No pause / freeze authority in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "parity",
     "label": "Docs-vs-chain parity",
     "state": "u",
     "value": "Uncompared: documentation not assessed (RPC-observed)"
    }
   ],
   "finding": "Baseline (BToken) · Non-Proxy Bytecode & Controller",
   "grade": "observed",
   "gradeLabel": "OBSERVED",
   "name": "Baseline Protocol",
   "pinnedBlock": 26458556,
   "probe": {
    "block_hash": "0xe258bb1cbcc988e2dfdba4ba173f9f8690520dba3647cdcae18e0651822769d2",
    "block_number": 26458556,
    "call_args": [],
    "call_signature": "owner()",
    "chain": "ethereum",
    "check_type": "eth_call",
    "extra_calls": [],
    "id": "baseline-protocol-control-plane",
    "repro_calldata": "0x8da5cb5b",
    "rpc_env_var": "$ETH_RPC_URL",
    "selector_or_slot": "0x8da5cb5b",
    "target_contract": "0x9fDbDE76236998Dc2836FE67A9954eDE456A1D63",
    "target_label": "Baseline (BToken)"
   },
   "reconciled": false,
   "reconciledFrom": [],
   "reconciledTo": [],
   "records": 1,
   "rosetteAria": "Baseline Protocol control-plane rosette: Upgradeability not determined; Timelock floor not determined; Signer quorum not determined; Emergency / freeze scope not determined; Docs-vs-chain parity uncompared",
   "search": "baseline protocol baseline-protocol token-owned liquidity amm with guaranteed floor prices (ethereum) baseline 0x9fdbde76236998dc2836fe67a9954ede456a1d63",
   "slug": "baseline-protocol",
   "summary_short": "Non-proxy contract no readable owner or admin; docs not assessed",
   "url": "https://pacta.wtf/protocols/baseline-protocol/"
  },
  {
   "baskets": [
    "eth_lst_lrt",
    "lending_vaults"
   ],
   "category": "Liquid restaking Bitcoin vault and token (uniBTC) with a Proof-of-Reserve mint check",
   "chains": [
    "ethereum"
   ],
   "deltas": 1,
   "easAttested": true,
   "evidence": {
    "documented": "'Before any minting action occurs, the smart contract automatically checks reserve sufficiency using the on-chain Proof of Reserve feed. If reserves fall short, the mint transaction reverts.' (docs.bedrock.technology/security/secure-mint)",
    "observed": "Bedrock VaultWithoutNative 0x047D41F2544B7F63A8e991aF2068a363d210d6Da (Ethereum): adequacyRatio() = 900, so checkReserve() evaluates existing supply * 900 / 1000 <= reserves before minting (feeders: reserve 0xc590D9fb8eE78a0909dFF341ccf717000b7b7fF2, supply 0xE542919E4b281f10b437F947c8Ba224DdfaBc716). The incoming mint amount is absent from this inequality, so ~111.1% is not a post-mint ceiling; separate per-asset caps and collateral-transfer checks in _mint() still apply, and uniBTC.mint() (0x004E9C3EF86bc1ca1f0bB5C7662861Ee93350568) performs no PoR check of its own. MANAGER_ROLE (setAdequacyRatio / setPoRFeeder) and PAUSER_ROLE are held by 0x9251fd3D79522bB2243a58FFf1dB43E25A495aaB, an account carrying 23-byte EIP-7702 delegation code. The vault and uniBTC share ProxyAdmin 0x029E4FbDAa31DE075dD74B2238222A08233978f6, owned by the 3-of-5 Safe 0xC9dA980fFABbE2bbe15d4734FDae5761B86b5Fc3, which also holds uniBTC's DEFAULT_ADMIN_ROLE. This record does not assert a reserve deficit.",
    "recordId": "bedrock-unibtc-secure-mint-precondition-s30",
    "surface": "Secure Mint precondition: adequacyRatio() 900 (existing supply x 0.9 vs reserves)"
   },
   "factors": [
    {
     "evidence": "bedrock-unibtc-secure-mint-precondition-s30: separate per-asset caps and collateral-transfer checks in _mint() still apply, and uniBTC.mint() (0x004E9C3EF86bc1ca1f0bB5C7662861Ee93350568) performs no PoR …",
     "key": "upgrade",
     "label": "Upgradeability",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "Upgradeable; the delay gating the upgrade path is not in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "timelock",
     "label": "Timelock floor",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No enforced admin delay in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": "bedrock-unibtc-secure-mint-precondition-s30: … 0x029E4FbDAa31DE075dD74B2238222A08233978f6, owned by the 3-of-5 Safe 0xC9dA980fFABbE2bbe15d4734FDae5761B86b5Fc3, …",
     "key": "quorum",
     "label": "Signer quorum",
     "state": "g",
     "value": "Lowest controlling quorum: 3-of-5"
    },
    {
     "evidence": "bedrock-unibtc-secure-mint-precondition-s30: separate per-asset caps and collateral-transfer checks in _mint() still apply, and uniBTC.mint() (0x004E9C3EF86bc1ca1f0bB5C7662861Ee93350568) performs no PoR …",
     "key": "emergency",
     "label": "Emergency / freeze scope",
     "state": "g",
     "value": "Pause / freeze authority scoped behind a multi-signer controller (3-of-5)"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "parity",
     "label": "Docs-vs-chain parity",
     "state": "a",
     "value": "Documentation differs from the chain (parameter delta)"
    }
   ],
   "finding": "Secure Mint precondition: adequacyRatio() 900 (existing supply x 0.9 vs reserves): docs say 'Before any minting action occurs, the smart contract automatically checks reserve sufficiency using the on-chain Proof of Reserve feed. · chain says Bedrock VaultWithoutNative 0x047D41F2544B7F63A8e991aF2068a363d210d6Da (Ethereum): adequacyRatio() = 900, so checkReserve() evaluates existing supply * 900 / 1000 <= reserves before minting (feeders: reserve 0xc590D9fb8e…",
   "grade": "delta",
   "gradeLabel": "DELTA",
   "name": "Bedrock (uniBTC)",
   "pinnedBlock": 26449594,
   "probe": {
    "block_hash": "0xbe263d5b378dcb7c3c4e18bd8e388f0cb2dab1adacd83de2be58c9408b377287",
    "block_number": 26449594,
    "call_args": [],
    "call_signature": "adequacyRatio()",
    "chain": "ethereum",
    "check_type": "eth_call",
    "extra_calls": [],
    "id": "bedrock-unibtc-secure-mint-precondition-s30",
    "repro_calldata": "0xe8e18531",
    "rpc_env_var": "$ETH_RPC_URL",
    "selector_or_slot": "0xe8e18531",
    "target_contract": "0x047D41F2544B7F63A8e991aF2068a363d210d6Da",
    "target_label": "Bedrock uniBTC VaultWithoutNative"
   },
   "reconciled": false,
   "reconciledFrom": [],
   "reconciledTo": [],
   "records": 1,
   "rosetteAria": "Bedrock (uniBTC) control-plane rosette: Upgradeability not determined; Timelock floor not determined; Signer quorum strong; Emergency / freeze scope strong; Docs-vs-chain parity weak",
   "search": "bedrock (unibtc) bedrock-unibtc liquid restaking bitcoin vault and token (unibtc) with a proof-of-reserve mint check bedrock(unibtc) 0x004e9c3ef86bc1ca1f0bb5c7662861ee93350568 0x029e4fbdaa31de075dd74b2238222a08233978f6 0x047d41f2544b7f63a8e991af2068a363d210d6da 0x9251fd3d79522bb2243a58fff1db43e25a495aab 0xc590d9fb8ee78a0909dff341ccf717000b7b7ff2 0xc9da980ffabbe2bbe15d4734fdae5761b86b5fc3 0xe542919e4b281f10b437f947c8ba224ddfabc716",
   "slug": "bedrock-unibtc",
   "summary_short": "uniBTC mints test 90% of existing supply vs reserves; docs say short reserves revert",
   "url": "https://pacta.wtf/protocols/bedrock-unibtc/"
  },
  {
   "baskets": [
    "eth_lst_lrt"
   ],
   "category": "Liquid Restaking",
   "chains": [
    "ethereum"
   ],
   "deltas": 1,
   "easAttested": true,
   "evidence": {
    "documented": "docs.bedrock.technology (uniETH contracts): 'Restaking proxy contract: https://etherscan.io/address/0x3f4eaceb930b0edfa78a1dfcbae5c5494e6e9850' / 'Restaking implementation: https://etherscan.io/address/0x9609af0490b96d7add7eea3554b1a944ee440262#code'",
    "observed": "Restaking proxy 0x3F4eaCeb930b0Edfa78a1DFCbaE5c5494E6e9850: EIP-1967 implementation = 0x1e4D0A963953e7c08Fc7602B01e683547Fc4E518 (Sourcify match), not the documented 0x9609Af0490b96D7AdD7EEa3554b1a944ee440262; admin = ProxyAdmin 0xa5F2B6AB5B38b88Ba221741b3A189999b4c889C6.",
    "recordId": "bedrock-unieth-restaking-impl-s25",
    "surface": "Restaking implementation differs from the one the docs list"
   },
   "factors": [
    {
     "evidence": "bedrock-unieth-restaking-impl-s25: admin = ProxyAdmin 0xa5F2B6AB5B38b88Ba221741b3A189999b4c889C6.",
     "key": "upgrade",
     "label": "Upgradeability",
     "state": "a",
     "value": "Upgradeable with no enforced delay: the ProxyAdmin's owner delay (1 other upgrade path not determined)"
    },
    {
     "evidence": "bedrock-unieth-restaking-impl-s25: admin = ProxyAdmin 0xa5F2B6AB5B38b88Ba221741b3A189999b4c889C6.",
     "key": "timelock",
     "label": "Timelock floor",
     "state": "a",
     "value": "0s minimum enforced delay across control surfaces"
    },
    {
     "evidence": "bedrock-unieth-upgrade-admin-s25: … 0x3050620423f4dB43E1904815E898C466526387b8 (3-of-5, no guard); uniETH owner() = Safe 0xAeE017052DF6Ac002647229D58B786E380B9721A …",
     "key": "quorum",
     "label": "Signer quorum",
     "state": "g",
     "value": "Lowest controlling quorum: 3-of-5"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "emergency",
     "label": "Emergency / freeze scope",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No pause / freeze authority in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "parity",
     "label": "Docs-vs-chain parity",
     "state": "a",
     "value": "Documentation differs from the chain (parameter delta)"
    }
   ],
   "finding": "Restaking implementation differs from the one the docs list: docs say docs.bedrock.technology (uniETH contracts): 'Restaking proxy contract: https://etherscan.io/address/0x3f4eaceb930b0edfa78a1dfcbae5c5494e6e9850' / 'Restaking implementation: https://etherscan.io/address/0x9609af0490b96d7… · chain says Restaking proxy 0x3F4eaCeb930b0Edfa78a1DFCbaE5c5494E6e9850: EIP-1967 implementation = 0x1e4D0A963953e7c08Fc7602B01e683547Fc4E518 (Sourcify match), not the documented 0x9609Af0490b96D7AdD7EEa3554b1a944ee440262;",
   "grade": "delta",
   "gradeLabel": "DELTA",
   "name": "Bedrock (uniETH)",
   "pinnedBlock": 26434786,
   "probe": {
    "block_hash": "0xb712439847099ec3e8b1617aafd1bc7ece29e22a88dc4e7c8afcf05e6944d987",
    "block_number": 26434786,
    "call_args": [],
    "call_signature": null,
    "chain": "ethereum",
    "check_type": "eth_getStorageAt",
    "extra_calls": [],
    "id": "bedrock-unieth-restaking-impl-s25",
    "repro_calldata": null,
    "rpc_env_var": "$ETH_RPC_URL",
    "selector_or_slot": "0x360894a13ba1a3210667c828492db98dca3e2076cc3735a920a3ca505d382bbc",
    "target_contract": "0x3F4eaCeb930b0Edfa78a1DFCbaE5c5494E6e9850",
    "target_label": "Bedrock Restaking (proxy)"
   },
   "reconciled": false,
   "reconciledFrom": [],
   "reconciledTo": [],
   "records": 4,
   "rosetteAria": "Bedrock (uniETH) control-plane rosette: Upgradeability weak; Timelock floor weak; Signer quorum strong; Emergency / freeze scope not determined; Docs-vs-chain parity weak",
   "search": "bedrock (unieth) bedrock-unieth liquid restaking unieth 0x1e4d0a963953e7c08fc7602b01e683547fc4e518 0x3050620423f4db43e1904815e898c466526387b8 0x3f4eaceb930b0edfa78a1dfcbae5c5494e6e9850 0x4befa2aa9c305238aa3e0b5d17eb20c045269e9d 0x926720ae39114d0e2043b79570a1e08f00d01cce 0x9609af0490b96d7add7eea3554b1a944ee440262 0xa5f2b6ab5b38b88ba221741b3a189999b4c889c6 0xaee017052df6ac002647229d58b786e380b9721a 0xf1376bcef0f78459c0ed0ba5ddce976f1ddf51f4",
   "slug": "bedrock-unieth",
   "summary_short": "Docs list an older restaking implementation; uniETH upgrades via a 3-of-5 Safe ProxyAdmin",
   "url": "https://pacta.wtf/protocols/bedrock-unieth/"
  },
  {
   "baskets": [
    "base",
    "lending_vaults"
   ],
   "category": "Automated Yield Vaults & CLM (Base)",
   "chains": [
    "base"
   ],
   "deltas": 1,
   "easAttested": true,
   "evidence": {
    "documented": "docs.beefy.finance (contracts and timelocks): 'Beefy ensures that all privileged functions and upgrades are protected by standardised smart contract timelocks.' and 'By default, a 6-hour timelock is configured for all strategy changes and upgrades.' / Base address book: 'vaultOwner: '0x09D19184F46A32213DF06b981122e06882B61309','",
    "observed": "vaultOwner timelock 0x09D19184F46A32213DF06b981122e06882B61309: getMinDelay() = 0s; the dev multisig 0x6FfaCA7C3B38Ec2d631D86e15f328ee6eF6C6226 holds PROPOSER_ROLE, EXECUTOR_ROLE and CANCELLER_ROLE, so an operation it schedules can execute in the same block; the timelock is its own admin (Sourcify exact match).",
    "recordId": "beefy-finance-base-vault-owner-timelock-zero-delay-s22",
    "surface": "Vault owner timelock: no delay (0 seconds)"
   },
   "factors": [
    {
     "evidence": "beefy-finance-base-fee-config-owner-dev-multisig-s22: transparent proxy (Sourcify exact match), implementation 0xAb35d11199216c7F7368080Cf41beD8f3AbBc4E4, EIP-1967 admin = ProxyAdmin …",
     "key": "upgrade",
     "label": "Upgradeability",
     "state": "b",
     "value": "Upgradeable behind a 1h–47h delay (6h)"
    },
    {
     "evidence": "beefy-finance-base-vault-owner-timelock-zero-delay-s22: observed_delay_seconds = 0",
     "key": "timelock",
     "label": "Timelock floor",
     "state": "a",
     "value": "0s minimum enforced delay across control surfaces"
    },
    {
     "evidence": "beefy-finance-base-fee-config-owner-dev-multisig-s22: … 0x6FfaCA7C3B38Ec2d631D86e15f328ee6eF6C6226 (3-of-6 Safe, v1.3.0, no modules); transparent …",
     "key": "quorum",
     "label": "Signer quorum",
     "state": "g",
     "value": "Lowest controlling quorum: 3-of-6"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "emergency",
     "label": "Emergency / freeze scope",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No pause / freeze authority in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "parity",
     "label": "Docs-vs-chain parity",
     "state": "a",
     "value": "Documentation differs from the chain (parameter delta)"
    }
   ],
   "finding": "Timelock delay: docs say 6 h · chain says 0 s (no delay)",
   "grade": "delta",
   "gradeLabel": "DELTA",
   "name": "Beefy Finance (Base)",
   "pinnedBlock": 58885628,
   "probe": {
    "block_hash": "0x5092b494a9f8555faecfaa0f49202536e0edcf26f2bdc6e25a563442258119cd",
    "block_number": 58315414,
    "call_args": [],
    "call_signature": "getMinDelay()",
    "chain": "base",
    "check_type": "eth_call",
    "extra_calls": [],
    "id": "beefy-finance-base-vault-owner-timelock-zero-delay-s22",
    "repro_calldata": "0xf27a0c92",
    "rpc_env_var": "$BASE_RPC_URL",
    "selector_or_slot": "0xf27a0c92",
    "target_contract": "0x09D19184F46A32213DF06b981122e06882B61309",
    "target_label": "BeefyVaultOwnerTimelock_Base"
   },
   "reconciled": false,
   "reconciledFrom": [],
   "reconciledTo": [],
   "records": 4,
   "rosetteAria": "Beefy Finance (Base) control-plane rosette: Upgradeability moderate; Timelock floor weak; Signer quorum strong; Emergency / freeze scope not determined; Docs-vs-chain parity weak",
   "search": "beefy finance (base) beefy-finance-base automated yield vaults & clm (base) bifi 0x03f6afbcbf398e2362c93ddc846619f1b1b860d2 0x09d19184f46a32213df06b981122e06882b61309 0x2b0c9702a4724f2bfe7922db92c4082098533c62 0x3b60f7f25b09e71356cdffc6475c222a466a2ac9 0x6ffaca7c3b38ec2d631d86e15f328ee6ef6c6226 0xab35d11199216c7f7368080cf41bed8f3abbc4e4 0xfc69704cc3caac545cc7577009ea4aa04f1a61eb",
   "slug": "beefy-finance-base",
   "summary_short": "Timelock delay: docs 6 hours · chain none",
   "url": "https://pacta.wtf/protocols/beefy-finance-base/"
  },
  {
   "baskets": [
    "lending_vaults"
   ],
   "category": "Yield on ApeCoin deposits matched with BAYC and MAYC collections (Ethereum)",
   "chains": [
    "ethereum"
   ],
   "deltas": 1,
   "easAttested": true,
   "evidence": {
    "documented": "'| Incentive | 7 Days Timelock | 0x859f6e05410893fe64BC84d92BdA773fF798cf66 |' (raw.githubusercontent.com/BendDAO/bend-gitbook-portal/HEAD/risk/security-and-audits.md)",
    "observed": "BEND token 0x0d02755a5700414B26FF040e1dE35D337DF56218 (Ethereum): EIP-1967 proxy, implementation 0x02863C14603C3b157379999F567DDECE151e9153, admin slot = ProxyAdmin 0x859f6e05410893fe64BC84d92BdA773fF798cf66 (the docs' 'Incentive' Proxy Admin). ProxyAdmin owner() = 0x4e4C314E2391A58775be6a15d7A05419ba7D2B6e, the docs' 'BendDAO Timelock 7D', an OpenZeppelin TimelockController (verified source): getMinDelay() = 86,400 s at this pin; the security page lists it at 7 days.",
    "recordId": "benddao-timelock-7d-reads-1d-s32",
    "surface": "BEND ProxyAdmin owner: BendDAO Timelock 7D, getMinDelay() 86,400 s"
   },
   "factors": [
    {
     "evidence": "benddao-timelock-7d-reads-1d-s32: BEND token 0x0d02755a5700414B26FF040e1dE35D337DF56218 (Ethereum): EIP-1967 proxy, implementation 0x02863C14603C3b157379999F567DDECE151e9153, admin slot = …",
     "key": "upgrade",
     "label": "Upgradeability",
     "state": "b",
     "value": "Upgradeable behind a 1h–47h delay (1d)"
    },
    {
     "evidence": "benddao-timelock-7d-reads-1d-s32: BEND token 0x0d02755a5700414B26FF040e1dE35D337DF56218 (Ethereum): EIP-1967 proxy, implementation 0x02863C14603C3b157379999F567DDECE151e9153, admin slot = …",
     "key": "timelock",
     "label": "Timelock floor",
     "state": "b",
     "value": "1d minimum enforced delay across control surfaces"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "quorum",
     "label": "Signer quorum",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No signer quorum in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "emergency",
     "label": "Emergency / freeze scope",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No pause / freeze authority in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "parity",
     "label": "Docs-vs-chain parity",
     "state": "a",
     "value": "Documentation differs from the chain (parameter delta)"
    }
   ],
   "finding": "Timelock delay: docs say 7 d · chain says 1 d",
   "grade": "delta",
   "gradeLabel": "DELTA",
   "name": "BendDAO APE Staking",
   "pinnedBlock": 26451608,
   "probe": {
    "block_hash": "0x0266af5bcad519d93b3be78e41b76a62985e22fbe4feef043ac3225f6f217a17",
    "block_number": 26451608,
    "call_args": [],
    "call_signature": "getMinDelay()",
    "chain": "ethereum",
    "check_type": "eth_call",
    "extra_calls": [],
    "id": "benddao-timelock-7d-reads-1d-s32",
    "repro_calldata": "0xf27a0c92",
    "rpc_env_var": "$ETH_RPC_URL",
    "selector_or_slot": "0xf27a0c92",
    "target_contract": "0x4e4C314E2391A58775be6a15d7A05419ba7D2B6e",
    "target_label": "BendDAO Timelock 7D (owner of the Incentive ProxyAdmin)"
   },
   "reconciled": false,
   "reconciledFrom": [],
   "reconciledTo": [],
   "records": 1,
   "rosetteAria": "BendDAO APE Staking control-plane rosette: Upgradeability moderate; Timelock floor moderate; Signer quorum not determined; Emergency / freeze scope not determined; Docs-vs-chain parity weak",
   "search": "benddao ape staking benddao-ape-staking yield on apecoin deposits matched with bayc and mayc collections (ethereum) bend 0x02863c14603c3b157379999f567ddece151e9153 0x0d02755a5700414b26ff040e1de35d337df56218 0x4e4c314e2391a58775be6a15d7a05419ba7d2b6e 0x859f6e05410893fe64bc84d92bda773ff798cf66",
   "slug": "benddao-ape-staking",
   "summary_short": "BendDAO's 7-day timelock over the BEND token proxy waits 24 hours",
   "url": "https://pacta.wtf/protocols/benddao-ape-staking/"
  },
  {
   "baskets": [],
   "category": "Decentralized-science funding layer for biotech projects (Ethereum)",
   "chains": [
    "ethereum"
   ],
   "deltas": 1,
   "easAttested": true,
   "evidence": {
    "documented": "'The supply is uncapped, meaning new BIO can be minted for future protocol or network growth. This requires deploying a new token contract to replace the current BIO token.' (docs.bio.xyz/bio/introduction/bio-token/basic-token-information.md)",
    "observed": "BIO token 0xcb1592591996765Ec0eFc1f92599A19767ee5ffA (Ethereum, not a proxy; BioToken, verified source): mint(to, amount) is onlyRole(MINTER_ROLE) and the token has no supply cap. getRoleMemberCount(MINTER_ROLE) = 2: 0xd9C6Ee1547Fd6d48F8872dD866473893Bbe8A1Ab, a 5-of-11 Safe, and 0x1783E7d1F498321D7E15044d769621E1beDc7F4C, an ERC-1967 proxy to a Wormhole NttManager (implementation 0x2bBaCb406d043D93997344F28a74A25069f3e9E3) that mints for inbound bridge transfers. The same Safe is the only DEFAULT_ADMIN_ROLE member, the admin of MINTER_ROLE. totalSupply() = 2,914,432,394 BIO. The page says new BIO requires deploying a new token contract; the current contract can mint.",
    "recordId": "bio-token-mint-role-safe-no-new-contract-s32",
    "surface": "BIO mint(): MINTER_ROLE held by a 5-of-11 Safe and a bridge manager; no cap"
   },
   "factors": [
    {
     "evidence": "bio-token-mint-role-safe-no-new-contract-s32: BIO token 0xcb1592591996765Ec0eFc1f92599A19767ee5ffA (Ethereum, not a proxy; BioToken, verified source): mint(to, amount) is onlyRole(MINTER_ROLE) and the token …",
     "key": "upgrade",
     "label": "Upgradeability",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "Upgradeable; the delay gating the upgrade path is not in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "timelock",
     "label": "Timelock floor",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No enforced admin delay in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": "bio-token-mint-role-safe-no-new-contract-s32: … 0xd9C6Ee1547Fd6d48F8872dD866473893Bbe8A1Ab, a 5-of-11 Safe, and 0x1783E7d1F498321D7E15044d769621E1beDc7F4C, …",
     "key": "quorum",
     "label": "Signer quorum",
     "state": "g",
     "value": "Lowest controlling quorum: 5-of-11"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "emergency",
     "label": "Emergency / freeze scope",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No pause / freeze authority in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "parity",
     "label": "Docs-vs-chain parity",
     "state": "a",
     "value": "Documentation differs from the chain (parameter delta)"
    }
   ],
   "finding": "BIO mint(): MINTER_ROLE held by a 5-of-11 Safe and a bridge manager; no cap: docs say 'The supply is uncapped, meaning new BIO can be minted for future protocol or network growth. · chain says BIO token 0xcb1592591996765Ec0eFc1f92599A19767ee5ffA (Ethereum, not a proxy;",
   "grade": "delta",
   "gradeLabel": "DELTA",
   "name": "Bio Protocol",
   "pinnedBlock": 26451608,
   "probe": {
    "block_hash": "0x0266af5bcad519d93b3be78e41b76a62985e22fbe4feef043ac3225f6f217a17",
    "block_number": 26451608,
    "call_args": [
     "0x9f2df0fed2c77648de5860a4cc508cd0818c85b8b8a1ab4ceeef8d981c8956a6",
     "0x0"
    ],
    "call_signature": "getRoleMember(bytes32,uint256)",
    "chain": "ethereum",
    "check_type": "eth_call",
    "extra_calls": [],
    "id": "bio-token-mint-role-safe-no-new-contract-s32",
    "repro_calldata": "0x9010d07c9f2df0fed2c77648de5860a4cc508cd0818c85b8b8a1ab4ceeef8d981c8956a60000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000",
    "rpc_env_var": "$ETH_RPC_URL",
    "selector_or_slot": "0x9010d07c",
    "target_contract": "0xcb1592591996765Ec0eFc1f92599A19767ee5ffA",
    "target_label": "BIO token (BioToken)"
   },
   "reconciled": false,
   "reconciledFrom": [],
   "reconciledTo": [],
   "records": 1,
   "rosetteAria": "Bio Protocol control-plane rosette: Upgradeability not determined; Timelock floor not determined; Signer quorum strong; Emergency / freeze scope not determined; Docs-vs-chain parity weak",
   "search": "bio protocol bio-protocol decentralized-science funding layer for biotech projects (ethereum) bio 0x1783e7d1f498321d7e15044d769621e1bedc7f4c 0x2bbacb406d043d93997344f28a74a25069f3e9e3 0xcb1592591996765ec0efc1f92599a19767ee5ffa 0xd9c6ee1547fd6d48f8872dd866473893bbe8a1ab",
   "slug": "bio-protocol",
   "summary_short": "BIO can be minted on the current contract by a Safe; docs: minting needs a new contract",
   "url": "https://pacta.wtf/protocols/bio-protocol/"
  },
  {
   "baskets": [
    "lending_vaults"
   ],
   "category": "Basis-Trade Yield Token (bfUSD issuer) (Ethereum)",
   "chains": [
    "ethereum"
   ],
   "deltas": 0,
   "easAttested": true,
   "evidence": {
    "documented": "'After a request is submitted, it must be approved by an authorized multisig manager.' (docs.bitfi.one/developer/using-contract/unstake-bfbtc); 'This is an administrative function callable only by the designated multisig manager.' (docs.bitfi.one/developer/using-contract/stake-bfbtc); 'bfBTC: 0xCdFb58c8C859Cb3F62ebe9Cf2767F9e036C7fb15' (docs.bitfi.one/developer/bfbtc-overview/deployed-contracts)",
    "observed": "bfBTC 0xCdFb58c8C859Cb3F62ebe9Cf2767F9e036C7fb15 (Ethereum; the deployed-contracts page lists it): ERC-1967 proxy, implementation slot = 0x4ca67a794051e036eefB5Aa4b34fE2bd836069F0, admin slot empty (UUPS); implementation Bfbtc (verified source). multisig() = 0x1Eb14eC5fc6D596C041F4DEA2Bf0F2cb6EF0dD03, a Safe: getThreshold() = 2 of getOwners() = 3; guard slot empty; getModulesPaginated() lists no module; its owners have no code. In the verified source depositNative, approveWithdraw, nativeWithdraw and updateEpoch are onlyMultisig (msg.sender == multisig), the functions the docs assign to the multisig manager. Not documented, and stated here: owner() = 0xd931401B37c3A368505E7AE6dE700f2b0ad14ac6, an account with no code at this pin, and the owner functions include setMultisig (replacing the multisig manager), _authorizeUpgrade (the UUPS upgrade), setPause, setBlacklisted, setFee and setFeeReceiver, with no timelock in the path. The docs say nothing about the owner role, so this record compares only the documented multisig manager. This record does not allege any misuse of these powers.",
    "recordId": "bitfi-bfbtc-multisig-manager-is-a-safe-s37",
    "surface": "bfBTC multisig manager: multisig() = a 2-of-3 Safe, as documented; owner() a key"
   },
   "factors": [
    {
     "evidence": "bitfi-bfbtc-multisig-manager-is-a-safe-s37: its owners have no code. In the verified source depositNative, approveWithdraw, nativeWithdraw and updateEpoch are onlyMultisig (msg.sender == multisig), the …",
     "key": "upgrade",
     "label": "Upgradeability",
     "state": "a",
     "value": "Upgradeable with no enforced delay: no timelock in front of upgrades (1 other upgrade path not determined)"
    },
    {
     "evidence": "bitfi-bfbtc-multisig-manager-is-a-safe-s37: its owners have no code. In the verified source depositNative, approveWithdraw, nativeWithdraw and updateEpoch are onlyMultisig (msg.sender == multisig), the …",
     "key": "timelock",
     "label": "Timelock floor",
     "state": "a",
     "value": "0s minimum enforced delay across control surfaces"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "quorum",
     "label": "Signer quorum",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No signer quorum in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "emergency",
     "label": "Emergency / freeze scope",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No pause / freeze authority in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "parity",
     "label": "Docs-vs-chain parity",
     "state": "g",
     "value": "Chain matches or is stronger than the documentation"
    }
   ],
   "finding": "bfBTC multisig manager: multisig() = a 2-of-3 Safe, as documented; owner() a key",
   "grade": "aligned",
   "gradeLabel": "ALIGNED",
   "name": "BitFi Basis",
   "pinnedBlock": 26458556,
   "probe": {
    "block_hash": "0xe258bb1cbcc988e2dfdba4ba173f9f8690520dba3647cdcae18e0651822769d2",
    "block_number": 26458556,
    "call_args": [],
    "call_signature": "multisig()",
    "chain": "ethereum",
    "check_type": "eth_call",
    "extra_calls": [],
    "id": "bitfi-bfbtc-multisig-manager-is-a-safe-s37",
    "repro_calldata": "0x4783c35b",
    "rpc_env_var": "$ETH_RPC_URL",
    "selector_or_slot": "0x4783c35b",
    "target_contract": "0xCdFb58c8C859Cb3F62ebe9Cf2767F9e036C7fb15",
    "target_label": "bfBTC (ERC-1967 UUPS proxy, Ethereum)"
   },
   "reconciled": false,
   "reconciledFrom": [],
   "reconciledTo": [],
   "records": 1,
   "rosetteAria": "BitFi Basis control-plane rosette: Upgradeability weak; Timelock floor weak; Signer quorum not determined; Emergency / freeze scope not determined; Docs-vs-chain parity strong",
   "search": "bitfi basis bitfi-basis basis-trade yield token (bfusd issuer) (ethereum) bfbtc 0x1eb14ec5fc6d596c041f4dea2bf0f2cb6ef0dd03 0x4ca67a794051e036eefb5aa4b34fe2bd836069f0 0xcdfb58c8c859cb3f62ebe9cf2767f9e036c7fb15 0xd931401b37c3a368505e7ae6de700f2b0ad14ac6",
   "slug": "bitfi-basis",
   "summary_short": "bfBTC withdrawals are approved by a multisig manager (2-of-3 Safe), as documented",
   "url": "https://pacta.wtf/protocols/bitfi-basis/"
  },
  {
   "baskets": [
    "lending_vaults",
    "stable_rwa"
   ],
   "category": "Deposit program that bootstrapped an L2's yield-bearing ETH and stablecoin balances before mainnet (Ethereum)",
   "chains": [
    "ethereum"
   ],
   "deltas": 0,
   "easAttested": false,
   "evidence": {
    "documented": "Blast pre-launch Farm documentation is linked for reference (https://blast.io/). This RPC-pinned record does not compare documentation parameters with the on-chain state.",
    "observed": "LaunchBridge (0x5F6AE08B8AeB7078cf2F96AFb089D7c9f51DA47d) verified on Ethereum Mainnet at canonical block #26,458,556 (792 bytes runtime code). EIP-1967 proxy: implementation 0x0bD88b59D580549285f0A207Db5F06bf24a8e561, admin slot zero. Direct owner() returns Safe 5-of-5 0x67CA7Ca75b69711cfd48B44eC3F64E469BaF608C.",
    "recordId": "blast-pre-launch-farm-control-plane",
    "surface": "LaunchBridge · EIP-1967 Proxy & Controller Chain"
   },
   "factors": [
    {
     "evidence": "blast-pre-launch-farm-control-plane: is_eip1967_proxy = true",
     "key": "upgrade",
     "label": "Upgradeability",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "Upgradeable; the delay gating the upgrade path is not in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "timelock",
     "label": "Timelock floor",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No enforced admin delay in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": "blast-pre-launch-farm-control-plane: … slot zero. Direct owner() returns Safe 5-of-5 0x67CA7Ca75b69711cfd48B44eC3F64E469BaF608C.",
     "key": "quorum",
     "label": "Signer quorum",
     "state": "g",
     "value": "Lowest controlling quorum: 5-of-5"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "emergency",
     "label": "Emergency / freeze scope",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No pause / freeze authority in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "parity",
     "label": "Docs-vs-chain parity",
     "state": "u",
     "value": "Uncompared: documentation not assessed (RPC-observed)"
    }
   ],
   "finding": "LaunchBridge · EIP-1967 Proxy & Controller Chain",
   "grade": "observed",
   "gradeLabel": "OBSERVED",
   "name": "Blast pre-launch Farm",
   "pinnedBlock": 26458556,
   "probe": {
    "block_hash": "0xe258bb1cbcc988e2dfdba4ba173f9f8690520dba3647cdcae18e0651822769d2",
    "block_number": 26458556,
    "call_args": [],
    "call_signature": "owner()",
    "chain": "ethereum",
    "check_type": "eth_call",
    "extra_calls": [],
    "id": "blast-pre-launch-farm-control-plane",
    "repro_calldata": "0x8da5cb5b",
    "rpc_env_var": "$ETH_RPC_URL",
    "selector_or_slot": "0x8da5cb5b",
    "target_contract": "0x5F6AE08B8AeB7078cf2F96AFb089D7c9f51DA47d",
    "target_label": "LaunchBridge"
   },
   "reconciled": false,
   "reconciledFrom": [],
   "reconciledTo": [],
   "records": 1,
   "rosetteAria": "Blast pre-launch Farm control-plane rosette: Upgradeability not determined; Timelock floor not determined; Signer quorum strong; Emergency / freeze scope not determined; Docs-vs-chain parity uncompared",
   "search": "blast pre-launch farm blast-pre-launch-farm deposit program that bootstrapped an l2's yield-bearing eth and stablecoin balances before mainnet (ethereum) blast 0x0bd88b59d580549285f0a207db5f06bf24a8e561 0x5f6ae08b8aeb7078cf2f96afb089d7c9f51da47d 0x67ca7ca75b69711cfd48b44ec3f64e469baf608c",
   "slug": "blast-pre-launch-farm",
   "summary_short": "Upgradeable proxy controlled by a 5-of-5 Safe; docs not assessed",
   "url": "https://pacta.wtf/protocols/blast-pre-launch-farm/"
  },
  {
   "baskets": [
    "lending_vaults"
   ],
   "category": "Pro-trader NFT bidding pools and marketplace (Ethereum)",
   "chains": [
    "ethereum"
   ],
   "deltas": 0,
   "easAttested": false,
   "evidence": {
    "documented": "Blur Bids documentation is linked for reference (https://blur.io/). This RPC-pinned record does not compare documentation parameters with the on-chain state.",
    "observed": "Blur (0x5283D291DBCF85356A21bA090E6db59121208b44) verified on Ethereum Mainnet at canonical block #26,458,556 (8,696 bytes runtime code). EIP-1967 implementation and admin storage slots are both zero (non-EIP-1967 contract). Direct owner() returns Safe 5-of-5 0x6e596823A8c9c48Eb6Fa4aB2208F34B97453A327.",
    "recordId": "blur-bids-control-plane",
    "surface": "Blur · Non-Proxy Bytecode & Controller"
   },
   "factors": [
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "upgrade",
     "label": "Upgradeability",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "Upgrade path not in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "timelock",
     "label": "Timelock floor",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No enforced admin delay in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": "blur-bids-control-plane: … contract). Direct owner() returns Safe 5-of-5 0x6e596823A8c9c48Eb6Fa4aB2208F34B97453A327.",
     "key": "quorum",
     "label": "Signer quorum",
     "state": "g",
     "value": "Lowest controlling quorum: 5-of-5"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "emergency",
     "label": "Emergency / freeze scope",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No pause / freeze authority in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "parity",
     "label": "Docs-vs-chain parity",
     "state": "u",
     "value": "Uncompared: documentation not assessed (RPC-observed)"
    }
   ],
   "finding": "Blur · Non-Proxy Bytecode & Controller",
   "grade": "observed",
   "gradeLabel": "OBSERVED",
   "name": "Blur Bids",
   "pinnedBlock": 26458556,
   "probe": {
    "block_hash": "0xe258bb1cbcc988e2dfdba4ba173f9f8690520dba3647cdcae18e0651822769d2",
    "block_number": 26458556,
    "call_args": [],
    "call_signature": "owner()",
    "chain": "ethereum",
    "check_type": "eth_call",
    "extra_calls": [],
    "id": "blur-bids-control-plane",
    "repro_calldata": "0x8da5cb5b",
    "rpc_env_var": "$ETH_RPC_URL",
    "selector_or_slot": "0x8da5cb5b",
    "target_contract": "0x5283D291DBCF85356A21bA090E6db59121208b44",
    "target_label": "Blur"
   },
   "reconciled": false,
   "reconciledFrom": [],
   "reconciledTo": [],
   "records": 1,
   "rosetteAria": "Blur Bids control-plane rosette: Upgradeability not determined; Timelock floor not determined; Signer quorum strong; Emergency / freeze scope not determined; Docs-vs-chain parity uncompared",
   "search": "blur bids blur-bids pro-trader nft bidding pools and marketplace (ethereum) blur 0x5283d291dbcf85356a21ba090e6db59121208b44 0x6e596823a8c9c48eb6fa4ab2208f34b97453a327",
   "slug": "blur-bids",
   "summary_short": "Non-proxy contract controlled by a 5-of-5 Safe; docs not assessed",
   "url": "https://pacta.wtf/protocols/blur-bids/"
  },
  {
   "baskets": [
    "base"
   ],
   "category": "Intent-based derivatives trading frontend with solver-quoted fills (Base)",
   "chains": [
    "base"
   ],
   "deltas": 0,
   "easAttested": false,
   "evidence": {
    "documented": "BMX Freestyle documentation is linked for reference (https://www.bmx.trade). This RPC-pinned record does not compare documentation parameters with the on-chain state.",
    "observed": "MultiAccount (0x6D63921D8203044f6AbaD8F346d3AEa9A2719dDD) verified on Base Mainnet at canonical block #60,070,202 (2,227 bytes runtime code). EIP-1967 proxy: implementation 0x589910C5836711a779eDf19Fce2935dc7aC95107, admin 0x5db3C638235b14520Ebd617267cAC0b108Be3157. The EIP-1967 admin slot holds contract ProxyAdmin 0x5db3C638235b14520Ebd617267cAC0b108Be3157. That controller is in turn controlled by Safe 3-of-7 0x5146C35725d9b8F11A84ebD4a3abe9845698Ada9.",
    "recordId": "bmx-freestyle-control-plane",
    "surface": "MultiAccount · EIP-1967 Proxy & Controller Chain"
   },
   "factors": [
    {
     "evidence": "bmx-freestyle-control-plane: MultiAccount (0x6D63921D8203044f6AbaD8F346d3AEa9A2719dDD) verified on Base Mainnet at canonical block #60,070,202 (2,227 bytes runtime code). EIP-1967 proxy …",
     "key": "upgrade",
     "label": "Upgradeability",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "Upgradeable; the delay gating the upgrade path is not in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "timelock",
     "label": "Timelock floor",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No enforced admin delay in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": "bmx-freestyle-control-plane: … controller is in turn controlled by Safe 3-of-7 0x5146C35725d9b8F11A84ebD4a3abe9845698Ada9.",
     "key": "quorum",
     "label": "Signer quorum",
     "state": "g",
     "value": "Lowest controlling quorum: 3-of-7"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "emergency",
     "label": "Emergency / freeze scope",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No pause / freeze authority in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "parity",
     "label": "Docs-vs-chain parity",
     "state": "u",
     "value": "Uncompared: documentation not assessed (RPC-observed)"
    }
   ],
   "finding": "MultiAccount · EIP-1967 Proxy & Controller Chain",
   "grade": "observed",
   "gradeLabel": "OBSERVED",
   "name": "BMX Freestyle",
   "pinnedBlock": 60070202,
   "probe": {
    "block_hash": "0x01b3f5dcecb67c63ba33350ec6942563f6b8a0d8ca9b4f69a752844a5bab4a20",
    "block_number": 60070202,
    "call_args": [],
    "call_signature": null,
    "chain": "base",
    "check_type": "eth_getStorageAt",
    "extra_calls": [],
    "id": "bmx-freestyle-control-plane",
    "repro_calldata": null,
    "rpc_env_var": "$BASE_RPC_URL",
    "selector_or_slot": "0xb53127684a568b3173ae13b9f8a6016e243e63b6e8ee1178d6a717850b5d6103",
    "target_contract": "0x6D63921D8203044f6AbaD8F346d3AEa9A2719dDD",
    "target_label": "MultiAccount"
   },
   "reconciled": false,
   "reconciledFrom": [],
   "reconciledTo": [],
   "records": 1,
   "rosetteAria": "BMX Freestyle control-plane rosette: Upgradeability not determined; Timelock floor not determined; Signer quorum strong; Emergency / freeze scope not determined; Docs-vs-chain parity uncompared",
   "search": "bmx freestyle bmx-freestyle intent-based derivatives trading frontend with solver-quoted fills (base) bmx 0x5146c35725d9b8f11a84ebd4a3abe9845698ada9 0x589910c5836711a779edf19fce2935dc7ac95107 0x5db3c638235b14520ebd617267cac0b108be3157 0x6d63921d8203044f6abad8f346d3aea9a2719ddd",
   "slug": "bmx-freestyle",
   "summary_short": "Upgradeable proxy controlled by a 3-of-7 Safe; docs not assessed",
   "url": "https://pacta.wtf/protocols/bmx-freestyle/"
  },
  {
   "baskets": [],
   "category": "Tokenization suite for issuing asset-backed securities (Ethereum)",
   "chains": [
    "ethereum"
   ],
   "deltas": 0,
   "easAttested": false,
   "evidence": {
    "documented": "Brickken documentation is linked for reference (https://docs.brickken.com/). This RPC-pinned record does not compare documentation parameters with the on-chain state.",
    "observed": "Brickken (0x0A638F07ACc6969abF392bB009f216D22aDEa36d) verified on Ethereum Mainnet at canonical block #26,458,556 (10,653 bytes runtime code). EIP-1967 implementation and admin storage slots are both zero (non-EIP-1967 contract). No owner(), admin(), authority(), curator() or AccessControl admin was readable on the contract.",
    "recordId": "brickken-control-plane",
    "surface": "Brickken · Non-Proxy Bytecode & Controller"
   },
   "factors": [
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "upgrade",
     "label": "Upgradeability",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "Upgrade path not in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "timelock",
     "label": "Timelock floor",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No enforced admin delay in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "quorum",
     "label": "Signer quorum",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No signer quorum in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "emergency",
     "label": "Emergency / freeze scope",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No pause / freeze authority in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "parity",
     "label": "Docs-vs-chain parity",
     "state": "u",
     "value": "Uncompared: documentation not assessed (RPC-observed)"
    }
   ],
   "finding": "Brickken · Non-Proxy Bytecode & Controller",
   "grade": "observed",
   "gradeLabel": "OBSERVED",
   "name": "Brickken",
   "pinnedBlock": 26458556,
   "probe": {
    "block_hash": "0xe258bb1cbcc988e2dfdba4ba173f9f8690520dba3647cdcae18e0651822769d2",
    "block_number": 26458556,
    "call_args": [],
    "call_signature": "owner()",
    "chain": "ethereum",
    "check_type": "eth_call",
    "extra_calls": [],
    "id": "brickken-control-plane",
    "repro_calldata": "0x8da5cb5b",
    "rpc_env_var": "$ETH_RPC_URL",
    "selector_or_slot": "0x8da5cb5b",
    "target_contract": "0x0A638F07ACc6969abF392bB009f216D22aDEa36d",
    "target_label": "Brickken"
   },
   "reconciled": false,
   "reconciledFrom": [],
   "reconciledTo": [],
   "records": 1,
   "rosetteAria": "Brickken control-plane rosette: Upgradeability not determined; Timelock floor not determined; Signer quorum not determined; Emergency / freeze scope not determined; Docs-vs-chain parity uncompared",
   "search": "brickken brickken tokenization suite for issuing asset-backed securities (ethereum) bkn 0x0a638f07acc6969abf392bb009f216d22adea36d",
   "slug": "brickken",
   "summary_short": "Non-proxy contract no readable owner or admin; docs not assessed",
   "url": "https://pacta.wtf/protocols/brickken/"
  },
  {
   "baskets": [
    "stable_rwa"
   ],
   "category": "Stablecoin / Credit",
   "chains": [
    "ethereum"
   ],
   "deltas": 0,
   "easAttested": true,
   "evidence": {
    "documented": "docs.cap.app (access controls): 'Roles are managed by the Access Control admin, currently set to Cap's multisig address'",
    "observed": "AccessControl 0x7731129a10d51e18cDE607C5C115F26503D2c683: the only DEFAULT_ADMIN_ROLE member, and the only grantAccess / revokeAccess holder, is the Timelock 0xD8236031d8279d82E615aF2BFab5FC0127A329ab; the Developer multisig 0xb8FC49402dF3ee4f8587268FB89fda4d621a8793 does not hold DEFAULT_ADMIN_ROLE, so role changes wait the 1-day delay.",
    "recordId": "cap-access-control-admin-is-timelock-s20",
    "surface": "Access-control admin: the Timelock, not the multisig directly"
   },
   "factors": [
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "upgrade",
     "label": "Upgradeability",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "Upgrade path not in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": "cap-1d-timelock-min-delay-s20: observed_delay_seconds = 86400",
     "key": "timelock",
     "label": "Timelock floor",
     "state": "b",
     "value": "1d minimum enforced delay across control surfaces"
    },
    {
     "evidence": "cap-1d-timelock-min-delay-s20: … 0xb8FC49402dF3ee4f8587268FB89fda4d621a8793 (3-of-5 Safe); the timelock is its own admin.",
     "key": "quorum",
     "label": "Signer quorum",
     "state": "g",
     "value": "Lowest controlling quorum: 3-of-5"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "emergency",
     "label": "Emergency / freeze scope",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No pause / freeze authority in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "parity",
     "label": "Docs-vs-chain parity",
     "state": "g",
     "value": "Chain matches or is stronger than the documentation"
    }
   ],
   "finding": "Access-control admin: the Timelock, not the multisig directly: docs say docs.cap.app (access controls): 'Roles are managed by the Access Control admin, currently set to Cap's multisig address' · chain says AccessControl 0x7731129a10d51e18cDE607C5C115F26503D2c683: the only DEFAULT_ADMIN_ROLE member, and the only grantAccess / revokeAccess holder, is the Timelock 0xD8236031d8279d82E615aF2BFab5FC0127A329ab;",
   "grade": "protective",
   "gradeLabel": "PROTECTIVE",
   "name": "Cap",
   "pinnedBlock": 26451608,
   "probe": {
    "block_hash": "0xfa22e277760f1df7134b0af20499d6305ee4e017219a917a61a78aa76e89382d",
    "block_number": 26425374,
    "call_args": [],
    "call_signature": "getMinDelay()",
    "chain": "ethereum",
    "check_type": "eth_call",
    "extra_calls": [],
    "id": "cap-1d-timelock-min-delay-s20",
    "repro_calldata": "0xf27a0c92",
    "rpc_env_var": "$ETH_RPC_URL",
    "selector_or_slot": "0xf27a0c92",
    "target_contract": "0xD8236031d8279d82E615aF2BFab5FC0127A329ab",
    "target_label": "Cap TimelockController (Developer multisig proposer)"
   },
   "reconciled": false,
   "reconciledFrom": [],
   "reconciledTo": [],
   "records": 4,
   "rosetteAria": "Cap control-plane rosette: Upgradeability not determined; Timelock floor moderate; Signer quorum strong; Emergency / freeze scope not determined; Docs-vs-chain parity strong",
   "search": "cap cap stablecoin / credit cusd stcusd cap 0x7731129a10d51e18cde607c5c115f26503d2c683 0xb8fc49402df3ee4f8587268fb89fda4d621a8793 0xcccc62962d17b8914c62d74ffb843d73b2a3cccc 0xd8236031d8279d82e615af2bfab5fc0127a329ab",
   "slug": "cap",
   "summary_short": "Access-control admin is a Timelock, not the multisig the docs name",
   "url": "https://pacta.wtf/protocols/cap/"
  },
  {
   "baskets": [],
   "category": "Liquidity-pool bridge between chains run by a state guardian network (Ethereum)",
   "chains": [
    "ethereum"
   ],
   "deltas": 1,
   "easAttested": true,
   "evidence": {
    "documented": "'It is only when nodes with more than ⅔ of the total stake are malicious, that the fund pool will be at risk.' (cbridge-docs.celer.network/print.html)",
    "observed": "cBridge Bridge 0x5427FEFA711Eff984124bFBB1AB6fbf5E3DA1820 (Ethereum, not a proxy; verified source): withdraw() and relay() accept a message signed by the stored signer set, and resetSigners(signers, powers) replaces that set onlyOwner, gated only by block.timestamp > resetTime (notifyResetSigners() sets it to now + noticePeriod()); noticePeriod() = 604,800 s, resetTime() = unset (max) at this pin. owner() = 0xF380166F8490F24AF32Bf47D1aA217FBA62B6575, a SimpleGovernance (verified source): 6 voters, all accounts with no code, powers 10000, 10000, 10000, 10000, 10000, 1; QuorumThreshold params(1) = 60% and FastPassThreshold params(2) = 40% of total power, so 3 of the 5 full-power voters pass a proposal it executes. delayPeriod() = 21,600 s (large-transfer delay). This record does not allege any misuse.",
    "recordId": "cbridge-liquidity-bridge-owner-resets-signers-s33",
    "surface": "Pool Bridge signers: owner can resetSigners after 7-day notice; owner = 3-of-5 EOA governance"
   },
   "factors": [
    {
     "evidence": "cbridge-liquidity-bridge-owner-resets-signers-s33: … 0x5427FEFA711Eff984124bFBB1AB6fbf5E3DA1820 (Ethereum, not a proxy; verified source): withdraw() and relay() …",
     "key": "upgrade",
     "label": "Upgradeability",
     "state": "g",
     "value": "Immutable or ownership renounced"
    },
    {
     "evidence": "cbridge-liquidity-bridge-owner-resets-signers-s33: observed_delay_seconds = 604800",
     "key": "timelock",
     "label": "Timelock floor",
     "state": "g",
     "value": "7d minimum enforced delay across control surfaces"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "quorum",
     "label": "Signer quorum",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No signer quorum in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "emergency",
     "label": "Emergency / freeze scope",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No pause / freeze authority in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "parity",
     "label": "Docs-vs-chain parity",
     "state": "a",
     "value": "Documentation differs from the chain (parameter delta)"
    }
   ],
   "finding": "Pool Bridge signers: owner can resetSigners after 7-day notice; owner = 3-of-5 EOA governance: docs say 'It is only when nodes with more than ⅔ of the total stake are malicious, that the fund pool will be at risk.' (cbridge-docs.celer.network/print.html) · chain says cBridge Bridge 0x5427FEFA711Eff984124bFBB1AB6fbf5E3DA1820 (Ethereum, not a proxy;",
   "grade": "delta",
   "gradeLabel": "DELTA",
   "name": "cBridge",
   "pinnedBlock": 26452373,
   "probe": {
    "block_hash": "0x63bfaa16f0019d8b37e757265d351bd135ad41e6ffa46207284198917123c55d",
    "block_number": 26452373,
    "call_args": [],
    "call_signature": "owner()",
    "chain": "ethereum",
    "check_type": "eth_call",
    "extra_calls": [],
    "id": "cbridge-liquidity-bridge-owner-resets-signers-s33",
    "repro_calldata": "0x8da5cb5b",
    "rpc_env_var": "$ETH_RPC_URL",
    "selector_or_slot": "0x8da5cb5b",
    "target_contract": "0x5427FEFA711Eff984124bFBB1AB6fbf5E3DA1820",
    "target_label": "cBridge pool-based Bridge (Ethereum)"
   },
   "reconciled": false,
   "reconciledFrom": [],
   "reconciledTo": [],
   "records": 1,
   "rosetteAria": "cBridge control-plane rosette: Upgradeability strong; Timelock floor strong; Signer quorum not determined; Emergency / freeze scope not determined; Docs-vs-chain parity weak",
   "search": "cbridge cbridge liquidity-pool bridge between chains run by a state guardian network (ethereum) celr 0x5427fefa711eff984124bfbb1ab6fbf5e3da1820 0xf380166f8490f24af32bf47d1aa217fba62b6575",
   "slug": "cbridge",
   "summary_short": "3 cBridge governance keys can replace the pool signers after 7 days; docs: 2/3 stake",
   "url": "https://pacta.wtf/protocols/cbridge/"
  },
  {
   "baskets": [
    "base",
    "stable_rwa"
   ],
   "category": "Institutional RWA Liquidity Pools",
   "chains": [
    "base"
   ],
   "deltas": 0,
   "easAttested": true,
   "evidence": {
    "documented": "docs.centrifuge.io (guardians) / Base deployment config: 'The ops guardian is deployed at `0x055589229506Ee89645EF08ebE9B9a863486d0dE` on all networks.' / 'The `OpsGuardian` is controlled by a separate Ops Safe multisig and handles day-to-day operational tasks such as adapter initialization, network wiring, and pool creation. It has no pause authority.' / '\"opsAdmin\": \"0xd21413291444C5c104F1b5918cA0D2f6EC91Ad16\",'",
    "observed": "Root 0x7Ed48C31f2fdC40d37407cBaBf0870B2b688368f (Base, block #58534152): wards(OpsGuardian 0x055589229506Ee89645EF08ebE9B9a863486d0dE) = 0; OpsGuardian (Sourcify match) opsSafe() = Safe 0xd21413291444C5c104F1b5918cA0D2f6EC91Ad16 (2-of-7, v1.4.1), not a ward either.",
    "recordId": "centrifuge-liquidity-pools-base-ops-guardian-s24",
    "surface": "OpsGuardian: not a ward of Root (no pause authority), run by the Ops Safe"
   },
   "factors": [
    {
     "evidence": "centrifuge-liquidity-pools-base-root-timelock-s24: … 172800s (48 hours); paused() = false; not a proxy.",
     "key": "upgrade",
     "label": "Upgradeability",
     "state": "g",
     "value": "Immutable or ownership renounced"
    },
    {
     "evidence": "centrifuge-liquidity-pools-base-root-timelock-s24: observed_delay_seconds = 172800",
     "key": "timelock",
     "label": "Timelock floor",
     "state": "g",
     "value": "2d minimum enforced delay across control surfaces"
    },
    {
     "evidence": "centrifuge-liquidity-pools-base-ops-guardian-s24: … 0xd21413291444C5c104F1b5918cA0D2f6EC91Ad16 (2-of-7, v1.4.1), not a ward either.",
     "key": "quorum",
     "label": "Signer quorum",
     "state": "b",
     "value": "Lowest controlling quorum: 2-of-7"
    },
    {
     "evidence": "centrifuge-liquidity-pools-base-root-timelock-s24: paused() = false",
     "key": "emergency",
     "label": "Emergency / freeze scope",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "Pause / freeze authority present; its holder is not determined"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "parity",
     "label": "Docs-vs-chain parity",
     "state": "g",
     "value": "Chain matches or is stronger than the documentation"
    }
   ],
   "finding": "OpsGuardian: not a ward of Root (no pause authority), run by the Ops Safe",
   "grade": "aligned",
   "gradeLabel": "ALIGNED",
   "name": "Centrifuge V3 Root (Base)",
   "pinnedBlock": 58534152,
   "probe": {
    "block_hash": "0x7b884f4d029427b5d15f71c50b128bd69ac7c6da6962ced946ca87b0b4e6e843",
    "block_number": 58534152,
    "call_args": [
     "0x055589229506Ee89645EF08ebE9B9a863486d0dE"
    ],
    "call_signature": "wards(address)",
    "chain": "base",
    "check_type": "eth_call",
    "extra_calls": [],
    "id": "centrifuge-liquidity-pools-base-ops-guardian-s24",
    "repro_calldata": "0xbf353dbb000000000000000000000000055589229506ee89645ef08ebe9b9a863486d0de",
    "rpc_env_var": "$BASE_RPC_URL",
    "selector_or_slot": "0xbf353dbb",
    "target_contract": "0x7Ed48C31f2fdC40d37407cBaBf0870B2b688368f",
    "target_label": "Centrifuge Root (Base)"
   },
   "reconciled": false,
   "reconciledFrom": [],
   "reconciledTo": [],
   "records": 3,
   "rosetteAria": "Centrifuge V3 Root (Base) control-plane rosette: Upgradeability strong; Timelock floor strong; Signer quorum moderate; Emergency / freeze scope not determined; Docs-vs-chain parity strong",
   "search": "centrifuge v3 root (base) centrifuge-liquidity-pools-base institutional rwa liquidity pools cfg 0x055589229506ee89645ef08ebe9b9a863486d0de 0x7ed48c31f2fdc40d37407cbabf0870b2b688368f 0x9711730060c73ee7fcfe1890e8a0993858a7d225 0xceb7ed5d5b3bad3088f6a1697738b60d829635c6 0xd21413291444c5c104f1b5918ca0d2f6ec91ad16",
   "slug": "centrifuge-liquidity-pools-base",
   "summary_short": "OpsGuardian has no pause authority over Root, as documented",
   "url": "https://pacta.wtf/protocols/centrifuge-liquidity-pools-base/"
  },
  {
   "baskets": [],
   "category": "Cross-Chain Messaging & Token Bridge Infrastructure",
   "chains": [
    "ethereum"
   ],
   "deltas": 1,
   "easAttested": true,
   "evidence": {
    "documented": "docs.chain.link (CCIP upgradability): 'All proposals originate from a ManyChainMultiSig (MCMS), which requires multiple independent signers to sign off.' / 'For example, you can view the Ethereum mainnet MCMS on Etherscan.'",
    "observed": "RBACTimelock 0x44835bBBA9D40DEDa9b64858095EcFB2693c9449: getRoleMemberCount(PROPOSER_ROLE) = 3: ManyChainMultiSig 0xE53289F32c8E690b7173aA33affE9B6B0CB0012F (the MCMS the docs link), GnosisSafeProxy 0xD6597750bf74DCAEC57e0F9aD2ec998D837005bf (Safe v1.3.0, 6-of-12; also a canceller) and ManyChainMultiSig 0xD9757aA52907798d1aF2FDa7A6C0cC733E5aCf7e.",
    "recordId": "chainlink-ccip-timelock-proposers-s24",
    "surface": "Timelock proposers: a 6-of-12 Safe besides the ManyChainMultiSigs (docs: all proposals from an MCMS)"
   },
   "factors": [
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "upgrade",
     "label": "Upgradeability",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "Upgrade path not in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": "chainlink-ccip-config-owner-rbac-timelock-s24: BYPASSER_ROLE has 1 member, ManyChainMultiSig 0x117ec8aD107976e1dBCc21717ff78407Bc36aADc, which can execute calls immediately through bypasserExecuteBatch (no …",
     "key": "timelock",
     "label": "Timelock floor",
     "state": "a",
     "value": "0s: a bypasser role can execute without waiting the timelock delay"
    },
    {
     "evidence": "chainlink-ccip-timelock-proposers-s24: … 0xD6597750bf74DCAEC57e0F9aD2ec998D837005bf (Safe v1.3.0, 6-of-12; also a canceller) and ManyChainMultiSig …",
     "key": "quorum",
     "label": "Signer quorum",
     "state": "g",
     "value": "Lowest controlling quorum: 6-of-12"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "emergency",
     "label": "Emergency / freeze scope",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No pause / freeze authority in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "parity",
     "label": "Docs-vs-chain parity",
     "state": "a",
     "value": "Documentation differs from the chain (parameter delta)"
    }
   ],
   "finding": "Timelock proposers: a 6-of-12 Safe besides the ManyChainMultiSigs (docs: all proposals from an MCMS): docs say docs.chain.link (CCIP upgradability): 'All proposals originate from a ManyChainMultiSig (MCMS), which requires multiple independent signers to sign off.' / 'For example, you can view the Ethereum mainnet MCMS on Ethersc… · chain says RBACTimelock 0x44835bBBA9D40DEDa9b64858095EcFB2693c9449: getRoleMemberCount(PROPOSER_ROLE) = 3: ManyChainMultiSig 0xE53289F32c8E690b7173aA33affE9B6B0CB0012F (the MCMS the docs link), GnosisSafeProxy 0xD6597750bf74DCAEC5…",
   "grade": "delta",
   "gradeLabel": "DELTA",
   "name": "Chainlink CCIP",
   "pinnedBlock": 26451608,
   "probe": {
    "block_hash": "0xa058ec92ccf0024822a76097f183d8e2d344d56e9539038c857e0cdaaa0ee5a7",
    "block_number": 26433001,
    "call_args": [
     "0xb09aa5aeb3702cfd50b6b62bc4532604938f21248a27a1d5ca736082b6819cc1"
    ],
    "call_signature": "getRoleMemberCount(bytes32)",
    "chain": "ethereum",
    "check_type": "eth_call",
    "extra_calls": [],
    "id": "chainlink-ccip-timelock-proposers-s24",
    "repro_calldata": "0xca15c873b09aa5aeb3702cfd50b6b62bc4532604938f21248a27a1d5ca736082b6819cc1",
    "rpc_env_var": "$ETH_RPC_URL",
    "selector_or_slot": "0xca15c873",
    "target_contract": "0x44835bBBA9D40DEDa9b64858095EcFB2693c9449",
    "target_label": "CCIP RBACTimelock (Ethereum)"
   },
   "reconciled": false,
   "reconciledFrom": [],
   "reconciledTo": [],
   "records": 5,
   "rosetteAria": "Chainlink CCIP control-plane rosette: Upgradeability not determined; Timelock floor weak; Signer quorum strong; Emergency / freeze scope not determined; Docs-vs-chain parity weak",
   "search": "chainlink ccip chainlink-ccip cross-chain messaging & token bridge infrastructure ccip link chainlink 0x0b047953451a207743fb62541b21199b95190602 0x117ec8ad107976e1dbcc21717ff78407bc36aadc 0x411de17f12d1a34ecc7f45f49844626267c75e81 0x44835bbba9d40deda9b64858095ecfb2693c9449 0x6608920e3f6b591ec3cf15ca1ddf66fbe117f56a 0x80226fc0ee2b096224eeac085bb9a8cba1146f7d 0x8c00cc7cc37396e88bbfe66371341a59d1b5771f 0xb22764f98dd05c789929716d677382df22c05cb6 0xd6597750bf74dcaec57e0f9ad2ec998d837005bf 0xd9757aa52907798d1af2fda7a6c0cc733e5acf7e 0xe53289f32c8e690b7173aa33affe9b6b0cb0012f 0xed3fc513f5888bd65e868ba77d25e8799fffa18e",
   "slug": "chainlink-ccip",
   "summary_short": "Docs: only the MCMS proposes · chain: a 6-of-12 Safe can also propose",
   "url": "https://pacta.wtf/protocols/chainlink-ccip/"
  },
  {
   "baskets": [
    "lending_vaults"
   ],
   "category": "Non-custodial managed portfolio vaults (formerly dHEDGE) (Ethereum)",
   "chains": [
    "ethereum"
   ],
   "deltas": 0,
   "easAttested": false,
   "evidence": {
    "documented": "Chamber Vaults documentation is linked for reference (https://docs.chamberfi.com/). This RPC-pinned record does not compare documentation parameters with the on-chain state.",
    "observed": "dHedge DAO Token (DHedgeTokenProxy) (0xca1207647Ff814039530D7d35df0e1Dd2e91Fa84) verified on Ethereum Mainnet at canonical block #26,458,556 (1,589 bytes runtime code). EIP-1967 proxy: implementation 0x50a6B25101173B41E41C1A30A5bae42f213b2687, admin 0x5a76f841bFe5182f04bf511fC0Ecf88C27189FCB. The EIP-1967 admin slot holds Safe 3-of-5 0x5a76f841bFe5182f04bf511fC0Ecf88C27189FCB.",
    "recordId": "chamber-vaults-control-plane",
    "surface": "dHedge DAO Token (DHedgeTokenProxy) · EIP-1967 Proxy & Controller Chain"
   },
   "factors": [
    {
     "evidence": "chamber-vaults-control-plane: is_eip1967_proxy = true",
     "key": "upgrade",
     "label": "Upgradeability",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "Upgradeable; the delay gating the upgrade path is not in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "timelock",
     "label": "Timelock floor",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No enforced admin delay in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": "chamber-vaults-control-plane: … The EIP-1967 admin slot holds Safe 3-of-5 0x5a76f841bFe5182f04bf511fC0Ecf88C27189FCB.",
     "key": "quorum",
     "label": "Signer quorum",
     "state": "g",
     "value": "Lowest controlling quorum: 3-of-5"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "emergency",
     "label": "Emergency / freeze scope",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No pause / freeze authority in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "parity",
     "label": "Docs-vs-chain parity",
     "state": "u",
     "value": "Uncompared: documentation not assessed (RPC-observed)"
    }
   ],
   "finding": "dHedge DAO Token (DHedgeTokenProxy) · EIP-1967 Proxy & Controller Chain",
   "grade": "observed",
   "gradeLabel": "OBSERVED",
   "name": "Chamber Vaults",
   "pinnedBlock": 26458556,
   "probe": {
    "block_hash": "0xe258bb1cbcc988e2dfdba4ba173f9f8690520dba3647cdcae18e0651822769d2",
    "block_number": 26458556,
    "call_args": [],
    "call_signature": null,
    "chain": "ethereum",
    "check_type": "eth_getStorageAt",
    "extra_calls": [],
    "id": "chamber-vaults-control-plane",
    "repro_calldata": null,
    "rpc_env_var": "$ETH_RPC_URL",
    "selector_or_slot": "0xb53127684a568b3173ae13b9f8a6016e243e63b6e8ee1178d6a717850b5d6103",
    "target_contract": "0xca1207647Ff814039530D7d35df0e1Dd2e91Fa84",
    "target_label": "dHedge DAO Token (DHedgeTokenProxy)"
   },
   "reconciled": false,
   "reconciledFrom": [],
   "reconciledTo": [],
   "records": 1,
   "rosetteAria": "Chamber Vaults control-plane rosette: Upgradeability not determined; Timelock floor not determined; Signer quorum strong; Emergency / freeze scope not determined; Docs-vs-chain parity uncompared",
   "search": "chamber vaults chamber-vaults non-custodial managed portfolio vaults (formerly dhedge) (ethereum) dht 0x50a6b25101173b41e41c1a30a5bae42f213b2687 0x5a76f841bfe5182f04bf511fc0ecf88c27189fcb 0xca1207647ff814039530d7d35df0e1dd2e91fa84",
   "slug": "chamber-vaults",
   "summary_short": "Upgradeable proxy controlled by a 3-of-5 Safe; docs not assessed",
   "url": "https://pacta.wtf/protocols/chamber-vaults/"
  },
  {
   "baskets": [
    "eth_lst_lrt",
    "lending_vaults"
   ],
   "category": "Leveraged Staking Vault (recursive ETH) (Ethereum)",
   "chains": [
    "ethereum"
   ],
   "deltas": 1,
   "easAttested": true,
   "evidence": {
    "documented": "'Fund allocation parameters are made transparent through multi-signature and time-lock mechanisms.' (docs.cian.app/llms-full.txt)",
    "observed": "CIAN stETH Yield Layer vault 0xB13aa2d0345b0439b064f26B82D8dCf3f508775d (Ethereum): EIP-1967 proxy, implementation 0xA1Dc0B6A02AB091580DC57bDd5Fe8a9E577E0842; in its verified source the strategy position limits, market capacity, fee rates, rebalancer and fee receiver setters are onlyOwner. owner() = 0x261090afE1E7305474F4e3eEFCAca9964eBffFf5, a 3-of-4 Safe; the vault's ProxyAdmin 0xf24955E9D0a05222373d4555f8831f7A05e83F62 is owned by the same Safe. The TimeLock its contract table lists, 0x0CBee811C47C3A5cb4637f1E58d98B0Abbb4c54f (delay() = 86,400 s, admin() = 0x261090afE1E7305474F4e3eEFCAca9964eBffFf5), owns neither.",
    "recordId": "cian-yield-layer-allocation-no-timelock-s31",
    "surface": "Fund allocation setters: owner is a 3-of-4 Safe, the documented TimeLock is not in the path"
   },
   "factors": [
    {
     "evidence": "cian-yield-layer-allocation-no-timelock-s31: the vault's ProxyAdmin 0xf24955E9D0a05222373d4555f8831f7A05e83F62 is owned by the same Safe. The TimeLock its contract table lists …",
     "key": "upgrade",
     "label": "Upgradeability",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "Upgradeable; the delay gating the upgrade path is not in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": "cian-yield-layer-allocation-no-timelock-s31: … 0x0CBee811C47C3A5cb4637f1E58d98B0Abbb4c54f (delay() = 86,400 s, admin() = 0x261090afE1E7305474F4e3eEFCAca9964eBffFf5), …",
     "key": "timelock",
     "label": "Timelock floor",
     "state": "b",
     "value": "1d minimum enforced delay across control surfaces"
    },
    {
     "evidence": "cian-yield-layer-allocation-no-timelock-s31: … 0x261090afE1E7305474F4e3eEFCAca9964eBffFf5, a 3-of-4 Safe; the vault's ProxyAdmin 0xf24955E9D0a05222373d4555f8831f7A05e83F62 …",
     "key": "quorum",
     "label": "Signer quorum",
     "state": "g",
     "value": "Lowest controlling quorum: 3-of-4"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "emergency",
     "label": "Emergency / freeze scope",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No pause / freeze authority in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "parity",
     "label": "Docs-vs-chain parity",
     "state": "a",
     "value": "Documentation differs from the chain (parameter delta)"
    }
   ],
   "finding": "Fund allocation setters: owner is a 3-of-4 Safe, the documented TimeLock is not in the path: docs say 'Fund allocation parameters are made transparent through multi-signature and time-lock mechanisms.' (docs.cian.app/llms-full.txt) · chain says CIAN stETH Yield Layer vault 0xB13aa2d0345b0439b064f26B82D8dCf3f508775d (Ethereum): EIP-1967 proxy, implementation 0xA1Dc0B6A02AB091580DC57bDd5Fe8a9E577E0842;",
   "grade": "delta",
   "gradeLabel": "DELTA",
   "name": "CIAN Yield Layer",
   "pinnedBlock": 26450616,
   "probe": {
    "block_hash": "0xd2df7ccb74a6772b51a5597c8f144f5cfae362efeabf193ecfc7c80f8ff37c35",
    "block_number": 26450616,
    "call_args": [],
    "call_signature": "owner()",
    "chain": "ethereum",
    "check_type": "eth_call",
    "extra_calls": [],
    "id": "cian-yield-layer-allocation-no-timelock-s31",
    "repro_calldata": "0x8da5cb5b",
    "rpc_env_var": "$ETH_RPC_URL",
    "selector_or_slot": "0x8da5cb5b",
    "target_contract": "0xB13aa2d0345b0439b064f26B82D8dCf3f508775d",
    "target_label": "CIAN stETH Yield Layer vault"
   },
   "reconciled": false,
   "reconciledFrom": [],
   "reconciledTo": [],
   "records": 1,
   "rosetteAria": "CIAN Yield Layer control-plane rosette: Upgradeability not determined; Timelock floor moderate; Signer quorum strong; Emergency / freeze scope not determined; Docs-vs-chain parity weak",
   "search": "cian yield layer cian-yield-layer leveraged staking vault (recursive eth) (ethereum) ylsteth 0x0cbee811c47c3a5cb4637f1e58d98b0abbb4c54f 0x261090afe1e7305474f4e3eefcaca9964ebffff5 0xa1dc0b6a02ab091580dc57bdd5fe8a9e577e0842 0xb13aa2d0345b0439b064f26b82d8dcf3f508775d 0xf24955e9d0a05222373d4555f8831f7a05e83f62",
   "slug": "cian-yield-layer",
   "summary_short": "CIAN's stETH vault settings change via a Safe directly; the docs say they are time-locked",
   "url": "https://pacta.wtf/protocols/cian-yield-layer/"
  },
  {
   "baskets": [],
   "category": "Chain-abstracted USDC balance: GatewayWallet deposits behind a UUPS proxy",
   "chains": [
    "ethereum"
   ],
   "deltas": 1,
   "easAttested": true,
   "evidence": {
    "documented": "'Users have full control of their deposited assets. Funds can only move with their signature, and withdrawals are trustless.' (www.circle.com/gateway)",
    "observed": "Circle GatewayWallet 0x77777777Dcc4d5A8B6E418Fd04D8997ef11000eE (Ethereum; the address the Gateway contract-addresses page lists): UUPS EIP-1967 proxy, implementation 0xF7a6D9D7Df917c072ac8987A820c58aA27A0e798 (GatewayWallet, verified source). owner() = 0x2A6A86466F181721ec8ff946967b56f1AA4758c5 and pauser() = 0x9812d5F0a0832d9A0a78a1ba728fACd87bC35b19, both accounts with no code (externally owned) at this pin; denylister() = 0x7359fD9aA258992eb4B6d9572c6f6c74Cf719a94, also without code. In the verified source _authorizeUpgrade, updateWithdrawalDelay and updatePauser are onlyOwner, pause() is onlyPauser, and both initiateWithdrawal() and withdraw() are whenNotPaused; no timelock sits in either path. withdrawalDelay() = 50,400 blocks; paused() = false. This record does not allege any misuse of these powers.",
    "recordId": "circle-gateway-wallet-eoa-owner-and-pauser-s32",
    "surface": "GatewayWallet: EOA owner (UUPS upgrade, withdrawal delay) and EOA pauser over withdrawals"
   },
   "factors": [
    {
     "evidence": "circle-gateway-wallet-eoa-owner-and-pauser-s32: Circle GatewayWallet 0x77777777Dcc4d5A8B6E418Fd04D8997ef11000eE (Ethereum; the address the Gateway contract-addresses page lists): UUPS EIP-1967 proxy …",
     "key": "upgrade",
     "label": "Upgradeability",
     "state": "a",
     "value": "Upgradeable with no enforced delay: no timelock in front of upgrades"
    },
    {
     "evidence": "circle-gateway-wallet-eoa-owner-and-pauser-s32: Circle GatewayWallet 0x77777777Dcc4d5A8B6E418Fd04D8997ef11000eE (Ethereum; the address the Gateway contract-addresses page lists): UUPS EIP-1967 proxy …",
     "key": "timelock",
     "label": "Timelock floor",
     "state": "a",
     "value": "0s minimum enforced delay across control surfaces"
    },
    {
     "evidence": "circle-gateway-wallet-eoa-owner-and-pauser-s32: … 0x9812d5F0a0832d9A0a78a1ba728fACd87bC35b19, both accounts with no code (externally owned) at this pin; denylister() = 0x7359fD9aA258992eb4B6d9572c6f6c74Cf719a94, …",
     "key": "quorum",
     "label": "Signer quorum",
     "state": "a",
     "value": "Lowest controlling quorum: a single key"
    },
    {
     "evidence": "circle-gateway-wallet-eoa-owner-and-pauser-s32: Circle GatewayWallet 0x77777777Dcc4d5A8B6E418Fd04D8997ef11000eE (Ethereum; the address the Gateway contract-addresses page lists): UUPS EIP-1967 proxy …",
     "key": "emergency",
     "label": "Emergency / freeze scope",
     "state": "a",
     "value": "Pause / freeze authority held by a single key"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "parity",
     "label": "Docs-vs-chain parity",
     "state": "a",
     "value": "Documentation differs from the chain (parameter delta)"
    }
   ],
   "finding": "GatewayWallet: EOA owner (UUPS upgrade, withdrawal delay) and EOA pauser over withdrawals: docs say 'Users have full control of their deposited assets. · chain says Circle GatewayWallet 0x77777777Dcc4d5A8B6E418Fd04D8997ef11000eE (Ethereum;",
   "grade": "delta",
   "gradeLabel": "DELTA",
   "name": "Circle Gateway",
   "pinnedBlock": 26451608,
   "probe": {
    "block_hash": "0x0266af5bcad519d93b3be78e41b76a62985e22fbe4feef043ac3225f6f217a17",
    "block_number": 26451608,
    "call_args": [],
    "call_signature": "owner()",
    "chain": "ethereum",
    "check_type": "eth_call",
    "extra_calls": [],
    "id": "circle-gateway-wallet-eoa-owner-and-pauser-s32",
    "repro_calldata": "0x8da5cb5b",
    "rpc_env_var": "$ETH_RPC_URL",
    "selector_or_slot": "0x8da5cb5b",
    "target_contract": "0x77777777Dcc4d5A8B6E418Fd04D8997ef11000eE",
    "target_label": "Circle GatewayWallet"
   },
   "reconciled": false,
   "reconciledFrom": [],
   "reconciledTo": [],
   "records": 1,
   "rosetteAria": "Circle Gateway control-plane rosette: Upgradeability weak; Timelock floor weak; Signer quorum weak; Emergency / freeze scope weak; Docs-vs-chain parity weak",
   "search": "circle gateway circle-gateway chain-abstracted usdc balance: gatewaywallet deposits behind a uups proxy circlegateway 0x2a6a86466f181721ec8ff946967b56f1aa4758c5 0x7359fd9aa258992eb4b6d9572c6f6c74cf719a94 0x77777777dcc4d5a8b6e418fd04d8997ef11000ee 0x9812d5f0a0832d9a0a78a1ba728facd87bc35b19 0xa0b86991c6218b36c1d19d4a2e9eb0ce3606eb48 0xf7a6d9d7df917c072ac8987a820c58aa27a0e798",
   "slug": "circle-gateway",
   "summary_short": "One key can pause Gateway withdrawals, another can upgrade it; docs say trustless",
   "url": "https://pacta.wtf/protocols/circle-gateway/"
  },
  {
   "baskets": [
    "base",
    "stable_rwa"
   ],
   "category": "Fiat-Backed Stablecoin (USDC)",
   "chains": [
    "base",
    "ethereum"
   ],
   "deltas": 0,
   "easAttested": true,
   "evidence": {
    "documented": "Circle token design (stablecoin-evm, doc/tokendesign.md): '`owner` - re-assign any of the roles except for `admin`'; '`masterMinter` - adds and removes minters and increases their minting allowance'; '`pauser` - pause the contract, which prevents all transfers, minting, and burning'; '`blacklister` - prevent all transfers to or from a particular address, and prevents that address from minting or burning' / developers.circle.com (USDC contract addresses): 'Base 0x833589fCD6eDb6E08f4c7C32D4f71b54bdA02913'",
    "observed": "USDC 0x833589fCD6eDb6E08f4c7C32D4f71b54bdA02913 (Base, block #58422815): owner() = 0x3ABd6f64A422225E61E435baE41db12096106df7, pauser() = 0xD3571B3bc51CECFf49194AD67aFFFC648d5e07b4, blacklister() = 0x1f2e3A640175d20ac31ed523B6733B977173E277 (no contract code); masterMinter() = MasterMinter 0x2230393EDAD0299b7E7B59F20AA856cD1bEd52e1, whose owner() is 0xb5bff84d169a72e76e94eC950da51Bac90b60284 (no code); rescuer() = 0x0; paused() = false; version() = 2.",
    "recordId": "circle-usdc-base-owner-role-assignment-s23",
    "surface": "USDC (Base) roles: owner, masterMinter, pauser and blacklister are single administrator addresses, as documented"
   },
   "factors": [
    {
     "evidence": "circle-usdc-base-proxy-admin-upgrade-key-s23: USDC FiatTokenProxy 0x833589fCD6eDb6E08f4c7C32D4f71b54bdA02913 (Base, block #58422815): admin slot keccak256('org.zeppelinos.proxy.admin') = …",
     "key": "upgrade",
     "label": "Upgradeability",
     "state": "a",
     "value": "Upgradeable with no enforced delay: no timelock in front of upgrades"
    },
    {
     "evidence": "circle-usdc-base-proxy-admin-upgrade-key-s23: USDC FiatTokenProxy 0x833589fCD6eDb6E08f4c7C32D4f71b54bdA02913 (Base, block #58422815): admin slot keccak256('org.zeppelinos.proxy.admin') = …",
     "key": "timelock",
     "label": "Timelock floor",
     "state": "a",
     "value": "0s minimum enforced delay across control surfaces"
    },
    {
     "evidence": "circle-usdc-base-owner-role-assignment-s23: … 0x1f2e3A640175d20ac31ed523B6733B977173E277 (no contract code); masterMinter() = MasterMinter 0x2230393EDAD0299b7E7B59F20AA856cD1bEd52e1, …",
     "key": "quorum",
     "label": "Signer quorum",
     "state": "a",
     "value": "Lowest controlling quorum: a single key"
    },
    {
     "evidence": "circle-usdc-base-owner-role-assignment-s23: USDC 0x833589fCD6eDb6E08f4c7C32D4f71b54bdA02913 (Base, block #58422815): owner() = 0x3ABd6f64A422225E61E435baE41db12096106df7, pauser() = …",
     "key": "emergency",
     "label": "Emergency / freeze scope",
     "state": "a",
     "value": "Pause / freeze authority held by a single key"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "parity",
     "label": "Docs-vs-chain parity",
     "state": "g",
     "value": "Chain matches or is stronger than the documentation"
    }
   ],
   "finding": "USDC (Base) roles: owner, masterMinter, pauser and blacklister are single administrator addresses, as documented",
   "grade": "aligned",
   "gradeLabel": "ALIGNED",
   "name": "Circle USDC",
   "pinnedBlock": 58422815,
   "probe": {
    "block_hash": "0x5aced8e0d59eebe168d9dc8778d0305063a1a02f9ffd264774cbd75b3b979a51",
    "block_number": 58422815,
    "call_args": [],
    "call_signature": "owner()",
    "chain": "base",
    "check_type": "eth_call",
    "extra_calls": [],
    "id": "circle-usdc-base-owner-role-assignment-s23",
    "repro_calldata": "0x8da5cb5b",
    "rpc_env_var": "$BASE_RPC_URL",
    "selector_or_slot": "0x8da5cb5b",
    "target_contract": "0x833589fCD6eDb6E08f4c7C32D4f71b54bdA02913",
    "target_label": "USDC FiatTokenProxy (Base)"
   },
   "reconciled": false,
   "reconciledFrom": [],
   "reconciledTo": [],
   "records": 4,
   "rosetteAria": "Circle USDC control-plane rosette: Upgradeability weak; Timelock floor weak; Signer quorum weak; Emergency / freeze scope weak; Docs-vs-chain parity strong",
   "search": "circle usdc circle-usdc fiat-backed stablecoin (usdc) usdc 0x0a06be16275b95a7d2567fbdae118b36c7da78f9 0x1f2e3a640175d20ac31ed523b6733b977173e277 0x2230393edad0299b7e7b59f20aa856cd1bed52e1 0x2ce6311ddae708829bc0784c967b7d77d19fd779 0x3abd6f64a422225e61e435bae41db12096106df7 0x43506849d7c04f9138d1a2050bbf3a0c054402dd 0x4914f61d25e5c567143774b76edbf4d5109a8566 0x4fc7850364958d97b4d3f5a08f79db2493f8ca44 0x807a96288a1a408dbc13de2b1d087d10356395d2 0x833589fcd6edb6e08f4c7c32d4f71b54bda02913 0xa0b86991c6218b36c1d19d4a2e9eb0ce3606eb48 0xb5bff84d169a72e76e94ec950da51bac90b60284 0xc1d9fe41d19dd52cb3ae5d1d3b0030b5d498c704 0xd3571b3bc51cecff49194ad67afffc648d5e07b4 0xe982615d461dd5cd06575bbea87624fda4e3de17 0xfcb19e6a322b27c06842a71e8c725399f049ae3a",
   "slug": "circle-usdc",
   "summary_short": "USDC roles on Base are single admin addresses, as Circle documents",
   "url": "https://pacta.wtf/protocols/circle-usdc/"
  },
  {
   "baskets": [],
   "category": "DEX tuned for the best prices on small trades (Ethereum)",
   "chains": [
    "ethereum"
   ],
   "deltas": 0,
   "easAttested": false,
   "evidence": {
    "documented": "Clipper documentation is linked for reference (). This RPC-pinned record does not compare documentation parameters with the on-chain state.",
    "observed": "SAIL Token (0xd8F1460044925d2D5c723C7054cd9247027415B7) verified on Ethereum Mainnet at canonical block #26,458,556 (13,151 bytes runtime code). EIP-1967 implementation and admin storage slots are both zero (non-EIP-1967 contract). Direct owner() returns Safe 3-of-9 0xD8Cc0304de58fCE5147796606Db14500d94b5EF2.",
    "recordId": "clipper-control-plane",
    "surface": "SAIL Token · Non-Proxy Bytecode & Controller"
   },
   "factors": [
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "upgrade",
     "label": "Upgradeability",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "Upgrade path not in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "timelock",
     "label": "Timelock floor",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No enforced admin delay in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": "clipper-control-plane: … contract). Direct owner() returns Safe 3-of-9 0xD8Cc0304de58fCE5147796606Db14500d94b5EF2.",
     "key": "quorum",
     "label": "Signer quorum",
     "state": "g",
     "value": "Lowest controlling quorum: 3-of-9"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "emergency",
     "label": "Emergency / freeze scope",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No pause / freeze authority in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "parity",
     "label": "Docs-vs-chain parity",
     "state": "u",
     "value": "Uncompared: documentation not assessed (RPC-observed)"
    }
   ],
   "finding": "SAIL Token · Non-Proxy Bytecode & Controller",
   "grade": "observed",
   "gradeLabel": "OBSERVED",
   "name": "Clipper",
   "pinnedBlock": 26458556,
   "probe": {
    "block_hash": "0xe258bb1cbcc988e2dfdba4ba173f9f8690520dba3647cdcae18e0651822769d2",
    "block_number": 26458556,
    "call_args": [],
    "call_signature": "owner()",
    "chain": "ethereum",
    "check_type": "eth_call",
    "extra_calls": [],
    "id": "clipper-control-plane",
    "repro_calldata": "0x8da5cb5b",
    "rpc_env_var": "$ETH_RPC_URL",
    "selector_or_slot": "0x8da5cb5b",
    "target_contract": "0xd8F1460044925d2D5c723C7054cd9247027415B7",
    "target_label": "SAIL Token"
   },
   "reconciled": false,
   "reconciledFrom": [],
   "reconciledTo": [],
   "records": 1,
   "rosetteAria": "Clipper control-plane rosette: Upgradeability not determined; Timelock floor not determined; Signer quorum strong; Emergency / freeze scope not determined; Docs-vs-chain parity uncompared",
   "search": "clipper clipper dex tuned for the best prices on small trades (ethereum) sail 0xd8cc0304de58fce5147796606db14500d94b5ef2 0xd8f1460044925d2d5c723c7054cd9247027415b7",
   "slug": "clipper",
   "summary_short": "Non-proxy contract controlled by a 3-of-9 Safe; docs not assessed",
   "url": "https://pacta.wtf/protocols/clipper/"
  },
  {
   "baskets": [
    "eth_lst_lrt"
   ],
   "category": "Liquid Staking Token (ETH)",
   "chains": [
    "ethereum"
   ],
   "deltas": 0,
   "easAttested": true,
   "evidence": {
    "documented": "github.com/coinbase/wrapped-tokens-os (README): 'The wrapped staked tokens inherit from Centre's fiat token contract and add an oracle role that can set an exchangeRate.' and 'we'll utilize a seperate rate limited exchange rate updater contract to minimize operational load.'",
    "observed": "cbETH 0xBe9895146f7AF43049ca1c1AE358B0541Ea49704: oracle() = ExchangeRateUpdater 0x9b37180d847B27ADC13C2277299045C1237Ae281 (Sourcify exact match), whose owner() is an externally owned account 0xA57aFe0Ba93f6854ed1DCd58dCE301E10B15D1D6.",
    "recordId": "coinbase-wrapped-staked-eth-oracle-exchange-rate-updater-s21",
    "surface": "Exchange-rate oracle: the rate-limited ExchangeRateUpdater"
   },
   "factors": [
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "upgrade",
     "label": "Upgradeability",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "Upgrade path not in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "timelock",
     "label": "Timelock floor",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No enforced admin delay in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": "coinbase-wrapped-staked-eth-oracle-exchange-rate-updater-s21: … (Sourcify exact match), whose owner() is an externally owned account 0xA57aFe0Ba93f6854ed1DCd58dCE301E10B15D1D6.",
     "key": "quorum",
     "label": "Signer quorum",
     "state": "a",
     "value": "Lowest controlling quorum: a single key"
    },
    {
     "evidence": "coinbase-wrapped-staked-eth-proxy-admin-separate-owner-s21: owner() = 0x4b8741C89ABFf2562e854899E24d67A36406eA03, pauser() = 0x9596EAE1744997161ac094252e5020E9314BDCc2, blacklister() = …",
     "key": "emergency",
     "label": "Emergency / freeze scope",
     "state": "a",
     "value": "Pause / freeze authority held by a single key"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "parity",
     "label": "Docs-vs-chain parity",
     "state": "g",
     "value": "Chain matches or is stronger than the documentation"
    }
   ],
   "finding": "Exchange-rate oracle: the rate-limited ExchangeRateUpdater",
   "grade": "aligned",
   "gradeLabel": "ALIGNED",
   "name": "Coinbase Wrapped Staked ETH",
   "pinnedBlock": 26427612,
   "probe": {
    "block_hash": "0x1c5ef52eb0b586e49da2a11dc9f905cae4125008dc814d6781f53a142f6555ac",
    "block_number": 26427612,
    "call_args": [],
    "call_signature": "oracle()",
    "chain": "ethereum",
    "check_type": "eth_call",
    "extra_calls": [],
    "id": "coinbase-wrapped-staked-eth-oracle-exchange-rate-updater-s21",
    "repro_calldata": "0x7dc0d1d0",
    "rpc_env_var": "$ETH_RPC_URL",
    "selector_or_slot": "0x7dc0d1d0",
    "target_contract": "0xBe9895146f7AF43049ca1c1AE358B0541Ea49704",
    "target_label": "Coinbase Wrapped Staked ETH (cbETH) FiatTokenProxy"
   },
   "reconciled": false,
   "reconciledFrom": [],
   "reconciledTo": [],
   "records": 2,
   "rosetteAria": "Coinbase Wrapped Staked ETH control-plane rosette: Upgradeability not determined; Timelock floor not determined; Signer quorum weak; Emergency / freeze scope weak; Docs-vs-chain parity strong",
   "search": "coinbase wrapped staked eth coinbase-wrapped-staked-eth liquid staking token (eth) cbeth 0x31724ca0c982a31fbb5c57f4217ab585271fc9a5 0x4b8741c89abff2562e854899e24d67a36406ea03 0x7dd4aa646b2e2850f9d809f9299e8e87ac97b77a 0x9596eae1744997161ac094252e5020e9314bdcc2 0x9b37180d847b27adc13c2277299045c1237ae281 0xa57afe0ba93f6854ed1dcd58dce301e10b15d1d6 0xbe3c68821d585cf1552214897a1c091014b1eb0a 0xbe9895146f7af43049ca1c1ae358b0541ea49704 0xeee4ac8a22a6b310c53d59a7d59b3e0336c19577",
   "slug": "coinbase-wrapped-staked-eth",
   "summary_short": "The exchange rate is set by a rate-limited updater, as documented",
   "url": "https://pacta.wtf/protocols/coinbase-wrapped-staked-eth/"
  },
  {
   "baskets": [
    "base",
    "lending_vaults"
   ],
   "category": "Lending Market (Base)",
   "chains": [
    "base"
   ],
   "deltas": 0,
   "easAttested": true,
   "evidence": {
    "documented": "docs.compound.finance (governance): 'The Timelock on Mainnet is the administrator of all community sanctioned instances of Compound III.' and 'Local Timelocks have an additional delay before Comet admin functions can be called via proposal execution.'",
    "observed": "BridgeReceiver (0x18281dfC4d00905DA1aaA6731414EABa843c468A).govTimelock() = Ethereum Timelock 0x6d903f6003cca6255D85CcA4D3B5E5146dC33925 (delay() = 172800s on Ethereum); localTimelock() = 0xCC3E7c85Bb0EE4f09380e041fee95a0caeDD4a02 (delay() = 86400s, admin() = the BridgeReceiver); governor() of cUSDbCv3 (0x9c4ec768c28520B50860ea7a15bd7213a9fF58bf) and cUSDCv3 (0xb125E6687d4313864e53df431d5425969c15Eb2F), owner() of CometProxyAdmin 0xbdE8F31D2DdDA895264e27DD990faB3DC87b372d and governor() of the Configurator 0x45939657d1CA34A8FA39A924B71D28Fe8431e581 are the local timelock.",
    "recordId": "compound-v3-base-mainnet-timelock-local-1d-delay-s19",
    "surface": "Both Base Comet markets are governed by the Ethereum Timelock through a bridge receiver and a 1-day local timelock"
   },
   "factors": [
    {
     "evidence": "compound-v3-base-mainnet-timelock-local-1d-delay-s19: governor() of cUSDbCv3 (0x9c4ec768c28520B50860ea7a15bd7213a9fF58bf) and cUSDCv3 (0xb125E6687d4313864e53df431d5425969c15Eb2F), owner() of CometProxyAdmin …",
     "key": "upgrade",
     "label": "Upgradeability",
     "state": "b",
     "value": "Upgradeable behind a 1h–47h delay (1d)"
    },
    {
     "evidence": "compound-v3-base-mainnet-timelock-local-1d-delay-s19: governor() of cUSDbCv3 (0x9c4ec768c28520B50860ea7a15bd7213a9fF58bf) and cUSDCv3 (0xb125E6687d4313864e53df431d5425969c15Eb2F), owner() of CometProxyAdmin …",
     "key": "timelock",
     "label": "Timelock floor",
     "state": "b",
     "value": "1d minimum enforced delay across control surfaces"
    },
    {
     "evidence": "compound-v3-base-pause-guardian-community-multisig-5of9-s19: … 0x3cb4653F3B45F448D9100b118B75a1503281d2ee (5-of-9, v1.3.0), whose 9 owners equal, in …",
     "key": "quorum",
     "label": "Signer quorum",
     "state": "g",
     "value": "Lowest controlling quorum: 5-of-9"
    },
    {
     "evidence": "compound-v3-base-pause-guardian-community-multisig-5of9-s19: cUSDbCv3 (0x9c4ec768c28520B50860ea7a15bd7213a9fF58bf) and cUSDCv3 (0xb125E6687d4313864e53df431d5425969c15Eb2F) pauseGuardian() = Safe …",
     "key": "emergency",
     "label": "Emergency / freeze scope",
     "state": "g",
     "value": "Pause / freeze authority scoped behind a multi-signer controller (5-of-9)"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "parity",
     "label": "Docs-vs-chain parity",
     "state": "g",
     "value": "Chain matches or is stronger than the documentation"
    }
   ],
   "finding": "Both Base Comet markets are governed by the Ethereum Timelock through a bridge receiver and a 1-day local timelock",
   "grade": "aligned",
   "gradeLabel": "ALIGNED",
   "name": "Compound V3 (Base)",
   "pinnedBlock": 57886975,
   "probe": {
    "block_hash": "0xf88ef5af0e0555ca6b7e28b325f5057163cb52d6ced0f509507613423c6ad277",
    "block_number": 57886975,
    "call_args": [],
    "call_signature": "govTimelock()",
    "chain": "base",
    "check_type": "eth_call",
    "extra_calls": [],
    "id": "compound-v3-base-mainnet-timelock-local-1d-delay-s19",
    "repro_calldata": "0x22086dbe",
    "rpc_env_var": "$BASE_RPC_URL",
    "selector_or_slot": "0x22086dbe",
    "target_contract": "0x18281dfC4d00905DA1aaA6731414EABa843c468A",
    "target_label": "Compound BridgeReceiver (Base)"
   },
   "reconciled": false,
   "reconciledFrom": [],
   "reconciledTo": [],
   "records": 2,
   "rosetteAria": "Compound V3 (Base) control-plane rosette: Upgradeability moderate; Timelock floor moderate; Signer quorum strong; Emergency / freeze scope strong; Docs-vs-chain parity strong",
   "search": "compound v3 (base) compound-v3-base lending market (base) comp cusdcv3 0x18281dfc4d00905da1aaa6731414eaba843c468a 0x3cb4653f3b45f448d9100b118b75a1503281d2ee 0x45939657d1ca34a8fa39a924b71d28fe8431e581 0x6d903f6003cca6255d85cca4d3b5e5146dc33925 0x9c4ec768c28520b50860ea7a15bd7213a9ff58bf 0xb125e6687d4313864e53df431d5425969c15eb2f 0xbbf3f1421d886e9b2c5d716b5192ac998af2012c 0xbde8f31d2ddda895264e27dd990fab3dc87b372d 0xcc3e7c85bb0ee4f09380e041fee95a0caedd4a02",
   "slug": "compound-v3-base",
   "summary_short": "Base markets follow the Ethereum Timelock plus a 1-day local timelock",
   "url": "https://pacta.wtf/protocols/compound-v3-base/"
  },
  {
   "baskets": [
    "lending_vaults"
   ],
   "category": "Blue-Chip Lending",
   "chains": [
    "ethereum"
   ],
   "deltas": 0,
   "easAttested": true,
   "evidence": {
    "documented": "Compound V3 governance documentation specifies 48-hour Timelock ownership and Community Multi-Sig pause guardian.",
    "observed": "Sampled cUSDCv3 (0xc3d688B66703497DAA19211EEdff47f25384cdc3) & cWETHv3 (0xA17581A9E3356d9A858b789D68B4d866e593aE94) governor() = CompoundTimelock (0x6d903f6003cca6255D85CcA4D3B5E5146dC33925, delay() = 172800s / 48h, admin() = CompoundGovernor 0x309a862bbC1A00e45506cB8A802D1ff10004c8C0); pauseGuardian() = 5-of-9 Community Pause Safe (0xbbf3f1421D886E9b2c5D716B5192aC998af2012c).",
    "recordId": "compound-v3-comet-timelock-and-pause-safe",
    "surface": "Comet Governor, 48h Timelock & Pause-Guardian Safe"
   },
   "factors": [
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "upgrade",
     "label": "Upgradeability",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "Upgrade path not in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": "compound-v3-comet-timelock-and-pause-safe: observed_delay_seconds = 172800",
     "key": "timelock",
     "label": "Timelock floor",
     "state": "g",
     "value": "2d minimum enforced delay across control surfaces"
    },
    {
     "evidence": "compound-v3-comet-timelock-and-pause-safe: … 0x309a862bbC1A00e45506cB8A802D1ff10004c8C0); pauseGuardian() = 5-of-9 Community Pause Safe (0xbbf3f1421D886E9b2c5D716B5192aC998af2012c).",
     "key": "quorum",
     "label": "Signer quorum",
     "state": "g",
     "value": "Lowest controlling quorum: 5-of-9"
    },
    {
     "evidence": "compound-v3-comet-timelock-and-pause-safe: pauseGuardian() = 5-of-9 Community Pause Safe (0xbbf3f1421D886E9b2c5D716B5192aC998af2012c).",
     "key": "emergency",
     "label": "Emergency / freeze scope",
     "state": "g",
     "value": "Pause / freeze authority scoped behind a multi-signer controller (5-of-9)"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "parity",
     "label": "Docs-vs-chain parity",
     "state": "g",
     "value": "Chain matches or is stronger than the documentation"
    }
   ],
   "finding": "Comet Governor, 48h Timelock & Pause-Guardian Safe",
   "grade": "aligned",
   "gradeLabel": "ALIGNED",
   "name": "Compound V3 (Comet)",
   "pinnedBlock": 26402160,
   "probe": {
    "block_hash": "0xd04a5e8aa3500c5b60d90c25a810ef28eb9d1bfffadf28f1da58a31ed90582dc",
    "block_number": 26402160,
    "call_args": [],
    "call_signature": "governor()",
    "chain": "ethereum",
    "check_type": "eth_call",
    "extra_calls": [],
    "id": "compound-v3-comet-timelock-and-pause-safe",
    "repro_calldata": "0x0c340a24",
    "rpc_env_var": "$ETH_RPC_URL",
    "selector_or_slot": "0x0c340a24",
    "target_contract": "0xc3d688B66703497DAA19211EEdff47f25384cdc3",
    "target_label": "cUSDCv3"
   },
   "reconciled": false,
   "reconciledFrom": [],
   "reconciledTo": [],
   "records": 1,
   "rosetteAria": "Compound V3 (Comet) control-plane rosette: Upgradeability not determined; Timelock floor strong; Signer quorum strong; Emergency / freeze scope strong; Docs-vs-chain parity strong",
   "search": "compound v3 (comet) compound-v3-comet blue-chip lending comp cusdcv3 comet 0x309a862bbc1a00e45506cb8a802d1ff10004c8c0 0x6d903f6003cca6255d85cca4d3b5e5146dc33925 0xa17581a9e3356d9a858b789d68b4d866e593ae94 0xbbf3f1421d886e9b2c5d716b5192ac998af2012c 0xc3d688b66703497daa19211eedff47f25384cdc3",
   "slug": "compound-v3-comet",
   "summary_short": "Governor, 48-hour Timelock and Pause Guardian Safe match the docs",
   "url": "https://pacta.wtf/protocols/compound-v3-comet/"
  },
  {
   "baskets": [],
   "category": "Curve & Convex Reward Compounder (Ethereum)",
   "chains": [
    "ethereum"
   ],
   "deltas": 0,
   "easAttested": false,
   "evidence": {
    "documented": "Concentrator documentation is linked for reference (https://docs.aladdin.club/). This RPC-pinned record does not compare documentation parameters with the on-chain state.",
    "observed": "Concentrator Token (Vyper_contract) (0xb3Ad645dB386D7F6D753B2b9C3F4B853DA6890B8) verified on Ethereum Mainnet at canonical block #26,458,556 (3,412 bytes runtime code). EIP-1967 implementation and admin storage slots are both zero (non-EIP-1967 contract). Direct admin() returns Safe 6-of-9 0xA0FB1b11ccA5871fb0225B64308e249B97804E99.",
    "recordId": "concentrator-control-plane",
    "surface": "Concentrator Token (Vyper_contract) · Non-Proxy Bytecode & Controller"
   },
   "factors": [
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "upgrade",
     "label": "Upgradeability",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "Upgrade path not in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "timelock",
     "label": "Timelock floor",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No enforced admin delay in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": "concentrator-control-plane: … contract). Direct admin() returns Safe 6-of-9 0xA0FB1b11ccA5871fb0225B64308e249B97804E99.",
     "key": "quorum",
     "label": "Signer quorum",
     "state": "g",
     "value": "Lowest controlling quorum: 6-of-9"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "emergency",
     "label": "Emergency / freeze scope",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No pause / freeze authority in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "parity",
     "label": "Docs-vs-chain parity",
     "state": "u",
     "value": "Uncompared: documentation not assessed (RPC-observed)"
    }
   ],
   "finding": "Concentrator Token (Vyper_contract) · Non-Proxy Bytecode & Controller",
   "grade": "observed",
   "gradeLabel": "OBSERVED",
   "name": "Concentrator",
   "pinnedBlock": 26458556,
   "probe": {
    "block_hash": "0xe258bb1cbcc988e2dfdba4ba173f9f8690520dba3647cdcae18e0651822769d2",
    "block_number": 26458556,
    "call_args": [],
    "call_signature": "admin()",
    "chain": "ethereum",
    "check_type": "eth_call",
    "extra_calls": [],
    "id": "concentrator-control-plane",
    "repro_calldata": "0xf851a440",
    "rpc_env_var": "$ETH_RPC_URL",
    "selector_or_slot": "0xf851a440",
    "target_contract": "0xb3Ad645dB386D7F6D753B2b9C3F4B853DA6890B8",
    "target_label": "Concentrator Token (Vyper_contract)"
   },
   "reconciled": false,
   "reconciledFrom": [],
   "reconciledTo": [],
   "records": 1,
   "rosetteAria": "Concentrator control-plane rosette: Upgradeability not determined; Timelock floor not determined; Signer quorum strong; Emergency / freeze scope not determined; Docs-vs-chain parity uncompared",
   "search": "concentrator concentrator curve & convex reward compounder (ethereum) ctr 0xa0fb1b11cca5871fb0225b64308e249b97804e99 0xb3ad645db386d7f6d753b2b9c3f4b853da6890b8",
   "slug": "concentrator",
   "summary_short": "Non-proxy contract controlled by a 6-of-9 Safe; docs not assessed",
   "url": "https://pacta.wtf/protocols/concentrator/"
  },
  {
   "baskets": [
    "lending_vaults"
   ],
   "category": "Yield Vaults (ERC-4626)",
   "chains": [
    "ethereum"
   ],
   "deltas": 1,
   "easAttested": true,
   "evidence": {
    "documented": "docs.concrete.xyz (risks and safety): 'Separated roles. Vault operations are split across distinct roles. No single key has full control or can drain a vault.'",
    "observed": "Safe 0x8F5f1d40243b259cEB7aB44bA421Ff191bCD3381: getThreshold() = 1 with 2 owners; it is the vault owner() (the gate for factory-driven vault upgrades), the only VAULT_MANAGER member and the factory's getFactoryManager().",
    "recordId": "concrete-vault-owner-safe-1of2-s20",
    "surface": "Vault owner, VAULT_MANAGER and factory manager Safe threshold: 1-of-2"
   },
   "factors": [
    {
     "evidence": "concrete-vault-proxy-admin-factory-s20: ctDeltaWeETH vault (0xB9DC54c8261745CB97070CeFBE3D3d815aee8f20) EIP-1967 admin slot = ConcreteFactory 0x0265d73a8E61F698d8EB0dfeb91Ddce55516844C, which is also …",
     "key": "upgrade",
     "label": "Upgradeability",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "Upgradeable; the delay gating the upgrade path is not in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "timelock",
     "label": "Timelock floor",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No enforced admin delay in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": "controller fact: Safe getThreshold()",
     "key": "quorum",
     "label": "Signer quorum",
     "state": "a",
     "value": "Lowest controlling quorum: 1-of-2"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "emergency",
     "label": "Emergency / freeze scope",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No pause / freeze authority in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "parity",
     "label": "Docs-vs-chain parity",
     "state": "a",
     "value": "Documentation differs from the chain (parameter delta)"
    }
   ],
   "finding": "Vault owner, VAULT_MANAGER and factory manager Safe threshold: 1-of-2: docs say docs.concrete.xyz (risks and safety): 'Separated roles. · chain says Safe 0x8F5f1d40243b259cEB7aB44bA421Ff191bCD3381: getThreshold() = 1 with 2 owners;",
   "grade": "delta",
   "gradeLabel": "DELTA",
   "name": "Concrete",
   "pinnedBlock": 26425374,
   "probe": {
    "block_hash": "0xfa22e277760f1df7134b0af20499d6305ee4e017219a917a61a78aa76e89382d",
    "block_number": 26425374,
    "call_args": [],
    "call_signature": "getThreshold()",
    "chain": "ethereum",
    "check_type": "eth_call",
    "extra_calls": [],
    "id": "concrete-vault-owner-safe-1of2-s20",
    "repro_calldata": "0xe75235b8",
    "rpc_env_var": "$ETH_RPC_URL",
    "selector_or_slot": "0xe75235b8",
    "target_contract": "0x8F5f1d40243b259cEB7aB44bA421Ff191bCD3381",
    "target_label": "Concrete Delta WeETH owner multisig"
   },
   "reconciled": false,
   "reconciledFrom": [],
   "reconciledTo": [],
   "records": 3,
   "rosetteAria": "Concrete control-plane rosette: Upgradeability not determined; Timelock floor not determined; Signer quorum weak; Emergency / freeze scope not determined; Docs-vs-chain parity weak",
   "search": "concrete concrete yield vaults (erc-4626) ctdeltaweeth concrete 0x0265d73a8e61f698d8eb0dfeb91ddce55516844c 0x70ebf87ba7a1517c204979e51979cfbf693364f9 0x8f5f1d40243b259ceb7ab44ba421ff191bcd3381 0xb9dc54c8261745cb97070cefbe3d3d815aee8f20 0xfb65336d4323ba79d07f7024c81b8b69e1781527",
   "slug": "concrete",
   "summary_short": "Vault and factory manager Safe runs at 1-of-2 despite documented role separation",
   "url": "https://pacta.wtf/protocols/concrete/"
  },
  {
   "baskets": [
    "lending_vaults"
   ],
   "category": "Yield boosting across the Curve ecosystem (Ethereum)",
   "chains": [
    "ethereum"
   ],
   "deltas": 0,
   "easAttested": false,
   "evidence": {
    "documented": "Convergence Fi documentation is linked for reference (). This RPC-pinned record does not compare documentation parameters with the on-chain state.",
    "observed": "CvgControlTowerV2 (0xB0Afc8363b8F36E0ccE5D54251e20720FfaeaeE7) verified on Ethereum Mainnet at canonical block #26,458,556 (2,109 bytes runtime code). EIP-1967 proxy: implementation 0xbdbdDc4bF67e9Bc02706e4Ce53BC14d6cE3038f1, admin 0xF16d93ACF337de38ee55dfb2F2A276883FF59e89. The EIP-1967 admin slot holds contract ProxyAdmin 0xF16d93ACF337de38ee55dfb2F2A276883FF59e89. That controller is in turn controlled by Safe 3-of-6 0x0af815364BD9e9E60f3d2D3bAc1320B77d3E35F7.",
    "recordId": "convergence-fi-control-plane",
    "surface": "CvgControlTowerV2 · EIP-1967 Proxy & Controller Chain"
   },
   "factors": [
    {
     "evidence": "convergence-fi-control-plane: CvgControlTowerV2 (0xB0Afc8363b8F36E0ccE5D54251e20720FfaeaeE7) verified on Ethereum Mainnet at canonical block #26,458,556 (2,109 bytes runtime code). EIP-1967 …",
     "key": "upgrade",
     "label": "Upgradeability",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "Upgradeable; the delay gating the upgrade path is not in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "timelock",
     "label": "Timelock floor",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No enforced admin delay in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": "convergence-fi-control-plane: … controller is in turn controlled by Safe 3-of-6 0x0af815364BD9e9E60f3d2D3bAc1320B77d3E35F7.",
     "key": "quorum",
     "label": "Signer quorum",
     "state": "g",
     "value": "Lowest controlling quorum: 3-of-6"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "emergency",
     "label": "Emergency / freeze scope",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No pause / freeze authority in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "parity",
     "label": "Docs-vs-chain parity",
     "state": "u",
     "value": "Uncompared: documentation not assessed (RPC-observed)"
    }
   ],
   "finding": "CvgControlTowerV2 · EIP-1967 Proxy & Controller Chain",
   "grade": "observed",
   "gradeLabel": "OBSERVED",
   "name": "Convergence Fi",
   "pinnedBlock": 26458556,
   "probe": {
    "block_hash": "0xe258bb1cbcc988e2dfdba4ba173f9f8690520dba3647cdcae18e0651822769d2",
    "block_number": 26458556,
    "call_args": [],
    "call_signature": null,
    "chain": "ethereum",
    "check_type": "eth_getStorageAt",
    "extra_calls": [],
    "id": "convergence-fi-control-plane",
    "repro_calldata": null,
    "rpc_env_var": "$ETH_RPC_URL",
    "selector_or_slot": "0xb53127684a568b3173ae13b9f8a6016e243e63b6e8ee1178d6a717850b5d6103",
    "target_contract": "0xB0Afc8363b8F36E0ccE5D54251e20720FfaeaeE7",
    "target_label": "CvgControlTowerV2"
   },
   "reconciled": false,
   "reconciledFrom": [],
   "reconciledTo": [],
   "records": 1,
   "rosetteAria": "Convergence Fi control-plane rosette: Upgradeability not determined; Timelock floor not determined; Signer quorum strong; Emergency / freeze scope not determined; Docs-vs-chain parity uncompared",
   "search": "convergence fi convergence-fi yield boosting across the curve ecosystem (ethereum) convergence 0x0af815364bd9e9e60f3d2d3bac1320b77d3e35f7 0xb0afc8363b8f36e0cce5d54251e20720ffaeaee7 0xbdbddc4bf67e9bc02706e4ce53bc14d6ce3038f1 0xf16d93acf337de38ee55dfb2f2a276883ff59e89",
   "slug": "convergence-fi",
   "summary_short": "Upgradeable proxy controlled by a 3-of-6 Safe; docs not assessed",
   "url": "https://pacta.wtf/protocols/convergence-fi/"
  },
  {
   "baskets": [],
   "category": "Curve Governance Aggregation",
   "chains": [
    "ethereum"
   ],
   "deltas": 0,
   "easAttested": true,
   "evidence": {
    "documented": "Convex Booster governance ownership hierarchy documentation.",
    "observed": "Convex Booster (0xF403C135812408BFbE8713b5A23a04b3D48AAE31) owner() resolves via 0x3cE6408F923326f81A7D7929952947748180f1E6 -> 0x256e1bbA846611C37CF89844a02435E6C098b86D -> 3-of-5 DAO Multisig (0xa3C5A1e09150B75ff251c1a7815A07182c3de2FB) at block 26401312.",
    "recordId": "convex-booster-governance-chain",
    "surface": "Sampled Booster Governance Ownership Chain"
   },
   "factors": [
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "upgrade",
     "label": "Upgradeability",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "Upgrade path not in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "timelock",
     "label": "Timelock floor",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No enforced admin delay in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": "convex-booster-governance-chain: … 0x256e1bbA846611C37CF89844a02435E6C098b86D -> 3-of-5 DAO Multisig (0xa3C5A1e09150B75ff251c1a7815A07182c3de2FB) …",
     "key": "quorum",
     "label": "Signer quorum",
     "state": "g",
     "value": "Lowest controlling quorum: 3-of-5"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "emergency",
     "label": "Emergency / freeze scope",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No pause / freeze authority in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "parity",
     "label": "Docs-vs-chain parity",
     "state": "g",
     "value": "Chain matches or is stronger than the documentation"
    }
   ],
   "finding": "Sampled Booster Governance Ownership Chain",
   "grade": "aligned",
   "gradeLabel": "ALIGNED",
   "name": "Convex Finance",
   "pinnedBlock": 26401312,
   "probe": {
    "block_hash": "0x95866ea3ef8f9a0567ce000bc8075f6dc5fb0f1e80cb4e9999ae624a2f0dc109",
    "block_number": 26401312,
    "call_args": [],
    "call_signature": "owner()",
    "chain": "ethereum",
    "check_type": "eth_call",
    "extra_calls": [],
    "id": "convex-booster-governance-chain",
    "repro_calldata": "0x8da5cb5b",
    "rpc_env_var": "$ETH_RPC_URL",
    "selector_or_slot": "0x8da5cb5b",
    "target_contract": "0xF403C135812408BFbE8713b5A23a04b3D48AAE31",
    "target_label": "Convex Booster"
   },
   "reconciled": false,
   "reconciledFrom": [],
   "reconciledTo": [],
   "records": 1,
   "rosetteAria": "Convex Finance control-plane rosette: Upgradeability not determined; Timelock floor not determined; Signer quorum strong; Emergency / freeze scope not determined; Docs-vs-chain parity strong",
   "search": "convex finance convex-finance curve governance aggregation cvx cvxcrv 0x256e1bba846611c37cf89844a02435e6c098b86d 0x3ce6408f923326f81a7d7929952947748180f1e6 0xa3c5a1e09150b75ff251c1a7815a07182c3de2fb 0xf403c135812408bfbe8713b5a23a04b3d48aae31",
   "slug": "convex-finance",
   "summary_short": "Booster governance ownership chain matches the docs",
   "url": "https://pacta.wtf/protocols/convex-finance/"
  },
  {
   "baskets": [],
   "category": "Fixed-Term Loans against gOHM (Ethereum)",
   "chains": [
    "ethereum"
   ],
   "deltas": 0,
   "easAttested": true,
   "evidence": {
    "documented": "'Threshold: 4-of-8 on Mainnet.' (docs.olympusdao.finance/main/security/multisigs)",
    "observed": "Cooler Loans Safe 0x245cc372C84B3645Bf0Ffe6538620B04a217988B (Ethereum): getThreshold() = 4 of getOwners() = 8 owners (Safe v1.3.0).",
    "recordId": "cooler-loans-safe-threshold-s26",
    "surface": "Cooler Loans multisig: 4-of-8 Safe, as documented"
   },
   "factors": [
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "upgrade",
     "label": "Upgradeability",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "Upgrade path not in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "timelock",
     "label": "Timelock floor",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No enforced admin delay in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": "controller fact: Safe getThreshold()",
     "key": "quorum",
     "label": "Signer quorum",
     "state": "g",
     "value": "Lowest controlling quorum: 4-of-8"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "emergency",
     "label": "Emergency / freeze scope",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No pause / freeze authority in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "parity",
     "label": "Docs-vs-chain parity",
     "state": "g",
     "value": "Chain matches or is stronger than the documentation"
    }
   ],
   "finding": "Cooler Loans multisig: 4-of-8 Safe, as documented",
   "grade": "aligned",
   "gradeLabel": "ALIGNED",
   "name": "Cooler Loans",
   "pinnedBlock": 26438867,
   "probe": {
    "block_hash": "0x6c477521320837df8611249a255cb7142052874937cddb9fe568f685763458ff",
    "block_number": 26438867,
    "call_args": [],
    "call_signature": "getThreshold()",
    "chain": "ethereum",
    "check_type": "eth_call",
    "extra_calls": [],
    "id": "cooler-loans-safe-threshold-s26",
    "repro_calldata": "0xe75235b8",
    "rpc_env_var": "$ETH_RPC_URL",
    "selector_or_slot": "0xe75235b8",
    "target_contract": "0x245cc372C84B3645Bf0Ffe6538620B04a217988B",
    "target_label": "Cooler Loans Safe"
   },
   "reconciled": false,
   "reconciledFrom": [],
   "reconciledTo": [],
   "records": 1,
   "rosetteAria": "Cooler Loans control-plane rosette: Upgradeability not determined; Timelock floor not determined; Signer quorum strong; Emergency / freeze scope not determined; Docs-vs-chain parity strong",
   "search": "cooler loans cooler-loans fixed-term loans against gohm (ethereum) ohm 0x245cc372c84b3645bf0ffe6538620b04a217988b",
   "slug": "cooler-loans",
   "summary_short": "The Cooler Loans multisig is a 4-of-8 Safe, as its docs state",
   "url": "https://pacta.wtf/protocols/cooler-loans/"
  },
  {
   "baskets": [
    "eth_lst_lrt",
    "lending_vaults"
   ],
   "category": "Liquid ETH staking derivative issued by a lending protocol (Ethereum)",
   "chains": [
    "ethereum"
   ],
   "deltas": 0,
   "easAttested": false,
   "evidence": {
    "documented": "CRETH2 documentation is linked for reference (https://classic.cream.finance/docs). This RPC-pinned record does not compare documentation parameters with the on-chain state.",
    "observed": "Cream (Comp) (0x2ba592F78dB6436527729929AAf6c908497cB200) verified on Ethereum Mainnet at canonical block #26,458,556 (6,790 bytes runtime code). EIP-1967 implementation and admin storage slots are both zero (non-EIP-1967 contract). No owner(), admin(), authority(), curator() or AccessControl admin was readable on the contract.",
    "recordId": "creth2-control-plane",
    "surface": "Cream (Comp) · Non-Proxy Bytecode & Controller"
   },
   "factors": [
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "upgrade",
     "label": "Upgradeability",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "Upgrade path not in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "timelock",
     "label": "Timelock floor",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No enforced admin delay in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "quorum",
     "label": "Signer quorum",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No signer quorum in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "emergency",
     "label": "Emergency / freeze scope",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No pause / freeze authority in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "parity",
     "label": "Docs-vs-chain parity",
     "state": "u",
     "value": "Uncompared: documentation not assessed (RPC-observed)"
    }
   ],
   "finding": "Cream (Comp) · Non-Proxy Bytecode & Controller",
   "grade": "observed",
   "gradeLabel": "OBSERVED",
   "name": "CRETH2",
   "pinnedBlock": 26458556,
   "probe": {
    "block_hash": "0xe258bb1cbcc988e2dfdba4ba173f9f8690520dba3647cdcae18e0651822769d2",
    "block_number": 26458556,
    "call_args": [],
    "call_signature": "owner()",
    "chain": "ethereum",
    "check_type": "eth_call",
    "extra_calls": [],
    "id": "creth2-control-plane",
    "repro_calldata": "0x8da5cb5b",
    "rpc_env_var": "$ETH_RPC_URL",
    "selector_or_slot": "0x8da5cb5b",
    "target_contract": "0x2ba592F78dB6436527729929AAf6c908497cB200",
    "target_label": "Cream (Comp)"
   },
   "reconciled": false,
   "reconciledFrom": [],
   "reconciledTo": [],
   "records": 1,
   "rosetteAria": "CRETH2 control-plane rosette: Upgradeability not determined; Timelock floor not determined; Signer quorum not determined; Emergency / freeze scope not determined; Docs-vs-chain parity uncompared",
   "search": "creth2 creth2 liquid eth staking derivative issued by a lending protocol (ethereum) cream 0x2ba592f78db6436527729929aaf6c908497cb200",
   "slug": "creth2",
   "summary_short": "Non-proxy contract no readable owner or admin; docs not assessed",
   "url": "https://pacta.wtf/protocols/creth2/"
  },
  {
   "baskets": [],
   "category": "Canonical bridge into a zero-knowledge rollup of the Crypto.com chain (Ethereum)",
   "chains": [
    "ethereum"
   ],
   "deltas": 0,
   "easAttested": false,
   "evidence": {
    "documented": "Cronos zkEVM Bridge documentation is linked for reference (https://docs.cronos.com/). This RPC-pinned record does not compare documentation parameters with the on-chain state.",
    "observed": "Cronos zkEVM CRO (ZkCro) (0x28Ff2E4dD1B58efEB0fC138602A28D5aE81e44e2) verified on Ethereum Mainnet at canonical block #26,458,556 (170 bytes runtime code). EIP-1967 proxy: implementation 0x34B35beD5AceD7C4472De906912Acb3e4C4616A5, admin slot zero. DEFAULT_ADMIN_ROLE member is externally owned account (no code) 0x65b5cFaad25c39063A248684DA546cAB1Cc46cf5.",
    "recordId": "cronos-zkevm-bridge-control-plane",
    "surface": "Cronos zkEVM CRO (ZkCro) · EIP-1967 Proxy & Controller Chain"
   },
   "factors": [
    {
     "evidence": "cronos-zkevm-bridge-control-plane: is_eip1967_proxy = true",
     "key": "upgrade",
     "label": "Upgradeability",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "Upgradeable; the delay gating the upgrade path is not in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "timelock",
     "label": "Timelock floor",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No enforced admin delay in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": "cronos-zkevm-bridge-control-plane: … zero. DEFAULT_ADMIN_ROLE member is externally owned account (no code) 0x65b5cFaad25c39063A248684DA546cAB1Cc46cf5.",
     "key": "quorum",
     "label": "Signer quorum",
     "state": "a",
     "value": "Lowest controlling quorum: a single key"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "emergency",
     "label": "Emergency / freeze scope",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No pause / freeze authority in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "parity",
     "label": "Docs-vs-chain parity",
     "state": "u",
     "value": "Uncompared: documentation not assessed (RPC-observed)"
    }
   ],
   "finding": "Cronos zkEVM CRO (ZkCro) · EIP-1967 Proxy & Controller Chain",
   "grade": "observed",
   "gradeLabel": "OBSERVED",
   "name": "Cronos zkEVM Bridge",
   "pinnedBlock": 26458556,
   "probe": {
    "block_hash": "0xe258bb1cbcc988e2dfdba4ba173f9f8690520dba3647cdcae18e0651822769d2",
    "block_number": 26458556,
    "call_args": [],
    "call_signature": "owner()",
    "chain": "ethereum",
    "check_type": "eth_call",
    "extra_calls": [],
    "id": "cronos-zkevm-bridge-control-plane",
    "repro_calldata": "0x8da5cb5b",
    "rpc_env_var": "$ETH_RPC_URL",
    "selector_or_slot": "0x8da5cb5b",
    "target_contract": "0x28Ff2E4dD1B58efEB0fC138602A28D5aE81e44e2",
    "target_label": "Cronos zkEVM CRO (ZkCro)"
   },
   "reconciled": false,
   "reconciledFrom": [],
   "reconciledTo": [],
   "records": 1,
   "rosetteAria": "Cronos zkEVM Bridge control-plane rosette: Upgradeability not determined; Timelock floor not determined; Signer quorum weak; Emergency / freeze scope not determined; Docs-vs-chain parity uncompared",
   "search": "cronos zkevm bridge cronos-zkevm-bridge canonical bridge into a zero-knowledge rollup of the crypto.com chain (ethereum) zkcro 0x28ff2e4dd1b58efeb0fc138602a28d5ae81e44e2 0x34b35bed5aced7c4472de906912acb3e4c4616a5 0x65b5cfaad25c39063a248684da546cab1cc46cf5",
   "slug": "cronos-zkevm-bridge",
   "summary_short": "Upgradeable proxy controlled by a single key (EOA); docs not assessed",
   "url": "https://pacta.wtf/protocols/cronos-zkevm-bridge/"
  },
  {
   "baskets": [
    "stable_rwa"
   ],
   "category": "Stableswap AMM Liquidity Pools (Ethereum)",
   "chains": [
    "ethereum"
   ],
   "deltas": 0,
   "easAttested": true,
   "evidence": {
    "documented": "'The EmergencyDAO is a **5-of-9 multisig** authorized for emergency interventions.' (docs.curve.finance/user/dao/emergency-dao.md)",
    "observed": "Curve DEX (Ethereum) Safe 0x467947EE34aF926cF1DCac093870f613C96B1E0c (Ethereum): getThreshold() = 5 of getOwners() = 9 owners (Safe v1.3.0).",
    "recordId": "curve-dex-ethereum-safe-threshold-s26",
    "surface": "Curve DEX (Ethereum) multisig: 5-of-9 Safe, as documented"
   },
   "factors": [
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "upgrade",
     "label": "Upgradeability",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "Upgrade path not in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "timelock",
     "label": "Timelock floor",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No enforced admin delay in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": "controller fact: Safe getThreshold()",
     "key": "quorum",
     "label": "Signer quorum",
     "state": "g",
     "value": "Lowest controlling quorum: 5-of-9"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "emergency",
     "label": "Emergency / freeze scope",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No pause / freeze authority in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "parity",
     "label": "Docs-vs-chain parity",
     "state": "g",
     "value": "Chain matches or is stronger than the documentation"
    }
   ],
   "finding": "Curve DEX (Ethereum) multisig: 5-of-9 Safe, as documented",
   "grade": "aligned",
   "gradeLabel": "ALIGNED",
   "name": "Curve DEX (Ethereum)",
   "pinnedBlock": 26438867,
   "probe": {
    "block_hash": "0x6c477521320837df8611249a255cb7142052874937cddb9fe568f685763458ff",
    "block_number": 26438867,
    "call_args": [],
    "call_signature": "getThreshold()",
    "chain": "ethereum",
    "check_type": "eth_call",
    "extra_calls": [],
    "id": "curve-dex-ethereum-safe-threshold-s26",
    "repro_calldata": "0xe75235b8",
    "rpc_env_var": "$ETH_RPC_URL",
    "selector_or_slot": "0xe75235b8",
    "target_contract": "0x467947EE34aF926cF1DCac093870f613C96B1E0c",
    "target_label": "Curve DEX (Ethereum) Safe"
   },
   "reconciled": false,
   "reconciledFrom": [],
   "reconciledTo": [],
   "records": 1,
   "rosetteAria": "Curve DEX (Ethereum) control-plane rosette: Upgradeability not determined; Timelock floor not determined; Signer quorum strong; Emergency / freeze scope not determined; Docs-vs-chain parity strong",
   "search": "curve dex (ethereum) curve-dex-ethereum stableswap amm liquidity pools (ethereum) curve 0x467947ee34af926cf1dcac093870f613c96b1e0c",
   "slug": "curve-dex-ethereum",
   "summary_short": "The Curve DEX (Ethereum) multisig is a 5-of-9 Safe, as its docs state",
   "url": "https://pacta.wtf/protocols/curve-dex-ethereum/"
  },
  {
   "baskets": [
    "lending_vaults",
    "stable_rwa"
   ],
   "category": "Decentralized Stablecoin & Lending",
   "chains": [
    "ethereum"
   ],
   "deltas": 1,
   "easAttested": true,
   "evidence": {
    "documented": "curvefi/docs docs/developer/crvusd/factory.md states 'Only its admin, the CurveOwnershipAgent, can call to add a market'; LendingOwnerProxy intermediate wrapper added at block 26300155.",
    "observed": "ControllerFactory (0xC9332fdCB1C491Dcc683bAe86Fe3cb70360738BC) admin() = LendingOwnerProxy (0xeDA020b067872717901916a3B8C724C21f6080d1), where dao() = CurveOwnershipAgent (0x40907540d8a6C65c637785e8f8B742ae6b0b9968, Aragon voteTime = 604800s / 7d on 0xE478de485ad2fe566d49342Cbd03E49ed7DB3356) and emergency_dao() = 5-of-9 EmergencyDAO Safe (0x467947EE34aF926cF1DCac093870f613C96B1E0c); crvUSD (0xf939E0A03FB07F59A73314E73794Be0E57ac1b4E) minter() = ControllerFactory, totalSupply = 2,134,809,204.98 crvUSD; debt_ceiling(0x370a449FeBb9411c95bf897021377fe0B7D100c0) = 1,000,000,000 crvUSD.",
    "recordId": "curve-crvusd-factory-lending-owner-proxy",
    "surface": "ControllerFactory Admin Proxy & EmergencyDAO Debt-Ceiling Guard"
   },
   "factors": [
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "upgrade",
     "label": "Upgradeability",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "Upgrade path not in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "timelock",
     "label": "Timelock floor",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No enforced admin delay in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": "curve-crvusd-factory-lending-owner-proxy: … 0xE478de485ad2fe566d49342Cbd03E49ed7DB3356) and emergency_dao() = 5-of-9 EmergencyDAO Safe (0x467947EE34aF926cF1DCac093870f613C96B1E0c); …",
     "key": "quorum",
     "label": "Signer quorum",
     "state": "g",
     "value": "Lowest controlling quorum: 5-of-9"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "emergency",
     "label": "Emergency / freeze scope",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No pause / freeze authority in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "parity",
     "label": "Docs-vs-chain parity",
     "state": "a",
     "value": "Documentation differs from the chain (parameter delta)"
    }
   ],
   "finding": "ControllerFactory Admin Proxy & EmergencyDAO Debt-Ceiling Guard: docs say curvefi/docs docs/developer/crvusd/factory.md states 'Only its admin, the CurveOwnershipAgent, can call to add a market'; · chain says ControllerFactory (0xC9332fdCB1C491Dcc683bAe86Fe3cb70360738BC) admin() = LendingOwnerProxy (0xeDA020b067872717901916a3B8C724C21f6080d1), where dao() = CurveOwnershipAgent (0x40907540d8a6C65c637785e8f8B742ae6b0b9968, Ara…",
   "grade": "delta",
   "gradeLabel": "DELTA",
   "name": "Curve Finance (crvUSD)",
   "pinnedBlock": 26403523,
   "probe": {
    "block_hash": "0xfc7beaa2338e8054577c0b101b641bc42afca2af39cb85d3fc13cbee32d4681a",
    "block_number": 26403523,
    "call_args": [],
    "call_signature": "admin()",
    "chain": "ethereum",
    "check_type": "eth_call",
    "extra_calls": [],
    "id": "curve-crvusd-factory-lending-owner-proxy",
    "repro_calldata": "0xf851a440",
    "rpc_env_var": "$ETH_RPC_URL",
    "selector_or_slot": "0xf851a440",
    "target_contract": "0xC9332fdCB1C491Dcc683bAe86Fe3cb70360738BC",
    "target_label": "crvUSD ControllerFactory"
   },
   "reconciled": false,
   "reconciledFrom": [],
   "reconciledTo": [],
   "records": 1,
   "rosetteAria": "Curve Finance (crvUSD) control-plane rosette: Upgradeability not determined; Timelock floor not determined; Signer quorum strong; Emergency / freeze scope not determined; Docs-vs-chain parity weak",
   "search": "curve finance (crvusd) curve-finance-crvusd decentralized stablecoin & lending crvusd crv 0x370a449febb9411c95bf897021377fe0b7d100c0 0x40907540d8a6c65c637785e8f8b742ae6b0b9968 0x467947ee34af926cf1dcac093870f613c96b1e0c 0xc9332fdcb1c491dcc683bae86fe3cb70360738bc 0xe478de485ad2fe566d49342cbd03e49ed7db3356 0xeda020b067872717901916a3b8c724c21f6080d1 0xf939e0a03fb07f59a73314e73794be0e57ac1b4e",
   "slug": "curve-finance-crvusd",
   "summary_short": "crvUSD factory admin is a LendingOwnerProxy; docs name the OwnershipAgent",
   "url": "https://pacta.wtf/protocols/curve-finance-crvusd/"
  },
  {
   "baskets": [],
   "category": "Deflationary farming token with locked liquidity (Ethereum)",
   "chains": [
    "ethereum"
   ],
   "deltas": 0,
   "easAttested": true,
   "evidence": {
    "documented": "'Theres absolutely no way to create new CORE tokens.' (raw.githubusercontent.com/cVault-finance/CORE-v1/master/README.md)",
    "observed": "CORE token 0x62359Ed7505Efc61FF1D56fEF82158CcaffA23D7 (Ethereum; not a proxy: EIP-1967 implementation, admin and beacon slots all empty; verified source): totalSupply() = 10,000. The runtime code holds no selector of mint(address,uint256), mint(uint256), upgradeTo(address), upgradeToAndCall(address,bytes). Its only mint is the internal one at construction. The owner (an externally owned account) can still set the transfer checker and fee distributor; supply is not among its powers.",
    "recordId": "cvault-core-no-new-tokens-s33",
    "surface": "CORE supply: 10,000, no mint function"
   },
   "factors": [
    {
     "evidence": "cvault-core-no-new-tokens-s33: CORE token 0x62359Ed7505Efc61FF1D56fEF82158CcaffA23D7 (Ethereum; not a proxy: EIP-1967 implementation, admin and beacon slots all empty; verified source) …",
     "key": "upgrade",
     "label": "Upgradeability",
     "state": "a",
     "value": "Upgradeable with no enforced delay: no timelock in front of upgrades"
    },
    {
     "evidence": "cvault-core-no-new-tokens-s33: CORE token 0x62359Ed7505Efc61FF1D56fEF82158CcaffA23D7 (Ethereum; not a proxy: EIP-1967 implementation, admin and beacon slots all empty; verified source) …",
     "key": "timelock",
     "label": "Timelock floor",
     "state": "a",
     "value": "0s minimum enforced delay across control surfaces"
    },
    {
     "evidence": "cvault-core-no-new-tokens-s33: … one at construction. The owner (an externally owned account) can still set the transfer …",
     "key": "quorum",
     "label": "Signer quorum",
     "state": "a",
     "value": "Lowest controlling quorum: a single key"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "emergency",
     "label": "Emergency / freeze scope",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No pause / freeze authority in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "parity",
     "label": "Docs-vs-chain parity",
     "state": "g",
     "value": "Chain matches or is stronger than the documentation"
    }
   ],
   "finding": "CORE supply: 10,000, no mint function",
   "grade": "aligned",
   "gradeLabel": "ALIGNED",
   "name": "cVault Finance",
   "pinnedBlock": 26452373,
   "probe": {
    "block_hash": "0x63bfaa16f0019d8b37e757265d351bd135ad41e6ffa46207284198917123c55d",
    "block_number": 26452373,
    "call_args": [],
    "call_signature": "totalSupply()",
    "chain": "ethereum",
    "check_type": "eth_call",
    "extra_calls": [],
    "id": "cvault-core-no-new-tokens-s33",
    "repro_calldata": "0x18160ddd",
    "rpc_env_var": "$ETH_RPC_URL",
    "selector_or_slot": "0x18160ddd",
    "target_contract": "0x62359Ed7505Efc61FF1D56fEF82158CcaffA23D7",
    "target_label": "CORE token"
   },
   "reconciled": false,
   "reconciledFrom": [],
   "reconciledTo": [],
   "records": 1,
   "rosetteAria": "cVault Finance control-plane rosette: Upgradeability weak; Timelock floor weak; Signer quorum weak; Emergency / freeze scope not determined; Docs-vs-chain parity strong",
   "search": "cvault finance cvault-finance deflationary farming token with locked liquidity (ethereum) core 0x62359ed7505efc61ff1d56fef82158ccaffa23d7",
   "slug": "cvault-finance",
   "summary_short": "No new CORE can be created, as documented",
   "url": "https://pacta.wtf/protocols/cvault-finance/"
  },
  {
   "baskets": [],
   "category": "Tokenized derivatives strategies run by institutional managers (Ethereum)",
   "chains": [
    "ethereum"
   ],
   "deltas": 0,
   "easAttested": false,
   "evidence": {
    "documented": "D2 Finance documentation is linked for reference (https://d2.finance/strategies). This RPC-pinned record does not compare documentation parameters with the on-chain state.",
    "observed": "DRV++ (VaultV3) (0x07Dff4087b43c4A759f4Fc69511c26d51929dAF4) verified on Ethereum Mainnet at canonical block #26,458,556 (23,568 bytes runtime code). EIP-1967 implementation and admin storage slots are both zero (non-EIP-1967 contract). Direct owner() returns Safe 2-of-3 0xBB856548bCD0EBa1749c2336244139F1dbE93498.",
    "recordId": "d2-finance-control-plane",
    "surface": "DRV++ (VaultV3) · Non-Proxy Bytecode & Controller"
   },
   "factors": [
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "upgrade",
     "label": "Upgradeability",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "Upgrade path not in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "timelock",
     "label": "Timelock floor",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No enforced admin delay in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": "d2-finance-control-plane: … contract). Direct owner() returns Safe 2-of-3 0xBB856548bCD0EBa1749c2336244139F1dbE93498.",
     "key": "quorum",
     "label": "Signer quorum",
     "state": "b",
     "value": "Lowest controlling quorum: 2-of-3"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "emergency",
     "label": "Emergency / freeze scope",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No pause / freeze authority in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "parity",
     "label": "Docs-vs-chain parity",
     "state": "u",
     "value": "Uncompared: documentation not assessed (RPC-observed)"
    }
   ],
   "finding": "DRV++ (VaultV3) · Non-Proxy Bytecode & Controller",
   "grade": "observed",
   "gradeLabel": "OBSERVED",
   "name": "D2 Finance",
   "pinnedBlock": 26458556,
   "probe": {
    "block_hash": "0xe258bb1cbcc988e2dfdba4ba173f9f8690520dba3647cdcae18e0651822769d2",
    "block_number": 26458556,
    "call_args": [],
    "call_signature": "owner()",
    "chain": "ethereum",
    "check_type": "eth_call",
    "extra_calls": [],
    "id": "d2-finance-control-plane",
    "repro_calldata": "0x8da5cb5b",
    "rpc_env_var": "$ETH_RPC_URL",
    "selector_or_slot": "0x8da5cb5b",
    "target_contract": "0x07Dff4087b43c4A759f4Fc69511c26d51929dAF4",
    "target_label": "DRV++ (VaultV3)"
   },
   "reconciled": false,
   "reconciledFrom": [],
   "reconciledTo": [],
   "records": 1,
   "rosetteAria": "D2 Finance control-plane rosette: Upgradeability not determined; Timelock floor not determined; Signer quorum moderate; Emergency / freeze scope not determined; Docs-vs-chain parity uncompared",
   "search": "d2 finance d2-finance tokenized derivatives strategies run by institutional managers (ethereum) drv++ 0x07dff4087b43c4a759f4fc69511c26d51929daf4 0xbb856548bcd0eba1749c2336244139f1dbe93498",
   "slug": "d2-finance",
   "summary_short": "Non-proxy contract controlled by a 2-of-3 Safe; docs not assessed",
   "url": "https://pacta.wtf/protocols/d2-finance/"
  },
  {
   "baskets": [],
   "category": "Cross-chain interoperability for arbitrary messages and asset transfers between blockchains (Ethereum)",
   "chains": [
    "ethereum"
   ],
   "deltas": 0,
   "easAttested": true,
   "evidence": {
    "documented": "'Validates ≥ 2⁄3 validator signatures before execution' (docs.debridge.com/dmp-details/dmp/deployed-contracts.md)",
    "observed": "deBridge SignatureVerifier 0x949b3B3c098348b879C9e4F15cecc8046d9C8A8c (Ethereum; EIP-1967 proxy, implementation 0xfE7De3c1e1BD252C67667B56347cABFC6df08dF4, verified): DeBridgeGate 0x43dE2d77BF8027e25dBD179B491e8d64f38398aA signatureVerifier() identifies this proxy. Its submit(bytes32,bytes,uint8) requires at least minConfirmations() = 8 distinct valid signatures from the 12 oracle addresses (array length word at storage slot 152; entry 0 = 0x4bC16662A2cE381E7bb54Dc577c05619C5E67526); requiredOraclesCount() = 0. The caller-supplied _excessConfirmations argument, and the separate stored excessConfirmations() = 3 check that applies only when submissionsInBlock exceeds confirmationThreshold, can only raise, never lower, that requirement: at least 8 of 12 is the documented 2/3 minimum.",
    "recordId": "debridge-signature-verifier-min-8-of-12-s33",
    "surface": "SignatureVerifier: at least 8 of 12 oracle signatures required (2/3)"
   },
   "factors": [
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "upgrade",
     "label": "Upgradeability",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "Upgrade path not in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "timelock",
     "label": "Timelock floor",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No enforced admin delay in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "quorum",
     "label": "Signer quorum",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No signer quorum in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "emergency",
     "label": "Emergency / freeze scope",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No pause / freeze authority in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "parity",
     "label": "Docs-vs-chain parity",
     "state": "g",
     "value": "Chain matches or is stronger than the documentation"
    }
   ],
   "finding": "SignatureVerifier: at least 8 of 12 oracle signatures required (2/3)",
   "grade": "aligned",
   "gradeLabel": "ALIGNED",
   "name": "deBridge",
   "pinnedBlock": 26452373,
   "probe": {
    "block_hash": "0x63bfaa16f0019d8b37e757265d351bd135ad41e6ffa46207284198917123c55d",
    "block_number": 26452373,
    "call_args": [],
    "call_signature": "minConfirmations()",
    "chain": "ethereum",
    "check_type": "eth_call",
    "extra_calls": [],
    "id": "debridge-signature-verifier-min-8-of-12-s33",
    "repro_calldata": "0xe7c4393e",
    "rpc_env_var": "$ETH_RPC_URL",
    "selector_or_slot": "0xe7c4393e",
    "target_contract": "0x949b3B3c098348b879C9e4F15cecc8046d9C8A8c",
    "target_label": "deBridge SignatureVerifier (Ethereum)"
   },
   "reconciled": false,
   "reconciledFrom": [],
   "reconciledTo": [],
   "records": 1,
   "rosetteAria": "deBridge control-plane rosette: Upgradeability not determined; Timelock floor not determined; Signer quorum not determined; Emergency / freeze scope not determined; Docs-vs-chain parity strong",
   "search": "debridge debridge cross-chain interoperability for arbitrary messages and asset transfers between blockchains (ethereum) debridge 0x43de2d77bf8027e25dbd179b491e8d64f38398aa 0x4bc16662a2ce381e7bb54dc577c05619c5e67526 0x949b3b3c098348b879c9e4f15cecc8046d9c8a8c 0xfe7de3c1e1bd252c67667b56347cabfc6df08df4",
   "slug": "debridge",
   "summary_short": "deBridge requires at least 8 of 12 validator signatures (2/3), as documented",
   "url": "https://pacta.wtf/protocols/debridge/"
  },
  {
   "baskets": [
    "stable_rwa"
   ],
   "category": "Oracle-free euro stablecoin (dEURO) minted against collateral (Ethereum)",
   "chains": [
    "ethereum"
   ],
   "deltas": 0,
   "easAttested": true,
   "evidence": {
    "documented": "'7-day timelock on all rate changes' (docs.deuro.com/smart-contracts.html)",
    "observed": "dEURO Savings V3 0x760233b90e45d186A9A98E911B115F7F4B90d3D9 (Ethereum, not a proxy): in its verified source (Leadrate) proposeChange() sets nextChange = block.timestamp + 7 days and applyChange() reverts before nextChange; the runtime code read at this pin holds the 604,800 s constant once. currentRatePPM() = 70,000.",
    "recordId": "decentralized-euro-leadrate-timelock-7d-s31",
    "surface": "Leadrate change delay: proposeChange() schedules 7 days ahead (604,800 s)"
   },
   "factors": [
    {
     "evidence": "decentralized-euro-leadrate-timelock-7d-s31: … 0x760233b90e45d186A9A98E911B115F7F4B90d3D9 (Ethereum, not a proxy): in its verified source (Leadrate) …",
     "key": "upgrade",
     "label": "Upgradeability",
     "state": "g",
     "value": "Immutable or ownership renounced"
    },
    {
     "evidence": "decentralized-euro-leadrate-timelock-7d-s31: observed_delay_seconds = 604800",
     "key": "timelock",
     "label": "Timelock floor",
     "state": "g",
     "value": "7d minimum enforced delay across control surfaces"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "quorum",
     "label": "Signer quorum",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No signer quorum in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "emergency",
     "label": "Emergency / freeze scope",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No pause / freeze authority in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "parity",
     "label": "Docs-vs-chain parity",
     "state": "g",
     "value": "Chain matches or is stronger than the documentation"
    }
   ],
   "finding": "Leadrate change delay: proposeChange() schedules 7 days ahead (604,800 s)",
   "grade": "aligned",
   "gradeLabel": "ALIGNED",
   "name": "Decentralized Euro",
   "pinnedBlock": 26450616,
   "probe": {
    "block_hash": "0xd2df7ccb74a6772b51a5597c8f144f5cfae362efeabf193ecfc7c80f8ff37c35",
    "block_number": 26450616,
    "call_args": [],
    "call_signature": "currentRatePPM()",
    "chain": "ethereum",
    "check_type": "eth_call",
    "extra_calls": [],
    "id": "decentralized-euro-leadrate-timelock-7d-s31",
    "repro_calldata": "0x06a7b376",
    "rpc_env_var": "$ETH_RPC_URL",
    "selector_or_slot": "0x06a7b376",
    "target_contract": "0x760233b90e45d186A9A98E911B115F7F4B90d3D9",
    "target_label": "dEURO Savings V3 (Leadrate)"
   },
   "reconciled": false,
   "reconciledFrom": [],
   "reconciledTo": [],
   "records": 1,
   "rosetteAria": "Decentralized Euro control-plane rosette: Upgradeability strong; Timelock floor strong; Signer quorum not determined; Emergency / freeze scope not determined; Docs-vs-chain parity strong",
   "search": "decentralized euro decentralized-euro oracle-free euro stablecoin (deuro) minted against collateral (ethereum) wfps 0x760233b90e45d186a9a98e911b115f7f4b90d3d9",
   "slug": "decentralized-euro",
   "summary_short": "dEURO's lead-rate changes take effect 7 days after a proposal, as documented",
   "url": "https://pacta.wtf/protocols/decentralized-euro/"
  },
  {
   "baskets": [],
   "category": "DeFi management and automation dashboard (recipes, automation strategies)",
   "chains": [
    "ethereum"
   ],
   "deltas": 1,
   "easAttested": true,
   "evidence": {
    "documented": "'Automation contracts are upgradeable, with any upgrades being locked behind a 24h timelock which can be activated by a 2/3 multisig (Admin) with actual upgrades initiable by a different 3/5 multisig (Owner).' (docs.defisaver.com/protocol/security-and-audits/admin-access-control)",
    "observed": "DFSRegistry 0x287778F121F134C66212FB16c9b53eC991D32f5b adminVault() = AdminVault 0xCCf3d848e08b94478Ed8f46fFead3008faF581fD; AdminVault.owner() = Safe 0xBc841B0dE0b93205e912CFBBd1D0c160A1ec6F00 (Ethereum) with getThreshold() = 3 of getOwners() = 6 owners (Safe v1.3.0).",
    "recordId": "defi-saver-adminvault-owner-safe-s28",
    "surface": "AdminVault Owner multisig: docs state 3/5, the Safe is 3-of-6"
   },
   "factors": [
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "upgrade",
     "label": "Upgradeability",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "Upgrade path not in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "timelock",
     "label": "Timelock floor",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No enforced admin delay in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": "controller fact: Safe getThreshold()",
     "key": "quorum",
     "label": "Signer quorum",
     "state": "g",
     "value": "Lowest controlling quorum: 3-of-6"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "emergency",
     "label": "Emergency / freeze scope",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No pause / freeze authority in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "parity",
     "label": "Docs-vs-chain parity",
     "state": "a",
     "value": "Documentation differs from the chain (parameter delta)"
    }
   ],
   "finding": "AdminVault Owner multisig: docs state 3/5, the Safe is 3-of-6: docs say 'Automation contracts are upgradeable, with any upgrades being locked behind a 24h timelock which can be activated by a 2/3 multisig (Admin) with actual upgrades initiable by a different 3/5 multisig (Owner).' (docs.def… · chain says DFSRegistry 0x287778F121F134C66212FB16c9b53eC991D32f5b adminVault() = AdminVault 0xCCf3d848e08b94478Ed8f46fFead3008faF581fD;",
   "grade": "delta",
   "gradeLabel": "DELTA",
   "name": "DeFi Saver",
   "pinnedBlock": 26441165,
   "probe": {
    "block_hash": "0x5182be2c61af5f48ed2ec43d3c177dedad257c4e966a7e384120829de73901d9",
    "block_number": 26441165,
    "call_args": [],
    "call_signature": "getThreshold()",
    "chain": "ethereum",
    "check_type": "eth_call",
    "extra_calls": [],
    "id": "defi-saver-adminvault-owner-safe-s28",
    "repro_calldata": "0xe75235b8",
    "rpc_env_var": "$ETH_RPC_URL",
    "selector_or_slot": "0xe75235b8",
    "target_contract": "0xBc841B0dE0b93205e912CFBBd1D0c160A1ec6F00",
    "target_label": "DeFi Saver Owner Safe"
   },
   "reconciled": false,
   "reconciledFrom": [],
   "reconciledTo": [],
   "records": 1,
   "rosetteAria": "DeFi Saver control-plane rosette: Upgradeability not determined; Timelock floor not determined; Signer quorum strong; Emergency / freeze scope not determined; Docs-vs-chain parity weak",
   "search": "defi saver defi-saver defi management and automation dashboard (recipes, automation strategies) defisaver 0x287778f121f134c66212fb16c9b53ec991d32f5b 0xbc841b0de0b93205e912cfbbd1d0c160a1ec6f00 0xccf3d848e08b94478ed8f46ffead3008faf581fd",
   "slug": "defi-saver",
   "summary_short": "Docs state a 2/3 Admin multisig; the Safe is 3-of-6",
   "url": "https://pacta.wtf/protocols/defi-saver/"
  },
  {
   "baskets": [
    "eth_lst_lrt",
    "lending_vaults"
   ],
   "category": "Filecoin lending, staking and finance services for storage providers (Ethereum)",
   "chains": [
    "ethereum"
   ],
   "deltas": 0,
   "easAttested": false,
   "evidence": {
    "documented": "DeFIL documentation is linked for reference (). This RPC-pinned record does not compare documentation parameters with the on-chain state.",
    "observed": "DeFIL-V2 (DFL) (0x09ce2B746C32528B7d864A1e3979Bd97d2f095AB) verified on Ethereum Mainnet at canonical block #26,458,556 (8,469 bytes runtime code). EIP-1967 implementation and admin storage slots are both zero (non-EIP-1967 contract). Direct owner() returns contract Unitroller 0x6B4F20B2259Eebb97945b6EF549a1c44FcA6Cd81. That controller is in turn controlled by externally owned account (no code) 0x557EdaaFD875569F0bd6AbaE1185c17fD5A30Ba0.",
    "recordId": "defil-control-plane",
    "surface": "DeFIL-V2 (DFL) · Non-Proxy Bytecode & Controller"
   },
   "factors": [
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "upgrade",
     "label": "Upgradeability",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "Upgrade path not in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "timelock",
     "label": "Timelock floor",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No enforced admin delay in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": "defil-control-plane: … controller is in turn controlled by externally owned account (no code) 0x557EdaaFD875569F0bd6AbaE1185c17fD5A30Ba0.",
     "key": "quorum",
     "label": "Signer quorum",
     "state": "a",
     "value": "Lowest controlling quorum: a single key"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "emergency",
     "label": "Emergency / freeze scope",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No pause / freeze authority in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "parity",
     "label": "Docs-vs-chain parity",
     "state": "u",
     "value": "Uncompared: documentation not assessed (RPC-observed)"
    }
   ],
   "finding": "DeFIL-V2 (DFL) · Non-Proxy Bytecode & Controller",
   "grade": "observed",
   "gradeLabel": "OBSERVED",
   "name": "DeFIL",
   "pinnedBlock": 26458556,
   "probe": {
    "block_hash": "0xe258bb1cbcc988e2dfdba4ba173f9f8690520dba3647cdcae18e0651822769d2",
    "block_number": 26458556,
    "call_args": [],
    "call_signature": "owner()",
    "chain": "ethereum",
    "check_type": "eth_call",
    "extra_calls": [],
    "id": "defil-control-plane",
    "repro_calldata": "0x8da5cb5b",
    "rpc_env_var": "$ETH_RPC_URL",
    "selector_or_slot": "0x8da5cb5b",
    "target_contract": "0x09ce2B746C32528B7d864A1e3979Bd97d2f095AB",
    "target_label": "DeFIL-V2 (DFL)"
   },
   "reconciled": false,
   "reconciledFrom": [],
   "reconciledTo": [],
   "records": 1,
   "rosetteAria": "DeFIL control-plane rosette: Upgradeability not determined; Timelock floor not determined; Signer quorum weak; Emergency / freeze scope not determined; Docs-vs-chain parity uncompared",
   "search": "defil defil filecoin lending, staking and finance services for storage providers (ethereum) dfl 0x09ce2b746c32528b7d864a1e3979bd97d2f095ab 0x557edaafd875569f0bd6abae1185c17fd5a30ba0 0x6b4f20b2259eebb97945b6ef549a1c44fca6cd81",
   "slug": "defil",
   "summary_short": "Non-proxy contract controlled by a contract; docs not assessed",
   "url": "https://pacta.wtf/protocols/defil/"
  },
  {
   "baskets": [
    "lending_vaults"
   ],
   "category": "Fixed-rate yield markets (formerly Element Finance) (Ethereum)",
   "chains": [
    "ethereum"
   ],
   "deltas": 0,
   "easAttested": false,
   "evidence": {
    "documented": "DELV Yield documentation is linked for reference (). This RPC-pinned record does not compare documentation parameters with the on-chain state.",
    "observed": "TrancheFactory (0x62F161BF3692E4015BefB05A03a94A40f520d1c0) verified on Ethereum Mainnet at canonical block #26,458,556 (13,566 bytes runtime code). EIP-1967 implementation and admin storage slots are both zero (non-EIP-1967 contract). No owner(), admin(), authority(), curator() or AccessControl admin was readable on the contract.",
    "recordId": "delv-yield-control-plane",
    "surface": "TrancheFactory · Non-Proxy Bytecode & Controller"
   },
   "factors": [
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "upgrade",
     "label": "Upgradeability",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "Upgrade path not in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "timelock",
     "label": "Timelock floor",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No enforced admin delay in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "quorum",
     "label": "Signer quorum",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No signer quorum in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "emergency",
     "label": "Emergency / freeze scope",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No pause / freeze authority in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "parity",
     "label": "Docs-vs-chain parity",
     "state": "u",
     "value": "Uncompared: documentation not assessed (RPC-observed)"
    }
   ],
   "finding": "TrancheFactory · Non-Proxy Bytecode & Controller",
   "grade": "observed",
   "gradeLabel": "OBSERVED",
   "name": "DELV Yield",
   "pinnedBlock": 26458556,
   "probe": {
    "block_hash": "0xe258bb1cbcc988e2dfdba4ba173f9f8690520dba3647cdcae18e0651822769d2",
    "block_number": 26458556,
    "call_args": [],
    "call_signature": "owner()",
    "chain": "ethereum",
    "check_type": "eth_call",
    "extra_calls": [],
    "id": "delv-yield-control-plane",
    "repro_calldata": "0x8da5cb5b",
    "rpc_env_var": "$ETH_RPC_URL",
    "selector_or_slot": "0x8da5cb5b",
    "target_contract": "0x62F161BF3692E4015BefB05A03a94A40f520d1c0",
    "target_label": "TrancheFactory"
   },
   "reconciled": false,
   "reconciledFrom": [],
   "reconciledTo": [],
   "records": 1,
   "rosetteAria": "DELV Yield control-plane rosette: Upgradeability not determined; Timelock floor not determined; Signer quorum not determined; Emergency / freeze scope not determined; Docs-vs-chain parity uncompared",
   "search": "delv yield delv-yield fixed-rate yield markets (formerly element finance) (ethereum) delv 0x62f161bf3692e4015befb05a03a94a40f520d1c0",
   "slug": "delv-yield",
   "summary_short": "Non-proxy contract no readable owner or admin; docs not assessed",
   "url": "https://pacta.wtf/protocols/delv-yield/"
  },
  {
   "baskets": [],
   "category": "Perpetual swaps trading venue (Ethereum)",
   "chains": [
    "ethereum"
   ],
   "deltas": 0,
   "easAttested": false,
   "evidence": {
    "documented": "DerivaDEX documentation is linked for reference (https://docs.derivadex.com/). This RPC-pinned record does not compare documentation parameters with the on-chain state.",
    "observed": "DerivaDAO (DDX) (0x3A880652F47bFaa771908C07Dd8673A787dAEd3A) verified on Ethereum Mainnet at canonical block #26,458,556 (13,644 bytes runtime code). EIP-1967 implementation and admin storage slots are both zero (non-EIP-1967 contract). No owner(), admin(), authority(), curator() or AccessControl admin was readable on the contract.",
    "recordId": "derivadex-control-plane",
    "surface": "DerivaDAO (DDX) · Non-Proxy Bytecode & Controller"
   },
   "factors": [
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "upgrade",
     "label": "Upgradeability",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "Upgrade path not in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "timelock",
     "label": "Timelock floor",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No enforced admin delay in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "quorum",
     "label": "Signer quorum",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No signer quorum in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "emergency",
     "label": "Emergency / freeze scope",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No pause / freeze authority in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "parity",
     "label": "Docs-vs-chain parity",
     "state": "u",
     "value": "Uncompared: documentation not assessed (RPC-observed)"
    }
   ],
   "finding": "DerivaDAO (DDX) · Non-Proxy Bytecode & Controller",
   "grade": "observed",
   "gradeLabel": "OBSERVED",
   "name": "DerivaDEX",
   "pinnedBlock": 26458556,
   "probe": {
    "block_hash": "0xe258bb1cbcc988e2dfdba4ba173f9f8690520dba3647cdcae18e0651822769d2",
    "block_number": 26458556,
    "call_args": [],
    "call_signature": "owner()",
    "chain": "ethereum",
    "check_type": "eth_call",
    "extra_calls": [],
    "id": "derivadex-control-plane",
    "repro_calldata": "0x8da5cb5b",
    "rpc_env_var": "$ETH_RPC_URL",
    "selector_or_slot": "0x8da5cb5b",
    "target_contract": "0x3A880652F47bFaa771908C07Dd8673A787dAEd3A",
    "target_label": "DerivaDAO (DDX)"
   },
   "reconciled": false,
   "reconciledFrom": [],
   "reconciledTo": [],
   "records": 1,
   "rosetteAria": "DerivaDEX control-plane rosette: Upgradeability not determined; Timelock floor not determined; Signer quorum not determined; Emergency / freeze scope not determined; Docs-vs-chain parity uncompared",
   "search": "derivadex derivadex perpetual swaps trading venue (ethereum) ddx 0x3a880652f47bfaa771908c07dd8673a787daed3a",
   "slug": "derivadex",
   "summary_short": "Non-proxy contract no readable owner or admin; docs not assessed",
   "url": "https://pacta.wtf/protocols/derivadex/"
  },
  {
   "baskets": [],
   "category": "zkVM Exchange Settling on Ethereum (DRV token) (Ethereum)",
   "chains": [
    "ethereum"
   ],
   "deltas": 0,
   "easAttested": false,
   "evidence": {
    "documented": "Derive V3 Options documentation is linked for reference (https://docs.derive.xyz/). This RPC-pinned record does not compare documentation parameters with the on-chain state.",
    "observed": "Derive (0xB1D1eae60EEA9525032a6DCb4c1CE336a1dE71BE) verified on Ethereum Mainnet at canonical block #26,458,556 (1,167 bytes runtime code). EIP-1967 proxy: implementation 0x4909AD99441Ea5311b90a94650C394cEa4A881B8, admin 0xaA7b17C2539437Efa236FED262A5815358Ae2CC3. The EIP-1967 admin slot holds contract ProxyAdmin 0xaA7b17C2539437Efa236FED262A5815358Ae2CC3.",
    "recordId": "derive-v3-options-control-plane",
    "surface": "Derive · EIP-1967 Proxy & Controller Chain"
   },
   "factors": [
    {
     "evidence": "derive-v3-options-control-plane: Derive (0xB1D1eae60EEA9525032a6DCb4c1CE336a1dE71BE) verified on Ethereum Mainnet at canonical block #26,458,556 (1,167 bytes runtime code). EIP-1967 proxy …",
     "key": "upgrade",
     "label": "Upgradeability",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "Upgradeable; the delay gating the upgrade path is not in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "timelock",
     "label": "Timelock floor",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No enforced admin delay in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "quorum",
     "label": "Signer quorum",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No signer quorum in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "emergency",
     "label": "Emergency / freeze scope",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No pause / freeze authority in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "parity",
     "label": "Docs-vs-chain parity",
     "state": "u",
     "value": "Uncompared: documentation not assessed (RPC-observed)"
    }
   ],
   "finding": "Derive · EIP-1967 Proxy & Controller Chain",
   "grade": "observed",
   "gradeLabel": "OBSERVED",
   "name": "Derive V3 Options",
   "pinnedBlock": 26458556,
   "probe": {
    "block_hash": "0xe258bb1cbcc988e2dfdba4ba173f9f8690520dba3647cdcae18e0651822769d2",
    "block_number": 26458556,
    "call_args": [],
    "call_signature": null,
    "chain": "ethereum",
    "check_type": "eth_getStorageAt",
    "extra_calls": [],
    "id": "derive-v3-options-control-plane",
    "repro_calldata": null,
    "rpc_env_var": "$ETH_RPC_URL",
    "selector_or_slot": "0xb53127684a568b3173ae13b9f8a6016e243e63b6e8ee1178d6a717850b5d6103",
    "target_contract": "0xB1D1eae60EEA9525032a6DCb4c1CE336a1dE71BE",
    "target_label": "Derive"
   },
   "reconciled": false,
   "reconciledFrom": [],
   "reconciledTo": [],
   "records": 1,
   "rosetteAria": "Derive V3 Options control-plane rosette: Upgradeability not determined; Timelock floor not determined; Signer quorum not determined; Emergency / freeze scope not determined; Docs-vs-chain parity uncompared",
   "search": "derive v3 options derive-v3-options zkvm exchange settling on ethereum (drv token) (ethereum) drv 0x4909ad99441ea5311b90a94650c394cea4a881b8 0xaa7b17c2539437efa236fed262a5815358ae2cc3 0xb1d1eae60eea9525032a6dcb4c1ce336a1de71be",
   "slug": "derive-v3-options",
   "summary_short": "Upgradeable proxy controlled by a contract; docs not assessed",
   "url": "https://pacta.wtf/protocols/derive-v3-options/"
  },
  {
   "baskets": [],
   "category": "Automated intelligent liquidity manager routing deposits across concentrated-liquidity positions (Ethereum)",
   "chains": [
    "ethereum"
   ],
   "deltas": 0,
   "easAttested": false,
   "evidence": {
    "documented": "DexFi Aggregator documentation is linked for reference (https://dexfi.com/docs). This RPC-pinned record does not compare documentation parameters with the on-chain state.",
    "observed": "DexFiVaultFactory (0x4C1a8a04577286Ce58d0723b1a90160F380E550A) verified on Ethereum Mainnet at canonical block #26,458,556 (16,297 bytes runtime code). EIP-1967 implementation and admin storage slots are both zero (non-EIP-1967 contract). Direct owner() returns Safe 2-of-3 0x76e1736ea8Cda4d0Ed4923B8E119586716C5725f.",
    "recordId": "dexfi-aggregator-control-plane",
    "surface": "DexFiVaultFactory · Non-Proxy Bytecode & Controller"
   },
   "factors": [
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "upgrade",
     "label": "Upgradeability",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "Upgrade path not in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "timelock",
     "label": "Timelock floor",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No enforced admin delay in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": "dexfi-aggregator-control-plane: … contract). Direct owner() returns Safe 2-of-3 0x76e1736ea8Cda4d0Ed4923B8E119586716C5725f.",
     "key": "quorum",
     "label": "Signer quorum",
     "state": "b",
     "value": "Lowest controlling quorum: 2-of-3"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "emergency",
     "label": "Emergency / freeze scope",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No pause / freeze authority in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "parity",
     "label": "Docs-vs-chain parity",
     "state": "u",
     "value": "Uncompared: documentation not assessed (RPC-observed)"
    }
   ],
   "finding": "DexFiVaultFactory · Non-Proxy Bytecode & Controller",
   "grade": "observed",
   "gradeLabel": "OBSERVED",
   "name": "DexFi Aggregator",
   "pinnedBlock": 26458556,
   "probe": {
    "block_hash": "0xe258bb1cbcc988e2dfdba4ba173f9f8690520dba3647cdcae18e0651822769d2",
    "block_number": 26458556,
    "call_args": [],
    "call_signature": "owner()",
    "chain": "ethereum",
    "check_type": "eth_call",
    "extra_calls": [],
    "id": "dexfi-aggregator-control-plane",
    "repro_calldata": "0x8da5cb5b",
    "rpc_env_var": "$ETH_RPC_URL",
    "selector_or_slot": "0x8da5cb5b",
    "target_contract": "0x4C1a8a04577286Ce58d0723b1a90160F380E550A",
    "target_label": "DexFiVaultFactory"
   },
   "reconciled": false,
   "reconciledFrom": [],
   "reconciledTo": [],
   "records": 1,
   "rosetteAria": "DexFi Aggregator control-plane rosette: Upgradeability not determined; Timelock floor not determined; Signer quorum moderate; Emergency / freeze scope not determined; Docs-vs-chain parity uncompared",
   "search": "dexfi aggregator dexfi-aggregator automated intelligent liquidity manager routing deposits across concentrated-liquidity positions (ethereum) dexfi 0x4c1a8a04577286ce58d0723b1a90160f380e550a 0x76e1736ea8cda4d0ed4923b8e119586716c5725f",
   "slug": "dexfi-aggregator",
   "summary_short": "Non-proxy contract controlled by a 2-of-3 Safe; docs not assessed",
   "url": "https://pacta.wtf/protocols/dexfi-aggregator/"
  },
  {
   "baskets": [
    "base",
    "lending_vaults"
   ],
   "category": "USDC yield streamed from Venice AI compute revenue with an auto-compounding wrapper (Base)",
   "chains": [
    "base"
   ],
   "deltas": 0,
   "easAttested": true,
   "evidence": {
    "documented": "'Admin / operator 2-of-2 Safe — 0x01Ea790410D9863A57771D992D2A72ea326DD7C9' (diem-relay.com/docs)",
    "observed": "DIEM Relay Safe 0x01Ea790410D9863A57771D992D2A72ea326DD7C9 (Base): getThreshold() = 2 of getOwners() = 2 owners (Safe v1.4.1).",
    "recordId": "diem-relay-safe-threshold-s28",
    "surface": "DIEM Relay multisig: 2-of-2 Safe, as documented"
   },
   "factors": [
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "upgrade",
     "label": "Upgradeability",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "Upgrade path not in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "timelock",
     "label": "Timelock floor",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No enforced admin delay in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": "controller fact: Safe getThreshold()",
     "key": "quorum",
     "label": "Signer quorum",
     "state": "b",
     "value": "Lowest controlling quorum: 2-of-2"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "emergency",
     "label": "Emergency / freeze scope",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No pause / freeze authority in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "parity",
     "label": "Docs-vs-chain parity",
     "state": "g",
     "value": "Chain matches or is stronger than the documentation"
    }
   ],
   "finding": "DIEM Relay multisig: 2-of-2 Safe, as documented",
   "grade": "aligned",
   "gradeLabel": "ALIGNED",
   "name": "DIEM Relay",
   "pinnedBlock": 59025642,
   "probe": {
    "block_hash": "0x8fc618f8e02aa1fd1c3bcf1300fd25e40291a0fcde351bd39ad8cb61781d5e12",
    "block_number": 59025642,
    "call_args": [],
    "call_signature": "getThreshold()",
    "chain": "base",
    "check_type": "eth_call",
    "extra_calls": [],
    "id": "diem-relay-safe-threshold-s28",
    "repro_calldata": "0xe75235b8",
    "rpc_env_var": "$BASE_RPC_URL",
    "selector_or_slot": "0xe75235b8",
    "target_contract": "0x01Ea790410D9863A57771D992D2A72ea326DD7C9",
    "target_label": "DIEM Relay Safe"
   },
   "reconciled": false,
   "reconciledFrom": [],
   "reconciledTo": [],
   "records": 1,
   "rosetteAria": "DIEM Relay control-plane rosette: Upgradeability not determined; Timelock floor not determined; Signer quorum moderate; Emergency / freeze scope not determined; Docs-vs-chain parity strong",
   "search": "diem relay diem-relay usdc yield streamed from venice ai compute revenue with an auto-compounding wrapper (base) diem 0x01ea790410d9863a57771d992d2a72ea326dd7c9",
   "slug": "diem-relay",
   "summary_short": "The DIEM Relay multisig is a 2-of-2 Safe, as its docs state",
   "url": "https://pacta.wtf/protocols/diem-relay/"
  },
  {
   "baskets": [
    "lending_vaults"
   ],
   "category": "Proactive market-maker pools with oracle-guided pricing (Ethereum)",
   "chains": [
    "ethereum"
   ],
   "deltas": 0,
   "easAttested": false,
   "evidence": {
    "documented": "DODO AMM documentation is linked for reference (https://docs.dodoex.io/en/home/what-is-dodo). This RPC-pinned record does not compare documentation parameters with the on-chain state.",
    "observed": "DODO bird (0x43Dfc4159D86F3A37A5A4B3D4580b888ad7d4DDd) verified on Ethereum Mainnet at canonical block #26,458,556 (1,995 bytes runtime code). EIP-1967 implementation and admin storage slots are both zero (non-EIP-1967 contract). No owner(), admin(), authority(), curator() or AccessControl admin was readable on the contract.",
    "recordId": "dodo-amm-control-plane",
    "surface": "DODO bird · Non-Proxy Bytecode & Controller"
   },
   "factors": [
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "upgrade",
     "label": "Upgradeability",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "Upgrade path not in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "timelock",
     "label": "Timelock floor",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No enforced admin delay in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "quorum",
     "label": "Signer quorum",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No signer quorum in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "emergency",
     "label": "Emergency / freeze scope",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No pause / freeze authority in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "parity",
     "label": "Docs-vs-chain parity",
     "state": "u",
     "value": "Uncompared: documentation not assessed (RPC-observed)"
    }
   ],
   "finding": "DODO bird · Non-Proxy Bytecode & Controller",
   "grade": "observed",
   "gradeLabel": "OBSERVED",
   "name": "DODO AMM",
   "pinnedBlock": 26458556,
   "probe": {
    "block_hash": "0xe258bb1cbcc988e2dfdba4ba173f9f8690520dba3647cdcae18e0651822769d2",
    "block_number": 26458556,
    "call_args": [],
    "call_signature": "owner()",
    "chain": "ethereum",
    "check_type": "eth_call",
    "extra_calls": [],
    "id": "dodo-amm-control-plane",
    "repro_calldata": "0x8da5cb5b",
    "rpc_env_var": "$ETH_RPC_URL",
    "selector_or_slot": "0x8da5cb5b",
    "target_contract": "0x43Dfc4159D86F3A37A5A4B3D4580b888ad7d4DDd",
    "target_label": "DODO bird"
   },
   "reconciled": false,
   "reconciledFrom": [],
   "reconciledTo": [],
   "records": 1,
   "rosetteAria": "DODO AMM control-plane rosette: Upgradeability not determined; Timelock floor not determined; Signer quorum not determined; Emergency / freeze scope not determined; Docs-vs-chain parity uncompared",
   "search": "dodo amm dodo-amm proactive market-maker pools with oracle-guided pricing (ethereum) dodo 0x43dfc4159d86f3a37a5a4b3d4580b888ad7d4ddd",
   "slug": "dodo-amm",
   "summary_short": "Non-proxy contract no readable owner or admin; docs not assessed",
   "url": "https://pacta.wtf/protocols/dodo-amm/"
  },
  {
   "baskets": [
    "lending_vaults"
   ],
   "category": "Isolated-position money market and prime brokerage for long-tail assets (Ethereum)",
   "chains": [
    "ethereum"
   ],
   "deltas": 0,
   "easAttested": true,
   "evidence": {
    "documented": "'The Gnosis Safe is a 2/3 wallet. Meaning, 2 signers are needed out of the 3 owners to execute a transaction.' (docs.dolomite.io/admin-privileges.md)",
    "observed": "Dolomite Safe 0xa75c21C5BE284122a87A37a76cc6C4DD3E55a1D4 (Ethereum): getThreshold() = 2 of getOwners() = 3 owners (Safe v1.4.1).",
    "recordId": "dolomite-safe-threshold-a75c21-s31",
    "surface": "Dolomite multisig: 2-of-3 Safe, as documented"
   },
   "factors": [
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "upgrade",
     "label": "Upgradeability",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "Upgrade path not in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "timelock",
     "label": "Timelock floor",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No enforced admin delay in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": "controller fact: Safe getThreshold()",
     "key": "quorum",
     "label": "Signer quorum",
     "state": "b",
     "value": "Lowest controlling quorum: 2-of-3"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "emergency",
     "label": "Emergency / freeze scope",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No pause / freeze authority in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "parity",
     "label": "Docs-vs-chain parity",
     "state": "g",
     "value": "Chain matches or is stronger than the documentation"
    }
   ],
   "finding": "Dolomite multisig: 2-of-3 Safe, as documented",
   "grade": "aligned",
   "gradeLabel": "ALIGNED",
   "name": "Dolomite",
   "pinnedBlock": 26450616,
   "probe": {
    "block_hash": "0xd2df7ccb74a6772b51a5597c8f144f5cfae362efeabf193ecfc7c80f8ff37c35",
    "block_number": 26450616,
    "call_args": [],
    "call_signature": "getThreshold()",
    "chain": "ethereum",
    "check_type": "eth_call",
    "extra_calls": [],
    "id": "dolomite-safe-threshold-a75c21-s31",
    "repro_calldata": "0xe75235b8",
    "rpc_env_var": "$ETH_RPC_URL",
    "selector_or_slot": "0xe75235b8",
    "target_contract": "0xa75c21C5BE284122a87A37a76cc6C4DD3E55a1D4",
    "target_label": "Dolomite Safe"
   },
   "reconciled": false,
   "reconciledFrom": [],
   "reconciledTo": [],
   "records": 1,
   "rosetteAria": "Dolomite control-plane rosette: Upgradeability not determined; Timelock floor not determined; Signer quorum moderate; Emergency / freeze scope not determined; Docs-vs-chain parity strong",
   "search": "dolomite dolomite isolated-position money market and prime brokerage for long-tail assets (ethereum) dolomite 0xa75c21c5be284122a87a37a76cc6c4dd3e55a1d4",
   "slug": "dolomite",
   "summary_short": "The Dolomite multisig is a 2-of-3 Safe, as its docs state",
   "url": "https://pacta.wtf/protocols/dolomite/"
  },
  {
   "baskets": [
    "lending_vaults",
    "stable_rwa"
   ],
   "category": "Structured credit vault from a high-frequency trading firm (Ethereum)",
   "chains": [
    "ethereum"
   ],
   "deltas": 0,
   "easAttested": false,
   "evidence": {
    "documented": "Drakewell USDdw documentation is linked for reference (https://docs.drakewell.fi/). This RPC-pinned record does not compare documentation parameters with the on-chain state.",
    "observed": "JUSD Credit Vault (AccountableAsyncRedeemVault) (0x2B5895b716311A1eaC8f93fB88C56aF9eC8C1A69) verified on Ethereum Mainnet at canonical block #26,458,556 (18,511 bytes runtime code). EIP-1967 implementation and admin storage slots are both zero (non-EIP-1967 contract). No owner(), admin(), authority(), curator() or AccessControl admin was readable on the contract.",
    "recordId": "drakewell-usddw-control-plane",
    "surface": "JUSD Credit Vault (AccountableAsyncRedeemVault) · Non-Proxy Bytecode & Controller"
   },
   "factors": [
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "upgrade",
     "label": "Upgradeability",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "Upgrade path not in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "timelock",
     "label": "Timelock floor",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No enforced admin delay in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "quorum",
     "label": "Signer quorum",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No signer quorum in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "emergency",
     "label": "Emergency / freeze scope",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No pause / freeze authority in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "parity",
     "label": "Docs-vs-chain parity",
     "state": "u",
     "value": "Uncompared: documentation not assessed (RPC-observed)"
    }
   ],
   "finding": "JUSD Credit Vault (AccountableAsyncRedeemVault) · Non-Proxy Bytecode & Controller",
   "grade": "observed",
   "gradeLabel": "OBSERVED",
   "name": "Drakewell USDdw",
   "pinnedBlock": 26458556,
   "probe": {
    "block_hash": "0xe258bb1cbcc988e2dfdba4ba173f9f8690520dba3647cdcae18e0651822769d2",
    "block_number": 26458556,
    "call_args": [],
    "call_signature": "owner()",
    "chain": "ethereum",
    "check_type": "eth_call",
    "extra_calls": [],
    "id": "drakewell-usddw-control-plane",
    "repro_calldata": "0x8da5cb5b",
    "rpc_env_var": "$ETH_RPC_URL",
    "selector_or_slot": "0x8da5cb5b",
    "target_contract": "0x2B5895b716311A1eaC8f93fB88C56aF9eC8C1A69",
    "target_label": "JUSD Credit Vault (AccountableAsyncRedeemVault)"
   },
   "reconciled": false,
   "reconciledFrom": [],
   "reconciledTo": [],
   "records": 1,
   "rosetteAria": "Drakewell USDdw control-plane rosette: Upgradeability not determined; Timelock floor not determined; Signer quorum not determined; Emergency / freeze scope not determined; Docs-vs-chain parity uncompared",
   "search": "drakewell usddw drakewell-usddw structured credit vault from a high-frequency trading firm (ethereum) jusd 0x2b5895b716311a1eac8f93fb88c56af9ec8c1a69",
   "slug": "drakewell-usddw",
   "summary_short": "Non-proxy contract no readable owner or admin; docs not assessed",
   "url": "https://pacta.wtf/protocols/drakewell-usddw/"
  },
  {
   "baskets": [],
   "category": "Multi-chain IDO launchpad and token management platform (Ethereum)",
   "chains": [
    "ethereum"
   ],
   "deltas": 0,
   "easAttested": false,
   "evidence": {
    "documented": "DxSale documentation is linked for reference (https://www.dx.app/dxsecurity). This RPC-pinned record does not compare documentation parameters with the on-chain state.",
    "observed": "DxSale.Network (MainToken) (0xF063fE1aB7a291c5d06a86e14730b00BF24cB589) verified on Ethereum Mainnet at canonical block #26,458,556 (6,700 bytes runtime code). EIP-1967 implementation and admin storage slots are both zero (non-EIP-1967 contract). No owner(), admin(), authority(), curator() or AccessControl admin was readable on the contract.",
    "recordId": "dxsale-control-plane",
    "surface": "DxSale.Network (MainToken) · Non-Proxy Bytecode & Controller"
   },
   "factors": [
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "upgrade",
     "label": "Upgradeability",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "Upgrade path not in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "timelock",
     "label": "Timelock floor",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No enforced admin delay in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "quorum",
     "label": "Signer quorum",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No signer quorum in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "emergency",
     "label": "Emergency / freeze scope",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No pause / freeze authority in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "parity",
     "label": "Docs-vs-chain parity",
     "state": "u",
     "value": "Uncompared: documentation not assessed (RPC-observed)"
    }
   ],
   "finding": "DxSale.Network (MainToken) · Non-Proxy Bytecode & Controller",
   "grade": "observed",
   "gradeLabel": "OBSERVED",
   "name": "DxSale",
   "pinnedBlock": 26458556,
   "probe": {
    "block_hash": "0xe258bb1cbcc988e2dfdba4ba173f9f8690520dba3647cdcae18e0651822769d2",
    "block_number": 26458556,
    "call_args": [],
    "call_signature": "owner()",
    "chain": "ethereum",
    "check_type": "eth_call",
    "extra_calls": [],
    "id": "dxsale-control-plane",
    "repro_calldata": "0x8da5cb5b",
    "rpc_env_var": "$ETH_RPC_URL",
    "selector_or_slot": "0x8da5cb5b",
    "target_contract": "0xF063fE1aB7a291c5d06a86e14730b00BF24cB589",
    "target_label": "DxSale.Network (MainToken)"
   },
   "reconciled": false,
   "reconciledFrom": [],
   "reconciledTo": [],
   "records": 1,
   "rosetteAria": "DxSale control-plane rosette: Upgradeability not determined; Timelock floor not determined; Signer quorum not determined; Emergency / freeze scope not determined; Docs-vs-chain parity uncompared",
   "search": "dxsale dxsale multi-chain ido launchpad and token management platform (ethereum) sale 0xf063fe1ab7a291c5d06a86e14730b00bf24cb589",
   "slug": "dxsale",
   "summary_short": "Non-proxy contract no readable owner or admin; docs not assessed",
   "url": "https://pacta.wtf/protocols/dxsale/"
  },
  {
   "baskets": [],
   "category": "Margin and perpetual trading platform (StarkEx generation) (Ethereum)",
   "chains": [
    "ethereum"
   ],
   "deltas": 0,
   "easAttested": true,
   "evidence": {
    "documented": "'Parameter Description Short Timelock Executor Merkle-Pauser Executor Long Timelock Executor Starkware Executor Timelock Delay* After a proposal passes and is queued, delay before the proposal is executed 2 days 0 days 7 days 2-9 days' (docs.dydx.community/dydx-governance/voting-and-governance/dip-proposal-lifecycle); 'Owner Can mint ethDYDX tokens after mint restriction Short Timelock' (docs.dydx.community/dydx-governance/voting-and-governance/governance-parameters)",
    "observed": "ethDYDX 0x92D6C1e31e14520e676a687F0a93788B716BEff5 (Ethereum) owner() = 0x64c7d40c07EFAbec2AafdC243bF59eaF2195c6dc, an Executor (verified source): getDelay() = 172,800 s, MINIMUM_DELAY() = 86,400 s, MAXIMUM_DELAY() = 604,800 s, GRACE_PERIOD() = 604,800 s, the documented Short Timelock Executor column (the Long Timelock column is 7 / 5 / 21 days).",
    "recordId": "dydx-ethdydx-owner-short-timelock-2d-s32",
    "surface": "ethDYDX owner: the Short Timelock Executor, getDelay() 172,800 s"
   },
   "factors": [
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "upgrade",
     "label": "Upgradeability",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "Upgrade path not in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": "dydx-ethdydx-owner-short-timelock-2d-s32: … (verified source): getDelay() = 172,800 s, MINIMUM_DELAY() = 86,400 s, MAXIMUM_DELAY() = 604,800 s, GRACE_PERIOD() …",
     "key": "timelock",
     "label": "Timelock floor",
     "state": "b",
     "value": "1d minimum enforced delay across control surfaces"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "quorum",
     "label": "Signer quorum",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No signer quorum in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "emergency",
     "label": "Emergency / freeze scope",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No pause / freeze authority in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "parity",
     "label": "Docs-vs-chain parity",
     "state": "g",
     "value": "Chain matches or is stronger than the documentation"
    }
   ],
   "finding": "ethDYDX owner: the Short Timelock Executor, getDelay() 172,800 s",
   "grade": "aligned",
   "gradeLabel": "ALIGNED",
   "name": "dYdX V3",
   "pinnedBlock": 26451608,
   "probe": {
    "block_hash": "0x0266af5bcad519d93b3be78e41b76a62985e22fbe4feef043ac3225f6f217a17",
    "block_number": 26451608,
    "call_args": [],
    "call_signature": "getDelay()",
    "chain": "ethereum",
    "check_type": "eth_call",
    "extra_calls": [],
    "id": "dydx-ethdydx-owner-short-timelock-2d-s32",
    "repro_calldata": "0xcebc9a82",
    "rpc_env_var": "$ETH_RPC_URL",
    "selector_or_slot": "0xcebc9a82",
    "target_contract": "0x64c7d40c07EFAbec2AafdC243bF59eaF2195c6dc",
    "target_label": "dYdX Short Timelock Executor"
   },
   "reconciled": false,
   "reconciledFrom": [],
   "reconciledTo": [],
   "records": 1,
   "rosetteAria": "dYdX V3 control-plane rosette: Upgradeability not determined; Timelock floor moderate; Signer quorum not determined; Emergency / freeze scope not determined; Docs-vs-chain parity strong",
   "search": "dydx v3 dydx-v3 margin and perpetual trading platform (starkex generation) (ethereum) dydx 0x64c7d40c07efabec2aafdc243bf59eaf2195c6dc 0x92d6c1e31e14520e676a687f0a93788b716beff5",
   "slug": "dydx-v3",
   "summary_short": "ethDYDX is owned by dYdX's Short Timelock Executor with a 48-hour delay, as documented",
   "url": "https://pacta.wtf/protocols/dydx-v3/"
  },
  {
   "baskets": [],
   "category": "Premium-free coverage pooled from protected deposits (Ethereum)",
   "chains": [
    "ethereum"
   ],
   "deltas": 0,
   "easAttested": false,
   "evidence": {
    "documented": "Easedefi.org documentation is linked for reference (https://www.easedefi.org/). This RPC-pinned record does not compare documentation parameters with the on-chain state.",
    "observed": "Ease Token (0xEa5eDef1287AfDF9Eb8A46f9773AbFc10820c61c) verified on Ethereum Mainnet at canonical block #26,458,556 (3,255 bytes runtime code). EIP-1967 implementation and admin storage slots are both zero (non-EIP-1967 contract). No owner(), admin(), authority(), curator() or AccessControl admin was readable on the contract.",
    "recordId": "easedefi-org-control-plane",
    "surface": "Ease Token · Non-Proxy Bytecode & Controller"
   },
   "factors": [
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "upgrade",
     "label": "Upgradeability",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "Upgrade path not in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "timelock",
     "label": "Timelock floor",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No enforced admin delay in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "quorum",
     "label": "Signer quorum",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No signer quorum in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "emergency",
     "label": "Emergency / freeze scope",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No pause / freeze authority in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "parity",
     "label": "Docs-vs-chain parity",
     "state": "u",
     "value": "Uncompared: documentation not assessed (RPC-observed)"
    }
   ],
   "finding": "Ease Token · Non-Proxy Bytecode & Controller",
   "grade": "observed",
   "gradeLabel": "OBSERVED",
   "name": "Easedefi.org",
   "pinnedBlock": 26458556,
   "probe": {
    "block_hash": "0xe258bb1cbcc988e2dfdba4ba173f9f8690520dba3647cdcae18e0651822769d2",
    "block_number": 26458556,
    "call_args": [],
    "call_signature": "owner()",
    "chain": "ethereum",
    "check_type": "eth_call",
    "extra_calls": [],
    "id": "easedefi-org-control-plane",
    "repro_calldata": "0x8da5cb5b",
    "rpc_env_var": "$ETH_RPC_URL",
    "selector_or_slot": "0x8da5cb5b",
    "target_contract": "0xEa5eDef1287AfDF9Eb8A46f9773AbFc10820c61c",
    "target_label": "Ease Token"
   },
   "reconciled": false,
   "reconciledFrom": [],
   "reconciledTo": [],
   "records": 1,
   "rosetteAria": "Easedefi.org control-plane rosette: Upgradeability not determined; Timelock floor not determined; Signer quorum not determined; Emergency / freeze scope not determined; Docs-vs-chain parity uncompared",
   "search": "easedefi.org easedefi-org premium-free coverage pooled from protected deposits (ethereum) ease 0xea5edef1287afdf9eb8a46f9773abfc10820c61c",
   "slug": "easedefi-org",
   "summary_short": "Non-proxy contract no readable owner or admin; docs not assessed",
   "url": "https://pacta.wtf/protocols/easedefi-org/"
  },
  {
   "baskets": [],
   "category": "Canonical deposit bridge into an SVM rollup settling on Ethereum (Ethereum)",
   "chains": [
    "ethereum"
   ],
   "deltas": 0,
   "easAttested": true,
   "evidence": {
    "documented": "'Our Canonical Bridge is governed by a 3-of-5 multisig.' (docs.eclipse.xyz/architecture/security-architecture-from-assumptions-to-guarantees.md)",
    "observed": "Eclipse Bridge Safe 0x7B2c1CbB33c53c3C6a695e36096AD2cfCE1c0efC (Ethereum): getThreshold() = 3 of getOwners() = 5 owners (Safe v1.3.0); it controls ERC1967Proxy 0x6055Dc6Ff1077eebe5e6D2BA1a1f53d7Ef8430dE.",
    "recordId": "eclipse-bridge-safe-threshold-s27",
    "surface": "Eclipse Bridge multisig: 3-of-5 Safe, as documented"
   },
   "factors": [
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "upgrade",
     "label": "Upgradeability",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "Upgrade path not in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "timelock",
     "label": "Timelock floor",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No enforced admin delay in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": "controller fact: Safe getThreshold()",
     "key": "quorum",
     "label": "Signer quorum",
     "state": "g",
     "value": "Lowest controlling quorum: 3-of-5"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "emergency",
     "label": "Emergency / freeze scope",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No pause / freeze authority in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "parity",
     "label": "Docs-vs-chain parity",
     "state": "g",
     "value": "Chain matches or is stronger than the documentation"
    }
   ],
   "finding": "Eclipse Bridge multisig: 3-of-5 Safe, as documented",
   "grade": "aligned",
   "gradeLabel": "ALIGNED",
   "name": "Eclipse Bridge",
   "pinnedBlock": 26440048,
   "probe": {
    "block_hash": "0x2c6e70ac6ce978ce5c457208ea6d953e60e92ebf2151578f46cbdd070baa54c6",
    "block_number": 26440048,
    "call_args": [],
    "call_signature": "getThreshold()",
    "chain": "ethereum",
    "check_type": "eth_call",
    "extra_calls": [],
    "id": "eclipse-bridge-safe-threshold-s27",
    "repro_calldata": "0xe75235b8",
    "rpc_env_var": "$ETH_RPC_URL",
    "selector_or_slot": "0xe75235b8",
    "target_contract": "0x7B2c1CbB33c53c3C6a695e36096AD2cfCE1c0efC",
    "target_label": "Eclipse Bridge Safe"
   },
   "reconciled": false,
   "reconciledFrom": [],
   "reconciledTo": [],
   "records": 1,
   "rosetteAria": "Eclipse Bridge control-plane rosette: Upgradeability not determined; Timelock floor not determined; Signer quorum strong; Emergency / freeze scope not determined; Docs-vs-chain parity strong",
   "search": "eclipse bridge eclipse-bridge canonical deposit bridge into an svm rollup settling on ethereum (ethereum) es 0x6055dc6ff1077eebe5e6d2ba1a1f53d7ef8430de 0x7b2c1cbb33c53c3c6a695e36096ad2cfce1c0efc",
   "slug": "eclipse-bridge",
   "summary_short": "The Eclipse Bridge multisig is a 3-of-5 Safe, as its docs state",
   "url": "https://pacta.wtf/protocols/eclipse-bridge/"
  },
  {
   "baskets": [],
   "category": "Collateral gateway for a perpetual futures venue listing crypto, stock and forex contracts (Ethereum)",
   "chains": [
    "ethereum"
   ],
   "deltas": 0,
   "easAttested": false,
   "evidence": {
    "documented": "edgeX Bridge documentation is linked for reference (https://edgex-1.gitbook.io/edgex-documentation). This RPC-pinned record does not compare documentation parameters with the on-chain state.",
    "observed": "Edge (0xB0076DE78Dc50581770BBa1D211dDc0aD4F2a241) verified on Ethereum Mainnet at canonical block #26,458,556 (136 bytes runtime code). EIP-1967 proxy: implementation 0x9406dD76452c172B3CC77092B42398e87daB3161, admin slot zero. No owner(), admin(), authority(), curator() or AccessControl admin was readable on the contract.",
    "recordId": "edgex-bridge-control-plane",
    "surface": "Edge · EIP-1967 Proxy & Controller Chain"
   },
   "factors": [
    {
     "evidence": "edgex-bridge-control-plane: is_eip1967_proxy = true",
     "key": "upgrade",
     "label": "Upgradeability",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "Upgradeable; the delay gating the upgrade path is not in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "timelock",
     "label": "Timelock floor",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No enforced admin delay in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "quorum",
     "label": "Signer quorum",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No signer quorum in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "emergency",
     "label": "Emergency / freeze scope",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No pause / freeze authority in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "parity",
     "label": "Docs-vs-chain parity",
     "state": "u",
     "value": "Uncompared: documentation not assessed (RPC-observed)"
    }
   ],
   "finding": "Edge · EIP-1967 Proxy & Controller Chain",
   "grade": "observed",
   "gradeLabel": "OBSERVED",
   "name": "edgeX Bridge",
   "pinnedBlock": 26458556,
   "probe": {
    "block_hash": "0xe258bb1cbcc988e2dfdba4ba173f9f8690520dba3647cdcae18e0651822769d2",
    "block_number": 26458556,
    "call_args": [],
    "call_signature": "owner()",
    "chain": "ethereum",
    "check_type": "eth_call",
    "extra_calls": [],
    "id": "edgex-bridge-control-plane",
    "repro_calldata": "0x8da5cb5b",
    "rpc_env_var": "$ETH_RPC_URL",
    "selector_or_slot": "0x8da5cb5b",
    "target_contract": "0xB0076DE78Dc50581770BBa1D211dDc0aD4F2a241",
    "target_label": "Edge"
   },
   "reconciled": false,
   "reconciledFrom": [],
   "reconciledTo": [],
   "records": 1,
   "rosetteAria": "edgeX Bridge control-plane rosette: Upgradeability not determined; Timelock floor not determined; Signer quorum not determined; Emergency / freeze scope not determined; Docs-vs-chain parity uncompared",
   "search": "edgex bridge edgex-bridge collateral gateway for a perpetual futures venue listing crypto, stock and forex contracts (ethereum) edge 0x9406dd76452c172b3cc77092b42398e87dab3161 0xb0076de78dc50581770bba1d211ddc0ad4f2a241",
   "slug": "edgex-bridge",
   "summary_short": "Upgradeable proxy no readable owner or admin; docs not assessed",
   "url": "https://pacta.wtf/protocols/edgex-bridge/"
  },
  {
   "baskets": [
    "eth_lst_lrt"
   ],
   "category": "Restaking Infrastructure",
   "chains": [
    "ethereum"
   ],
   "deltas": 0,
   "easAttested": true,
   "evidence": {
    "documented": "Layr-Labs/eigenlayer-contracts main README documents Core ProxyAdmin, 10-day TimelockController + CommunityMultisig Executor wrapper, and PauserRegistry 0xB8765ed72235d279c3Fb53936E4606db0Ef12806.",
    "observed": "DelegationManager (0x39053D51B77DC0d36036Fc1fCc8Cb819df8Ef37A) EIP-1967 admin slot = Core ProxyAdmin (0x8b9566AdA63B64d1E1dcF1418b43fd1433b72444), owner() = 1-of-2 ExecutorMultisig (0x369e6F597e22EaB55fFb173C6d9cD234BD699111) shared between 10d TimelockController (0xC06Fd4F821eaC1fF1ae8067b36342899b57BAa2d, getMinDelay() = 864000s) and 9-of-13 CommunityMultisig (0xFEA47018D632A77bA579846c840d5706705Dc598); pauserRegistry() = 0xB8765ed72235d279c3Fb53936E4606db0Ef12806.",
    "recordId": "eigenlayer-core-proxy-admin-and-timelock",
    "surface": "Core ProxyAdmin, Dual-Owner Executor Safe & 10d Timelock"
   },
   "factors": [
    {
     "evidence": "eigenlayer-core-proxy-admin-and-timelock: DelegationManager (0x39053D51B77DC0d36036Fc1fCc8Cb819df8Ef37A) EIP-1967 admin slot = Core ProxyAdmin (0x8b9566AdA63B64d1E1dcF1418b43fd1433b72444), owner() = …",
     "key": "upgrade",
     "label": "Upgradeability",
     "state": "a",
     "value": "Upgradeable with no enforced delay: a 1-of-N executor co-owned by the timelock and a non-timelock signer bypasses the delay"
    },
    {
     "evidence": "eigenlayer-core-proxy-admin-and-timelock: DelegationManager (0x39053D51B77DC0d36036Fc1fCc8Cb819df8Ef37A) EIP-1967 admin slot = Core ProxyAdmin (0x8b9566AdA63B64d1E1dcF1418b43fd1433b72444), owner() = …",
     "key": "timelock",
     "label": "Timelock floor",
     "state": "a",
     "value": "0s minimum enforced delay across control surfaces"
    },
    {
     "evidence": "eigenlayer-core-proxy-admin-and-timelock: … (0xC06Fd4F821eaC1fF1ae8067b36342899b57BAa2d, getMinDelay() = 864000s) and 9-of-13 CommunityMultisig (0xFEA47018D632A77bA579846c840d5706705Dc598); …",
     "key": "quorum",
     "label": "Signer quorum",
     "state": "g",
     "value": "Lowest controlling quorum: 9-of-13 (via a 1-of-N contract-executor wrapper co-owned with a timelock)"
    },
    {
     "evidence": "eigenlayer-core-proxy-admin-and-timelock: pauserRegistry() = 0xB8765ed72235d279c3Fb53936E4606db0Ef12806.",
     "key": "emergency",
     "label": "Emergency / freeze scope",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "Pause / freeze authority present; its holder is not determined"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "parity",
     "label": "Docs-vs-chain parity",
     "state": "g",
     "value": "Chain matches or is stronger than the documentation"
    }
   ],
   "finding": "Core ProxyAdmin, Dual-Owner Executor Safe & 10d Timelock",
   "grade": "aligned",
   "gradeLabel": "ALIGNED",
   "name": "EigenLayer Core",
   "pinnedBlock": 26402160,
   "probe": {
    "block_hash": "0xd04a5e8aa3500c5b60d90c25a810ef28eb9d1bfffadf28f1da58a31ed90582dc",
    "block_number": 26402160,
    "call_args": [],
    "call_signature": "getMinDelay()",
    "chain": "ethereum",
    "check_type": "eth_call",
    "extra_calls": [],
    "id": "eigenlayer-core-proxy-admin-and-timelock",
    "repro_calldata": "0xf27a0c92",
    "rpc_env_var": "$ETH_RPC_URL",
    "selector_or_slot": "0xf27a0c92",
    "target_contract": "0xC06Fd4F821eaC1fF1ae8067b36342899b57BAa2d",
    "target_label": "EigenLayerTimelockController"
   },
   "reconciled": false,
   "reconciledFrom": [],
   "reconciledTo": [],
   "records": 1,
   "rosetteAria": "EigenLayer Core control-plane rosette: Upgradeability weak; Timelock floor weak; Signer quorum strong; Emergency / freeze scope not determined; Docs-vs-chain parity strong",
   "search": "eigenlayer core eigenlayer-core restaking infrastructure eigen 0x369e6f597e22eab55ffb173c6d9cd234bd699111 0x39053d51b77dc0d36036fc1fcc8cb819df8ef37a 0x8b9566ada63b64d1e1dcf1418b43fd1433b72444 0xb8765ed72235d279c3fb53936e4606db0ef12806 0xc06fd4f821eac1ff1ae8067b36342899b57baa2d 0xfea47018d632a77ba579846c840d5706705dc598",
   "slug": "eigenlayer-core",
   "summary_short": "Core ProxyAdmin, executor Safe and 10-day Timelock match the docs",
   "url": "https://pacta.wtf/protocols/eigenlayer-core/"
  },
  {
   "baskets": [
    "eth_lst_lrt"
   ],
   "category": "Magpie subDAO restaking ether liquid staking tokens (Ethereum)",
   "chains": [
    "ethereum"
   ],
   "deltas": 0,
   "easAttested": false,
   "evidence": {
    "documented": "Eigenpie documentation is linked for reference (https://docs.magpiexyz.io/terms-and-conditions). This RPC-pinned record does not compare documentation parameters with the on-chain state.",
    "observed": "EigenpieConfig (0x20b70E4A1883b81429533FeD944d7957121c7CAB) verified on Ethereum Mainnet at canonical block #26,458,556 (2,837 bytes runtime code). EIP-1967 proxy: implementation 0x416dFb213f640B18E367A91Fd39E6EE0F55f6753, admin 0xaF69B55b083AB19893D5Ff18213b3E67875E01F3. The EIP-1967 admin slot holds contract ProxyAdmin 0xaF69B55b083AB19893D5Ff18213b3E67875E01F3. That controller is in turn controlled by Safe 3-of-7 0xf433c2A2D6FACeCDd9Edd7B8cE9cEaaB96F41866.",
    "recordId": "eigenpie-control-plane",
    "surface": "EigenpieConfig · EIP-1967 Proxy & Controller Chain"
   },
   "factors": [
    {
     "evidence": "eigenpie-control-plane: EigenpieConfig (0x20b70E4A1883b81429533FeD944d7957121c7CAB) verified on Ethereum Mainnet at canonical block #26,458,556 (2,837 bytes runtime code). EIP-1967 …",
     "key": "upgrade",
     "label": "Upgradeability",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "Upgradeable; the delay gating the upgrade path is not in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "timelock",
     "label": "Timelock floor",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No enforced admin delay in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": "eigenpie-control-plane: … controller is in turn controlled by Safe 3-of-7 0xf433c2A2D6FACeCDd9Edd7B8cE9cEaaB96F41866.",
     "key": "quorum",
     "label": "Signer quorum",
     "state": "g",
     "value": "Lowest controlling quorum: 3-of-7"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "emergency",
     "label": "Emergency / freeze scope",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No pause / freeze authority in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "parity",
     "label": "Docs-vs-chain parity",
     "state": "u",
     "value": "Uncompared: documentation not assessed (RPC-observed)"
    }
   ],
   "finding": "EigenpieConfig · EIP-1967 Proxy & Controller Chain",
   "grade": "observed",
   "gradeLabel": "OBSERVED",
   "name": "Eigenpie",
   "pinnedBlock": 26458556,
   "probe": {
    "block_hash": "0xe258bb1cbcc988e2dfdba4ba173f9f8690520dba3647cdcae18e0651822769d2",
    "block_number": 26458556,
    "call_args": [],
    "call_signature": null,
    "chain": "ethereum",
    "check_type": "eth_getStorageAt",
    "extra_calls": [],
    "id": "eigenpie-control-plane",
    "repro_calldata": null,
    "rpc_env_var": "$ETH_RPC_URL",
    "selector_or_slot": "0xb53127684a568b3173ae13b9f8a6016e243e63b6e8ee1178d6a717850b5d6103",
    "target_contract": "0x20b70E4A1883b81429533FeD944d7957121c7CAB",
    "target_label": "EigenpieConfig"
   },
   "reconciled": false,
   "reconciledFrom": [],
   "reconciledTo": [],
   "records": 1,
   "rosetteAria": "Eigenpie control-plane rosette: Upgradeability not determined; Timelock floor not determined; Signer quorum strong; Emergency / freeze scope not determined; Docs-vs-chain parity uncompared",
   "search": "eigenpie eigenpie magpie subdao restaking ether liquid staking tokens (ethereum) eigenpie 0x20b70e4a1883b81429533fed944d7957121c7cab 0x416dfb213f640b18e367a91fd39e6ee0f55f6753 0xaf69b55b083ab19893d5ff18213b3e67875e01f3 0xf433c2a2d6facecdd9edd7b8ce9ceaab96f41866",
   "slug": "eigenpie",
   "summary_short": "Upgradeable proxy controlled by a 3-of-7 Safe; docs not assessed",
   "url": "https://pacta.wtf/protocols/eigenpie/"
  },
  {
   "baskets": [],
   "category": "Singleton concentrated-liquidity exchange with hooks-style extensions and flash accounting (Ethereum)",
   "chains": [
    "ethereum"
   ],
   "deltas": 0,
   "easAttested": true,
   "evidence": {
    "documented": "'All smart contracts on Ethereum are immutable' (docs.ekubo.org/reference/contracts/evm-v2)",
    "observed": "Ekubo Core 0xe0e0e08A6A4b9Dc7bD67BCB7aadE5cF48157d444 (Ethereum): EIP-1967 implementation, admin and beacon slots all empty; verified source (runtime exact match) has no delegatecall and no upgrade function, and its only onlyOwner functions are withdrawProtocolFees and the ownership transfers. owner() = 0x1E0EF4162e42C9bF820c307218c4E41cCcA6E9CC, StarknetOwnerProxy: immutable l2Owner() = 0x053499f7aa2706395060fe72d00388803fb2dcc111429891ad7b2d9dcea29acd (the Ekubo DAO Governor on Starknet), l2MessageBridge() = 0xc662c410C0ECf747543f5bA90660f6ABeBD9C8c4; it executes only calls consumed as L2 messages from that Governor. The docs mark the V2 EVM deployment deprecated.",
    "recordId": "ekubo-core-immutable-starknet-owner-s32",
    "surface": "Core: not a proxy; owner() is the StarknetOwnerProxy driven by the Starknet Governor"
   },
   "factors": [
    {
     "evidence": "ekubo-core-immutable-starknet-owner-s32: … 0x1E0EF4162e42C9bF820c307218c4E41cCcA6E9CC, StarknetOwnerProxy: immutable l2Owner() = 0x053499f7aa2706395060fe72d00388803fb2dcc111429891ad7b2d9dcea29acd …",
     "key": "upgrade",
     "label": "Upgradeability",
     "state": "g",
     "value": "Immutable or ownership renounced"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "timelock",
     "label": "Timelock floor",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No enforced admin delay in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": "ekubo-core-immutable-starknet-owner-s32: … 0x053499f7aa2706395060fe72d00388803fb2dcc111429891ad7b2d9dcea29acd (the Ekubo DAO Governor on Starknet), l2MessageBridge() = 0xc662c410C0ECf747543f5bA90660f6ABeBD9C8c4; …",
     "key": "quorum",
     "label": "Signer quorum",
     "state": "g",
     "value": "DAO Governor (token vote)"
    },
    {
     "evidence": "ekubo-core-immutable-starknet-owner-s32: it executes only calls consumed as L2 messages from that Governor. The docs mark the V2 EVM deployment deprecated.",
     "key": "emergency",
     "label": "Emergency / freeze scope",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "Pause / freeze authority present; its holder is not determined"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "parity",
     "label": "Docs-vs-chain parity",
     "state": "g",
     "value": "Chain matches or is stronger than the documentation"
    }
   ],
   "finding": "Core: not a proxy; owner() is the StarknetOwnerProxy driven by the Starknet Governor",
   "grade": "aligned",
   "gradeLabel": "ALIGNED",
   "name": "Ekubo",
   "pinnedBlock": 26451608,
   "probe": {
    "block_hash": "0x0266af5bcad519d93b3be78e41b76a62985e22fbe4feef043ac3225f6f217a17",
    "block_number": 26451608,
    "call_args": [],
    "call_signature": "owner()",
    "chain": "ethereum",
    "check_type": "eth_call",
    "extra_calls": [],
    "id": "ekubo-core-immutable-starknet-owner-s32",
    "repro_calldata": "0x8da5cb5b",
    "rpc_env_var": "$ETH_RPC_URL",
    "selector_or_slot": "0x8da5cb5b",
    "target_contract": "0xe0e0e08A6A4b9Dc7bD67BCB7aadE5cF48157d444",
    "target_label": "Ekubo Core (EVM V2)"
   },
   "reconciled": false,
   "reconciledFrom": [],
   "reconciledTo": [],
   "records": 1,
   "rosetteAria": "Ekubo control-plane rosette: Upgradeability strong; Timelock floor not determined; Signer quorum strong; Emergency / freeze scope not determined; Docs-vs-chain parity strong",
   "search": "ekubo ekubo singleton concentrated-liquidity exchange with hooks-style extensions and flash accounting (ethereum) ekubo 0x1e0ef4162e42c9bf820c307218c4e41ccca6e9cc 0xc662c410c0ecf747543f5ba90660f6abebd9c8c4 0xe0e0e08a6a4b9dc7bd67bcb7aade5cf48157d444",
   "slug": "ekubo",
   "summary_short": "Ekubo Core is immutable and owned by its Starknet governance proxy, as documented",
   "url": "https://pacta.wtf/protocols/ekubo/"
  },
  {
   "baskets": [
    "base",
    "lending_vaults"
   ],
   "category": "Oracle-priced DEX vaults (Base)",
   "chains": [
    "base"
   ],
   "deltas": 0,
   "easAttested": false,
   "evidence": {
    "documented": "ElfomoFi documentation is linked for reference (https://docs.elfomo.fi/). This RPC-pinned record does not compare documentation parameters with the on-chain state.",
    "observed": "VaultsManager (0x64f8bE47A011DF0fAB47319d5De258D18E93f4ef) verified on Base Mainnet at canonical block #60,070,202 (16,167 bytes runtime code). EIP-1967 implementation and admin storage slots are both zero (non-EIP-1967 contract). Direct owner() returns Safe 3-of-5 0x1a0554f4832a0901709b9C13BBE459f72f7b9ACb.",
    "recordId": "elfomofi-control-plane",
    "surface": "VaultsManager · Non-Proxy Bytecode & Controller"
   },
   "factors": [
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "upgrade",
     "label": "Upgradeability",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "Upgrade path not in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "timelock",
     "label": "Timelock floor",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No enforced admin delay in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": "elfomofi-control-plane: … contract). Direct owner() returns Safe 3-of-5 0x1a0554f4832a0901709b9C13BBE459f72f7b9ACb.",
     "key": "quorum",
     "label": "Signer quorum",
     "state": "g",
     "value": "Lowest controlling quorum: 3-of-5"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "emergency",
     "label": "Emergency / freeze scope",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No pause / freeze authority in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "parity",
     "label": "Docs-vs-chain parity",
     "state": "u",
     "value": "Uncompared: documentation not assessed (RPC-observed)"
    }
   ],
   "finding": "VaultsManager · Non-Proxy Bytecode & Controller",
   "grade": "observed",
   "gradeLabel": "OBSERVED",
   "name": "ElfomoFi",
   "pinnedBlock": 60070202,
   "probe": {
    "block_hash": "0x01b3f5dcecb67c63ba33350ec6942563f6b8a0d8ca9b4f69a752844a5bab4a20",
    "block_number": 60070202,
    "call_args": [],
    "call_signature": "owner()",
    "chain": "base",
    "check_type": "eth_call",
    "extra_calls": [],
    "id": "elfomofi-control-plane",
    "repro_calldata": "0x8da5cb5b",
    "rpc_env_var": "$BASE_RPC_URL",
    "selector_or_slot": "0x8da5cb5b",
    "target_contract": "0x64f8bE47A011DF0fAB47319d5De258D18E93f4ef",
    "target_label": "VaultsManager"
   },
   "reconciled": false,
   "reconciledFrom": [],
   "reconciledTo": [],
   "records": 1,
   "rosetteAria": "ElfomoFi control-plane rosette: Upgradeability not determined; Timelock floor not determined; Signer quorum strong; Emergency / freeze scope not determined; Docs-vs-chain parity uncompared",
   "search": "elfomofi elfomofi oracle-priced dex vaults (base) elfomofi 0x1a0554f4832a0901709b9c13bbe459f72f7b9acb 0x64f8be47a011df0fab47319d5de258d18e93f4ef",
   "slug": "elfomofi",
   "summary_short": "Non-proxy contract controlled by a 3-of-5 Safe; docs not assessed",
   "url": "https://pacta.wtf/protocols/elfomofi/"
  },
  {
   "baskets": [],
   "category": "On-chain Asset Management",
   "chains": [
    "ethereum"
   ],
   "deltas": 0,
   "easAttested": true,
   "evidence": {
    "documented": "specs.enzyme.finance (fund lifecycle): 'MigratorA waits for the `migrationTimelock` defined on the `Dispatcher` to pass. [NOTE: This is no longer used and is set to `0`]'; access-control handoff: 'The owner is already the Enzyme Council.' (no Council address or threshold is published).",
    "observed": "Dispatcher (0xC3DC853dD716bd5754f421ef94fdCbac3902ab32, Sourcify exact_match) getMigrationTimelock() = 604800s (7d), enforced by signalMigration (executableTimestamp = block.timestamp + migrationTimelock). getOwner() = 3-of-5 Safe 0xb270FE91e8E4b80452fBF1b4704208792A350f53 (getNominatedOwner() = 0), which also owns the live FundDeployer 0x4f1C53F096533C04d8157EFB6Bca3eb22ddC6360 (getCurrentFundDeployer()); setCurrentFundDeployer and setMigrationTimelock are onlyOwner with no delay.",
    "recordId": "enzyme-dispatcher-7d-migration-timelock-s18",
    "surface": "Dispatcher migration timelock = 7 days (specs: 'no longer used and is set to 0')"
   },
   "factors": [
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "upgrade",
     "label": "Upgradeability",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "Upgrade path not in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": "enzyme-dispatcher-7d-migration-timelock-s18: observed_delay_seconds = 604800",
     "key": "timelock",
     "label": "Timelock floor",
     "state": "g",
     "value": "7d minimum enforced delay across control surfaces"
    },
    {
     "evidence": "enzyme-dispatcher-7d-migration-timelock-s18: … + migrationTimelock). getOwner() = 3-of-5 Safe 0xb270FE91e8E4b80452fBF1b4704208792A350f53 …",
     "key": "quorum",
     "label": "Signer quorum",
     "state": "g",
     "value": "Lowest controlling quorum: 3-of-5"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "emergency",
     "label": "Emergency / freeze scope",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No pause / freeze authority in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "parity",
     "label": "Docs-vs-chain parity",
     "state": "g",
     "value": "Chain matches or is stronger than the documentation"
    }
   ],
   "finding": "Timelock delay: docs say 0 s (no delay) · chain says 7 d",
   "grade": "protective",
   "gradeLabel": "PROTECTIVE",
   "name": "Enzyme Finance",
   "pinnedBlock": 26421541,
   "probe": {
    "block_hash": "0xfc2e93c53812cd390b29924a4e217bd4f75d77725bd2882968fb5b087a17150d",
    "block_number": 26421541,
    "call_args": [],
    "call_signature": "getMigrationTimelock()",
    "chain": "ethereum",
    "check_type": "eth_call",
    "extra_calls": [],
    "id": "enzyme-dispatcher-7d-migration-timelock-s18",
    "repro_calldata": "0x2fa0c161",
    "rpc_env_var": "$ETH_RPC_URL",
    "selector_or_slot": "0x2fa0c161",
    "target_contract": "0xC3DC853dD716bd5754f421ef94fdCbac3902ab32",
    "target_label": "Enzyme Dispatcher"
   },
   "reconciled": false,
   "reconciledFrom": [],
   "reconciledTo": [],
   "records": 1,
   "rosetteAria": "Enzyme Finance control-plane rosette: Upgradeability not determined; Timelock floor strong; Signer quorum strong; Emergency / freeze scope not determined; Docs-vs-chain parity strong",
   "search": "enzyme finance enzyme-finance on-chain asset management mln enzyme 0x4f1c53f096533c04d8157efb6bca3eb22ddc6360 0xb270fe91e8e4b80452fbf1b4704208792a350f53 0xc3dc853dd716bd5754f421ef94fdcbac3902ab32",
   "slug": "enzyme-finance",
   "summary_short": "Timelock delay: docs none · chain 7 days (stricter)",
   "url": "https://pacta.wtf/protocols/enzyme-finance/"
  },
  {
   "baskets": [],
   "category": "vePENDLE booster: tokenized voting power and boosted LP rewards (Ethereum)",
   "chains": [
    "ethereum"
   ],
   "deltas": 0,
   "easAttested": true,
   "evidence": {
    "documented": "'Following this process, an upgrade is made by the team, and the multi-sig signer proposes the upgrade with a 24-hour timelock.' (docs.equilibria.fi/security-and-risk/multi-sig-and-timelock.md)",
    "observed": "Equilibria TimelockController 0xe2A63438747D2c71E14BdC2Cc222be89B1C11D03 (Ethereum): getMinDelay() = 86400s (1 d).",
    "recordId": "equilibria-timelock-delay-s27",
    "surface": "Equilibria timelock: 24-hour minimum delay, as documented"
   },
   "factors": [
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "upgrade",
     "label": "Upgradeability",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "Upgrade path not in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": "controller fact: getMinDelay() = 86400s",
     "key": "timelock",
     "label": "Timelock floor",
     "state": "b",
     "value": "1d minimum enforced delay across control surfaces"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "quorum",
     "label": "Signer quorum",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No signer quorum in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "emergency",
     "label": "Emergency / freeze scope",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No pause / freeze authority in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "parity",
     "label": "Docs-vs-chain parity",
     "state": "g",
     "value": "Chain matches or is stronger than the documentation"
    }
   ],
   "finding": "Equilibria timelock: 24-hour minimum delay, as documented",
   "grade": "aligned",
   "gradeLabel": "ALIGNED",
   "name": "Equilibria",
   "pinnedBlock": 26440048,
   "probe": {
    "block_hash": "0x2c6e70ac6ce978ce5c457208ea6d953e60e92ebf2151578f46cbdd070baa54c6",
    "block_number": 26440048,
    "call_args": [],
    "call_signature": "getMinDelay()",
    "chain": "ethereum",
    "check_type": "eth_call",
    "extra_calls": [],
    "id": "equilibria-timelock-delay-s27",
    "repro_calldata": "0xf27a0c92",
    "rpc_env_var": "$ETH_RPC_URL",
    "selector_or_slot": "0xf27a0c92",
    "target_contract": "0xe2A63438747D2c71E14BdC2Cc222be89B1C11D03",
    "target_label": "Equilibria TimelockController"
   },
   "reconciled": false,
   "reconciledFrom": [],
   "reconciledTo": [],
   "records": 1,
   "rosetteAria": "Equilibria control-plane rosette: Upgradeability not determined; Timelock floor moderate; Signer quorum not determined; Emergency / freeze scope not determined; Docs-vs-chain parity strong",
   "search": "equilibria equilibria vependle booster: tokenized voting power and boosted lp rewards (ethereum) equilibria 0xe2a63438747d2c71e14bdc2cc222be89b1c11d03",
   "slug": "equilibria",
   "summary_short": "Equilibria changes wait a 24-hour timelock, as documented",
   "url": "https://pacta.wtf/protocols/equilibria/"
  },
  {
   "baskets": [
    "stable_rwa"
   ],
   "category": "Treasury accumulation token giving leveraged ether exposure without liquidation (Ethereum)",
   "chains": [
    "ethereum"
   ],
   "deltas": 0,
   "easAttested": true,
   "evidence": {
    "documented": "'The ETH Strategy Multisig (root authority) is a **3-of-5** Safe (v1.4.1). Five distinct EOA signers must produce 3 signatures to execute any governance action.' (docs.ethstrat.xyz/security-and-risk/decentralization-scorecard.md)",
    "observed": "ETH Strategy Safe 0xC53CCed6332D06972A7eaEDc64FDF6d4aF5220b8 (Ethereum): getThreshold() = 3 of getOwners() = 5 owners (Safe v1.4.1).",
    "recordId": "eth-strategy-safe-threshold-s27",
    "surface": "ETH Strategy multisig: 3-of-5 Safe, as documented"
   },
   "factors": [
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "upgrade",
     "label": "Upgradeability",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "Upgrade path not in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "timelock",
     "label": "Timelock floor",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No enforced admin delay in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": "controller fact: Safe getThreshold()",
     "key": "quorum",
     "label": "Signer quorum",
     "state": "g",
     "value": "Lowest controlling quorum: 3-of-5"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "emergency",
     "label": "Emergency / freeze scope",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No pause / freeze authority in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "parity",
     "label": "Docs-vs-chain parity",
     "state": "g",
     "value": "Chain matches or is stronger than the documentation"
    }
   ],
   "finding": "ETH Strategy multisig: 3-of-5 Safe, as documented",
   "grade": "aligned",
   "gradeLabel": "ALIGNED",
   "name": "ETH Strategy",
   "pinnedBlock": 26440048,
   "probe": {
    "block_hash": "0x2c6e70ac6ce978ce5c457208ea6d953e60e92ebf2151578f46cbdd070baa54c6",
    "block_number": 26440048,
    "call_args": [],
    "call_signature": "getThreshold()",
    "chain": "ethereum",
    "check_type": "eth_call",
    "extra_calls": [],
    "id": "eth-strategy-safe-threshold-s27",
    "repro_calldata": "0xe75235b8",
    "rpc_env_var": "$ETH_RPC_URL",
    "selector_or_slot": "0xe75235b8",
    "target_contract": "0xC53CCed6332D06972A7eaEDc64FDF6d4aF5220b8",
    "target_label": "ETH Strategy Safe"
   },
   "reconciled": false,
   "reconciledFrom": [],
   "reconciledTo": [],
   "records": 1,
   "rosetteAria": "ETH Strategy control-plane rosette: Upgradeability not determined; Timelock floor not determined; Signer quorum strong; Emergency / freeze scope not determined; Docs-vs-chain parity strong",
   "search": "eth strategy eth-strategy treasury accumulation token giving leveraged ether exposure without liquidation (ethereum) strat 0xc53cced6332d06972a7eaedc64fdf6d4af5220b8",
   "slug": "eth-strategy",
   "summary_short": "The ETH Strategy multisig is a 3-of-5 Safe, as its docs state",
   "url": "https://pacta.wtf/protocols/eth-strategy/"
  },
  {
   "baskets": [
    "stable_rwa"
   ],
   "category": "Synthetic Dollar / Basis Collateral",
   "chains": [
    "ethereum"
   ],
   "deltas": 2,
   "easAttested": true,
   "evidence": {
    "documented": "key-trust-assumptions.md lists 7-day time-locks and 7 signatures (key-addresses.md lists 5/11); Risk Committee forum topic 810 (Jul 2026) notes 1-day delay.",
    "observed": "getMinDelay() = 86400s (1 day); Dev Multisig (0x3B0AAf6e6fCd4a7cEEf8c92C32DFeA9E64dC1862) getThreshold() = 5, getOwners().length = 10 (5-of-10 Gnosis Safe).",
    "recordId": "ethena-admin-timelock-and-dev-safe",
    "surface": "TimelockController MinDelay & Dev Multisig Quorum"
   },
   "factors": [
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "upgrade",
     "label": "Upgradeability",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "Upgrade path not in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": "controller fact: getMinDelay() = 86400s",
     "key": "timelock",
     "label": "Timelock floor",
     "state": "b",
     "value": "1d minimum enforced delay across control surfaces"
    },
    {
     "evidence": "ethena-admin-timelock-and-dev-safe: … getThreshold() = 5, getOwners().length = 10 (5-of-10 Gnosis Safe).",
     "key": "quorum",
     "label": "Signer quorum",
     "state": "g",
     "value": "Lowest controlling quorum: 5-of-10"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "emergency",
     "label": "Emergency / freeze scope",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No pause / freeze authority in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "parity",
     "label": "Docs-vs-chain parity",
     "state": "a",
     "value": "Documentation differs from the chain (parameter delta)"
    }
   ],
   "finding": "Timelock delay: docs say 7 d · chain says 1 d",
   "grade": "delta",
   "gradeLabel": "DELTA",
   "name": "Ethena (USDe / sUSDe)",
   "pinnedBlock": 26406106,
   "probe": {
    "block_hash": "0xe62ad2969617ad07c23bec298c3d5e197ea7c3084f7f66c90d2eb51d04c6273e",
    "block_number": 26401638,
    "call_args": [],
    "call_signature": "getMinDelay()",
    "chain": "ethereum",
    "check_type": "eth_call",
    "extra_calls": [],
    "id": "ethena-admin-timelock-and-dev-safe",
    "repro_calldata": "0xf27a0c92",
    "rpc_env_var": "$ETH_RPC_URL",
    "selector_or_slot": "0xf27a0c92",
    "target_contract": "0xE8Dc0Fab349EA169283C48Ccfd09d797E6DB7c94",
    "target_label": "EthenaTimelockController"
   },
   "reconciled": false,
   "reconciledFrom": [],
   "reconciledTo": [],
   "records": 2,
   "rosetteAria": "Ethena (USDe / sUSDe) control-plane rosette: Upgradeability not determined; Timelock floor moderate; Signer quorum strong; Emergency / freeze scope not determined; Docs-vs-chain parity weak",
   "search": "ethena (usde / susde) ethena-usde-susde synthetic dollar / basis collateral usde susde ena 0x3b0aaf6e6fcd4a7ceef8c92c32dfea9e64dc1862 0x4c9edd5852cd905f086c759e8383e09bff1e68b3 0x57e114b691db790c35207b2e685d4a43181e6061 0x9d39a5de30e57443bff2a8307a4256c8797a3497 0xe3490297a08d6fc8da46edb7b6142e4f461b62d3 0xe8dc0fab349ea169283c48ccfd09d797e6db7c94",
   "slug": "ethena-usde-susde",
   "summary_short": "Timelock delay: docs 7 days · chain 1 day",
   "url": "https://pacta.wtf/protocols/ethena-usde-susde/"
  },
  {
   "baskets": [
    "stable_rwa"
   ],
   "category": "RWA-Backed Stablecoin",
   "chains": [
    "ethereum"
   ],
   "deltas": 0,
   "easAttested": true,
   "evidence": {
    "documented": "docs.ethena.fi key addresses (Dev multisig): '5/11 signers.' and 'Owner of Ethena's deployed mainnet smart contracts & able to modify contract parameters.'",
    "observed": "PSM (0x73E35C5c35A274E34AdE6EB13cC7f62aEE323728).owner() = EthenaTimelockController 0xE8Dc0Fab349EA169283C48Ccfd09d797E6DB7c94 (getMinDelay() = 86400s), which also holds the PSM DEFAULT_ADMIN_ROLE (the Dev multisig does not); the Dev multisig 0x3B0AAf6e6fCd4a7cEEf8c92C32DFeA9E64dC1862 (5-of-10, v1.3.0) holds PROPOSER_ROLE, CANCELLER_ROLE and EXECUTOR_ROLE on the timelock; asset() = USDtb, isSwapEnabled() = true.",
    "recordId": "ethena-usdtb-psm-owner-24h-timelock-s19",
    "surface": "USDtb PSM owned by a 24-hour TimelockController (Dev multisig proposes), not by the Dev multisig directly"
   },
   "factors": [
    {
     "evidence": "ethena-usdtb-single-admin-no-timelock-s19: USDtb (0xC139190F447e929f090Edeb554D95AbB8b18aC1C).owner() = 0xd93826BB299765c87D13AeBa2A7E5d9B27A03956 (no code), which also holds DEFAULT_ADMIN_ROLE and owns …",
     "key": "upgrade",
     "label": "Upgradeability",
     "state": "a",
     "value": "Upgradeable with no enforced delay: no timelock in front of upgrades"
    },
    {
     "evidence": "ethena-usdtb-single-admin-no-timelock-s19: USDtb (0xC139190F447e929f090Edeb554D95AbB8b18aC1C).owner() = 0xd93826BB299765c87D13AeBa2A7E5d9B27A03956 (no code), which also holds DEFAULT_ADMIN_ROLE and owns …",
     "key": "timelock",
     "label": "Timelock floor",
     "state": "a",
     "value": "0s minimum enforced delay across control surfaces"
    },
    {
     "evidence": "ethena-usdtb-single-admin-no-timelock-s19: … 0xd93826BB299765c87D13AeBa2A7E5d9B27A03956 (no code), which also holds DEFAULT_ADMIN_ROLE …",
     "key": "quorum",
     "label": "Signer quorum",
     "state": "a",
     "value": "Lowest controlling quorum: a single key"
    },
    {
     "evidence": "ethena-usdtb-single-admin-no-timelock-s19: MINTER_BURNER_ROLE, BLOCKLISTER_ROLE and PAUSER_ROLE are each held by one address without code",
     "key": "emergency",
     "label": "Emergency / freeze scope",
     "state": "a",
     "value": "Pause / freeze authority held by a single key"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "parity",
     "label": "Docs-vs-chain parity",
     "state": "g",
     "value": "Chain matches or is stronger than the documentation"
    }
   ],
   "finding": "USDtb PSM owned by a 24-hour TimelockController (Dev multisig proposes), not by the Dev multisig directly: docs say docs.ethena.fi key addresses (Dev multisig): '5/11 signers.' and 'Owner of Ethena's deployed mainnet smart contracts & able to modify contract parameters.' · chain says PSM (0x73E35C5c35A274E34AdE6EB13cC7f62aEE323728).owner() = EthenaTimelockController 0xE8Dc0Fab349EA169283C48Ccfd09d797E6DB7c94 (getMinDelay() = 86400s), which also holds the PSM DEFAULT_ADMIN_ROLE (the Dev multisig does…",
   "grade": "protective",
   "gradeLabel": "PROTECTIVE",
   "name": "Ethena USDtb",
   "pinnedBlock": 26422243,
   "probe": {
    "block_hash": "0xbbe80f9ef9966a9d04cea23db216847f8c8fcc8d66f87c215dc7f712f0743410",
    "block_number": 26422243,
    "call_args": [],
    "call_signature": "owner()",
    "chain": "ethereum",
    "check_type": "eth_call",
    "extra_calls": [],
    "id": "ethena-usdtb-psm-owner-24h-timelock-s19",
    "repro_calldata": "0x8da5cb5b",
    "rpc_env_var": "$ETH_RPC_URL",
    "selector_or_slot": "0x8da5cb5b",
    "target_contract": "0x73E35C5c35A274E34AdE6EB13cC7f62aEE323728",
    "target_label": "USDtb PSM"
   },
   "reconciled": false,
   "reconciledFrom": [],
   "reconciledTo": [],
   "records": 2,
   "rosetteAria": "Ethena USDtb control-plane rosette: Upgradeability weak; Timelock floor weak; Signer quorum weak; Emergency / freeze scope weak; Docs-vs-chain parity strong",
   "search": "ethena usdtb ethena-usdtb rwa-backed stablecoin usdtb usdtb 0x3b0aaf6e6fcd4a7ceef8c92c32dfea9e64dc1862 0x3c405f68d5c6ece868e5646cac926679839acd68 0x73e35c5c35a274e34ade6eb13cc7f62aee323728 0x9d6d77a21702b9afcf924983fbfb84aaaae79589 0xc139190f447e929f090edeb554d95abb8b18ac1c 0xd93826bb299765c87d13aeba2a7e5d9b27a03956 0xe897d8620d5eba2c8ecaaf0ada191a23230ab8ec 0xe8dc0fab349ea169283c48ccfd09d797e6db7c94",
   "slug": "ethena-usdtb",
   "summary_short": "USDtb PSM is owned by a 24-hour timelock, not the Dev multisig directly",
   "url": "https://pacta.wtf/protocols/ethena-usdtb/"
  },
  {
   "baskets": [
    "eth_lst_lrt"
   ],
   "category": "Liquid Staking & Restaking",
   "chains": [
    "ethereum"
   ],
   "deltas": 0,
   "easAttested": true,
   "evidence": {
    "documented": "Public pre-execution brief https://pacta.wtf/briefs/etherfi-op-0x244e/ (decoded calldata, storage-layout and delegate trace).",
    "observed": "getMinDelay() = 864000s (10d); operation 0x244e3f6c3df722246c471cee58804dd34c7703fce9cee1eadc1c5a85f171359f: isOperationPending() = true, getTimestamp() = 1795193651 (2026-11-20 16:54:11 UTC). The scheduled call EtherfiL1SyncPoolETH (0xD789870beA40D056A4d26055d0bEFcC8755DA146).setDelegate(EtherFiTimelock) puts the LayerZero V2 endpoint delegate behind the 10-day timelock.",
    "recordId": "etherfi-core-timelock-op-0x244e",
    "surface": "Core Upgrade Timelock (10d) — queued LayerZero V2 setDelegate to Timelock"
   },
   "factors": [
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "upgrade",
     "label": "Upgradeability",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "Upgrade path not in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": "etherfi-core-timelocks: … (0xcD425f44758a08BaAB3C4908f3e3dE5776e45d7a) getMinDelay() = 172800s (2 days); LiquidityPool (0x308861A430be4cce5502d0A12724771Fc6DaF216) …",
     "key": "timelock",
     "label": "Timelock floor",
     "state": "g",
     "value": "2d minimum enforced delay across control surfaces"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "quorum",
     "label": "Signer quorum",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No signer quorum in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "emergency",
     "label": "Emergency / freeze scope",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No pause / freeze authority in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "parity",
     "label": "Docs-vs-chain parity",
     "state": "g",
     "value": "Chain matches or is stronger than the documentation"
    }
   ],
   "finding": "Core Upgrade Timelock (10d) — queued LayerZero V2 setDelegate to Timelock: docs say Public pre-execution brief https://pacta.wtf/briefs/etherfi-op-0x244e/ (decoded calldata, storage-layout and delegate trace). · chain says getMinDelay() = 864000s (10d);",
   "grade": "protective",
   "gradeLabel": "PROTECTIVE",
   "name": "ether.fi Core (eETH / weETH)",
   "pinnedBlock": 26405302,
   "probe": {
    "block_hash": "0xe62ad2969617ad07c23bec298c3d5e197ea7c3084f7f66c90d2eb51d04c6273e",
    "block_number": 26401638,
    "call_args": [],
    "call_signature": "getMinDelay()",
    "chain": "ethereum",
    "check_type": "eth_call",
    "extra_calls": [],
    "id": "etherfi-core-timelocks",
    "repro_calldata": "0xf27a0c92",
    "rpc_env_var": "$ETH_RPC_URL",
    "selector_or_slot": "0xf27a0c92",
    "target_contract": "0x9f26d4C958fD811A1F59B01B86Be7dFFc9d20761",
    "target_label": "ether.fi Upgrade Timelock"
   },
   "reconciled": false,
   "reconciledFrom": [],
   "reconciledTo": [],
   "records": 2,
   "rosetteAria": "ether.fi Core (eETH / weETH) control-plane rosette: Upgradeability not determined; Timelock floor strong; Signer quorum not determined; Emergency / freeze scope not determined; Docs-vs-chain parity strong",
   "search": "ether.fi core (eeth / weeth) ether-fi-core-eeth-weeth liquid staking & restaking eeth weeth ethfi 0x308861a430be4cce5502d0a12724771fc6daf216 0x35fa164735182de50811e8e2e824cfb9b6118ac2 0x9f26d4c958fd811a1f59b01b86be7dffc9d20761 0xcd425f44758a08baab3c4908f3e3de5776e45d7a 0xcd5fe23c85820f7b72d0926fc9b05b43e359b7ee 0xd789870bea40d056a4d26055d0befcc8755da146 0xfe0c30065b384f05761f15d0cc899d4f9f9cc0eb",
   "slug": "ether-fi-core-eeth-weeth",
   "summary_short": "10-day upgrade timelock; a queued LayerZero delegate change moves behind it",
   "url": "https://pacta.wtf/protocols/ether-fi-core-eeth-weeth/"
  },
  {
   "baskets": [
    "eth_lst_lrt",
    "lending_vaults"
   ],
   "category": "Curated Restaking Vaults",
   "chains": [
    "ethereum"
   ],
   "deltas": 0,
   "easAttested": true,
   "evidence": {
    "documented": "Sampled BoringVault Accountant authority() and RolesAuthority TimelockController ownership verified at block 26401070.",
    "observed": "AccountantWithRateProviders (0x0d05D94a5F1E76C18fbeB7A13d17C8a314088198) authority() = 0x485Bde66Bb668a51f2372E34e45B1c6226798122; RolesAuthority.owner() = 0xD829F278016b90FEc735F9A12Bf8b75E06102C89 (TimelockController, getMinDelay = 86400s / 1d at block 26401070).",
    "recordId": "etherfi-liquid-veda-roles-authority",
    "surface": "Sampled RolesAuthority Owner & Timelock Wiring"
   },
   "factors": [
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "upgrade",
     "label": "Upgradeability",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "Upgrade path not in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": "controller fact: getMinDelay() = 86400s",
     "key": "timelock",
     "label": "Timelock floor",
     "state": "b",
     "value": "1d minimum enforced delay across control surfaces"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "quorum",
     "label": "Signer quorum",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No signer quorum in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "emergency",
     "label": "Emergency / freeze scope",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No pause / freeze authority in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "parity",
     "label": "Docs-vs-chain parity",
     "state": "g",
     "value": "Chain matches or is stronger than the documentation"
    }
   ],
   "finding": "Sampled RolesAuthority Owner & Timelock Wiring",
   "grade": "aligned",
   "gradeLabel": "ALIGNED",
   "name": "ether.fi Liquid / Veda BoringVault",
   "pinnedBlock": 26401070,
   "probe": {
    "block_hash": "0xcf55f6a42ae610c1f8766b5c2fb676d91f178469fa10ef777eccbb76f6506234",
    "block_number": 26401070,
    "call_args": [],
    "call_signature": "owner()",
    "chain": "ethereum",
    "check_type": "eth_call",
    "extra_calls": [],
    "id": "etherfi-liquid-veda-roles-authority",
    "repro_calldata": "0x8da5cb5b",
    "rpc_env_var": "$ETH_RPC_URL",
    "selector_or_slot": "0x8da5cb5b",
    "target_contract": "0x485Bde66Bb668a51f2372E34e45B1c6226798122",
    "target_label": "Liquid RolesAuthority"
   },
   "reconciled": false,
   "reconciledFrom": [],
   "reconciledTo": [],
   "records": 1,
   "rosetteAria": "ether.fi Liquid / Veda BoringVault control-plane rosette: Upgradeability not determined; Timelock floor moderate; Signer quorum not determined; Emergency / freeze scope not determined; Docs-vs-chain parity strong",
   "search": "ether.fi liquid / veda boringvault ether-fi-liquid-veda-boringvault curated restaking vaults liquid veda boringvault 0x0d05d94a5f1e76c18fbeb7a13d17c8a314088198 0x485bde66bb668a51f2372e34e45b1c6226798122 0xd829f278016b90fec735f9a12bf8b75e06102c89",
   "slug": "ether-fi-liquid-veda-boringvault",
   "summary_short": "RolesAuthority owner and timelock wiring match the docs",
   "url": "https://pacta.wtf/protocols/ether-fi-liquid-veda-boringvault/"
  },
  {
   "baskets": [
    "lending_vaults"
   ],
   "category": "Modular Lending Vault Kit",
   "chains": [
    "ethereum"
   ],
   "deltas": 0,
   "easAttested": true,
   "evidence": {
    "documented": "docs.euler.finance: '`FactoryGovernor` is installed as the `upgradeAdmin` of the EVK factory.' and 'The deployed EVC is immutable'; Euler forum: 'The signer set will be updated to 6 Euler Labs signers and 2 Foundation Directors, with a 4/8 threshold.' The prose docs state no delay; the official evk-periphery deployment script sets EVAULT_FACTORY_TIMELOCK_MIN_DELAY = 4 days.",
    "observed": "GenericFactory (0x29a56a1b8214D9Cf7c5561811750D5cBDb45CC8e).upgradeAdmin() = FactoryGovernor 0x2F13256E04022d6356d8CE8C53C7364e13DC1f3d; its only DEFAULT_ADMIN_ROLE member is TimelockController 0xfb034c1C6c7F42171b2d1Cb8486E0f43ED07A968 (getMinDelay() = 345600s, 4d; PROPOSER_ROLE: 4-of-8 Safe 0xcAD001c30E96765aC90307669d578219D4fb1DCe; EXECUTOR_ROLE open; CANCELLER_ROLE: that Safe and 2-of-3 Safe 0xb3b84e8320250Afe7a5fb313Ee32B52982b73c53). PAUSE_GUARDIAN_ROLE has 3 members (2-of-6 Safe 0xB1345E7A4D35FB3E6bF22A32B3741Ae74E5Fba27, 0xff217004BdD3A6A592162380dc0E6BbF143291eB, 0xcC6451385685721778E7Bd80B54F8c92b484F601); UNPAUSE_ADMIN_ROLE: the 2-of-6 Safe. EthereumVaultConnector (0x0C9a3dd6b8F28529d72d7f9cE918D493519EE383): no EIP-1967 slots; owner() and admin() revert.",
    "recordId": "euler-v2-evk-factorygovernor-4d-timelock-s18",
    "surface": "EVK factory upgradeAdmin = FactoryGovernor behind a 4d TimelockController (DAO 4-of-8 proposes)"
   },
   "factors": [
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "upgrade",
     "label": "Upgradeability",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "Upgrade path not in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": "controller fact: getMinDelay() = 345600s",
     "key": "timelock",
     "label": "Timelock floor",
     "state": "g",
     "value": "4d minimum enforced delay across control surfaces"
    },
    {
     "evidence": "euler-v2-evk-factorygovernor-4d-timelock-s18: … open; CANCELLER_ROLE: that Safe and 2-of-3 Safe 0xb3b84e8320250Afe7a5fb313Ee32B52982b73c53). …",
     "key": "quorum",
     "label": "Signer quorum",
     "state": "b",
     "value": "Lowest controlling quorum: 2-of-3"
    },
    {
     "evidence": "euler-v2-evk-factorygovernor-4d-timelock-s18: its only DEFAULT_ADMIN_ROLE member is TimelockController 0xfb034c1C6c7F42171b2d1Cb8486E0f43ED07A968 (getMinDelay() = 345600s, 4d; PROPOSER_ROLE: 4-of-8 Safe …",
     "key": "emergency",
     "label": "Emergency / freeze scope",
     "state": "g",
     "value": "Pause / freeze authority scoped behind a multi-signer controller (2-of-3)"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "parity",
     "label": "Docs-vs-chain parity",
     "state": "g",
     "value": "Chain matches or is stronger than the documentation"
    }
   ],
   "finding": "EVK factory upgradeAdmin = FactoryGovernor behind a 4d TimelockController (DAO 4-of-8 proposes)",
   "grade": "aligned",
   "gradeLabel": "ALIGNED",
   "name": "Euler V2 (EVK)",
   "pinnedBlock": 26421541,
   "probe": {
    "block_hash": "0xfc2e93c53812cd390b29924a4e217bd4f75d77725bd2882968fb5b087a17150d",
    "block_number": 26421541,
    "call_args": [],
    "call_signature": "upgradeAdmin()",
    "chain": "ethereum",
    "check_type": "eth_call",
    "extra_calls": [],
    "id": "euler-v2-evk-factorygovernor-4d-timelock-s18",
    "repro_calldata": "0xc4d5608a",
    "rpc_env_var": "$ETH_RPC_URL",
    "selector_or_slot": "0xc4d5608a",
    "target_contract": "0x29a56a1b8214D9Cf7c5561811750D5cBDb45CC8e",
    "target_label": "EulerEVaultFactory (GenericFactory)"
   },
   "reconciled": false,
   "reconciledFrom": [],
   "reconciledTo": [],
   "records": 1,
   "rosetteAria": "Euler V2 (EVK) control-plane rosette: Upgradeability not determined; Timelock floor strong; Signer quorum moderate; Emergency / freeze scope strong; Docs-vs-chain parity strong",
   "search": "euler v2 (evk) euler-v2-evk modular lending vault kit eul evk evc 0x0c9a3dd6b8f28529d72d7f9ce918d493519ee383 0x29a56a1b8214d9cf7c5561811750d5cbdb45cc8e 0x2f13256e04022d6356d8ce8c53c7364e13dc1f3d 0xb1345e7a4d35fb3e6bf22a32b3741ae74e5fba27 0xb3b84e8320250afe7a5fb313ee32b52982b73c53 0xcad001c30e96765ac90307669d578219d4fb1dce 0xcc6451385685721778e7bd80b54f8c92b484f601 0xfb034c1c6c7f42171b2d1cb8486e0f43ed07a968 0xff217004bdd3a6a592162380dc0e6bbf143291eb",
   "slug": "euler-v2-evk",
   "summary_short": "Factory upgrades wait 4 days in a timelock (DAO 4-of-8 proposes), as documented",
   "url": "https://pacta.wtf/protocols/euler-v2-evk/"
  },
  {
   "baskets": [
    "lending_vaults",
    "stable_rwa"
   ],
   "category": "Fixed and variable interest rate credit markets (Ethereum)",
   "chains": [
    "ethereum"
   ],
   "deltas": 0,
   "easAttested": true,
   "evidence": {
    "documented": "'The timelock period is 24 hours' (docs.exact.ly/security/access-control.md)",
    "observed": "Exactly Auditor 0x310A2694521f75C7B2b64b5937C16CE65C3EFE01 (Ethereum): EIP-1967 admin slot = ProxyAdmin 0x3866eA62494597A5EDeA4A97f9429f82b9d7Ca34; ProxyAdmin owner() = 0x92024C4bDa9DA602b711B9AbB610d072018eb58b, a TimelockController with getMinDelay() = 86,400 s. The access-control page lists the Auditor among the contracts the TimelockController can upgrade.",
    "recordId": "exactly-auditor-timelock-24h-s30",
    "surface": "Auditor upgrade path: ProxyAdmin owned by a timelock, getMinDelay() 86,400 s"
   },
   "factors": [
    {
     "evidence": "exactly-auditor-timelock-24h-s30: ProxyAdmin owner() = 0x92024C4bDa9DA602b711B9AbB610d072018eb58b, a TimelockController with getMinDelay() = 86,400 s. The access-control page lists the Auditor …",
     "key": "upgrade",
     "label": "Upgradeability",
     "state": "b",
     "value": "Upgradeable behind a 1h–47h delay (1d) (1 other upgrade path not determined)"
    },
    {
     "evidence": "controller fact: getMinDelay() = 86400s",
     "key": "timelock",
     "label": "Timelock floor",
     "state": "b",
     "value": "1d minimum enforced delay across control surfaces"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "quorum",
     "label": "Signer quorum",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No signer quorum in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "emergency",
     "label": "Emergency / freeze scope",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No pause / freeze authority in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "parity",
     "label": "Docs-vs-chain parity",
     "state": "g",
     "value": "Chain matches or is stronger than the documentation"
    }
   ],
   "finding": "Auditor upgrade path: ProxyAdmin owned by a timelock, getMinDelay() 86,400 s",
   "grade": "aligned",
   "gradeLabel": "ALIGNED",
   "name": "Exactly",
   "pinnedBlock": 26449594,
   "probe": {
    "block_hash": "0xbe263d5b378dcb7c3c4e18bd8e388f0cb2dab1adacd83de2be58c9408b377287",
    "block_number": 26449594,
    "call_args": [],
    "call_signature": "getMinDelay()",
    "chain": "ethereum",
    "check_type": "eth_call",
    "extra_calls": [],
    "id": "exactly-auditor-timelock-24h-s30",
    "repro_calldata": "0xf27a0c92",
    "rpc_env_var": "$ETH_RPC_URL",
    "selector_or_slot": "0xf27a0c92",
    "target_contract": "0x92024C4bDa9DA602b711B9AbB610d072018eb58b",
    "target_label": "Exactly TimelockController (owner of the Auditor's ProxyAdmin)"
   },
   "reconciled": false,
   "reconciledFrom": [],
   "reconciledTo": [],
   "records": 1,
   "rosetteAria": "Exactly control-plane rosette: Upgradeability moderate; Timelock floor moderate; Signer quorum not determined; Emergency / freeze scope not determined; Docs-vs-chain parity strong",
   "search": "exactly exactly fixed and variable interest rate credit markets (ethereum) exactly 0x310a2694521f75c7b2b64b5937c16ce65c3efe01 0x3866ea62494597a5edea4a97f9429f82b9d7ca34 0x92024c4bda9da602b711b9abb610d072018eb58b",
   "slug": "exactly",
   "summary_short": "The Auditor's ProxyAdmin is owned by a 24-hour timelock, as documented",
   "url": "https://pacta.wtf/protocols/exactly/"
  },
  {
   "baskets": [
    "base",
    "lending_vaults"
   ],
   "category": "Leveraged Yield & Lending (Base)",
   "chains": [
    "base"
   ],
   "deltas": 0,
   "easAttested": false,
   "evidence": {
    "documented": "Extra Finance (Base) documentation is linked for reference (https://docs.extrafi.io/; governance: https://snapshot.org/#/extrafi.eth). This RPC-pinned record does not compare documentation parameters with the on-chain state.",
    "observed": "ExtraLendingPool_Base (0xBB505c54D71E9e599cB8435b4F0cEEc05fC71cbD) verified on Base Mainnet at canonical block #60,070,202 (20,198 bytes runtime code). EIP-1967 implementation and admin storage slots are both zero (non-EIP-1967 contract). Direct owner() returns governance controller contract 0x5a70429e0e5c7BE9E5F83B497C18F5AC82345113.",
    "recordId": "extra-finance-base-control-plane",
    "surface": "ExtraLendingPool_Base · Non-Proxy Bytecode & Role Architecture"
   },
   "factors": [
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "upgrade",
     "label": "Upgradeability",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "Upgrade path not in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "timelock",
     "label": "Timelock floor",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No enforced admin delay in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "quorum",
     "label": "Signer quorum",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No signer quorum in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "emergency",
     "label": "Emergency / freeze scope",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No pause / freeze authority in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "parity",
     "label": "Docs-vs-chain parity",
     "state": "u",
     "value": "Uncompared: documentation not assessed (RPC-observed)"
    }
   ],
   "finding": "ExtraLendingPool_Base · Non-Proxy Bytecode & Role Architecture",
   "grade": "observed",
   "gradeLabel": "OBSERVED",
   "name": "Extra Finance (Base)",
   "pinnedBlock": 60070202,
   "probe": {
    "block_hash": "0x01b3f5dcecb67c63ba33350ec6942563f6b8a0d8ca9b4f69a752844a5bab4a20",
    "block_number": 60070202,
    "call_args": [],
    "call_signature": "owner()",
    "chain": "base",
    "check_type": "eth_call",
    "extra_calls": [],
    "id": "extra-finance-base-control-plane",
    "repro_calldata": "0x8da5cb5b",
    "rpc_env_var": "$BASE_RPC_URL",
    "selector_or_slot": "0x8da5cb5b",
    "target_contract": "0xBB505c54D71E9e599cB8435b4F0cEEc05fC71cbD",
    "target_label": "ExtraLendingPool_Base"
   },
   "reconciled": false,
   "reconciledFrom": [],
   "reconciledTo": [],
   "records": 1,
   "rosetteAria": "Extra Finance (Base) control-plane rosette: Upgradeability not determined; Timelock floor not determined; Signer quorum not determined; Emergency / freeze scope not determined; Docs-vs-chain parity uncompared",
   "search": "extra finance (base) extra-finance-base leveraged yield & lending (base) extra 0x5a70429e0e5c7be9e5f83b497c18f5ac82345113 0xbb505c54d71e9e599cb8435b4f0ceec05fc71cbd",
   "slug": "extra-finance-base",
   "summary_short": "Non-proxy lending pool with role-based admin; docs not assessed",
   "url": "https://pacta.wtf/protocols/extra-finance-base/"
  },
  {
   "baskets": [
    "stable_rwa"
   ],
   "category": "Leveraged ETH / Stablecoin",
   "chains": [
    "ethereum"
   ],
   "deltas": 2,
   "easAttested": true,
   "evidence": {
    "documented": "LongPoolManager (0x250893CA4Ba5d05626C785e8da758026928FCD24) and v2 governance docs scope EmergencySafe strictly to EMERGENCY_ROLE behind 3-day Timelock admin.",
    "observed": "DEFAULT_ADMIN_ROLE (0x00) on all 4 v2 ProtocolTreasury proxies (0x32356FE312Eba9B7D6A157ad28D1ca91b571CdA6, 0xb178197E88D58Da21bE22A408E850d1e6Dc09A38, 0x6D9e81c5b7C4b37d0Fe9E8CDA776e057f4040868, 0x87d5e4cAaF4358A4337C10859c7107c7AEF4f8Ce) held directly by OpsSafe (0x26B2ec4E02ebe2F54583af25b647b1D619e67BbF, 6-of-9 Safe) and EmergencySafe (0x28c921adAC4c1072658eB01a28DA06b5F651eF62, 3-of-4 Safe), while Timelock (0x68863fb8855b04509a835082478D6E3D0bE4E61a, getMinDelay = 259200s) holds false.",
    "recordId": "fx-protocol-v2-treasury-admin",
    "surface": "ProtocolTreasury DEFAULT_ADMIN_ROLE Holders"
   },
   "factors": [
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "upgrade",
     "label": "Upgradeability",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "Upgrade path not in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": "f-x-protocol-v2-router-owner-safe-s29: observed_delay_seconds = 0",
     "key": "timelock",
     "label": "Timelock floor",
     "state": "a",
     "value": "0s minimum enforced delay across control surfaces"
    },
    {
     "evidence": "fx-protocol-v2-treasury-admin: … (0x28c921adAC4c1072658eB01a28DA06b5F651eF62, 3-of-4 Safe), while Timelock (0x68863fb8855b04509a835082478D6E3D0bE4E61a, …",
     "key": "quorum",
     "label": "Signer quorum",
     "state": "g",
     "value": "Lowest controlling quorum: 3-of-4"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "emergency",
     "label": "Emergency / freeze scope",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No pause / freeze authority in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "parity",
     "label": "Docs-vs-chain parity",
     "state": "a",
     "value": "Documentation differs from the chain (parameter delta)"
    }
   ],
   "finding": "ProtocolTreasury DEFAULT_ADMIN_ROLE Holders: docs say LongPoolManager (0x250893CA4Ba5d05626C785e8da758026928FCD24) and v2 governance docs scope EmergencySafe strictly to EMERGENCY_ROLE behind 3-day Timelock admin. · chain says DEFAULT_ADMIN_ROLE (0x00) on all 4 v2 ProtocolTreasury proxies (0x32356FE312Eba9B7D6A157ad28D1ca91b571CdA6, 0xb178197E88D58Da21bE22A408E850d1e6Dc09A38, 0x6D9e81c5b7C4b37d0Fe9E8CDA776e057f4040868, 0x87d5e4cAaF4358A4337C1…",
   "grade": "delta",
   "gradeLabel": "DELTA",
   "name": "f(x) Protocol v2",
   "pinnedBlock": 26448221,
   "probe": {
    "block_hash": "0xa9a61622304ec55c5fec49abbcabec60069f66f28792cf841bdd7aef12ce63aa",
    "block_number": 26400152,
    "call_args": [
     "0x0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000",
     "0x26B2ec4E02ebe2F54583af25b647b1D619e67BbF"
    ],
    "call_signature": "hasRole(bytes32,address)",
    "chain": "ethereum",
    "check_type": "eth_call",
    "extra_calls": [],
    "id": "fx-protocol-v2-treasury-admin",
    "repro_calldata": "0x91d14854000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000026b2ec4e02ebe2f54583af25b647b1d619e67bbf",
    "rpc_env_var": "$ETH_RPC_URL",
    "selector_or_slot": "0x91d14854",
    "target_contract": "0x32356FE312Eba9B7D6A157ad28D1ca91b571CdA6",
    "target_label": "ProtocolTreasury (wstETH)"
   },
   "reconciled": false,
   "reconciledFrom": [],
   "reconciledTo": [],
   "records": 2,
   "rosetteAria": "f(x) Protocol v2 control-plane rosette: Upgradeability not determined; Timelock floor weak; Signer quorum strong; Emergency / freeze scope not determined; Docs-vs-chain parity weak",
   "search": "f(x) protocol v2 f-x-protocol-v2 leveraged eth / stablecoin fxusd fxn 0x221ffb180ad01213ff882ab7de9c75e23f9efa63 0x250893ca4ba5d05626c785e8da758026928fcd24 0x26b2ec4e02ebe2f54583af25b647b1d619e67bbf 0x28c921adac4c1072658eb01a28da06b5f651ef62 0x32356fe312eba9b7d6a157ad28d1ca91b571cda6 0x33636d49fbefbe798e15e7f356e8dbef543cc708 0x68863fb8855b04509a835082478d6e3d0be4e61a 0x6d9e81c5b7c4b37d0fe9e8cda776e057f4040868 0x87d5e4caaf4358a4337c10859c7107c7aef4f8ce 0xb178197e88d58da21be22a408e850d1e6dc09a38",
   "slug": "f-x-protocol-v2",
   "summary_short": "Docs set a 3-day timelock on every transaction; the V2 Router's owner is a 6-of-9 Safe",
   "url": "https://pacta.wtf/protocols/f-x-protocol-v2/"
  },
  {
   "baskets": [
    "lending_vaults"
   ],
   "category": "Randomized NFT marketplace with ETH-backed listings (Ethereum)",
   "chains": [
    "ethereum"
   ],
   "deltas": 0,
   "easAttested": false,
   "evidence": {
    "documented": "Fake World Assets V2 documentation is linked for reference (https://www.fwa.fun/). This RPC-pinned record does not compare documentation parameters with the on-chain state.",
    "observed": "Fake World Assets (FWAToken) (0xa0Df17B5aC76ABaBA36E1450E2cbCd18A620C845) verified on Ethereum Mainnet at canonical block #26,458,556 (11,394 bytes runtime code). EIP-1967 implementation and admin storage slots are both zero (non-EIP-1967 contract). Direct owner() returns externally owned account (no code) 0x019817aD02a31B990433542097bE29D97613E8Cb.",
    "recordId": "fake-world-assets-v2-control-plane",
    "surface": "Fake World Assets (FWAToken) · Non-Proxy Bytecode & Controller"
   },
   "factors": [
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "upgrade",
     "label": "Upgradeability",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "Upgrade path not in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "timelock",
     "label": "Timelock floor",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No enforced admin delay in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": "fake-world-assets-v2-control-plane: … (non-EIP-1967 contract). Direct owner() returns externally owned account (no code) 0x019817aD02a31B990433542097bE29D97613E8Cb.",
     "key": "quorum",
     "label": "Signer quorum",
     "state": "a",
     "value": "Lowest controlling quorum: a single key"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "emergency",
     "label": "Emergency / freeze scope",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No pause / freeze authority in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "parity",
     "label": "Docs-vs-chain parity",
     "state": "u",
     "value": "Uncompared: documentation not assessed (RPC-observed)"
    }
   ],
   "finding": "Fake World Assets (FWAToken) · Non-Proxy Bytecode & Controller",
   "grade": "observed",
   "gradeLabel": "OBSERVED",
   "name": "Fake World Assets V2",
   "pinnedBlock": 26458556,
   "probe": {
    "block_hash": "0xe258bb1cbcc988e2dfdba4ba173f9f8690520dba3647cdcae18e0651822769d2",
    "block_number": 26458556,
    "call_args": [],
    "call_signature": "owner()",
    "chain": "ethereum",
    "check_type": "eth_call",
    "extra_calls": [],
    "id": "fake-world-assets-v2-control-plane",
    "repro_calldata": "0x8da5cb5b",
    "rpc_env_var": "$ETH_RPC_URL",
    "selector_or_slot": "0x8da5cb5b",
    "target_contract": "0xa0Df17B5aC76ABaBA36E1450E2cbCd18A620C845",
    "target_label": "Fake World Assets (FWAToken)"
   },
   "reconciled": false,
   "reconciledFrom": [],
   "reconciledTo": [],
   "records": 1,
   "rosetteAria": "Fake World Assets V2 control-plane rosette: Upgradeability not determined; Timelock floor not determined; Signer quorum weak; Emergency / freeze scope not determined; Docs-vs-chain parity uncompared",
   "search": "fake world assets v2 fake-world-assets-v2 randomized nft marketplace with eth-backed listings (ethereum) fwa 0x019817ad02a31b990433542097be29d97613e8cb 0xa0df17b5ac76ababa36e1450e2cbcd18a620c845",
   "slug": "fake-world-assets-v2",
   "summary_short": "Non-proxy contract controlled by a single key (EOA); docs not assessed",
   "url": "https://pacta.wtf/protocols/fake-world-assets-v2/"
  },
  {
   "baskets": [
    "stable_rwa"
   ],
   "category": "Synthetic Dollar",
   "chains": [
    "ethereum"
   ],
   "deltas": 0,
   "easAttested": true,
   "evidence": {
    "documented": "docs.falcon.finance/mechanism/redemptions/: 'This is not to be confused with unstaking, where users can unstake their sUSDf and receive USDf in return immediately.'",
    "observed": "sUSDf (0xc8CF6D7991f15525488b2A83Df53468D682Ba4B0).cooldownDuration() = 0; asset() = USDf (0xFa2B947eEc368f42195f24F36d2aF29f7c24CeC2); totalSupply() = 33,273,012.15 sUSDf (USDf 1,516,215,860.42). Context, not compared with documentation: USDf and sUSDf are EIP-1967 proxies whose admins (0x3Ef1127Fdf81B553066daE0FaEA58785A2AA6E14, 0x16a2605C026BFe4f4B7f4471933714D9b2149AcE) both return owner() = 4-of-6 Safe 0x1E482B60bf19Cb1cc859389e0eA3DED153f16Bd7.",
    "recordId": "falcon-susdf-zero-cooldown-instant-unstake-s17",
    "surface": "sUSDf cooldownDuration() = 0 — instant unstaking to USDf"
   },
   "factors": [
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "upgrade",
     "label": "Upgradeability",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "Upgrade path not in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "timelock",
     "label": "Timelock floor",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No enforced admin delay in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": "falcon-susdf-zero-cooldown-instant-unstake-s17: … 0x16a2605C026BFe4f4B7f4471933714D9b2149AcE) both return owner() = 4-of-6 Safe 0x1E482B60bf19Cb1cc859389e0eA3DED153f16Bd7.",
     "key": "quorum",
     "label": "Signer quorum",
     "state": "g",
     "value": "Lowest controlling quorum: 4-of-6"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "emergency",
     "label": "Emergency / freeze scope",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No pause / freeze authority in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "parity",
     "label": "Docs-vs-chain parity",
     "state": "g",
     "value": "Chain matches or is stronger than the documentation"
    }
   ],
   "finding": "sUSDf cooldownDuration() = 0 — instant unstaking to USDf",
   "grade": "aligned",
   "gradeLabel": "ALIGNED",
   "name": "Falcon Finance (USDf / sUSDf)",
   "pinnedBlock": 26418060,
   "probe": {
    "block_hash": "0x8914f5134a4488a812b61c1c7f479c3082d80f6fbe2f181abb9e5ef4ff973f3c",
    "block_number": 26418060,
    "call_args": [],
    "call_signature": "cooldownDuration()",
    "chain": "ethereum",
    "check_type": "eth_call",
    "extra_calls": [],
    "id": "falcon-susdf-zero-cooldown-instant-unstake-s17",
    "repro_calldata": "0x35269315",
    "rpc_env_var": "$ETH_RPC_URL",
    "selector_or_slot": "0x35269315",
    "target_contract": "0xc8CF6D7991f15525488b2A83Df53468D682Ba4B0",
    "target_label": "Falcon sUSDf vault"
   },
   "reconciled": false,
   "reconciledFrom": [],
   "reconciledTo": [],
   "records": 1,
   "rosetteAria": "Falcon Finance (USDf / sUSDf) control-plane rosette: Upgradeability not determined; Timelock floor not determined; Signer quorum strong; Emergency / freeze scope not determined; Docs-vs-chain parity strong",
   "search": "falcon finance (usdf / susdf) falcon-finance-usdf-susdf synthetic dollar usdf susdf 0x16a2605c026bfe4f4b7f4471933714d9b2149ace 0x1e482b60bf19cb1cc859389e0ea3ded153f16bd7 0x3ef1127fdf81b553066dae0faea58785a2aa6e14 0xc8cf6d7991f15525488b2a83df53468d682ba4b0 0xfa2b947eec368f42195f24f36d2af29f7c24cec2",
   "slug": "falcon-finance-usdf-susdf",
   "summary_short": "sUSDf cooldown is zero, so unstaking to USDf is instant, as documented",
   "url": "https://pacta.wtf/protocols/falcon-finance-usdf-susdf/"
  },
  {
   "baskets": [
    "lending_vaults"
   ],
   "category": "Proprietary automated market maker on Ethereum (Ethereum)",
   "chains": [
    "ethereum"
   ],
   "deltas": 0,
   "easAttested": false,
   "evidence": {
    "documented": "FermiSwap documentation is linked for reference (). This RPC-pinned record does not compare documentation parameters with the on-chain state.",
    "observed": "FermiSwapper (0xb1076fE3AB5e28005C7c323Bac5AC06a680d452e) verified on Ethereum Mainnet at canonical block #26,458,556 (10,182 bytes runtime code). EIP-1967 implementation and admin storage slots are both zero (non-EIP-1967 contract). No owner(), admin(), authority(), curator() or AccessControl admin was readable on the contract.",
    "recordId": "fermiswap-control-plane",
    "surface": "FermiSwapper · Non-Proxy Bytecode & Controller"
   },
   "factors": [
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "upgrade",
     "label": "Upgradeability",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "Upgrade path not in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "timelock",
     "label": "Timelock floor",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No enforced admin delay in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "quorum",
     "label": "Signer quorum",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No signer quorum in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "emergency",
     "label": "Emergency / freeze scope",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No pause / freeze authority in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "parity",
     "label": "Docs-vs-chain parity",
     "state": "u",
     "value": "Uncompared: documentation not assessed (RPC-observed)"
    }
   ],
   "finding": "FermiSwapper · Non-Proxy Bytecode & Controller",
   "grade": "observed",
   "gradeLabel": "OBSERVED",
   "name": "FermiSwap",
   "pinnedBlock": 26458556,
   "probe": {
    "block_hash": "0xe258bb1cbcc988e2dfdba4ba173f9f8690520dba3647cdcae18e0651822769d2",
    "block_number": 26458556,
    "call_args": [],
    "call_signature": "owner()",
    "chain": "ethereum",
    "check_type": "eth_call",
    "extra_calls": [],
    "id": "fermiswap-control-plane",
    "repro_calldata": "0x8da5cb5b",
    "rpc_env_var": "$ETH_RPC_URL",
    "selector_or_slot": "0x8da5cb5b",
    "target_contract": "0xb1076fE3AB5e28005C7c323Bac5AC06a680d452e",
    "target_label": "FermiSwapper"
   },
   "reconciled": false,
   "reconciledFrom": [],
   "reconciledTo": [],
   "records": 1,
   "rosetteAria": "FermiSwap control-plane rosette: Upgradeability not determined; Timelock floor not determined; Signer quorum not determined; Emergency / freeze scope not determined; Docs-vs-chain parity uncompared",
   "search": "fermiswap fermiswap proprietary automated market maker on ethereum (ethereum) fermiswap 0xb1076fe3ab5e28005c7c323bac5ac06a680d452e",
   "slug": "fermiswap",
   "summary_short": "Non-proxy contract no readable owner or admin; docs not assessed",
   "url": "https://pacta.wtf/protocols/fermiswap/"
  },
  {
   "baskets": [],
   "category": "Meme-token launchpad routing trading fees to creators and buybacks (Base)",
   "chains": [
    "ethereum"
   ],
   "deltas": 0,
   "easAttested": true,
   "evidence": {
    "documented": "'a two day timelock will follow before the proposed code is executed' (docs.flaunch.gg/community/governance/proposals-and-voting.md)",
    "observed": "flaunch TimelockController 0x6c4c0CD7E0E5eeFfbd77AAfe1820d3b9B1ef27b0 (Ethereum): getMinDelay() = 172800s (2 d).",
    "recordId": "flaunch-timelock-delay-s29",
    "surface": "flaunch timelock: 2-day minimum delay, as documented"
   },
   "factors": [
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "upgrade",
     "label": "Upgradeability",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "Upgrade path not in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": "controller fact: getMinDelay() = 172800s",
     "key": "timelock",
     "label": "Timelock floor",
     "state": "g",
     "value": "2d minimum enforced delay across control surfaces"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "quorum",
     "label": "Signer quorum",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No signer quorum in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "emergency",
     "label": "Emergency / freeze scope",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No pause / freeze authority in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "parity",
     "label": "Docs-vs-chain parity",
     "state": "g",
     "value": "Chain matches or is stronger than the documentation"
    }
   ],
   "finding": "flaunch timelock: 2-day minimum delay, as documented",
   "grade": "aligned",
   "gradeLabel": "ALIGNED",
   "name": "flaunch",
   "pinnedBlock": 26448221,
   "probe": {
    "block_hash": "0xa7818c0e1b8807aac0c999c2dc9aeeea40b91b4f19b1b76a62ad02d8d17607c8",
    "block_number": 26448221,
    "call_args": [],
    "call_signature": "getMinDelay()",
    "chain": "ethereum",
    "check_type": "eth_call",
    "extra_calls": [],
    "id": "flaunch-timelock-delay-s29",
    "repro_calldata": "0xf27a0c92",
    "rpc_env_var": "$ETH_RPC_URL",
    "selector_or_slot": "0xf27a0c92",
    "target_contract": "0x6c4c0CD7E0E5eeFfbd77AAfe1820d3b9B1ef27b0",
    "target_label": "flaunch TimelockController"
   },
   "reconciled": false,
   "reconciledFrom": [],
   "reconciledTo": [],
   "records": 1,
   "rosetteAria": "flaunch control-plane rosette: Upgradeability not determined; Timelock floor strong; Signer quorum not determined; Emergency / freeze scope not determined; Docs-vs-chain parity strong",
   "search": "flaunch flaunch meme-token launchpad routing trading fees to creators and buybacks (base) fleth 0x6c4c0cd7e0e5eeffbd77aafe1820d3b9b1ef27b0",
   "slug": "flaunch",
   "summary_short": "flaunch changes wait a 2-day timelock, as documented",
   "url": "https://pacta.wtf/protocols/flaunch/"
  },
  {
   "baskets": [],
   "category": "Staked collateral securing instant merchant payment settlement networks (Ethereum)",
   "chains": [
    "ethereum"
   ],
   "deltas": 0,
   "easAttested": false,
   "evidence": {
    "documented": "Flexa documentation is linked for reference (https://docs.amp.xyz/). This RPC-pinned record does not compare documentation parameters with the on-chain state.",
    "observed": "Amp (0xfF20817765cB7f73d4bde2e66e067E58D11095C2) verified on Ethereum Mainnet at canonical block #26,458,556 (13,920 bytes runtime code). EIP-1967 implementation and admin storage slots are both zero (non-EIP-1967 contract). Direct owner() returns contract contract 0x533a36b5e56C1f0361a53d4395F4F0c5f1AD63f8.",
    "recordId": "flexa-control-plane",
    "surface": "Amp · Non-Proxy Bytecode & Controller"
   },
   "factors": [
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "upgrade",
     "label": "Upgradeability",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "Upgrade path not in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "timelock",
     "label": "Timelock floor",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No enforced admin delay in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "quorum",
     "label": "Signer quorum",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No signer quorum in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "emergency",
     "label": "Emergency / freeze scope",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No pause / freeze authority in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "parity",
     "label": "Docs-vs-chain parity",
     "state": "u",
     "value": "Uncompared: documentation not assessed (RPC-observed)"
    }
   ],
   "finding": "Amp · Non-Proxy Bytecode & Controller",
   "grade": "observed",
   "gradeLabel": "OBSERVED",
   "name": "Flexa",
   "pinnedBlock": 26458556,
   "probe": {
    "block_hash": "0xe258bb1cbcc988e2dfdba4ba173f9f8690520dba3647cdcae18e0651822769d2",
    "block_number": 26458556,
    "call_args": [],
    "call_signature": "owner()",
    "chain": "ethereum",
    "check_type": "eth_call",
    "extra_calls": [],
    "id": "flexa-control-plane",
    "repro_calldata": "0x8da5cb5b",
    "rpc_env_var": "$ETH_RPC_URL",
    "selector_or_slot": "0x8da5cb5b",
    "target_contract": "0xfF20817765cB7f73d4bde2e66e067E58D11095C2",
    "target_label": "Amp"
   },
   "reconciled": false,
   "reconciledFrom": [],
   "reconciledTo": [],
   "records": 1,
   "rosetteAria": "Flexa control-plane rosette: Upgradeability not determined; Timelock floor not determined; Signer quorum not determined; Emergency / freeze scope not determined; Docs-vs-chain parity uncompared",
   "search": "flexa flexa staked collateral securing instant merchant payment settlement networks (ethereum) amp 0x533a36b5e56c1f0361a53d4395f4f0c5f1ad63f8 0xff20817765cb7f73d4bde2e66e067e58d11095c2",
   "slug": "flexa",
   "summary_short": "Non-proxy contract controlled by a contract; docs not assessed",
   "url": "https://pacta.wtf/protocols/flexa/"
  },
  {
   "baskets": [],
   "category": "Time-locks for LP tokens, NFTs and fungible tokens (Ethereum)",
   "chains": [
    "ethereum"
   ],
   "deltas": 0,
   "easAttested": false,
   "evidence": {
    "documented": "FlokiFi Locker documentation is linked for reference (https://docs.flokifi.com/). This RPC-pinned record does not compare documentation parameters with the on-chain state.",
    "observed": "FLOKI (0xcf0C122c6b73ff809C693DB761e7BaeBe62b6a2E) verified on Ethereum Mainnet at canonical block #26,458,556 (8,007 bytes runtime code). EIP-1967 implementation and admin storage slots are both zero (non-EIP-1967 contract). Direct owner() returns externally owned account (no code) 0x000000000000000000000000000000000000dEaD.",
    "recordId": "flokifi-locker-control-plane",
    "surface": "FLOKI · Non-Proxy Bytecode & Controller"
   },
   "factors": [
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "upgrade",
     "label": "Upgradeability",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "Upgrade path not in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "timelock",
     "label": "Timelock floor",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No enforced admin delay in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": "flokifi-locker-control-plane: … (non-EIP-1967 contract). Direct owner() returns externally owned account (no code) 0x000000000000000000000000000000000000dEaD.",
     "key": "quorum",
     "label": "Signer quorum",
     "state": "a",
     "value": "Lowest controlling quorum: a single key"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "emergency",
     "label": "Emergency / freeze scope",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No pause / freeze authority in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "parity",
     "label": "Docs-vs-chain parity",
     "state": "u",
     "value": "Uncompared: documentation not assessed (RPC-observed)"
    }
   ],
   "finding": "FLOKI · Non-Proxy Bytecode & Controller",
   "grade": "observed",
   "gradeLabel": "OBSERVED",
   "name": "FlokiFi Locker",
   "pinnedBlock": 26458556,
   "probe": {
    "block_hash": "0xe258bb1cbcc988e2dfdba4ba173f9f8690520dba3647cdcae18e0651822769d2",
    "block_number": 26458556,
    "call_args": [],
    "call_signature": "owner()",
    "chain": "ethereum",
    "check_type": "eth_call",
    "extra_calls": [],
    "id": "flokifi-locker-control-plane",
    "repro_calldata": "0x8da5cb5b",
    "rpc_env_var": "$ETH_RPC_URL",
    "selector_or_slot": "0x8da5cb5b",
    "target_contract": "0xcf0C122c6b73ff809C693DB761e7BaeBe62b6a2E",
    "target_label": "FLOKI"
   },
   "reconciled": false,
   "reconciledFrom": [],
   "reconciledTo": [],
   "records": 1,
   "rosetteAria": "FlokiFi Locker control-plane rosette: Upgradeability not determined; Timelock floor not determined; Signer quorum weak; Emergency / freeze scope not determined; Docs-vs-chain parity uncompared",
   "search": "flokifi locker flokifi-locker time-locks for lp tokens, nfts and fungible tokens (ethereum) floki 0x000000000000000000000000000000000000dead 0xcf0c122c6b73ff809c693db761e7baebe62b6a2e",
   "slug": "flokifi-locker",
   "summary_short": "Non-proxy contract controlled by a single key (EOA); docs not assessed",
   "url": "https://pacta.wtf/protocols/flokifi-locker/"
  },
  {
   "baskets": [
    "lending_vaults"
   ],
   "category": "Modular Lending & DEX Vaults",
   "chains": [
    "ethereum"
   ],
   "deltas": 1,
   "easAttested": true,
   "evidence": {
    "documented": "fluid-permissions-and-mutability.md describes narrow fee/reward/magnifier team multisig scope outside migration grants.",
    "observed": "isVaultAuth(vault, 0x4F6F977aCDD1177DCD81aB83074855EcB9C2D49e) returns true on Vault 76 (0x7FE0B032cB5982Af72498F96be3DD6566F7B7de8), Vault 110 (0xee327311D8640156E87eC33ea55FcbF2309e0ce6), Vault 111 (0x984636a30ed2B4A61FB7150CED644096349275d3), and Vault 144 (0x0e19B64F3A79FeeE12Df1b6f239929c6ab6C7ED0) per IGP-98 / IGP-126 migration configuration.",
    "recordId": "fluid-instadapp-vault-factory-auth",
    "surface": "VaultFactory.isVaultAuth Migration Scope"
   },
   "factors": [
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "upgrade",
     "label": "Upgradeability",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "Upgrade path not in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "timelock",
     "label": "Timelock floor",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No enforced admin delay in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "quorum",
     "label": "Signer quorum",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No signer quorum in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "emergency",
     "label": "Emergency / freeze scope",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No pause / freeze authority in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "parity",
     "label": "Docs-vs-chain parity",
     "state": "a",
     "value": "Documentation differs from the chain (parameter delta)"
    }
   ],
   "finding": "VaultFactory.isVaultAuth Migration Scope: docs say fluid-permissions-and-mutability.md describes narrow fee/reward/magnifier team multisig scope outside migration grants. · chain says isVaultAuth(vault, 0x4F6F977aCDD1177DCD81aB83074855EcB9C2D49e) returns true on Vault 76 (0x7FE0B032cB5982Af72498F96be3DD6566F7B7de8), Vault 110 (0xee327311D8640156E87eC33ea55FcbF2309e0ce6), Vault 111 (0x984636a30ed2B4A6…",
   "grade": "delta",
   "gradeLabel": "DELTA",
   "name": "Fluid / Instadapp",
   "pinnedBlock": 26401405,
   "probe": {
    "block_hash": "0x26e155e1569d436406a52ecee31c94d8d8ef2ca4c45d82211a84c8c802be1510",
    "block_number": 26401405,
    "call_args": [
     "0x7FE0B032cB5982Af72498F96be3DD6566F7B7de8",
     "0x4F6F977aCDD1177DCD81aB83074855EcB9C2D49e"
    ],
    "call_signature": "isVaultAuth(address,address)",
    "chain": "ethereum",
    "check_type": "eth_call",
    "extra_calls": [],
    "id": "fluid-instadapp-vault-factory-auth",
    "repro_calldata": "0xe04c8e5d0000000000000000000000007fe0b032cb5982af72498f96be3dd6566f7b7de80000000000000000000000004f6f977acdd1177dcd81ab83074855ecb9c2d49e",
    "rpc_env_var": "$ETH_RPC_URL",
    "selector_or_slot": "0xe04c8e5d",
    "target_contract": "0x324c5Dc1fC42c7a4D43d92df1eBA58a54d13Bf2d",
    "target_label": "VaultFactory"
   },
   "reconciled": false,
   "reconciledFrom": [],
   "reconciledTo": [],
   "records": 1,
   "rosetteAria": "Fluid / Instadapp control-plane rosette: Upgradeability not determined; Timelock floor not determined; Signer quorum not determined; Emergency / freeze scope not determined; Docs-vs-chain parity weak",
   "search": "fluid / instadapp fluid-instadapp modular lending & dex vaults fluid inst 0x0e19b64f3a79feee12df1b6f239929c6ab6c7ed0 0x324c5dc1fc42c7a4d43d92df1eba58a54d13bf2d 0x4f6f977acdd1177dcd81ab83074855ecb9c2d49e 0x7fe0b032cb5982af72498f96be3dd6566f7b7de8 0x984636a30ed2b4a61fb7150ced644096349275d3 0xee327311d8640156e87ec33ea55fcbf2309e0ce6",
   "slug": "fluid-instadapp",
   "summary_short": "Migration auth is live on four vaults, beyond the documented multisig scope",
   "url": "https://pacta.wtf/protocols/fluid-instadapp/"
  },
  {
   "baskets": [
    "lending_vaults"
   ],
   "category": "Custom lending market on Sonic and Ethereum (Ethereum)",
   "chains": [
    "ethereum"
   ],
   "deltas": 0,
   "easAttested": true,
   "evidence": {
    "documented": "'| `0x1118e1c057211306a40A4d7006C040dbfE1370Cb` |  3/5      | Msig, treasury   | PutManager, Marketplace  |' (docs.flyingtulip.com/llms.txt)",
    "observed": "Flying Tulip treasury Safe 0x1118e1c057211306a40A4d7006C040dbfE1370Cb (Ethereum): getThreshold() = 3 of 5 owners. It is owner() of the FT token 0x5DD1A7A369e8273371d2DBf9d83356057088082c.",
    "recordId": "flying-tulip-treasury-safe-3of5-s30",
    "surface": "Treasury Safe (FT owner): 3-of-5"
   },
   "factors": [
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "upgrade",
     "label": "Upgradeability",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "Upgrade path not in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "timelock",
     "label": "Timelock floor",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No enforced admin delay in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": "controller fact: Safe getThreshold()",
     "key": "quorum",
     "label": "Signer quorum",
     "state": "g",
     "value": "Lowest controlling quorum: 3-of-5"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "emergency",
     "label": "Emergency / freeze scope",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No pause / freeze authority in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "parity",
     "label": "Docs-vs-chain parity",
     "state": "g",
     "value": "Chain matches or is stronger than the documentation"
    }
   ],
   "finding": "Treasury Safe (FT owner): 3-of-5",
   "grade": "aligned",
   "gradeLabel": "ALIGNED",
   "name": "Flying Tulip Lend",
   "pinnedBlock": 26449594,
   "probe": {
    "block_hash": "0xbe263d5b378dcb7c3c4e18bd8e388f0cb2dab1adacd83de2be58c9408b377287",
    "block_number": 26449594,
    "call_args": [],
    "call_signature": "getThreshold()",
    "chain": "ethereum",
    "check_type": "eth_call",
    "extra_calls": [],
    "id": "flying-tulip-treasury-safe-3of5-s30",
    "repro_calldata": "0xe75235b8",
    "rpc_env_var": "$ETH_RPC_URL",
    "selector_or_slot": "0xe75235b8",
    "target_contract": "0x1118e1c057211306a40A4d7006C040dbfE1370Cb",
    "target_label": "Flying Tulip treasury Safe"
   },
   "reconciled": false,
   "reconciledFrom": [],
   "reconciledTo": [],
   "records": 1,
   "rosetteAria": "Flying Tulip Lend control-plane rosette: Upgradeability not determined; Timelock floor not determined; Signer quorum strong; Emergency / freeze scope not determined; Docs-vs-chain parity strong",
   "search": "flying tulip lend flying-tulip-lend custom lending market on sonic and ethereum (ethereum) ft 0x1118e1c057211306a40a4d7006c040dbfe1370cb 0x5dd1a7a369e8273371d2dbf9d83356057088082c",
   "slug": "flying-tulip-lend",
   "summary_short": "Flying Tulip's treasury Safe, owner of the FT token, is 3-of-5 as documented",
   "url": "https://pacta.wtf/protocols/flying-tulip-lend/"
  },
  {
   "baskets": [
    "stable_rwa"
   ],
   "category": "Oracle-Free Swiss Franc Stablecoin CDP (Ethereum)",
   "chains": [
    "ethereum"
   ],
   "deltas": 0,
   "easAttested": false,
   "evidence": {
    "documented": "Frankencoin documentation is linked for reference (https://docs.frankencoin.com/). This RPC-pinned record does not compare documentation parameters with the on-chain state.",
    "observed": "Frankencoin Shares (FCS) (0xDb861830D9Ae2d1fCF99fA0cfd3973de382B0B5b) verified on Ethereum Mainnet at canonical block #26,458,556 (11,451 bytes runtime code). EIP-1967 implementation and admin storage slots are both zero (non-EIP-1967 contract). No owner(), admin(), authority(), curator() or AccessControl admin was readable on the contract.",
    "recordId": "frankencoin-control-plane",
    "surface": "Frankencoin Shares (FCS) · Non-Proxy Bytecode & Controller"
   },
   "factors": [
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "upgrade",
     "label": "Upgradeability",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "Upgrade path not in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "timelock",
     "label": "Timelock floor",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No enforced admin delay in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "quorum",
     "label": "Signer quorum",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No signer quorum in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "emergency",
     "label": "Emergency / freeze scope",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No pause / freeze authority in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "parity",
     "label": "Docs-vs-chain parity",
     "state": "u",
     "value": "Uncompared: documentation not assessed (RPC-observed)"
    }
   ],
   "finding": "Frankencoin Shares (FCS) · Non-Proxy Bytecode & Controller",
   "grade": "observed",
   "gradeLabel": "OBSERVED",
   "name": "Frankencoin",
   "pinnedBlock": 26458556,
   "probe": {
    "block_hash": "0xe258bb1cbcc988e2dfdba4ba173f9f8690520dba3647cdcae18e0651822769d2",
    "block_number": 26458556,
    "call_args": [],
    "call_signature": "owner()",
    "chain": "ethereum",
    "check_type": "eth_call",
    "extra_calls": [],
    "id": "frankencoin-control-plane",
    "repro_calldata": "0x8da5cb5b",
    "rpc_env_var": "$ETH_RPC_URL",
    "selector_or_slot": "0x8da5cb5b",
    "target_contract": "0xDb861830D9Ae2d1fCF99fA0cfd3973de382B0B5b",
    "target_label": "Frankencoin Shares (FCS)"
   },
   "reconciled": false,
   "reconciledFrom": [],
   "reconciledTo": [],
   "records": 1,
   "rosetteAria": "Frankencoin control-plane rosette: Upgradeability not determined; Timelock floor not determined; Signer quorum not determined; Emergency / freeze scope not determined; Docs-vs-chain parity uncompared",
   "search": "frankencoin frankencoin oracle-free swiss franc stablecoin cdp (ethereum) fcs 0xdb861830d9ae2d1fcf99fa0cfd3973de382b0b5b",
   "slug": "frankencoin",
   "summary_short": "Non-proxy contract no readable owner or admin; docs not assessed",
   "url": "https://pacta.wtf/protocols/frankencoin/"
  },
  {
   "baskets": [
    "eth_lst_lrt"
   ],
   "category": "Liquid Staking & Monetary Infrastructure",
   "chains": [
    "ethereum"
   ],
   "deltas": 0,
   "easAttested": true,
   "evidence": {
    "documented": "docs.frax.com (frxETH addresses): 'Multisigs / Chain / Name / Contract / Ethereum / Comptroller / 0x8306300ffd616049FD7e4b0354a64Da835c1A81C'",
    "observed": "frxETHMinter 0xbAFA44EFE7901E04E39Dad13167D089C559c1138: owner() = Comptroller 0x8306300ffd616049FD7e4b0354a64Da835c1A81C (4-of-7 Safe), nominatedOwner() = 0; not upgradeable.",
    "recordId": "frax-ether-comptroller-owns-frxethminter-s20",
    "surface": "frxETHMinter owner: the documented Comptroller"
   },
   "factors": [
    {
     "evidence": "frax-ether-upgrade-timelock-24h-s20: owner of ProxyAdmin 0x223a681fc5c5522c85C96157c0efA18cd6c5405c, the EIP-1967 admin of both Ethereum lockboxes.",
     "key": "upgrade",
     "label": "Upgradeability",
     "state": "b",
     "value": "Upgradeable behind a 1h–47h delay (1d)"
    },
    {
     "evidence": "frax-ether-upgrade-timelock-24h-s20: observed_delay_seconds = 86400",
     "key": "timelock",
     "label": "Timelock floor",
     "state": "b",
     "value": "1d minimum enforced delay across control surfaces"
    },
    {
     "evidence": "controller fact: Safe getThreshold()",
     "key": "quorum",
     "label": "Signer quorum",
     "state": "g",
     "value": "Lowest controlling quorum: 3-of-5"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "emergency",
     "label": "Emergency / freeze scope",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No pause / freeze authority in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "parity",
     "label": "Docs-vs-chain parity",
     "state": "g",
     "value": "Chain matches or is stronger than the documentation"
    }
   ],
   "finding": "frxETHMinter owner: the documented Comptroller",
   "grade": "aligned",
   "gradeLabel": "ALIGNED",
   "name": "Frax Ether (frxETH / sfrxETH)",
   "pinnedBlock": 26425374,
   "probe": {
    "block_hash": "0xfa22e277760f1df7134b0af20499d6305ee4e017219a917a61a78aa76e89382d",
    "block_number": 26425374,
    "call_args": [],
    "call_signature": "owner()",
    "chain": "ethereum",
    "check_type": "eth_call",
    "extra_calls": [],
    "id": "frax-ether-comptroller-owns-frxethminter-s20",
    "repro_calldata": "0x8da5cb5b",
    "rpc_env_var": "$ETH_RPC_URL",
    "selector_or_slot": "0x8da5cb5b",
    "target_contract": "0xbAFA44EFE7901E04E39Dad13167D089C559c1138",
    "target_label": "frxETHMinter"
   },
   "reconciled": false,
   "reconciledFrom": [],
   "reconciledTo": [],
   "records": 3,
   "rosetteAria": "Frax Ether (frxETH / sfrxETH) control-plane rosette: Upgradeability moderate; Timelock floor moderate; Signer quorum strong; Emergency / freeze scope not determined; Docs-vs-chain parity strong",
   "search": "frax ether (frxeth / sfrxeth) frax-ether-sfrxeth liquid staking & monetary infrastructure frxeth sfrxeth fxs 0x1c1649a38f4a3c5a0c4a24070f688c525ab7d6e6 0x223a681fc5c5522c85c96157c0efa18cd6c5405c 0x8306300ffd616049fd7e4b0354a64da835c1a81c 0xb1748c79709f4ba2dd82834b8c82d4a505003f27 0xb898ad2976b4d8f2e21521c9db16b7497825e503 0xbafa44efe7901e04e39dad13167d089c559c1138 0xbbc424e58ed38dd911309611ae2d7a23014bd960 0xffffff4f3bac444b2c0ecf2a1840d018be783937",
   "slug": "frax-ether-sfrxeth",
   "summary_short": "frxETHMinter owner is the documented Comptroller",
   "url": "https://pacta.wtf/protocols/frax-ether-sfrxeth/"
  },
  {
   "baskets": [
    "lending_vaults",
    "stable_rwa"
   ],
   "category": "Fiat-Redeemable Stablecoin (frxUSD) & Yield Vault",
   "chains": [
    "ethereum"
   ],
   "deltas": 0,
   "easAttested": true,
   "evidence": {
    "documented": "docs.frax.com (frxUSD): 'The Frax DAO retains ownership and ultimate control of the protocol and may amend or revoke delegated authority at any time.' / addresses: 'frxUSD Chain type Address Ethereum Native 0xCAcd6fd266aF91b8AeD52aCCc382b4e165586E29'",
    "observed": "frxUSD 0xCAcd6fd266aF91b8AeD52aCCc382b4e165586E29: EIP-1967 admin = ProxyAdmin 0x0b2C3dF006b2bd43cBCC60075e7a0bf314474eD6, owner() = Timelock 0xb898Ad2976b4d8f2E21521C9db16b7497825E503 (Sourcify exact match): delay() = 86400s (1 day), admin() = Safe 0xfFFffF4F3baC444b2C0ecf2A1840d018bE783937 (4-of-7, v1.3.0); frxUSD owner() is the same Safe directly.",
    "recordId": "frax-usd-frxusd-admin-upgrades-1d-timelock-s23",
    "surface": "frxUSD upgrades: ProxyAdmin owned by a 1-day timelock run by the 4-of-7 Frax Safe"
   },
   "factors": [
    {
     "evidence": "frax-usd-sfrxusd-proxyadmin-safe-3of5-s23: sfrxUSD 0xcf62F905562626CfcDD2261162a51fd02Fc9c5b6: EIP-1967 admin = ProxyAdmin 0xeA0a6EC8114a0Af6Cf74Ca0036Ab31d892Df13cB, owner() = Safe …",
     "key": "upgrade",
     "label": "Upgradeability",
     "state": "a",
     "value": "Upgradeable with no enforced delay: no timelock in front of upgrades"
    },
    {
     "evidence": "frax-usd-sfrxusd-proxyadmin-safe-3of5-s23: sfrxUSD 0xcf62F905562626CfcDD2261162a51fd02Fc9c5b6: EIP-1967 admin = ProxyAdmin 0xeA0a6EC8114a0Af6Cf74Ca0036Ab31d892Df13cB, owner() = Safe …",
     "key": "timelock",
     "label": "Timelock floor",
     "state": "a",
     "value": "0s minimum enforced delay across control surfaces"
    },
    {
     "evidence": "frax-usd-sfrxusd-proxyadmin-safe-3of5-s23: … 0xB1748C79709f4Ba2Dd82834B8c82D4a505003f27 (3-of-5, v1.3.0; no timelock); timelockAddress() …",
     "key": "quorum",
     "label": "Signer quorum",
     "state": "g",
     "value": "Lowest controlling quorum: 3-of-5"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "emergency",
     "label": "Emergency / freeze scope",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No pause / freeze authority in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "parity",
     "label": "Docs-vs-chain parity",
     "state": "g",
     "value": "Chain matches or is stronger than the documentation"
    }
   ],
   "finding": "frxUSD upgrades: ProxyAdmin owned by a 1-day timelock run by the 4-of-7 Frax Safe",
   "grade": "aligned",
   "gradeLabel": "ALIGNED",
   "name": "Frax USD (frxUSD)",
   "pinnedBlock": 26431152,
   "probe": {
    "block_hash": "0xfe2ed4e127f30bb42dd30c6fc1460a82d8438cff3a717ec89210805e55199a46",
    "block_number": 26431152,
    "call_args": [],
    "call_signature": null,
    "chain": "ethereum",
    "check_type": "eth_getStorageAt",
    "extra_calls": [],
    "id": "frax-usd-frxusd-admin-upgrades-1d-timelock-s23",
    "repro_calldata": null,
    "rpc_env_var": "$ETH_RPC_URL",
    "selector_or_slot": "0xb53127684a568b3173ae13b9f8a6016e243e63b6e8ee1178d6a717850b5d6103",
    "target_contract": "0xCAcd6fd266aF91b8AeD52aCCc382b4e165586E29",
    "target_label": "frxUSD (TransparentUpgradeableProxy)"
   },
   "reconciled": false,
   "reconciledFrom": [],
   "reconciledTo": [],
   "records": 3,
   "rosetteAria": "Frax USD (frxUSD) control-plane rosette: Upgradeability weak; Timelock floor weak; Signer quorum strong; Emergency / freeze scope not determined; Docs-vs-chain parity strong",
   "search": "frax usd (frxusd) frax-usd-frxusd fiat-redeemable stablecoin (frxusd) & yield vault frxusd sfrxusd 0x0b2c3df006b2bd43cbcc60075e7a0bf314474ed6 0x4b45d73b83686e69d08e61105fdb7f7b51f41bc1 0x831822660572bd54ebaa065c2acef662a6277d40 0xb1748c79709f4ba2dd82834b8c82d4a505003f27 0xb898ad2976b4d8f2e21521c9db16b7497825e503 0xcacd6fd266af91b8aed52accc382b4e165586e29 0xcf62f905562626cfcdd2261162a51fd02fc9c5b6 0xea0a6ec8114a0af6cf74ca0036ab31d892df13cb 0xffffff4f3bac444b2c0ecf2a1840d018be783937",
   "slug": "frax-usd-frxusd",
   "summary_short": "Upgrades go through a 1-day timelock run by the 4-of-7 Frax Safe",
   "url": "https://pacta.wtf/protocols/frax-usd-frxusd/"
  },
  {
   "baskets": [
    "base"
   ],
   "category": "Creator shares priced on a bonding curve for social trading and chat access (Base)",
   "chains": [
    "base"
   ],
   "deltas": 0,
   "easAttested": false,
   "evidence": {
    "documented": "friend.tech V1 documentation is linked for reference (https://www.friend.tech/keys). This RPC-pinned record does not compare documentation parameters with the on-chain state.",
    "observed": "FRIEND (Points) (0x0bD4887f7D41B35CD75DFF9FfeE2856106f86670) verified on Base Mainnet at canonical block #60,070,202 (6,037 bytes runtime code). EIP-1967 implementation and admin storage slots are both zero (non-EIP-1967 contract). No owner(), admin(), authority(), curator() or AccessControl admin was readable on the contract.",
    "recordId": "friend-tech-v1-control-plane",
    "surface": "FRIEND (Points) · Non-Proxy Bytecode & Controller"
   },
   "factors": [
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "upgrade",
     "label": "Upgradeability",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "Upgrade path not in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "timelock",
     "label": "Timelock floor",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No enforced admin delay in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "quorum",
     "label": "Signer quorum",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No signer quorum in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "emergency",
     "label": "Emergency / freeze scope",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No pause / freeze authority in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "parity",
     "label": "Docs-vs-chain parity",
     "state": "u",
     "value": "Uncompared: documentation not assessed (RPC-observed)"
    }
   ],
   "finding": "FRIEND (Points) · Non-Proxy Bytecode & Controller",
   "grade": "observed",
   "gradeLabel": "OBSERVED",
   "name": "friend.tech V1",
   "pinnedBlock": 60070202,
   "probe": {
    "block_hash": "0x01b3f5dcecb67c63ba33350ec6942563f6b8a0d8ca9b4f69a752844a5bab4a20",
    "block_number": 60070202,
    "call_args": [],
    "call_signature": "owner()",
    "chain": "base",
    "check_type": "eth_call",
    "extra_calls": [],
    "id": "friend-tech-v1-control-plane",
    "repro_calldata": "0x8da5cb5b",
    "rpc_env_var": "$BASE_RPC_URL",
    "selector_or_slot": "0x8da5cb5b",
    "target_contract": "0x0bD4887f7D41B35CD75DFF9FfeE2856106f86670",
    "target_label": "FRIEND (Points)"
   },
   "reconciled": false,
   "reconciledFrom": [],
   "reconciledTo": [],
   "records": 1,
   "rosetteAria": "friend.tech V1 control-plane rosette: Upgradeability not determined; Timelock floor not determined; Signer quorum not determined; Emergency / freeze scope not determined; Docs-vs-chain parity uncompared",
   "search": "friend.tech v1 friend-tech-v1 creator shares priced on a bonding curve for social trading and chat access (base) friend 0x0bd4887f7d41b35cd75dff9ffee2856106f86670",
   "slug": "friend-tech-v1",
   "summary_short": "Non-proxy contract no readable owner or admin; docs not assessed",
   "url": "https://pacta.wtf/protocols/friend-tech-v1/"
  },
  {
   "baskets": [
    "lending_vaults"
   ],
   "category": "Automated rebalancing of concentrated-liquidity positions and market-making strategies for partners (Ethereum)",
   "chains": [
    "ethereum"
   ],
   "deltas": 0,
   "easAttested": true,
   "evidence": {
    "documented": "'Total Supply 100,000,000' (docs.gamma.xyz/gamma/learn/tokenomics.md)",
    "observed": "GAMMA token 0x6BeA7CFEF803D1e3d5f7C0103f7ded065644e197 (Ethereum; not a proxy: EIP-1967 implementation, admin and beacon slots all empty; verified source): totalSupply() = 100,000,000. The runtime code holds no selector of mint(address,uint256), mint(uint256), upgradeTo(address), upgradeToAndCall(address,bytes). The whole supply is minted in its constructor; the owner can only take snapshots and transfer ownership.",
    "recordId": "gamma-token-supply-100m-s34",
    "surface": "GAMMA supply: 100,000,000, no mint function"
   },
   "factors": [
    {
     "evidence": "gamma-token-supply-100m-s34: GAMMA token 0x6BeA7CFEF803D1e3d5f7C0103f7ded065644e197 (Ethereum; not a proxy: EIP-1967 implementation, admin and beacon slots all empty; verified source) …",
     "key": "upgrade",
     "label": "Upgradeability",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "Upgradeable; the delay gating the upgrade path is not in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "timelock",
     "label": "Timelock floor",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No enforced admin delay in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "quorum",
     "label": "Signer quorum",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No signer quorum in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "emergency",
     "label": "Emergency / freeze scope",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No pause / freeze authority in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "parity",
     "label": "Docs-vs-chain parity",
     "state": "g",
     "value": "Chain matches or is stronger than the documentation"
    }
   ],
   "finding": "GAMMA supply: 100,000,000, no mint function",
   "grade": "aligned",
   "gradeLabel": "ALIGNED",
   "name": "Gamma",
   "pinnedBlock": 26453551,
   "probe": {
    "block_hash": "0x51e9967ffd6a84012d0dad44204d523b8ac43928e69de2801d2e72dbf8767129",
    "block_number": 26453551,
    "call_args": [],
    "call_signature": "totalSupply()",
    "chain": "ethereum",
    "check_type": "eth_call",
    "extra_calls": [],
    "id": "gamma-token-supply-100m-s34",
    "repro_calldata": "0x18160ddd",
    "rpc_env_var": "$ETH_RPC_URL",
    "selector_or_slot": "0x18160ddd",
    "target_contract": "0x6BeA7CFEF803D1e3d5f7C0103f7ded065644e197",
    "target_label": "GAMMA token"
   },
   "reconciled": false,
   "reconciledFrom": [],
   "reconciledTo": [],
   "records": 1,
   "rosetteAria": "Gamma control-plane rosette: Upgradeability not determined; Timelock floor not determined; Signer quorum not determined; Emergency / freeze scope not determined; Docs-vs-chain parity strong",
   "search": "gamma gamma automated rebalancing of concentrated-liquidity positions and market-making strategies for partners (ethereum) gamma 0x6bea7cfef803d1e3d5f7c0103f7ded065644e197",
   "slug": "gamma",
   "summary_short": "GAMMA's supply is 100M with no mint function, as documented",
   "url": "https://pacta.wtf/protocols/gamma/"
  },
  {
   "baskets": [
    "lending_vaults",
    "stable_rwa"
   ],
   "category": "Leveraged Credit & Curated Lending",
   "chains": [
    "ethereum"
   ],
   "deltas": 1,
   "easAttested": true,
   "evidence": {
    "documented": "docs.gearbox.finance states technical changes are 'behind a 2-day timelock' (172800s) and lists InstanceManager multisig as '4-of-12 (Subject to chain-specific configuration)'.",
    "observed": "LegacyTimelock (0xa133C9A92Fb8dDB962Af1cbae58b2723A0bdf23b) delay() = 129600s (36 hours, GIP-104), admin() = LegacyGovernor (0x29B97F37B3E0C704bCFD785F5b7bBa2A0B7df2c7); InstanceManager (0x77777777144339Bdc3aCceE992D8d4D31734CB2e) owner() = 4-of-21 Gnosis Safe (0x1E9ec044853611F4bCD4BBcFE7657508BD1c53D3); Tech (0xA7D5DDc1b8557914F158076b228AA91eF613f1D5, 6-of-12), Veto (0xbb803559B4D58b75E12dd74641AB955e8B0Df40E, 4-of-12), Treasury (0x7b065Fcb0760dF0CEA8CFd144e08554F3CeA73D1, 5-of-10), and Fee (0x3E965117A51186e41c2BB58b729A1e518A715e5F, 5-of-10) Guard Safes match documented thresholds.",
    "recordId": "gearbox-v3-legacy-timelock-and-instance-safe",
    "surface": "LegacyTimelock Delay & InstanceManager Safe Quorum"
   },
   "factors": [
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "upgrade",
     "label": "Upgradeability",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "Upgrade path not in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": "gearbox-v3-legacy-timelock-and-instance-safe: observed_delay_seconds = 129600",
     "key": "timelock",
     "label": "Timelock floor",
     "state": "b",
     "value": "1d 12h minimum enforced delay across control surfaces"
    },
    {
     "evidence": "gearbox-v3-legacy-timelock-and-instance-safe: … (0xbb803559B4D58b75E12dd74641AB955e8B0Df40E, 4-of-12), Treasury (0x7b065Fcb0760dF0CEA8CFd144e08554F3CeA73D1, …",
     "key": "quorum",
     "label": "Signer quorum",
     "state": "g",
     "value": "Lowest controlling quorum: 4-of-12"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "emergency",
     "label": "Emergency / freeze scope",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No pause / freeze authority in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "parity",
     "label": "Docs-vs-chain parity",
     "state": "a",
     "value": "Documentation differs from the chain (parameter delta)"
    }
   ],
   "finding": "Timelock delay: docs say 2 d · chain says 36 h",
   "grade": "delta",
   "gradeLabel": "DELTA",
   "name": "Gearbox V3 / V3.1",
   "pinnedBlock": 26403523,
   "probe": {
    "block_hash": "0xfc7beaa2338e8054577c0b101b641bc42afca2af39cb85d3fc13cbee32d4681a",
    "block_number": 26403523,
    "call_args": [],
    "call_signature": "delay()",
    "chain": "ethereum",
    "check_type": "eth_call",
    "extra_calls": [],
    "id": "gearbox-v3-legacy-timelock-and-instance-safe",
    "repro_calldata": "0x6a42b8f8",
    "rpc_env_var": "$ETH_RPC_URL",
    "selector_or_slot": "0x6a42b8f8",
    "target_contract": "0xa133C9A92Fb8dDB962Af1cbae58b2723A0bdf23b",
    "target_label": "Gearbox LegacyTimelock"
   },
   "reconciled": false,
   "reconciledFrom": [],
   "reconciledTo": [],
   "records": 1,
   "rosetteAria": "Gearbox V3 / V3.1 control-plane rosette: Upgradeability not determined; Timelock floor moderate; Signer quorum strong; Emergency / freeze scope not determined; Docs-vs-chain parity weak",
   "search": "gearbox v3 / v3.1 gearbox-v3-v3-1 leveraged credit & curated lending gear 0x1e9ec044853611f4bcd4bbcfe7657508bd1c53d3 0x29b97f37b3e0c704bcfd785f5b7bba2a0b7df2c7 0x3e965117a51186e41c2bb58b729a1e518a715e5f 0x77777777144339bdc3accee992d8d4d31734cb2e 0x7b065fcb0760df0cea8cfd144e08554f3cea73d1 0xa133c9a92fb8ddb962af1cbae58b2723a0bdf23b 0xa7d5ddc1b8557914f158076b228aa91ef613f1d5 0xbb803559b4d58b75e12dd74641ab955e8b0df40e",
   "slug": "gearbox-v3-v3-1",
   "summary_short": "Timelock delay: docs 2 days · chain 36 hours",
   "url": "https://pacta.wtf/protocols/gearbox-v3-v3-1/"
  },
  {
   "baskets": [
    "eth_lst_lrt"
   ],
   "category": "Wallet-issued liquid staking receipt for ether deposits (Ethereum)",
   "chains": [
    "ethereum"
   ],
   "deltas": 0,
   "easAttested": false,
   "evidence": {
    "documented": "GETH documentation is linked for reference (https://guarda.com/academy/blockchain/dencun-ethereum-upgrade-exploring-eip-4844/). This RPC-pinned record does not compare documentation parameters with the on-chain state.",
    "observed": "Guarded Ether (StakeToken) (0x3802c218221390025BCEABBaD5D8C59F40eB74B8) verified on Ethereum Mainnet at canonical block #26,458,556 (5,764 bytes runtime code). EIP-1967 implementation and admin storage slots are both zero (non-EIP-1967 contract). No owner(), admin(), authority(), curator() or AccessControl admin was readable on the contract.",
    "recordId": "geth-control-plane",
    "surface": "Guarded Ether (StakeToken) · Non-Proxy Bytecode & Controller"
   },
   "factors": [
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "upgrade",
     "label": "Upgradeability",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "Upgrade path not in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "timelock",
     "label": "Timelock floor",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No enforced admin delay in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "quorum",
     "label": "Signer quorum",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No signer quorum in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "emergency",
     "label": "Emergency / freeze scope",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No pause / freeze authority in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "parity",
     "label": "Docs-vs-chain parity",
     "state": "u",
     "value": "Uncompared: documentation not assessed (RPC-observed)"
    }
   ],
   "finding": "Guarded Ether (StakeToken) · Non-Proxy Bytecode & Controller",
   "grade": "observed",
   "gradeLabel": "OBSERVED",
   "name": "GETH",
   "pinnedBlock": 26458556,
   "probe": {
    "block_hash": "0xe258bb1cbcc988e2dfdba4ba173f9f8690520dba3647cdcae18e0651822769d2",
    "block_number": 26458556,
    "call_args": [],
    "call_signature": "owner()",
    "chain": "ethereum",
    "check_type": "eth_call",
    "extra_calls": [],
    "id": "geth-control-plane",
    "repro_calldata": "0x8da5cb5b",
    "rpc_env_var": "$ETH_RPC_URL",
    "selector_or_slot": "0x8da5cb5b",
    "target_contract": "0x3802c218221390025BCEABBaD5D8C59F40eB74B8",
    "target_label": "Guarded Ether (StakeToken)"
   },
   "reconciled": false,
   "reconciledFrom": [],
   "reconciledTo": [],
   "records": 1,
   "rosetteAria": "GETH control-plane rosette: Upgradeability not determined; Timelock floor not determined; Signer quorum not determined; Emergency / freeze scope not determined; Docs-vs-chain parity uncompared",
   "search": "geth geth wallet-issued liquid staking receipt for ether deposits (ethereum) geth 0x3802c218221390025bceabbad5d8c59f40eb74b8",
   "slug": "geth",
   "summary_short": "Non-proxy contract no readable owner or admin; docs not assessed",
   "url": "https://pacta.wtf/protocols/geth/"
  },
  {
   "baskets": [
    "base",
    "eth_lst_lrt",
    "lending_vaults"
   ],
   "category": "Liquid staking pools lending to DePIN hardware providers (Base)",
   "chains": [
    "base"
   ],
   "deltas": 0,
   "easAttested": false,
   "evidence": {
    "documented": "GLIF documentation is linked for reference (https://docs.glif.io/en/developer-resources/deployed-contracts). This RPC-pinned record does not compare documentation parameters with the on-chain state.",
    "observed": "Staked ICNT (PoolV2) (0xAeD7C2eD7Bb84396AfCB55fF72c8F8E87FFb68f3) verified on Base Mainnet at canonical block #60,070,202 (141 bytes runtime code). EIP-1967 proxy: implementation 0x530a0cDd4E5f24A5BE77587146A05056c35edcEb, admin slot zero. Direct owner() returns Safe 3-of-6 0x5CC0FC29C893Bba884D3E073997C97Bf776dA9F3.",
    "recordId": "glif-control-plane",
    "surface": "Staked ICNT (PoolV2) · EIP-1967 Proxy & Controller Chain"
   },
   "factors": [
    {
     "evidence": "glif-control-plane: is_eip1967_proxy = true",
     "key": "upgrade",
     "label": "Upgradeability",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "Upgradeable; the delay gating the upgrade path is not in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "timelock",
     "label": "Timelock floor",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No enforced admin delay in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": "glif-control-plane: … slot zero. Direct owner() returns Safe 3-of-6 0x5CC0FC29C893Bba884D3E073997C97Bf776dA9F3.",
     "key": "quorum",
     "label": "Signer quorum",
     "state": "g",
     "value": "Lowest controlling quorum: 3-of-6"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "emergency",
     "label": "Emergency / freeze scope",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No pause / freeze authority in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "parity",
     "label": "Docs-vs-chain parity",
     "state": "u",
     "value": "Uncompared: documentation not assessed (RPC-observed)"
    }
   ],
   "finding": "Staked ICNT (PoolV2) · EIP-1967 Proxy & Controller Chain",
   "grade": "observed",
   "gradeLabel": "OBSERVED",
   "name": "GLIF",
   "pinnedBlock": 60070202,
   "probe": {
    "block_hash": "0x01b3f5dcecb67c63ba33350ec6942563f6b8a0d8ca9b4f69a752844a5bab4a20",
    "block_number": 60070202,
    "call_args": [],
    "call_signature": "owner()",
    "chain": "base",
    "check_type": "eth_call",
    "extra_calls": [],
    "id": "glif-control-plane",
    "repro_calldata": "0x8da5cb5b",
    "rpc_env_var": "$BASE_RPC_URL",
    "selector_or_slot": "0x8da5cb5b",
    "target_contract": "0xAeD7C2eD7Bb84396AfCB55fF72c8F8E87FFb68f3",
    "target_label": "Staked ICNT (PoolV2)"
   },
   "reconciled": false,
   "reconciledFrom": [],
   "reconciledTo": [],
   "records": 1,
   "rosetteAria": "GLIF control-plane rosette: Upgradeability not determined; Timelock floor not determined; Signer quorum strong; Emergency / freeze scope not determined; Docs-vs-chain parity uncompared",
   "search": "glif glif liquid staking pools lending to depin hardware providers (base) sticnt 0x530a0cdd4e5f24a5be77587146a05056c35edceb 0x5cc0fc29c893bba884d3e073997c97bf776da9f3 0xaed7c2ed7bb84396afcb55ff72c8f8e87ffb68f3",
   "slug": "glif",
   "summary_short": "Upgradeable proxy controlled by a 3-of-6 Safe; docs not assessed",
   "url": "https://pacta.wtf/protocols/glif/"
  },
  {
   "baskets": [
    "stable_rwa"
   ],
   "category": "Undercollateralized real-world credit pools for off-chain borrowers (Ethereum)",
   "chains": [
    "ethereum"
   ],
   "deltas": 1,
   "easAttested": true,
   "evidence": {
    "documented": "'The Goldfinch Council is a 6-of-10 multisig with 10 members who represent all stakeholders of the protocol' (docs.goldfinch.finance/goldfinch/goldfinch-v1/governance.md)",
    "observed": "Goldfinch Safe 0xBEb28978B2c755155f20fd3d09Cb37e300A6981f (Ethereum): getThreshold() = 6 of getOwners() = 12 owners (Safe v1.1.1).",
    "recordId": "goldfinch-safe-threshold-s30",
    "surface": "Goldfinch multisig: docs state 6-of-10, the Safe is 6-of-12"
   },
   "factors": [
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "upgrade",
     "label": "Upgradeability",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "Upgrade path not in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "timelock",
     "label": "Timelock floor",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No enforced admin delay in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": "controller fact: Safe getThreshold()",
     "key": "quorum",
     "label": "Signer quorum",
     "state": "g",
     "value": "Lowest controlling quorum: 6-of-12"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "emergency",
     "label": "Emergency / freeze scope",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No pause / freeze authority in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "parity",
     "label": "Docs-vs-chain parity",
     "state": "a",
     "value": "Documentation differs from the chain (parameter delta)"
    }
   ],
   "finding": "Goldfinch multisig: docs state 6-of-10, the Safe is 6-of-12: docs say 'The Goldfinch Council is a 6-of-10 multisig with 10 members who represent all stakeholders of the protocol' (docs.goldfinch.finance/goldfinch/goldfinch-v1/governance.md) · chain says Goldfinch Safe 0xBEb28978B2c755155f20fd3d09Cb37e300A6981f (Ethereum): getThreshold() = 6 of getOwners() = 12 owners (Safe v1.1.1).",
   "grade": "delta",
   "gradeLabel": "DELTA",
   "name": "Goldfinch",
   "pinnedBlock": 26449594,
   "probe": {
    "block_hash": "0xbe263d5b378dcb7c3c4e18bd8e388f0cb2dab1adacd83de2be58c9408b377287",
    "block_number": 26449594,
    "call_args": [],
    "call_signature": "getThreshold()",
    "chain": "ethereum",
    "check_type": "eth_call",
    "extra_calls": [],
    "id": "goldfinch-safe-threshold-s30",
    "repro_calldata": "0xe75235b8",
    "rpc_env_var": "$ETH_RPC_URL",
    "selector_or_slot": "0xe75235b8",
    "target_contract": "0xBEb28978B2c755155f20fd3d09Cb37e300A6981f",
    "target_label": "Goldfinch Council multisig (governance signers of the protocol)"
   },
   "reconciled": false,
   "reconciledFrom": [],
   "reconciledTo": [],
   "records": 1,
   "rosetteAria": "Goldfinch control-plane rosette: Upgradeability not determined; Timelock floor not determined; Signer quorum strong; Emergency / freeze scope not determined; Docs-vs-chain parity weak",
   "search": "goldfinch goldfinch undercollateralized real-world credit pools for off-chain borrowers (ethereum) gfi 0xbeb28978b2c755155f20fd3d09cb37e300a6981f",
   "slug": "goldfinch",
   "summary_short": "Docs state a 6-of-10 multisig; the Goldfinch Safe is 6-of-12",
   "url": "https://pacta.wtf/protocols/goldfinch/"
  },
  {
   "baskets": [],
   "category": "Peer-to-peer NFT-collateral loans with refinancing (Ethereum)",
   "chains": [
    "ethereum"
   ],
   "deltas": 0,
   "easAttested": false,
   "evidence": {
    "documented": "Gondi V3 documentation is linked for reference (https://docs.gondi.xyz/). This RPC-pinned record does not compare documentation parameters with the on-chain state.",
    "observed": "GONDI_MULTI_SOURCE_LOAN (MultiSourceLoan) (0xf65B99CE6DC5F6c556172BCC0Ff27D3665a7d9A8) verified on Ethereum Mainnet at canonical block #26,458,556 (24,576 bytes runtime code). EIP-1967 implementation and admin storage slots are both zero (non-EIP-1967 contract). Direct owner() returns externally owned account (no code) 0xE9c9Ef882f534a21d74b084845348044d03aca85.",
    "recordId": "gondi-v3-control-plane",
    "surface": "GONDI_MULTI_SOURCE_LOAN (MultiSourceLoan) · Non-Proxy Bytecode & Controller"
   },
   "factors": [
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "upgrade",
     "label": "Upgradeability",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "Upgrade path not in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "timelock",
     "label": "Timelock floor",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No enforced admin delay in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": "gondi-v3-control-plane: … (non-EIP-1967 contract). Direct owner() returns externally owned account (no code) 0xE9c9Ef882f534a21d74b084845348044d03aca85.",
     "key": "quorum",
     "label": "Signer quorum",
     "state": "a",
     "value": "Lowest controlling quorum: a single key"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "emergency",
     "label": "Emergency / freeze scope",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No pause / freeze authority in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "parity",
     "label": "Docs-vs-chain parity",
     "state": "u",
     "value": "Uncompared: documentation not assessed (RPC-observed)"
    }
   ],
   "finding": "GONDI_MULTI_SOURCE_LOAN (MultiSourceLoan) · Non-Proxy Bytecode & Controller",
   "grade": "observed",
   "gradeLabel": "OBSERVED",
   "name": "Gondi V3",
   "pinnedBlock": 26458556,
   "probe": {
    "block_hash": "0xe258bb1cbcc988e2dfdba4ba173f9f8690520dba3647cdcae18e0651822769d2",
    "block_number": 26458556,
    "call_args": [],
    "call_signature": "owner()",
    "chain": "ethereum",
    "check_type": "eth_call",
    "extra_calls": [],
    "id": "gondi-v3-control-plane",
    "repro_calldata": "0x8da5cb5b",
    "rpc_env_var": "$ETH_RPC_URL",
    "selector_or_slot": "0x8da5cb5b",
    "target_contract": "0xf65B99CE6DC5F6c556172BCC0Ff27D3665a7d9A8",
    "target_label": "GONDI_MULTI_SOURCE_LOAN (MultiSourceLoan)"
   },
   "reconciled": false,
   "reconciledFrom": [],
   "reconciledTo": [],
   "records": 1,
   "rosetteAria": "Gondi V3 control-plane rosette: Upgradeability not determined; Timelock floor not determined; Signer quorum weak; Emergency / freeze scope not determined; Docs-vs-chain parity uncompared",
   "search": "gondi v3 gondi-v3 peer-to-peer nft-collateral loans with refinancing (ethereum) gondi 0xe9c9ef882f534a21d74b084845348044d03aca85 0xf65b99ce6dc5f6c556172bcc0ff27d3665a7d9a8",
   "slug": "gondi-v3",
   "summary_short": "Non-proxy contract controlled by a single key (EOA); docs not assessed",
   "url": "https://pacta.wtf/protocols/gondi-v3/"
  },
  {
   "baskets": [],
   "category": "Ethereum gateway into a parallel-EVM Layer 1 with a native protocol-level oracle (Ethereum)",
   "chains": [
    "ethereum"
   ],
   "deltas": 0,
   "easAttested": true,
   "evidence": {
    "documented": "'**Administration.** Each contract is owned by a 3-of-6 Safe multisig (`0xeF936B0CaaAdfb439dd24F14411949694aB3C507` on Gravity L1, `0xbD6e434dB90FD8AD4E28d85C133AD34cA6fbfB6D` on Ethereum).' (docs.gravity.xyz/llms-full.txt)",
    "observed": "Gravity by Galxe Bridge Safe 0xbD6e434dB90FD8AD4E28d85C133AD34cA6fbfB6D (Ethereum): getThreshold() = 3 of getOwners() = 6 owners (Safe v1.3.0).",
    "recordId": "gravity-by-galxe-bridge-safe-threshold-s27",
    "surface": "Gravity by Galxe Bridge multisig: 3-of-6 Safe, as documented"
   },
   "factors": [
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "upgrade",
     "label": "Upgradeability",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "Upgrade path not in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "timelock",
     "label": "Timelock floor",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No enforced admin delay in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": "controller fact: Safe getThreshold()",
     "key": "quorum",
     "label": "Signer quorum",
     "state": "g",
     "value": "Lowest controlling quorum: 3-of-6"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "emergency",
     "label": "Emergency / freeze scope",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No pause / freeze authority in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "parity",
     "label": "Docs-vs-chain parity",
     "state": "g",
     "value": "Chain matches or is stronger than the documentation"
    }
   ],
   "finding": "Gravity by Galxe Bridge multisig: 3-of-6 Safe, as documented",
   "grade": "aligned",
   "gradeLabel": "ALIGNED",
   "name": "Gravity by Galxe Bridge",
   "pinnedBlock": 26440048,
   "probe": {
    "block_hash": "0x2c6e70ac6ce978ce5c457208ea6d953e60e92ebf2151578f46cbdd070baa54c6",
    "block_number": 26440048,
    "call_args": [],
    "call_signature": "getThreshold()",
    "chain": "ethereum",
    "check_type": "eth_call",
    "extra_calls": [],
    "id": "gravity-by-galxe-bridge-safe-threshold-s27",
    "repro_calldata": "0xe75235b8",
    "rpc_env_var": "$ETH_RPC_URL",
    "selector_or_slot": "0xe75235b8",
    "target_contract": "0xbD6e434dB90FD8AD4E28d85C133AD34cA6fbfB6D",
    "target_label": "Gravity by Galxe Bridge Safe"
   },
   "reconciled": false,
   "reconciledFrom": [],
   "reconciledTo": [],
   "records": 1,
   "rosetteAria": "Gravity by Galxe Bridge control-plane rosette: Upgradeability not determined; Timelock floor not determined; Signer quorum strong; Emergency / freeze scope not determined; Docs-vs-chain parity strong",
   "search": "gravity by galxe bridge gravity-by-galxe-bridge ethereum gateway into a parallel-evm layer 1 with a native protocol-level oracle (ethereum) gravity 0xbd6e434db90fd8ad4e28d85c133ad34ca6fbfb6d 0xef936b0caaadfb439dd24f14411949694ab3c507",
   "slug": "gravity-by-galxe-bridge",
   "summary_short": "The Gravity by Galxe Bridge multisig is a 3-of-6 Safe, as its docs state",
   "url": "https://pacta.wtf/protocols/gravity-by-galxe-bridge/"
  },
  {
   "baskets": [
    "lending_vaults",
    "stable_rwa"
   ],
   "category": "Risk-tranched stablecoin yield aggregator (PWRD and leveraged Vault) (Ethereum)",
   "chains": [
    "ethereum"
   ],
   "deltas": 0,
   "easAttested": false,
   "evidence": {
    "documented": "Gro documentation is linked for reference (). This RPC-pinned record does not compare documentation parameters with the on-chain state.",
    "observed": "Gro DAO Token (0x3Ec8798B81485A254928B70CDA1cf0A2BB0B74D7) verified on Ethereum Mainnet at canonical block #26,458,556 (5,256 bytes runtime code). EIP-1967 implementation and admin storage slots are both zero (non-EIP-1967 contract). Direct owner() returns Safe 3-of-7 0x359F4fe841f246a095a82cb26F5819E10a91fe0d.",
    "recordId": "gro-control-plane",
    "surface": "Gro DAO Token · Non-Proxy Bytecode & Controller"
   },
   "factors": [
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "upgrade",
     "label": "Upgradeability",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "Upgrade path not in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "timelock",
     "label": "Timelock floor",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No enforced admin delay in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": "gro-control-plane: … contract). Direct owner() returns Safe 3-of-7 0x359F4fe841f246a095a82cb26F5819E10a91fe0d.",
     "key": "quorum",
     "label": "Signer quorum",
     "state": "g",
     "value": "Lowest controlling quorum: 3-of-7"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "emergency",
     "label": "Emergency / freeze scope",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No pause / freeze authority in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "parity",
     "label": "Docs-vs-chain parity",
     "state": "u",
     "value": "Uncompared: documentation not assessed (RPC-observed)"
    }
   ],
   "finding": "Gro DAO Token · Non-Proxy Bytecode & Controller",
   "grade": "observed",
   "gradeLabel": "OBSERVED",
   "name": "Gro",
   "pinnedBlock": 26458556,
   "probe": {
    "block_hash": "0xe258bb1cbcc988e2dfdba4ba173f9f8690520dba3647cdcae18e0651822769d2",
    "block_number": 26458556,
    "call_args": [],
    "call_signature": "owner()",
    "chain": "ethereum",
    "check_type": "eth_call",
    "extra_calls": [],
    "id": "gro-control-plane",
    "repro_calldata": "0x8da5cb5b",
    "rpc_env_var": "$ETH_RPC_URL",
    "selector_or_slot": "0x8da5cb5b",
    "target_contract": "0x3Ec8798B81485A254928B70CDA1cf0A2BB0B74D7",
    "target_label": "Gro DAO Token"
   },
   "reconciled": false,
   "reconciledFrom": [],
   "reconciledTo": [],
   "records": 1,
   "rosetteAria": "Gro control-plane rosette: Upgradeability not determined; Timelock floor not determined; Signer quorum strong; Emergency / freeze scope not determined; Docs-vs-chain parity uncompared",
   "search": "gro gro risk-tranched stablecoin yield aggregator (pwrd and leveraged vault) (ethereum) gro 0x359f4fe841f246a095a82cb26f5819e10a91fe0d 0x3ec8798b81485a254928b70cda1cf0a2bb0b74d7",
   "slug": "gro",
   "summary_short": "Non-proxy contract controlled by a 3-of-7 Safe; docs not assessed",
   "url": "https://pacta.wtf/protocols/gro/"
  },
  {
   "baskets": [
    "lending_vaults"
   ],
   "category": "Onchain Capital Allocator (Sky Star)",
   "chains": [
    "ethereum"
   ],
   "deltas": 0,
   "easAttested": true,
   "evidence": {
    "documented": "docs.grove.finance (allocator permissions, governance addresses): 'DEFAULT_ADMIN_ROLE Grants and revokes all other roles.' / 'Grove SubProxy ( GROVE_PROXY) 0x1369f7b2b38c76B6478c0f0E66D94923421891Ba'",
    "observed": "ALMProxy 0x491EDFB0B8b608044e227225C715981a30F3A44E, MainnetController 0xfd9dEA9a8D5B955649579Af482DB7198A392A9F5 and RateLimits 0x5F5cfCB8a463868E37Ab27B5eFF3ba02112dF19a: hasRole(DEFAULT_ADMIN_ROLE, Grove SubProxy 0x1369f7b2b38c76B6478c0f0E66D94923421891Ba) = true; CONTROLLER on the ALMProxy and RateLimits = the MainnetController; none of the three is a proxy.",
    "recordId": "grove-finance-alm-admin-subproxy-s21",
    "surface": "Role admin over allocator custody: Grove SubProxy (Sky governance)"
   },
   "factors": [
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "upgrade",
     "label": "Upgradeability",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "Upgrade path not in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "timelock",
     "label": "Timelock floor",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No enforced admin delay in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": "grove-finance-freezer-safe-2of5-s21: … 0xB0113804960345fd0a245788b3423319c86940e5) = true; that Safe is 2-of-5 (v1.4.1, no modules).",
     "key": "quorum",
     "label": "Signer quorum",
     "state": "b",
     "value": "Lowest controlling quorum: 2-of-5"
    },
    {
     "evidence": "grove-finance-freezer-safe-2of5-s21: MainnetController 0xfd9dEA9a8D5B955649579Af482DB7198A392A9F5: hasRole(FREEZER, 0xB0113804960345fd0a245788b3423319c86940e5) = true; that Safe is 2-of-5 (v1.4.1 …",
     "key": "emergency",
     "label": "Emergency / freeze scope",
     "state": "g",
     "value": "Pause / freeze authority scoped behind a multi-signer controller (2-of-5)"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "parity",
     "label": "Docs-vs-chain parity",
     "state": "g",
     "value": "Chain matches or is stronger than the documentation"
    }
   ],
   "finding": "Role admin over allocator custody: Grove SubProxy (Sky governance)",
   "grade": "aligned",
   "gradeLabel": "ALIGNED",
   "name": "Grove Finance",
   "pinnedBlock": 26427612,
   "probe": {
    "block_hash": "0x1c5ef52eb0b586e49da2a11dc9f905cae4125008dc814d6781f53a142f6555ac",
    "block_number": 26427612,
    "call_args": [
     "0x0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000",
     "0x1369f7b2b38c76B6478c0f0E66D94923421891Ba"
    ],
    "call_signature": "hasRole(bytes32,address)",
    "chain": "ethereum",
    "check_type": "eth_call",
    "extra_calls": [],
    "id": "grove-finance-alm-admin-subproxy-s21",
    "repro_calldata": "0x91d1485400000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000001369f7b2b38c76b6478c0f0e66d94923421891ba",
    "rpc_env_var": "$ETH_RPC_URL",
    "selector_or_slot": "0x91d14854",
    "target_contract": "0x491EDFB0B8b608044e227225C715981a30F3A44E",
    "target_label": "Grove ALMProxy (custody of allocator funds)"
   },
   "reconciled": false,
   "reconciledFrom": [],
   "reconciledTo": [],
   "records": 3,
   "rosetteAria": "Grove Finance control-plane rosette: Upgradeability not determined; Timelock floor not determined; Signer quorum moderate; Emergency / freeze scope strong; Docs-vs-chain parity strong",
   "search": "grove finance grove-finance onchain capital allocator (sky star) grove stgrove 0x0eec86649e756a23cbc68d9efed756f16ad5f85f 0x1369f7b2b38c76b6478c0f0e66d94923421891ba 0x491edfb0b8b608044e227225c715981a30f3a44e 0x5f5cfcb8a463868e37ab27b5eff3ba02112df19a 0xb0113804960345fd0a245788b3423319c86940e5 0xfd9dea9a8d5b955649579af482db7198a392a9f5",
   "slug": "grove-finance",
   "summary_short": "Allocator custody role admin is the Grove SubProxy under Sky governance",
   "url": "https://pacta.wtf/protocols/grove-finance/"
  },
  {
   "baskets": [],
   "category": "Zero-Knowledge Private Derivatives Venue (Ethereum)",
   "chains": [
    "ethereum"
   ],
   "deltas": 0,
   "easAttested": false,
   "evidence": {
    "documented": "Grvt Bridge documentation is linked for reference (https://grvt.io). This RPC-pinned record does not compare documentation parameters with the on-chain state.",
    "observed": "GRVT (GRVTToken) (0xAD29F2723fcdBcF665F210F25E06f97477e417cF) verified on Ethereum Mainnet at canonical block #26,458,556 (3,953 bytes runtime code). EIP-1967 implementation and admin storage slots are both zero (non-EIP-1967 contract). No owner(), admin(), authority(), curator() or AccessControl admin was readable on the contract.",
    "recordId": "grvt-bridge-control-plane",
    "surface": "GRVT (GRVTToken) · Non-Proxy Bytecode & Controller"
   },
   "factors": [
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "upgrade",
     "label": "Upgradeability",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "Upgrade path not in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "timelock",
     "label": "Timelock floor",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No enforced admin delay in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "quorum",
     "label": "Signer quorum",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No signer quorum in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "emergency",
     "label": "Emergency / freeze scope",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No pause / freeze authority in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "parity",
     "label": "Docs-vs-chain parity",
     "state": "u",
     "value": "Uncompared: documentation not assessed (RPC-observed)"
    }
   ],
   "finding": "GRVT (GRVTToken) · Non-Proxy Bytecode & Controller",
   "grade": "observed",
   "gradeLabel": "OBSERVED",
   "name": "Grvt Bridge",
   "pinnedBlock": 26458556,
   "probe": {
    "block_hash": "0xe258bb1cbcc988e2dfdba4ba173f9f8690520dba3647cdcae18e0651822769d2",
    "block_number": 26458556,
    "call_args": [],
    "call_signature": "owner()",
    "chain": "ethereum",
    "check_type": "eth_call",
    "extra_calls": [],
    "id": "grvt-bridge-control-plane",
    "repro_calldata": "0x8da5cb5b",
    "rpc_env_var": "$ETH_RPC_URL",
    "selector_or_slot": "0x8da5cb5b",
    "target_contract": "0xAD29F2723fcdBcF665F210F25E06f97477e417cF",
    "target_label": "GRVT (GRVTToken)"
   },
   "reconciled": false,
   "reconciledFrom": [],
   "reconciledTo": [],
   "records": 1,
   "rosetteAria": "Grvt Bridge control-plane rosette: Upgradeability not determined; Timelock floor not determined; Signer quorum not determined; Emergency / freeze scope not determined; Docs-vs-chain parity uncompared",
   "search": "grvt bridge grvt-bridge zero-knowledge private derivatives venue (ethereum) grvt 0xad29f2723fcdbcf665f210f25e06f97477e417cf",
   "slug": "grvt-bridge",
   "summary_short": "Non-proxy contract no readable owner or admin; docs not assessed",
   "url": "https://pacta.wtf/protocols/grvt-bridge/"
  },
  {
   "baskets": [],
   "category": "Crypto-native hedging instruments: impermanent-loss and interest-rate derivatives (iGain) (Ethereum)",
   "chains": [
    "ethereum"
   ],
   "deltas": 1,
   "easAttested": true,
   "evidence": {
    "documented": "'The keyholders are as follows.' (hakkafinance.gitbook.io/hakka-wiki/governance/multi-sig.md)",
    "observed": "Hakka multi-sig 0xF2B8f214Dc81b849ed3BDCAEdA6c8c39625c500A (Ethereum Safe, the address the page gives): getThreshold() = 2 of getOwners() = 4; guard slot empty; getModulesPaginated() lists no module. Owners: 0x9033c3677E6C63FC252E9546AD5b5E7d66Fc0926, 0x1D075f1F543bB09Df4530F44ed21CA50303A65B2, 0xF9aCeFD1A4e4360eE3A534Cb3485Bce36F5F05A4, 0x784e010430a923Ce2a3Ff9846C4010694Bb7BEfb, all accounts with no code; the three documented keyholders are owners, and 0x9033c3677E6C63FC252E9546AD5b5E7d66Fc0926 is an owner the page does not name. With a threshold of 2, that key and any one documented keyholder can execute. HAKKA token 0x0E29e5AbbB5FD88e28b2d355774e73BD47dE3bcd owner() = this Safe.",
    "recordId": "hakka-multisig-undocumented-signer-s34",
    "surface": "Multi-sig: docs name 3 keyholders; the Safe is 2-of-4 with 1 unnamed owner"
   },
   "factors": [
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "upgrade",
     "label": "Upgradeability",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "Upgrade path not in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "timelock",
     "label": "Timelock floor",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No enforced admin delay in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": "controller fact: Safe getThreshold()",
     "key": "quorum",
     "label": "Signer quorum",
     "state": "b",
     "value": "Lowest controlling quorum: 2-of-4"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "emergency",
     "label": "Emergency / freeze scope",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No pause / freeze authority in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "parity",
     "label": "Docs-vs-chain parity",
     "state": "a",
     "value": "Documentation differs from the chain (parameter delta)"
    }
   ],
   "finding": "Multi-sig: docs name 3 keyholders; the Safe is 2-of-4 with 1 unnamed owner: docs say 'The keyholders are as follows.' (hakkafinance.gitbook.io/hakka-wiki/governance/multi-sig.md) · chain says Hakka multi-sig 0xF2B8f214Dc81b849ed3BDCAEdA6c8c39625c500A (Ethereum Safe, the address the page gives): getThreshold() = 2 of getOwners() = 4;",
   "grade": "delta",
   "gradeLabel": "DELTA",
   "name": "Hakka Finance",
   "pinnedBlock": 26453551,
   "probe": {
    "block_hash": "0x51e9967ffd6a84012d0dad44204d523b8ac43928e69de2801d2e72dbf8767129",
    "block_number": 26453551,
    "call_args": [],
    "call_signature": "getOwners()",
    "chain": "ethereum",
    "check_type": "eth_call",
    "extra_calls": [],
    "id": "hakka-multisig-undocumented-signer-s34",
    "repro_calldata": "0xa0e67e2b",
    "rpc_env_var": "$ETH_RPC_URL",
    "selector_or_slot": "0xa0e67e2b",
    "target_contract": "0xF2B8f214Dc81b849ed3BDCAEdA6c8c39625c500A",
    "target_label": "Hakka Finance multi-sig (Safe)"
   },
   "reconciled": false,
   "reconciledFrom": [],
   "reconciledTo": [],
   "records": 1,
   "rosetteAria": "Hakka Finance control-plane rosette: Upgradeability not determined; Timelock floor not determined; Signer quorum moderate; Emergency / freeze scope not determined; Docs-vs-chain parity weak",
   "search": "hakka finance hakka-finance crypto-native hedging instruments: impermanent-loss and interest-rate derivatives (igain) (ethereum) hakka 0x0e29e5abbb5fd88e28b2d355774e73bd47de3bcd 0x1d075f1f543bb09df4530f44ed21ca50303a65b2 0x784e010430a923ce2a3ff9846c4010694bb7befb 0x9033c3677e6c63fc252e9546ad5b5e7d66fc0926 0xf2b8f214dc81b849ed3bdcaeda6c8c39625c500a 0xf9acefd1a4e4360ee3a534cb3485bce36f5f05a4",
   "slug": "hakka-finance",
   "summary_short": "Hakka's multi-sig has 4 signers (2 needed); docs name 3 keyholders",
   "url": "https://pacta.wtf/protocols/hakka-finance/"
  },
  {
   "baskets": [
    "lending_vaults"
   ],
   "category": "Automated farming strategies with auto-compounding vaults (Ethereum)",
   "chains": [
    "ethereum"
   ],
   "deltas": 0,
   "easAttested": false,
   "evidence": {
    "documented": "Harvest Finance documentation is linked for reference (https://harvest.finance/docs). This RPC-pinned record does not compare documentation parameters with the on-chain state.",
    "observed": "FARM Reward Token (0xa0246c9032bC3A600820415aE600c6388619A14D) verified on Ethereum Mainnet at canonical block #26,458,556 (4,746 bytes runtime code). EIP-1967 implementation and admin storage slots are both zero (non-EIP-1967 contract). No owner(), admin(), authority(), curator() or AccessControl admin was readable on the contract.",
    "recordId": "harvest-finance-control-plane",
    "surface": "FARM Reward Token · Non-Proxy Bytecode & Controller"
   },
   "factors": [
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "upgrade",
     "label": "Upgradeability",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "Upgrade path not in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "timelock",
     "label": "Timelock floor",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No enforced admin delay in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "quorum",
     "label": "Signer quorum",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No signer quorum in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "emergency",
     "label": "Emergency / freeze scope",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No pause / freeze authority in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "parity",
     "label": "Docs-vs-chain parity",
     "state": "u",
     "value": "Uncompared: documentation not assessed (RPC-observed)"
    }
   ],
   "finding": "FARM Reward Token · Non-Proxy Bytecode & Controller",
   "grade": "observed",
   "gradeLabel": "OBSERVED",
   "name": "Harvest Finance",
   "pinnedBlock": 26458556,
   "probe": {
    "block_hash": "0xe258bb1cbcc988e2dfdba4ba173f9f8690520dba3647cdcae18e0651822769d2",
    "block_number": 26458556,
    "call_args": [],
    "call_signature": "owner()",
    "chain": "ethereum",
    "check_type": "eth_call",
    "extra_calls": [],
    "id": "harvest-finance-control-plane",
    "repro_calldata": "0x8da5cb5b",
    "rpc_env_var": "$ETH_RPC_URL",
    "selector_or_slot": "0x8da5cb5b",
    "target_contract": "0xa0246c9032bC3A600820415aE600c6388619A14D",
    "target_label": "FARM Reward Token"
   },
   "reconciled": false,
   "reconciledFrom": [],
   "reconciledTo": [],
   "records": 1,
   "rosetteAria": "Harvest Finance control-plane rosette: Upgradeability not determined; Timelock floor not determined; Signer quorum not determined; Emergency / freeze scope not determined; Docs-vs-chain parity uncompared",
   "search": "harvest finance harvest-finance automated farming strategies with auto-compounding vaults (ethereum) farm 0xa0246c9032bc3a600820415ae600c6388619a14d",
   "slug": "harvest-finance",
   "summary_short": "Non-proxy contract no readable owner or admin; docs not assessed",
   "url": "https://pacta.wtf/protocols/harvest-finance/"
  },
  {
   "baskets": [],
   "category": "Enterprise bridging utility moving assets between networks (Ethereum)",
   "chains": [
    "ethereum"
   ],
   "deltas": 0,
   "easAttested": true,
   "evidence": {
    "documented": "'Smart Contracts use [EIP-2535](https://eips.ethereum.org/EIPS/eip-2535).' (raw.githubusercontent.com/LimeChain/hashport-contracts/main/README.md); '`Hashport (Diamond)`: `0x367e59b559283C8506207d75B0c5D8C66c4Cd4B7`' (raw.githubusercontent.com/LimeChain/hashport-contracts/main/Deployment.md)",
    "observed": "Hashport Router diamond 0x367e59b559283C8506207d75B0c5D8C66c4Cd4B7 (Ethereum, EIP-2535): facetAddress(diamondCut 0x1f931c1c) = 0xe79c9Bb508f00ab7B03cf3043929639e86626EF9, the DiamondCutFacet of Deployment.md; in its verified source diamondCut() calls LibDiamond.enforceIsContractOwner() before adding, replacing or removing facets. owner() = 0x10AB2d9C085c816f43ccB0FB1b27d024224E36f1, a 5-of-9 Safe.",
    "recordId": "hashport-diamond-cut-owner-safe-s32",
    "surface": "Diamond (EIP-2535): diamondCut owner-only; owner is a 5-of-9 Safe"
   },
   "factors": [
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "upgrade",
     "label": "Upgradeability",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "Upgrade path not in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "timelock",
     "label": "Timelock floor",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No enforced admin delay in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": "hashport-diamond-cut-owner-safe-s32: … 0x10AB2d9C085c816f43ccB0FB1b27d024224E36f1, a 5-of-9 Safe.",
     "key": "quorum",
     "label": "Signer quorum",
     "state": "g",
     "value": "Lowest controlling quorum: 5-of-9"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "emergency",
     "label": "Emergency / freeze scope",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No pause / freeze authority in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "parity",
     "label": "Docs-vs-chain parity",
     "state": "g",
     "value": "Chain matches or is stronger than the documentation"
    }
   ],
   "finding": "Diamond (EIP-2535): diamondCut owner-only; owner is a 5-of-9 Safe",
   "grade": "aligned",
   "gradeLabel": "ALIGNED",
   "name": "Hashport",
   "pinnedBlock": 26451608,
   "probe": {
    "block_hash": "0x0266af5bcad519d93b3be78e41b76a62985e22fbe4feef043ac3225f6f217a17",
    "block_number": 26451608,
    "call_args": [],
    "call_signature": "owner()",
    "chain": "ethereum",
    "check_type": "eth_call",
    "extra_calls": [],
    "id": "hashport-diamond-cut-owner-safe-s32",
    "repro_calldata": "0x8da5cb5b",
    "rpc_env_var": "$ETH_RPC_URL",
    "selector_or_slot": "0x8da5cb5b",
    "target_contract": "0x367e59b559283C8506207d75B0c5D8C66c4Cd4B7",
    "target_label": "Hashport Router (Diamond)"
   },
   "reconciled": false,
   "reconciledFrom": [],
   "reconciledTo": [],
   "records": 1,
   "rosetteAria": "Hashport control-plane rosette: Upgradeability not determined; Timelock floor not determined; Signer quorum strong; Emergency / freeze scope not determined; Docs-vs-chain parity strong",
   "search": "hashport hashport enterprise bridging utility moving assets between networks (ethereum) hashport 0x10ab2d9c085c816f43ccb0fb1b27d024224e36f1 0x367e59b559283c8506207d75b0c5d8c66c4cd4b7 0xe79c9bb508f00ab7b03cf3043929639e86626ef9",
   "slug": "hashport",
   "summary_short": "Hashport's router is an upgradeable diamond whose owner is a 5-of-9 Safe, as documented",
   "url": "https://pacta.wtf/protocols/hashport/"
  },
  {
   "baskets": [],
   "category": "Peer-to-pool options on ETH and WBTC with one-click strategies (Ethereum)",
   "chains": [
    "ethereum"
   ],
   "deltas": 0,
   "easAttested": false,
   "evidence": {
    "documented": "Hegic documentation is linked for reference (https://www.hegic.co/). This RPC-pinned record does not compare documentation parameters with the on-chain state.",
    "observed": "Hegic (0x584bC13c7D411c00c01A62e8019472dE68768430) verified on Ethereum Mainnet at canonical block #26,458,556 (2,546 bytes runtime code). EIP-1967 implementation and admin storage slots are both zero (non-EIP-1967 contract). No owner(), admin(), authority(), curator() or AccessControl admin was readable on the contract.",
    "recordId": "hegic-control-plane",
    "surface": "Hegic · Non-Proxy Bytecode & Controller"
   },
   "factors": [
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "upgrade",
     "label": "Upgradeability",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "Upgrade path not in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "timelock",
     "label": "Timelock floor",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No enforced admin delay in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "quorum",
     "label": "Signer quorum",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No signer quorum in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "emergency",
     "label": "Emergency / freeze scope",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No pause / freeze authority in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "parity",
     "label": "Docs-vs-chain parity",
     "state": "u",
     "value": "Uncompared: documentation not assessed (RPC-observed)"
    }
   ],
   "finding": "Hegic · Non-Proxy Bytecode & Controller",
   "grade": "observed",
   "gradeLabel": "OBSERVED",
   "name": "Hegic",
   "pinnedBlock": 26458556,
   "probe": {
    "block_hash": "0xe258bb1cbcc988e2dfdba4ba173f9f8690520dba3647cdcae18e0651822769d2",
    "block_number": 26458556,
    "call_args": [],
    "call_signature": "owner()",
    "chain": "ethereum",
    "check_type": "eth_call",
    "extra_calls": [],
    "id": "hegic-control-plane",
    "repro_calldata": "0x8da5cb5b",
    "rpc_env_var": "$ETH_RPC_URL",
    "selector_or_slot": "0x8da5cb5b",
    "target_contract": "0x584bC13c7D411c00c01A62e8019472dE68768430",
    "target_label": "Hegic"
   },
   "reconciled": false,
   "reconciledFrom": [],
   "reconciledTo": [],
   "records": 1,
   "rosetteAria": "Hegic control-plane rosette: Upgradeability not determined; Timelock floor not determined; Signer quorum not determined; Emergency / freeze scope not determined; Docs-vs-chain parity uncompared",
   "search": "hegic hegic peer-to-pool options on eth and wbtc with one-click strategies (ethereum) hegic 0x584bc13c7d411c00c01a62e8019472de68768430",
   "slug": "hegic",
   "summary_short": "Non-proxy contract no readable owner or admin; docs not assessed",
   "url": "https://pacta.wtf/protocols/hegic/"
  },
  {
   "baskets": [],
   "category": "Rollup-to-rollup token bridge using bonders (Ethereum)",
   "chains": [
    "ethereum"
   ],
   "deltas": 1,
   "easAttested": true,
   "evidence": {
    "documented": "'In summary, the Hop DAO controls every aspect of the protocol.' (docs.hop.exchange/governance/into-to-hop-dao); '0xeeA8422a08258e73c139Fc32a25e10410c14bd7a' (docs.hop.exchange/governance/important-links); 'l1Bridge: '0xb8901acB165ed027E32754E0FFe830802919727f'' (raw.githubusercontent.com/hop-protocol/hop/develop/packages/sdk/src/addresses/mainnet.ts)",
    "observed": "Hop L1_ETH_Bridge 0xb8901acB165ed027E32754E0FFe830802919727f (Ethereum, not a proxy; verified source; the SDK's Ethereum ETH l1Bridge): addBonder(), removeBonder(), setGovernance(), setChallengePeriod(), setChainIdDepositsPaused() and rescueTransferRoot() are onlyGovernance, and governance() = 0x22e3F828b3f47dAcFACd875D20bd5cc0879C96e7, a Compound-style Timelock (verified) with delay() = 86,400 s, pendingAdmin() empty and admin() = Safe 0x1ec078551A5ac8F0f51fAc57Ffc48Ea7d9A86E9d: getThreshold() = 2 of getOwners() = 3; guard slot empty; getModulesPaginated() lists no module; all 3 owners are accounts with no code. Neither the DAO Governor 0xed8Bdb5895B8B7f9Fdb3C087628FD8410E853D48 nor the DAO Timelock 0xeeA8422a08258e73c139Fc32a25e10410c14bd7a (both on the governance links page) is in this path: 2 keys queue and execute any onlyGovernance call after 24 hours.",
    "recordId": "hop-l1-eth-bridge-governance-2-of-3-safe-s34",
    "surface": "L1 ETH Bridge governance: 24h Timelock whose admin is a 2-of-3 key Safe"
   },
   "factors": [
    {
     "evidence": "hop-l1-eth-bridge-governance-2-of-3-safe-s34: … 0xb8901acB165ed027E32754E0FFe830802919727f (Ethereum, not a proxy; verified source; the SDK's Ethereum …",
     "key": "upgrade",
     "label": "Upgradeability",
     "state": "g",
     "value": "Immutable or ownership renounced"
    },
    {
     "evidence": "hop-l1-eth-bridge-governance-2-of-3-safe-s34: observed_delay_seconds = 86400",
     "key": "timelock",
     "label": "Timelock floor",
     "state": "b",
     "value": "1d minimum enforced delay across control surfaces"
    },
    {
     "evidence": "hop-l1-eth-bridge-governance-2-of-3-safe-s34: … accounts with no code. Neither the DAO Governor 0xed8Bdb5895B8B7f9Fdb3C087628FD8410E853D48 …",
     "key": "quorum",
     "label": "Signer quorum",
     "state": "g",
     "value": "DAO Governor (token vote)"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "emergency",
     "label": "Emergency / freeze scope",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No pause / freeze authority in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "parity",
     "label": "Docs-vs-chain parity",
     "state": "a",
     "value": "Documentation differs from the chain (parameter delta)"
    }
   ],
   "finding": "L1 ETH Bridge governance: 24h Timelock whose admin is a 2-of-3 key Safe: docs say 'In summary, the Hop DAO controls every aspect of the protocol.' (docs.hop.exchange/governance/into-to-hop-dao); · chain says Hop L1_ETH_Bridge 0xb8901acB165ed027E32754E0FFe830802919727f (Ethereum, not a proxy;",
   "grade": "delta",
   "gradeLabel": "DELTA",
   "name": "Hop Protocol",
   "pinnedBlock": 26453551,
   "probe": {
    "block_hash": "0x51e9967ffd6a84012d0dad44204d523b8ac43928e69de2801d2e72dbf8767129",
    "block_number": 26453551,
    "call_args": [],
    "call_signature": "governance()",
    "chain": "ethereum",
    "check_type": "eth_call",
    "extra_calls": [],
    "id": "hop-l1-eth-bridge-governance-2-of-3-safe-s34",
    "repro_calldata": "0x5aa6e675",
    "rpc_env_var": "$ETH_RPC_URL",
    "selector_or_slot": "0x5aa6e675",
    "target_contract": "0xb8901acB165ed027E32754E0FFe830802919727f",
    "target_label": "Hop L1_ETH_Bridge (Ethereum)"
   },
   "reconciled": false,
   "reconciledFrom": [],
   "reconciledTo": [],
   "records": 1,
   "rosetteAria": "Hop Protocol control-plane rosette: Upgradeability strong; Timelock floor moderate; Signer quorum strong; Emergency / freeze scope not determined; Docs-vs-chain parity weak",
   "search": "hop protocol hop-protocol rollup-to-rollup token bridge using bonders (ethereum) hop 0x1ec078551a5ac8f0f51fac57ffc48ea7d9a86e9d 0x22e3f828b3f47dacfacd875d20bd5cc0879c96e7 0xb8901acb165ed027e32754e0ffe830802919727f 0xed8bdb5895b8b7f9fdb3c087628fd8410e853d48 0xeea8422a08258e73c139fc32a25e10410c14bd7a",
   "slug": "hop-protocol",
   "summary_short": "Hop's Bonder whitelist is set by a 2-of-3 key Safe, not the documented DAO",
   "url": "https://pacta.wtf/protocols/hop-protocol/"
  },
  {
   "baskets": [],
   "category": "Permissionless Interchain Messaging (token lockbox) (Ethereum)",
   "chains": [
    "ethereum"
   ],
   "deltas": 0,
   "easAttested": false,
   "evidence": {
    "documented": "Hyperlane documentation is linked for reference (https://docs.hyperlane.xyz/). This RPC-pinned record does not compare documentation parameters with the on-chain state.",
    "observed": "XERC20Lockbox (0x6D265C7dD8d76F25155F1a7687C693FDC1220D12) verified on Ethereum Mainnet at canonical block #26,458,556 (1,563 bytes runtime code). EIP-1967 implementation and admin storage slots are both zero (non-EIP-1967 contract). No owner(), admin(), authority(), curator() or AccessControl admin was readable on the contract.",
    "recordId": "hyperlane-control-plane",
    "surface": "XERC20Lockbox · Non-Proxy Bytecode & Controller"
   },
   "factors": [
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "upgrade",
     "label": "Upgradeability",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "Upgrade path not in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "timelock",
     "label": "Timelock floor",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No enforced admin delay in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "quorum",
     "label": "Signer quorum",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No signer quorum in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "emergency",
     "label": "Emergency / freeze scope",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No pause / freeze authority in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "parity",
     "label": "Docs-vs-chain parity",
     "state": "u",
     "value": "Uncompared: documentation not assessed (RPC-observed)"
    }
   ],
   "finding": "XERC20Lockbox · Non-Proxy Bytecode & Controller",
   "grade": "observed",
   "gradeLabel": "OBSERVED",
   "name": "Hyperlane",
   "pinnedBlock": 26458556,
   "probe": {
    "block_hash": "0xe258bb1cbcc988e2dfdba4ba173f9f8690520dba3647cdcae18e0651822769d2",
    "block_number": 26458556,
    "call_args": [],
    "call_signature": "owner()",
    "chain": "ethereum",
    "check_type": "eth_call",
    "extra_calls": [],
    "id": "hyperlane-control-plane",
    "repro_calldata": "0x8da5cb5b",
    "rpc_env_var": "$ETH_RPC_URL",
    "selector_or_slot": "0x8da5cb5b",
    "target_contract": "0x6D265C7dD8d76F25155F1a7687C693FDC1220D12",
    "target_label": "XERC20Lockbox"
   },
   "reconciled": false,
   "reconciledFrom": [],
   "reconciledTo": [],
   "records": 1,
   "rosetteAria": "Hyperlane control-plane rosette: Upgradeability not determined; Timelock floor not determined; Signer quorum not determined; Emergency / freeze scope not determined; Docs-vs-chain parity uncompared",
   "search": "hyperlane hyperlane permissionless interchain messaging (token lockbox) (ethereum) hyperlane 0x6d265c7dd8d76f25155f1a7687c693fdc1220d12",
   "slug": "hyperlane",
   "summary_short": "Non-proxy contract no readable owner or admin; docs not assessed",
   "url": "https://pacta.wtf/protocols/hyperlane/"
  },
  {
   "baskets": [
    "base"
   ],
   "category": "Liquid locker automating veAERO voting and reward harvesting (Base)",
   "chains": [
    "base"
   ],
   "deltas": 0,
   "easAttested": true,
   "evidence": {
    "documented": "'xiAERO's owner is the protocol Safe, a 3-of-4 multisig (`0x1039CB48254a3150fC604d4B9ea08F66f4739D37`)' (docs.iaero.finance/llms-full.txt)",
    "observed": "iAero Protocol Safe 0x1039CB48254a3150fC604d4B9ea08F66f4739D37 (Base): getThreshold() = 3 of getOwners() = 4 owners (Safe v1.4.1); it controls StakedIAERO 0x44D8172b95a208082327f58c5b42269d48a34847.",
    "recordId": "iaero-protocol-safe-threshold-44d817-s30",
    "surface": "iAero Protocol multisig: 3-of-4 Safe, as documented"
   },
   "factors": [
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "upgrade",
     "label": "Upgradeability",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "Upgrade path not in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "timelock",
     "label": "Timelock floor",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No enforced admin delay in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": "controller fact: Safe getThreshold()",
     "key": "quorum",
     "label": "Signer quorum",
     "state": "g",
     "value": "Lowest controlling quorum: 3-of-4"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "emergency",
     "label": "Emergency / freeze scope",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No pause / freeze authority in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "parity",
     "label": "Docs-vs-chain parity",
     "state": "g",
     "value": "Chain matches or is stronger than the documentation"
    }
   ],
   "finding": "iAero Protocol multisig: 3-of-4 Safe, as documented",
   "grade": "aligned",
   "gradeLabel": "ALIGNED",
   "name": "iAero Protocol",
   "pinnedBlock": 59532664,
   "probe": {
    "block_hash": "0xff515cb7dd2fd4e2de0f326c6c78aaaf038978e80baf47e5711377db3c07c025",
    "block_number": 59532664,
    "call_args": [],
    "call_signature": "getThreshold()",
    "chain": "base",
    "check_type": "eth_call",
    "extra_calls": [],
    "id": "iaero-protocol-safe-threshold-44d817-s30",
    "repro_calldata": "0xe75235b8",
    "rpc_env_var": "$BASE_RPC_URL",
    "selector_or_slot": "0xe75235b8",
    "target_contract": "0x1039CB48254a3150fC604d4B9ea08F66f4739D37",
    "target_label": "iAero Protocol Safe"
   },
   "reconciled": false,
   "reconciledFrom": [],
   "reconciledTo": [],
   "records": 1,
   "rosetteAria": "iAero Protocol control-plane rosette: Upgradeability not determined; Timelock floor not determined; Signer quorum strong; Emergency / freeze scope not determined; Docs-vs-chain parity strong",
   "search": "iaero protocol iaero-protocol liquid locker automating veaero voting and reward harvesting (base) liq 0x1039cb48254a3150fc604d4b9ea08f66f4739d37 0x44d8172b95a208082327f58c5b42269d48a34847",
   "slug": "iaero-protocol",
   "summary_short": "The iAero Protocol multisig is a 3-of-4 Safe, as its docs state",
   "url": "https://pacta.wtf/protocols/iaero-protocol/"
  },
  {
   "baskets": [],
   "category": "Algorithmic single-sided liquidity strategies on concentrated-liquidity DEXes (Ethereum)",
   "chains": [
    "ethereum"
   ],
   "deltas": 0,
   "easAttested": false,
   "evidence": {
    "documented": "ICHI documentation is linked for reference (https://docs.ichi.org/home). This RPC-pinned record does not compare documentation parameters with the on-chain state.",
    "observed": "ICHI (IchiV2) (0x111111517e4929D3dcbdfa7CCe55d30d4B6BC4d6) verified on Ethereum Mainnet at canonical block #26,458,556 (11,873 bytes runtime code). EIP-1967 implementation and admin storage slots are both zero (non-EIP-1967 contract). No owner(), admin(), authority(), curator() or AccessControl admin was readable on the contract.",
    "recordId": "ichi-control-plane",
    "surface": "ICHI (IchiV2) · Non-Proxy Bytecode & Controller"
   },
   "factors": [
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "upgrade",
     "label": "Upgradeability",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "Upgrade path not in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "timelock",
     "label": "Timelock floor",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No enforced admin delay in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "quorum",
     "label": "Signer quorum",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No signer quorum in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "emergency",
     "label": "Emergency / freeze scope",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No pause / freeze authority in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "parity",
     "label": "Docs-vs-chain parity",
     "state": "u",
     "value": "Uncompared: documentation not assessed (RPC-observed)"
    }
   ],
   "finding": "ICHI (IchiV2) · Non-Proxy Bytecode & Controller",
   "grade": "observed",
   "gradeLabel": "OBSERVED",
   "name": "ICHI",
   "pinnedBlock": 26458556,
   "probe": {
    "block_hash": "0xe258bb1cbcc988e2dfdba4ba173f9f8690520dba3647cdcae18e0651822769d2",
    "block_number": 26458556,
    "call_args": [],
    "call_signature": "owner()",
    "chain": "ethereum",
    "check_type": "eth_call",
    "extra_calls": [],
    "id": "ichi-control-plane",
    "repro_calldata": "0x8da5cb5b",
    "rpc_env_var": "$ETH_RPC_URL",
    "selector_or_slot": "0x8da5cb5b",
    "target_contract": "0x111111517e4929D3dcbdfa7CCe55d30d4B6BC4d6",
    "target_label": "ICHI (IchiV2)"
   },
   "reconciled": false,
   "reconciledFrom": [],
   "reconciledTo": [],
   "records": 1,
   "rosetteAria": "ICHI control-plane rosette: Upgradeability not determined; Timelock floor not determined; Signer quorum not determined; Emergency / freeze scope not determined; Docs-vs-chain parity uncompared",
   "search": "ichi ichi algorithmic single-sided liquidity strategies on concentrated-liquidity dexes (ethereum) ichi 0x111111517e4929d3dcbdfa7cce55d30d4b6bc4d6",
   "slug": "ichi",
   "summary_short": "Non-proxy contract no readable owner or admin; docs not assessed",
   "url": "https://pacta.wtf/protocols/ichi/"
  },
  {
   "baskets": [],
   "category": "Hybrid order-book exchange with on-chain settlement, first deployment (Ethereum)",
   "chains": [
    "ethereum"
   ],
   "deltas": 0,
   "easAttested": false,
   "evidence": {
    "documented": "IDEX V1 documentation is linked for reference (). This RPC-pinned record does not compare documentation parameters with the on-chain state.",
    "observed": "IDEX Token (IDEX) (0xB705268213D593B8FD88d3FDEFF93AFF5CbDcfAE) verified on Ethereum Mainnet at canonical block #26,458,556 (2,437 bytes runtime code). EIP-1967 implementation and admin storage slots are both zero (non-EIP-1967 contract). No owner(), admin(), authority(), curator() or AccessControl admin was readable on the contract.",
    "recordId": "idex-v1-control-plane",
    "surface": "IDEX Token (IDEX) · Non-Proxy Bytecode & Controller"
   },
   "factors": [
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "upgrade",
     "label": "Upgradeability",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "Upgrade path not in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "timelock",
     "label": "Timelock floor",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No enforced admin delay in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "quorum",
     "label": "Signer quorum",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No signer quorum in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "emergency",
     "label": "Emergency / freeze scope",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No pause / freeze authority in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "parity",
     "label": "Docs-vs-chain parity",
     "state": "u",
     "value": "Uncompared: documentation not assessed (RPC-observed)"
    }
   ],
   "finding": "IDEX Token (IDEX) · Non-Proxy Bytecode & Controller",
   "grade": "observed",
   "gradeLabel": "OBSERVED",
   "name": "IDEX V1",
   "pinnedBlock": 26458556,
   "probe": {
    "block_hash": "0xe258bb1cbcc988e2dfdba4ba173f9f8690520dba3647cdcae18e0651822769d2",
    "block_number": 26458556,
    "call_args": [],
    "call_signature": "owner()",
    "chain": "ethereum",
    "check_type": "eth_call",
    "extra_calls": [],
    "id": "idex-v1-control-plane",
    "repro_calldata": "0x8da5cb5b",
    "rpc_env_var": "$ETH_RPC_URL",
    "selector_or_slot": "0x8da5cb5b",
    "target_contract": "0xB705268213D593B8FD88d3FDEFF93AFF5CbDcfAE",
    "target_label": "IDEX Token (IDEX)"
   },
   "reconciled": false,
   "reconciledFrom": [],
   "reconciledTo": [],
   "records": 1,
   "rosetteAria": "IDEX V1 control-plane rosette: Upgradeability not determined; Timelock floor not determined; Signer quorum not determined; Emergency / freeze scope not determined; Docs-vs-chain parity uncompared",
   "search": "idex v1 idex-v1 hybrid order-book exchange with on-chain settlement, first deployment (ethereum) idex 0xb705268213d593b8fd88d3fdeff93aff5cbdcfae",
   "slug": "idex-v1",
   "summary_short": "Non-proxy contract no readable owner or admin; docs not assessed",
   "url": "https://pacta.wtf/protocols/idex-v1/"
  },
  {
   "baskets": [
    "lending_vaults"
   ],
   "category": "Yield tranches and best-yield vaults that rebalance across lending markets (Ethereum)",
   "chains": [
    "ethereum"
   ],
   "deltas": 0,
   "easAttested": true,
   "evidence": {
    "documented": "'it is queued in the Timelock and can be implemented after 2 days' (docs.idle.finance/governance/idle.md)",
    "observed": "Idle governance Timelock 0xD6dABBc2b275114a2366555d6C481EF08FDC2556 (Ethereum): delay() = 172,800 s; Governor Bravo 0x3D5Fc645320be0A085A32885F078F7121e5E5375 timelock() = this Timelock. The Timelock's admin() (who may queue and execute) is 0xFb3bD022D5DAcF95eE28a6B07825D4Ff9C5b3814.",
    "recordId": "idle-governance-timelock-2d-s31",
    "surface": "Governance Timelock: delay() 172,800 s"
   },
   "factors": [
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "upgrade",
     "label": "Upgradeability",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "Upgrade path not in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": "idle-governance-timelock-2d-s31: observed_delay_seconds = 172800",
     "key": "timelock",
     "label": "Timelock floor",
     "state": "g",
     "value": "2d minimum enforced delay across control surfaces"
    },
    {
     "evidence": "idle-governance-timelock-2d-s31: … 0xD6dABBc2b275114a2366555d6C481EF08FDC2556 (Ethereum): delay() = 172,800 s; Governor Bravo 0x3D5Fc645320be0A085A32885F078F7121e5E5375 …",
     "key": "quorum",
     "label": "Signer quorum",
     "state": "g",
     "value": "DAO Governor (token vote)"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "emergency",
     "label": "Emergency / freeze scope",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No pause / freeze authority in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "parity",
     "label": "Docs-vs-chain parity",
     "state": "g",
     "value": "Chain matches or is stronger than the documentation"
    }
   ],
   "finding": "Governance Timelock: delay() 172,800 s",
   "grade": "aligned",
   "gradeLabel": "ALIGNED",
   "name": "Idle",
   "pinnedBlock": 26450616,
   "probe": {
    "block_hash": "0xd2df7ccb74a6772b51a5597c8f144f5cfae362efeabf193ecfc7c80f8ff37c35",
    "block_number": 26450616,
    "call_args": [],
    "call_signature": "delay()",
    "chain": "ethereum",
    "check_type": "eth_call",
    "extra_calls": [],
    "id": "idle-governance-timelock-2d-s31",
    "repro_calldata": "0x6a42b8f8",
    "rpc_env_var": "$ETH_RPC_URL",
    "selector_or_slot": "0x6a42b8f8",
    "target_contract": "0xD6dABBc2b275114a2366555d6C481EF08FDC2556",
    "target_label": "Idle governance Timelock (Compound-style)"
   },
   "reconciled": false,
   "reconciledFrom": [],
   "reconciledTo": [],
   "records": 1,
   "rosetteAria": "Idle control-plane rosette: Upgradeability not determined; Timelock floor strong; Signer quorum strong; Emergency / freeze scope not determined; Docs-vs-chain parity strong",
   "search": "idle idle yield tranches and best-yield vaults that rebalance across lending markets (ethereum) idle 0x3d5fc645320be0a085a32885f078f7121e5e5375 0xd6dabbc2b275114a2366555d6c481ef08fdc2556 0xfb3bd022d5dacf95ee28a6b07825d4ff9c5b3814",
   "slug": "idle",
   "summary_short": "Idle's governance Timelock waits 48 hours before execution, as documented",
   "url": "https://pacta.wtf/protocols/idle/"
  },
  {
   "baskets": [
    "eth_lst_lrt",
    "lending_vaults"
   ],
   "category": "Isolated liquid restaking vaults over EigenLayer (Ethereum)",
   "chains": [
    "ethereum"
   ],
   "deltas": 0,
   "easAttested": true,
   "evidence": {
    "documented": "'The contracts are upgradeable and guarded with the [TimeLockController]' (raw.githubusercontent.com/inceptionlrt/smart-contracts/HEAD/projects/vaults/README.md)",
    "observed": "InceptionTimeLock 0x650bD9Dee50E3eE15cbb49749ff6ABcf55A8FB1e (Ethereum), a TimelockController: getMinDelay() = 259,200 s. InstEthVault 0x814CC6B8fd2555845541FB843f37418b05977d8d (implementation 0x9Bb0F64c5A5e9120f55cde6B15683FF11Abc0eD4): ProxyAdmin 0xB81e55e7Ee6B286aF6abFEa4eFad83f7BA4D1f1e, owner() = the timelock; inLBTCVault_S 0xD496417a50DB34279631e0aF459493Cf9685F529 (implementation 0xb83ad67814BeD3478BB4239a5961391d836fCe4d): ProxyAdmin 0x177bFf0AD93B8132012F05081A10a0e574fa5F97, owner() = the timelock. The README lists InstEthVault under deprecated LSTs. Both vaults' own owner() is 0x8e6C8799B542E507bfDDCA1a424867e885D96e79, a 3-of-5 Safe, acting without the timelock on owner-only vault settings.",
    "recordId": "inception-vault-upgrades-timelock-3d-s32",
    "surface": "Vault upgrades: ProxyAdmins owned by InceptionTimeLock, getMinDelay() 259,200 s"
   },
   "factors": [
    {
     "evidence": "inception-vault-upgrades-timelock-3d-s32: InceptionTimeLock 0x650bD9Dee50E3eE15cbb49749ff6ABcf55A8FB1e (Ethereum), a TimelockController: getMinDelay() = 259,200 s. InstEthVault …",
     "key": "upgrade",
     "label": "Upgradeability",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "Upgradeable; the delay gating the upgrade path is not in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": "controller fact: getMinDelay() = 259200s",
     "key": "timelock",
     "label": "Timelock floor",
     "state": "g",
     "value": "3d minimum enforced delay across control surfaces"
    },
    {
     "evidence": "inception-vault-upgrades-timelock-3d-s32: … 0x8e6C8799B542E507bfDDCA1a424867e885D96e79, a 3-of-5 Safe, acting without the timelock on …",
     "key": "quorum",
     "label": "Signer quorum",
     "state": "g",
     "value": "Lowest controlling quorum: 3-of-5"
    },
    {
     "evidence": "inception-vault-upgrades-timelock-3d-s32: inLBTCVault_S 0xD496417a50DB34279631e0aF459493Cf9685F529 (implementation 0xb83ad67814BeD3478BB4239a5961391d836fCe4d): ProxyAdmin …",
     "key": "emergency",
     "label": "Emergency / freeze scope",
     "state": "g",
     "value": "Pause / freeze authority scoped behind a multi-signer controller (3-of-5)"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "parity",
     "label": "Docs-vs-chain parity",
     "state": "g",
     "value": "Chain matches or is stronger than the documentation"
    }
   ],
   "finding": "Vault upgrades: ProxyAdmins owned by InceptionTimeLock, getMinDelay() 259,200 s",
   "grade": "aligned",
   "gradeLabel": "ALIGNED",
   "name": "InceptionLRT (Isolated Restaking)",
   "pinnedBlock": 26451608,
   "probe": {
    "block_hash": "0x0266af5bcad519d93b3be78e41b76a62985e22fbe4feef043ac3225f6f217a17",
    "block_number": 26451608,
    "call_args": [],
    "call_signature": "getMinDelay()",
    "chain": "ethereum",
    "check_type": "eth_call",
    "extra_calls": [],
    "id": "inception-vault-upgrades-timelock-3d-s32",
    "repro_calldata": "0xf27a0c92",
    "rpc_env_var": "$ETH_RPC_URL",
    "selector_or_slot": "0xf27a0c92",
    "target_contract": "0x650bD9Dee50E3eE15cbb49749ff6ABcf55A8FB1e",
    "target_label": "InceptionTimeLock (owner of the vault ProxyAdmins)"
   },
   "reconciled": false,
   "reconciledFrom": [],
   "reconciledTo": [],
   "records": 1,
   "rosetteAria": "InceptionLRT (Isolated Restaking) control-plane rosette: Upgradeability not determined; Timelock floor strong; Signer quorum strong; Emergency / freeze scope strong; Docs-vs-chain parity strong",
   "search": "inceptionlrt (isolated restaking) inceptionlrt-isolated-restaking isolated liquid restaking vaults over eigenlayer (ethereum) inceptionlrt 0x177bff0ad93b8132012f05081a10a0e574fa5f97 0x650bd9dee50e3ee15cbb49749ff6abcf55a8fb1e 0x814cc6b8fd2555845541fb843f37418b05977d8d 0x8e6c8799b542e507bfddca1a424867e885d96e79 0x9bb0f64c5a5e9120f55cde6b15683ff11abc0ed4 0xb81e55e7ee6b286af6abfea4efad83f7ba4d1f1e 0xb83ad67814bed3478bb4239a5961391d836fce4d 0xd496417a50db34279631e0af459493cf9685f529",
   "slug": "inceptionlrt-isolated-restaking",
   "summary_short": "Inception vault upgrades go through its TimelockController (3-day delay), as documented",
   "url": "https://pacta.wtf/protocols/inceptionlrt-isolated-restaking/"
  },
  {
   "baskets": [],
   "category": "Fully collateralized crypto index products and leveraged indices (Ethereum)",
   "chains": [
    "ethereum"
   ],
   "deltas": 0,
   "easAttested": true,
   "evidence": {
    "documented": "'There is a maximum supply of 10 million $INDEX tokens.' (docs.indexcoop.com/index-coop-community-handbook/resources/governance/the-index-token.md)",
    "observed": "INDEX token 0x0954906da0Bf32d5479e25f46056d22f08464cab (Ethereum; not a proxy: EIP-1967 implementation, admin and beacon slots all empty; verified source): totalSupply() = 10,000,000. The runtime code holds no selector of mint(address,uint256), mint(uint256), upgradeTo(address), upgradeToAndCall(address,bytes). The whole supply is assigned in its constructor; no function creates tokens.",
    "recordId": "index-coop-index-max-supply-10m-s33",
    "surface": "INDEX supply: 10,000,000, no mint function"
   },
   "factors": [
    {
     "evidence": "index-coop-index-max-supply-10m-s33: INDEX token 0x0954906da0Bf32d5479e25f46056d22f08464cab (Ethereum; not a proxy: EIP-1967 implementation, admin and beacon slots all empty; verified source) …",
     "key": "upgrade",
     "label": "Upgradeability",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "Upgradeable; the delay gating the upgrade path is not in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "timelock",
     "label": "Timelock floor",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No enforced admin delay in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "quorum",
     "label": "Signer quorum",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No signer quorum in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "emergency",
     "label": "Emergency / freeze scope",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No pause / freeze authority in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "parity",
     "label": "Docs-vs-chain parity",
     "state": "g",
     "value": "Chain matches or is stronger than the documentation"
    }
   ],
   "finding": "INDEX supply: 10,000,000, no mint function",
   "grade": "aligned",
   "gradeLabel": "ALIGNED",
   "name": "Index Coop",
   "pinnedBlock": 26452373,
   "probe": {
    "block_hash": "0x63bfaa16f0019d8b37e757265d351bd135ad41e6ffa46207284198917123c55d",
    "block_number": 26452373,
    "call_args": [],
    "call_signature": "totalSupply()",
    "chain": "ethereum",
    "check_type": "eth_call",
    "extra_calls": [],
    "id": "index-coop-index-max-supply-10m-s33",
    "repro_calldata": "0x18160ddd",
    "rpc_env_var": "$ETH_RPC_URL",
    "selector_or_slot": "0x18160ddd",
    "target_contract": "0x0954906da0Bf32d5479e25f46056d22f08464cab",
    "target_label": "INDEX token"
   },
   "reconciled": false,
   "reconciledFrom": [],
   "reconciledTo": [],
   "records": 1,
   "rosetteAria": "Index Coop control-plane rosette: Upgradeability not determined; Timelock floor not determined; Signer quorum not determined; Emergency / freeze scope not determined; Docs-vs-chain parity strong",
   "search": "index coop index-coop fully collateralized crypto index products and leveraged indices (ethereum) index 0x0954906da0bf32d5479e25f46056d22f08464cab",
   "slug": "index-coop",
   "summary_short": "INDEX is fully minted at its 10M maximum, as documented",
   "url": "https://pacta.wtf/protocols/index-coop/"
  },
  {
   "baskets": [
    "lending_vaults",
    "stable_rwa"
   ],
   "category": "Yield-Bearing Stablecoin",
   "chains": [
    "ethereum"
   ],
   "deltas": 1,
   "easAttested": true,
   "evidence": {
    "documented": "docs.infinifi.xyz (roles documentation): 'PAUSE / Pause protocol functions / GOVERNOR / UNPAUSE / Unpause functions / GOVERNOR'",
    "observed": "InfiniFiCore 0xF6d48735EcCf12bDC1DF2674b1ce3fcb3bD25490: getRoleAdmin(UNPAUSE) = getRoleAdmin(PAUSE) = keccak256(\"MINOR_ROLES_MANAGER\") (0x9849206c..6512), whose members are the Team Multisig 0x80608f852D152024c0a2087b16939235fEc2400c and the Long Timelock; GOVERNOR is not the admin of either role.",
    "recordId": "infinifi-pause-role-admin-minor-roles-s20",
    "surface": "PAUSE / UNPAUSE role admin: MINOR_ROLES_MANAGER, not GOVERNOR"
   },
   "factors": [
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "upgrade",
     "label": "Upgradeability",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "Upgrade path not in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": "controller fact: getMinDelay() = 604800s",
     "key": "timelock",
     "label": "Timelock floor",
     "state": "g",
     "value": "7d minimum enforced delay across control surfaces"
    },
    {
     "evidence": "controller fact: Safe getThreshold()",
     "key": "quorum",
     "label": "Signer quorum",
     "state": "g",
     "value": "Lowest controlling quorum: 4-of-7"
    },
    {
     "evidence": "infinifi-pause-role-admin-minor-roles-s20: InfiniFiCore 0xF6d48735EcCf12bDC1DF2674b1ce3fcb3bD25490: getRoleAdmin(UNPAUSE) = getRoleAdmin(PAUSE) = keccak256(\"MINOR_ROLES_MANAGER\") (0x9849206c..6512) …",
     "key": "emergency",
     "label": "Emergency / freeze scope",
     "state": "g",
     "value": "Pause / freeze authority scoped behind a multi-signer controller (4-of-N Safe)"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "parity",
     "label": "Docs-vs-chain parity",
     "state": "a",
     "value": "Documentation differs from the chain (parameter delta)"
    }
   ],
   "finding": "PAUSE / UNPAUSE role admin: MINOR_ROLES_MANAGER, not GOVERNOR: docs say docs.infinifi.xyz (roles documentation): 'PAUSE / Pause protocol functions / GOVERNOR / UNPAUSE / Unpause functions / GOVERNOR' · chain says InfiniFiCore 0xF6d48735EcCf12bDC1DF2674b1ce3fcb3bD25490: getRoleAdmin(UNPAUSE) = getRoleAdmin(PAUSE) = keccak256(\"MINOR_ROLES_MANAGER\") (0x9849206c..6512), whose members are the Team Multisig 0x80608f852D152024c0a2087b1…",
   "grade": "delta",
   "gradeLabel": "DELTA",
   "name": "infiniFi",
   "pinnedBlock": 26449594,
   "probe": {
    "block_hash": "0xfa22e277760f1df7134b0af20499d6305ee4e017219a917a61a78aa76e89382d",
    "block_number": 26425374,
    "call_args": [
     "0xe7276a2a84d8de556657ec9cf93a55a7d66f096e529d0582ed08e9e2208b92b5"
    ],
    "call_signature": "getRoleAdmin(bytes32)",
    "chain": "ethereum",
    "check_type": "eth_call",
    "extra_calls": [],
    "id": "infinifi-pause-role-admin-minor-roles-s20",
    "repro_calldata": "0x248a9ca3e7276a2a84d8de556657ec9cf93a55a7d66f096e529d0582ed08e9e2208b92b5",
    "rpc_env_var": "$ETH_RPC_URL",
    "selector_or_slot": "0x248a9ca3",
    "target_contract": "0xF6d48735EcCf12bDC1DF2674b1ce3fcb3bD25490",
    "target_label": "InfiniFiCore role registry"
   },
   "reconciled": false,
   "reconciledFrom": [],
   "reconciledTo": [],
   "records": 4,
   "rosetteAria": "infiniFi control-plane rosette: Upgradeability not determined; Timelock floor strong; Signer quorum strong; Emergency / freeze scope strong; Docs-vs-chain parity weak",
   "search": "infinifi infinifi yield-bearing stablecoin iusd siusd liusd 0x3d18480cc32b6ab3b833dcabd80e76cfd41c48a9 0x4b174afbed7b98ba01f50e36109eee5e6d327c32 0x579b18e60d0245c0f66fa9463610b15e226ae8fd 0x80608f852d152024c0a2087b16939235fec2400c 0xee529a21cea25efdf527e85bb4c597603e14ccfc 0xf6d48735eccf12bdc1df2674b1ce3fcb3bd25490",
   "slug": "infinifi",
   "summary_short": "Pause roles are administered by MINOR_ROLES_MANAGER; docs say GOVERNOR",
   "url": "https://pacta.wtf/protocols/infinifi/"
  },
  {
   "baskets": [],
   "category": "Peggy bridge between Ethereum and a Cosmos-SDK exchange chain (Ethereum)",
   "chains": [
    "ethereum"
   ],
   "deltas": 0,
   "easAttested": false,
   "evidence": {
    "documented": "Injective Bridge documentation is linked for reference (https://injective.com/blog/a-new-era-of-injective-the-volan-mainnet-upgrade). This RPC-pinned record does not compare documentation parameters with the on-chain state.",
    "observed": "Injective Token (0xe28b3B32B6c345A34Ff64674606124Dd5Aceca30) verified on Ethereum Mainnet at canonical block #26,458,556 (4,324 bytes runtime code). EIP-1967 implementation and admin storage slots are both zero (non-EIP-1967 contract). No owner(), admin(), authority(), curator() or AccessControl admin was readable on the contract.",
    "recordId": "injective-bridge-control-plane",
    "surface": "Injective Token · Non-Proxy Bytecode & Controller"
   },
   "factors": [
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "upgrade",
     "label": "Upgradeability",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "Upgrade path not in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "timelock",
     "label": "Timelock floor",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No enforced admin delay in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "quorum",
     "label": "Signer quorum",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No signer quorum in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "emergency",
     "label": "Emergency / freeze scope",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No pause / freeze authority in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "parity",
     "label": "Docs-vs-chain parity",
     "state": "u",
     "value": "Uncompared: documentation not assessed (RPC-observed)"
    }
   ],
   "finding": "Injective Token · Non-Proxy Bytecode & Controller",
   "grade": "observed",
   "gradeLabel": "OBSERVED",
   "name": "Injective Bridge",
   "pinnedBlock": 26458556,
   "probe": {
    "block_hash": "0xe258bb1cbcc988e2dfdba4ba173f9f8690520dba3647cdcae18e0651822769d2",
    "block_number": 26458556,
    "call_args": [],
    "call_signature": "owner()",
    "chain": "ethereum",
    "check_type": "eth_call",
    "extra_calls": [],
    "id": "injective-bridge-control-plane",
    "repro_calldata": "0x8da5cb5b",
    "rpc_env_var": "$ETH_RPC_URL",
    "selector_or_slot": "0x8da5cb5b",
    "target_contract": "0xe28b3B32B6c345A34Ff64674606124Dd5Aceca30",
    "target_label": "Injective Token"
   },
   "reconciled": false,
   "reconciledFrom": [],
   "reconciledTo": [],
   "records": 1,
   "rosetteAria": "Injective Bridge control-plane rosette: Upgradeability not determined; Timelock floor not determined; Signer quorum not determined; Emergency / freeze scope not determined; Docs-vs-chain parity uncompared",
   "search": "injective bridge injective-bridge peggy bridge between ethereum and a cosmos-sdk exchange chain (ethereum) inj 0xe28b3b32b6c345a34ff64674606124dd5aceca30",
   "slug": "injective-bridge",
   "summary_short": "Non-proxy contract no readable owner or admin; docs not assessed",
   "url": "https://pacta.wtf/protocols/injective-bridge/"
  },
  {
   "baskets": [
    "lending_vaults"
   ],
   "category": "Fractional-reserve lending that mints USDi (Ethereum)",
   "chains": [
    "ethereum"
   ],
   "deltas": 0,
   "easAttested": false,
   "evidence": {
    "documented": "Interest Protocol documentation is linked for reference (). This RPC-pinned record does not compare documentation parameters with the on-chain state.",
    "observed": "USDI Token (0x2A54bA2964C8Cd459Dc568853F79813a60761B58) verified on Ethereum Mainnet at canonical block #26,458,556 (2,151 bytes runtime code). EIP-1967 proxy: implementation 0x57d0E13F353d630ab5218aC841C88985AB31A066, admin 0x3D9d8c08dC16Aa104b5B24aBDd1aD857e2c0D8C5. The EIP-1967 admin slot holds contract ProxyAdmin 0x3D9d8c08dC16Aa104b5B24aBDd1aD857e2c0D8C5. That controller is in turn controlled by externally owned account (no code) 0x3CB68a6762041aA05E762814A8791CA9d98E79A0.",
    "recordId": "interest-protocol-control-plane",
    "surface": "USDI Token · EIP-1967 Proxy & Controller Chain"
   },
   "factors": [
    {
     "evidence": "interest-protocol-control-plane: USDI Token (0x2A54bA2964C8Cd459Dc568853F79813a60761B58) verified on Ethereum Mainnet at canonical block #26,458,556 (2,151 bytes runtime code). EIP-1967 proxy …",
     "key": "upgrade",
     "label": "Upgradeability",
     "state": "a",
     "value": "Upgradeable with no enforced delay: no timelock in front of upgrades"
    },
    {
     "evidence": "interest-protocol-control-plane: USDI Token (0x2A54bA2964C8Cd459Dc568853F79813a60761B58) verified on Ethereum Mainnet at canonical block #26,458,556 (2,151 bytes runtime code). EIP-1967 proxy …",
     "key": "timelock",
     "label": "Timelock floor",
     "state": "a",
     "value": "0s minimum enforced delay across control surfaces"
    },
    {
     "evidence": "interest-protocol-control-plane: … controller is in turn controlled by externally owned account (no code) 0x3CB68a6762041aA05E762814A8791CA9d98E79A0.",
     "key": "quorum",
     "label": "Signer quorum",
     "state": "a",
     "value": "Lowest controlling quorum: a single key"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "emergency",
     "label": "Emergency / freeze scope",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No pause / freeze authority in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "parity",
     "label": "Docs-vs-chain parity",
     "state": "u",
     "value": "Uncompared: documentation not assessed (RPC-observed)"
    }
   ],
   "finding": "USDI Token · EIP-1967 Proxy & Controller Chain",
   "grade": "observed",
   "gradeLabel": "OBSERVED",
   "name": "Interest Protocol",
   "pinnedBlock": 26458556,
   "probe": {
    "block_hash": "0xe258bb1cbcc988e2dfdba4ba173f9f8690520dba3647cdcae18e0651822769d2",
    "block_number": 26458556,
    "call_args": [],
    "call_signature": null,
    "chain": "ethereum",
    "check_type": "eth_getStorageAt",
    "extra_calls": [],
    "id": "interest-protocol-control-plane",
    "repro_calldata": null,
    "rpc_env_var": "$ETH_RPC_URL",
    "selector_or_slot": "0xb53127684a568b3173ae13b9f8a6016e243e63b6e8ee1178d6a717850b5d6103",
    "target_contract": "0x2A54bA2964C8Cd459Dc568853F79813a60761B58",
    "target_label": "USDI Token"
   },
   "reconciled": false,
   "reconciledFrom": [],
   "reconciledTo": [],
   "records": 1,
   "rosetteAria": "Interest Protocol control-plane rosette: Upgradeability weak; Timelock floor weak; Signer quorum weak; Emergency / freeze scope not determined; Docs-vs-chain parity uncompared",
   "search": "interest protocol interest-protocol fractional-reserve lending that mints usdi (ethereum) usdi 0x2a54ba2964c8cd459dc568853f79813a60761b58 0x3cb68a6762041aa05e762814a8791ca9d98e79a0 0x3d9d8c08dc16aa104b5b24abdd1ad857e2c0d8c5 0x57d0e13f353d630ab5218ac841c88985ab31a066",
   "slug": "interest-protocol",
   "summary_short": "Upgradeable proxy controlled by a contract; docs not assessed",
   "url": "https://pacta.wtf/protocols/interest-protocol/"
  },
  {
   "baskets": [
    "lending_vaults",
    "stable_rwa"
   ],
   "category": "Fixed-Rate Lending",
   "chains": [
    "ethereum"
   ],
   "deltas": 2,
   "easAttested": true,
   "evidence": {
    "documented": "Working-groups governance documentation lists 5-of-9 Policy Committee multisig.",
    "observed": "GovernorMills (0xBeCCB6bb0aa4ab551966A7E4B97cec74bb359Bf6) guardian() wrapper (0x941c2699eC7E55a50Bde030d8E1e70649839259D) references Policy Committee Safe (0x4b6c63E6a94ef26E2dF60b89372db2d8e211F1B7) with getThreshold() = 4, getOwners().length = 7 (4-of-7 Gnosis Safe); GovernorMills.timelock() (0x926dF14a23BE491164dCF93f4c468A50ef659D5B) delay() = 172800s (48h).",
    "recordId": "inverse-finance-firm-policy-safe",
    "surface": "Policy Committee Safe Quorum & GovernorMills Timelock"
   },
   "factors": [
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "upgrade",
     "label": "Upgradeability",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "Upgrade path not in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": "inverse-finance-firm-policy-safe: observed_delay_seconds = 172800",
     "key": "timelock",
     "label": "Timelock floor",
     "state": "g",
     "value": "2d minimum enforced delay across control surfaces"
    },
    {
     "evidence": "inverse-firm-policy-safe-3of6-s30: … inverse-finance-firm-policy-safe) and already 3-of-6 at #26,406,106 and at the protocol's …",
     "key": "quorum",
     "label": "Signer quorum",
     "state": "g",
     "value": "Lowest controlling quorum: 3-of-6"
    },
    {
     "evidence": "inverse-finance-firm-policy-safe: GovernorMills (0xBeCCB6bb0aa4ab551966A7E4B97cec74bb359Bf6) guardian() wrapper (0x941c2699eC7E55a50Bde030d8E1e70649839259D) references Policy Committee Safe …",
     "key": "emergency",
     "label": "Emergency / freeze scope",
     "state": "g",
     "value": "Pause / freeze authority scoped behind a multi-signer controller (3-of-N Safe)"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "parity",
     "label": "Docs-vs-chain parity",
     "state": "a",
     "value": "Documentation differs from the chain (parameter delta)"
    }
   ],
   "finding": "Policy Committee Safe Quorum & GovernorMills Timelock: docs say Working-groups governance documentation lists 5-of-9 Policy Committee multisig. · chain says GovernorMills (0xBeCCB6bb0aa4ab551966A7E4B97cec74bb359Bf6) guardian() wrapper (0x941c2699eC7E55a50Bde030d8E1e70649839259D) references Policy Committee Safe (0x4b6c63E6a94ef26E2dF60b89372db2d8e211F1B7) with getThreshold(…",
   "grade": "delta",
   "gradeLabel": "DELTA",
   "name": "Inverse Finance (FiRM)",
   "pinnedBlock": 26449594,
   "probe": {
    "block_hash": "0x8bf896b892683ff3267b88b367ab015a70cf5caf53542eb405f4f648f6bcde8a",
    "block_number": 26399876,
    "call_args": [],
    "call_signature": "getThreshold()",
    "chain": "ethereum",
    "check_type": "eth_call",
    "extra_calls": [],
    "id": "inverse-finance-firm-policy-safe",
    "repro_calldata": "0xe75235b8",
    "rpc_env_var": "$ETH_RPC_URL",
    "selector_or_slot": "0xe75235b8",
    "target_contract": "0x4b6c63E6a94ef26E2dF60b89372db2d8e211F1B7",
    "target_label": "Policy Committee Safe"
   },
   "reconciled": false,
   "reconciledFrom": [],
   "reconciledTo": [],
   "records": 4,
   "rosetteAria": "Inverse Finance (FiRM) control-plane rosette: Upgradeability not determined; Timelock floor strong; Signer quorum strong; Emergency / freeze scope strong; Docs-vs-chain parity weak",
   "search": "inverse finance (firm) inverse-finance-firm fixed-rate lending dola inv firm 0x01eca33e20a4c379bd8a5361f896a7dd2bae4ce8 0x4b6c63e6a94ef26e2df60b89372db2d8e211f1b7 0x926df14a23be491164dcf93f4c468a50ef659d5b 0x941c2699ec7e55a50bde030d8e1e70649839259d 0xbeccb6bb0aa4ab551966a7e4b97cec74bb359bf6 0xc45e9c231ab5d9bd3f1131e7901b100d8d236c4d",
   "slug": "inverse-finance-firm",
   "summary_short": "sDOLA staleness limit reads 86,500 s, was 0 (check off); docs say typically 1-24 hours",
   "url": "https://pacta.wtf/protocols/inverse-finance-firm/"
  },
  {
   "baskets": [
    "base",
    "lending_vaults"
   ],
   "category": "Onchain Capital Allocation Vault Factory (Base)",
   "chains": [
    "base"
   ],
   "deltas": 0,
   "easAttested": true,
   "evidence": {
    "documented": "'The factory proxy stays at 0x1455717668fA96534f675856347A973fA907e922 ; its implementation is now IporFusionFactoryImpl 0x378fEb2E96082FB965E2BB922AEE484d07c14014 .' (ipor.io/developer-news/smart-contracts-2026-09-28-base)",
    "observed": "IPOR Fusion ERC1967Proxy 0x1455717668fA96534f675856347A973fA907e922 (Base): EIP-1967 implementation slot = 0x378fEb2E96082FB965E2BB922AEE484d07c14014; upgradeable (EIP-1967 implementation exposing upgradeToAndCall (UUPS)).",
    "recordId": "ipor-fusion-upgradeability-s26",
    "surface": "IPOR Fusion ERC1967Proxy: upgradeable (UUPS), as documented"
   },
   "factors": [
    {
     "evidence": "ipor-fusion-upgradeability-s26: IPOR Fusion ERC1967Proxy 0x1455717668fA96534f675856347A973fA907e922 (Base): EIP-1967 implementation slot = 0x378fEb2E96082FB965E2BB922AEE484d07c14014",
     "key": "upgrade",
     "label": "Upgradeability",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "Upgradeable; the delay gating the upgrade path is not in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "timelock",
     "label": "Timelock floor",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No enforced admin delay in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "quorum",
     "label": "Signer quorum",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No signer quorum in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "emergency",
     "label": "Emergency / freeze scope",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No pause / freeze authority in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "parity",
     "label": "Docs-vs-chain parity",
     "state": "g",
     "value": "Chain matches or is stronger than the documentation"
    }
   ],
   "finding": "IPOR Fusion ERC1967Proxy: upgradeable (UUPS), as documented",
   "grade": "aligned",
   "gradeLabel": "ALIGNED",
   "name": "IPOR Fusion",
   "pinnedBlock": 58885628,
   "probe": {
    "block_hash": "0x732b5472c93d5c4bf65f39440097e2b0143d5875cfec028646f7f06123a20094",
    "block_number": 58885628,
    "call_args": [],
    "call_signature": null,
    "chain": "base",
    "check_type": "eth_getStorageAt",
    "extra_calls": [],
    "id": "ipor-fusion-upgradeability-s26",
    "repro_calldata": null,
    "rpc_env_var": "$BASE_RPC_URL",
    "selector_or_slot": "0x360894a13ba1a3210667c828492db98dca3e2076cc3735a920a3ca505d382bbc",
    "target_contract": "0x1455717668fA96534f675856347A973fA907e922",
    "target_label": "IPOR Fusion ERC1967Proxy"
   },
   "reconciled": false,
   "reconciledFrom": [],
   "reconciledTo": [],
   "records": 1,
   "rosetteAria": "IPOR Fusion control-plane rosette: Upgradeability not determined; Timelock floor not determined; Signer quorum not determined; Emergency / freeze scope not determined; Docs-vs-chain parity strong",
   "search": "ipor fusion ipor-fusion onchain capital allocation vault factory (base) ipor 0x1455717668fa96534f675856347a973fa907e922 0x378feb2e96082fb965e2bb922aee484d07c14014",
   "slug": "ipor-fusion",
   "summary_short": "The IPOR Fusion ERC1967Proxy is upgradeable (UUPS), as its docs state",
   "url": "https://pacta.wtf/protocols/ipor-fusion/"
  },
  {
   "baskets": [
    "stable_rwa"
   ],
   "category": "Yen-tracking stablecoin minted permissionlessly by depositing crypto assets (Ethereum)",
   "chains": [
    "ethereum"
   ],
   "deltas": 0,
   "easAttested": true,
   "evidence": {
    "documented": "'Ordinary configuration changes and upgrades to JPY DeFi's proprietary layers are proposed by a multisig and executed through a 12-hour TimelockController.' (jpydf.gitbook.io/jpy-defi/governance/governance-and-timelock.md)",
    "observed": "JPY DeFi TimelockController 0xf27de84F11E089B838769EDFcFf9872BC45c84Fe (Ethereum): getMinDelay() = 43200s (12 h).",
    "recordId": "jpy-defi-timelock-delay-s30",
    "surface": "JPY DeFi timelock: 12-hour minimum delay, as documented"
   },
   "factors": [
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "upgrade",
     "label": "Upgradeability",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "Upgrade path not in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": "controller fact: getMinDelay() = 43200s",
     "key": "timelock",
     "label": "Timelock floor",
     "state": "b",
     "value": "12h minimum enforced delay across control surfaces"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "quorum",
     "label": "Signer quorum",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No signer quorum in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "emergency",
     "label": "Emergency / freeze scope",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No pause / freeze authority in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "parity",
     "label": "Docs-vs-chain parity",
     "state": "g",
     "value": "Chain matches or is stronger than the documentation"
    }
   ],
   "finding": "JPY DeFi timelock: 12-hour minimum delay, as documented",
   "grade": "aligned",
   "gradeLabel": "ALIGNED",
   "name": "JPY DeFi",
   "pinnedBlock": 26449594,
   "probe": {
    "block_hash": "0xbe263d5b378dcb7c3c4e18bd8e388f0cb2dab1adacd83de2be58c9408b377287",
    "block_number": 26449594,
    "call_args": [],
    "call_signature": "getMinDelay()",
    "chain": "ethereum",
    "check_type": "eth_call",
    "extra_calls": [],
    "id": "jpy-defi-timelock-delay-s30",
    "repro_calldata": "0xf27a0c92",
    "rpc_env_var": "$ETH_RPC_URL",
    "selector_or_slot": "0xf27a0c92",
    "target_contract": "0xf27de84F11E089B838769EDFcFf9872BC45c84Fe",
    "target_label": "Governance TimelockController queueing upgrades of the dToken and Strategy layers"
   },
   "reconciled": false,
   "reconciledFrom": [],
   "reconciledTo": [],
   "records": 1,
   "rosetteAria": "JPY DeFi control-plane rosette: Upgradeability not determined; Timelock floor moderate; Signer quorum not determined; Emergency / freeze scope not determined; Docs-vs-chain parity strong",
   "search": "jpy defi jpy-defi yen-tracking stablecoin minted permissionlessly by depositing crypto assets (ethereum) jpy 0xf27de84f11e089b838769edfcff9872bc45c84fe",
   "slug": "jpy-defi",
   "summary_short": "JPY DeFi changes wait a 12-hour timelock, as documented",
   "url": "https://pacta.wtf/protocols/jpy-defi/"
  },
  {
   "baskets": [
    "stable_rwa"
   ],
   "category": "Programmable crowdfunding treasuries for communities (Ethereum)",
   "chains": [
    "ethereum"
   ],
   "deltas": 0,
   "easAttested": false,
   "evidence": {
    "documented": "Juicebox V1 documentation is linked for reference (https://docs.juicebox.money/). This RPC-pinned record does not compare documentation parameters with the on-chain state.",
    "observed": "Juicebox (Tickets) (0x3abF2A4f8452cCC2CF7b4C1e4663147600646f66) verified on Ethereum Mainnet at canonical block #26,458,556 (5,940 bytes runtime code). EIP-1967 implementation and admin storage slots are both zero (non-EIP-1967 contract). Direct owner() returns contract TicketBooth 0xee2eBCcB7CDb34a8A822b589F9E8427C24351bfc.",
    "recordId": "juicebox-v1-control-plane",
    "surface": "Juicebox (Tickets) · Non-Proxy Bytecode & Controller"
   },
   "factors": [
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "upgrade",
     "label": "Upgradeability",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "Upgrade path not in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "timelock",
     "label": "Timelock floor",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No enforced admin delay in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "quorum",
     "label": "Signer quorum",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No signer quorum in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "emergency",
     "label": "Emergency / freeze scope",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No pause / freeze authority in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "parity",
     "label": "Docs-vs-chain parity",
     "state": "u",
     "value": "Uncompared: documentation not assessed (RPC-observed)"
    }
   ],
   "finding": "Juicebox (Tickets) · Non-Proxy Bytecode & Controller",
   "grade": "observed",
   "gradeLabel": "OBSERVED",
   "name": "Juicebox V1",
   "pinnedBlock": 26458556,
   "probe": {
    "block_hash": "0xe258bb1cbcc988e2dfdba4ba173f9f8690520dba3647cdcae18e0651822769d2",
    "block_number": 26458556,
    "call_args": [],
    "call_signature": "owner()",
    "chain": "ethereum",
    "check_type": "eth_call",
    "extra_calls": [],
    "id": "juicebox-v1-control-plane",
    "repro_calldata": "0x8da5cb5b",
    "rpc_env_var": "$ETH_RPC_URL",
    "selector_or_slot": "0x8da5cb5b",
    "target_contract": "0x3abF2A4f8452cCC2CF7b4C1e4663147600646f66",
    "target_label": "Juicebox (Tickets)"
   },
   "reconciled": false,
   "reconciledFrom": [],
   "reconciledTo": [],
   "records": 1,
   "rosetteAria": "Juicebox V1 control-plane rosette: Upgradeability not determined; Timelock floor not determined; Signer quorum not determined; Emergency / freeze scope not determined; Docs-vs-chain parity uncompared",
   "search": "juicebox v1 juicebox-v1 programmable crowdfunding treasuries for communities (ethereum) jbx 0x3abf2a4f8452ccc2cf7b4c1e4663147600646f66 0xee2ebccb7cdb34a8a822b589f9e8427c24351bfc",
   "slug": "juicebox-v1",
   "summary_short": "Non-proxy contract controlled by a contract; docs not assessed",
   "url": "https://pacta.wtf/protocols/juicebox-v1/"
  },
  {
   "baskets": [
    "eth_lst_lrt",
    "lending_vaults"
   ],
   "category": "Institutional risk manager curating a restaking vault for liquid staking collateral (Ethereum)",
   "chains": [
    "ethereum"
   ],
   "deltas": 0,
   "easAttested": false,
   "evidence": {
    "documented": "K3 Capital documentation is linked for reference (https://docs.k3.capital/). This RPC-pinned record does not compare documentation parameters with the on-chain state.",
    "observed": "MigratableEntityProxy (0xdC47953c816531a8CA9E1D461AB53687d48EEA26) verified on Ethereum Mainnet at canonical block #26,458,556 (808 bytes runtime code). EIP-1967 proxy: implementation 0xDd649AdaB2e67cAdC2EC29d75ABe73f3Df08065c, admin 0xAEb6bdd95c502390db8f52c8909F703E9Af6a346. The EIP-1967 admin slot holds contract VaultFactory 0xAEb6bdd95c502390db8f52c8909F703E9Af6a346. That controller is in turn controlled by Safe 2-of-3 0x5721ce64Ee0D772Ce613b62D411350091C544cD0.",
    "recordId": "k3-capital-control-plane",
    "surface": "MigratableEntityProxy · EIP-1967 Proxy & Controller Chain"
   },
   "factors": [
    {
     "evidence": "k3-capital-control-plane: is_eip1967_proxy = true",
     "key": "upgrade",
     "label": "Upgradeability",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "Upgradeable; the delay gating the upgrade path is not in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "timelock",
     "label": "Timelock floor",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No enforced admin delay in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": "k3-capital-control-plane: … controller is in turn controlled by Safe 2-of-3 0x5721ce64Ee0D772Ce613b62D411350091C544cD0.",
     "key": "quorum",
     "label": "Signer quorum",
     "state": "b",
     "value": "Lowest controlling quorum: 2-of-3"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "emergency",
     "label": "Emergency / freeze scope",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No pause / freeze authority in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "parity",
     "label": "Docs-vs-chain parity",
     "state": "u",
     "value": "Uncompared: documentation not assessed (RPC-observed)"
    }
   ],
   "finding": "MigratableEntityProxy · EIP-1967 Proxy & Controller Chain",
   "grade": "observed",
   "gradeLabel": "OBSERVED",
   "name": "K3 Capital",
   "pinnedBlock": 26458556,
   "probe": {
    "block_hash": "0xe258bb1cbcc988e2dfdba4ba173f9f8690520dba3647cdcae18e0651822769d2",
    "block_number": 26458556,
    "call_args": [],
    "call_signature": null,
    "chain": "ethereum",
    "check_type": "eth_getStorageAt",
    "extra_calls": [],
    "id": "k3-capital-control-plane",
    "repro_calldata": null,
    "rpc_env_var": "$ETH_RPC_URL",
    "selector_or_slot": "0xb53127684a568b3173ae13b9f8a6016e243e63b6e8ee1178d6a717850b5d6103",
    "target_contract": "0xdC47953c816531a8CA9E1D461AB53687d48EEA26",
    "target_label": "MigratableEntityProxy"
   },
   "reconciled": false,
   "reconciledFrom": [],
   "reconciledTo": [],
   "records": 1,
   "rosetteAria": "K3 Capital control-plane rosette: Upgradeability not determined; Timelock floor not determined; Signer quorum moderate; Emergency / freeze scope not determined; Docs-vs-chain parity uncompared",
   "search": "k3 capital k3-capital institutional risk manager curating a restaking vault for liquid staking collateral (ethereum) k3 0x5721ce64ee0d772ce613b62d411350091c544cd0 0xaeb6bdd95c502390db8f52c8909f703e9af6a346 0xdc47953c816531a8ca9e1d461ab53687d48eea26 0xdd649adab2e67cadc2ec29d75abe73f3df08065c",
   "slug": "k3-capital",
   "summary_short": "Upgradeable proxy controlled by a 2-of-3 Safe; docs not assessed",
   "url": "https://pacta.wtf/protocols/k3-capital/"
  },
  {
   "baskets": [],
   "category": "DeFi-focused network on the Agglayer; upgrades proposed by the Katana Admin multisig",
   "chains": [
    "ethereum"
   ],
   "deltas": 0,
   "easAttested": true,
   "evidence": {
    "documented": "'**3-of-5 multisig**, controlled by major network partners Katana Foundation, GSR, and Polygon Labs.' (docs.katana.network/katana/core-concepts/governance/index.md)",
    "observed": "Katana Admin 0xd512543315c95506E4209805b888414EEF15C8C4 (Ethereum; the governance page names it as the Admin multisig address, next to the 3-of-5 statement): a Safe, getThreshold() = 3 of getOwners() = 5; guard slot empty; getModulesPaginated() lists no module. The same page says upgrades proposed by the Admin enter a 10-day timelock; that timelock is not identified here (no Katana-specific timelock is readable without event logs), so this record compares only the documented quorum.",
    "recordId": "katana-admin-multisig-3-of-5-s37",
    "surface": "Katana Admin multisig (Ethereum): 3-of-5 Safe (docs: 3-of-5)"
   },
   "factors": [
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "upgrade",
     "label": "Upgradeability",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "Upgrade path not in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "timelock",
     "label": "Timelock floor",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No enforced admin delay in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": "katana-admin-multisig-3-of-5-s37: … Admin multisig address, next to the 3-of-5 statement): a Safe, getThreshold() …",
     "key": "quorum",
     "label": "Signer quorum",
     "state": "g",
     "value": "Lowest controlling quorum: 3-of-5"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "emergency",
     "label": "Emergency / freeze scope",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No pause / freeze authority in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "parity",
     "label": "Docs-vs-chain parity",
     "state": "g",
     "value": "Chain matches or is stronger than the documentation"
    }
   ],
   "finding": "Katana Admin multisig (Ethereum): 3-of-5 Safe (docs: 3-of-5)",
   "grade": "aligned",
   "gradeLabel": "ALIGNED",
   "name": "Katana",
   "pinnedBlock": 26458556,
   "probe": {
    "block_hash": "0xe258bb1cbcc988e2dfdba4ba173f9f8690520dba3647cdcae18e0651822769d2",
    "block_number": 26458556,
    "call_args": [],
    "call_signature": "getThreshold()",
    "chain": "ethereum",
    "check_type": "eth_call",
    "extra_calls": [],
    "id": "katana-admin-multisig-3-of-5-s37",
    "repro_calldata": "0xe75235b8",
    "rpc_env_var": "$ETH_RPC_URL",
    "selector_or_slot": "0xe75235b8",
    "target_contract": "0xd512543315c95506E4209805b888414EEF15C8C4",
    "target_label": "Katana Admin multisig (Ethereum Safe)"
   },
   "reconciled": false,
   "reconciledFrom": [],
   "reconciledTo": [],
   "records": 1,
   "rosetteAria": "Katana control-plane rosette: Upgradeability not determined; Timelock floor not determined; Signer quorum strong; Emergency / freeze scope not determined; Docs-vs-chain parity strong",
   "search": "katana katana defi-focused network on the agglayer; upgrades proposed by the katana admin multisig kat 0xd512543315c95506e4209805b888414eef15c8c4",
   "slug": "katana",
   "summary_short": "The Katana Admin multisig is 3-of-5, as documented",
   "url": "https://pacta.wtf/protocols/katana/"
  },
  {
   "baskets": [
    "eth_lst_lrt"
   ],
   "category": "Liquid Restaking",
   "chains": [
    "ethereum"
   ],
   "deltas": 0,
   "easAttested": true,
   "evidence": {
    "documented": "Kelp DAO security & contract documentation specifies 10-day TimelockController upgrade governance and multisig admin.",
    "observed": "rsETH (0xA1290d69c65A6Fe4DF752f95823fae25cB99e5A7) EIP-1967 admin slot = ProxyAdmin (0xb61e0E39b6d4030C36A176f576aaBE44BF59Dc78), owner() = TimelockController (0x49bD9989E31aD35B0A62c20BE86335196A3135B1, getMinDelay() = 864000s / 10d); LRTConfig (0x947Cb49334e6571ccBFEF1f1f1178d8469D65ec7) DEFAULT_ADMIN_ROLE held by 6-of-11 Safe (0xb3696a817D01C8623E66D156B6798291fa10a46d); rsETH totalSupply = 338,071.33 rsETH.",
    "recordId": "kelp-dao-rseth-proxy-admin-and-timelock",
    "surface": "ProxyAdmin 10d Timelock & LRTConfig Admin Safe"
   },
   "factors": [
    {
     "evidence": "kelp-dao-rseth-proxy-admin-and-timelock: rsETH (0xA1290d69c65A6Fe4DF752f95823fae25cB99e5A7) EIP-1967 admin slot = ProxyAdmin (0xb61e0E39b6d4030C36A176f576aaBE44BF59Dc78), owner() = TimelockController …",
     "key": "upgrade",
     "label": "Upgradeability",
     "state": "g",
     "value": "Upgradeable behind a ≥48h delay (10d)"
    },
    {
     "evidence": "controller fact: getMinDelay() = 864000s",
     "key": "timelock",
     "label": "Timelock floor",
     "state": "g",
     "value": "10d minimum enforced delay across control surfaces"
    },
    {
     "evidence": "kelp-dao-rseth-proxy-admin-and-timelock: … (0x947Cb49334e6571ccBFEF1f1f1178d8469D65ec7) DEFAULT_ADMIN_ROLE held by 6-of-11 Safe (0xb3696a817D01C8623E66D156B6798291fa10a46d); …",
     "key": "quorum",
     "label": "Signer quorum",
     "state": "g",
     "value": "Lowest controlling quorum: 6-of-11"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "emergency",
     "label": "Emergency / freeze scope",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No pause / freeze authority in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "parity",
     "label": "Docs-vs-chain parity",
     "state": "g",
     "value": "Chain matches or is stronger than the documentation"
    }
   ],
   "finding": "ProxyAdmin 10d Timelock & LRTConfig Admin Safe",
   "grade": "aligned",
   "gradeLabel": "ALIGNED",
   "name": "Kelp DAO (rsETH)",
   "pinnedBlock": 26451608,
   "probe": {
    "block_hash": "0xd04a5e8aa3500c5b60d90c25a810ef28eb9d1bfffadf28f1da58a31ed90582dc",
    "block_number": 26402160,
    "call_args": [],
    "call_signature": "getMinDelay()",
    "chain": "ethereum",
    "check_type": "eth_call",
    "extra_calls": [],
    "id": "kelp-dao-rseth-proxy-admin-and-timelock",
    "repro_calldata": "0xf27a0c92",
    "rpc_env_var": "$ETH_RPC_URL",
    "selector_or_slot": "0xf27a0c92",
    "target_contract": "0x49bD9989E31aD35B0A62c20BE86335196A3135B1",
    "target_label": "KelpTimelockController"
   },
   "reconciled": false,
   "reconciledFrom": [],
   "reconciledTo": [],
   "records": 4,
   "rosetteAria": "Kelp DAO (rsETH) control-plane rosette: Upgradeability strong; Timelock floor strong; Signer quorum strong; Emergency / freeze scope not determined; Docs-vs-chain parity strong",
   "search": "kelp dao (rseth) kelp-dao-rseth liquid restaking rseth 0x036676389e48133b63a802f8635ad39e752d375d 0x49bd9989e31ad35b0a62c20be86335196a3135b1 0x7aad74b7f0d60d5867b59dbd377a71783425af47 0x85d456b2dff1fd8245387c0bfb64dfb700e98ef3 0x947cb49334e6571ccbfef1f1f1178d8469d65ec7 0xa1290d69c65a6fe4df752f95823fae25cb99e5a7 0xb3696a817d01c8623e66d156b6798291fa10a46d 0xb61e0e39b6d4030c36a176f576aabe44bf59dc78 0xcbcdd778aa25476f203814214dd3e9b9c46829a1",
   "slug": "kelp-dao-rseth",
   "summary_short": "ProxyAdmin sits behind a 10-day timelock; config admin Safe as documented",
   "url": "https://pacta.wtf/protocols/kelp-dao-rseth/"
  },
  {
   "baskets": [],
   "category": "Liquidity pools backing derivatives trading on trusted price feeds (Ethereum)",
   "chains": [
    "ethereum"
   ],
   "deltas": 0,
   "easAttested": false,
   "evidence": {
    "documented": "Kine Finance documentation is linked for reference (). This RPC-pinned record does not compare documentation parameters with the on-chain state.",
    "observed": "Unitroller (0xbB7D94a423f4978545ecf73161f0678e8AfD1a92) verified on Ethereum Mainnet at canonical block #26,458,556 (1,533 bytes runtime code). EIP-1967 implementation and admin storage slots are both zero (non-EIP-1967 contract). Direct admin() returns timelock (2 d delay) 0x9E8e622e0bA0deE491Fbc42d1Bb12Ab947e2D03B. That controller is in turn controlled by contract KineMultiSigWallet 0xa6e17aE4b683Ed2Ee7cB7414A92bD8316f330191.",
    "recordId": "kine-finance-control-plane",
    "surface": "Unitroller · Non-Proxy Bytecode & Controller"
   },
   "factors": [
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "upgrade",
     "label": "Upgradeability",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "Upgrade path not in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "timelock",
     "label": "Timelock floor",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No enforced admin delay in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "quorum",
     "label": "Signer quorum",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No signer quorum in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "emergency",
     "label": "Emergency / freeze scope",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No pause / freeze authority in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "parity",
     "label": "Docs-vs-chain parity",
     "state": "u",
     "value": "Uncompared: documentation not assessed (RPC-observed)"
    }
   ],
   "finding": "Unitroller · Non-Proxy Bytecode & Controller",
   "grade": "observed",
   "gradeLabel": "OBSERVED",
   "name": "Kine Finance",
   "pinnedBlock": 26458556,
   "probe": {
    "block_hash": "0xe258bb1cbcc988e2dfdba4ba173f9f8690520dba3647cdcae18e0651822769d2",
    "block_number": 26458556,
    "call_args": [],
    "call_signature": "admin()",
    "chain": "ethereum",
    "check_type": "eth_call",
    "extra_calls": [],
    "id": "kine-finance-control-plane",
    "repro_calldata": "0xf851a440",
    "rpc_env_var": "$ETH_RPC_URL",
    "selector_or_slot": "0xf851a440",
    "target_contract": "0xbB7D94a423f4978545ecf73161f0678e8AfD1a92",
    "target_label": "Unitroller"
   },
   "reconciled": false,
   "reconciledFrom": [],
   "reconciledTo": [],
   "records": 1,
   "rosetteAria": "Kine Finance control-plane rosette: Upgradeability not determined; Timelock floor not determined; Signer quorum not determined; Emergency / freeze scope not determined; Docs-vs-chain parity uncompared",
   "search": "kine finance kine-finance liquidity pools backing derivatives trading on trusted price feeds (ethereum) kine 0x9e8e622e0ba0dee491fbc42d1bb12ab947e2d03b 0xa6e17ae4b683ed2ee7cb7414a92bd8316f330191 0xbb7d94a423f4978545ecf73161f0678e8afd1a92",
   "slug": "kine-finance",
   "summary_short": "Non-proxy contract controlled by a timelock; docs not assessed",
   "url": "https://pacta.wtf/protocols/kine-finance/"
  },
  {
   "baskets": [
    "eth_lst_lrt",
    "lending_vaults"
   ],
   "category": "Vault pooling restaking reward tokens for LRT projects (Ethereum)",
   "chains": [
    "ethereum"
   ],
   "deltas": 0,
   "easAttested": false,
   "evidence": {
    "documented": "King Protocol documentation is linked for reference (https://docs.kingprotocol.org/). This RPC-pinned record does not compare documentation parameters with the on-chain state.",
    "observed": "King Protocol (UUPSProxy) (0x8F08B70456eb22f6109F57b8fafE862ED28E6040) verified on Ethereum Mainnet at canonical block #26,458,556 (141 bytes runtime code). EIP-1967 proxy: implementation 0x1cB489ef513E1Cc35C4657c91853A2E6fF1957dE, admin slot zero. No owner(), admin(), authority(), curator() or AccessControl admin was readable on the contract.",
    "recordId": "king-protocol-control-plane",
    "surface": "King Protocol (UUPSProxy) · EIP-1967 Proxy & Controller Chain"
   },
   "factors": [
    {
     "evidence": "king-protocol-control-plane: King Protocol (UUPSProxy) (0x8F08B70456eb22f6109F57b8fafE862ED28E6040) verified on Ethereum Mainnet at canonical block #26,458,556 (141 bytes runtime code). …",
     "key": "upgrade",
     "label": "Upgradeability",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "Upgradeable; the delay gating the upgrade path is not in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "timelock",
     "label": "Timelock floor",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No enforced admin delay in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "quorum",
     "label": "Signer quorum",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No signer quorum in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "emergency",
     "label": "Emergency / freeze scope",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No pause / freeze authority in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "parity",
     "label": "Docs-vs-chain parity",
     "state": "u",
     "value": "Uncompared: documentation not assessed (RPC-observed)"
    }
   ],
   "finding": "King Protocol (UUPSProxy) · EIP-1967 Proxy & Controller Chain",
   "grade": "observed",
   "gradeLabel": "OBSERVED",
   "name": "King Protocol",
   "pinnedBlock": 26458556,
   "probe": {
    "block_hash": "0xe258bb1cbcc988e2dfdba4ba173f9f8690520dba3647cdcae18e0651822769d2",
    "block_number": 26458556,
    "call_args": [],
    "call_signature": "owner()",
    "chain": "ethereum",
    "check_type": "eth_call",
    "extra_calls": [],
    "id": "king-protocol-control-plane",
    "repro_calldata": "0x8da5cb5b",
    "rpc_env_var": "$ETH_RPC_URL",
    "selector_or_slot": "0x8da5cb5b",
    "target_contract": "0x8F08B70456eb22f6109F57b8fafE862ED28E6040",
    "target_label": "King Protocol (UUPSProxy)"
   },
   "reconciled": false,
   "reconciledFrom": [],
   "reconciledTo": [],
   "records": 1,
   "rosetteAria": "King Protocol control-plane rosette: Upgradeability not determined; Timelock floor not determined; Signer quorum not determined; Emergency / freeze scope not determined; Docs-vs-chain parity uncompared",
   "search": "king protocol king-protocol vault pooling restaking reward tokens for lrt projects (ethereum) king 0x1cb489ef513e1cc35c4657c91853a2e6ff1957de 0x8f08b70456eb22f6109f57b8fafe862ed28e6040",
   "slug": "king-protocol",
   "summary_short": "Upgradeable proxy no readable owner or admin; docs not assessed",
   "url": "https://pacta.wtf/protocols/king-protocol/"
  },
  {
   "baskets": [
    "lending_vaults",
    "stable_rwa"
   ],
   "category": "Onchain Asset Manager & Risk Curator (DAO treasuries) (Ethereum)",
   "chains": [
    "ethereum"
   ],
   "deltas": 0,
   "easAttested": true,
   "evidence": {
    "documented": "'Security Council Safe (5/8), [`0x8b884f80B3B839F52b6cE168f133e7a5D1f0A537`]' (docs.kpk.io/llms-full.txt)",
    "observed": "KPK Security Council Safe 0x8b884f80B3B839F52b6cE168f133e7a5D1f0A537 (Ethereum): getThreshold() = 5 of 8 owners. The documentation names it the owner and sentinel of the KPK vaults (legacy v1 vaults excepted).",
    "recordId": "kpk-security-council-safe-5of8-s30",
    "surface": "Security Council Safe (vault owner and sentinel): 5-of-8"
   },
   "factors": [
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "upgrade",
     "label": "Upgradeability",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "Upgrade path not in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "timelock",
     "label": "Timelock floor",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No enforced admin delay in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": "controller fact: Safe getThreshold()",
     "key": "quorum",
     "label": "Signer quorum",
     "state": "g",
     "value": "Lowest controlling quorum: 5-of-8"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "emergency",
     "label": "Emergency / freeze scope",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No pause / freeze authority in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "parity",
     "label": "Docs-vs-chain parity",
     "state": "g",
     "value": "Chain matches or is stronger than the documentation"
    }
   ],
   "finding": "Security Council Safe (vault owner and sentinel): 5-of-8",
   "grade": "aligned",
   "gradeLabel": "ALIGNED",
   "name": "KPK",
   "pinnedBlock": 26449594,
   "probe": {
    "block_hash": "0xbe263d5b378dcb7c3c4e18bd8e388f0cb2dab1adacd83de2be58c9408b377287",
    "block_number": 26449594,
    "call_args": [],
    "call_signature": "getThreshold()",
    "chain": "ethereum",
    "check_type": "eth_call",
    "extra_calls": [],
    "id": "kpk-security-council-safe-5of8-s30",
    "repro_calldata": "0xe75235b8",
    "rpc_env_var": "$ETH_RPC_URL",
    "selector_or_slot": "0xe75235b8",
    "target_contract": "0x8b884f80B3B839F52b6cE168f133e7a5D1f0A537",
    "target_label": "KPK Security Council Safe"
   },
   "reconciled": false,
   "reconciledFrom": [],
   "reconciledTo": [],
   "records": 1,
   "rosetteAria": "KPK control-plane rosette: Upgradeability not determined; Timelock floor not determined; Signer quorum strong; Emergency / freeze scope not determined; Docs-vs-chain parity strong",
   "search": "kpk kpk onchain asset manager & risk curator (dao treasuries) (ethereum) kpk 0x8b884f80b3b839f52b6ce168f133e7a5d1f0a537",
   "slug": "kpk",
   "summary_short": "KPK's Security Council Safe, owner and sentinel of its vaults, is 5-of-8",
   "url": "https://pacta.wtf/protocols/kpk/"
  },
  {
   "baskets": [],
   "category": "Interest-bearing tokens backed by tokenized government bonds (regulated NFTs) (Ethereum)",
   "chains": [
    "ethereum"
   ],
   "deltas": 0,
   "easAttested": true,
   "evidence": {
    "documented": "'The multisig requires 4/7 signatures to execute a transaction.' (docs.kuma.bond/kuma-protocol/dao-and-governance/multisig.md)",
    "observed": "KUMA Protocol Safe 0xB5502747AABDCa21E832951b4caaF739dA33f450 (Ethereum): getThreshold() = 4 of getOwners() = 7 owners (Safe v1.3.0).",
    "recordId": "kuma-protocol-safe-threshold-s27",
    "surface": "KUMA Protocol multisig: 4-of-7 Safe, as documented"
   },
   "factors": [
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "upgrade",
     "label": "Upgradeability",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "Upgrade path not in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "timelock",
     "label": "Timelock floor",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No enforced admin delay in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": "controller fact: Safe getThreshold()",
     "key": "quorum",
     "label": "Signer quorum",
     "state": "g",
     "value": "Lowest controlling quorum: 4-of-7"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "emergency",
     "label": "Emergency / freeze scope",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No pause / freeze authority in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "parity",
     "label": "Docs-vs-chain parity",
     "state": "g",
     "value": "Chain matches or is stronger than the documentation"
    }
   ],
   "finding": "KUMA Protocol multisig: 4-of-7 Safe, as documented",
   "grade": "aligned",
   "gradeLabel": "ALIGNED",
   "name": "KUMA Protocol",
   "pinnedBlock": 26440048,
   "probe": {
    "block_hash": "0x2c6e70ac6ce978ce5c457208ea6d953e60e92ebf2151578f46cbdd070baa54c6",
    "block_number": 26440048,
    "call_args": [],
    "call_signature": "getThreshold()",
    "chain": "ethereum",
    "check_type": "eth_call",
    "extra_calls": [],
    "id": "kuma-protocol-safe-threshold-s27",
    "repro_calldata": "0xe75235b8",
    "rpc_env_var": "$ETH_RPC_URL",
    "selector_or_slot": "0xe75235b8",
    "target_contract": "0xB5502747AABDCa21E832951b4caaF739dA33f450",
    "target_label": "KUMA Protocol Safe"
   },
   "reconciled": false,
   "reconciledFrom": [],
   "reconciledTo": [],
   "records": 1,
   "rosetteAria": "KUMA Protocol control-plane rosette: Upgradeability not determined; Timelock floor not determined; Signer quorum strong; Emergency / freeze scope not determined; Docs-vs-chain parity strong",
   "search": "kuma protocol kuma-protocol interest-bearing tokens backed by tokenized government bonds (regulated nfts) (ethereum) usk 0xb5502747aabdca21e832951b4caaf739da33f450",
   "slug": "kuma-protocol",
   "summary_short": "The KUMA Protocol multisig is a 4-of-7 Safe, as its docs state",
   "url": "https://pacta.wtf/protocols/kuma-protocol/"
  },
  {
   "baskets": [],
   "category": "Capital-efficient liquidity pools earning fees for providers (Ethereum)",
   "chains": [
    "ethereum"
   ],
   "deltas": 0,
   "easAttested": true,
   "evidence": {
    "documented": "'KNC is dynamic and can be upgraded or minted by KyberDAO to better support liquidity and growth.' (docs.kyberswap.com/governance/knc-token.md)",
    "observed": "KyberSwap Classic KyberNetworkTokenV2 proxy 0xdeFA4e8a7bcBA345F687a2f1456F5Edd9CE97202 (Ethereum): EIP-1967 implementation slot = 0xe5E8E834086F1a964f9A089eB6Ae11796862e4CE, admin slot = 0x500180A94cB854e98770872AF4E4BB1dD67Af559; upgradeable (EIP-1967 implementation + admin slot (transparent proxy)).",
    "recordId": "kyberswap-classic-upgradeability-s28",
    "surface": "KyberSwap Classic KyberNetworkTokenV2 proxy: upgradeable (proxy admin), as documented"
   },
   "factors": [
    {
     "evidence": "kyberswap-classic-upgradeability-s28: KyberSwap Classic KyberNetworkTokenV2 proxy 0xdeFA4e8a7bcBA345F687a2f1456F5Edd9CE97202 (Ethereum): EIP-1967 implementation slot = …",
     "key": "upgrade",
     "label": "Upgradeability",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "Upgradeable; the delay gating the upgrade path is not in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "timelock",
     "label": "Timelock floor",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No enforced admin delay in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "quorum",
     "label": "Signer quorum",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No signer quorum in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "emergency",
     "label": "Emergency / freeze scope",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No pause / freeze authority in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "parity",
     "label": "Docs-vs-chain parity",
     "state": "g",
     "value": "Chain matches or is stronger than the documentation"
    }
   ],
   "finding": "KyberSwap Classic KyberNetworkTokenV2 proxy: upgradeable (proxy admin), as documented",
   "grade": "aligned",
   "gradeLabel": "ALIGNED",
   "name": "KyberSwap Classic",
   "pinnedBlock": 26441165,
   "probe": {
    "block_hash": "0x5182be2c61af5f48ed2ec43d3c177dedad257c4e966a7e384120829de73901d9",
    "block_number": 26441165,
    "call_args": [],
    "call_signature": null,
    "chain": "ethereum",
    "check_type": "eth_getStorageAt",
    "extra_calls": [],
    "id": "kyberswap-classic-upgradeability-s28",
    "repro_calldata": null,
    "rpc_env_var": "$ETH_RPC_URL",
    "selector_or_slot": "0x360894a13ba1a3210667c828492db98dca3e2076cc3735a920a3ca505d382bbc",
    "target_contract": "0xdeFA4e8a7bcBA345F687a2f1456F5Edd9CE97202",
    "target_label": "KyberSwap Classic KyberNetworkTokenV2 proxy"
   },
   "reconciled": false,
   "reconciledFrom": [],
   "reconciledTo": [],
   "records": 1,
   "rosetteAria": "KyberSwap Classic control-plane rosette: Upgradeability not determined; Timelock floor not determined; Signer quorum not determined; Emergency / freeze scope not determined; Docs-vs-chain parity strong",
   "search": "kyberswap classic kyberswap-classic capital-efficient liquidity pools earning fees for providers (ethereum) knc 0x500180a94cb854e98770872af4e4bb1dd67af559 0xdefa4e8a7bcba345f687a2f1456f5edd9ce97202 0xe5e8e834086f1a964f9a089eb6ae11796862e4ce",
   "slug": "kyberswap-classic",
   "summary_short": "Upgradeable proxy, as documented",
   "url": "https://pacta.wtf/protocols/kyberswap-classic/"
  },
  {
   "baskets": [
    "lending_vaults"
   ],
   "category": "Curated vault infrastructure: ERC-7540 vaults behind upgradeable proxies",
   "chains": [
    "ethereum"
   ],
   "deltas": 1,
   "easAttested": true,
   "evidence": {
    "documented": "'Every upgrade is subject to a mandatory waiting period before it takes effect. This gives investors time to evaluate the incoming change and exit the vault if needed.' and 'The delay window is configurable by the vault admin , within the protocol bounds of 24 hours (minimum) to 30 days (maximum).' (docs.lagoon.finance/vault/upgradability-and-opt-in-proxy)",
    "observed": "Lagoon cbBTC vault 0xB09F761Cb13baCa8eC087Ac476647361b6314F98 (Ethereum) is an EIP-1967 BeaconProxy: beacon slot = UpgradeableBeacon 0x707D622cdA4b5459e7DcEe8Ba8E429F154f96A27 (implementation() = 0x6C77c47FB8168E22976C3B0338CB1769c952249f), admin slot empty. The beacon's owner() = Safe 0x6D46e28aB34622d9A39d0F306a37a8dC270951aF with getThreshold() = 3 of getOwners() = 6 owners (Safe v1.3.0), no Safe guard; the beacon exposes no delay(). An upgrade of the beacon applies to the vault at once.",
    "recordId": "lagoon-vault-beacon-upgrade-delay-s29",
    "surface": "cbBTC vault upgrades: docs require a 24 h to 30 day wait; the vault's beacon owner is a 3-of-6 Safe with no delay"
   },
   "factors": [
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "upgrade",
     "label": "Upgradeability",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "Upgrade path not in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": "lagoon-vault-beacon-upgrade-delay-s29: observed_delay_seconds = 0",
     "key": "timelock",
     "label": "Timelock floor",
     "state": "a",
     "value": "0s minimum enforced delay across control surfaces"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "quorum",
     "label": "Signer quorum",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No signer quorum in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "emergency",
     "label": "Emergency / freeze scope",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No pause / freeze authority in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "parity",
     "label": "Docs-vs-chain parity",
     "state": "a",
     "value": "Documentation differs from the chain (parameter delta)"
    }
   ],
   "finding": "Timelock delay: docs say 1 d · chain says 0 s (no delay)",
   "grade": "delta",
   "gradeLabel": "DELTA",
   "name": "Lagoon",
   "pinnedBlock": 26448221,
   "probe": {
    "block_hash": "0xa7818c0e1b8807aac0c999c2dc9aeeea40b91b4f19b1b76a62ad02d8d17607c8",
    "block_number": 26448221,
    "call_args": [],
    "call_signature": "owner()",
    "chain": "ethereum",
    "check_type": "eth_call",
    "extra_calls": [],
    "id": "lagoon-vault-beacon-upgrade-delay-s29",
    "repro_calldata": "0x8da5cb5b",
    "rpc_env_var": "$ETH_RPC_URL",
    "selector_or_slot": "0x8da5cb5b",
    "target_contract": "0x707D622cdA4b5459e7DcEe8Ba8E429F154f96A27",
    "target_label": "Lagoon cbBTC vault UpgradeableBeacon"
   },
   "reconciled": false,
   "reconciledFrom": [],
   "reconciledTo": [],
   "records": 1,
   "rosetteAria": "Lagoon control-plane rosette: Upgradeability not determined; Timelock floor weak; Signer quorum not determined; Emergency / freeze scope not determined; Docs-vs-chain parity weak",
   "search": "lagoon lagoon curated vault infrastructure: erc-7540 vaults behind upgradeable proxies lagoon 0x6c77c47fb8168e22976c3b0338cb1769c952249f 0x6d46e28ab34622d9a39d0f306a37a8dc270951af 0x707d622cda4b5459e7dcee8ba8e429f154f96a27 0xb09f761cb13baca8ec087ac476647361b6314f98",
   "slug": "lagoon",
   "summary_short": "Docs require a 24 h minimum upgrade wait; the vault beacon's owner is a 3-of-6 Safe",
   "url": "https://pacta.wtf/protocols/lagoon/"
  },
  {
   "baskets": [],
   "category": "Farmland-secured financing repaid from future crop harvests (Ethereum)",
   "chains": [
    "ethereum"
   ],
   "deltas": 0,
   "easAttested": false,
   "evidence": {
    "documented": "LandX Finance documentation is linked for reference (). This RPC-pinned record does not compare documentation parameters with the on-chain state.",
    "observed": "LandX Governance Token (LNDX) (0x08A1C30BBB26425c1031ee9E43FA0B9960742539) verified on Ethereum Mainnet at canonical block #26,458,556 (22,113 bytes runtime code). EIP-1967 implementation and admin storage slots are both zero (non-EIP-1967 contract). Direct owner() returns Safe 2-of-3 0xf44Bc45368Fb7f6ffC74C5545326Aa0F068b6d4c.",
    "recordId": "landx-finance-control-plane",
    "surface": "LandX Governance Token (LNDX) · Non-Proxy Bytecode & Controller"
   },
   "factors": [
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "upgrade",
     "label": "Upgradeability",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "Upgrade path not in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "timelock",
     "label": "Timelock floor",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No enforced admin delay in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": "landx-finance-control-plane: … contract). Direct owner() returns Safe 2-of-3 0xf44Bc45368Fb7f6ffC74C5545326Aa0F068b6d4c.",
     "key": "quorum",
     "label": "Signer quorum",
     "state": "b",
     "value": "Lowest controlling quorum: 2-of-3"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "emergency",
     "label": "Emergency / freeze scope",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No pause / freeze authority in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "parity",
     "label": "Docs-vs-chain parity",
     "state": "u",
     "value": "Uncompared: documentation not assessed (RPC-observed)"
    }
   ],
   "finding": "LandX Governance Token (LNDX) · Non-Proxy Bytecode & Controller",
   "grade": "observed",
   "gradeLabel": "OBSERVED",
   "name": "LandX Finance",
   "pinnedBlock": 26458556,
   "probe": {
    "block_hash": "0xe258bb1cbcc988e2dfdba4ba173f9f8690520dba3647cdcae18e0651822769d2",
    "block_number": 26458556,
    "call_args": [],
    "call_signature": "owner()",
    "chain": "ethereum",
    "check_type": "eth_call",
    "extra_calls": [],
    "id": "landx-finance-control-plane",
    "repro_calldata": "0x8da5cb5b",
    "rpc_env_var": "$ETH_RPC_URL",
    "selector_or_slot": "0x8da5cb5b",
    "target_contract": "0x08A1C30BBB26425c1031ee9E43FA0B9960742539",
    "target_label": "LandX Governance Token (LNDX)"
   },
   "reconciled": false,
   "reconciledFrom": [],
   "reconciledTo": [],
   "records": 1,
   "rosetteAria": "LandX Finance control-plane rosette: Upgradeability not determined; Timelock floor not determined; Signer quorum moderate; Emergency / freeze scope not determined; Docs-vs-chain parity uncompared",
   "search": "landx finance landx-finance farmland-secured financing repaid from future crop harvests (ethereum) lndx 0x08a1c30bbb26425c1031ee9e43fa0b9960742539 0xf44bc45368fb7f6ffc74c5545326aa0f068b6d4c",
   "slug": "landx-finance",
   "summary_short": "Non-proxy contract controlled by a 2-of-3 Safe; docs not assessed",
   "url": "https://pacta.wtf/protocols/landx-finance/"
  },
  {
   "baskets": [],
   "category": "Cross-Chain Messaging (Endpoint & Message Libraries)",
   "chains": [
    "ethereum"
   ],
   "deltas": 0,
   "easAttested": true,
   "evidence": {
    "documented": "docs.layerzero.network (endpoint): 'The LayerZero Endpoint is the immutable, permissionless protocol entrypoint for sending and receiving omnichain messages.' / 'The LayerZero Endpoint is the single, immutable entry and exit point for cross‑chain messaging, built on five core modules:'",
    "observed": "EndpointV2 0x1a44076050125825900e736c501f859c50fE728c (Ethereum; Sourcify match): EIP-1967 implementation slot = 0x0 (not a proxy); the Base endpoint at the same address is also not a proxy.",
    "recordId": "layerzero-v2-endpoint-immutable-s25",
    "surface": "EndpointV2: not a proxy; its code cannot be replaced"
   },
   "factors": [
    {
     "evidence": "layerzero-v2-endpoint-immutable-s25: EndpointV2 0x1a44076050125825900e736c501f859c50fE728c (Ethereum; Sourcify match): EIP-1967 implementation slot = 0x0 (not a proxy)",
     "key": "upgrade",
     "label": "Upgradeability",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "Upgradeable; the delay gating the upgrade path is not in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "timelock",
     "label": "Timelock floor",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No enforced admin delay in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "quorum",
     "label": "Signer quorum",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No signer quorum in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "emergency",
     "label": "Emergency / freeze scope",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No pause / freeze authority in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "parity",
     "label": "Docs-vs-chain parity",
     "state": "g",
     "value": "Chain matches or is stronger than the documentation"
    }
   ],
   "finding": "EndpointV2: not a proxy; its code cannot be replaced",
   "grade": "aligned",
   "gradeLabel": "ALIGNED",
   "name": "LayerZero V2",
   "pinnedBlock": 26434786,
   "probe": {
    "block_hash": "0xb712439847099ec3e8b1617aafd1bc7ece29e22a88dc4e7c8afcf05e6944d987",
    "block_number": 26434786,
    "call_args": [],
    "call_signature": null,
    "chain": "ethereum",
    "check_type": "eth_getStorageAt",
    "extra_calls": [],
    "id": "layerzero-v2-endpoint-immutable-s25",
    "repro_calldata": null,
    "rpc_env_var": "$ETH_RPC_URL",
    "selector_or_slot": "0x360894a13ba1a3210667c828492db98dca3e2076cc3735a920a3ca505d382bbc",
    "target_contract": "0x1a44076050125825900e736c501f859c50fE728c",
    "target_label": "LayerZero EndpointV2 (Ethereum)"
   },
   "reconciled": false,
   "reconciledFrom": [],
   "reconciledTo": [],
   "records": 3,
   "rosetteAria": "LayerZero V2 control-plane rosette: Upgradeability not determined; Timelock floor not determined; Signer quorum not determined; Emergency / freeze scope not determined; Docs-vs-chain parity strong",
   "search": "layerzero v2 layerzero-v2 cross-chain messaging (endpoint & message libraries) zro layerzero endpointv2 0x1a44076050125825900e736c501f859c50fe728c 0x380275805876ff19055ea900cdb2b46a94ecf20d 0x554833698ae0fb22ecc90b01222903fd62ca4b47 0x589dedbd617e0cbcb916a9223f4d1300c294236b 0x9e059a54699a285714207b43b055483e78faac25 0xa0392d116d71ed3b75086194aba6de3cd1e39b7e 0xa4fe5a5b9a846458a70cd0748228aed3bf65c2cd 0xa59ba433ac34d2927232918ef5b2eaafcf130ba5 0xa7b5189bca84cd304d8553977c7c614329750d99 0xbb2ea70c9e858123480642cf96acbcce1372dce1 0xbe010a7e3686fdf65e93344ab664d065a0b02478 0xc70ab6f32772f59fbfc23889caf4ba3376c84baf 0xcd37ca043f8479064e10635020c65ffc005d36f6",
   "slug": "layerzero-v2",
   "summary_short": "Endpoint is immutable; a 5-of-9 multisig sets the message defaults, as documented",
   "url": "https://pacta.wtf/protocols/layerzero-v2/"
  },
  {
   "baskets": [
    "lending_vaults"
   ],
   "category": "USDC savings vault with auto-accruing yield (Ethereum)",
   "chains": [
    "ethereum"
   ],
   "deltas": 0,
   "easAttested": false,
   "evidence": {
    "documented": "Lazy documentation is linked for reference (https://getlazy.xyz/docs). This RPC-pinned record does not compare documentation parameters with the on-chain state.",
    "observed": "LazyUSD (LazyUSDVault) (0xd53B68fB4eb907c3c1E348CD7d7bEDE34f763805) verified on Ethereum Mainnet at canonical block #26,458,556 (15,843 bytes runtime code). EIP-1967 implementation and admin storage slots are both zero (non-EIP-1967 contract). No owner(), admin(), authority(), curator() or AccessControl admin was readable on the contract.",
    "recordId": "lazy-control-plane",
    "surface": "LazyUSD (LazyUSDVault) · Non-Proxy Bytecode & Controller"
   },
   "factors": [
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "upgrade",
     "label": "Upgradeability",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "Upgrade path not in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "timelock",
     "label": "Timelock floor",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No enforced admin delay in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "quorum",
     "label": "Signer quorum",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No signer quorum in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "emergency",
     "label": "Emergency / freeze scope",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No pause / freeze authority in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "parity",
     "label": "Docs-vs-chain parity",
     "state": "u",
     "value": "Uncompared: documentation not assessed (RPC-observed)"
    }
   ],
   "finding": "LazyUSD (LazyUSDVault) · Non-Proxy Bytecode & Controller",
   "grade": "observed",
   "gradeLabel": "OBSERVED",
   "name": "Lazy",
   "pinnedBlock": 26458556,
   "probe": {
    "block_hash": "0xe258bb1cbcc988e2dfdba4ba173f9f8690520dba3647cdcae18e0651822769d2",
    "block_number": 26458556,
    "call_args": [],
    "call_signature": "owner()",
    "chain": "ethereum",
    "check_type": "eth_call",
    "extra_calls": [],
    "id": "lazy-control-plane",
    "repro_calldata": "0x8da5cb5b",
    "rpc_env_var": "$ETH_RPC_URL",
    "selector_or_slot": "0x8da5cb5b",
    "target_contract": "0xd53B68fB4eb907c3c1E348CD7d7bEDE34f763805",
    "target_label": "LazyUSD (LazyUSDVault)"
   },
   "reconciled": false,
   "reconciledFrom": [],
   "reconciledTo": [],
   "records": 1,
   "rosetteAria": "Lazy control-plane rosette: Upgradeability not determined; Timelock floor not determined; Signer quorum not determined; Emergency / freeze scope not determined; Docs-vs-chain parity uncompared",
   "search": "lazy lazy usdc savings vault with auto-accruing yield (ethereum) lazyusd 0xd53b68fb4eb907c3c1e348cd7d7bede34f763805",
   "slug": "lazy",
   "summary_short": "Non-proxy contract no readable owner or admin; docs not assessed",
   "url": "https://pacta.wtf/protocols/lazy/"
  },
  {
   "baskets": [
    "lending_vaults"
   ],
   "category": "Real-world yield vaults backed by institutional fixed income (Ethereum)",
   "chains": [
    "ethereum"
   ],
   "deltas": 0,
   "easAttested": false,
   "evidence": {
    "documented": "Ledgity Yield documentation is linked for reference (None). This RPC-pinned record does not compare documentation parameters with the on-chain state.",
    "observed": "Ledgity Token (LDY) (0x482dF7483a52496F4C65AB499966dfcdf4DDFDbc) verified on Ethereum Mainnet at canonical block #26,458,556 (6,041 bytes runtime code). EIP-1967 implementation and admin storage slots are both zero (non-EIP-1967 contract). Direct owner() returns Safe 2-of-3 0x30Fa557608017afB6E8e4ABe8027787C00473FF0.",
    "recordId": "ledgity-yield-control-plane",
    "surface": "Ledgity Token (LDY) · Non-Proxy Bytecode & Controller"
   },
   "factors": [
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "upgrade",
     "label": "Upgradeability",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "Upgrade path not in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "timelock",
     "label": "Timelock floor",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No enforced admin delay in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": "ledgity-yield-control-plane: … contract). Direct owner() returns Safe 2-of-3 0x30Fa557608017afB6E8e4ABe8027787C00473FF0.",
     "key": "quorum",
     "label": "Signer quorum",
     "state": "b",
     "value": "Lowest controlling quorum: 2-of-3"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "emergency",
     "label": "Emergency / freeze scope",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No pause / freeze authority in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "parity",
     "label": "Docs-vs-chain parity",
     "state": "u",
     "value": "Uncompared: documentation not assessed (RPC-observed)"
    }
   ],
   "finding": "Ledgity Token (LDY) · Non-Proxy Bytecode & Controller",
   "grade": "observed",
   "gradeLabel": "OBSERVED",
   "name": "Ledgity Yield",
   "pinnedBlock": 26458556,
   "probe": {
    "block_hash": "0xe258bb1cbcc988e2dfdba4ba173f9f8690520dba3647cdcae18e0651822769d2",
    "block_number": 26458556,
    "call_args": [],
    "call_signature": "owner()",
    "chain": "ethereum",
    "check_type": "eth_call",
    "extra_calls": [],
    "id": "ledgity-yield-control-plane",
    "repro_calldata": "0x8da5cb5b",
    "rpc_env_var": "$ETH_RPC_URL",
    "selector_or_slot": "0x8da5cb5b",
    "target_contract": "0x482dF7483a52496F4C65AB499966dfcdf4DDFDbc",
    "target_label": "Ledgity Token (LDY)"
   },
   "reconciled": false,
   "reconciledFrom": [],
   "reconciledTo": [],
   "records": 1,
   "rosetteAria": "Ledgity Yield control-plane rosette: Upgradeability not determined; Timelock floor not determined; Signer quorum moderate; Emergency / freeze scope not determined; Docs-vs-chain parity uncompared",
   "search": "ledgity yield ledgity-yield real-world yield vaults backed by institutional fixed income (ethereum) ldy 0x30fa557608017afb6e8e4abe8027787c00473ff0 0x482df7483a52496f4c65ab499966dfcdf4ddfdbc",
   "slug": "ledgity-yield",
   "summary_short": "Non-proxy contract controlled by a 2-of-3 Safe; docs not assessed",
   "url": "https://pacta.wtf/protocols/ledgity-yield/"
  },
  {
   "baskets": [],
   "category": "Merit-based token sale platform scoring onchain reputation (Ethereum)",
   "chains": [
    "ethereum"
   ],
   "deltas": 0,
   "easAttested": false,
   "evidence": {
    "documented": "Legion documentation is linked for reference (https://legion.cc/legal/security-policy). This RPC-pinned record does not compare documentation parameters with the on-chain state.",
    "observed": "LegionPreLiquidSaleV2Factory (0xa0BeB0A8C765482c128a2986c063AF5C3171ff2F) verified on Ethereum Mainnet at canonical block #26,458,556 (2,941 bytes runtime code). EIP-1967 implementation and admin storage slots are both zero (non-EIP-1967 contract). Direct owner() returns contract LegionBouncer 0x4a7aCA57A685c9E893F60a716415E5e588500533. That controller is in turn controlled by Safe 2-of-3 0x17C61f4a7f41b96eb9c0D8805255b8411387c63b.",
    "recordId": "legion-control-plane",
    "surface": "LegionPreLiquidSaleV2Factory · Non-Proxy Bytecode & Controller"
   },
   "factors": [
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "upgrade",
     "label": "Upgradeability",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "Upgrade path not in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "timelock",
     "label": "Timelock floor",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No enforced admin delay in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": "legion-control-plane: … controller is in turn controlled by Safe 2-of-3 0x17C61f4a7f41b96eb9c0D8805255b8411387c63b.",
     "key": "quorum",
     "label": "Signer quorum",
     "state": "b",
     "value": "Lowest controlling quorum: 2-of-3"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "emergency",
     "label": "Emergency / freeze scope",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No pause / freeze authority in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "parity",
     "label": "Docs-vs-chain parity",
     "state": "u",
     "value": "Uncompared: documentation not assessed (RPC-observed)"
    }
   ],
   "finding": "LegionPreLiquidSaleV2Factory · Non-Proxy Bytecode & Controller",
   "grade": "observed",
   "gradeLabel": "OBSERVED",
   "name": "Legion",
   "pinnedBlock": 26458556,
   "probe": {
    "block_hash": "0xe258bb1cbcc988e2dfdba4ba173f9f8690520dba3647cdcae18e0651822769d2",
    "block_number": 26458556,
    "call_args": [],
    "call_signature": "owner()",
    "chain": "ethereum",
    "check_type": "eth_call",
    "extra_calls": [],
    "id": "legion-control-plane",
    "repro_calldata": "0x8da5cb5b",
    "rpc_env_var": "$ETH_RPC_URL",
    "selector_or_slot": "0x8da5cb5b",
    "target_contract": "0xa0BeB0A8C765482c128a2986c063AF5C3171ff2F",
    "target_label": "LegionPreLiquidSaleV2Factory"
   },
   "reconciled": false,
   "reconciledFrom": [],
   "reconciledTo": [],
   "records": 1,
   "rosetteAria": "Legion control-plane rosette: Upgradeability not determined; Timelock floor not determined; Signer quorum moderate; Emergency / freeze scope not determined; Docs-vs-chain parity uncompared",
   "search": "legion legion merit-based token sale platform scoring onchain reputation (ethereum) legion 0x17c61f4a7f41b96eb9c0d8805255b8411387c63b 0x4a7aca57a685c9e893f60a716415e5e588500533 0xa0beb0a8c765482c128a2986c063af5c3171ff2f",
   "slug": "legion",
   "summary_short": "Non-proxy contract controlled by a 2-of-3 Safe; docs not assessed",
   "url": "https://pacta.wtf/protocols/legion/"
  },
  {
   "baskets": [],
   "category": "Fixed-rate fixed-term loans against Curve LP collateral (Ethereum)",
   "chains": [
    "ethereum"
   ],
   "deltas": 0,
   "easAttested": false,
   "evidence": {
    "documented": "LendFlare documentation is linked for reference (). This RPC-pinned record does not compare documentation parameters with the on-chain state.",
    "observed": "LendFlare DAO Token (LendFlareProxy) (0xB620Be8a1949AA9532e6a3510132864EF9Bc3F82) verified on Ethereum Mainnet at canonical block #26,458,556 (2,092 bytes runtime code). EIP-1967 proxy: implementation 0xEf9423D140C8009597d1185b4b6d5302df21ca0f, admin 0xc413AcBb126fa228d7E3d1943bA506b507C91aF7. The EIP-1967 admin slot holds externally owned account (no code) 0xc413AcBb126fa228d7E3d1943bA506b507C91aF7.",
    "recordId": "lendflare-control-plane",
    "surface": "LendFlare DAO Token (LendFlareProxy) · EIP-1967 Proxy & Controller Chain"
   },
   "factors": [
    {
     "evidence": "lendflare-control-plane: is_eip1967_proxy = true",
     "key": "upgrade",
     "label": "Upgradeability",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "Upgradeable; the delay gating the upgrade path is not in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "timelock",
     "label": "Timelock floor",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No enforced admin delay in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": "lendflare-control-plane: … 0xc413AcBb126fa228d7E3d1943bA506b507C91aF7. The EIP-1967 admin slot holds externally owned account (no code) 0xc413AcBb126fa228d7E3d1943bA506b507C91aF7.",
     "key": "quorum",
     "label": "Signer quorum",
     "state": "a",
     "value": "Lowest controlling quorum: a single key"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "emergency",
     "label": "Emergency / freeze scope",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No pause / freeze authority in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "parity",
     "label": "Docs-vs-chain parity",
     "state": "u",
     "value": "Uncompared: documentation not assessed (RPC-observed)"
    }
   ],
   "finding": "LendFlare DAO Token (LendFlareProxy) · EIP-1967 Proxy & Controller Chain",
   "grade": "observed",
   "gradeLabel": "OBSERVED",
   "name": "LendFlare",
   "pinnedBlock": 26458556,
   "probe": {
    "block_hash": "0xe258bb1cbcc988e2dfdba4ba173f9f8690520dba3647cdcae18e0651822769d2",
    "block_number": 26458556,
    "call_args": [],
    "call_signature": null,
    "chain": "ethereum",
    "check_type": "eth_getStorageAt",
    "extra_calls": [],
    "id": "lendflare-control-plane",
    "repro_calldata": null,
    "rpc_env_var": "$ETH_RPC_URL",
    "selector_or_slot": "0xb53127684a568b3173ae13b9f8a6016e243e63b6e8ee1178d6a717850b5d6103",
    "target_contract": "0xB620Be8a1949AA9532e6a3510132864EF9Bc3F82",
    "target_label": "LendFlare DAO Token (LendFlareProxy)"
   },
   "reconciled": false,
   "reconciledFrom": [],
   "reconciledTo": [],
   "records": 1,
   "rosetteAria": "LendFlare control-plane rosette: Upgradeability not determined; Timelock floor not determined; Signer quorum weak; Emergency / freeze scope not determined; Docs-vs-chain parity uncompared",
   "search": "lendflare lendflare fixed-rate fixed-term loans against curve lp collateral (ethereum) lft 0xb620be8a1949aa9532e6a3510132864ef9bc3f82 0xc413acbb126fa228d7e3d1943ba506b507c91af7 0xef9423d140c8009597d1185b4b6d5302df21ca0f",
   "slug": "lendflare",
   "summary_short": "Upgradeable proxy controlled by a single key (EOA); docs not assessed",
   "url": "https://pacta.wtf/protocols/lendflare/"
  },
  {
   "baskets": [
    "eth_lst_lrt"
   ],
   "category": "Blue-Chip Liquid Staking",
   "chains": [
    "ethereum"
   ],
   "deltas": 0,
   "easAttested": true,
   "evidence": {
    "documented": "lidofinance/dual-governance deploy-config-mainnet.toml, lidofinance/docs committee specs, and forum record 10032.",
    "observed": "EmergencyProtectedTimelock (0xCE0425301C85c5Ea2A0873A2dEe44d78E02D2316) getAfterSubmitDelay() = 259200s (3d), getAfterScheduleDelay() = 86400s (1d), getGovernance() = DualGovernance (0xC1db28B3301331277e307FDCfF8DE28242A4486E), getEmergencyProtectionDetails() = (2592000, 0, 1813449600); Emergency Activation (0x8B7854488Fde088d686Ea672B6ba1A5242515f45, 4-of-7 Safe), Emergency Execution (0xC7792b3F2B399bB0EdF53fECDceCeB97FBEB18AF, 5-of-7 Safe), Reseal (0xFFe21561251c49AdccFad065C94Fb4931dF49081, 5-of-6 Safe), and CircuitBreaker (0x8772E3a2D86B9347A2688f9bc1808A6d8917760C, 3-of-6 Safe); stETH totalSupply = 9,759,371.53 stETH.",
    "recordId": "lido-dual-governance-emergency-timelock",
    "surface": "EmergencyProtectedTimelock Delays, DualGovernance & Committee Safes"
   },
   "factors": [
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "upgrade",
     "label": "Upgradeability",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "Upgrade path not in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": "lido-dual-governance-emergency-timelock: observed_delay_seconds = 259200",
     "key": "timelock",
     "label": "Timelock floor",
     "state": "g",
     "value": "3d minimum enforced delay across control surfaces"
    },
    {
     "evidence": "lido-dual-governance-emergency-timelock: … (0x8772E3a2D86B9347A2688f9bc1808A6d8917760C, 3-of-6 Safe); stETH totalSupply = 9,759,371.53 …",
     "key": "quorum",
     "label": "Signer quorum",
     "state": "g",
     "value": "Lowest controlling quorum: 3-of-6"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "emergency",
     "label": "Emergency / freeze scope",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No pause / freeze authority in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "parity",
     "label": "Docs-vs-chain parity",
     "state": "g",
     "value": "Chain matches or is stronger than the documentation"
    }
   ],
   "finding": "EmergencyProtectedTimelock Delays, DualGovernance & Committee Safes",
   "grade": "aligned",
   "gradeLabel": "ALIGNED",
   "name": "Lido (stETH / Dual Governance)",
   "pinnedBlock": 26448221,
   "probe": {
    "block_hash": "0x71acee2313a2c8eacd7d2c87667dc505310b3e9224d84eaebb71d5a890ef9d1c",
    "block_number": 26403121,
    "call_args": [],
    "call_signature": "getAfterSubmitDelay()",
    "chain": "ethereum",
    "check_type": "eth_call",
    "extra_calls": [],
    "id": "lido-dual-governance-emergency-timelock",
    "repro_calldata": "0x709105d7",
    "rpc_env_var": "$ETH_RPC_URL",
    "selector_or_slot": "0x709105d7",
    "target_contract": "0xCE0425301C85c5Ea2A0873A2dEe44d78E02D2316",
    "target_label": "EmergencyProtectedTimelock"
   },
   "reconciled": false,
   "reconciledFrom": [],
   "reconciledTo": [],
   "records": 3,
   "rosetteAria": "Lido (stETH / Dual Governance) control-plane rosette: Upgradeability not determined; Timelock floor strong; Signer quorum strong; Emergency / freeze scope not determined; Docs-vs-chain parity strong",
   "search": "lido (steth / dual governance) lido-steth-dual-governance blue-chip liquid staking steth wsteth ldo 0x237cddf3aa765260cf6b60e064065da7c3aa1559 0x3554630ec64e7756007df4137abf7c5881c533d0 0x5a98fcbea516cf06857215779fd812ca3bef1b32 0x7f39c581f595b53c5cb19bd0b3f8da6c935e2ca0 0x8772e3a2d86b9347a2688f9bc1808a6d8917760c 0x8b7854488fde088d686ea672b6ba1a5242515f45 0xae7ab96520de3a18e5e111b5eaab095312d7fe84 0xc1db28b3301331277e307fdcff8de28242a4486e 0xc7792b3f2b399bb0edf53fecdceceb97fbeb18af 0xce0425301c85c5ea2a0873a2dee44d78e02d2316 0xffe21561251c49adccfad065c94fb4931df49081",
   "slug": "lido-steth-dual-governance",
   "summary_short": "Dual Governance timelock delays and committee Safes match the docs",
   "url": "https://pacta.wtf/protocols/lido-steth-dual-governance/"
  },
  {
   "baskets": [],
   "category": "Perpetuals Exchange Deposit Bridge (zk order book) (Ethereum)",
   "chains": [
    "ethereum"
   ],
   "deltas": 0,
   "easAttested": false,
   "evidence": {
    "documented": "Lighter Bridge documentation is linked for reference (https://docs.lighter.xyz/). This RPC-pinned record does not compare documentation parameters with the on-chain state.",
    "observed": "Lighter (0x232CE3bd40fCd6f80f3d55A522d03f25Df784Ee2) verified on Ethereum Mainnet at canonical block #26,458,556 (4,137 bytes runtime code). EIP-1967 implementation and admin storage slots are both zero (non-EIP-1967 contract). No owner(), admin(), authority(), curator() or AccessControl admin was readable on the contract.",
    "recordId": "lighter-bridge-control-plane",
    "surface": "Lighter · Non-Proxy Bytecode & Controller"
   },
   "factors": [
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "upgrade",
     "label": "Upgradeability",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "Upgrade path not in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "timelock",
     "label": "Timelock floor",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No enforced admin delay in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "quorum",
     "label": "Signer quorum",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No signer quorum in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "emergency",
     "label": "Emergency / freeze scope",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No pause / freeze authority in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "parity",
     "label": "Docs-vs-chain parity",
     "state": "u",
     "value": "Uncompared: documentation not assessed (RPC-observed)"
    }
   ],
   "finding": "Lighter · Non-Proxy Bytecode & Controller",
   "grade": "observed",
   "gradeLabel": "OBSERVED",
   "name": "Lighter Bridge",
   "pinnedBlock": 26458556,
   "probe": {
    "block_hash": "0xe258bb1cbcc988e2dfdba4ba173f9f8690520dba3647cdcae18e0651822769d2",
    "block_number": 26458556,
    "call_args": [],
    "call_signature": "owner()",
    "chain": "ethereum",
    "check_type": "eth_call",
    "extra_calls": [],
    "id": "lighter-bridge-control-plane",
    "repro_calldata": "0x8da5cb5b",
    "rpc_env_var": "$ETH_RPC_URL",
    "selector_or_slot": "0x8da5cb5b",
    "target_contract": "0x232CE3bd40fCd6f80f3d55A522d03f25Df784Ee2",
    "target_label": "Lighter"
   },
   "reconciled": false,
   "reconciledFrom": [],
   "reconciledTo": [],
   "records": 1,
   "rosetteAria": "Lighter Bridge control-plane rosette: Upgradeability not determined; Timelock floor not determined; Signer quorum not determined; Emergency / freeze scope not determined; Docs-vs-chain parity uncompared",
   "search": "lighter bridge lighter-bridge perpetuals exchange deposit bridge (zk order book) (ethereum) lit 0x232ce3bd40fcd6f80f3d55a522d03f25df784ee2",
   "slug": "lighter-bridge",
   "summary_short": "Non-proxy contract no readable owner or admin; docs not assessed",
   "url": "https://pacta.wtf/protocols/lighter-bridge/"
  },
  {
   "baskets": [
    "eth_lst_lrt"
   ],
   "category": "Institutional Liquid Staking",
   "chains": [
    "ethereum"
   ],
   "deltas": 0,
   "easAttested": true,
   "evidence": {
    "documented": "docs.liquidcollective.io (ETH FAQs): 'An administrative multisig is made up of a variety of Liquid Collective ecosystem participants.'",
    "observed": "River (0x8c1BEd5b9a0928467c9B1341Da1D7BD5e10b6549) EIP-1967 admin slot = Firewall 0x3A5b4db174a3CC17d8cE40C5B04272737195151b, whose getAdmin() is Safe 0x8EE3fC0Bcd7B57429203751C5bE5fdf1AB8409f3 (4-of-7, v1.3.0, no modules); getAdmin() = Firewall 0xd745A68c705F5aa75DFf528540678288ed2aD9eE, whose getAdmin() is Safe 0xE3208Aa9d1186c1D1C8A5b76E794b2B68E6cb3a5 (4-of-7, the same 7 owners, no modules); the Firewall executor Safe 0xDE55C9dc78f985fE1502484Cb98EBfAB66A56B62 (2-of-3) may call pause() but not unpause() or upgradeTo(address). Implementation RiverV1 0x0056f9ed62dAa4dc3F972340C92326AcCddd1a9D (version() = 1.3.0).",
    "recordId": "liquid-collective-lseth-admin-multisig-4of7-s19",
    "surface": "River (LsETH) upgrade and admin Firewalls are administered by 4-of-7 Safes"
   },
   "factors": [
    {
     "evidence": "liquid-collective-lseth-admin-multisig-4of7-s19: River (0x8c1BEd5b9a0928467c9B1341Da1D7BD5e10b6549) EIP-1967 admin slot = Firewall 0x3A5b4db174a3CC17d8cE40C5B04272737195151b, whose getAdmin() is Safe …",
     "key": "upgrade",
     "label": "Upgradeability",
     "state": "a",
     "value": "Upgradeable with no enforced delay: upgraded by a Safe directly (a Safe has no delay of its own) (1 other upgrade path not determined)"
    },
    {
     "evidence": "liquid-collective-lseth-admin-multisig-4of7-s19: River (0x8c1BEd5b9a0928467c9B1341Da1D7BD5e10b6549) EIP-1967 admin slot = Firewall 0x3A5b4db174a3CC17d8cE40C5B04272737195151b, whose getAdmin() is Safe …",
     "key": "timelock",
     "label": "Timelock floor",
     "state": "a",
     "value": "0s minimum enforced delay across control surfaces"
    },
    {
     "evidence": "liquid-collective-lseth-admin-multisig-4of7-s19: … 0xDE55C9dc78f985fE1502484Cb98EBfAB66A56B62 (2-of-3) may call pause() but not unpause() …",
     "key": "quorum",
     "label": "Signer quorum",
     "state": "b",
     "value": "Lowest controlling quorum: 2-of-3"
    },
    {
     "evidence": "liquid-collective-lseth-admin-multisig-4of7-s19: the Firewall executor Safe 0xDE55C9dc78f985fE1502484Cb98EBfAB66A56B62 (2-of-3) may call pause() but not unpause() or upgradeTo(address). Implementation RiverV1 …",
     "key": "emergency",
     "label": "Emergency / freeze scope",
     "state": "g",
     "value": "Pause / freeze authority scoped behind a multi-signer controller (2-of-3)"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "parity",
     "label": "Docs-vs-chain parity",
     "state": "g",
     "value": "Chain matches or is stronger than the documentation"
    }
   ],
   "finding": "River (LsETH) upgrade and admin Firewalls are administered by 4-of-7 Safes",
   "grade": "aligned",
   "gradeLabel": "ALIGNED",
   "name": "Liquid Collective (LsETH)",
   "pinnedBlock": 26422243,
   "probe": {
    "block_hash": "0xbbe80f9ef9966a9d04cea23db216847f8c8fcc8d66f87c215dc7f712f0743410",
    "block_number": 26422243,
    "call_args": [],
    "call_signature": null,
    "chain": "ethereum",
    "check_type": "eth_getStorageAt",
    "extra_calls": [],
    "id": "liquid-collective-lseth-admin-multisig-4of7-s19",
    "repro_calldata": null,
    "rpc_env_var": "$ETH_RPC_URL",
    "selector_or_slot": "0xb53127684a568b3173ae13b9f8a6016e243e63b6e8ee1178d6a717850b5d6103",
    "target_contract": "0x8c1BEd5b9a0928467c9B1341Da1D7BD5e10b6549",
    "target_label": "River (LsETH) proxy"
   },
   "reconciled": false,
   "reconciledFrom": [],
   "reconciledTo": [],
   "records": 2,
   "rosetteAria": "Liquid Collective (LsETH) control-plane rosette: Upgradeability weak; Timelock floor weak; Signer quorum moderate; Emergency / freeze scope strong; Docs-vs-chain parity strong",
   "search": "liquid collective (lseth) liquid-collective-lseth institutional liquid staking lseth liquid collective 0x0056f9ed62daa4dc3f972340c92326accddd1a9d 0x3a5b4db174a3cc17d8ce40c5b04272737195151b 0x8c1bed5b9a0928467c9b1341da1d7bd5e10b6549 0x8ee3fc0bcd7b57429203751c5be5fdf1ab8409f3 0xd745a68c705f5aa75dff528540678288ed2ad9ee 0xde55c9dc78f985fe1502484cb98ebfab66a56b62 0xe3208aa9d1186c1d1c8a5b76e794b2b68e6cb3a5",
   "slug": "liquid-collective-lseth",
   "summary_short": "Upgrade and admin firewalls are run by 4-of-7 Safes, as documented",
   "url": "https://pacta.wtf/protocols/liquid-collective-lseth/"
  },
  {
   "baskets": [
    "stable_rwa"
   ],
   "category": "Interest-Free ETH-Backed Borrowing",
   "chains": [
    "ethereum"
   ],
   "deltas": 0,
   "easAttested": true,
   "evidence": {
    "documented": "docs.liquity.org (Liquity V1, borrowing): 'This is a protocol parameter that is set to `110%`.' / Recovery Mode: 'During Recovery Mode, Troves with a collateral ratio below 150% can be liquidated.'",
    "observed": "TroveManager 0xA39739EF8b0231DbFA0DcdA07d7e29faAbCf4bb2: MCR() = 1100000000000000000 (110%), CCR() = 1500000000000000000 (150%); compile-time constants of a contract with no owner and no proxy.",
    "recordId": "liquity-v1-lusd-collateral-ratios-110-150-s22",
    "surface": "Liquidation thresholds: 110% minimum, 150% in Recovery Mode"
   },
   "factors": [
    {
     "evidence": "liquity-v1-lusd-core-ownership-renounced-s22: … 0xA39739EF8b0231DbFA0DcdA07d7e29faAbCf4bb2: owner() = 0x0; BorrowerOperations 0x24179CD81c9e782A4096035f7eC97fB8B783e007, …",
     "key": "upgrade",
     "label": "Upgradeability",
     "state": "g",
     "value": "Immutable or ownership renounced"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "timelock",
     "label": "Timelock floor",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No enforced admin delay in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "quorum",
     "label": "Signer quorum",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No signer quorum in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "emergency",
     "label": "Emergency / freeze scope",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No pause / freeze authority in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "parity",
     "label": "Docs-vs-chain parity",
     "state": "g",
     "value": "Chain matches or is stronger than the documentation"
    }
   ],
   "finding": "Liquidation thresholds: 110% minimum, 150% in Recovery Mode",
   "grade": "aligned",
   "gradeLabel": "ALIGNED",
   "name": "Liquity V1 (LUSD)",
   "pinnedBlock": 26429396,
   "probe": {
    "block_hash": "0x3fb83aa053c26ac6b98d634858da1b3c23bb65bae7a12f8f14d72d8273e16d71",
    "block_number": 26429396,
    "call_args": [],
    "call_signature": "MCR()",
    "chain": "ethereum",
    "check_type": "eth_call",
    "extra_calls": [],
    "id": "liquity-v1-lusd-collateral-ratios-110-150-s22",
    "repro_calldata": "0x794e5724",
    "rpc_env_var": "$ETH_RPC_URL",
    "selector_or_slot": "0x794e5724",
    "target_contract": "0xA39739EF8b0231DbFA0DcdA07d7e29faAbCf4bb2",
    "target_label": "Liquity V1 TroveManager"
   },
   "reconciled": false,
   "reconciledFrom": [],
   "reconciledTo": [],
   "records": 3,
   "rosetteAria": "Liquity V1 (LUSD) control-plane rosette: Upgradeability strong; Timelock floor not determined; Signer quorum not determined; Emergency / freeze scope not determined; Docs-vs-chain parity strong",
   "search": "liquity v1 (lusd) liquity-v1-lusd interest-free eth-backed borrowing lusd lqty 0x24179cd81c9e782a4096035f7ec97fb8b783e007 0x5f98805a4e8be255a32880fdec7f6728c6568ba0 0x66017d22b0f8556afdd19fc67041899eb65a21bb 0xa39739ef8b0231dbfa0dcda07d7e29faabcf4bb2",
   "slug": "liquity-v1-lusd",
   "summary_short": "Liquidation thresholds are 110% and 150% in Recovery Mode, as documented",
   "url": "https://pacta.wtf/protocols/liquity-v1-lusd/"
  },
  {
   "baskets": [
    "stable_rwa"
   ],
   "category": "Immutable CDP Stablecoin",
   "chains": [
    "ethereum"
   ],
   "deltas": 0,
   "easAttested": true,
   "evidence": {
    "documented": "Liquity V2 immutability and non-upgradeable core specification.",
    "observed": "BOLD.owner() = 0x0; Governance (0x807DEf5E7d057DF05C796F4bc75C3Fe82Bd6EeE1) owner() = 0x0; CollateralRegistry (0xf949982B91C8c61e952B3bA942cbbfaef5386684) EIP-1967 implementation slot = 0x00...00.",
    "recordId": "liquity-v2-bold-immutability",
    "surface": "Sampled Owner & EIP-1967 Slot Alignment"
   },
   "factors": [
    {
     "evidence": "liquity-v2-bold-immutability: CollateralRegistry (0xf949982B91C8c61e952B3bA942cbbfaef5386684) EIP-1967 implementation slot = 0x00...00.",
     "key": "upgrade",
     "label": "Upgradeability",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "Upgradeable; the delay gating the upgrade path is not in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "timelock",
     "label": "Timelock floor",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No enforced admin delay in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "quorum",
     "label": "Signer quorum",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No signer quorum in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "emergency",
     "label": "Emergency / freeze scope",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No pause / freeze authority in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "parity",
     "label": "Docs-vs-chain parity",
     "state": "g",
     "value": "Chain matches or is stronger than the documentation"
    }
   ],
   "finding": "Sampled Owner & EIP-1967 Slot Alignment",
   "grade": "aligned",
   "gradeLabel": "ALIGNED",
   "name": "Liquity V2 (BOLD)",
   "pinnedBlock": 26401540,
   "probe": {
    "block_hash": "0x49324aaf84b0ffd4e21026c5345272788bff377f0f86fcdb74280cdfc32a9641",
    "block_number": 26401540,
    "call_args": [],
    "call_signature": "owner()",
    "chain": "ethereum",
    "check_type": "eth_call",
    "extra_calls": [],
    "id": "liquity-v2-bold-immutability",
    "repro_calldata": "0x8da5cb5b",
    "rpc_env_var": "$ETH_RPC_URL",
    "selector_or_slot": "0x8da5cb5b",
    "target_contract": "0x6440f144b7e50D6a8439336510312d2F54beB01D",
    "target_label": "BOLD Token"
   },
   "reconciled": false,
   "reconciledFrom": [],
   "reconciledTo": [],
   "records": 1,
   "rosetteAria": "Liquity V2 (BOLD) control-plane rosette: Upgradeability not determined; Timelock floor not determined; Signer quorum not determined; Emergency / freeze scope not determined; Docs-vs-chain parity strong",
   "search": "liquity v2 (bold) liquity-v2-bold immutable cdp stablecoin bold lqty 0x6440f144b7e50d6a8439336510312d2f54beb01d 0x807def5e7d057df05c796f4bc75c3fe82bd6eee1 0xf949982b91c8c61e952b3ba942cbbfaef5386684",
   "slug": "liquity-v2-bold",
   "summary_short": "Sampled owner and proxy slots match the docs",
   "url": "https://pacta.wtf/protocols/liquity-v2-bold/"
  },
  {
   "baskets": [
    "lending_vaults"
   ],
   "category": "Vault-based peer-to-pool lending markets first built on BNB Chain (Ethereum)",
   "chains": [
    "ethereum"
   ],
   "deltas": 0,
   "easAttested": true,
   "evidence": {
    "documented": "'Upgrade authority sits behind an OpenZeppelin `TimelockController`' (docs.bsc.lista.org/for-developer/lista-lending/contract-reference.md)",
    "observed": "Lista Moolah 0xf820fB4680712CD7263a0D3D024D5b5aEA82Fd70 (Ethereum): EIP-1967 proxy, implementation 0xD7C983093065E0169e955c44ab8370110231D3cf; in its verified source _authorizeUpgrade is onlyRole(DEFAULT_ADMIN_ROLE). getRoleMemberCount(DEFAULT_ADMIN_ROLE) = 1 and its member is 0xa18ae79AEDA3e711E0CD64cfe1Cd06402d400D61, the 'Admin TimeLock' of the Ethereum contract table: a TimelockController (verified source) with getMinDelay() = 86,400 s.",
    "recordId": "lista-moolah-upgrade-admin-timelock-s32",
    "surface": "Moolah upgrade authority: sole DEFAULT_ADMIN_ROLE member is the Admin TimeLock, 86,400 s"
   },
   "factors": [
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "upgrade",
     "label": "Upgradeability",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "Upgrade path not in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": "controller fact: getMinDelay() = 86400s",
     "key": "timelock",
     "label": "Timelock floor",
     "state": "b",
     "value": "1d minimum enforced delay across control surfaces"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "quorum",
     "label": "Signer quorum",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No signer quorum in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "emergency",
     "label": "Emergency / freeze scope",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No pause / freeze authority in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "parity",
     "label": "Docs-vs-chain parity",
     "state": "g",
     "value": "Chain matches or is stronger than the documentation"
    }
   ],
   "finding": "Moolah upgrade authority: sole DEFAULT_ADMIN_ROLE member is the Admin TimeLock, 86,400 s",
   "grade": "aligned",
   "gradeLabel": "ALIGNED",
   "name": "Lista Lending",
   "pinnedBlock": 26451608,
   "probe": {
    "block_hash": "0x0266af5bcad519d93b3be78e41b76a62985e22fbe4feef043ac3225f6f217a17",
    "block_number": 26451608,
    "call_args": [
     "0x0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000",
     "0x0"
    ],
    "call_signature": "getRoleMember(bytes32,uint256)",
    "chain": "ethereum",
    "check_type": "eth_call",
    "extra_calls": [],
    "id": "lista-moolah-upgrade-admin-timelock-s32",
    "repro_calldata": "0x9010d07c00000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000",
    "rpc_env_var": "$ETH_RPC_URL",
    "selector_or_slot": "0x9010d07c",
    "target_contract": "0xf820fB4680712CD7263a0D3D024D5b5aEA82Fd70",
    "target_label": "Lista Moolah (Ethereum)"
   },
   "reconciled": false,
   "reconciledFrom": [],
   "reconciledTo": [],
   "records": 1,
   "rosetteAria": "Lista Lending control-plane rosette: Upgradeability not determined; Timelock floor moderate; Signer quorum not determined; Emergency / freeze scope not determined; Docs-vs-chain parity strong",
   "search": "lista lending lista-lending vault-based peer-to-pool lending markets first built on bnb chain (ethereum) lista 0xa18ae79aeda3e711e0cd64cfe1cd06402d400d61 0xd7c983093065e0169e955c44ab8370110231d3cf 0xf820fb4680712cd7263a0d3d024d5b5aea82fd70",
   "slug": "lista-lending",
   "summary_short": "Lista's Moolah upgrades sit behind its Admin TimeLock (24 h), as documented",
   "url": "https://pacta.wtf/protocols/lista-lending/"
  },
  {
   "baskets": [],
   "category": "Institutional BTCfi / Liquid Staked Bitcoin",
   "chains": [
    "ethereum"
   ],
   "deltas": 0,
   "easAttested": true,
   "evidence": {
    "documented": "docs.lombard.finance/learn/transparency/smart-contracts states 'Each Proxy Upgrade Timelock enforces a 24-hour minimum delay on contract upgrades.'",
    "observed": "LBTC (0x8236a87084f8B84306f72007F36F2618A5634494) EIP-1967 admin slot = ProxyAdmin (0xbae061C73876952aa2C5e483B74DfA785425f879), whose owner() — along with AssetRouter ProxyAdmin (0xBf4202c8a0d852D432266dfE112ED624a1a36754) and Consortium ProxyAdmin (0x1629AE77cC70DaAc95Ec479caAEA23ECE77c67c5) — resolves to TimelockController (0x055E84e7FE8955E2781010B866f10Ef6E1E77e59, getMinDelay() = 86400s / 24h, EXECUTOR_ROLE held by 3-of-5 Safe 0x251a604E8E8f6906d60f8dedC5aAeb8CD38F4892 with Guard 0x87bde523e05Fee2C557d6F592F7EB686C69189Ab); LBTC totalSupply = 6,203.54 LBTC (8 dec).",
    "recordId": "lombard-lbtc-core-proxy-upgrade-timelock",
    "surface": "Sampled Core ProxyAdmin Wiring & 24h TimelockController"
   },
   "factors": [
    {
     "evidence": "lombard-lbtc-core-proxy-upgrade-timelock: LBTC (0x8236a87084f8B84306f72007F36F2618A5634494) EIP-1967 admin slot = ProxyAdmin (0xbae061C73876952aa2C5e483B74DfA785425f879), whose owner() — along with …",
     "key": "upgrade",
     "label": "Upgradeability",
     "state": "b",
     "value": "Upgradeable behind a 1h–47h delay (1d)"
    },
    {
     "evidence": "controller fact: getMinDelay() = 86400s",
     "key": "timelock",
     "label": "Timelock floor",
     "state": "b",
     "value": "1d minimum enforced delay across control surfaces"
    },
    {
     "evidence": "lombard-lbtc-core-proxy-upgrade-timelock: … 86400s / 24h, EXECUTOR_ROLE held by 3-of-5 Safe 0x251a604E8E8f6906d60f8dedC5aAeb8CD38F4892 …",
     "key": "quorum",
     "label": "Signer quorum",
     "state": "g",
     "value": "Lowest controlling quorum: 3-of-5"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "emergency",
     "label": "Emergency / freeze scope",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No pause / freeze authority in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "parity",
     "label": "Docs-vs-chain parity",
     "state": "g",
     "value": "Chain matches or is stronger than the documentation"
    }
   ],
   "finding": "Sampled Core ProxyAdmin Wiring & 24h TimelockController",
   "grade": "aligned",
   "gradeLabel": "ALIGNED",
   "name": "Lombard (LBTC)",
   "pinnedBlock": 26407707,
   "probe": {
    "block_hash": "0xfc7beaa2338e8054577c0b101b641bc42afca2af39cb85d3fc13cbee32d4681a",
    "block_number": 26403523,
    "call_args": [],
    "call_signature": "getMinDelay()",
    "chain": "ethereum",
    "check_type": "eth_call",
    "extra_calls": [],
    "id": "lombard-lbtc-core-proxy-upgrade-timelock",
    "repro_calldata": "0xf27a0c92",
    "rpc_env_var": "$ETH_RPC_URL",
    "selector_or_slot": "0xf27a0c92",
    "target_contract": "0x055E84e7FE8955E2781010B866f10Ef6E1E77e59",
    "target_label": "Lombard TimelockController"
   },
   "reconciled": false,
   "reconciledFrom": [],
   "reconciledTo": [],
   "records": 2,
   "rosetteAria": "Lombard (LBTC) control-plane rosette: Upgradeability moderate; Timelock floor moderate; Signer quorum strong; Emergency / freeze scope not determined; Docs-vs-chain parity strong",
   "search": "lombard (lbtc) lombard-lbtc institutional btcfi / liquid staked bitcoin lbtc 0x055e84e7fe8955e2781010b866f10ef6e1e77e59 0x1629ae77cc70daac95ec479caaea23ece77c67c5 0x251a604e8e8f6906d60f8dedc5aaeb8cd38f4892 0x8236a87084f8b84306f72007f36f2618a5634494 0x87bde523e05fee2c557d6f592f7eb686c69189ab 0xbae061c73876952aa2c5e483b74dfa785425f879 0xbf4202c8a0d852d432266dfe112ed624a1a36754 0xc3ecfe771564e3f28cfb7a9b203f4d10279338ed",
   "slug": "lombard-lbtc",
   "summary_short": "Core ProxyAdmin wiring and 24-hour timelock match the docs",
   "url": "https://pacta.wtf/protocols/lombard-lbtc/"
  },
  {
   "baskets": [],
   "category": "Bonding mechanism that bootstraps protocol-owned LUSD liquidity (Ethereum)",
   "chains": [
    "ethereum"
   ],
   "deltas": 0,
   "easAttested": true,
   "evidence": {
    "documented": "'After deployment and initialization, no upgrade is possible.' (docs.chickenbonds.org/faq/technical-design.md); '0x57619FE9C539f890b19c61812226F9703ce37137' (docs.chickenbonds.org/llms-full.txt)",
    "observed": "ChickenBondManager 0x57619FE9C539f890b19c61812226F9703ce37137 (Ethereum; not a proxy: EIP-1967 implementation and admin slots empty; verified source): no owner() (the call reverts), no delegatecall or selfdestruct, and no upgrade path. Two functions are restricted to yearnGovernanceAddress() = 0xFEB4acf3df3cDEA7399794D0869ef76A6EfAff52 while migration is inactive: activateMigration(), the documented one-time wind-down (migration() = false at this pin), and sendFeeShare(uint256), which transfers LUSD from Yearn governance to the manager and deposits it to B.Protocol (a fee-share donation); no function is restricted to the Liquity team. bLUSD 0xB9D7DdDca9a4AC480991865EfEf82E01273F79C3 (not a proxy): owner() is the zero address (setAddresses already used, ownership renounced) and mint / burn require msg.sender == chickenBondManagerAddress() = the ChickenBondManager. BondNFT 0xa8384862219188a8f03c144953Cf21fc124029Ee: owner() is the zero address, chickenBondManager() = the ChickenBondManager.",
    "recordId": "lusd-chickenbonds-no-upgrade-no-admin-s34",
    "surface": "ChickenBondManager not a proxy, no owner; bLUSD and BondNFT owners renounced"
   },
   "factors": [
    {
     "evidence": "lusd-chickenbonds-no-upgrade-no-admin-s34: … 0x57619FE9C539f890b19c61812226F9703ce37137 (Ethereum; not a proxy: EIP-1967 implementation and admin …",
     "key": "upgrade",
     "label": "Upgradeability",
     "state": "g",
     "value": "Immutable or ownership renounced"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "timelock",
     "label": "Timelock floor",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No enforced admin delay in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "quorum",
     "label": "Signer quorum",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No signer quorum in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "emergency",
     "label": "Emergency / freeze scope",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No pause / freeze authority in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "parity",
     "label": "Docs-vs-chain parity",
     "state": "g",
     "value": "Chain matches or is stronger than the documentation"
    }
   ],
   "finding": "ChickenBondManager not a proxy, no owner; bLUSD and BondNFT owners renounced",
   "grade": "aligned",
   "gradeLabel": "ALIGNED",
   "name": "LUSD ChickenBonds",
   "pinnedBlock": 26453551,
   "probe": {
    "block_hash": "0x51e9967ffd6a84012d0dad44204d523b8ac43928e69de2801d2e72dbf8767129",
    "block_number": 26453551,
    "call_args": [],
    "call_signature": "owner()",
    "chain": "ethereum",
    "check_type": "eth_call",
    "extra_calls": [],
    "id": "lusd-chickenbonds-no-upgrade-no-admin-s34",
    "repro_calldata": "0x8da5cb5b",
    "rpc_env_var": "$ETH_RPC_URL",
    "selector_or_slot": "0x8da5cb5b",
    "target_contract": "0xB9D7DdDca9a4AC480991865EfEf82E01273F79C3",
    "target_label": "bLUSD"
   },
   "reconciled": false,
   "reconciledFrom": [],
   "reconciledTo": [],
   "records": 1,
   "rosetteAria": "LUSD ChickenBonds control-plane rosette: Upgradeability strong; Timelock floor not determined; Signer quorum not determined; Emergency / freeze scope not determined; Docs-vs-chain parity strong",
   "search": "lusd chickenbonds lusd-chickenbonds bonding mechanism that bootstraps protocol-owned lusd liquidity (ethereum) blusd 0x57619fe9c539f890b19c61812226f9703ce37137 0xa8384862219188a8f03c144953cf21fc124029ee 0xb9d7dddca9a4ac480991865efef82e01273f79c3 0xfeb4acf3df3cdea7399794d0869ef76a6efaff52",
   "slug": "lusd-chickenbonds",
   "summary_short": "LUSD Chicken Bonds cannot be upgraded; the Liquity team holds no admin, as documented",
   "url": "https://pacta.wtf/protocols/lusd-chickenbonds/"
  },
  {
   "baskets": [
    "stable_rwa"
   ],
   "category": "Stablecoin Infrastructure",
   "chains": [
    "ethereum"
   ],
   "deltas": 0,
   "easAttested": true,
   "evidence": {
    "documented": "docs.m0.org/raw/protocol/m-token.md: 'The MToken contract itself is designed to be immutable, meaning its core logic cannot be upgraded directly.'",
    "observed": "MToken (0x866A2BF4E572CbcF37D5071A7a58503Bfb36be1b) EIP-1967 implementation and admin slots are both 0 (no EIP-1967 proxy); name() = 'M by M^0', totalSupply() = 249,955,861.65 M (6 decimals); ttgRegistrar() = Registrar (0x119FbeeDD4F4f4298Fb59B720d5654442b81ae2c), minterGateway() = MinterGateway (0xf7f9638cb444D65e5A40bF5ff98ebE4ff319F04E).",
    "recordId": "m0-mtoken-no-eip1967-proxy-immutable-s17",
    "surface": "MToken: no EIP-1967 proxy slots (immutable core logic)"
   },
   "factors": [
    {
     "evidence": "m0-ttg-registrar-governors-match-docs-s17: EIP-1967 implementation slot = 0. MinterGateway.ttgRegistrar() returns the same Registrar.",
     "key": "upgrade",
     "label": "Upgradeability",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "Upgradeable; the delay gating the upgrade path is not in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "timelock",
     "label": "Timelock floor",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No enforced admin delay in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "quorum",
     "label": "Signer quorum",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No signer quorum in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "emergency",
     "label": "Emergency / freeze scope",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No pause / freeze authority in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "parity",
     "label": "Docs-vs-chain parity",
     "state": "g",
     "value": "Chain matches or is stronger than the documentation"
    }
   ],
   "finding": "MToken: no EIP-1967 proxy slots (immutable core logic)",
   "grade": "aligned",
   "gradeLabel": "ALIGNED",
   "name": "M0 Protocol ($M)",
   "pinnedBlock": 26418060,
   "probe": {
    "block_hash": "0x8914f5134a4488a812b61c1c7f479c3082d80f6fbe2f181abb9e5ef4ff973f3c",
    "block_number": 26418060,
    "call_args": [],
    "call_signature": null,
    "chain": "ethereum",
    "check_type": "eth_getStorageAt",
    "extra_calls": [],
    "id": "m0-mtoken-no-eip1967-proxy-immutable-s17",
    "repro_calldata": null,
    "rpc_env_var": "$ETH_RPC_URL",
    "selector_or_slot": "0x360894a13ba1a3210667c828492db98dca3e2076cc3735a920a3ca505d382bbc",
    "target_contract": "0x866A2BF4E572CbcF37D5071A7a58503Bfb36be1b",
    "target_label": "M0 MToken ($M)"
   },
   "reconciled": false,
   "reconciledFrom": [],
   "reconciledTo": [],
   "records": 2,
   "rosetteAria": "M0 Protocol ($M) control-plane rosette: Upgradeability not determined; Timelock floor not determined; Signer quorum not determined; Emergency / freeze scope not determined; Docs-vs-chain parity strong",
   "search": "m0 protocol ($m) m0-protocol-m stablecoin infrastructure m m0 mtoken 0x119fbeedd4f4f4298fb59b720d5654442b81ae2c 0x866a2bf4e572cbcf37d5071a7a58503bfb36be1b 0x886d405949f709bc3f4451491bdd07ff51cdf90a 0xa0dafaeea4a1d44534e1b9227e19cae6358b80fe 0xb024ac5a7c6bc92fbacc8c3387e628a07e1da016 0xf7f9638cb444d65e5a40bf5ff98ebe4ff319f04e",
   "slug": "m0-protocol-m",
   "summary_short": "MToken has no proxy slots: immutable core logic, as documented",
   "url": "https://pacta.wtf/protocols/m0-protocol-m/"
  },
  {
   "baskets": [],
   "category": "Execution infrastructure where asset managers run strategies as Machines (Ethereum)",
   "chains": [
    "ethereum"
   ],
   "deltas": 0,
   "easAttested": true,
   "evidence": {
    "documented": "'`INFRA_UPGRADE_ROLE` is held by the DAO with a **2-day execution delay**' (docs.makina.finance/llms-full.txt) (roles table: INFRA_UPGRADE_ROLE = 6)",
    "observed": "Makina AccessManager 0x0fCEfa3f1047F35521A49cD8B06faBd588665d7F (Ethereum): getAccess(6, DAO multisig 0x62244C74e1d09b3D86EF7342d354b5D7770bDE10) = member since 1779354899, execution delay 172,800 s; getRoleGuardian(6) = 7. The HubCoreFactory 0x8d28A69328561eF9F171c58996fEcB9F494e070c's EIP-1967 admin is ProxyAdmin 0xEb78836D3aa3A0518A96fd7C9c549d0FFB7D6dA9, whose owner() is the AccessManager.",
    "recordId": "makina-upgrade-role-dao-delay-2d-s30",
    "surface": "Upgrade role (6): DAO multisig execution delay 172,800 s"
   },
   "factors": [
    {
     "evidence": "makina-upgrade-role-dao-delay-2d-s30: getRoleGuardian(6) = 7. The HubCoreFactory 0x8d28A69328561eF9F171c58996fEcB9F494e070c's EIP-1967 admin is ProxyAdmin 0xEb78836D3aa3A0518A96fd7C9c549d0FFB7D6dA9 …",
     "key": "upgrade",
     "label": "Upgradeability",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "Upgradeable; the delay gating the upgrade path is not in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": "makina-upgrade-role-dao-delay-2d-s30: observed_delay_seconds = 172800",
     "key": "timelock",
     "label": "Timelock floor",
     "state": "g",
     "value": "2d minimum enforced delay across control surfaces"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "quorum",
     "label": "Signer quorum",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No signer quorum in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "emergency",
     "label": "Emergency / freeze scope",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No pause / freeze authority in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "parity",
     "label": "Docs-vs-chain parity",
     "state": "g",
     "value": "Chain matches or is stronger than the documentation"
    }
   ],
   "finding": "Upgrade role (6): DAO multisig execution delay 172,800 s",
   "grade": "aligned",
   "gradeLabel": "ALIGNED",
   "name": "Makina",
   "pinnedBlock": 26449594,
   "probe": {
    "block_hash": "0xbe263d5b378dcb7c3c4e18bd8e388f0cb2dab1adacd83de2be58c9408b377287",
    "block_number": 26449594,
    "call_args": [
     "0x6",
     "0x62244C74e1d09b3D86EF7342d354b5D7770bDE10"
    ],
    "call_signature": "getAccess(uint64,address)",
    "chain": "ethereum",
    "check_type": "eth_call",
    "extra_calls": [],
    "id": "makina-upgrade-role-dao-delay-2d-s30",
    "repro_calldata": "0x3078f114000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000600000000000000000000000062244c74e1d09b3d86ef7342d354b5d7770bde10",
    "rpc_env_var": "$ETH_RPC_URL",
    "selector_or_slot": "0x3078f114",
    "target_contract": "0x0fCEfa3f1047F35521A49cD8B06faBd588665d7F",
    "target_label": "Makina AccessManager"
   },
   "reconciled": false,
   "reconciledFrom": [],
   "reconciledTo": [],
   "records": 1,
   "rosetteAria": "Makina control-plane rosette: Upgradeability not determined; Timelock floor strong; Signer quorum not determined; Emergency / freeze scope not determined; Docs-vs-chain parity strong",
   "search": "makina makina execution infrastructure where asset managers run strategies as machines (ethereum) makina 0x0fcefa3f1047f35521a49cd8b06fabd588665d7f 0x62244c74e1d09b3d86ef7342d354b5d7770bde10 0x8d28a69328561ef9f171c58996fecb9f494e070c 0xeb78836d3aa3a0518a96fd7c9c549d0ffb7d6da9",
   "slug": "makina",
   "summary_short": "Makina's DAO multisig must wait 48 hours to use the upgrade role, as documented",
   "url": "https://pacta.wtf/protocols/makina/"
  },
  {
   "baskets": [
    "eth_lst_lrt"
   ],
   "category": "Liquid Staking & Restaking",
   "chains": [
    "ethereum"
   ],
   "deltas": 0,
   "easAttested": true,
   "evidence": {
    "documented": "docs.mantle.xyz/meth/concepts/risk-management/upgradability-and-timelock.md previously noted 'The timelock is configured with a default delay of 0' (live deployment enforces stricter 3-day UpgradeTimelock).",
    "observed": "mETH (0xd5F7838F5C461fefF7FE49ea5ebaF7728bB0ADfa) & Staking (0xe3cBd06D7dadB3F4e6557bAb7EdD924CD1489E8f) EIP-1967 admin slots point to UpgradeTimelock (0xc26016f1166bE7b6c5611AAB104122E0f6c2aCE2) with getMinDelay() = 259200s (3 days) and PROPOSER_ROLE held by 6-of-14 Security Council Safe (0x4e59e778a0fb77fBb305637435C62FaeD9aED40f); mETH totalSupply = 217,256.94 mETH.",
    "recordId": "mantle-lsp-meth-upgrade-timelock",
    "surface": "Core Proxy EIP-1967 Admin Slot & 3-Day UpgradeTimelock"
   },
   "factors": [
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "upgrade",
     "label": "Upgradeability",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "Upgrade path not in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": "controller fact: getMinDelay() = 259200s",
     "key": "timelock",
     "label": "Timelock floor",
     "state": "g",
     "value": "3d minimum enforced delay across control surfaces"
    },
    {
     "evidence": "mantle-lsp-meth-upgrade-timelock: … (3 days) and PROPOSER_ROLE held by 6-of-14 Security Council Safe (0x4e59e778a0fb77fBb305637435C62FaeD9aED40f); …",
     "key": "quorum",
     "label": "Signer quorum",
     "state": "g",
     "value": "Lowest controlling quorum: 6-of-14"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "emergency",
     "label": "Emergency / freeze scope",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No pause / freeze authority in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "parity",
     "label": "Docs-vs-chain parity",
     "state": "g",
     "value": "Chain matches or is stronger than the documentation"
    }
   ],
   "finding": "Timelock delay: docs say 0 s (no delay) · chain says 3 d",
   "grade": "protective",
   "gradeLabel": "PROTECTIVE",
   "name": "Mantle Liquid Staking (mETH / cmETH)",
   "pinnedBlock": 26403121,
   "probe": {
    "block_hash": "0x71acee2313a2c8eacd7d2c87667dc505310b3e9224d84eaebb71d5a890ef9d1c",
    "block_number": 26403121,
    "call_args": [],
    "call_signature": "getMinDelay()",
    "chain": "ethereum",
    "check_type": "eth_call",
    "extra_calls": [],
    "id": "mantle-lsp-meth-upgrade-timelock",
    "repro_calldata": "0xf27a0c92",
    "rpc_env_var": "$ETH_RPC_URL",
    "selector_or_slot": "0xf27a0c92",
    "target_contract": "0xc26016f1166bE7b6c5611AAB104122E0f6c2aCE2",
    "target_label": "Mantle UpgradeTimelock"
   },
   "reconciled": false,
   "reconciledFrom": [],
   "reconciledTo": [],
   "records": 1,
   "rosetteAria": "Mantle Liquid Staking (mETH / cmETH) control-plane rosette: Upgradeability not determined; Timelock floor strong; Signer quorum strong; Emergency / freeze scope not determined; Docs-vs-chain parity strong",
   "search": "mantle liquid staking (meth / cmeth) mantle-liquid-staking-meth-cmeth liquid staking & restaking meth cmeth 0x4e59e778a0fb77fbb305637435c62faed9aed40f 0xc26016f1166be7b6c5611aab104122e0f6c2ace2 0xd5f7838f5c461feff7fe49ea5ebaf7728bb0adfa 0xe3cbd06d7dadb3f4e6557bab7edd924cd1489e8f",
   "slug": "mantle-liquid-staking-meth-cmeth",
   "summary_short": "Timelock delay: docs none · chain 3 days (stricter)",
   "url": "https://pacta.wtf/protocols/mantle-liquid-staking-meth-cmeth/"
  },
  {
   "baskets": [
    "stable_rwa"
   ],
   "category": "Institutional Credit / RWA",
   "chains": [
    "ethereum"
   ],
   "deltas": 1,
   "easAttested": true,
   "evidence": {
    "documented": "Governor admin actions documentation describes GovernorTimelock (3-day delay) governance path.",
    "observed": "EIP-1967 admin slot holds 4-of-7 Maple DAO Safe (0xd6d4Bcde6c816F17889f1Dd3000aF0261B03a196); Globals.governor() (0x804a6F5F667170F545Bf14e5DDB48C70B788390C) points to GovernorTimelock (0x2eFFf88747EB5a3FF00d4d8d0f0800E306C0426b, getMinDelay = 259200s / 3d); syrupUSDC (0x80ac24aA929eaF5013f6436cdA2a7ba190f5Cc0b) totalAssets = 898,551,580.57 units (6 dec).",
    "recordId": "maple-v2-syrup-ppm-admin",
    "surface": "EIP-1967 Proxy Admin Slot vs. GovernorTimelock"
   },
   "factors": [
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "upgrade",
     "label": "Upgradeability",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "Upgrade path not in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "timelock",
     "label": "Timelock floor",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No enforced admin delay in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": "maple-v2-syrup-ppm-admin: EIP-1967 admin slot holds 4-of-7 Maple DAO Safe (0xd6d4Bcde6c816F17889f1Dd3000aF0261B03a196); …",
     "key": "quorum",
     "label": "Signer quorum",
     "state": "g",
     "value": "Lowest controlling quorum: 4-of-7"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "emergency",
     "label": "Emergency / freeze scope",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No pause / freeze authority in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "parity",
     "label": "Docs-vs-chain parity",
     "state": "a",
     "value": "Documentation differs from the chain (parameter delta)"
    }
   ],
   "finding": "EIP-1967 Proxy Admin Slot vs. GovernorTimelock: docs say Governor admin actions documentation describes GovernorTimelock (3-day delay) governance path. · chain says EIP-1967 admin slot holds 4-of-7 Maple DAO Safe (0xd6d4Bcde6c816F17889f1Dd3000aF0261B03a196);",
   "grade": "delta",
   "gradeLabel": "DELTA",
   "name": "Maple Finance V2 / Syrup",
   "pinnedBlock": 26401540,
   "probe": {
    "block_hash": "0x49324aaf84b0ffd4e21026c5345272788bff377f0f86fcdb74280cdfc32a9641",
    "block_number": 26401540,
    "call_args": [],
    "call_signature": null,
    "chain": "ethereum",
    "check_type": "eth_getStorageAt",
    "extra_calls": [],
    "id": "maple-v2-syrup-ppm-admin",
    "repro_calldata": null,
    "rpc_env_var": "$ETH_RPC_URL",
    "selector_or_slot": "0xb53127684a568b3173ae13b9f8a6016e243e63b6e8ee1178d6a717850b5d6103",
    "target_contract": "0xBe10aDcE8B6E3E02Db384E7FaDA5395DD113D8b3",
    "target_label": "PoolPermissionManager"
   },
   "reconciled": false,
   "reconciledFrom": [],
   "reconciledTo": [],
   "records": 1,
   "rosetteAria": "Maple Finance V2 / Syrup control-plane rosette: Upgradeability not determined; Timelock floor not determined; Signer quorum strong; Emergency / freeze scope not determined; Docs-vs-chain parity weak",
   "search": "maple finance v2 / syrup maple-finance-v2-syrup institutional credit / rwa syrup syrupusdc syrupusdt 0x2efff88747eb5a3ff00d4d8d0f0800e306c0426b 0x804a6f5f667170f545bf14e5ddb48c70b788390c 0x80ac24aa929eaf5013f6436cda2a7ba190f5cc0b 0xbe10adce8b6e3e02db384e7fada5395dd113d8b3 0xd6d4bcde6c816f17889f1dd3000af0261b03a196",
   "slug": "maple-finance-v2-syrup",
   "summary_short": "Proxy admin is the 4-of-7 DAO Safe; docs describe a 3-day GovernorTimelock",
   "url": "https://pacta.wtf/protocols/maple-finance-v2-syrup/"
  },
  {
   "baskets": [],
   "category": "AMM-based perpetual swaps (wound down; user deposits remain) (Ethereum)",
   "chains": [
    "ethereum"
   ],
   "deltas": 0,
   "easAttested": true,
   "evidence": {
    "documented": "'DAO uses a multi-sig on each chain, and each multi-sig requires the confirmation of 4 out of 8 owners.' (docs.mux.network/protocol/contracts/contracts-dao.md)",
    "observed": "DAO Safe 0x38ca50c6E3391A5bf73c2504bd9Cd9c0b9D89053 (Ethereum): getThreshold() = 4 of getOwners() = 8 owners (Safe v1.1.1); it controls AdminUpgradeabilityProxy 0x4e352cF164E64ADCBad318C3a1e222E9EBa4Ce42.",
    "recordId": "mcdex-safe-threshold-s28",
    "surface": "DAO: 4-of-8 Safe, as documented"
   },
   "factors": [
    {
     "evidence": "mcdex-safe-threshold-s28: it controls AdminUpgradeabilityProxy 0x4e352cF164E64ADCBad318C3a1e222E9EBa4Ce42.",
     "key": "upgrade",
     "label": "Upgradeability",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "Upgradeable; the delay gating the upgrade path is not in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "timelock",
     "label": "Timelock floor",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No enforced admin delay in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": "controller fact: Safe getThreshold()",
     "key": "quorum",
     "label": "Signer quorum",
     "state": "g",
     "value": "Lowest controlling quorum: 4-of-8"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "emergency",
     "label": "Emergency / freeze scope",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No pause / freeze authority in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "parity",
     "label": "Docs-vs-chain parity",
     "state": "g",
     "value": "Chain matches or is stronger than the documentation"
    }
   ],
   "finding": "DAO: 4-of-8 Safe, as documented",
   "grade": "aligned",
   "gradeLabel": "ALIGNED",
   "name": "MCDEX",
   "pinnedBlock": 26441165,
   "probe": {
    "block_hash": "0x5182be2c61af5f48ed2ec43d3c177dedad257c4e966a7e384120829de73901d9",
    "block_number": 26441165,
    "call_args": [],
    "call_signature": "getThreshold()",
    "chain": "ethereum",
    "check_type": "eth_call",
    "extra_calls": [],
    "id": "mcdex-safe-threshold-s28",
    "repro_calldata": "0xe75235b8",
    "rpc_env_var": "$ETH_RPC_URL",
    "selector_or_slot": "0xe75235b8",
    "target_contract": "0x38ca50c6E3391A5bf73c2504bd9Cd9c0b9D89053",
    "target_label": "DAO Safe"
   },
   "reconciled": false,
   "reconciledFrom": [],
   "reconciledTo": [],
   "records": 1,
   "rosetteAria": "MCDEX control-plane rosette: Upgradeability not determined; Timelock floor not determined; Signer quorum strong; Emergency / freeze scope not determined; Docs-vs-chain parity strong",
   "search": "mcdex mcdex amm-based perpetual swaps (wound down; user deposits remain) (ethereum) mcb 0x38ca50c6e3391a5bf73c2504bd9cd9c0b9d89053 0x4e352cf164e64adcbad318c3a1e222e9eba4ce42",
   "slug": "mcdex",
   "summary_short": "MCDEX's DAO is a 4-of-8 Safe, as documented",
   "url": "https://pacta.wtf/protocols/mcdex/"
  },
  {
   "baskets": [
    "eth_lst_lrt",
    "lending_vaults"
   ],
   "category": "Liquid Restaking / Curated Vaults",
   "chains": [
    "ethereum"
   ],
   "deltas": 1,
   "easAttested": true,
   "evidence": {
    "documented": "lidofinance/docs (earn/deployment-contracts.md line 199) lists 3/6 multisig; Mellow Core Vault docs describe bounded curator permissions.",
    "observed": "getThreshold() = 3, getOwners().length = 5 (3-of-5 Gnosis Safe); DEFAULT_ADMIN_ROLE (0x00) on earnETH (0x6a37725ca7f4CE81c004c955f7280d5C704a249e) and earnUSD (0x014e6DA8F283C4aF65B2AA0f201438680A004452) held by 5-of-8 Lazy Vault Admin Safe (0x0Dd73341d6158a72b4D224541f1094188f57076E, Timelock 0x363Ba8843d06BA5968f55C26aB055162eDd62189 getMinDelay = 0s), where all 5 Curator signers are Lazy Vault Admin owners.",
    "recordId": "mellow-lido-earn-curator-quorum",
    "surface": "Curator Safe Quorum & Lazy Admin Signer Overlap"
   },
   "factors": [
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "upgrade",
     "label": "Upgradeability",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "Upgrade path not in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": "controller fact: getMinDelay() = 0s",
     "key": "timelock",
     "label": "Timelock floor",
     "state": "a",
     "value": "0s minimum enforced delay across control surfaces"
    },
    {
     "evidence": "mellow-lido-earn-curator-quorum: getThreshold() = 3, getOwners().length = 5 (3-of-5 Gnosis Safe); DEFAULT_ADMIN_ROLE (0x00) …",
     "key": "quorum",
     "label": "Signer quorum",
     "state": "g",
     "value": "Lowest controlling quorum: 3-of-5"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "emergency",
     "label": "Emergency / freeze scope",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No pause / freeze authority in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "parity",
     "label": "Docs-vs-chain parity",
     "state": "a",
     "value": "Documentation differs from the chain (parameter delta)"
    }
   ],
   "finding": "Curator Safe Quorum & Lazy Admin Signer Overlap: docs say lidofinance/docs (earn/deployment-contracts.md line 199) lists 3/6 multisig; · chain says getThreshold() = 3, getOwners().length = 5 (3-of-5 Gnosis Safe);",
   "grade": "delta",
   "gradeLabel": "DELTA",
   "name": "Mellow Protocol / Lido Earn",
   "pinnedBlock": 26401312,
   "probe": {
    "block_hash": "0x95866ea3ef8f9a0567ce000bc8075f6dc5fb0f1e80cb4e9999ae624a2f0dc109",
    "block_number": 26401312,
    "call_args": [],
    "call_signature": "getThreshold()",
    "chain": "ethereum",
    "check_type": "eth_call",
    "extra_calls": [],
    "id": "mellow-lido-earn-curator-quorum",
    "repro_calldata": "0xe75235b8",
    "rpc_env_var": "$ETH_RPC_URL",
    "selector_or_slot": "0xe75235b8",
    "target_contract": "0xe5abcc40196174Ae0d12153dE286F0D8E401769d",
    "target_label": "Mellow Curator Safe"
   },
   "reconciled": false,
   "reconciledFrom": [],
   "reconciledTo": [],
   "records": 1,
   "rosetteAria": "Mellow Protocol / Lido Earn control-plane rosette: Upgradeability not determined; Timelock floor weak; Signer quorum strong; Emergency / freeze scope not determined; Docs-vs-chain parity weak",
   "search": "mellow protocol / lido earn mellow-protocol-lido-earn liquid restaking / curated vaults mellow lido earn 0x014e6da8f283c4af65b2aa0f201438680a004452 0x0dd73341d6158a72b4d224541f1094188f57076e 0x363ba8843d06ba5968f55c26ab055162edd62189 0x6a37725ca7f4ce81c004c955f7280d5c704a249e 0xe5abcc40196174ae0d12153de286f0d8e401769d",
   "slug": "mellow-protocol-lido-earn",
   "summary_short": "Curator Safe: docs 3-of-6 · chain 3-of-5",
   "url": "https://pacta.wtf/protocols/mellow-protocol-lido-earn/"
  },
  {
   "baskets": [
    "eth_lst_lrt"
   ],
   "category": "Liquid staking spanning NEAR and Ethereum validators (Ethereum)",
   "chains": [
    "ethereum"
   ],
   "deltas": 0,
   "easAttested": true,
   "evidence": {
    "documented": "'Proxy Admin Address: 0x806F870ee04A2CC8bf2aD053BAa5ed9999A1f182' (docs.metapool.app/llms-full.txt)",
    "observed": "Meta Pool spETH 0xD06f6a56c5f599cB375B616DF306f32B7F6f4A0E (Ethereum): EIP-1967 proxy (implementation 0xD3dB79D2D00A6B82531D8Ccf65C376d9eE9513aC), admin slot = ProxyAdmin 0x806F870ee04A2CC8bf2aD053BAa5ed9999A1f182. The same ProxyAdmin administers the published target (MetaPoolETH 0x48AFbBd342F64EF8a9Ab1C143719b63C2AD81710) and the documented Liquid Unstake Pool 0xdF261F967E87B2aa44e18a22f4aCE5d7f74f03Cc. ProxyAdmin owner() = 0x24D9664Ba8384D94499d6698ab285b69E879D971, a 3-of-6 Safe: the contract list names both addresses (Proxy Admin; SAFE Multisig (DAO Admin)).",
    "recordId": "meta-pool-eth-proxy-admin-dao-safe-s30",
    "surface": "spETH upgrade admin: the documented ProxyAdmin, owned by the DAO Admin Safe (3-of-6)"
   },
   "factors": [
    {
     "evidence": "meta-pool-eth-proxy-admin-dao-safe-s30: Meta Pool spETH 0xD06f6a56c5f599cB375B616DF306f32B7F6f4A0E (Ethereum): EIP-1967 proxy (implementation 0xD3dB79D2D00A6B82531D8Ccf65C376d9eE9513aC), admin slot = …",
     "key": "upgrade",
     "label": "Upgradeability",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "Upgradeable; the delay gating the upgrade path is not in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "timelock",
     "label": "Timelock floor",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No enforced admin delay in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": "meta-pool-eth-proxy-admin-dao-safe-s30: … 0x24D9664Ba8384D94499d6698ab285b69E879D971, a 3-of-6 Safe: the contract list names both …",
     "key": "quorum",
     "label": "Signer quorum",
     "state": "g",
     "value": "Lowest controlling quorum: 3-of-6"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "emergency",
     "label": "Emergency / freeze scope",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No pause / freeze authority in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "parity",
     "label": "Docs-vs-chain parity",
     "state": "g",
     "value": "Chain matches or is stronger than the documentation"
    }
   ],
   "finding": "spETH upgrade admin: the documented ProxyAdmin, owned by the DAO Admin Safe (3-of-6)",
   "grade": "aligned",
   "gradeLabel": "ALIGNED",
   "name": "Meta Pool ETH",
   "pinnedBlock": 26449594,
   "probe": {
    "block_hash": "0xbe263d5b378dcb7c3c4e18bd8e388f0cb2dab1adacd83de2be58c9408b377287",
    "block_number": 26449594,
    "call_args": [],
    "call_signature": "owner()",
    "chain": "ethereum",
    "check_type": "eth_call",
    "extra_calls": [],
    "id": "meta-pool-eth-proxy-admin-dao-safe-s30",
    "repro_calldata": "0x8da5cb5b",
    "rpc_env_var": "$ETH_RPC_URL",
    "selector_or_slot": "0x8da5cb5b",
    "target_contract": "0x806F870ee04A2CC8bf2aD053BAa5ed9999A1f182",
    "target_label": "Meta Pool ProxyAdmin (spETH, Liquid Unstake Pool, MetaPoolETH)"
   },
   "reconciled": false,
   "reconciledFrom": [],
   "reconciledTo": [],
   "records": 1,
   "rosetteAria": "Meta Pool ETH control-plane rosette: Upgradeability not determined; Timelock floor not determined; Signer quorum strong; Emergency / freeze scope not determined; Docs-vs-chain parity strong",
   "search": "meta pool eth meta-pool-eth liquid staking spanning near and ethereum validators (ethereum) mpeth 0x24d9664ba8384d94499d6698ab285b69e879d971 0x48afbbd342f64ef8a9ab1c143719b63c2ad81710 0x806f870ee04a2cc8bf2ad053baa5ed9999a1f182 0xd06f6a56c5f599cb375b616df306f32b7f6f4a0e 0xd3db79d2d00a6b82531d8ccf65c376d9ee9513ac 0xdf261f967e87b2aa44e18a22f4ace5d7f74f03cc",
   "slug": "meta-pool-eth",
   "summary_short": "spETH upgrades through the documented ProxyAdmin, owned by the 3-of-6 DAO Admin Safe",
   "url": "https://pacta.wtf/protocols/meta-pool-eth/"
  },
  {
   "baskets": [
    "lending_vaults"
   ],
   "category": "Curated Lending Vaults",
   "chains": [
    "ethereum"
   ],
   "deltas": 1,
   "easAttested": true,
   "evidence": {
    "documented": "Peer Re7 curated vault architecture and Aragon guardian integration.",
    "observed": "Re7 WETH owner() = 0xE86399fE6d7007FdEcb08A2ee1434Ee677a04433 (2-of-4 Safe), timelock() = 259200s (3d), guardian() = 0x0000000000000000000000000000000000000000, pendingGuardian() = (0x0, 0); peer Re7 USDT (0x95EeF579155cd2C5510F312c8fA39208c3Be01a8) sets guardian() = 0x2F80ba89362f86a9acC71BFfE5EcF4997F52BDd4 (Aragon Guardian).",
    "recordId": "metamorpho-re7-weth-guardian-parity",
    "surface": "Sampled MetaMorpho Vault Guardian Configuration"
   },
   "factors": [
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "upgrade",
     "label": "Upgradeability",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "Upgrade path not in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": "metamorpho-re7-weth-guardian-parity: observed_delay_seconds = 259200",
     "key": "timelock",
     "label": "Timelock floor",
     "state": "g",
     "value": "3d minimum enforced delay across control surfaces"
    },
    {
     "evidence": "metamorpho-re7-weth-guardian-parity: … 0xE86399fE6d7007FdEcb08A2ee1434Ee677a04433 (2-of-4 Safe), timelock() = 259200s (3d), guardian() …",
     "key": "quorum",
     "label": "Signer quorum",
     "state": "b",
     "value": "Lowest controlling quorum: 2-of-4"
    },
    {
     "evidence": "metamorpho-re7-weth-guardian-parity: Re7 WETH owner() = 0xE86399fE6d7007FdEcb08A2ee1434Ee677a04433 (2-of-4 Safe), timelock() = 259200s (3d), guardian() = 0x0000000000000000000000000000000000000000 …",
     "key": "emergency",
     "label": "Emergency / freeze scope",
     "state": "g",
     "value": "Pause / freeze authority scoped behind a multi-signer controller (2-of-4)"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "parity",
     "label": "Docs-vs-chain parity",
     "state": "a",
     "value": "Documentation differs from the chain (parameter delta)"
    }
   ],
   "finding": "Sampled MetaMorpho Vault Guardian Configuration: docs say Peer Re7 curated vault architecture and Aragon guardian integration. · chain says Re7 WETH owner() = 0xE86399fE6d7007FdEcb08A2ee1434Ee677a04433 (2-of-4 Safe), timelock() = 259200s (3d), guardian() = 0x0000000000000000000000000000000000000000, pendingGuardian() = (0x0, 0);",
   "grade": "delta",
   "gradeLabel": "DELTA",
   "name": "MetaMorpho (Re7 WETH vs. Re7 USDT)",
   "pinnedBlock": 26401405,
   "probe": {
    "block_hash": "0x26e155e1569d436406a52ecee31c94d8d8ef2ca4c45d82211a84c8c802be1510",
    "block_number": 26401405,
    "call_args": [],
    "call_signature": "guardian()",
    "chain": "ethereum",
    "check_type": "eth_call",
    "extra_calls": [],
    "id": "metamorpho-re7-weth-guardian-parity",
    "repro_calldata": "0x452a9320",
    "rpc_env_var": "$ETH_RPC_URL",
    "selector_or_slot": "0x452a9320",
    "target_contract": "0x78Fc2c2eD1A4cDb5402365934aE5648aDAd094d0",
    "target_label": "MetaMorpho Re7 WETH"
   },
   "reconciled": false,
   "reconciledFrom": [],
   "reconciledTo": [],
   "records": 1,
   "rosetteAria": "MetaMorpho (Re7 WETH vs. Re7 USDT) control-plane rosette: Upgradeability not determined; Timelock floor strong; Signer quorum moderate; Emergency / freeze scope strong; Docs-vs-chain parity weak",
   "search": "metamorpho (re7 weth vs. re7 usdt) metamorpho-re7-weth-vs-re7-usdt curated lending vaults re7weth re7usdt metamorpho 0x0000000000000000000000000000000000000000 0x2f80ba89362f86a9acc71bffe5ecf4997f52bdd4 0x78fc2c2ed1a4cdb5402365934ae5648adad094d0 0x95eef579155cd2c5510f312c8fa39208c3be01a8 0xe86399fe6d7007fdecb08a2ee1434ee677a04433",
   "slug": "metamorpho-re7-weth-vs-re7-usdt",
   "summary_short": "Re7 WETH vault has no guardian; its owner is a 2-of-4 Safe with a 3-day timelock",
   "url": "https://pacta.wtf/protocols/metamorpho-re7-weth-vs-re7-usdt/"
  },
  {
   "baskets": [],
   "category": "Canonical L1 gateway for an optimistic rollup with a decentralized sequencer pool (Ethereum)",
   "chains": [
    "ethereum"
   ],
   "deltas": 0,
   "easAttested": false,
   "evidence": {
    "documented": "Metis Bridge documentation is linked for reference (https://bridge.metis.io/docs). This RPC-pinned record does not compare documentation parameters with the on-chain state.",
    "observed": "Metis Token (MToken) (0x9E32b13ce7f2E80A01932B42553652E053D6ed8e) verified on Ethereum Mainnet at canonical block #26,458,556 (8,912 bytes runtime code). EIP-1967 implementation and admin storage slots are both zero (non-EIP-1967 contract). No owner(), admin(), authority(), curator() or AccessControl admin was readable on the contract.",
    "recordId": "metis-bridge-control-plane",
    "surface": "Metis Token (MToken) · Non-Proxy Bytecode & Controller"
   },
   "factors": [
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "upgrade",
     "label": "Upgradeability",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "Upgrade path not in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "timelock",
     "label": "Timelock floor",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No enforced admin delay in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "quorum",
     "label": "Signer quorum",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No signer quorum in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "emergency",
     "label": "Emergency / freeze scope",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No pause / freeze authority in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "parity",
     "label": "Docs-vs-chain parity",
     "state": "u",
     "value": "Uncompared: documentation not assessed (RPC-observed)"
    }
   ],
   "finding": "Metis Token (MToken) · Non-Proxy Bytecode & Controller",
   "grade": "observed",
   "gradeLabel": "OBSERVED",
   "name": "Metis Bridge",
   "pinnedBlock": 26458556,
   "probe": {
    "block_hash": "0xe258bb1cbcc988e2dfdba4ba173f9f8690520dba3647cdcae18e0651822769d2",
    "block_number": 26458556,
    "call_args": [],
    "call_signature": "owner()",
    "chain": "ethereum",
    "check_type": "eth_call",
    "extra_calls": [],
    "id": "metis-bridge-control-plane",
    "repro_calldata": "0x8da5cb5b",
    "rpc_env_var": "$ETH_RPC_URL",
    "selector_or_slot": "0x8da5cb5b",
    "target_contract": "0x9E32b13ce7f2E80A01932B42553652E053D6ed8e",
    "target_label": "Metis Token (MToken)"
   },
   "reconciled": false,
   "reconciledFrom": [],
   "reconciledTo": [],
   "records": 1,
   "rosetteAria": "Metis Bridge control-plane rosette: Upgradeability not determined; Timelock floor not determined; Signer quorum not determined; Emergency / freeze scope not determined; Docs-vs-chain parity uncompared",
   "search": "metis bridge metis-bridge canonical l1 gateway for an optimistic rollup with a decentralized sequencer pool (ethereum) metis 0x9e32b13ce7f2e80a01932b42553652e053d6ed8e",
   "slug": "metis-bridge",
   "summary_short": "Non-proxy contract no readable owner or admin; docs not assessed",
   "url": "https://pacta.wtf/protocols/metis-bridge/"
  },
  {
   "baskets": [
    "lending_vaults"
   ],
   "category": "Order-matching market-maker pools for swaps (Ethereum)",
   "chains": [
    "ethereum"
   ],
   "deltas": 0,
   "easAttested": true,
   "evidence": {
    "documented": "'The curator and Metric can each change their share of the spread at any time and with no timelock' (docs.metric.xyz/use-metric/fees.md); 'The core, periphery and extension contracts below are deployed at the same addresses on every chain in this table.' (docs.metric.xyz/reference/supported-chains-and-deployments.md)",
    "observed": "MetricOmmPoolFactory 0x2a53833cc95548cf52c7b159110e22D3a9018f32 (Ethereum, not a proxy; verified source): setPoolProtocolFee and setPoolProtocolFeeBatch are requiresAuth, and Auth.isAuthorized admits owner() unconditionally (or a caller the authority 0x032a22958EE9277eCce675E04e8302B85224a1B0 allows); the new fee applies in the same call. owner() = 0xa082C768B1C40f5e980b75959D85cF245AFF0FAE, a 3-of-5 Safe.",
    "recordId": "metric-factory-protocol-fee-no-timelock-s32",
    "surface": "Protocol fee share: setPoolProtocolFee by the owner, a 3-of-5 Safe, with no delay"
   },
   "factors": [
    {
     "evidence": "metric-factory-protocol-fee-no-timelock-s32: … 0x2a53833cc95548cf52c7b159110e22D3a9018f32 (Ethereum, not a proxy; verified source): setPoolProtocolFee …",
     "key": "upgrade",
     "label": "Upgradeability",
     "state": "g",
     "value": "Immutable or ownership renounced"
    },
    {
     "evidence": "metric-factory-protocol-fee-no-timelock-s32: observed_delay_seconds = 0",
     "key": "timelock",
     "label": "Timelock floor",
     "state": "a",
     "value": "0s minimum enforced delay across control surfaces"
    },
    {
     "evidence": "metric-factory-protocol-fee-no-timelock-s32: … 0xa082C768B1C40f5e980b75959D85cF245AFF0FAE, a 3-of-5 Safe.",
     "key": "quorum",
     "label": "Signer quorum",
     "state": "g",
     "value": "Lowest controlling quorum: 3-of-5"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "emergency",
     "label": "Emergency / freeze scope",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No pause / freeze authority in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "parity",
     "label": "Docs-vs-chain parity",
     "state": "g",
     "value": "Chain matches or is stronger than the documentation"
    }
   ],
   "finding": "Protocol fee share: setPoolProtocolFee by the owner, a 3-of-5 Safe, with no delay",
   "grade": "aligned",
   "gradeLabel": "ALIGNED",
   "name": "Metric V1",
   "pinnedBlock": 26451608,
   "probe": {
    "block_hash": "0x0266af5bcad519d93b3be78e41b76a62985e22fbe4feef043ac3225f6f217a17",
    "block_number": 26451608,
    "call_args": [],
    "call_signature": "owner()",
    "chain": "ethereum",
    "check_type": "eth_call",
    "extra_calls": [],
    "id": "metric-factory-protocol-fee-no-timelock-s32",
    "repro_calldata": "0x8da5cb5b",
    "rpc_env_var": "$ETH_RPC_URL",
    "selector_or_slot": "0x8da5cb5b",
    "target_contract": "0x2a53833cc95548cf52c7b159110e22D3a9018f32",
    "target_label": "MetricOmmPoolFactory"
   },
   "reconciled": false,
   "reconciledFrom": [],
   "reconciledTo": [],
   "records": 1,
   "rosetteAria": "Metric V1 control-plane rosette: Upgradeability strong; Timelock floor weak; Signer quorum strong; Emergency / freeze scope not determined; Docs-vs-chain parity strong",
   "search": "metric v1 metric-v1 order-matching market-maker pools for swaps (ethereum) metric 0x032a22958ee9277ecce675e04e8302b85224a1b0 0x2a53833cc95548cf52c7b159110e22d3a9018f32 0xa082c768b1c40f5e980b75959d85cf245aff0fae",
   "slug": "metric-v1",
   "summary_short": "Metric's protocol fee share changes from a 3-of-5 Safe with no timelock, as documented",
   "url": "https://pacta.wtf/protocols/metric-v1/"
  },
  {
   "baskets": [],
   "category": "Multi-collateral synthetic asset minting (Ethereum)",
   "chains": [
    "ethereum"
   ],
   "deltas": 0,
   "easAttested": false,
   "evidence": {
    "documented": "Metronome Synth documentation is linked for reference (https://docs.metronome.io/). This RPC-pinned record does not compare documentation parameters with the on-chain state.",
    "observed": "Metronome2 (0x2Ebd53d035150f328bd754D6DC66B99B0eDB89aa) verified on Ethereum Mainnet at canonical block #26,458,556 (15,045 bytes runtime code). EIP-1967 implementation and admin storage slots are both zero (non-EIP-1967 contract). Direct owner() returns Safe 3-of-5 0xd1DE3F9CD4AE2F23DA941a67cA4C739f8dD9Af33.",
    "recordId": "metronome-synth-control-plane",
    "surface": "Metronome2 · Non-Proxy Bytecode & Controller"
   },
   "factors": [
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "upgrade",
     "label": "Upgradeability",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "Upgrade path not in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "timelock",
     "label": "Timelock floor",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No enforced admin delay in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": "metronome-synth-control-plane: … contract). Direct owner() returns Safe 3-of-5 0xd1DE3F9CD4AE2F23DA941a67cA4C739f8dD9Af33.",
     "key": "quorum",
     "label": "Signer quorum",
     "state": "g",
     "value": "Lowest controlling quorum: 3-of-5"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "emergency",
     "label": "Emergency / freeze scope",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No pause / freeze authority in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "parity",
     "label": "Docs-vs-chain parity",
     "state": "u",
     "value": "Uncompared: documentation not assessed (RPC-observed)"
    }
   ],
   "finding": "Metronome2 · Non-Proxy Bytecode & Controller",
   "grade": "observed",
   "gradeLabel": "OBSERVED",
   "name": "Metronome Synth",
   "pinnedBlock": 26458556,
   "probe": {
    "block_hash": "0xe258bb1cbcc988e2dfdba4ba173f9f8690520dba3647cdcae18e0651822769d2",
    "block_number": 26458556,
    "call_args": [],
    "call_signature": "owner()",
    "chain": "ethereum",
    "check_type": "eth_call",
    "extra_calls": [],
    "id": "metronome-synth-control-plane",
    "repro_calldata": "0x8da5cb5b",
    "rpc_env_var": "$ETH_RPC_URL",
    "selector_or_slot": "0x8da5cb5b",
    "target_contract": "0x2Ebd53d035150f328bd754D6DC66B99B0eDB89aa",
    "target_label": "Metronome2"
   },
   "reconciled": false,
   "reconciledFrom": [],
   "reconciledTo": [],
   "records": 1,
   "rosetteAria": "Metronome Synth control-plane rosette: Upgradeability not determined; Timelock floor not determined; Signer quorum strong; Emergency / freeze scope not determined; Docs-vs-chain parity uncompared",
   "search": "metronome synth metronome-synth multi-collateral synthetic asset minting (ethereum) met 0x2ebd53d035150f328bd754d6dc66b99b0edb89aa 0xd1de3f9cd4ae2f23da941a67ca4c739f8dd9af33",
   "slug": "metronome-synth",
   "summary_short": "Non-proxy contract controlled by a 3-of-5 Safe; docs not assessed",
   "url": "https://pacta.wtf/protocols/metronome-synth/"
  },
  {
   "baskets": [
    "lending_vaults"
   ],
   "category": "MetaMorpho (Morpho Vaults V1) WETH vault curated by MEV Capital",
   "chains": [
    "ethereum"
   ],
   "deltas": 0,
   "easAttested": true,
   "evidence": {
    "documented": "'After the initial setup, any change to the timelock must set its duration to be between **1 day and 2 weeks**.' (docs.morpho.org/curate/concepts/timelock.md)",
    "observed": "MCwETH 0x9a8bC3B04b7f3D87cfC09ba407dCED575f2d61D8 (Ethereum): a MetaMorpho vault (isMetaMorpho = true on the MetaMorpho factory 0xA9c3D3a366466Fa809d1Ae982Fb2c46E5fC41101; verified source MetaMorpho, ConstantsLib MIN_TIMELOCK = 1 days and MAX_TIMELOCK = 2 weeks, enforced by _checkTimelockBounds), asset() = WETH, fee() = 10%. timelock() = 259,200 s, within the bounds Morpho documents for Vaults V1; guardian() = 0x777498D046d593F747Fd5884A73B3b9964479711 (a contract; it can revoke pending timelocked actions). owner() = 0x38afC3aA2c76b4cA1F8e1DabA68e998e1F4782DB, a Safe: getThreshold() = 2 of getOwners() = 5; guard slot empty; getModulesPaginated() lists no module; in the verified source setCurator, setIsAllocator, setFee, setFeeRecipient, setSkimRecipient, submitTimelock and submitGuardian are onlyOwner (timelock decreases and guardian changes wait for the timelock). The same Safe owns MEV Capital's sibling vaults, read at this pin: MC.eUSDC 0x1265a81d42d513Df40d0031f8f2e1346954d665a: timelock() = 86,400 s, guardian() = the zero address (no guardian); USUALUSDC+ 0xd63070114470f685b75B74D60EEc7c1113d33a3D: timelock() = 259,200 s, guardian() = 0x6e9d65eC80D69b1f508560Bc7aeA5003db1f7FB7.",
    "recordId": "mev-capital-weth-metamorpho-timelock-within-bounds-s37",
    "surface": "MCwETH: timelock() = 259,200 s (3 days), within Morpho V1's documented 1 day - 2 weeks; guardian set"
   },
   "factors": [
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "upgrade",
     "label": "Upgradeability",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "Upgrade path not in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": "mev-capital-weth-metamorpho-timelock-within-bounds-s37: observed_delay_seconds = 259200",
     "key": "timelock",
     "label": "Timelock floor",
     "state": "g",
     "value": "3d minimum enforced delay across control surfaces"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "quorum",
     "label": "Signer quorum",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No signer quorum in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": "mev-capital-weth-metamorpho-timelock-within-bounds-s37: guardian() = 0x777498D046d593F747Fd5884A73B3b9964479711 (a contract; it can revoke pending timelocked actions). owner() = …",
     "key": "emergency",
     "label": "Emergency / freeze scope",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "Pause / freeze authority present; its holder is not determined"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "parity",
     "label": "Docs-vs-chain parity",
     "state": "g",
     "value": "Chain matches or is stronger than the documentation"
    }
   ],
   "finding": "MCwETH: timelock() = 259,200 s (3 days), within Morpho V1's documented 1 day - 2 weeks; guardian set",
   "grade": "aligned",
   "gradeLabel": "ALIGNED",
   "name": "MEV Capital wETH (MetaMorpho)",
   "pinnedBlock": 26458556,
   "probe": {
    "block_hash": "0xe258bb1cbcc988e2dfdba4ba173f9f8690520dba3647cdcae18e0651822769d2",
    "block_number": 26458556,
    "call_args": [],
    "call_signature": "timelock()",
    "chain": "ethereum",
    "check_type": "eth_call",
    "extra_calls": [],
    "id": "mev-capital-weth-metamorpho-timelock-within-bounds-s37",
    "repro_calldata": "0xd33219b4",
    "rpc_env_var": "$ETH_RPC_URL",
    "selector_or_slot": "0xd33219b4",
    "target_contract": "0x9a8bC3B04b7f3D87cfC09ba407dCED575f2d61D8",
    "target_label": "MEV Capital wETH (MCwETH, MetaMorpho)"
   },
   "reconciled": false,
   "reconciledFrom": [],
   "reconciledTo": [],
   "records": 1,
   "rosetteAria": "MEV Capital wETH (MetaMorpho) control-plane rosette: Upgradeability not determined; Timelock floor strong; Signer quorum not determined; Emergency / freeze scope not determined; Docs-vs-chain parity strong",
   "search": "mev capital weth (metamorpho) mev-capital-weth-metamorpho metamorpho (morpho vaults v1) weth vault curated by mev capital mcweth 0x1265a81d42d513df40d0031f8f2e1346954d665a 0x38afc3aa2c76b4ca1f8e1daba68e998e1f4782db 0x6e9d65ec80d69b1f508560bc7aea5003db1f7fb7 0x777498d046d593f747fd5884a73b3b9964479711 0x9a8bc3b04b7f3d87cfc09ba407dced575f2d61d8 0xa9c3d3a366466fa809d1ae982fb2c46e5fc41101 0xd63070114470f685b75b74d60eec7c1113d33a3d",
   "slug": "mev-capital-weth-metamorpho",
   "summary_short": "MEV Capital's wETH vault timelock is 3 days, within Morpho's documented bounds",
   "url": "https://pacta.wtf/protocols/mev-capital-weth-metamorpho/"
  },
  {
   "baskets": [
    "lending_vaults",
    "stable_rwa"
   ],
   "category": "Permissionless deployer of crypto-backed stablecoins, each with its own lender, PSM and price feed (Ethereum)",
   "chains": [
    "ethereum"
   ],
   "deltas": 0,
   "easAttested": false,
   "evidence": {
    "documented": "Monolith Market documentation is linked for reference (https://docs.monolith.market/). This RPC-pinned record does not compare documentation parameters with the on-chain state.",
    "observed": "Factory (0x6D961c9DCF1AD73566822BA4B087892e3839B849) verified on Ethereum Mainnet at canonical block #26,458,556 (5,071 bytes runtime code). EIP-1967 implementation and admin storage slots are both zero (non-EIP-1967 contract). No owner(), admin(), authority(), curator() or AccessControl admin was readable on the contract.",
    "recordId": "monolith-market-control-plane",
    "surface": "Factory · Non-Proxy Bytecode & Controller"
   },
   "factors": [
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "upgrade",
     "label": "Upgradeability",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "Upgrade path not in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "timelock",
     "label": "Timelock floor",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No enforced admin delay in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "quorum",
     "label": "Signer quorum",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No signer quorum in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "emergency",
     "label": "Emergency / freeze scope",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No pause / freeze authority in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "parity",
     "label": "Docs-vs-chain parity",
     "state": "u",
     "value": "Uncompared: documentation not assessed (RPC-observed)"
    }
   ],
   "finding": "Factory · Non-Proxy Bytecode & Controller",
   "grade": "observed",
   "gradeLabel": "OBSERVED",
   "name": "Monolith Market",
   "pinnedBlock": 26458556,
   "probe": {
    "block_hash": "0xe258bb1cbcc988e2dfdba4ba173f9f8690520dba3647cdcae18e0651822769d2",
    "block_number": 26458556,
    "call_args": [],
    "call_signature": "owner()",
    "chain": "ethereum",
    "check_type": "eth_call",
    "extra_calls": [],
    "id": "monolith-market-control-plane",
    "repro_calldata": "0x8da5cb5b",
    "rpc_env_var": "$ETH_RPC_URL",
    "selector_or_slot": "0x8da5cb5b",
    "target_contract": "0x6D961c9DCF1AD73566822BA4B087892e3839B849",
    "target_label": "Factory"
   },
   "reconciled": false,
   "reconciledFrom": [],
   "reconciledTo": [],
   "records": 1,
   "rosetteAria": "Monolith Market control-plane rosette: Upgradeability not determined; Timelock floor not determined; Signer quorum not determined; Emergency / freeze scope not determined; Docs-vs-chain parity uncompared",
   "search": "monolith market monolith-market permissionless deployer of crypto-backed stablecoins, each with its own lender, psm and price feed (ethereum) monolith 0x6d961c9dcf1ad73566822ba4b087892e3839b849",
   "slug": "monolith-market",
   "summary_short": "Non-proxy contract no readable owner or admin; docs not assessed",
   "url": "https://pacta.wtf/protocols/monolith-market/"
  },
  {
   "baskets": [
    "base",
    "lending_vaults",
    "stable_rwa"
   ],
   "category": "Base Lending & Borrowing",
   "chains": [
    "base"
   ],
   "deltas": 1,
   "easAttested": true,
   "evidence": {
    "documented": "Moonwell DAO Constitution 8.1: 'The Security Council has the power to execute any pause functionality, or perform other required actions with no delay ... Performing any Emergency Action requires a 3-of-5 approval from the Security Council.'",
    "observed": "Unitroller (0xfBb21d0380beE3312B33c4353c8936a0F13EF26C).pauseGuardian() = 2-of-4 Safe 0x5B710010586C1b728B047c3E42473c700eeA4026 (v1.4.1); 1 of its 4 owner addresses is also an owner of the 3-of-5 Security Council Safe 0x446342AF4F3bCD374276891C6bb3411bf2F8779E. borrowCapGuardian() = supplyCapGuardian() = 2-of-4 Safe 0x08eDEbFFaE68970DCf751baa826182b3a4aCFC05.",
    "recordId": "moonwell-pause-guardian-2of4-safe-s18",
    "surface": "Comptroller pauseGuardian = 2-of-4 Safe (Constitution: pause = Security Council 3-of-5)"
   },
   "factors": [
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "upgrade",
     "label": "Upgradeability",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "Upgrade path not in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": "moonwell-temporal-governor-24h-security-council-3of5-s18: observed_delay_seconds = 86400",
     "key": "timelock",
     "label": "Timelock floor",
     "state": "b",
     "value": "1d minimum enforced delay across control surfaces"
    },
    {
     "evidence": "moonwell-pause-guardian-2of4-safe-s18: … (0xfBb21d0380beE3312B33c4353c8936a0F13EF26C).pauseGuardian() = 2-of-4 Safe 0x5B710010586C1b728B047c3E42473c700eeA4026 …",
     "key": "quorum",
     "label": "Signer quorum",
     "state": "b",
     "value": "Lowest controlling quorum: 2-of-4"
    },
    {
     "evidence": "moonwell-pause-guardian-2of4-safe-s18: Unitroller (0xfBb21d0380beE3312B33c4353c8936a0F13EF26C).pauseGuardian() = 2-of-4 Safe 0x5B710010586C1b728B047c3E42473c700eeA4026 (v1.4.1)",
     "key": "emergency",
     "label": "Emergency / freeze scope",
     "state": "g",
     "value": "Pause / freeze authority scoped behind a multi-signer controller (2-of-4)"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "parity",
     "label": "Docs-vs-chain parity",
     "state": "a",
     "value": "Documentation differs from the chain (parameter delta)"
    }
   ],
   "finding": "Comptroller pauseGuardian = 2-of-4 Safe (Constitution: pause = Security Council 3-of-5): docs say Moonwell DAO Constitution 8.1: 'The Security Council has the power to execute any pause functionality, or perform other required actions with no delay ... · chain says Unitroller (0xfBb21d0380beE3312B33c4353c8936a0F13EF26C).pauseGuardian() = 2-of-4 Safe 0x5B710010586C1b728B047c3E42473c700eeA4026 (v1.4.1);",
   "grade": "delta",
   "gradeLabel": "DELTA",
   "name": "Moonwell Lending (Base)",
   "pinnedBlock": 57842915,
   "probe": {
    "block_hash": "0x7ae27f2be8e931c33ac284c8d5c548c8fd7a68f08e18bb372c70e2ca3b4bd129",
    "block_number": 57842915,
    "call_args": [],
    "call_signature": "pauseGuardian()",
    "chain": "base",
    "check_type": "eth_call",
    "extra_calls": [],
    "id": "moonwell-pause-guardian-2of4-safe-s18",
    "repro_calldata": "0x24a3d622",
    "rpc_env_var": "$BASE_RPC_URL",
    "selector_or_slot": "0x24a3d622",
    "target_contract": "0xfBb21d0380beE3312B33c4353c8936a0F13EF26C",
    "target_label": "Moonwell Unitroller (Comptroller proxy)"
   },
   "reconciled": false,
   "reconciledFrom": [],
   "reconciledTo": [],
   "records": 2,
   "rosetteAria": "Moonwell Lending (Base) control-plane rosette: Upgradeability not determined; Timelock floor moderate; Signer quorum moderate; Emergency / freeze scope strong; Docs-vs-chain parity weak",
   "search": "moonwell lending (base) moonwell-lending-base base lending & borrowing well 0x08edebffae68970dcf751baa826182b3a4acfc05 0x446342af4f3bcd374276891c6bb3411bf2f8779e 0x5b710010586c1b728b047c3e42473c700eea4026 0x8769b70ac7c93af0e75de0d69877709b66d75838 0x8b621804a7637b781e2bbd58e256a591f2df7d51 0xfbb21d0380bee3312b33c4353c8936a0f13ef26c",
   "slug": "moonwell-lending-base",
   "summary_short": "Pause guardian: docs 3-of-5 Security Council · chain 2-of-4 Safe",
   "url": "https://pacta.wtf/protocols/moonwell-lending-base/"
  },
  {
   "baskets": [],
   "category": "Canonical message bridge between Ethereum and an optimistic zk rollup (Ethereum)",
   "chains": [
    "ethereum"
   ],
   "deltas": 0,
   "easAttested": false,
   "evidence": {
    "documented": "Morph Bridge documentation is linked for reference (https://docs.morph.network/). This RPC-pinned record does not compare documentation parameters with the on-chain state.",
    "observed": "L1CrossDomainMessenger (0xDc71366EFFA760804DCFC3EDF87fa2A6f1623304) verified on Ethereum Mainnet at canonical block #26,458,556 (2,796 bytes runtime code). EIP-1967 proxy: implementation 0x0cC37d5239F9027A1269f53D83c73084D538f3a9, admin 0x31110622D6CA24c9FF307d6ae1715F16E47F16A0. The EIP-1967 admin slot holds contract ProxyAdmin 0x31110622D6CA24c9FF307d6ae1715F16E47F16A0. That controller is in turn controlled by timelock (0 s delay) 0x542675E90E269F20ecbb9e0095d4751ac155B530.",
    "recordId": "morph-bridge-control-plane",
    "surface": "L1CrossDomainMessenger · EIP-1967 Proxy & Controller Chain"
   },
   "factors": [
    {
     "evidence": "morph-bridge-control-plane: L1CrossDomainMessenger (0xDc71366EFFA760804DCFC3EDF87fa2A6f1623304) verified on Ethereum Mainnet at canonical block #26,458,556 (2,796 bytes runtime code). …",
     "key": "upgrade",
     "label": "Upgradeability",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "Upgradeable; the delay gating the upgrade path is not in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": "controller fact: getMinDelay() = 0s",
     "key": "timelock",
     "label": "Timelock floor",
     "state": "a",
     "value": "0s minimum enforced delay across control surfaces"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "quorum",
     "label": "Signer quorum",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No signer quorum in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "emergency",
     "label": "Emergency / freeze scope",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No pause / freeze authority in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "parity",
     "label": "Docs-vs-chain parity",
     "state": "u",
     "value": "Uncompared: documentation not assessed (RPC-observed)"
    }
   ],
   "finding": "L1CrossDomainMessenger · EIP-1967 Proxy & Controller Chain",
   "grade": "observed",
   "gradeLabel": "OBSERVED",
   "name": "Morph Bridge",
   "pinnedBlock": 26458556,
   "probe": {
    "block_hash": "0xe258bb1cbcc988e2dfdba4ba173f9f8690520dba3647cdcae18e0651822769d2",
    "block_number": 26458556,
    "call_args": [],
    "call_signature": null,
    "chain": "ethereum",
    "check_type": "eth_getStorageAt",
    "extra_calls": [],
    "id": "morph-bridge-control-plane",
    "repro_calldata": null,
    "rpc_env_var": "$ETH_RPC_URL",
    "selector_or_slot": "0xb53127684a568b3173ae13b9f8a6016e243e63b6e8ee1178d6a717850b5d6103",
    "target_contract": "0xDc71366EFFA760804DCFC3EDF87fa2A6f1623304",
    "target_label": "L1CrossDomainMessenger"
   },
   "reconciled": false,
   "reconciledFrom": [],
   "reconciledTo": [],
   "records": 1,
   "rosetteAria": "Morph Bridge control-plane rosette: Upgradeability not determined; Timelock floor weak; Signer quorum not determined; Emergency / freeze scope not determined; Docs-vs-chain parity uncompared",
   "search": "morph bridge morph-bridge canonical message bridge between ethereum and an optimistic zk rollup (ethereum) morph 0x0cc37d5239f9027a1269f53d83c73084d538f3a9 0x31110622d6ca24c9ff307d6ae1715f16e47f16a0 0x542675e90e269f20ecbb9e0095d4751ac155b530 0xdc71366effa760804dcfc3edf87fa2a6f1623304",
   "slug": "morph-bridge",
   "summary_short": "Upgradeable proxy controlled by a contract; docs not assessed",
   "url": "https://pacta.wtf/protocols/morph-bridge/"
  },
  {
   "baskets": [
    "lending_vaults"
   ],
   "category": "Yield-funded decentralized AI agent infrastructure (Ethereum)",
   "chains": [
    "ethereum"
   ],
   "deltas": 0,
   "easAttested": true,
   "evidence": {
    "documented": "'This setup requires 5 out of 9 key holders to sign transactions' (gitbook.mor.org/smart-contracts/multisig.md)",
    "observed": "Morpheus Ethereum Safe 0x1FE04BC15Cf2c5A2d41a0b3a96725596676eBa1E (Ethereum): getThreshold() = 5 of 9 owners. DepositPool 0x47176B2Af9885dC6C4575d4eFd63895f7Aaa4790 (EIP-1967 proxy, implementation 0xdB10dAEF167eA2233Ba6811457dD24D676FbD670) owner() = this Safe.",
    "recordId": "morpheus-ethereum-safe-5of9-s32",
    "surface": "Ethereum multisig: 5-of-9, owner of the DepositPool"
   },
   "factors": [
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "upgrade",
     "label": "Upgradeability",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "Upgrade path not in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "timelock",
     "label": "Timelock floor",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No enforced admin delay in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": "controller fact: Safe getThreshold()",
     "key": "quorum",
     "label": "Signer quorum",
     "state": "g",
     "value": "Lowest controlling quorum: 5-of-9"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "emergency",
     "label": "Emergency / freeze scope",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No pause / freeze authority in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "parity",
     "label": "Docs-vs-chain parity",
     "state": "g",
     "value": "Chain matches or is stronger than the documentation"
    }
   ],
   "finding": "Ethereum multisig: 5-of-9, owner of the DepositPool",
   "grade": "aligned",
   "gradeLabel": "ALIGNED",
   "name": "MorpheusAI",
   "pinnedBlock": 26451608,
   "probe": {
    "block_hash": "0x0266af5bcad519d93b3be78e41b76a62985e22fbe4feef043ac3225f6f217a17",
    "block_number": 26451608,
    "call_args": [],
    "call_signature": "getThreshold()",
    "chain": "ethereum",
    "check_type": "eth_call",
    "extra_calls": [],
    "id": "morpheus-ethereum-safe-5of9-s32",
    "repro_calldata": "0xe75235b8",
    "rpc_env_var": "$ETH_RPC_URL",
    "selector_or_slot": "0xe75235b8",
    "target_contract": "0x1FE04BC15Cf2c5A2d41a0b3a96725596676eBa1E",
    "target_label": "Morpheus Ethereum multisig (Safe)"
   },
   "reconciled": false,
   "reconciledFrom": [],
   "reconciledTo": [],
   "records": 1,
   "rosetteAria": "MorpheusAI control-plane rosette: Upgradeability not determined; Timelock floor not determined; Signer quorum strong; Emergency / freeze scope not determined; Docs-vs-chain parity strong",
   "search": "morpheusai morpheusai yield-funded decentralized ai agent infrastructure (ethereum) morpheusai 0x1fe04bc15cf2c5a2d41a0b3a96725596676eba1e 0x47176b2af9885dc6c4575d4efd63895f7aaa4790 0xdb10daef167ea2233ba6811457dd24d676fbd670",
   "slug": "morpheusai",
   "summary_short": "Morpheus's Ethereum multisig is 5-of-9 and owns the DepositPool, as documented",
   "url": "https://pacta.wtf/protocols/morpheusai/"
  },
  {
   "baskets": [
    "lending_vaults"
   ],
   "category": "Base Lending Infrastructure",
   "chains": [
    "ethereum"
   ],
   "deltas": 0,
   "easAttested": true,
   "evidence": {
    "documented": "Morpho Blue core singleton ownership and immutable fee/LLTV bound specification.",
    "observed": "Morpho Blue owner() = 0xcBa28b38103307Ec8dA98377ffF9816C164f9AFa and sampled fee/LLTV bounds match documentation at block 26401070.",
    "recordId": "morpho-blue-singleton-owner",
    "surface": "Sampled Singleton Owner & Fee/LLTV Bounds"
   },
   "factors": [
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "upgrade",
     "label": "Upgradeability",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "Upgrade path not in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "timelock",
     "label": "Timelock floor",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No enforced admin delay in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "quorum",
     "label": "Signer quorum",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No signer quorum in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "emergency",
     "label": "Emergency / freeze scope",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No pause / freeze authority in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "parity",
     "label": "Docs-vs-chain parity",
     "state": "g",
     "value": "Chain matches or is stronger than the documentation"
    }
   ],
   "finding": "Sampled Singleton Owner & Fee/LLTV Bounds",
   "grade": "aligned",
   "gradeLabel": "ALIGNED",
   "name": "Morpho Blue Core",
   "pinnedBlock": 26401070,
   "probe": {
    "block_hash": "0xcf55f6a42ae610c1f8766b5c2fb676d91f178469fa10ef777eccbb76f6506234",
    "block_number": 26401070,
    "call_args": [],
    "call_signature": "owner()",
    "chain": "ethereum",
    "check_type": "eth_call",
    "extra_calls": [],
    "id": "morpho-blue-singleton-owner",
    "repro_calldata": "0x8da5cb5b",
    "rpc_env_var": "$ETH_RPC_URL",
    "selector_or_slot": "0x8da5cb5b",
    "target_contract": "0xBBBBBbbBBb9cC5e90e3b3Af64bdAF62C37EEFFCb",
    "target_label": "Morpho Blue Singleton"
   },
   "reconciled": false,
   "reconciledFrom": [],
   "reconciledTo": [],
   "records": 1,
   "rosetteAria": "Morpho Blue Core control-plane rosette: Upgradeability not determined; Timelock floor not determined; Signer quorum not determined; Emergency / freeze scope not determined; Docs-vs-chain parity strong",
   "search": "morpho blue core morpho-blue-core base lending infrastructure morpho 0x58d97b57bb95320f9a05dc918aef65434969c2b2 0xbbbbbbbbbb9cc5e90e3b3af64bdaf62c37eeffcb 0xcba28b38103307ec8da98377fff9816c164f9afa",
   "slug": "morpho-blue-core",
   "summary_short": "Singleton owner and fee and LLTV bounds match the docs",
   "url": "https://pacta.wtf/protocols/morpho-blue-core/"
  },
  {
   "baskets": [
    "base"
   ],
   "category": "Non-liquidating crypto mortgages of up to 30 years (Base)",
   "chains": [
    "base"
   ],
   "deltas": 0,
   "easAttested": false,
   "evidence": {
    "documented": "MortgageFi documentation is linked for reference (https://mortgagefi-docs.gitbook.io/mortgagefi-documentation). This RPC-pinned record does not compare documentation parameters with the on-chain state.",
    "observed": "mortgagefi-earn-usdc-weth (mortgagefipoolusdcweth) (0x1bE87D273d47C3832Ab7853812E9A995A4DE9EEA) verified on Base Mainnet at canonical block #60,070,202 (17,646 bytes runtime code). EIP-1967 implementation and admin storage slots are both zero (non-EIP-1967 contract). No owner(), admin(), authority(), curator() or AccessControl admin was readable on the contract.",
    "recordId": "mortgagefi-control-plane",
    "surface": "mortgagefi-earn-usdc-weth (mortgagefipoolusdcweth) · Non-Proxy Bytecode & Controller"
   },
   "factors": [
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "upgrade",
     "label": "Upgradeability",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "Upgrade path not in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "timelock",
     "label": "Timelock floor",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No enforced admin delay in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "quorum",
     "label": "Signer quorum",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No signer quorum in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "emergency",
     "label": "Emergency / freeze scope",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No pause / freeze authority in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "parity",
     "label": "Docs-vs-chain parity",
     "state": "u",
     "value": "Uncompared: documentation not assessed (RPC-observed)"
    }
   ],
   "finding": "mortgagefi-earn-usdc-weth (mortgagefipoolusdcweth) · Non-Proxy Bytecode & Controller",
   "grade": "observed",
   "gradeLabel": "OBSERVED",
   "name": "MortgageFi",
   "pinnedBlock": 60070202,
   "probe": {
    "block_hash": "0x01b3f5dcecb67c63ba33350ec6942563f6b8a0d8ca9b4f69a752844a5bab4a20",
    "block_number": 60070202,
    "call_args": [],
    "call_signature": "owner()",
    "chain": "base",
    "check_type": "eth_call",
    "extra_calls": [],
    "id": "mortgagefi-control-plane",
    "repro_calldata": "0x8da5cb5b",
    "rpc_env_var": "$BASE_RPC_URL",
    "selector_or_slot": "0x8da5cb5b",
    "target_contract": "0x1bE87D273d47C3832Ab7853812E9A995A4DE9EEA",
    "target_label": "mortgagefi-earn-usdc-weth (mortgagefipoolusdcweth)"
   },
   "reconciled": false,
   "reconciledFrom": [],
   "reconciledTo": [],
   "records": 1,
   "rosetteAria": "MortgageFi control-plane rosette: Upgradeability not determined; Timelock floor not determined; Signer quorum not determined; Emergency / freeze scope not determined; Docs-vs-chain parity uncompared",
   "search": "mortgagefi mortgagefi non-liquidating crypto mortgages of up to 30 years (base) mf-e-usdc-weth 0x1be87d273d47c3832ab7853812e9a995a4de9eea",
   "slug": "mortgagefi",
   "summary_short": "Non-proxy contract no readable owner or admin; docs not assessed",
   "url": "https://pacta.wtf/protocols/mortgagefi/"
  },
  {
   "baskets": [],
   "category": "Cross-chain router whose operators halted after the 2023 key compromise (Ethereum)",
   "chains": [
    "ethereum"
   ],
   "deltas": 0,
   "easAttested": false,
   "evidence": {
    "documented": "Multichain documentation is linked for reference (). This RPC-pinned record does not compare documentation parameters with the on-chain state.",
    "observed": "Multichain (AnyswapV5ERC20) (0x9Fb9a33956351cf4fa040f65A13b835A3C8764E3) verified on Ethereum Mainnet at canonical block #26,458,556 (10,660 bytes runtime code). EIP-1967 implementation and admin storage slots are both zero (non-EIP-1967 contract). Direct owner() returns contract AnyswapV3Router 0xe95fD76CF16008c12FF3b3a937CB16Cd9Cc20284.",
    "recordId": "multichain-control-plane",
    "surface": "Multichain (AnyswapV5ERC20) · Non-Proxy Bytecode & Controller"
   },
   "factors": [
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "upgrade",
     "label": "Upgradeability",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "Upgrade path not in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "timelock",
     "label": "Timelock floor",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No enforced admin delay in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "quorum",
     "label": "Signer quorum",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No signer quorum in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "emergency",
     "label": "Emergency / freeze scope",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No pause / freeze authority in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "parity",
     "label": "Docs-vs-chain parity",
     "state": "u",
     "value": "Uncompared: documentation not assessed (RPC-observed)"
    }
   ],
   "finding": "Multichain (AnyswapV5ERC20) · Non-Proxy Bytecode & Controller",
   "grade": "observed",
   "gradeLabel": "OBSERVED",
   "name": "Multichain",
   "pinnedBlock": 26458556,
   "probe": {
    "block_hash": "0xe258bb1cbcc988e2dfdba4ba173f9f8690520dba3647cdcae18e0651822769d2",
    "block_number": 26458556,
    "call_args": [],
    "call_signature": "owner()",
    "chain": "ethereum",
    "check_type": "eth_call",
    "extra_calls": [],
    "id": "multichain-control-plane",
    "repro_calldata": "0x8da5cb5b",
    "rpc_env_var": "$ETH_RPC_URL",
    "selector_or_slot": "0x8da5cb5b",
    "target_contract": "0x9Fb9a33956351cf4fa040f65A13b835A3C8764E3",
    "target_label": "Multichain (AnyswapV5ERC20)"
   },
   "reconciled": false,
   "reconciledFrom": [],
   "reconciledTo": [],
   "records": 1,
   "rosetteAria": "Multichain control-plane rosette: Upgradeability not determined; Timelock floor not determined; Signer quorum not determined; Emergency / freeze scope not determined; Docs-vs-chain parity uncompared",
   "search": "multichain multichain cross-chain router whose operators halted after the 2023 key compromise (ethereum) anymulti 0x9fb9a33956351cf4fa040f65a13b835a3c8764e3 0xe95fd76cf16008c12ff3b3a937cb16cd9cc20284",
   "slug": "multichain",
   "summary_short": "Non-proxy contract controlled by a contract; docs not assessed",
   "url": "https://pacta.wtf/protocols/multichain/"
  },
  {
   "baskets": [],
   "category": "Multichain concentrated-liquidity DEX with an omni layer and ve(3,3) emissions (Ethereum)",
   "chains": [
    "ethereum"
   ],
   "deltas": 0,
   "easAttested": false,
   "evidence": {
    "documented": "Nami documentation is linked for reference (https://docs.nami.fi/introduction/the-nami-ecosystem). This RPC-pinned record does not compare documentation parameters with the on-chain state.",
    "observed": "BatcherAccountProxyFactory (0x0100000002935Dce071f4AFA607b961575672b4C) verified on Ethereum Mainnet at canonical block #26,458,556 (9,446 bytes runtime code). EIP-1967 implementation and admin storage slots are both zero (non-EIP-1967 contract). Direct owner() returns Safe 4-of-7 0x892081a87803B32559afC0Ad7b28a39E657fD844.",
    "recordId": "nami-control-plane",
    "surface": "BatcherAccountProxyFactory · Non-Proxy Bytecode & Controller"
   },
   "factors": [
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "upgrade",
     "label": "Upgradeability",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "Upgrade path not in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "timelock",
     "label": "Timelock floor",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No enforced admin delay in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": "nami-control-plane: … contract). Direct owner() returns Safe 4-of-7 0x892081a87803B32559afC0Ad7b28a39E657fD844.",
     "key": "quorum",
     "label": "Signer quorum",
     "state": "g",
     "value": "Lowest controlling quorum: 4-of-7"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "emergency",
     "label": "Emergency / freeze scope",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No pause / freeze authority in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "parity",
     "label": "Docs-vs-chain parity",
     "state": "u",
     "value": "Uncompared: documentation not assessed (RPC-observed)"
    }
   ],
   "finding": "BatcherAccountProxyFactory · Non-Proxy Bytecode & Controller",
   "grade": "observed",
   "gradeLabel": "OBSERVED",
   "name": "Nami",
   "pinnedBlock": 26458556,
   "probe": {
    "block_hash": "0xe258bb1cbcc988e2dfdba4ba173f9f8690520dba3647cdcae18e0651822769d2",
    "block_number": 26458556,
    "call_args": [],
    "call_signature": "owner()",
    "chain": "ethereum",
    "check_type": "eth_call",
    "extra_calls": [],
    "id": "nami-control-plane",
    "repro_calldata": "0x8da5cb5b",
    "rpc_env_var": "$ETH_RPC_URL",
    "selector_or_slot": "0x8da5cb5b",
    "target_contract": "0x0100000002935Dce071f4AFA607b961575672b4C",
    "target_label": "BatcherAccountProxyFactory"
   },
   "reconciled": false,
   "reconciledFrom": [],
   "reconciledTo": [],
   "records": 1,
   "rosetteAria": "Nami control-plane rosette: Upgradeability not determined; Timelock floor not determined; Signer quorum strong; Emergency / freeze scope not determined; Docs-vs-chain parity uncompared",
   "search": "nami nami multichain concentrated-liquidity dex with an omni layer and ve(3,3) emissions (ethereum) nami 0x0100000002935dce071f4afa607b961575672b4c 0x892081a87803b32559afc0ad7b28a39e657fd844",
   "slug": "nami",
   "summary_short": "Non-proxy contract controlled by a 4-of-7 Safe; docs not assessed",
   "url": "https://pacta.wtf/protocols/nami/"
  },
  {
   "baskets": [
    "lending_vaults"
   ],
   "category": "Single-sided supply pool lending to market makers (Ethereum)",
   "chains": [
    "ethereum"
   ],
   "deltas": 0,
   "easAttested": false,
   "evidence": {
    "documented": "Native Credit Pool documentation is linked for reference (https://docs.native.org/native-dev). This RPC-pinned record does not compare documentation parameters with the on-chain state.",
    "observed": "CreditVault (0xe3D41d19564922C9952f692C5Dd0563030f5f2EF) verified on Ethereum Mainnet at canonical block #26,458,556 (20,743 bytes runtime code). EIP-1967 implementation and admin storage slots are both zero (non-EIP-1967 contract). Direct owner() returns contract contract 0x9b9Dc7c56e18cfdA57D402CA7Ded491b1544DC56. That controller is in turn controlled by Safe 3-of-5 0x83fc28e6962E41e38F7854308eFF827E3f6b906B.",
    "recordId": "native-credit-pool-control-plane",
    "surface": "CreditVault · Non-Proxy Bytecode & Controller"
   },
   "factors": [
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "upgrade",
     "label": "Upgradeability",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "Upgrade path not in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "timelock",
     "label": "Timelock floor",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No enforced admin delay in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": "native-credit-pool-control-plane: … controller is in turn controlled by Safe 3-of-5 0x83fc28e6962E41e38F7854308eFF827E3f6b906B.",
     "key": "quorum",
     "label": "Signer quorum",
     "state": "g",
     "value": "Lowest controlling quorum: 3-of-5"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "emergency",
     "label": "Emergency / freeze scope",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No pause / freeze authority in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "parity",
     "label": "Docs-vs-chain parity",
     "state": "u",
     "value": "Uncompared: documentation not assessed (RPC-observed)"
    }
   ],
   "finding": "CreditVault · Non-Proxy Bytecode & Controller",
   "grade": "observed",
   "gradeLabel": "OBSERVED",
   "name": "Native Credit Pool",
   "pinnedBlock": 26458556,
   "probe": {
    "block_hash": "0xe258bb1cbcc988e2dfdba4ba173f9f8690520dba3647cdcae18e0651822769d2",
    "block_number": 26458556,
    "call_args": [],
    "call_signature": "owner()",
    "chain": "ethereum",
    "check_type": "eth_call",
    "extra_calls": [],
    "id": "native-credit-pool-control-plane",
    "repro_calldata": "0x8da5cb5b",
    "rpc_env_var": "$ETH_RPC_URL",
    "selector_or_slot": "0x8da5cb5b",
    "target_contract": "0xe3D41d19564922C9952f692C5Dd0563030f5f2EF",
    "target_label": "CreditVault"
   },
   "reconciled": false,
   "reconciledFrom": [],
   "reconciledTo": [],
   "records": 1,
   "rosetteAria": "Native Credit Pool control-plane rosette: Upgradeability not determined; Timelock floor not determined; Signer quorum strong; Emergency / freeze scope not determined; Docs-vs-chain parity uncompared",
   "search": "native credit pool native-credit-pool single-sided supply pool lending to market makers (ethereum) native 0x83fc28e6962e41e38f7854308eff827e3f6b906b 0x9b9dc7c56e18cfda57d402ca7ded491b1544dc56 0xe3d41d19564922c9952f692c5dd0563030f5f2ef",
   "slug": "native-credit-pool",
   "summary_short": "Non-proxy contract controlled by a 3-of-5 Safe; docs not assessed",
   "url": "https://pacta.wtf/protocols/native-credit-pool/"
  },
  {
   "baskets": [],
   "category": "Discretionary Mutual / Cover",
   "chains": [
    "ethereum"
   ],
   "deltas": 0,
   "easAttested": true,
   "evidence": {
    "documented": "docs.nexusmutual.io/governance/: 'Three votes in favour carry the proposal, at which point voting closes and the timelock starts.' and 'A 24-hour timelock runs before a carried proposal can be executed.'",
    "observed": "Governor (0xcafea6063d4Ec6b045d9676e58897C1f0882Ca32, EIP-1967 proxy; implementation Governor 0xcafea466bF6dEFe480cdd54056C020c63b7DA830, Sourcify exact_match): TIMELOCK_PERIOD() = 86400s, VOTING_PERIOD() = 259200s, ADVISORY_BOARD_THRESHOLD() = 3. Registry (0xcafea2c575550512582090AA06d0a069E7236b9e, ADVISORY_BOARD_SEATS() = 5) lists the Governor at contract index 2, is the proxyOwner() of all 10 module proxies resolved through NXMaster.getLatestAddress (GV, P1, MR, TC, CO, SP, RA, AS, CI, LO), and is itself an EIP-1967 proxy administered by the Governor; its verified upgradeContract is onlyGovernor. Pause: getPauseConfig() = 0; isEmergencyAdmin() is true for 6 EOAs (the 5 Advisory Board seat holders and 0x6fe2c2643cb5064951fb7dd87fbce4777fb146e3), and a pause needs one admin to propose and another to confirm. Context, not compared: the legacy NXMaster (0x01BFd82675DBCc7762C84019cA518e701C0cD07e) is owned by the legacy Governance proxy (0x4A5C681dDC32acC6ccA51ac17e9d461e6be87900) running TemporaryGovernance, whose advisoryBoardMultisig (0x51ad1265C8702c9e96Ea61Fe4088C2e22eD4418e, 3-of-5 Safe owned by the 5 seat holders) can execute any call through it without a timelock; the docs list NXMaster and Governance as legacy.",
    "recordId": "nexus-mutual-governor-24h-timelock-s18",
    "surface": "Governor: 3 Advisory Board votes + 24h timelock; Registry upgrades every module"
   },
   "factors": [
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "upgrade",
     "label": "Upgradeability",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "Upgrade path not in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": "nexus-mutual-governor-24h-timelock-s18: observed_delay_seconds = 86400",
     "key": "timelock",
     "label": "Timelock floor",
     "state": "b",
     "value": "1d minimum enforced delay across control surfaces"
    },
    {
     "evidence": "nexus-mutual-governor-24h-timelock-s18: … (0x51ad1265C8702c9e96Ea61Fe4088C2e22eD4418e, 3-of-5 Safe owned by the 5 seat holders) can …",
     "key": "quorum",
     "label": "Signer quorum",
     "state": "g",
     "value": "Lowest controlling quorum: 3-of-5"
    },
    {
     "evidence": "nexus-mutual-governor-24h-timelock-s18: isEmergencyAdmin() is true for 6 EOAs (the 5 Advisory Board seat holders and 0x6fe2c2643cb5064951fb7dd87fbce4777fb146e3), and a pause needs one admin to propose …",
     "key": "emergency",
     "label": "Emergency / freeze scope",
     "state": "g",
     "value": "Pause / freeze authority scoped behind a multi-signer controller (3-of-5)"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "parity",
     "label": "Docs-vs-chain parity",
     "state": "g",
     "value": "Chain matches or is stronger than the documentation"
    }
   ],
   "finding": "Governor: 3 Advisory Board votes + 24h timelock; Registry upgrades every module",
   "grade": "aligned",
   "gradeLabel": "ALIGNED",
   "name": "Nexus Mutual",
   "pinnedBlock": 26421541,
   "probe": {
    "block_hash": "0xfc2e93c53812cd390b29924a4e217bd4f75d77725bd2882968fb5b087a17150d",
    "block_number": 26421541,
    "call_args": [],
    "call_signature": "TIMELOCK_PERIOD()",
    "chain": "ethereum",
    "check_type": "eth_call",
    "extra_calls": [],
    "id": "nexus-mutual-governor-24h-timelock-s18",
    "repro_calldata": "0x4a5bcbf8",
    "rpc_env_var": "$ETH_RPC_URL",
    "selector_or_slot": "0x4a5bcbf8",
    "target_contract": "0xcafea6063d4Ec6b045d9676e58897C1f0882Ca32",
    "target_label": "Nexus Mutual Governor"
   },
   "reconciled": false,
   "reconciledFrom": [],
   "reconciledTo": [],
   "records": 1,
   "rosetteAria": "Nexus Mutual control-plane rosette: Upgradeability not determined; Timelock floor moderate; Signer quorum strong; Emergency / freeze scope strong; Docs-vs-chain parity strong",
   "search": "nexus mutual nexus-mutual discretionary mutual / cover nxm wnxm nexus mutual 0x01bfd82675dbcc7762c84019ca518e701c0cd07e 0x4a5c681ddc32acc6cca51ac17e9d461e6be87900 0x51ad1265c8702c9e96ea61fe4088c2e22ed4418e 0x6fe2c2643cb5064951fb7dd87fbce4777fb146e3 0xcafea2c575550512582090aa06d0a069e7236b9e 0xcafea466bf6defe480cdd54056c020c63b7da830 0xcafea6063d4ec6b045d9676e58897c1f0882ca32",
   "slug": "nexus-mutual",
   "summary_short": "Governance needs 3 Advisory Board votes plus a 24-hour timelock, as documented",
   "url": "https://pacta.wtf/protocols/nexus-mutual/"
  },
  {
   "baskets": [
    "lending_vaults"
   ],
   "category": "ERC-20 vault tokens redeemable for NFT collectibles (Ethereum)",
   "chains": [
    "ethereum"
   ],
   "deltas": 0,
   "easAttested": false,
   "evidence": {
    "documented": "NFTX documentation is linked for reference (https://docs.nftx.io/). This RPC-pinned record does not compare documentation parameters with the on-chain state.",
    "observed": "NFTX (MiniMeToken) (0x87d73E916D7057945c9BcD8cdd94e42A6F47f776) verified on Ethereum Mainnet at canonical block #26,458,556 (7,440 bytes runtime code). EIP-1967 implementation and admin storage slots are both zero (non-EIP-1967 contract). No owner(), admin(), authority(), curator() or AccessControl admin was readable on the contract.",
    "recordId": "nftx-control-plane",
    "surface": "NFTX (MiniMeToken) · Non-Proxy Bytecode & Controller"
   },
   "factors": [
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "upgrade",
     "label": "Upgradeability",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "Upgrade path not in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "timelock",
     "label": "Timelock floor",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No enforced admin delay in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "quorum",
     "label": "Signer quorum",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No signer quorum in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "emergency",
     "label": "Emergency / freeze scope",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No pause / freeze authority in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "parity",
     "label": "Docs-vs-chain parity",
     "state": "u",
     "value": "Uncompared: documentation not assessed (RPC-observed)"
    }
   ],
   "finding": "NFTX (MiniMeToken) · Non-Proxy Bytecode & Controller",
   "grade": "observed",
   "gradeLabel": "OBSERVED",
   "name": "NFTX",
   "pinnedBlock": 26458556,
   "probe": {
    "block_hash": "0xe258bb1cbcc988e2dfdba4ba173f9f8690520dba3647cdcae18e0651822769d2",
    "block_number": 26458556,
    "call_args": [],
    "call_signature": "owner()",
    "chain": "ethereum",
    "check_type": "eth_call",
    "extra_calls": [],
    "id": "nftx-control-plane",
    "repro_calldata": "0x8da5cb5b",
    "rpc_env_var": "$ETH_RPC_URL",
    "selector_or_slot": "0x8da5cb5b",
    "target_contract": "0x87d73E916D7057945c9BcD8cdd94e42A6F47f776",
    "target_label": "NFTX (MiniMeToken)"
   },
   "reconciled": false,
   "reconciledFrom": [],
   "reconciledTo": [],
   "records": 1,
   "rosetteAria": "NFTX control-plane rosette: Upgradeability not determined; Timelock floor not determined; Signer quorum not determined; Emergency / freeze scope not determined; Docs-vs-chain parity uncompared",
   "search": "nftx nftx erc-20 vault tokens redeemable for nft collectibles (ethereum) nftx 0x87d73e916d7057945c9bcd8cdd94e42a6f47f776",
   "slug": "nftx",
   "summary_short": "Non-proxy contract no readable owner or admin; docs not assessed",
   "url": "https://pacta.wtf/protocols/nftx/"
  },
  {
   "baskets": [
    "eth_lst_lrt"
   ],
   "category": "Liquid staking pool with operator-run beacon-chain validators (Ethereum)",
   "chains": [
    "ethereum"
   ],
   "deltas": 0,
   "easAttested": false,
   "evidence": {
    "documented": "NodeDAO documentation is linked for reference (https://nodedao.com/). This RPC-pinned record does not compare documentation parameters with the on-chain state.",
    "observed": "NodeDAOView (0xd7C049CD4ba216679ecC04Eb2767cC5E39812121) verified on Ethereum Mainnet at canonical block #26,458,556 (708 bytes runtime code). EIP-1967 proxy: implementation 0x857BF02B1f5fD85E064e6726658eA1864a14d948, admin slot zero. Direct owner() returns timelock (1 h delay) 0x16F692525f3b8c8a96F8c945D365Da958Fb5735B.",
    "recordId": "nodedao-control-plane",
    "surface": "NodeDAOView · EIP-1967 Proxy & Controller Chain"
   },
   "factors": [
    {
     "evidence": "nodedao-control-plane: is_eip1967_proxy = true",
     "key": "upgrade",
     "label": "Upgradeability",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "Upgradeable; the delay gating the upgrade path is not in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": "controller fact: getMinDelay() = 3600s",
     "key": "timelock",
     "label": "Timelock floor",
     "state": "b",
     "value": "1h minimum enforced delay across control surfaces"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "quorum",
     "label": "Signer quorum",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No signer quorum in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "emergency",
     "label": "Emergency / freeze scope",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No pause / freeze authority in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "parity",
     "label": "Docs-vs-chain parity",
     "state": "u",
     "value": "Uncompared: documentation not assessed (RPC-observed)"
    }
   ],
   "finding": "NodeDAOView · EIP-1967 Proxy & Controller Chain",
   "grade": "observed",
   "gradeLabel": "OBSERVED",
   "name": "NodeDAO",
   "pinnedBlock": 26458556,
   "probe": {
    "block_hash": "0xe258bb1cbcc988e2dfdba4ba173f9f8690520dba3647cdcae18e0651822769d2",
    "block_number": 26458556,
    "call_args": [],
    "call_signature": "owner()",
    "chain": "ethereum",
    "check_type": "eth_call",
    "extra_calls": [],
    "id": "nodedao-control-plane",
    "repro_calldata": "0x8da5cb5b",
    "rpc_env_var": "$ETH_RPC_URL",
    "selector_or_slot": "0x8da5cb5b",
    "target_contract": "0xd7C049CD4ba216679ecC04Eb2767cC5E39812121",
    "target_label": "NodeDAOView"
   },
   "reconciled": false,
   "reconciledFrom": [],
   "reconciledTo": [],
   "records": 1,
   "rosetteAria": "NodeDAO control-plane rosette: Upgradeability not determined; Timelock floor moderate; Signer quorum not determined; Emergency / freeze scope not determined; Docs-vs-chain parity uncompared",
   "search": "nodedao nodedao liquid staking pool with operator-run beacon-chain validators (ethereum) nodedao 0x16f692525f3b8c8a96f8c945d365da958fb5735b 0x857bf02b1f5fd85e064e6726658ea1864a14d948 0xd7c049cd4ba216679ecc04eb2767cc5e39812121",
   "slug": "nodedao",
   "summary_short": "Upgradeable proxy controlled by a timelock; docs not assessed",
   "url": "https://pacta.wtf/protocols/nodedao/"
  },
  {
   "baskets": [
    "lending_vaults",
    "stable_rwa"
   ],
   "category": "Delta-Neutral Yield Stablecoin (sUSN) (Ethereum)",
   "chains": [
    "ethereum"
   ],
   "deltas": 0,
   "easAttested": true,
   "evidence": {
    "documented": "'All non-emergency contract upgrades are subjected to a mandatory 48-hour on-chain timelock' (docs.noon.capital/5.-the-security-framework/smart-contract-security-and-audits.md)",
    "observed": "Noon USN 0xdA67B4284609d2d48e5d10cfAc411572727dc1eD (Ethereum): EIP-1967 proxy, implementation 0x79FD7FE2a8EbcAE47798321b2AC97107dF3de229, admin slot = ProxyAdmin 0x55f39512cb43111A13E8440ee3e3602e72628239. ProxyAdmin owner() = 0xE5e412C212B4FBbF550A94e7BD5e83dB0B315A7F, Noon's Upgrade Timelock: delay() = 172,800 s (MIN_DELAY 86,400 s); its verified source lets the owner reach ProxyAdmin.upgradeAndCall only through scheduleUpgrade, then executeUpgrade after the delay. Timelock owner() = 0x1ea169EcCcf7714E7ba04900e1a3357cCA77327f, a 3-of-5 Safe.",
    "recordId": "noon-usn-upgrade-timelock-48h-s31",
    "surface": "USN upgrade path: ProxyAdmin owned by the Upgrade Timelock, delay() 172,800 s"
   },
   "factors": [
    {
     "evidence": "noon-usn-upgrade-timelock-48h-s31: Noon USN 0xdA67B4284609d2d48e5d10cfAc411572727dc1eD (Ethereum): EIP-1967 proxy, implementation 0x79FD7FE2a8EbcAE47798321b2AC97107dF3de229, admin slot = …",
     "key": "upgrade",
     "label": "Upgradeability",
     "state": "g",
     "value": "Upgradeable behind a ≥48h delay (2d) (1 other upgrade path not determined)"
    },
    {
     "evidence": "noon-usn-upgrade-timelock-48h-s31: Noon USN 0xdA67B4284609d2d48e5d10cfAc411572727dc1eD (Ethereum): EIP-1967 proxy, implementation 0x79FD7FE2a8EbcAE47798321b2AC97107dF3de229, admin slot = …",
     "key": "timelock",
     "label": "Timelock floor",
     "state": "g",
     "value": "2d minimum enforced delay across control surfaces"
    },
    {
     "evidence": "noon-usn-upgrade-timelock-48h-s31: … 0x1ea169EcCcf7714E7ba04900e1a3357cCA77327f, a 3-of-5 Safe.",
     "key": "quorum",
     "label": "Signer quorum",
     "state": "g",
     "value": "Lowest controlling quorum: 3-of-5"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "emergency",
     "label": "Emergency / freeze scope",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No pause / freeze authority in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "parity",
     "label": "Docs-vs-chain parity",
     "state": "g",
     "value": "Chain matches or is stronger than the documentation"
    }
   ],
   "finding": "USN upgrade path: ProxyAdmin owned by the Upgrade Timelock, delay() 172,800 s",
   "grade": "aligned",
   "gradeLabel": "ALIGNED",
   "name": "Noon",
   "pinnedBlock": 26450616,
   "probe": {
    "block_hash": "0xd2df7ccb74a6772b51a5597c8f144f5cfae362efeabf193ecfc7c80f8ff37c35",
    "block_number": 26450616,
    "call_args": [],
    "call_signature": "delay()",
    "chain": "ethereum",
    "check_type": "eth_call",
    "extra_calls": [],
    "id": "noon-usn-upgrade-timelock-48h-s31",
    "repro_calldata": "0x6a42b8f8",
    "rpc_env_var": "$ETH_RPC_URL",
    "selector_or_slot": "0x6a42b8f8",
    "target_contract": "0xE5e412C212B4FBbF550A94e7BD5e83dB0B315A7F",
    "target_label": "Noon Upgrade Timelock (owner of the USN ProxyAdmin)"
   },
   "reconciled": false,
   "reconciledFrom": [],
   "reconciledTo": [],
   "records": 1,
   "rosetteAria": "Noon control-plane rosette: Upgradeability strong; Timelock floor strong; Signer quorum strong; Emergency / freeze scope not determined; Docs-vs-chain parity strong",
   "search": "noon noon delta-neutral yield stablecoin (susn) (ethereum) usn 0x1ea169ecccf7714e7ba04900e1a3357cca77327f 0x55f39512cb43111a13e8440ee3e3602e72628239 0x79fd7fe2a8ebcae47798321b2ac97107df3de229 0xda67b4284609d2d48e5d10cfac411572727dc1ed 0xe5e412c212b4fbbf550a94e7bd5e83db0b315a7f",
   "slug": "noon",
   "summary_short": "Noon's USN upgrades wait 48 hours in its Upgrade Timelock, as documented",
   "url": "https://pacta.wtf/protocols/noon/"
  },
  {
   "baskets": [
    "lending_vaults"
   ],
   "category": "Embedded native-yield vaults for new networks (Ethereum)",
   "chains": [
    "ethereum"
   ],
   "deltas": 0,
   "easAttested": false,
   "evidence": {
    "documented": "Nucleus documentation is linked for reference (). This RPC-pinned record does not compare documentation parameters with the on-chain state.",
    "observed": "Boba Native Yield Nucleus Token (BoringVault) (0x52E4d8989fa8b3E1C06696e7b16DEf5d7707A0d1) verified on Ethereum Mainnet at canonical block #26,458,556 (7,494 bytes runtime code). EIP-1967 implementation and admin storage slots are both zero (non-EIP-1967 contract). Direct owner() returns Safe 3-of-5 0x0000000000417626Ef34D62C4DC189b021603f2F.",
    "recordId": "nucleus-control-plane",
    "surface": "Boba Native Yield Nucleus Token (BoringVault) · Non-Proxy Bytecode & Controller"
   },
   "factors": [
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "upgrade",
     "label": "Upgradeability",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "Upgrade path not in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "timelock",
     "label": "Timelock floor",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No enforced admin delay in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": "nucleus-control-plane: … contract). Direct owner() returns Safe 3-of-5 0x0000000000417626Ef34D62C4DC189b021603f2F.",
     "key": "quorum",
     "label": "Signer quorum",
     "state": "g",
     "value": "Lowest controlling quorum: 3-of-5"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "emergency",
     "label": "Emergency / freeze scope",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No pause / freeze authority in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "parity",
     "label": "Docs-vs-chain parity",
     "state": "u",
     "value": "Uncompared: documentation not assessed (RPC-observed)"
    }
   ],
   "finding": "Boba Native Yield Nucleus Token (BoringVault) · Non-Proxy Bytecode & Controller",
   "grade": "observed",
   "gradeLabel": "OBSERVED",
   "name": "Nucleus",
   "pinnedBlock": 26458556,
   "probe": {
    "block_hash": "0xe258bb1cbcc988e2dfdba4ba173f9f8690520dba3647cdcae18e0651822769d2",
    "block_number": 26458556,
    "call_args": [],
    "call_signature": "owner()",
    "chain": "ethereum",
    "check_type": "eth_call",
    "extra_calls": [],
    "id": "nucleus-control-plane",
    "repro_calldata": "0x8da5cb5b",
    "rpc_env_var": "$ETH_RPC_URL",
    "selector_or_slot": "0x8da5cb5b",
    "target_contract": "0x52E4d8989fa8b3E1C06696e7b16DEf5d7707A0d1",
    "target_label": "Boba Native Yield Nucleus Token (BoringVault)"
   },
   "reconciled": false,
   "reconciledFrom": [],
   "reconciledTo": [],
   "records": 1,
   "rosetteAria": "Nucleus control-plane rosette: Upgradeability not determined; Timelock floor not determined; Signer quorum strong; Emergency / freeze scope not determined; Docs-vs-chain parity uncompared",
   "search": "nucleus nucleus embedded native-yield vaults for new networks (ethereum) bobaeth 0x0000000000417626ef34d62c4dc189b021603f2f 0x52e4d8989fa8b3e1c06696e7b16def5d7707a0d1",
   "slug": "nucleus",
   "summary_short": "Non-proxy contract controlled by a 3-of-5 Safe; docs not assessed",
   "url": "https://pacta.wtf/protocols/nucleus/"
  },
  {
   "baskets": [
    "lending_vaults"
   ],
   "category": "Real-world asset vaults with tokenized yield products (Ethereum)",
   "chains": [
    "ethereum"
   ],
   "deltas": 0,
   "easAttested": true,
   "evidence": {
    "documented": "'every upgrade is subject to a 48-hour timelock before it takes effect' (nuva.finance/docs/security-trust)",
    "observed": "NUVA DedicatedVaultRouter 0x50AE1e4A612A4623b747aEeFb30aFBA82804e12c (Ethereum) is an EIP-1967 proxy (implementation 0x027207E16E2BB920dc89AA9FeF7826e23091588a, admin slot zero: upgrades are authorized by owner()); owner() = 0xDEa75A312b2F99b5A7558c4636897b39C195E241, a TimelockController with getMinDelay() = 172,800 s.",
    "recordId": "nuva-router-timelock-48h-s30",
    "surface": "DedicatedVaultRouter upgrade authority: timelock, getMinDelay() 172,800 s"
   },
   "factors": [
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "upgrade",
     "label": "Upgradeability",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "Upgrade path not in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": "controller fact: getMinDelay() = 172800s",
     "key": "timelock",
     "label": "Timelock floor",
     "state": "g",
     "value": "2d minimum enforced delay across control surfaces"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "quorum",
     "label": "Signer quorum",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No signer quorum in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "emergency",
     "label": "Emergency / freeze scope",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No pause / freeze authority in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "parity",
     "label": "Docs-vs-chain parity",
     "state": "g",
     "value": "Chain matches or is stronger than the documentation"
    }
   ],
   "finding": "DedicatedVaultRouter upgrade authority: timelock, getMinDelay() 172,800 s",
   "grade": "aligned",
   "gradeLabel": "ALIGNED",
   "name": "NUVA",
   "pinnedBlock": 26449594,
   "probe": {
    "block_hash": "0xbe263d5b378dcb7c3c4e18bd8e388f0cb2dab1adacd83de2be58c9408b377287",
    "block_number": 26449594,
    "call_args": [],
    "call_signature": "getMinDelay()",
    "chain": "ethereum",
    "check_type": "eth_call",
    "extra_calls": [],
    "id": "nuva-router-timelock-48h-s30",
    "repro_calldata": "0xf27a0c92",
    "rpc_env_var": "$ETH_RPC_URL",
    "selector_or_slot": "0xf27a0c92",
    "target_contract": "0xDEa75A312b2F99b5A7558c4636897b39C195E241",
    "target_label": "NUVA TimelockController (owner of the DedicatedVaultRouter)"
   },
   "reconciled": false,
   "reconciledFrom": [],
   "reconciledTo": [],
   "records": 1,
   "rosetteAria": "NUVA control-plane rosette: Upgradeability not determined; Timelock floor strong; Signer quorum not determined; Emergency / freeze scope not determined; Docs-vs-chain parity strong",
   "search": "nuva nuva real-world asset vaults with tokenized yield products (ethereum) nuva 0x027207e16e2bb920dc89aa9fef7826e23091588a 0x50ae1e4a612a4623b747aeefb30afba82804e12c 0xdea75a312b2f99b5a7558c4636897b39c195e241",
   "slug": "nuva",
   "summary_short": "The vault router's upgrade authority is a 48-hour timelock; the docs state 48 hours",
   "url": "https://pacta.wtf/protocols/nuva/"
  },
  {
   "baskets": [
    "eth_lst_lrt"
   ],
   "category": "Distributed Validator Infrastructure & Governance Token",
   "chains": [
    "ethereum"
   ],
   "deltas": 1,
   "easAttested": true,
   "evidence": {
    "documented": "docs.obol.org (token distribution; OBOL token): 'The total supply is capped at 500 million tokens.' / 'The official token contract address of the OBOL Token is 0x0B010000b7624eb9B3DfBC279673C76E9D29D5F7'",
    "observed": "ObolToken 0x0B010000b7624eb9B3DfBC279673C76E9D29D5F7 (Sourcify exact match): totalSupply() = 500000000000000103303500000 (500,000,000.0000001033035 OBOL); mint() has no supply cap; MINTER_ROLE and DEFAULT_ADMIN_ROLE held by Safe 0x42D201CC4d9C1e31c032397F54caCE2f48C1FA72 (2-of-3, v1.3.0), not by the timelock.",
    "recordId": "obol-network-token-supply-cap-s24",
    "surface": "OBOL supply: documented cap of 500M, no cap on-chain; a 2-of-3 Safe holds MINTER_ROLE"
   },
   "factors": [
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "upgrade",
     "label": "Upgradeability",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "Upgrade path not in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": "controller fact: getMinDelay() = 432000s",
     "key": "timelock",
     "label": "Timelock floor",
     "state": "g",
     "value": "5d minimum enforced delay across control surfaces"
    },
    {
     "evidence": "obol-network-stobol-withdraw-delay-s24: … 0x7E90E03654732ABedF89Faf87f05BcD03ACEeFdC (1-of-2, v1.4.1).",
     "key": "quorum",
     "label": "Signer quorum",
     "state": "a",
     "value": "Lowest controlling quorum: 1-of-2"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "emergency",
     "label": "Emergency / freeze scope",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No pause / freeze authority in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "parity",
     "label": "Docs-vs-chain parity",
     "state": "a",
     "value": "Documentation differs from the chain (parameter delta)"
    }
   ],
   "finding": "OBOL supply: documented cap of 500M, no cap on-chain; a 2-of-3 Safe holds MINTER_ROLE: docs say docs.obol.org (token distribution; · chain says ObolToken 0x0B010000b7624eb9B3DfBC279673C76E9D29D5F7 (Sourcify exact match): totalSupply() = 500000000000000103303500000 (500,000,000.0000001033035 OBOL);",
   "grade": "delta",
   "gradeLabel": "DELTA",
   "name": "Obol Network",
   "pinnedBlock": 26433001,
   "probe": {
    "block_hash": "0xa058ec92ccf0024822a76097f183d8e2d344d56e9539038c857e0cdaaa0ee5a7",
    "block_number": 26433001,
    "call_args": [],
    "call_signature": "totalSupply()",
    "chain": "ethereum",
    "check_type": "eth_call",
    "extra_calls": [],
    "id": "obol-network-token-supply-cap-s24",
    "repro_calldata": "0x18160ddd",
    "rpc_env_var": "$ETH_RPC_URL",
    "selector_or_slot": "0x18160ddd",
    "target_contract": "0x0B010000b7624eb9B3DfBC279673C76E9D29D5F7",
    "target_label": "ObolToken"
   },
   "reconciled": false,
   "reconciledFrom": [],
   "reconciledTo": [],
   "records": 4,
   "rosetteAria": "Obol Network control-plane rosette: Upgradeability not determined; Timelock floor strong; Signer quorum weak; Emergency / freeze scope not determined; Docs-vs-chain parity weak",
   "search": "obol network obol-network distributed validator infrastructure & governance token obol stobol obol 0x02b5d1fd67246c0513223d320901474aa20bf973 0x0b010000b7624eb9b3dfbc279673c76e9d29d5f7 0x4094c8d36e40795ca25bfe9451f158d30614666a 0x42d201cc4d9c1e31c032397f54cace2f48c1fa72 0x6590cbbccbe6b83ef3774ef1904d86a7b02c2fcc 0x7e90e03654732abedf89faf87f05bcd03aceefdc 0xcb1622185a0c62a80494bede05ba95ef29fbf85c 0xcdbf527842ab04da548d33eb09d03db831381fb0",
   "slug": "obol-network",
   "summary_short": "Supply: docs cap 500M · chain no cap; a 2-of-3 Safe holds the minter role",
   "url": "https://pacta.wtf/protocols/obol-network/"
  },
  {
   "baskets": [],
   "category": "Automated DeFi position manager: strategies, order executors and fee policies behind upgradeable proxies",
   "chains": [
    "ethereum"
   ],
   "deltas": 1,
   "easAttested": true,
   "evidence": {
    "documented": "'Control of upgrades and emergency actions rests with a designated **governor**, currently managed through a secure multi-signature wallet **(3/5)**.' (docs.odyssey.finance/architecture/protocol.md); '## Mainnet' (docs.odyssey.finance/resources/contracts.md)",
    "observed": "PositionRegistry 0xeE156D8ea7b96a5524CcC3CF9283ab85E80E9534 (Ethereum; the contracts page lists it as PositionRegistry_Proxy for Mainnet and Base): TransparentUpgradeableProxy whose EIP-1967 admin slot = 0x3F6da0A118B3A0ddfdbaB4690cC96b2cF73B488D, the PositionRegistry_ProxyAdmin the page lists (OZ 5 ProxyAdmin, verified on Sourcify, exact match; upgradeAndCall onlyOwner). owner() of that ProxyAdmin and of the five other *_ProxyAdmin contracts the page lists (ApyTieredFeePolicy_1000_5_5_ProxyAdmin, ApyTieredFeePolicy_600_5_5_ProxyAdmin, PerformanceFeePolicy_1000_5_5_ProxyAdmin, PerformanceFeePolicy_600_5_5_ProxyAdmin, ProtocolTieredFeePolicy_5_5_ProxyAdmin) = 0xd44A3e93A256c445F17a12f35A0ffEf975ec6817; PositionRegistry's own owner() = the same Safe (its verified source makes addStrategy, addKeeper, removeKeeper, updateFeePolicy, updateImplementation, updateIsActive, updateFeeCollector, updateSwapAggregator, addCalldataToWhitelist and removeCalldataFromWhitelist onlyOwner; updateIsActive is the documented emergency restriction). Every upgrade and emergency controller read for this record is that one Safe: getThreshold() = 2 of getOwners() = 4; guard slot empty; getModulesPaginated() lists no module; its owners have no code (keys). On Base, at the Sprint Base pin, the same addresses read the same way: the registry's admin slot is the same ProxyAdmin (runtime code identical to the Ethereum one), all six ProxyAdmins and the registry are owned by 0xd44A3e93A256c445F17a12f35A0ffEf975ec6817, a Safe there too: getThreshold() = 2 of getOwners() = 4; guard slot empty; getModulesPaginated() lists no module. The protocol page names no address; this record binds its statement about the governor to the one Safe all listed controllers resolve to. The docs state the governor is a 3/5 multi-signature wallet; on chain 2 signatures of 4 owners execute an upgrade or an emergency restriction, with no timelock in the path. This record does not allege any misuse of these powers.",
    "recordId": "odyssey-finance-governor-safe-2-of-4-vs-3-of-5-s37",
    "surface": "Upgrade governor: docs state a 3/5 multisig; every ProxyAdmin owner is one Safe, 2-of-4 (Ethereum and Base)"
   },
   "factors": [
    {
     "evidence": "odyssey-finance-governor-safe-2-of-4-vs-3-of-5-s37: PositionRegistry 0xeE156D8ea7b96a5524CcC3CF9283ab85E80E9534 (Ethereum; the contracts page lists it as PositionRegistry_Proxy for Mainnet and Base) …",
     "key": "upgrade",
     "label": "Upgradeability",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "Upgradeable; the delay gating the upgrade path is not in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "timelock",
     "label": "Timelock floor",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No enforced admin delay in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "quorum",
     "label": "Signer quorum",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No signer quorum in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "emergency",
     "label": "Emergency / freeze scope",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No pause / freeze authority in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "parity",
     "label": "Docs-vs-chain parity",
     "state": "a",
     "value": "Documentation differs from the chain (parameter delta)"
    }
   ],
   "finding": "Upgrade governor: docs state a 3/5 multisig; every ProxyAdmin owner is one Safe, 2-of-4 (Ethereum and Base): docs say 'Control of upgrades and emergency actions rests with a designated **governor**, currently managed through a secure multi-signature wallet **(3/5)**.' (docs.odyssey.finance/architecture/protocol.md); · chain says PositionRegistry 0xeE156D8ea7b96a5524CcC3CF9283ab85E80E9534 (Ethereum;",
   "grade": "delta",
   "gradeLabel": "DELTA",
   "name": "Odyssey Finance",
   "pinnedBlock": 26458556,
   "probe": {
    "block_hash": "0xe258bb1cbcc988e2dfdba4ba173f9f8690520dba3647cdcae18e0651822769d2",
    "block_number": 26458556,
    "call_args": [],
    "call_signature": "owner()",
    "chain": "ethereum",
    "check_type": "eth_call",
    "extra_calls": [],
    "id": "odyssey-finance-governor-safe-2-of-4-vs-3-of-5-s37",
    "repro_calldata": "0x8da5cb5b",
    "rpc_env_var": "$ETH_RPC_URL",
    "selector_or_slot": "0x8da5cb5b",
    "target_contract": "0x3F6da0A118B3A0ddfdbaB4690cC96b2cF73B488D",
    "target_label": "PositionRegistry ProxyAdmin (Ethereum)"
   },
   "reconciled": false,
   "reconciledFrom": [],
   "reconciledTo": [],
   "records": 1,
   "rosetteAria": "Odyssey Finance control-plane rosette: Upgradeability not determined; Timelock floor not determined; Signer quorum not determined; Emergency / freeze scope not determined; Docs-vs-chain parity weak",
   "search": "odyssey finance odyssey-finance automated defi position manager: strategies, order executors and fee policies behind upgradeable proxies odyssey 0x3f6da0a118b3a0ddfdbab4690cc96b2cf73b488d 0xd44a3e93a256c445f17a12f35a0ffef975ec6817 0xee156d8ea7b96a5524ccc3cf9283ab85e80e9534",
   "slug": "odyssey-finance",
   "summary_short": "Odyssey's upgrade governor is a 2-of-4 Safe; docs say 3/5",
   "url": "https://pacta.wtf/protocols/odyssey-finance/"
  },
  {
   "baskets": [
    "stable_rwa"
   ],
   "category": "Institutional RWA / Tokenized Treasuries",
   "chains": [
    "ethereum"
   ],
   "deltas": 1,
   "easAttested": true,
   "evidence": {
    "documented": "docs.ondo.finance/qualified-access-products/ousg/instant-limits.md states 'Instant minting has a $50M Global Limit' and 'Instant redemptions have a $50M Global Limit'; Flux docs specify 1-day Timelock governance.",
    "observed": "RateLimiter (0x98Db502215Da1ad9F626D4a0090A8A2f4971003c) globalSubscriptionLimits(0x1B19C19393e2d034D8Ff31ff34c81252FcBbee92) word [2] = 100000000000000000000000000 ($100M per 86400s window), globalRedemptionLimits(OUSG) word [2] = 50000000000000000000000000 ($50M per 86400s); Flux Comptroller (0x95Af143a021DF745bc78e845b54591C53a8B3A51) admin() = FluxTimelock (0x2c5898da4DF1d45EAb2B7B192a361C3b9EB18d9c, delay() = 86400s / 1d, admin() = 0x336505EC1BcC1A020EeDe459f57581725D23465A); OUSG totalSupply = 1,110,569.33 OUSG.",
    "recordId": "ondo-ousg-rate-limiter-and-flux-timelock",
    "surface": "OUSG RateLimiter Global Subscription Limit & Flux 1d Timelock"
   },
   "factors": [
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "upgrade",
     "label": "Upgradeability",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "Upgrade path not in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": "ondo-ousg-rate-limiter-and-flux-timelock: observed_delay_seconds = 86400",
     "key": "timelock",
     "label": "Timelock floor",
     "state": "b",
     "value": "1d minimum enforced delay across control surfaces"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "quorum",
     "label": "Signer quorum",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No signer quorum in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "emergency",
     "label": "Emergency / freeze scope",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No pause / freeze authority in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "parity",
     "label": "Docs-vs-chain parity",
     "state": "a",
     "value": "Documentation differs from the chain (parameter delta)"
    }
   ],
   "finding": "OUSG RateLimiter Global Subscription Limit & Flux 1d Timelock: docs say docs.ondo.finance/qualified-access-products/ousg/instant-limits.md states 'Instant minting has a $50M Global Limit' and 'Instant redemptions have a $50M Global Limit'; · chain says RateLimiter (0x98Db502215Da1ad9F626D4a0090A8A2f4971003c) globalSubscriptionLimits(0x1B19C19393e2d034D8Ff31ff34c81252FcBbee92) word [2] = 100000000000000000000000000 ($100M per 86400s window), globalRedemptionLimits(OUSG…",
   "grade": "delta",
   "gradeLabel": "DELTA",
   "name": "Ondo Finance (OUSG & Flux Finance)",
   "pinnedBlock": 26403121,
   "probe": {
    "block_hash": "0x71acee2313a2c8eacd7d2c87667dc505310b3e9224d84eaebb71d5a890ef9d1c",
    "block_number": 26403121,
    "call_args": [
     "0x1B19C19393e2d034D8Ff31ff34c81252FcBbee92"
    ],
    "call_signature": "globalSubscriptionLimits(address)",
    "chain": "ethereum",
    "check_type": "eth_call",
    "extra_calls": [],
    "id": "ondo-ousg-rate-limiter-and-flux-timelock",
    "repro_calldata": "0x435e3a080000000000000000000000001b19c19393e2d034d8ff31ff34c81252fcbbee92",
    "rpc_env_var": "$ETH_RPC_URL",
    "selector_or_slot": "0x435e3a08",
    "target_contract": "0x98Db502215Da1ad9F626D4a0090A8A2f4971003c",
    "target_label": "Ondo RateLimiter"
   },
   "reconciled": false,
   "reconciledFrom": [],
   "reconciledTo": [],
   "records": 1,
   "rosetteAria": "Ondo Finance (OUSG & Flux Finance) control-plane rosette: Upgradeability not determined; Timelock floor moderate; Signer quorum not determined; Emergency / freeze scope not determined; Docs-vs-chain parity weak",
   "search": "ondo finance (ousg & flux finance) ondo-finance-ousg-flux-finance institutional rwa / tokenized treasuries ousg ondo flux 0x1b19c19393e2d034d8ff31ff34c81252fcbbee92 0x2c5898da4df1d45eab2b7b192a361c3b9eb18d9c 0x336505ec1bcc1a020eede459f57581725d23465a 0x95af143a021df745bc78e845b54591c53a8b3a51 0x98db502215da1ad9f626d4a0090a8a2f4971003c",
   "slug": "ondo-finance-ousg-flux-finance",
   "summary_short": "OUSG instant mint limit: docs $50M · chain $100M per day",
   "url": "https://pacta.wtf/protocols/ondo-finance-ousg-flux-finance/"
  },
  {
   "baskets": [
    "eth_lst_lrt"
   ],
   "category": "Universal restaking layer pooling collateral to back other networks' economic guarantees (Ethereum)",
   "chains": [
    "ethereum"
   ],
   "deltas": 0,
   "easAttested": false,
   "evidence": {
    "documented": "OpenGDP Shared Security documentation is linked for reference (https://opengdp.network/). This RPC-pinned record does not compare documentation parameters with the on-chain state.",
    "observed": "VaultSupervisor (0x54e44DbB92dBA848ACe27F44c0CB4268981eF1CC) verified on Ethereum Mainnet at canonical block #26,458,556 (127 bytes runtime code). EIP-1967 proxy: implementation 0x3788f64A0805f3eC777Ce26080BB2EeeB29C1199, admin slot zero. Direct owner() returns timelock (2 d delay) 0x275ac9C64eF372f528F7c87D3a987D1e3d76Ca65.",
    "recordId": "opengdp-shared-security-control-plane",
    "surface": "VaultSupervisor · EIP-1967 Proxy & Controller Chain"
   },
   "factors": [
    {
     "evidence": "opengdp-shared-security-control-plane: is_eip1967_proxy = true",
     "key": "upgrade",
     "label": "Upgradeability",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "Upgradeable; the delay gating the upgrade path is not in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": "controller fact: getMinDelay() = 172800s",
     "key": "timelock",
     "label": "Timelock floor",
     "state": "g",
     "value": "2d minimum enforced delay across control surfaces"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "quorum",
     "label": "Signer quorum",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No signer quorum in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "emergency",
     "label": "Emergency / freeze scope",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No pause / freeze authority in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "parity",
     "label": "Docs-vs-chain parity",
     "state": "u",
     "value": "Uncompared: documentation not assessed (RPC-observed)"
    }
   ],
   "finding": "VaultSupervisor · EIP-1967 Proxy & Controller Chain",
   "grade": "observed",
   "gradeLabel": "OBSERVED",
   "name": "OpenGDP Shared Security",
   "pinnedBlock": 26458556,
   "probe": {
    "block_hash": "0xe258bb1cbcc988e2dfdba4ba173f9f8690520dba3647cdcae18e0651822769d2",
    "block_number": 26458556,
    "call_args": [],
    "call_signature": "owner()",
    "chain": "ethereum",
    "check_type": "eth_call",
    "extra_calls": [],
    "id": "opengdp-shared-security-control-plane",
    "repro_calldata": "0x8da5cb5b",
    "rpc_env_var": "$ETH_RPC_URL",
    "selector_or_slot": "0x8da5cb5b",
    "target_contract": "0x54e44DbB92dBA848ACe27F44c0CB4268981eF1CC",
    "target_label": "VaultSupervisor"
   },
   "reconciled": false,
   "reconciledFrom": [],
   "reconciledTo": [],
   "records": 1,
   "rosetteAria": "OpenGDP Shared Security control-plane rosette: Upgradeability not determined; Timelock floor strong; Signer quorum not determined; Emergency / freeze scope not determined; Docs-vs-chain parity uncompared",
   "search": "opengdp shared security opengdp-shared-security universal restaking layer pooling collateral to back other networks' economic guarantees (ethereum) opengdp 0x275ac9c64ef372f528f7c87d3a987d1e3d76ca65 0x3788f64a0805f3ec777ce26080bb2eeeb29c1199 0x54e44dbb92dba848ace27f44c0cb4268981ef1cc",
   "slug": "opengdp-shared-security",
   "summary_short": "Upgradeable proxy controlled by a timelock; docs not assessed",
   "url": "https://pacta.wtf/protocols/opengdp-shared-security/"
  },
  {
   "baskets": [],
   "category": "Omnichain order-book liquidity layer deposits (Ethereum)",
   "chains": [
    "ethereum"
   ],
   "deltas": 0,
   "easAttested": true,
   "evidence": {
    "documented": "'Maximum supply: 1,000,000,000' (orderly.network/docs/introduction/tokenomics/distribution-and-emission-schedule)",
    "observed": "ORDER token 0xABD4C63d2616A5201454168269031355f4764337 (Ethereum; not a proxy: EIP-1967 implementation, admin and beacon slots all empty; verified source): totalSupply() = 1,000,000,000. The runtime code holds no selector of mint(address,uint256), mint(uint256), upgradeTo(address), upgradeToAndCall(address,bytes). Its only mint is the internal one at construction.",
    "recordId": "orderly-order-max-supply-1b-s33",
    "surface": "ORDER supply: 1,000,000,000, no mint function"
   },
   "factors": [
    {
     "evidence": "orderly-order-max-supply-1b-s33: ORDER token 0xABD4C63d2616A5201454168269031355f4764337 (Ethereum; not a proxy: EIP-1967 implementation, admin and beacon slots all empty; verified source) …",
     "key": "upgrade",
     "label": "Upgradeability",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "Upgradeable; the delay gating the upgrade path is not in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "timelock",
     "label": "Timelock floor",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No enforced admin delay in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "quorum",
     "label": "Signer quorum",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No signer quorum in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "emergency",
     "label": "Emergency / freeze scope",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No pause / freeze authority in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "parity",
     "label": "Docs-vs-chain parity",
     "state": "g",
     "value": "Chain matches or is stronger than the documentation"
    }
   ],
   "finding": "ORDER supply: 1,000,000,000, no mint function",
   "grade": "aligned",
   "gradeLabel": "ALIGNED",
   "name": "Orderly Bridge",
   "pinnedBlock": 26452373,
   "probe": {
    "block_hash": "0x63bfaa16f0019d8b37e757265d351bd135ad41e6ffa46207284198917123c55d",
    "block_number": 26452373,
    "call_args": [],
    "call_signature": "totalSupply()",
    "chain": "ethereum",
    "check_type": "eth_call",
    "extra_calls": [],
    "id": "orderly-order-max-supply-1b-s33",
    "repro_calldata": "0x18160ddd",
    "rpc_env_var": "$ETH_RPC_URL",
    "selector_or_slot": "0x18160ddd",
    "target_contract": "0xABD4C63d2616A5201454168269031355f4764337",
    "target_label": "ORDER token"
   },
   "reconciled": false,
   "reconciledFrom": [],
   "reconciledTo": [],
   "records": 1,
   "rosetteAria": "Orderly Bridge control-plane rosette: Upgradeability not determined; Timelock floor not determined; Signer quorum not determined; Emergency / freeze scope not determined; Docs-vs-chain parity strong",
   "search": "orderly bridge orderly-bridge omnichain order-book liquidity layer deposits (ethereum) order 0xabd4c63d2616a5201454168269031355f4764337",
   "slug": "orderly-bridge",
   "summary_short": "ORDER is fully minted at its 1B maximum, as documented",
   "url": "https://pacta.wtf/protocols/orderly-bridge/"
  },
  {
   "baskets": [
    "lending_vaults"
   ],
   "category": "Automated leverage vaults (looped auto-compounding positions) (Ethereum)",
   "chains": [
    "ethereum"
   ],
   "deltas": 0,
   "easAttested": false,
   "evidence": {
    "documented": "Origami Finance documentation is linked for reference (). This RPC-pinned record does not compare documentation parameters with the on-chain state.",
    "observed": "Origami SKY+ Auto-Compounder (OrigamiDelegated4626Vault) (0x07c5500359161b81eb0DfFF83097d5025D3cF5A2) verified on Ethereum Mainnet at canonical block #26,458,556 (15,404 bytes runtime code). EIP-1967 implementation and admin storage slots are both zero (non-EIP-1967 contract). Direct owner() returns Safe 2-of-4 0x781B4c57100738095222bd92D37B07ed034AB696.",
    "recordId": "origami-finance-control-plane",
    "surface": "Origami SKY+ Auto-Compounder (OrigamiDelegated4626Vault) · Non-Proxy Bytecode & Controller"
   },
   "factors": [
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "upgrade",
     "label": "Upgradeability",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "Upgrade path not in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "timelock",
     "label": "Timelock floor",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No enforced admin delay in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": "origami-finance-control-plane: … contract). Direct owner() returns Safe 2-of-4 0x781B4c57100738095222bd92D37B07ed034AB696.",
     "key": "quorum",
     "label": "Signer quorum",
     "state": "b",
     "value": "Lowest controlling quorum: 2-of-4"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "emergency",
     "label": "Emergency / freeze scope",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No pause / freeze authority in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "parity",
     "label": "Docs-vs-chain parity",
     "state": "u",
     "value": "Uncompared: documentation not assessed (RPC-observed)"
    }
   ],
   "finding": "Origami SKY+ Auto-Compounder (OrigamiDelegated4626Vault) · Non-Proxy Bytecode & Controller",
   "grade": "observed",
   "gradeLabel": "OBSERVED",
   "name": "Origami Finance",
   "pinnedBlock": 26458556,
   "probe": {
    "block_hash": "0xe258bb1cbcc988e2dfdba4ba173f9f8690520dba3647cdcae18e0651822769d2",
    "block_number": 26458556,
    "call_args": [],
    "call_signature": "owner()",
    "chain": "ethereum",
    "check_type": "eth_call",
    "extra_calls": [],
    "id": "origami-finance-control-plane",
    "repro_calldata": "0x8da5cb5b",
    "rpc_env_var": "$ETH_RPC_URL",
    "selector_or_slot": "0x8da5cb5b",
    "target_contract": "0x07c5500359161b81eb0DfFF83097d5025D3cF5A2",
    "target_label": "Origami SKY+ Auto-Compounder (OrigamiDelegated4626Vault)"
   },
   "reconciled": false,
   "reconciledFrom": [],
   "reconciledTo": [],
   "records": 1,
   "rosetteAria": "Origami Finance control-plane rosette: Upgradeability not determined; Timelock floor not determined; Signer quorum moderate; Emergency / freeze scope not determined; Docs-vs-chain parity uncompared",
   "search": "origami finance origami-finance automated leverage vaults (looped auto-compounding positions) (ethereum) sky+ 0x07c5500359161b81eb0dfff83097d5025d3cf5a2 0x781b4c57100738095222bd92d37b07ed034ab696",
   "slug": "origami-finance",
   "summary_short": "Non-proxy contract controlled by a 2-of-4 Safe; docs not assessed",
   "url": "https://pacta.wtf/protocols/origami-finance/"
  },
  {
   "baskets": [
    "base",
    "eth_lst_lrt"
   ],
   "category": "Supercharged Liquid Staking (Base)",
   "chains": [
    "base"
   ],
   "deltas": 0,
   "easAttested": true,
   "evidence": {
    "documented": "'Admin Base/HyperEVM 0x92A19381444A001d62cE67BaFF066fA1111d7202 5-of-8 Safe' (docs.originprotocol.com/llms-full.txt)",
    "observed": "Origin Base Admin Safe 0x92A19381444A001d62cE67BaFF066fA1111d7202 (Base): getThreshold() = 5 of 8 owners. SuperOETHb VaultProxy 0xDBFeFD2e8460a6Ee4955A68582F85708BAEA60A3 (implementation 0xCcd483cE093682D7D9a41e645EEb710AFaa88249) admin() = 0xf817cb3092179083c48c014688D98B72fB61464f, a TimelockController (getMinDelay() = 172,800 s) on which the Safe holds PROPOSER_ROLE.",
    "recordId": "origin-superoeth-base-admin-safe-5of8-s31",
    "surface": "Base Admin Safe: 5-of-8, proposer on the vault's timelock"
   },
   "factors": [
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "upgrade",
     "label": "Upgradeability",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "Upgrade path not in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": "origin-superoeth-base-admin-safe-5of8-s31: … 0xf817cb3092179083c48c014688D98B72fB61464f, a TimelockController (getMinDelay() = 172,800 s) on which the Safe holds PROPOSER_ROLE.",
     "key": "timelock",
     "label": "Timelock floor",
     "state": "g",
     "value": "2d minimum enforced delay across control surfaces"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "quorum",
     "label": "Signer quorum",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No signer quorum in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "emergency",
     "label": "Emergency / freeze scope",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No pause / freeze authority in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "parity",
     "label": "Docs-vs-chain parity",
     "state": "g",
     "value": "Chain matches or is stronger than the documentation"
    }
   ],
   "finding": "Base Admin Safe: 5-of-8, proposer on the vault's timelock",
   "grade": "aligned",
   "gradeLabel": "ALIGNED",
   "name": "Origin Protocol (SuperOETHb Base)",
   "pinnedBlock": 59594105,
   "probe": {
    "block_hash": "0x7646bbc83a9f0d26a48a94274cd6003a3f10bc4747a20d817b8e536618e28496",
    "block_number": 59594105,
    "call_args": [],
    "call_signature": "getThreshold()",
    "chain": "base",
    "check_type": "eth_call",
    "extra_calls": [],
    "id": "origin-superoeth-base-admin-safe-5of8-s31",
    "repro_calldata": "0xe75235b8",
    "rpc_env_var": "$BASE_RPC_URL",
    "selector_or_slot": "0xe75235b8",
    "target_contract": "0x92A19381444A001d62cE67BaFF066fA1111d7202",
    "target_label": "Origin Base Admin Safe"
   },
   "reconciled": false,
   "reconciledFrom": [],
   "reconciledTo": [],
   "records": 1,
   "rosetteAria": "Origin Protocol (SuperOETHb Base) control-plane rosette: Upgradeability not determined; Timelock floor strong; Signer quorum not determined; Emergency / freeze scope not determined; Docs-vs-chain parity strong",
   "search": "origin protocol (superoethb base) origin-superoeth-base supercharged liquid staking (base) superoethb oeth ogn 0x92a19381444a001d62ce67baff066fa1111d7202 0xccd483ce093682d7d9a41e645eeb710afaa88249 0xdbfefd2e8460a6ee4955a68582f85708baea60a3 0xf817cb3092179083c48c014688d98b72fb61464f",
   "slug": "origin-superoeth-base",
   "summary_short": "Origin's Base Admin Safe is 5-of-8 and proposes on the vault timelock",
   "url": "https://pacta.wtf/protocols/origin-superoeth-base/"
  },
  {
   "baskets": [],
   "category": "Long-short pair contracts for DAO outcome incentives (Ethereum)",
   "chains": [
    "ethereum"
   ],
   "deltas": 0,
   "easAttested": false,
   "evidence": {
    "documented": "Outcome Finance documentation is linked for reference (). This RPC-pinned record does not compare documentation parameters with the on-chain state.",
    "observed": "LongShortPairCreator (0x0b8de441B26E36f461b2748919ed71f50593A67b) verified on Ethereum Mainnet at canonical block #26,458,556 (13,594 bytes runtime code). EIP-1967 implementation and admin storage slots are both zero (non-EIP-1967 contract). No owner(), admin(), authority(), curator() or AccessControl admin was readable on the contract.",
    "recordId": "outcome-finance-control-plane",
    "surface": "LongShortPairCreator · Non-Proxy Bytecode & Controller"
   },
   "factors": [
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "upgrade",
     "label": "Upgradeability",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "Upgrade path not in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "timelock",
     "label": "Timelock floor",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No enforced admin delay in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "quorum",
     "label": "Signer quorum",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No signer quorum in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "emergency",
     "label": "Emergency / freeze scope",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No pause / freeze authority in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "parity",
     "label": "Docs-vs-chain parity",
     "state": "u",
     "value": "Uncompared: documentation not assessed (RPC-observed)"
    }
   ],
   "finding": "LongShortPairCreator · Non-Proxy Bytecode & Controller",
   "grade": "observed",
   "gradeLabel": "OBSERVED",
   "name": "Outcome Finance",
   "pinnedBlock": 26458556,
   "probe": {
    "block_hash": "0xe258bb1cbcc988e2dfdba4ba173f9f8690520dba3647cdcae18e0651822769d2",
    "block_number": 26458556,
    "call_args": [],
    "call_signature": "owner()",
    "chain": "ethereum",
    "check_type": "eth_call",
    "extra_calls": [],
    "id": "outcome-finance-control-plane",
    "repro_calldata": "0x8da5cb5b",
    "rpc_env_var": "$ETH_RPC_URL",
    "selector_or_slot": "0x8da5cb5b",
    "target_contract": "0x0b8de441B26E36f461b2748919ed71f50593A67b",
    "target_label": "LongShortPairCreator"
   },
   "reconciled": false,
   "reconciledFrom": [],
   "reconciledTo": [],
   "records": 1,
   "rosetteAria": "Outcome Finance control-plane rosette: Upgradeability not determined; Timelock floor not determined; Signer quorum not determined; Emergency / freeze scope not determined; Docs-vs-chain parity uncompared",
   "search": "outcome finance outcome-finance long-short pair contracts for dao outcome incentives (ethereum) outcome 0x0b8de441b26e36f461b2748919ed71f50593a67b",
   "slug": "outcome-finance",
   "summary_short": "Non-proxy contract no readable owner or admin; docs not assessed",
   "url": "https://pacta.wtf/protocols/outcome-finance/"
  },
  {
   "baskets": [],
   "category": "On-chain sportsbook using Chainlink sports data (Ethereum)",
   "chains": [
    "ethereum"
   ],
   "deltas": 0,
   "easAttested": false,
   "evidence": {
    "documented": "Overtime documentation is linked for reference (https://www.overtimemarkets.xyz). This RPC-pinned record does not compare documentation parameters with the on-chain state.",
    "observed": "Overtime DAO Token (OverToken) (0x90cE5720c17587D28E4Af120ae2d313B3BAD1722) verified on Ethereum Mainnet at canonical block #26,458,556 (4,561 bytes runtime code). EIP-1967 implementation and admin storage slots are both zero (non-EIP-1967 contract). Direct owner() returns externally owned account (no code) 0x4dA7493C2CE2BEce36e75AaDdF39D5c041B6d468.",
    "recordId": "overtime-control-plane",
    "surface": "Overtime DAO Token (OverToken) · Non-Proxy Bytecode & Controller"
   },
   "factors": [
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "upgrade",
     "label": "Upgradeability",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "Upgrade path not in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "timelock",
     "label": "Timelock floor",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No enforced admin delay in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": "overtime-control-plane: … (non-EIP-1967 contract). Direct owner() returns externally owned account (no code) 0x4dA7493C2CE2BEce36e75AaDdF39D5c041B6d468.",
     "key": "quorum",
     "label": "Signer quorum",
     "state": "a",
     "value": "Lowest controlling quorum: a single key"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "emergency",
     "label": "Emergency / freeze scope",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No pause / freeze authority in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "parity",
     "label": "Docs-vs-chain parity",
     "state": "u",
     "value": "Uncompared: documentation not assessed (RPC-observed)"
    }
   ],
   "finding": "Overtime DAO Token (OverToken) · Non-Proxy Bytecode & Controller",
   "grade": "observed",
   "gradeLabel": "OBSERVED",
   "name": "Overtime",
   "pinnedBlock": 26458556,
   "probe": {
    "block_hash": "0xe258bb1cbcc988e2dfdba4ba173f9f8690520dba3647cdcae18e0651822769d2",
    "block_number": 26458556,
    "call_args": [],
    "call_signature": "owner()",
    "chain": "ethereum",
    "check_type": "eth_call",
    "extra_calls": [],
    "id": "overtime-control-plane",
    "repro_calldata": "0x8da5cb5b",
    "rpc_env_var": "$ETH_RPC_URL",
    "selector_or_slot": "0x8da5cb5b",
    "target_contract": "0x90cE5720c17587D28E4Af120ae2d313B3BAD1722",
    "target_label": "Overtime DAO Token (OverToken)"
   },
   "reconciled": false,
   "reconciledFrom": [],
   "reconciledTo": [],
   "records": 1,
   "rosetteAria": "Overtime control-plane rosette: Upgradeability not determined; Timelock floor not determined; Signer quorum weak; Emergency / freeze scope not determined; Docs-vs-chain parity uncompared",
   "search": "overtime overtime on-chain sportsbook using chainlink sports data (ethereum) over 0x4da7493c2ce2bece36e75aaddf39d5c041b6d468 0x90ce5720c17587d28e4af120ae2d313b3bad1722",
   "slug": "overtime",
   "summary_short": "Non-proxy contract controlled by a single key (EOA); docs not assessed",
   "url": "https://pacta.wtf/protocols/overtime/"
  },
  {
   "baskets": [],
   "category": "Concentrated-liquidity pool factory of a multichain swap venue first built on BNB Chain (Ethereum)",
   "chains": [
    "ethereum"
   ],
   "deltas": 0,
   "easAttested": false,
   "evidence": {
    "documented": "PancakeSwap AMM V3 documentation is linked for reference (https://developer.pancakeswap.finance/). This RPC-pinned record does not compare documentation parameters with the on-chain state.",
    "observed": "PlunderV3Factory (0x0BFbCF9fa4f9C56B0F40a671Ad40E0805A091865) verified on Ethereum Mainnet at canonical block #26,458,556 (5,151 bytes runtime code). EIP-1967 implementation and admin storage slots are both zero (non-EIP-1967 contract). Direct owner() returns contract V3OpenFeeAdapter 0x0f6f9A6dd9f065DC4455bb2B8e3F0CFFB6F2410c. That controller is in turn controlled by Safe 3-of-7 0x21835332cBDf1b3530fAE9f6Cd66FEB9477dFC02.",
    "recordId": "pancakeswap-amm-v3-control-plane",
    "surface": "PlunderV3Factory · Non-Proxy Bytecode & Controller"
   },
   "factors": [
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "upgrade",
     "label": "Upgradeability",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "Upgrade path not in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "timelock",
     "label": "Timelock floor",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No enforced admin delay in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": "pancakeswap-amm-v3-control-plane: … controller is in turn controlled by Safe 3-of-7 0x21835332cBDf1b3530fAE9f6Cd66FEB9477dFC02.",
     "key": "quorum",
     "label": "Signer quorum",
     "state": "g",
     "value": "Lowest controlling quorum: 3-of-7"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "emergency",
     "label": "Emergency / freeze scope",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No pause / freeze authority in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "parity",
     "label": "Docs-vs-chain parity",
     "state": "u",
     "value": "Uncompared: documentation not assessed (RPC-observed)"
    }
   ],
   "finding": "PlunderV3Factory · Non-Proxy Bytecode & Controller",
   "grade": "observed",
   "gradeLabel": "OBSERVED",
   "name": "PancakeSwap AMM V3",
   "pinnedBlock": 26458556,
   "probe": {
    "block_hash": "0xe258bb1cbcc988e2dfdba4ba173f9f8690520dba3647cdcae18e0651822769d2",
    "block_number": 26458556,
    "call_args": [],
    "call_signature": "owner()",
    "chain": "ethereum",
    "check_type": "eth_call",
    "extra_calls": [],
    "id": "pancakeswap-amm-v3-control-plane",
    "repro_calldata": "0x8da5cb5b",
    "rpc_env_var": "$ETH_RPC_URL",
    "selector_or_slot": "0x8da5cb5b",
    "target_contract": "0x0BFbCF9fa4f9C56B0F40a671Ad40E0805A091865",
    "target_label": "PlunderV3Factory"
   },
   "reconciled": false,
   "reconciledFrom": [],
   "reconciledTo": [],
   "records": 1,
   "rosetteAria": "PancakeSwap AMM V3 control-plane rosette: Upgradeability not determined; Timelock floor not determined; Signer quorum strong; Emergency / freeze scope not determined; Docs-vs-chain parity uncompared",
   "search": "pancakeswap amm v3 pancakeswap-amm-v3 concentrated-liquidity pool factory of a multichain swap venue first built on bnb chain (ethereum) pancakeswap 0x0bfbcf9fa4f9c56b0f40a671ad40e0805a091865 0x0f6f9a6dd9f065dc4455bb2b8e3f0cffb6f2410c 0x21835332cbdf1b3530fae9f6cd66feb9477dfc02",
   "slug": "pancakeswap-amm-v3",
   "summary_short": "Non-proxy contract controlled by a 3-of-7 Safe; docs not assessed",
   "url": "https://pacta.wtf/protocols/pancakeswap-amm-v3/"
  },
  {
   "baskets": [],
   "category": "Perpetual options built on concentrated-liquidity positions (Ethereum)",
   "chains": [
    "ethereum"
   ],
   "deltas": 0,
   "easAttested": true,
   "evidence": {
    "documented": "'Pools retain a fixed RiskEngine proxy address; an authorized implementation upgrade can change their risk policy in place.' (panoptic.xyz/docs/contracts/parameters.md)",
    "observed": "Panoptic V2 RiskEngineProxy 0x000000000000ffE5eFdB5AE76b9200263C58b4c0 (Ethereum): EIP-1967 implementation slot = 0x000000000000f69c150aFEa8Cc4f8fC4462AdBB4, admin slot = 0x22BD5EC2Ee6685C373781420E12c1426dd7776F2; upgradeable (EIP-1967 implementation + admin slot (transparent proxy)).",
    "recordId": "panoptic-v2-upgradeability-s30",
    "surface": "Panoptic V2 RiskEngineProxy: upgradeable (proxy admin), as documented"
   },
   "factors": [
    {
     "evidence": "panoptic-v2-upgradeability-s30: Panoptic V2 RiskEngineProxy 0x000000000000ffE5eFdB5AE76b9200263C58b4c0 (Ethereum): EIP-1967 implementation slot = 0x000000000000f69c150aFEa8Cc4f8fC4462AdBB4 …",
     "key": "upgrade",
     "label": "Upgradeability",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "Upgradeable; the delay gating the upgrade path is not in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "timelock",
     "label": "Timelock floor",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No enforced admin delay in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "quorum",
     "label": "Signer quorum",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No signer quorum in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "emergency",
     "label": "Emergency / freeze scope",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No pause / freeze authority in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "parity",
     "label": "Docs-vs-chain parity",
     "state": "g",
     "value": "Chain matches or is stronger than the documentation"
    }
   ],
   "finding": "Panoptic V2 RiskEngineProxy: upgradeable (proxy admin), as documented",
   "grade": "aligned",
   "gradeLabel": "ALIGNED",
   "name": "Panoptic V2",
   "pinnedBlock": 26449594,
   "probe": {
    "block_hash": "0xbe263d5b378dcb7c3c4e18bd8e388f0cb2dab1adacd83de2be58c9408b377287",
    "block_number": 26449594,
    "call_args": [],
    "call_signature": null,
    "chain": "ethereum",
    "check_type": "eth_getStorageAt",
    "extra_calls": [],
    "id": "panoptic-v2-upgradeability-s30",
    "repro_calldata": null,
    "rpc_env_var": "$ETH_RPC_URL",
    "selector_or_slot": "0x360894a13ba1a3210667c828492db98dca3e2076cc3735a920a3ca505d382bbc",
    "target_contract": "0x000000000000ffE5eFdB5AE76b9200263C58b4c0",
    "target_label": "Panoptic V2 RiskEngineProxy"
   },
   "reconciled": false,
   "reconciledFrom": [],
   "reconciledTo": [],
   "records": 1,
   "rosetteAria": "Panoptic V2 control-plane rosette: Upgradeability not determined; Timelock floor not determined; Signer quorum not determined; Emergency / freeze scope not determined; Docs-vs-chain parity strong",
   "search": "panoptic v2 panoptic-v2 perpetual options built on concentrated-liquidity positions (ethereum) panoptic-nft 0x000000000000f69c150afea8cc4f8fc4462adbb4 0x000000000000ffe5efdb5ae76b9200263c58b4c0 0x22bd5ec2ee6685c373781420e12c1426dd7776f2",
   "slug": "panoptic-v2",
   "summary_short": "The Panoptic V2 RiskEngineProxy is upgradeable (proxy admin), as its docs state",
   "url": "https://pacta.wtf/protocols/panoptic-v2/"
  },
  {
   "baskets": [],
   "category": "Deposit bridge for a perpetuals exchange on a Starknet appchain (Ethereum)",
   "chains": [
    "ethereum"
   ],
   "deltas": 0,
   "easAttested": false,
   "evidence": {
    "documented": "Paradex Bridge documentation is linked for reference (https://docs.paradex.trade/home). This RPC-pinned record does not compare documentation parameters with the on-chain state.",
    "observed": "DIME (0xb32E10022FFBeDfE10bc818a1C7e67D9d87e0fa7) verified on Ethereum Mainnet at canonical block #26,458,556 (170 bytes runtime code). EIP-1967 proxy: implementation 0x515244B743dde07925d2D9e6478930528AE5e3Fc, admin slot zero. No owner(), admin(), authority(), curator() or AccessControl admin was readable on the contract.",
    "recordId": "paradex-bridge-control-plane",
    "surface": "DIME · EIP-1967 Proxy & Controller Chain"
   },
   "factors": [
    {
     "evidence": "paradex-bridge-control-plane: is_eip1967_proxy = true",
     "key": "upgrade",
     "label": "Upgradeability",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "Upgradeable; the delay gating the upgrade path is not in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "timelock",
     "label": "Timelock floor",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No enforced admin delay in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "quorum",
     "label": "Signer quorum",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No signer quorum in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "emergency",
     "label": "Emergency / freeze scope",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No pause / freeze authority in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "parity",
     "label": "Docs-vs-chain parity",
     "state": "u",
     "value": "Uncompared: documentation not assessed (RPC-observed)"
    }
   ],
   "finding": "DIME · EIP-1967 Proxy & Controller Chain",
   "grade": "observed",
   "gradeLabel": "OBSERVED",
   "name": "Paradex Bridge",
   "pinnedBlock": 26458556,
   "probe": {
    "block_hash": "0xe258bb1cbcc988e2dfdba4ba173f9f8690520dba3647cdcae18e0651822769d2",
    "block_number": 26458556,
    "call_args": [],
    "call_signature": "owner()",
    "chain": "ethereum",
    "check_type": "eth_call",
    "extra_calls": [],
    "id": "paradex-bridge-control-plane",
    "repro_calldata": "0x8da5cb5b",
    "rpc_env_var": "$ETH_RPC_URL",
    "selector_or_slot": "0x8da5cb5b",
    "target_contract": "0xb32E10022FFBeDfE10bc818a1C7e67D9d87e0fa7",
    "target_label": "DIME"
   },
   "reconciled": false,
   "reconciledFrom": [],
   "reconciledTo": [],
   "records": 1,
   "rosetteAria": "Paradex Bridge control-plane rosette: Upgradeability not determined; Timelock floor not determined; Signer quorum not determined; Emergency / freeze scope not determined; Docs-vs-chain parity uncompared",
   "search": "paradex bridge paradex-bridge deposit bridge for a perpetuals exchange on a starknet appchain (ethereum) dime 0x515244b743dde07925d2d9e6478930528ae5e3fc 0xb32e10022ffbedfe10bc818a1c7e67d9d87e0fa7",
   "slug": "paradex-bridge",
   "summary_short": "Upgradeable proxy no readable owner or admin; docs not assessed",
   "url": "https://pacta.wtf/protocols/paradex-bridge/"
  },
  {
   "baskets": [
    "lending_vaults",
    "stable_rwa"
   ],
   "category": "Modular overcollateralized stablecoins minted against yield-bearing baskets (Ethereum)",
   "chains": [
    "ethereum"
   ],
   "deltas": 0,
   "easAttested": true,
   "evidence": {
    "documented": "'PRL has no mint function, so its supply can only go down.' (docs.parallel.best/governance/parallel-governance-token-prl.md)",
    "observed": "PRL token 0x6c0aeceeDc55c9d55d8B99216a670D85330941c3 (Ethereum; not a proxy: EIP-1967 implementation, admin and beacon slots all empty; verified source): totalSupply() = 1,000,000,000. The runtime code holds no selector of mint(address,uint256), mint(uint256), upgradeTo(address), upgradeToAndCall(address,bytes). Its only mint is the internal one at construction (burns to 0x…dEaD do not reduce totalSupply).",
    "recordId": "parallel-prl-no-mint-s33",
    "surface": "PRL: 1,000,000,000, no mint function"
   },
   "factors": [
    {
     "evidence": "parallel-prl-no-mint-s33: PRL token 0x6c0aeceeDc55c9d55d8B99216a670D85330941c3 (Ethereum; not a proxy: EIP-1967 implementation, admin and beacon slots all empty; verified source) …",
     "key": "upgrade",
     "label": "Upgradeability",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "Upgradeable; the delay gating the upgrade path is not in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "timelock",
     "label": "Timelock floor",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No enforced admin delay in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "quorum",
     "label": "Signer quorum",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No signer quorum in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "emergency",
     "label": "Emergency / freeze scope",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No pause / freeze authority in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "parity",
     "label": "Docs-vs-chain parity",
     "state": "g",
     "value": "Chain matches or is stronger than the documentation"
    }
   ],
   "finding": "PRL: 1,000,000,000, no mint function",
   "grade": "aligned",
   "gradeLabel": "ALIGNED",
   "name": "Parallel Protocol V3",
   "pinnedBlock": 26452373,
   "probe": {
    "block_hash": "0x63bfaa16f0019d8b37e757265d351bd135ad41e6ffa46207284198917123c55d",
    "block_number": 26452373,
    "call_args": [],
    "call_signature": "totalSupply()",
    "chain": "ethereum",
    "check_type": "eth_call",
    "extra_calls": [],
    "id": "parallel-prl-no-mint-s33",
    "repro_calldata": "0x18160ddd",
    "rpc_env_var": "$ETH_RPC_URL",
    "selector_or_slot": "0x18160ddd",
    "target_contract": "0x6c0aeceeDc55c9d55d8B99216a670D85330941c3",
    "target_label": "PRL token"
   },
   "reconciled": false,
   "reconciledFrom": [],
   "reconciledTo": [],
   "records": 1,
   "rosetteAria": "Parallel Protocol V3 control-plane rosette: Upgradeability not determined; Timelock floor not determined; Signer quorum not determined; Emergency / freeze scope not determined; Docs-vs-chain parity strong",
   "search": "parallel protocol v3 parallel-protocol-v3 modular overcollateralized stablecoins minted against yield-bearing baskets (ethereum) prl 0x6c0aeceedc55c9d55d8b99216a670d85330941c3",
   "slug": "parallel-protocol-v3",
   "summary_short": "PRL has no mint function, as documented",
   "url": "https://pacta.wtf/protocols/parallel-protocol-v3/"
  },
  {
   "baskets": [
    "stable_rwa"
   ],
   "category": "Fiat-Backed Stablecoin (PYUSD)",
   "chains": [
    "ethereum"
   ],
   "deltas": 0,
   "easAttested": true,
   "evidence": {
    "documented": "PYUSD contract README: 'In the event of a critical security threat, Paxos has the ability to pause transfers and approvals of the PYUSD token. The ability to pause is controlled by a single `owner` role,' / 'The `ASSET_PROTECTION_ROLE` can freeze and unfreeze the token balance of any address on chain.' / docs.paxos.com: 'Ethereum Mainnet 0x6c3ea9036406852006290770BEdFcAbA0e23A0e8'",
    "observed": "PYUSD 0x6c3ea9036406852006290770BEdFcAbA0e23A0e8: defaultAdmin() = owner() = 0x3Af3e85f4f97De7AD0f000B724Fb77fE5ffc024B (no contract code), holding PAUSE_ROLE, ASSET_PROTECTION_ROLE and DEFAULT_ADMIN_ROLE (roles not enumerable); defaultAdminDelay() = 10800s (3 hours); no pending default admin; paused() = false.",
    "recordId": "paypal-usd-pyusd-pause-asset-protection-single-owner-role-s23",
    "surface": "Pause and asset-protection roles: one address without contract code, as documented"
   },
   "factors": [
    {
     "evidence": "paypal-usd-pyusd-proxy-admin-upgrade-key-s23: PYUSD 0x6c3ea9036406852006290770BEdFcAbA0e23A0e8: admin slot keccak256('org.zeppelinos.proxy.admin') = 0xC94BcF6e1d8B3558E3B62e743630D50497E3851C (no contract …",
     "key": "upgrade",
     "label": "Upgradeability",
     "state": "a",
     "value": "Upgradeable with no enforced delay: no timelock in front of upgrades (2 other upgrade paths not determined)"
    },
    {
     "evidence": "paypal-usd-pyusd-proxy-admin-upgrade-key-s23: PYUSD 0x6c3ea9036406852006290770BEdFcAbA0e23A0e8: admin slot keccak256('org.zeppelinos.proxy.admin') = 0xC94BcF6e1d8B3558E3B62e743630D50497E3851C (no contract …",
     "key": "timelock",
     "label": "Timelock floor",
     "state": "a",
     "value": "0s minimum enforced delay across control surfaces"
    },
    {
     "evidence": "paypal-usd-pyusd-pause-asset-protection-single-owner-role-s23: … 0x3Af3e85f4f97De7AD0f000B724Fb77fE5ffc024B (no contract code), holding PAUSE_ROLE, ASSET_PROTECTION_ROLE …",
     "key": "quorum",
     "label": "Signer quorum",
     "state": "a",
     "value": "Lowest controlling quorum: a single key"
    },
    {
     "evidence": "paypal-usd-pyusd-pause-asset-protection-single-owner-role-s23: PYUSD 0x6c3ea9036406852006290770BEdFcAbA0e23A0e8: defaultAdmin() = owner() = 0x3Af3e85f4f97De7AD0f000B724Fb77fE5ffc024B (no contract code), holding PAUSE_ROLE …",
     "key": "emergency",
     "label": "Emergency / freeze scope",
     "state": "a",
     "value": "Pause / freeze authority held by a single key"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "parity",
     "label": "Docs-vs-chain parity",
     "state": "g",
     "value": "Chain matches or is stronger than the documentation"
    }
   ],
   "finding": "Pause and asset-protection roles: one address without contract code, as documented",
   "grade": "aligned",
   "gradeLabel": "ALIGNED",
   "name": "PayPal USD (PYUSD)",
   "pinnedBlock": 26431152,
   "probe": {
    "block_hash": "0xfe2ed4e127f30bb42dd30c6fc1460a82d8438cff3a717ec89210805e55199a46",
    "block_number": 26431152,
    "call_args": [],
    "call_signature": "defaultAdmin()",
    "chain": "ethereum",
    "check_type": "eth_call",
    "extra_calls": [],
    "id": "paypal-usd-pyusd-pause-asset-protection-single-owner-role-s23",
    "repro_calldata": "0x84ef8ffc",
    "rpc_env_var": "$ETH_RPC_URL",
    "selector_or_slot": "0x84ef8ffc",
    "target_contract": "0x6c3ea9036406852006290770BEdFcAbA0e23A0e8",
    "target_label": "PayPal USD (PYUSD) AdminUpgradeabilityProxy"
   },
   "reconciled": false,
   "reconciledFrom": [],
   "reconciledTo": [],
   "records": 3,
   "rosetteAria": "PayPal USD (PYUSD) control-plane rosette: Upgradeability weak; Timelock floor weak; Signer quorum weak; Emergency / freeze scope weak; Docs-vs-chain parity strong",
   "search": "paypal usd (pyusd) paypal-usd-pyusd fiat-backed stablecoin (pyusd) pyusd 0x31d9bdea6f104606c954f8fe6ba614f1bd347ec3 0x3af3e85f4f97de7ad0f000b724fb77fe5ffc024b 0x6c3ea9036406852006290770bedfcaba0e23a0e8 0x8c35caa5fd5bdc64b6b11344ad57594a3676256a 0xc94bcf6e1d8b3558e3b62e743630d50497e3851c 0xfab5891ed867a1195303251912013b92c4fc3a1d",
   "slug": "paypal-usd-pyusd",
   "summary_short": "Pause and asset-protection roles sit with one key address, as documented",
   "url": "https://pacta.wtf/protocols/paypal-usd-pyusd/"
  },
  {
   "baskets": [
    "lending_vaults"
   ],
   "category": "Volatility farming indexes that earn yield on liquid assets (Ethereum)",
   "chains": [
    "ethereum"
   ],
   "deltas": 0,
   "easAttested": true,
   "evidence": {
    "documented": "'making sure no additional PEAS are ever coming into circulation when expanding to additional chains' (docs.peapods.finance/links/contract-addresses.md)",
    "observed": "PEAS token 0x02f92800F57BCD74066F5709F1Daa1A4302Df875 (Ethereum; not a proxy: EIP-1967 implementation, admin and beacon slots all empty; verified source): totalSupply() = 9,936,639.21. The runtime code holds no selector of mint(address,uint256), mint(uint256), upgradeTo(address), upgradeToAndCall(address,bytes). Its only mint is the internal one at construction; supply is below the initial 10,000,000 through burns.",
    "recordId": "peapods-peas-no-mint-ethereum-s33",
    "surface": "PEAS (Ethereum): 9,936,639.21, no mint function"
   },
   "factors": [
    {
     "evidence": "peapods-peas-no-mint-ethereum-s33: PEAS token 0x02f92800F57BCD74066F5709F1Daa1A4302Df875 (Ethereum; not a proxy: EIP-1967 implementation, admin and beacon slots all empty; verified source) …",
     "key": "upgrade",
     "label": "Upgradeability",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "Upgradeable; the delay gating the upgrade path is not in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "timelock",
     "label": "Timelock floor",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No enforced admin delay in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "quorum",
     "label": "Signer quorum",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No signer quorum in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "emergency",
     "label": "Emergency / freeze scope",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No pause / freeze authority in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "parity",
     "label": "Docs-vs-chain parity",
     "state": "g",
     "value": "Chain matches or is stronger than the documentation"
    }
   ],
   "finding": "PEAS (Ethereum): 9,936,639.21, no mint function",
   "grade": "aligned",
   "gradeLabel": "ALIGNED",
   "name": "Peapods Finance",
   "pinnedBlock": 26452373,
   "probe": {
    "block_hash": "0x63bfaa16f0019d8b37e757265d351bd135ad41e6ffa46207284198917123c55d",
    "block_number": 26452373,
    "call_args": [],
    "call_signature": "totalSupply()",
    "chain": "ethereum",
    "check_type": "eth_call",
    "extra_calls": [],
    "id": "peapods-peas-no-mint-ethereum-s33",
    "repro_calldata": "0x18160ddd",
    "rpc_env_var": "$ETH_RPC_URL",
    "selector_or_slot": "0x18160ddd",
    "target_contract": "0x02f92800F57BCD74066F5709F1Daa1A4302Df875",
    "target_label": "PEAS token"
   },
   "reconciled": false,
   "reconciledFrom": [],
   "reconciledTo": [],
   "records": 1,
   "rosetteAria": "Peapods Finance control-plane rosette: Upgradeability not determined; Timelock floor not determined; Signer quorum not determined; Emergency / freeze scope not determined; Docs-vs-chain parity strong",
   "search": "peapods finance peapods-finance volatility farming indexes that earn yield on liquid assets (ethereum) peas 0x02f92800f57bcd74066f5709f1daa1a4302df875",
   "slug": "peapods-finance",
   "summary_short": "No PEAS can be minted on Ethereum, as documented",
   "url": "https://pacta.wtf/protocols/peapods-finance/"
  },
  {
   "baskets": [
    "lending_vaults"
   ],
   "category": "Yield Tokenization & AMM",
   "chains": [
    "ethereum"
   ],
   "deltas": 0,
   "easAttested": true,
   "evidence": {
    "documented": "docs.pendle.finance (fees): '20% of all swap fees are given to LP providers of the pool as yield.'",
    "observed": "PendleMarketFactory (0x6d247b1c044fA1E22e6B04fA9F71Baf99EB29A9f).reserveFeePercent() = 80 (maxReserveFeePercent() = 100); treasury() = 0x8270400d528c34e1596EF367eeDEc99080A1b592; owner() = PendleGovernanceProxy 0x2aD631F72fB16d91c4953A7f4260A97C2fE2f31e (DEFAULT_ADMIN_ROLE: 3-of-5 Safe 0x8119EC16F0573B7dAc7C0CB94EB504FB32456ee1); EIP-1967 admin ProxyAdmin 0xA28c08f165116587D4F3E708743B4dEe155c5E64 (owner() = the Safe).",
    "recordId": "pendle-finance-v2-reserve-fee-80-lp-20-s19",
    "surface": "Market factory sends 80% of swap fees to the treasury, leaving 20% to LPs"
   },
   "factors": [
    {
     "evidence": "pendle-finance-v2-reserve-fee-80-lp-20-s19: EIP-1967 admin ProxyAdmin 0xA28c08f165116587D4F3E708743B4dEe155c5E64 (owner() = the Safe).",
     "key": "upgrade",
     "label": "Upgradeability",
     "state": "a",
     "value": "Upgradeable with no enforced delay: upgraded by a Safe directly (a Safe has no delay of its own)"
    },
    {
     "evidence": "pendle-finance-v2-reserve-fee-80-lp-20-s19: EIP-1967 admin ProxyAdmin 0xA28c08f165116587D4F3E708743B4dEe155c5E64 (owner() = the Safe).",
     "key": "timelock",
     "label": "Timelock floor",
     "state": "a",
     "value": "0s minimum enforced delay across control surfaces"
    },
    {
     "evidence": "pendle-finance-v2-reserve-fee-80-lp-20-s19: … 0x2aD631F72fB16d91c4953A7f4260A97C2fE2f31e (DEFAULT_ADMIN_ROLE: 3-of-5 Safe 0x8119EC16F0573B7dAc7C0CB94EB504FB32456ee1); …",
     "key": "quorum",
     "label": "Signer quorum",
     "state": "g",
     "value": "Lowest controlling quorum: 3-of-5"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "emergency",
     "label": "Emergency / freeze scope",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No pause / freeze authority in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "parity",
     "label": "Docs-vs-chain parity",
     "state": "g",
     "value": "Chain matches or is stronger than the documentation"
    }
   ],
   "finding": "Market factory sends 80% of swap fees to the treasury, leaving 20% to LPs",
   "grade": "aligned",
   "gradeLabel": "ALIGNED",
   "name": "Pendle Finance V2",
   "pinnedBlock": 26422243,
   "probe": {
    "block_hash": "0xbbe80f9ef9966a9d04cea23db216847f8c8fcc8d66f87c215dc7f712f0743410",
    "block_number": 26422243,
    "call_args": [],
    "call_signature": "reserveFeePercent()",
    "chain": "ethereum",
    "check_type": "eth_call",
    "extra_calls": [],
    "id": "pendle-finance-v2-reserve-fee-80-lp-20-s19",
    "repro_calldata": "0x1feec244",
    "rpc_env_var": "$ETH_RPC_URL",
    "selector_or_slot": "0x1feec244",
    "target_contract": "0x6d247b1c044fA1E22e6B04fA9F71Baf99EB29A9f",
    "target_label": "PendleMarketFactory (V7Upg)"
   },
   "reconciled": false,
   "reconciledFrom": [],
   "reconciledTo": [],
   "records": 2,
   "rosetteAria": "Pendle Finance V2 control-plane rosette: Upgradeability weak; Timelock floor weak; Signer quorum strong; Emergency / freeze scope not determined; Docs-vs-chain parity strong",
   "search": "pendle finance v2 pendle-finance-v2 yield tokenization & amm pendle vependle 0x2ad631f72fb16d91c4953a7f4260a97c2fe2f31e 0x3e6eba46abc5ab18ed95f6667d8b2fd4020e4637 0x4f30a9d41b80ecc5b94306ab4364951ae3170210 0x6d247b1c044fa1e22e6b04fa9f71baf99eb29a9f 0x808507121b80c02388fad14726482e061b8da827 0x8119ec16f0573b7dac7c0cb94eb504fb32456ee1 0x8270400d528c34e1596ef367eedec99080a1b592 0x888888888889758f76e7103c6cbf23abbf58f946 0xa28c08f165116587d4f3e708743b4dee155c5e64",
   "slug": "pendle-finance-v2",
   "summary_short": "Markets send 80% of swap fees to the treasury and 20% to LPs, as documented",
   "url": "https://pacta.wtf/protocols/pendle-finance-v2/"
  },
  {
   "baskets": [
    "eth_lst_lrt",
    "lending_vaults"
   ],
   "category": "Auto-compounding LP yield aggregator with dill staking (Ethereum)",
   "chains": [
    "ethereum"
   ],
   "deltas": 1,
   "easAttested": true,
   "evidence": {
    "documented": "'All key admin functions on the MasterChef contract, which controls the emission of PICKLEs to the Farms are controlled by a 24 hour timelock contract' (docs.pickle.finance/security/audits-and-timelock/timelocks-and-multisig)",
    "observed": "Pickle MasterChef 0xbD17B1ce622d73bD438b9E658acA5996dc394b0d (Ethereum, not a proxy): its verified source makes add, set, setPicklePerBlock, setBonusEndBlock, setDevFundDivRate and the PICKLE mint path onlyOwner; MasterChef is owner() of the PICKLE token 0x429881672B9AE42b8EbA0E26cD9C73711b891Ca5. MasterChef owner() = 0x9d074E37d408542FD38be78848e8814AFB38db17, a 2-of-6 Safe (the page calls it a 2/5 multisig). The 24-hour Timelock the page links, 0x0040E05CE9A5fc9C0aBF89889f7b60c2fC278416 (delay() = 86,400 s, admin() = the same Safe), does not own MasterChef.",
    "recordId": "pickle-masterchef-owner-safe-no-timelock-s32",
    "surface": "MasterChef admin: owner is a 2-of-6 Safe, the documented 24 h timelock is not in the path"
   },
   "factors": [
    {
     "evidence": "pickle-masterchef-owner-safe-no-timelock-s32: … 0xbD17B1ce622d73bD438b9E658acA5996dc394b0d (Ethereum, not a proxy): its verified source makes add, set, …",
     "key": "upgrade",
     "label": "Upgradeability",
     "state": "g",
     "value": "Immutable or ownership renounced"
    },
    {
     "evidence": "pickle-masterchef-owner-safe-no-timelock-s32: … 0x0040E05CE9A5fc9C0aBF89889f7b60c2fC278416 (delay() = 86,400 s, admin() = the same Safe), does not …",
     "key": "timelock",
     "label": "Timelock floor",
     "state": "b",
     "value": "1d minimum enforced delay across control surfaces"
    },
    {
     "evidence": "pickle-masterchef-owner-safe-no-timelock-s32: … 0x9d074E37d408542FD38be78848e8814AFB38db17, a 2-of-6 Safe (the page calls it a 2/5 multisig). …",
     "key": "quorum",
     "label": "Signer quorum",
     "state": "b",
     "value": "Lowest controlling quorum: 2-of-6"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "emergency",
     "label": "Emergency / freeze scope",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No pause / freeze authority in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "parity",
     "label": "Docs-vs-chain parity",
     "state": "a",
     "value": "Documentation differs from the chain (parameter delta)"
    }
   ],
   "finding": "MasterChef admin: owner is a 2-of-6 Safe, the documented 24 h timelock is not in the path: docs say 'All key admin functions on the MasterChef contract, which controls the emission of PICKLEs to the Farms are controlled by a 24 hour timelock contract' (docs.pickle.finance/security/audits-and-timelock/timelocks-and-mul… · chain says Pickle MasterChef 0xbD17B1ce622d73bD438b9E658acA5996dc394b0d (Ethereum, not a proxy): its verified source makes add, set, setPicklePerBlock, setBonusEndBlock, setDevFundDivRate and the PICKLE mint path onlyOwner;",
   "grade": "delta",
   "gradeLabel": "DELTA",
   "name": "Pickle",
   "pinnedBlock": 26451608,
   "probe": {
    "block_hash": "0x0266af5bcad519d93b3be78e41b76a62985e22fbe4feef043ac3225f6f217a17",
    "block_number": 26451608,
    "call_args": [],
    "call_signature": "owner()",
    "chain": "ethereum",
    "check_type": "eth_call",
    "extra_calls": [],
    "id": "pickle-masterchef-owner-safe-no-timelock-s32",
    "repro_calldata": "0x8da5cb5b",
    "rpc_env_var": "$ETH_RPC_URL",
    "selector_or_slot": "0x8da5cb5b",
    "target_contract": "0xbD17B1ce622d73bD438b9E658acA5996dc394b0d",
    "target_label": "Pickle MasterChef"
   },
   "reconciled": false,
   "reconciledFrom": [],
   "reconciledTo": [],
   "records": 1,
   "rosetteAria": "Pickle control-plane rosette: Upgradeability strong; Timelock floor moderate; Signer quorum moderate; Emergency / freeze scope not determined; Docs-vs-chain parity weak",
   "search": "pickle pickle auto-compounding lp yield aggregator with dill staking (ethereum) pickle 0x0040e05ce9a5fc9c0abf89889f7b60c2fc278416 0x429881672b9ae42b8eba0e26cd9c73711b891ca5 0x9d074e37d408542fd38be78848e8814afb38db17 0xbd17b1ce622d73bd438b9e658aca5996dc394b0d",
   "slug": "pickle",
   "summary_short": "Pickle's MasterChef admin functions run from a Safe directly; docs: a 24-hour timelock",
   "url": "https://pacta.wtf/protocols/pickle/"
  },
  {
   "baskets": [
    "lending_vaults",
    "stable_rwa"
   ],
   "category": "Yield-optimized stablecoin (USP) with institutional vaults (Ethereum)",
   "chains": [
    "ethereum"
   ],
   "deltas": 0,
   "easAttested": true,
   "evidence": {
    "documented": "'**Total Token Supply: 500,000,000 PIKU**' (docs.piku.co/piku/pikudao/piku.md)",
    "observed": "PIKU token 0x2E4039E8E31475d65DC00293C366FDBfBBC02DC3 (Ethereum; not a proxy: EIP-1967 implementation, admin and beacon slots all empty; verified source): totalSupply() = 500,000,000. The runtime code holds no selector of mint(address,uint256), mint(uint256), upgradeTo(address), upgradeToAndCall(address,bytes). The whole supply is minted to the admin in its constructor; no function creates tokens.",
    "recordId": "piku-token-supply-500m-s34",
    "surface": "PIKU supply: 500,000,000, no mint function"
   },
   "factors": [
    {
     "evidence": "piku-token-supply-500m-s34: PIKU token 0x2E4039E8E31475d65DC00293C366FDBfBBC02DC3 (Ethereum; not a proxy: EIP-1967 implementation, admin and beacon slots all empty; verified source) …",
     "key": "upgrade",
     "label": "Upgradeability",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "Upgradeable; the delay gating the upgrade path is not in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "timelock",
     "label": "Timelock floor",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No enforced admin delay in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "quorum",
     "label": "Signer quorum",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No signer quorum in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "emergency",
     "label": "Emergency / freeze scope",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No pause / freeze authority in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "parity",
     "label": "Docs-vs-chain parity",
     "state": "g",
     "value": "Chain matches or is stronger than the documentation"
    }
   ],
   "finding": "PIKU supply: 500,000,000, no mint function",
   "grade": "aligned",
   "gradeLabel": "ALIGNED",
   "name": "Piku Finance",
   "pinnedBlock": 26453551,
   "probe": {
    "block_hash": "0x51e9967ffd6a84012d0dad44204d523b8ac43928e69de2801d2e72dbf8767129",
    "block_number": 26453551,
    "call_args": [],
    "call_signature": "totalSupply()",
    "chain": "ethereum",
    "check_type": "eth_call",
    "extra_calls": [],
    "id": "piku-token-supply-500m-s34",
    "repro_calldata": "0x18160ddd",
    "rpc_env_var": "$ETH_RPC_URL",
    "selector_or_slot": "0x18160ddd",
    "target_contract": "0x2E4039E8E31475d65DC00293C366FDBfBBC02DC3",
    "target_label": "PIKU token"
   },
   "reconciled": false,
   "reconciledFrom": [],
   "reconciledTo": [],
   "records": 1,
   "rosetteAria": "Piku Finance control-plane rosette: Upgradeability not determined; Timelock floor not determined; Signer quorum not determined; Emergency / freeze scope not determined; Docs-vs-chain parity strong",
   "search": "piku finance piku-finance yield-optimized stablecoin (usp) with institutional vaults (ethereum) piku 0x2e4039e8e31475d65dc00293c366fdbfbbc02dc3",
   "slug": "piku-finance",
   "summary_short": "PIKU's supply is 500M with no mint function, as documented",
   "url": "https://pacta.wtf/protocols/piku-finance/"
  },
  {
   "baskets": [
    "lending_vaults"
   ],
   "category": "Liquid wrappers tokenizing future yield and votes (Redacted) (Ethereum)",
   "chains": [
    "ethereum"
   ],
   "deltas": 0,
   "easAttested": false,
   "evidence": {
    "documented": "Pirex documentation is linked for reference (https://llama.airforce/pirex). This RPC-pinned record does not compare documentation parameters with the on-chain state.",
    "observed": "BTRFLY (BTRFLYV2) (0xc55126051B22eBb829D00368f4B12Bde432de5Da) verified on Ethereum Mainnet at canonical block #26,458,556 (4,729 bytes runtime code). EIP-1967 implementation and admin storage slots are both zero (non-EIP-1967 contract). No owner(), admin(), authority(), curator() or AccessControl admin was readable on the contract.",
    "recordId": "pirex-control-plane",
    "surface": "BTRFLY (BTRFLYV2) · Non-Proxy Bytecode & Controller"
   },
   "factors": [
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "upgrade",
     "label": "Upgradeability",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "Upgrade path not in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "timelock",
     "label": "Timelock floor",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No enforced admin delay in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "quorum",
     "label": "Signer quorum",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No signer quorum in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "emergency",
     "label": "Emergency / freeze scope",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No pause / freeze authority in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "parity",
     "label": "Docs-vs-chain parity",
     "state": "u",
     "value": "Uncompared: documentation not assessed (RPC-observed)"
    }
   ],
   "finding": "BTRFLY (BTRFLYV2) · Non-Proxy Bytecode & Controller",
   "grade": "observed",
   "gradeLabel": "OBSERVED",
   "name": "Pirex",
   "pinnedBlock": 26458556,
   "probe": {
    "block_hash": "0xe258bb1cbcc988e2dfdba4ba173f9f8690520dba3647cdcae18e0651822769d2",
    "block_number": 26458556,
    "call_args": [],
    "call_signature": "owner()",
    "chain": "ethereum",
    "check_type": "eth_call",
    "extra_calls": [],
    "id": "pirex-control-plane",
    "repro_calldata": "0x8da5cb5b",
    "rpc_env_var": "$ETH_RPC_URL",
    "selector_or_slot": "0x8da5cb5b",
    "target_contract": "0xc55126051B22eBb829D00368f4B12Bde432de5Da",
    "target_label": "BTRFLY (BTRFLYV2)"
   },
   "reconciled": false,
   "reconciledFrom": [],
   "reconciledTo": [],
   "records": 1,
   "rosetteAria": "Pirex control-plane rosette: Upgradeability not determined; Timelock floor not determined; Signer quorum not determined; Emergency / freeze scope not determined; Docs-vs-chain parity uncompared",
   "search": "pirex pirex liquid wrappers tokenizing future yield and votes (redacted) (ethereum) btrfly 0xc55126051b22ebb829d00368f4b12bde432de5da",
   "slug": "pirex",
   "summary_short": "Non-proxy contract no readable owner or admin; docs not assessed",
   "url": "https://pacta.wtf/protocols/pirex/"
  },
  {
   "baskets": [],
   "category": "Canonical Bridge (sidechain checkpoints) (Ethereum)",
   "chains": [
    "ethereum"
   ],
   "deltas": 2,
   "easAttested": true,
   "evidence": {
    "documented": "'4/8 Multisig 0x424bDE99FCfB68c5a1218fd3215caFfD031f19C4' (docs.polygon.technology/pos/reference/commit-chain-multisigs)",
    "observed": "Polygon custom ChildERC20 mapping Safe 0x424bDE99FCfB68c5a1218fd3215caFfD031f19C4 (Ethereum): getThreshold() = 4 of 13 owners; the multisig page lists it as a 4/8 Multisig.",
    "recordId": "polygon-bridge-mapping-safe-4of13-s30",
    "surface": "Custom ChildERC20 mapping Safe: 4-of-13 (docs: 4/8)"
   },
   "factors": [
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "upgrade",
     "label": "Upgradeability",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "Upgrade path not in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "timelock",
     "label": "Timelock floor",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No enforced admin delay in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": "controller fact: Safe getThreshold()",
     "key": "quorum",
     "label": "Signer quorum",
     "state": "g",
     "value": "Lowest controlling quorum: 4-of-13"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "emergency",
     "label": "Emergency / freeze scope",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No pause / freeze authority in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "parity",
     "label": "Docs-vs-chain parity",
     "state": "a",
     "value": "Documentation differs from the chain (parameter delta)"
    }
   ],
   "finding": "Custom ChildERC20 mapping Safe: 4-of-13 (docs: 4/8): docs say '4/8 Multisig 0x424bDE99FCfB68c5a1218fd3215caFfD031f19C4' (docs.polygon.technology/pos/reference/commit-chain-multisigs) · chain says Polygon custom ChildERC20 mapping Safe 0x424bDE99FCfB68c5a1218fd3215caFfD031f19C4 (Ethereum): getThreshold() = 4 of 13 owners;",
   "grade": "delta",
   "gradeLabel": "DELTA",
   "name": "Polygon Bridge",
   "pinnedBlock": 26449594,
   "probe": {
    "block_hash": "0xbe263d5b378dcb7c3c4e18bd8e388f0cb2dab1adacd83de2be58c9408b377287",
    "block_number": 26449594,
    "call_args": [],
    "call_signature": "getThreshold()",
    "chain": "ethereum",
    "check_type": "eth_call",
    "extra_calls": [],
    "id": "polygon-bridge-mapping-safe-4of13-s30",
    "repro_calldata": "0xe75235b8",
    "rpc_env_var": "$ETH_RPC_URL",
    "selector_or_slot": "0xe75235b8",
    "target_contract": "0x424bDE99FCfB68c5a1218fd3215caFfD031f19C4",
    "target_label": "Polygon commitchain token-mapping multisig"
   },
   "reconciled": false,
   "reconciledFrom": [],
   "reconciledTo": [],
   "records": 3,
   "rosetteAria": "Polygon Bridge control-plane rosette: Upgradeability not determined; Timelock floor not determined; Signer quorum strong; Emergency / freeze scope not determined; Docs-vs-chain parity weak",
   "search": "polygon bridge polygon-bridge canonical bridge (sidechain checkpoints) (ethereum) polygon 0x40ec5b33f54e0e8a33a975908c5ba1c14e5bbbdf 0x424bde99fcfb68c5a1218fd3215caffd031f19c4 0x8484ef722627bf18ca5ae6bcf031c23e6e922b30 0xa0c68c638235ee32657e8f720a23cec1bfc77c77 0xcaf0aa768a3ae1297df20072419db8bb8b5c8cef 0xfa7d2a996ac6350f4b56c043112da0366a59b74c",
   "slug": "polygon-bridge",
   "summary_short": "Polygon's 5-of-9 Safe can upgrade the bridge with no delay; docs say it cannot censor",
   "url": "https://pacta.wtf/protocols/polygon-bridge/"
  },
  {
   "baskets": [],
   "category": "No-loss prize savings lottery (Ethereum)",
   "chains": [
    "ethereum"
   ],
   "deltas": 0,
   "easAttested": true,
   "evidence": {
    "documented": "'The total supply of POOL tokens is 10 million' (docs.pooltogether.com/pooltogether/pool-token/pool-supply.md); '$POOL Ethereum 0x0cec1a9154ff802e7934fc916ed7ca50bde6844e' (docs.pooltogether.com/pooltogether/pool-token.md)",
    "observed": "POOL token 0x0cEC1A9154Ff802e7934Fc916Ed7Ca50bDE6844e (Ethereum; not a proxy: EIP-1967 implementation, admin and beacon slots all empty; verified source): totalSupply() = 10,000,000. The runtime code holds no selector of mint(uint256), upgradeTo(address), upgradeToAndCall(address,bytes). mint() and setMinter() both require msg.sender == minter(), and minter() is the zero address, so no further POOL can be minted and no minter can be set.",
    "recordId": "pooltogether-pool-supply-10m-no-minter-s33",
    "surface": "POOL supply: 10,000,000; minter() is the zero address"
   },
   "factors": [
    {
     "evidence": "pooltogether-pool-supply-10m-no-minter-s33: POOL token 0x0cEC1A9154Ff802e7934Fc916Ed7Ca50bDE6844e (Ethereum; not a proxy: EIP-1967 implementation, admin and beacon slots all empty; verified source) …",
     "key": "upgrade",
     "label": "Upgradeability",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "Upgradeable; the delay gating the upgrade path is not in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "timelock",
     "label": "Timelock floor",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No enforced admin delay in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "quorum",
     "label": "Signer quorum",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No signer quorum in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "emergency",
     "label": "Emergency / freeze scope",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No pause / freeze authority in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "parity",
     "label": "Docs-vs-chain parity",
     "state": "g",
     "value": "Chain matches or is stronger than the documentation"
    }
   ],
   "finding": "POOL supply: 10,000,000; minter() is the zero address",
   "grade": "aligned",
   "gradeLabel": "ALIGNED",
   "name": "PoolTogether V3",
   "pinnedBlock": 26452373,
   "probe": {
    "block_hash": "0x63bfaa16f0019d8b37e757265d351bd135ad41e6ffa46207284198917123c55d",
    "block_number": 26452373,
    "call_args": [],
    "call_signature": "totalSupply()",
    "chain": "ethereum",
    "check_type": "eth_call",
    "extra_calls": [],
    "id": "pooltogether-pool-supply-10m-no-minter-s33",
    "repro_calldata": "0x18160ddd",
    "rpc_env_var": "$ETH_RPC_URL",
    "selector_or_slot": "0x18160ddd",
    "target_contract": "0x0cEC1A9154Ff802e7934Fc916Ed7Ca50bDE6844e",
    "target_label": "POOL token"
   },
   "reconciled": false,
   "reconciledFrom": [],
   "reconciledTo": [],
   "records": 1,
   "rosetteAria": "PoolTogether V3 control-plane rosette: Upgradeability not determined; Timelock floor not determined; Signer quorum not determined; Emergency / freeze scope not determined; Docs-vs-chain parity strong",
   "search": "pooltogether v3 pooltogether-v3 no-loss prize savings lottery (ethereum) pool 0x0cec1a9154ff802e7934fc916ed7ca50bde6844e",
   "slug": "pooltogether-v3",
   "summary_short": "POOL supply is 10 million and no minter remains, as documented",
   "url": "https://pacta.wtf/protocols/pooltogether-v3/"
  },
  {
   "baskets": [],
   "category": "Zero-knowledge withdrawals with association-set compliance proofs (Ethereum)",
   "chains": [
    "ethereum"
   ],
   "deltas": 0,
   "easAttested": true,
   "evidence": {
    "documented": "'PoolVault 0x0Eb42804BF897662aF851370eaeAdcDBEC1b97ed (UUPS proxy; implementation 0x5f89cd5c3610c2ad870b1b33126d209fecdb69c7)' (docs.privacypools.com/deployments/mainnet.md)",
    "observed": "Privacy Pools V1 PoolVault proxy 0x0Eb42804BF897662aF851370eaeAdcDBEC1b97ed (Ethereum): EIP-1967 implementation slot = 0x5F89cD5c3610c2AD870B1b33126d209fECdb69c7; upgradeable (EIP-1967 implementation exposing upgradeToAndCall (UUPS)).",
    "recordId": "privacy-pools-v1-upgradeability-s27",
    "surface": "Privacy Pools V1 PoolVault proxy: upgradeable (UUPS), as documented"
   },
   "factors": [
    {
     "evidence": "privacy-pools-v1-upgradeability-s27: Privacy Pools V1 PoolVault proxy 0x0Eb42804BF897662aF851370eaeAdcDBEC1b97ed (Ethereum): EIP-1967 implementation slot = …",
     "key": "upgrade",
     "label": "Upgradeability",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "Upgradeable; the delay gating the upgrade path is not in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "timelock",
     "label": "Timelock floor",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No enforced admin delay in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "quorum",
     "label": "Signer quorum",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No signer quorum in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "emergency",
     "label": "Emergency / freeze scope",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No pause / freeze authority in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "parity",
     "label": "Docs-vs-chain parity",
     "state": "g",
     "value": "Chain matches or is stronger than the documentation"
    }
   ],
   "finding": "Privacy Pools V1 PoolVault proxy: upgradeable (UUPS), as documented",
   "grade": "aligned",
   "gradeLabel": "ALIGNED",
   "name": "Privacy Pools V1",
   "pinnedBlock": 26440048,
   "probe": {
    "block_hash": "0x2c6e70ac6ce978ce5c457208ea6d953e60e92ebf2151578f46cbdd070baa54c6",
    "block_number": 26440048,
    "call_args": [],
    "call_signature": null,
    "chain": "ethereum",
    "check_type": "eth_getStorageAt",
    "extra_calls": [],
    "id": "privacy-pools-v1-upgradeability-s27",
    "repro_calldata": null,
    "rpc_env_var": "$ETH_RPC_URL",
    "selector_or_slot": "0x360894a13ba1a3210667c828492db98dca3e2076cc3735a920a3ca505d382bbc",
    "target_contract": "0x0Eb42804BF897662aF851370eaeAdcDBEC1b97ed",
    "target_label": "Privacy Pools V1 PoolVault proxy"
   },
   "reconciled": false,
   "reconciledFrom": [],
   "reconciledTo": [],
   "records": 1,
   "rosetteAria": "Privacy Pools V1 control-plane rosette: Upgradeability not determined; Timelock floor not determined; Signer quorum not determined; Emergency / freeze scope not determined; Docs-vs-chain parity strong",
   "search": "privacy pools v1 privacy-pools-v1 zero-knowledge withdrawals with association-set compliance proofs (ethereum) privacy 0x0eb42804bf897662af851370eaeadcdbec1b97ed 0x5f89cd5c3610c2ad870b1b33126d209fecdb69c7",
   "slug": "privacy-pools-v1",
   "summary_short": "The Privacy Pools V1 PoolVault proxy is upgradeable (UUPS), as its docs state",
   "url": "https://pacta.wtf/protocols/privacy-pools-v1/"
  },
  {
   "baskets": [
    "eth_lst_lrt"
   ],
   "category": "Native Liquid Restaking",
   "chains": [
    "ethereum"
   ],
   "deltas": 1,
   "easAttested": true,
   "evidence": {
    "documented": "docs.puffer.fi (multisig): 'Puffer's Community Multisig is a 3-of-6 multisig composed of reputable and aligned Ethereum community members and auditing firms.'",
    "observed": "Safe 0x446d4d6b26815f9bA78B5D454E303315D586Cb2a (= Timelock COMMUNITY_MULTISIG()): getThreshold() = 3 with 7 owners (v1.3.0); holds AccessManager role 1 (upgrader) with execution delay 0.",
    "recordId": "puffer-community-multisig-3of7-s20",
    "surface": "Community Multisig threshold: 3-of-7"
   },
   "factors": [
    {
     "evidence": "puffer-7d-timelock-delay-s20: ACCESS_MANAGER() = 0x8c1686069474410E6243425f4a10177a94EBEE11, the authority() of PufferVault 0xD9A442856C234a39a81a089C06451EBAa4306a72, where upgradeToAndCall …",
     "key": "upgrade",
     "label": "Upgradeability",
     "state": "g",
     "value": "Upgradeable behind a ≥48h delay (168h)"
    },
    {
     "evidence": "puffer-7d-timelock-delay-s20: ACCESS_MANAGER() = 0x8c1686069474410E6243425f4a10177a94EBEE11, the authority() of PufferVault 0xD9A442856C234a39a81a089C06451EBAa4306a72, where upgradeToAndCall …",
     "key": "timelock",
     "label": "Timelock floor",
     "state": "g",
     "value": "168h minimum enforced delay across control surfaces"
    },
    {
     "evidence": "controller fact: Safe getThreshold()",
     "key": "quorum",
     "label": "Signer quorum",
     "state": "g",
     "value": "Lowest controlling quorum: 3-of-6"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "emergency",
     "label": "Emergency / freeze scope",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No pause / freeze authority in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "parity",
     "label": "Docs-vs-chain parity",
     "state": "a",
     "value": "Documentation differs from the chain (parameter delta)"
    }
   ],
   "finding": "Community Multisig threshold: 3-of-7: docs say docs.puffer.fi (multisig): 'Puffer's Community Multisig is a 3-of-6 multisig composed of reputable and aligned Ethereum community members and auditing firms.' · chain says Safe 0x446d4d6b26815f9bA78B5D454E303315D586Cb2a (= Timelock COMMUNITY_MULTISIG()): getThreshold() = 3 with 7 owners (v1.3.0);",
   "grade": "delta",
   "gradeLabel": "DELTA",
   "name": "Puffer Finance (pufETH)",
   "pinnedBlock": 26425374,
   "probe": {
    "block_hash": "0xfa22e277760f1df7134b0af20499d6305ee4e017219a917a61a78aa76e89382d",
    "block_number": 26425374,
    "call_args": [],
    "call_signature": "getThreshold()",
    "chain": "ethereum",
    "check_type": "eth_call",
    "extra_calls": [],
    "id": "puffer-community-multisig-3of7-s20",
    "repro_calldata": "0xe75235b8",
    "rpc_env_var": "$ETH_RPC_URL",
    "selector_or_slot": "0xe75235b8",
    "target_contract": "0x446d4d6b26815f9bA78B5D454E303315D586Cb2a",
    "target_label": "Puffer Community Multisig (upgrader role)"
   },
   "reconciled": false,
   "reconciledFrom": [],
   "reconciledTo": [],
   "records": 3,
   "rosetteAria": "Puffer Finance (pufETH) control-plane rosette: Upgradeability strong; Timelock floor strong; Signer quorum strong; Emergency / freeze scope not determined; Docs-vs-chain parity weak",
   "search": "puffer finance (pufeth) puffer-finance-pufeth native liquid restaking pufeth puffer 0x3c28b7c7ba1a1f55c9ce66b263b33b204f2126ea 0x446d4d6b26815f9ba78b5d454e303315d586cb2a 0x8c1686069474410e6243425f4a10177a94ebee11 0xc0896ab1a8cae8c2c1d27d011eb955cca955580d 0xd9a442856c234a39a81a089c06451ebaa4306a72",
   "slug": "puffer-finance-pufeth",
   "summary_short": "Community multisig: docs 3-of-6 · chain 3-of-7",
   "url": "https://pacta.wtf/protocols/puffer-finance-pufeth/"
  },
  {
   "baskets": [],
   "category": "CryptoPunks trading terminal with trait-filtered Merkle bids (Ethereum)",
   "chains": [
    "ethereum"
   ],
   "deltas": 0,
   "easAttested": false,
   "evidence": {
    "documented": "Punks Terminal documentation is linked for reference (https://lightyear.build/). This RPC-pinned record does not compare documentation parameters with the on-chain state.",
    "observed": "StashFactory (0x000000000000A6fA31F5fC51c1640aAc76866750) verified on Ethereum Mainnet at canonical block #26,458,556 (3,974 bytes runtime code). EIP-1967 implementation and admin storage slots are both zero (non-EIP-1967 contract). Direct owner() returns contract contract 0xb07603da6B63C936566F0A29856FbD52829b4605. That controller is in turn controlled by externally owned account (no code) 0x83Ea85356358411Ce320e1909Cc75DBd216d6182.",
    "recordId": "punks-terminal-control-plane",
    "surface": "StashFactory · Non-Proxy Bytecode & Controller"
   },
   "factors": [
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "upgrade",
     "label": "Upgradeability",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "Upgrade path not in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "timelock",
     "label": "Timelock floor",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No enforced admin delay in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": "punks-terminal-control-plane: … controller is in turn controlled by externally owned account (no code) 0x83Ea85356358411Ce320e1909Cc75DBd216d6182.",
     "key": "quorum",
     "label": "Signer quorum",
     "state": "a",
     "value": "Lowest controlling quorum: a single key"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "emergency",
     "label": "Emergency / freeze scope",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No pause / freeze authority in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "parity",
     "label": "Docs-vs-chain parity",
     "state": "u",
     "value": "Uncompared: documentation not assessed (RPC-observed)"
    }
   ],
   "finding": "StashFactory · Non-Proxy Bytecode & Controller",
   "grade": "observed",
   "gradeLabel": "OBSERVED",
   "name": "Punks Terminal",
   "pinnedBlock": 26458556,
   "probe": {
    "block_hash": "0xe258bb1cbcc988e2dfdba4ba173f9f8690520dba3647cdcae18e0651822769d2",
    "block_number": 26458556,
    "call_args": [],
    "call_signature": "owner()",
    "chain": "ethereum",
    "check_type": "eth_call",
    "extra_calls": [],
    "id": "punks-terminal-control-plane",
    "repro_calldata": "0x8da5cb5b",
    "rpc_env_var": "$ETH_RPC_URL",
    "selector_or_slot": "0x8da5cb5b",
    "target_contract": "0x000000000000A6fA31F5fC51c1640aAc76866750",
    "target_label": "StashFactory"
   },
   "reconciled": false,
   "reconciledFrom": [],
   "reconciledTo": [],
   "records": 1,
   "rosetteAria": "Punks Terminal control-plane rosette: Upgradeability not determined; Timelock floor not determined; Signer quorum weak; Emergency / freeze scope not determined; Docs-vs-chain parity uncompared",
   "search": "punks terminal punks-terminal cryptopunks trading terminal with trait-filtered merkle bids (ethereum) punks 0x000000000000a6fa31f5fc51c1640aac76866750 0x83ea85356358411ce320e1909cc75dbd216d6182 0xb07603da6b63c936566f0a29856fbd52829b4605",
   "slug": "punks-terminal",
   "summary_short": "Non-proxy contract controlled by a contract; docs not assessed",
   "url": "https://pacta.wtf/protocols/punks-terminal/"
  },
  {
   "baskets": [
    "base"
   ],
   "category": "Algebra-powered pools with dynamic fees and customizable plugins (Base)",
   "chains": [
    "base"
   ],
   "deltas": 0,
   "easAttested": false,
   "evidence": {
    "documented": "Quickswap V4 documentation is linked for reference (https://dapp.quickswap.exchange/docs). This RPC-pinned record does not compare documentation parameters with the on-chain state.",
    "observed": "AlgebraFactory (0xC5396866754799B9720125B104AE01d935Ab9C7b) verified on Base Mainnet at canonical block #60,070,202 (10,699 bytes runtime code). EIP-1967 implementation and admin storage slots are both zero (non-EIP-1967 contract). Direct owner() returns Safe 3-of-5 0xDA1077c4b0dd6da1BDF166F30aa4BDbF517d637b.",
    "recordId": "quickswap-v4-control-plane",
    "surface": "AlgebraFactory · Non-Proxy Bytecode & Controller"
   },
   "factors": [
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "upgrade",
     "label": "Upgradeability",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "Upgrade path not in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "timelock",
     "label": "Timelock floor",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No enforced admin delay in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": "quickswap-v4-control-plane: … contract). Direct owner() returns Safe 3-of-5 0xDA1077c4b0dd6da1BDF166F30aa4BDbF517d637b.",
     "key": "quorum",
     "label": "Signer quorum",
     "state": "g",
     "value": "Lowest controlling quorum: 3-of-5"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "emergency",
     "label": "Emergency / freeze scope",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No pause / freeze authority in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "parity",
     "label": "Docs-vs-chain parity",
     "state": "u",
     "value": "Uncompared: documentation not assessed (RPC-observed)"
    }
   ],
   "finding": "AlgebraFactory · Non-Proxy Bytecode & Controller",
   "grade": "observed",
   "gradeLabel": "OBSERVED",
   "name": "Quickswap V4",
   "pinnedBlock": 60070202,
   "probe": {
    "block_hash": "0x01b3f5dcecb67c63ba33350ec6942563f6b8a0d8ca9b4f69a752844a5bab4a20",
    "block_number": 60070202,
    "call_args": [],
    "call_signature": "owner()",
    "chain": "base",
    "check_type": "eth_call",
    "extra_calls": [],
    "id": "quickswap-v4-control-plane",
    "repro_calldata": "0x8da5cb5b",
    "rpc_env_var": "$BASE_RPC_URL",
    "selector_or_slot": "0x8da5cb5b",
    "target_contract": "0xC5396866754799B9720125B104AE01d935Ab9C7b",
    "target_label": "AlgebraFactory"
   },
   "reconciled": false,
   "reconciledFrom": [],
   "reconciledTo": [],
   "records": 1,
   "rosetteAria": "Quickswap V4 control-plane rosette: Upgradeability not determined; Timelock floor not determined; Signer quorum strong; Emergency / freeze scope not determined; Docs-vs-chain parity uncompared",
   "search": "quickswap v4 quickswap-v4 algebra-powered pools with dynamic fees and customizable plugins (base) quickswap 0xc5396866754799b9720125b104ae01d935ab9c7b 0xda1077c4b0dd6da1bdf166f30aa4bdbf517d637b",
   "slug": "quickswap-v4",
   "summary_short": "Non-proxy contract controlled by a 3-of-5 Safe; docs not assessed",
   "url": "https://pacta.wtf/protocols/quickswap-v4/"
  },
  {
   "baskets": [],
   "category": "Zero-Knowledge Privacy Pool (Shielded Wallet)",
   "chains": [
    "ethereum"
   ],
   "deltas": 0,
   "easAttested": true,
   "evidence": {
    "documented": "docs.railgun.org (deductions / helpful links): 'The smart contracts take a 0.25% deduction per shield and unshield interaction which is then sent to the “treasury address”.' / 'Protocol deductions (0.25% on shield and unshield interactions) are sent directly on-chain to the treasury contract for that network.'",
    "observed": "RailgunSmartWallet 0xFA7093CDD9EE6932B4eb2c9e1cde7CE00B1FA4b9: shieldFee() = 25 and unshieldFee() = 25 basis points (of 10000); treasury() = 0xE8A8B458BcD1Ececc6b6b58F80929b29cCecFF40.",
    "recordId": "railgun-fees-shield-unshield-s25",
    "surface": "Shield and unshield fees: 0.25% each"
   },
   "factors": [
    {
     "evidence": "railgun-upgrade-admin-s25: RailgunSmartWallet 0xFA7093CDD9EE6932B4eb2c9e1cde7CE00B1FA4b9: EIP-1967 admin = ProxyAdmin 0x4F8E20f55f879beE7Bc010Bd6bD2138B34aC65c8, owner() = Delegator …",
     "key": "upgrade",
     "label": "Upgradeability",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "Upgradeable; the delay gating the upgrade path is not in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "timelock",
     "label": "Timelock floor",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No enforced admin delay in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "quorum",
     "label": "Signer quorum",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No signer quorum in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "emergency",
     "label": "Emergency / freeze scope",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No pause / freeze authority in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "parity",
     "label": "Docs-vs-chain parity",
     "state": "g",
     "value": "Chain matches or is stronger than the documentation"
    }
   ],
   "finding": "Shield and unshield fees: 0.25% each",
   "grade": "aligned",
   "gradeLabel": "ALIGNED",
   "name": "RAILGUN",
   "pinnedBlock": 26434786,
   "probe": {
    "block_hash": "0xb712439847099ec3e8b1617aafd1bc7ece29e22a88dc4e7c8afcf05e6944d987",
    "block_number": 26434786,
    "call_args": [],
    "call_signature": "shieldFee()",
    "chain": "ethereum",
    "check_type": "eth_call",
    "extra_calls": [],
    "id": "railgun-fees-shield-unshield-s25",
    "repro_calldata": "0x01c37790",
    "rpc_env_var": "$ETH_RPC_URL",
    "selector_or_slot": "0x01c37790",
    "target_contract": "0xFA7093CDD9EE6932B4eb2c9e1cde7CE00B1FA4b9",
    "target_label": "RailgunSmartWallet (proxy)"
   },
   "reconciled": false,
   "reconciledFrom": [],
   "reconciledTo": [],
   "records": 4,
   "rosetteAria": "RAILGUN control-plane rosette: Upgradeability not determined; Timelock floor not determined; Signer quorum not determined; Emergency / freeze scope not determined; Docs-vs-chain parity strong",
   "search": "railgun railgun zero-knowledge privacy pool (shielded wallet) rail railgun 0x4f8e20f55f879bee7bc010bd6bd2138b34ac65c8 0xb6d513f6222ee92fff975e901bd792e2513fb53b 0xc480f68a3dcc3edd82134fab45c14a0fcf1da3cc 0xe8a8b458bcd1ececc6b6b58f80929b29ccecff40 0xfa7093cdd9ee6932b4eb2c9e1cde7ce00b1fa4b9",
   "slug": "railgun",
   "summary_short": "0.25% shield fees; upgrades and pauses only via the on-chain protocol vote, as documented",
   "url": "https://pacta.wtf/protocols/railgun/"
  },
  {
   "baskets": [
    "stable_rwa"
   ],
   "category": "Reinsurance-Backed Stablecoin",
   "chains": [
    "ethereum"
   ],
   "deltas": 0,
   "easAttested": true,
   "evidence": {
    "documented": "docs.re.xyz (ICL permissions note): 'The Safe holds DEFAULT_ADMIN_ROLE on every ICL (Ethereum reUSD and reUSDe, Avalanche, Arbitrum, Base), alongside the chain's timelock.' and '... so the Safe can grant itself ICL UPGRADER_ROLE with no delay'",
    "observed": "ICL 0x4691C475bE804Fa85f91c2D6D0aDf03114de3093 (shareToken() = reUSD): hasRole(DEFAULT_ADMIN_ROLE, Safe 0x8eec10616802Ef639CA55c98ac856553fAdEfBaD) = false; the Timelock 0x69dDEa332723cF5407151aAF68B9b076557FCA93 holds DEFAULT_ADMIN_ROLE and UPGRADER_ROLE; getRoleAdmin(UPGRADER_ROLE) = DEFAULT_ADMIN_ROLE, so granting UPGRADER_ROLE on this ICL waits the 48-hour delay.",
    "recordId": "re-icl-admin-timelock-not-safe-s21",
    "surface": "Deposit vault role admin held behind the delay; multisig lacks it"
   },
   "factors": [
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "upgrade",
     "label": "Upgradeability",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "Upgrade path not in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": "controller fact: getMinDelay() = 172800s",
     "key": "timelock",
     "label": "Timelock floor",
     "state": "g",
     "value": "2d minimum enforced delay across control surfaces"
    },
    {
     "evidence": "re-safe-sole-timelock-proposer-s21: … timelock is its own admin; the Safe is 3-of-5 (v1.4.1, no modules).",
     "key": "quorum",
     "label": "Signer quorum",
     "state": "g",
     "value": "Lowest controlling quorum: 3-of-5"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "emergency",
     "label": "Emergency / freeze scope",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No pause / freeze authority in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "parity",
     "label": "Docs-vs-chain parity",
     "state": "g",
     "value": "Chain matches or is stronger than the documentation"
    }
   ],
   "finding": "Deposit vault role admin held behind the delay; multisig lacks it: docs say docs.re.xyz (ICL permissions note): 'The Safe holds DEFAULT_ADMIN_ROLE on every ICL (Ethereum reUSD and reUSDe, Avalanche, Arbitrum, Base), alongside the chain's timelock.' and '... · chain says ICL 0x4691C475bE804Fa85f91c2D6D0aDf03114de3093 (shareToken() = reUSD): hasRole(DEFAULT_ADMIN_ROLE, Safe 0x8eec10616802Ef639CA55c98ac856553fAdEfBaD) = false;",
   "grade": "protective",
   "gradeLabel": "PROTECTIVE",
   "name": "Re Protocol (reUSD / reUSDe)",
   "pinnedBlock": 26427612,
   "probe": {
    "block_hash": "0x1c5ef52eb0b586e49da2a11dc9f905cae4125008dc814d6781f53a142f6555ac",
    "block_number": 26427612,
    "call_args": [
     "0x0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000",
     "0x69dDEa332723cF5407151aAF68B9b076557FCA93"
    ],
    "call_signature": "hasRole(bytes32,address)",
    "chain": "ethereum",
    "check_type": "eth_call",
    "extra_calls": [],
    "id": "re-48h-timelock-token-admin-s21",
    "repro_calldata": "0x91d14854000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000069ddea332723cf5407151aaf68b9b076557fca93",
    "rpc_env_var": "$ETH_RPC_URL",
    "selector_or_slot": "0x91d14854",
    "target_contract": "0x5086bf358635B81D8C47C66d1C8b9E567Db70c72",
    "target_label": "reUSD senior-tranche stablecoin token"
   },
   "reconciled": false,
   "reconciledFrom": [],
   "reconciledTo": [],
   "records": 3,
   "rosetteAria": "Re Protocol (reUSD / reUSDe) control-plane rosette: Upgradeability not determined; Timelock floor strong; Signer quorum strong; Emergency / freeze scope not determined; Docs-vs-chain parity strong",
   "search": "re protocol (reusd / reusde) re reinsurance-backed stablecoin reusd reusde re 0x4691c475be804fa85f91c2d6d0adf03114de3093 0x5086bf358635b81d8c47c66d1c8b9e567db70c72 0x69ddea332723cf5407151aaf68b9b076557fca93 0x8eec10616802ef639ca55c98ac856553fadefbad 0xddc0f880ff6e4e22e4b74632fbb43ce4df6ccc5a",
   "slug": "re",
   "summary_short": "Vault admin role sits only behind the timelock; docs say the Safe holds it too",
   "url": "https://pacta.wtf/protocols/re/"
  },
  {
   "baskets": [
    "stable_rwa"
   ],
   "category": "Non-pegged stable asset (RAI) issued against ETH collateral (Ethereum)",
   "chains": [
    "ethereum"
   ],
   "deltas": 0,
   "easAttested": false,
   "evidence": {
    "documented": "Reflexer documentation is linked for reference (https://docs.reflexer.finance/). This RPC-pinned record does not compare documentation parameters with the on-chain state.",
    "observed": "Flex Ungovernance Token (DSDelegateToken) (0x6243d8CEA23066d098a15582d81a598b4e8391F4) verified on Ethereum Mainnet at canonical block #26,458,556 (15,011 bytes runtime code). EIP-1967 implementation and admin storage slots are both zero (non-EIP-1967 contract). Direct authority() returns contract ProtocolTokenAuthority 0xcb8479840A5576B1cafBb3FA7276e04Df122FDc7.",
    "recordId": "reflexer-control-plane",
    "surface": "Flex Ungovernance Token (DSDelegateToken) · Non-Proxy Bytecode & Controller"
   },
   "factors": [
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "upgrade",
     "label": "Upgradeability",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "Upgrade path not in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "timelock",
     "label": "Timelock floor",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No enforced admin delay in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "quorum",
     "label": "Signer quorum",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No signer quorum in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "emergency",
     "label": "Emergency / freeze scope",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No pause / freeze authority in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "parity",
     "label": "Docs-vs-chain parity",
     "state": "u",
     "value": "Uncompared: documentation not assessed (RPC-observed)"
    }
   ],
   "finding": "Flex Ungovernance Token (DSDelegateToken) · Non-Proxy Bytecode & Controller",
   "grade": "observed",
   "gradeLabel": "OBSERVED",
   "name": "Reflexer",
   "pinnedBlock": 26458556,
   "probe": {
    "block_hash": "0xe258bb1cbcc988e2dfdba4ba173f9f8690520dba3647cdcae18e0651822769d2",
    "block_number": 26458556,
    "call_args": [],
    "call_signature": "authority()",
    "chain": "ethereum",
    "check_type": "eth_call",
    "extra_calls": [],
    "id": "reflexer-control-plane",
    "repro_calldata": "0xbf7e214f",
    "rpc_env_var": "$ETH_RPC_URL",
    "selector_or_slot": "0xbf7e214f",
    "target_contract": "0x6243d8CEA23066d098a15582d81a598b4e8391F4",
    "target_label": "Flex Ungovernance Token (DSDelegateToken)"
   },
   "reconciled": false,
   "reconciledFrom": [],
   "reconciledTo": [],
   "records": 1,
   "rosetteAria": "Reflexer control-plane rosette: Upgradeability not determined; Timelock floor not determined; Signer quorum not determined; Emergency / freeze scope not determined; Docs-vs-chain parity uncompared",
   "search": "reflexer reflexer non-pegged stable asset (rai) issued against eth collateral (ethereum) flx 0x6243d8cea23066d098a15582d81a598b4e8391f4 0xcb8479840a5576b1cafbb3fa7276e04df122fdc7",
   "slug": "reflexer",
   "summary_short": "Non-proxy contract controlled by a contract; docs not assessed",
   "url": "https://pacta.wtf/protocols/reflexer/"
  },
  {
   "baskets": [
    "eth_lst_lrt"
   ],
   "category": "Liquid Restaking",
   "chains": [
    "ethereum"
   ],
   "deltas": 2,
   "easAttested": true,
   "evidence": {
    "documented": "docs.renzoprotocol.com/docs/products/staking-suite/ezeth states 10% fee on restaking rewards.",
    "observed": "feeBasisPoints() = 1500 (15%); Admin Multisig (0xD1e6626310fD54Eceb5b9a51dA2eC329D6D4B68A) is 3-of-5 Gnosis Safe; ezETH (0xbf5495Efe5DB9ce00f80364C8B423567e58d2110) totalSupply = 39,495.32 ezETH.",
    "recordId": "renzo-ezeth-deposit-queue-fee",
    "surface": "DepositQueue.feeBasisPoints Parameter vs. Staking Docs"
   },
   "factors": [
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "upgrade",
     "label": "Upgradeability",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "Upgrade path not in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "timelock",
     "label": "Timelock floor",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No enforced admin delay in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": "renzo-ezeth-deposit-queue-fee: … (0xD1e6626310fD54Eceb5b9a51dA2eC329D6D4B68A) is 3-of-5 Gnosis Safe; ezETH (0xbf5495Efe5DB9ce00f80364C8B423567e58d2110) …",
     "key": "quorum",
     "label": "Signer quorum",
     "state": "g",
     "value": "Lowest controlling quorum: 3-of-5"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "emergency",
     "label": "Emergency / freeze scope",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No pause / freeze authority in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "parity",
     "label": "Docs-vs-chain parity",
     "state": "a",
     "value": "Documentation differs from the chain (parameter delta)"
    }
   ],
   "finding": "DepositQueue.feeBasisPoints Parameter vs. Staking Docs: docs say docs.renzoprotocol.com/docs/products/staking-suite/ezeth states 10% fee on restaking rewards. · chain says feeBasisPoints() = 1500 (15%);",
   "grade": "delta",
   "gradeLabel": "DELTA",
   "name": "Renzo Protocol (ezETH)",
   "pinnedBlock": 26448221,
   "probe": {
    "block_hash": "0xec3820f0a9db32c01728e66f78dc1958e410269e1077fd1db53df4fbce2ad7a1",
    "block_number": 26401725,
    "call_args": [],
    "call_signature": "feeBasisPoints()",
    "chain": "ethereum",
    "check_type": "eth_call",
    "extra_calls": [],
    "id": "renzo-ezeth-deposit-queue-fee",
    "repro_calldata": "0xb8606eef",
    "rpc_env_var": "$ETH_RPC_URL",
    "selector_or_slot": "0xb8606eef",
    "target_contract": "0xf2F305D14DCD8aaef887E0428B3c9534795D0d60",
    "target_label": "DepositQueue"
   },
   "reconciled": false,
   "reconciledFrom": [],
   "reconciledTo": [],
   "records": 2,
   "rosetteAria": "Renzo Protocol (ezETH) control-plane rosette: Upgradeability not determined; Timelock floor not determined; Signer quorum strong; Emergency / freeze scope not determined; Docs-vs-chain parity weak",
   "search": "renzo protocol (ezeth) renzo-protocol-ezeth liquid restaking ezeth rez 0x10586b9b7ff0f842913a57539f8167ce143c3011 0x24aa958c90b7973dc16c63c9992f69e1767377ae 0xbf5495efe5db9ce00f80364c8b423567e58d2110 0xd1e6626310fd54eceb5b9a51da2ec329d6d4b68a 0xf2f305d14dcd8aaef887e0428b3c9534795d0d60",
   "slug": "renzo-protocol-ezeth",
   "summary_short": "Docs state a 10% reward fee; feeBasisPoints() now reads 10,000 (100%), up from 1,500",
   "url": "https://pacta.wtf/protocols/renzo-protocol-ezeth/"
  },
  {
   "baskets": [],
   "category": "Asset-Backed RToken Infrastructure",
   "chains": [
    "ethereum"
   ],
   "deltas": 0,
   "easAttested": true,
   "evidence": {
    "documented": "docs.reserve.org (Yield DTF advanced parameters): 'Long freeze duration (s) The number of seconds a long freeze lasts. Long freezes can be disabled by removing all addresses associated with the role. Default value: 604800 = 1 week'",
    "observed": "eUSD Main 0x7697aE4dEf3C3Cd52493Ba3a6F57fc6d8c59108a (eUSD 0xA0d69E286B938e21CBf7E51D71F6A4c8918f482F.main()): longFreeze() = 604800s (1 week); frozen() = false.",
    "recordId": "reserve-eusd-long-freeze-1-week-s23",
    "surface": "Long freeze: 1 week, the documented default"
   },
   "factors": [
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "upgrade",
     "label": "Upgradeability",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "Upgrade path not in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "timelock",
     "label": "Timelock floor",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No enforced admin delay in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "quorum",
     "label": "Signer quorum",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No signer quorum in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "emergency",
     "label": "Emergency / freeze scope",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No pause / freeze authority in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "parity",
     "label": "Docs-vs-chain parity",
     "state": "g",
     "value": "Chain matches or is stronger than the documentation"
    }
   ],
   "finding": "Long freeze: 1 week, the documented default",
   "grade": "aligned",
   "gradeLabel": "ALIGNED",
   "name": "Reserve Protocol (eUSD RToken)",
   "pinnedBlock": 26431152,
   "probe": {
    "block_hash": "0xfe2ed4e127f30bb42dd30c6fc1460a82d8438cff3a717ec89210805e55199a46",
    "block_number": 26431152,
    "call_args": [],
    "call_signature": "longFreeze()",
    "chain": "ethereum",
    "check_type": "eth_call",
    "extra_calls": [],
    "id": "reserve-eusd-long-freeze-1-week-s23",
    "repro_calldata": "0xf8aa0c4e",
    "rpc_env_var": "$ETH_RPC_URL",
    "selector_or_slot": "0xf8aa0c4e",
    "target_contract": "0x7697aE4dEf3C3Cd52493Ba3a6F57fc6d8c59108a",
    "target_label": "Reserve eUSD Main"
   },
   "reconciled": false,
   "reconciledFrom": [],
   "reconciledTo": [],
   "records": 3,
   "rosetteAria": "Reserve Protocol (eUSD RToken) control-plane rosette: Upgradeability not determined; Timelock floor not determined; Signer quorum not determined; Emergency / freeze scope not determined; Docs-vs-chain parity strong",
   "search": "reserve protocol (eusd rtoken) reserve-protocol-rtoken asset-backed rtoken infrastructure eusd rsr 0x18ba6e33ceb80f077deb9260c9111e62f21ae7b8 0x7697ae4def3c3cd52493ba3a6f57fc6d8c59108a 0xa0d69e286b938e21cbf7e51d71f6a4c8918f482f",
   "slug": "reserve-protocol-rtoken",
   "summary_short": "Long freeze is 1 week, the documented default",
   "url": "https://pacta.wtf/protocols/reserve-protocol-rtoken/"
  },
  {
   "baskets": [
    "stable_rwa"
   ],
   "category": "Delta-Neutral Synthetic Dollar",
   "chains": [
    "ethereum"
   ],
   "deltas": 0,
   "easAttested": true,
   "evidence": {
    "documented": "docs.resolv.xyz/litepaper/for-developers/smart-contracts.md core token and external request manager deployment registry.",
    "observed": "Sampled USR (0x66a1E37c9b0eAddca17d3662D6c05F4DECf3e110) defaultAdmin() = 4-of-6 Core Safe (0xD6889F307BE1b83Bb355d5DA7d4478FB0d2Af547) with defaultAdminDelay() = 86400s (1 day); sampled UsrExternalRequestsManager (0xa27a69Ae180e202fDe5D38189a3F24Fe24E55861) and RlpExternalRequestsManager (0xc7AB90c2Ea9271EFB31f5fA2843Eeb4B331eaFA0) return paused() = true; USR totalSupply = 6,085,929.53 USR, RLP (0x4956b52aE2fF65D74CA2d61207523288e4528f96) totalSupply = 1,592,731.62 RLP.",
    "recordId": "resolv-usr-default-admin-delay-and-safe",
    "surface": "Sampled USR AccessControlDefaultAdminRules Delay & Request Counters"
   },
   "factors": [
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "upgrade",
     "label": "Upgradeability",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "Upgrade path not in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": "resolv-usr-default-admin-delay-and-safe: observed_delay_seconds = 86400",
     "key": "timelock",
     "label": "Timelock floor",
     "state": "b",
     "value": "1d minimum enforced delay across control surfaces"
    },
    {
     "evidence": "resolv-usr-default-admin-delay-and-safe: … (0x66a1E37c9b0eAddca17d3662D6c05F4DECf3e110) defaultAdmin() = 4-of-6 Core Safe (0xD6889F307BE1b83Bb355d5DA7d4478FB0d2Af547) …",
     "key": "quorum",
     "label": "Signer quorum",
     "state": "g",
     "value": "Lowest controlling quorum: 4-of-6"
    },
    {
     "evidence": "resolv-usr-default-admin-delay-and-safe: sampled UsrExternalRequestsManager (0xa27a69Ae180e202fDe5D38189a3F24Fe24E55861) and RlpExternalRequestsManager (0xc7AB90c2Ea9271EFB31f5fA2843Eeb4B331eaFA0) …",
     "key": "emergency",
     "label": "Emergency / freeze scope",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "Pause / freeze authority present; its holder is not determined"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "parity",
     "label": "Docs-vs-chain parity",
     "state": "g",
     "value": "Chain matches or is stronger than the documentation"
    }
   ],
   "finding": "Sampled USR AccessControlDefaultAdminRules Delay & Request Counters",
   "grade": "aligned",
   "gradeLabel": "ALIGNED",
   "name": "Resolv (USR / RLP)",
   "pinnedBlock": 26449594,
   "probe": {
    "block_hash": "0xfc7beaa2338e8054577c0b101b641bc42afca2af39cb85d3fc13cbee32d4681a",
    "block_number": 26403523,
    "call_args": [],
    "call_signature": "defaultAdminDelay()",
    "chain": "ethereum",
    "check_type": "eth_call",
    "extra_calls": [],
    "id": "resolv-usr-default-admin-delay-and-safe",
    "repro_calldata": "0xcc8463c8",
    "rpc_env_var": "$ETH_RPC_URL",
    "selector_or_slot": "0xcc8463c8",
    "target_contract": "0x66a1E37c9b0eAddca17d3662D6c05F4DECf3e110",
    "target_label": "Resolv USR Token"
   },
   "reconciled": false,
   "reconciledFrom": [],
   "reconciledTo": [],
   "records": 2,
   "rosetteAria": "Resolv (USR / RLP) control-plane rosette: Upgradeability not determined; Timelock floor moderate; Signer quorum strong; Emergency / freeze scope not determined; Docs-vs-chain parity strong",
   "search": "resolv (usr / rlp) resolv-usr-rlp delta-neutral synthetic dollar usr rlp wstusr resolv 0x15cad41e6bdcadc7121ce65080489c92cf6de398 0x4956b52ae2ff65d74ca2d61207523288e4528f96 0x66a1e37c9b0eaddca17d3662d6c05f4decf3e110 0xa27a69ae180e202fde5d38189a3f24fe24e55861 0xc7ab90c2ea9271efb31f5fa2843eeb4b331eafa0 0xd6889f307be1b83bb355d5da7d4478fb0d2af547",
   "slug": "resolv-usr-rlp",
   "summary_short": "USR admin-rules delay and request counters match the docs",
   "url": "https://pacta.wtf/protocols/resolv-usr-rlp/"
  },
  {
   "baskets": [
    "lending_vaults",
    "stable_rwa"
   ],
   "category": "CDP Stablecoin (reUSD) & Lending Markets",
   "chains": [
    "ethereum"
   ],
   "deltas": 1,
   "easAttested": true,
   "evidence": {
    "documented": "docs.resupply.finance (multisig and admin permissions): 'Multisig Members (3 of 4)' / contract addresses: 'Multisig (3-of-4) | `0xFE11a5009f2121622271e7dd0FD470264e076af6`'",
    "observed": "Main Multisig 0xFE11a5009f2121622271e7dd0FD470264e076af6: 3-of-5 (getThreshold() = 3, getOwners() = 5 owners; Safe v1.4.1, no modules).",
    "recordId": "resupply-main-multisig-3of5-s22",
    "surface": "Main multisig: 3-of-5 signers"
   },
   "factors": [
    {
     "evidence": "resupply-guardian-role-main-multisig-s22: ERC-1967 proxy with implementation GuardianUpgradeable 0x74C85620F1459862834A947dB9441911BCEBF066 (Sourcify match). The Treasury Manager operator proxy …",
     "key": "upgrade",
     "label": "Upgradeability",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "Upgradeable; the delay gating the upgrade path is not in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": "resupply-core-voter-execution-delay-1d-s22: observed_delay_seconds = 86400",
     "key": "timelock",
     "label": "Timelock floor",
     "state": "b",
     "value": "1d minimum enforced delay across control surfaces"
    },
    {
     "evidence": "resupply-main-multisig-3of5-s22: … 0xFE11a5009f2121622271e7dd0FD470264e076af6: 3-of-5 (getThreshold() = 3, getOwners() = …",
     "key": "quorum",
     "label": "Signer quorum",
     "state": "g",
     "value": "Lowest controlling quorum: 3-of-5"
    },
    {
     "evidence": "resupply-guardian-role-main-multisig-s22: Guardian operator proxy 0xA4745e0B1F40ab3DCFD98F381835De591a8974E3: guardian() = Main Multisig 0xFE11a5009f2121622271e7dd0FD470264e076af6",
     "key": "emergency",
     "label": "Emergency / freeze scope",
     "state": "g",
     "value": "Pause / freeze authority scoped behind a multi-signer controller (3-of-N Safe)"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "parity",
     "label": "Docs-vs-chain parity",
     "state": "a",
     "value": "Documentation differs from the chain (parameter delta)"
    }
   ],
   "finding": "Safe threshold: docs say 3-of-4 · chain says 3-of-5",
   "grade": "delta",
   "gradeLabel": "DELTA",
   "name": "Resupply",
   "pinnedBlock": 26429396,
   "probe": {
    "block_hash": "0x3fb83aa053c26ac6b98d634858da1b3c23bb65bae7a12f8f14d72d8273e16d71",
    "block_number": 26429396,
    "call_args": [],
    "call_signature": "getThreshold()",
    "chain": "ethereum",
    "check_type": "eth_call",
    "extra_calls": [],
    "id": "resupply-main-multisig-3of5-s22",
    "repro_calldata": "0xe75235b8",
    "rpc_env_var": "$ETH_RPC_URL",
    "selector_or_slot": "0xe75235b8",
    "target_contract": "0xFE11a5009f2121622271e7dd0FD470264e076af6",
    "target_label": "Resupply Main Multisig (Safe)"
   },
   "reconciled": false,
   "reconciledFrom": [],
   "reconciledTo": [],
   "records": 4,
   "rosetteAria": "Resupply control-plane rosette: Upgradeability not determined; Timelock floor moderate; Signer quorum strong; Emergency / freeze scope strong; Docs-vs-chain parity weak",
   "search": "resupply resupply cdp stablecoin (reusd) & lending markets rsup sreusd 0x10101010e0c3171d894b71b3400668af311e7d94 0x11111111063874ce8dc6232cb5c1c849359476e6 0x4cf97a55d58aad14c493a46c8151a0bfffb10403 0x74c85620f1459862834a947db9441911bcebf066 0xa4745e0b1f40ab3dcfd98f381835de591a8974e3 0xc07e000044f95655c11fda4cd37f70a94d7e0a7d 0xfe11a5009f2121622271e7dd0fd470264e076af6",
   "slug": "resupply",
   "summary_short": "Safe threshold: docs 3-of-4 · chain 3-of-5",
   "url": "https://pacta.wtf/protocols/resupply/"
  },
  {
   "baskets": [
    "lending_vaults"
   ],
   "category": "Options vault structured products (Ethereum)",
   "chains": [
    "ethereum"
   ],
   "deltas": 0,
   "easAttested": false,
   "evidence": {
    "documented": "Ribbon documentation is linked for reference (). This RPC-pinned record does not compare documentation parameters with the on-chain state.",
    "observed": "Ribbon (0x6123B0049F904d730dB3C36a31167D9d4121fA6B) verified on Ethereum Mainnet at canonical block #26,458,556 (5,288 bytes runtime code). EIP-1967 implementation and admin storage slots are both zero (non-EIP-1967 contract). No owner(), admin(), authority(), curator() or AccessControl admin was readable on the contract.",
    "recordId": "ribbon-control-plane",
    "surface": "Ribbon · Non-Proxy Bytecode & Controller"
   },
   "factors": [
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "upgrade",
     "label": "Upgradeability",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "Upgrade path not in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "timelock",
     "label": "Timelock floor",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No enforced admin delay in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "quorum",
     "label": "Signer quorum",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No signer quorum in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "emergency",
     "label": "Emergency / freeze scope",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No pause / freeze authority in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "parity",
     "label": "Docs-vs-chain parity",
     "state": "u",
     "value": "Uncompared: documentation not assessed (RPC-observed)"
    }
   ],
   "finding": "Ribbon · Non-Proxy Bytecode & Controller",
   "grade": "observed",
   "gradeLabel": "OBSERVED",
   "name": "Ribbon",
   "pinnedBlock": 26458556,
   "probe": {
    "block_hash": "0xe258bb1cbcc988e2dfdba4ba173f9f8690520dba3647cdcae18e0651822769d2",
    "block_number": 26458556,
    "call_args": [],
    "call_signature": "owner()",
    "chain": "ethereum",
    "check_type": "eth_call",
    "extra_calls": [],
    "id": "ribbon-control-plane",
    "repro_calldata": "0x8da5cb5b",
    "rpc_env_var": "$ETH_RPC_URL",
    "selector_or_slot": "0x8da5cb5b",
    "target_contract": "0x6123B0049F904d730dB3C36a31167D9d4121fA6B",
    "target_label": "Ribbon"
   },
   "reconciled": false,
   "reconciledFrom": [],
   "reconciledTo": [],
   "records": 1,
   "rosetteAria": "Ribbon control-plane rosette: Upgradeability not determined; Timelock floor not determined; Signer quorum not determined; Emergency / freeze scope not determined; Docs-vs-chain parity uncompared",
   "search": "ribbon ribbon options vault structured products (ethereum) rbn 0x6123b0049f904d730db3c36a31167d9d4121fa6b",
   "slug": "ribbon",
   "summary_short": "Non-proxy contract no readable owner or admin; docs not assessed",
   "url": "https://pacta.wtf/protocols/ribbon/"
  },
  {
   "baskets": [],
   "category": "FewToken wrapping layer that feeds a native swap AMM (Ethereum)",
   "chains": [
    "ethereum"
   ],
   "deltas": 0,
   "easAttested": false,
   "evidence": {
    "documented": "Ring Few documentation is linked for reference (https://docs.ring.exchange/). This RPC-pinned record does not compare documentation parameters with the on-chain state.",
    "observed": "FewFactory (0x7D86394139bf1122E82FDF45Bb4e3b038A4464DD) verified on Ethereum Mainnet at canonical block #26,458,556 (11,754 bytes runtime code). EIP-1967 implementation and admin storage slots are both zero (non-EIP-1967 contract). No owner(), admin(), authority(), curator() or AccessControl admin was readable on the contract.",
    "recordId": "ring-few-control-plane",
    "surface": "FewFactory · Non-Proxy Bytecode & Controller"
   },
   "factors": [
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "upgrade",
     "label": "Upgradeability",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "Upgrade path not in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "timelock",
     "label": "Timelock floor",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No enforced admin delay in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "quorum",
     "label": "Signer quorum",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No signer quorum in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "emergency",
     "label": "Emergency / freeze scope",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No pause / freeze authority in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "parity",
     "label": "Docs-vs-chain parity",
     "state": "u",
     "value": "Uncompared: documentation not assessed (RPC-observed)"
    }
   ],
   "finding": "FewFactory · Non-Proxy Bytecode & Controller",
   "grade": "observed",
   "gradeLabel": "OBSERVED",
   "name": "Ring Few",
   "pinnedBlock": 26458556,
   "probe": {
    "block_hash": "0xe258bb1cbcc988e2dfdba4ba173f9f8690520dba3647cdcae18e0651822769d2",
    "block_number": 26458556,
    "call_args": [],
    "call_signature": "owner()",
    "chain": "ethereum",
    "check_type": "eth_call",
    "extra_calls": [],
    "id": "ring-few-control-plane",
    "repro_calldata": "0x8da5cb5b",
    "rpc_env_var": "$ETH_RPC_URL",
    "selector_or_slot": "0x8da5cb5b",
    "target_contract": "0x7D86394139bf1122E82FDF45Bb4e3b038A4464DD",
    "target_label": "FewFactory"
   },
   "reconciled": false,
   "reconciledFrom": [],
   "reconciledTo": [],
   "records": 1,
   "rosetteAria": "Ring Few control-plane rosette: Upgradeability not determined; Timelock floor not determined; Signer quorum not determined; Emergency / freeze scope not determined; Docs-vs-chain parity uncompared",
   "search": "ring few ring-few fewtoken wrapping layer that feeds a native swap amm (ethereum) ring 0x7d86394139bf1122e82fdf45bb4e3b038a4464dd",
   "slug": "ring-few",
   "summary_short": "Non-proxy contract no readable owner or admin; docs not assessed",
   "url": "https://pacta.wtf/protocols/ring-few/"
  },
  {
   "baskets": [
    "lending_vaults"
   ],
   "category": "Risk Curator Vault (market-neutral strategies) (Ethereum)",
   "chains": [
    "ethereum"
   ],
   "deltas": 0,
   "easAttested": false,
   "evidence": {
    "documented": "RockawayX documentation is linked for reference (https://rockawayx.com/insights/backing-builders-rockawayxs-role-in-lidos-defi-expansion). This RPC-pinned record does not compare documentation parameters with the on-chain state.",
    "observed": "Ember Y10K (EmberVault) (0x953972ea0C1703c58F09FB6fD2477Fdcf0FEe074) verified on Ethereum Mainnet at canonical block #26,458,556 (170 bytes runtime code). EIP-1967 proxy: implementation 0xd0Ac2Cd802604702DF874Bc45AEE88E8884B896D, admin slot zero. Direct owner() returns timelock (1 d delay) 0x12917E06b55995e7a5D73681cE491774C73b7C6a.",
    "recordId": "rockawayx-control-plane",
    "surface": "Ember Y10K (EmberVault) · EIP-1967 Proxy & Controller Chain"
   },
   "factors": [
    {
     "evidence": "rockawayx-control-plane: is_eip1967_proxy = true",
     "key": "upgrade",
     "label": "Upgradeability",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "Upgradeable; the delay gating the upgrade path is not in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": "controller fact: getMinDelay() = 86400s",
     "key": "timelock",
     "label": "Timelock floor",
     "state": "b",
     "value": "1d minimum enforced delay across control surfaces"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "quorum",
     "label": "Signer quorum",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No signer quorum in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "emergency",
     "label": "Emergency / freeze scope",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No pause / freeze authority in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "parity",
     "label": "Docs-vs-chain parity",
     "state": "u",
     "value": "Uncompared: documentation not assessed (RPC-observed)"
    }
   ],
   "finding": "Ember Y10K (EmberVault) · EIP-1967 Proxy & Controller Chain",
   "grade": "observed",
   "gradeLabel": "OBSERVED",
   "name": "RockawayX",
   "pinnedBlock": 26458556,
   "probe": {
    "block_hash": "0xe258bb1cbcc988e2dfdba4ba173f9f8690520dba3647cdcae18e0651822769d2",
    "block_number": 26458556,
    "call_args": [],
    "call_signature": "owner()",
    "chain": "ethereum",
    "check_type": "eth_call",
    "extra_calls": [],
    "id": "rockawayx-control-plane",
    "repro_calldata": "0x8da5cb5b",
    "rpc_env_var": "$ETH_RPC_URL",
    "selector_or_slot": "0x8da5cb5b",
    "target_contract": "0x953972ea0C1703c58F09FB6fD2477Fdcf0FEe074",
    "target_label": "Ember Y10K (EmberVault)"
   },
   "reconciled": false,
   "reconciledFrom": [],
   "reconciledTo": [],
   "records": 1,
   "rosetteAria": "RockawayX control-plane rosette: Upgradeability not determined; Timelock floor moderate; Signer quorum not determined; Emergency / freeze scope not determined; Docs-vs-chain parity uncompared",
   "search": "rockawayx rockawayx risk curator vault (market-neutral strategies) (ethereum) ey10k 0x12917e06b55995e7a5d73681ce491774c73b7c6a 0x953972ea0c1703c58f09fb6fd2477fdcf0fee074 0xd0ac2cd802604702df874bc45aee88e8884b896d",
   "slug": "rockawayx",
   "summary_short": "Upgradeable proxy controlled by a timelock; docs not assessed",
   "url": "https://pacta.wtf/protocols/rockawayx/"
  },
  {
   "baskets": [
    "eth_lst_lrt"
   ],
   "category": "Decentralized Liquid Staking",
   "chains": [
    "ethereum"
   ],
   "deltas": 1,
   "easAttested": true,
   "evidence": {
    "documented": "rpips.rocketpool.net RPIP-33 parameter table, members.leave.time: 'How long a member must give notice for before manually leaving the security council' with the bound '< 14 days'",
    "observed": "RocketDAOProtocolSettingsSecurity (0xC9D771AaF504F33bB3C8a7E67eA9f1881F837cFf).getLeaveTime() = 2419200s (28 days). The security council has 1 member, Safe 0x6C565aF34f15dE064b56afEdF7B0F59C15bB20FE (2-of-3).",
    "recordId": "rocket-pool-reth-security-council-leave-time-28d-s19",
    "surface": "Security council members.leave.time = 28 days (RPIP-33 bound: < 14 days)"
   },
   "factors": [
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "upgrade",
     "label": "Upgradeability",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "Upgrade path not in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": "rocket-pool-reth-upgrade-delay-1w-s19: observed_delay_seconds = 604800",
     "key": "timelock",
     "label": "Timelock floor",
     "state": "g",
     "value": "7d minimum enforced delay across control surfaces"
    },
    {
     "evidence": "rocket-pool-reth-security-council-leave-time-28d-s19: … 0x6C565aF34f15dE064b56afEdF7B0F59C15bB20FE (2-of-3).",
     "key": "quorum",
     "label": "Signer quorum",
     "state": "b",
     "value": "Lowest controlling quorum: 2-of-3"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "emergency",
     "label": "Emergency / freeze scope",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No pause / freeze authority in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "parity",
     "label": "Docs-vs-chain parity",
     "state": "a",
     "value": "Documentation differs from the chain (parameter delta)"
    }
   ],
   "finding": "Security council members.leave.time = 28 days (RPIP-33 bound: < 14 days): docs say rpips.rocketpool.net RPIP-33 parameter table, members.leave.time: 'How long a member must give notice for before manually leaving the security council' with the bound '< 14 days' · chain says RocketDAOProtocolSettingsSecurity (0xC9D771AaF504F33bB3C8a7E67eA9f1881F837cFf).getLeaveTime() = 2419200s (28 days).",
   "grade": "delta",
   "gradeLabel": "DELTA",
   "name": "Rocket Pool (rETH)",
   "pinnedBlock": 26422243,
   "probe": {
    "block_hash": "0xbbe80f9ef9966a9d04cea23db216847f8c8fcc8d66f87c215dc7f712f0743410",
    "block_number": 26422243,
    "call_args": [],
    "call_signature": "getLeaveTime()",
    "chain": "ethereum",
    "check_type": "eth_call",
    "extra_calls": [],
    "id": "rocket-pool-reth-security-council-leave-time-28d-s19",
    "repro_calldata": "0x11b5e486",
    "rpc_env_var": "$ETH_RPC_URL",
    "selector_or_slot": "0x11b5e486",
    "target_contract": "0xC9D771AaF504F33bB3C8a7E67eA9f1881F837cFf",
    "target_label": "RocketDAOProtocolSettingsSecurity"
   },
   "reconciled": false,
   "reconciledFrom": [],
   "reconciledTo": [],
   "records": 3,
   "rosetteAria": "Rocket Pool (rETH) control-plane rosette: Upgradeability not determined; Timelock floor strong; Signer quorum moderate; Emergency / freeze scope not determined; Docs-vs-chain parity weak",
   "search": "rocket pool (reth) rocket-pool-reth decentralized liquid staking reth rpl 0x6c565af34f15de064b56afedf7b0f59c15bb20fe 0xc9d771aaf504f33bb3c8a7e67ea9f1881f837cff 0xda1ab39e62e0a5297af44c7064e501b0613f0d01",
   "slug": "rocket-pool-reth",
   "summary_short": "Council leave notice: chain 28 days · RPIP-33 bound under 14 days",
   "url": "https://pacta.wtf/protocols/rocket-pool-reth/"
  },
  {
   "baskets": [
    "lending_vaults"
   ],
   "category": "Incentivized action market matching depositors with protocols (Ethereum)",
   "chains": [
    "ethereum"
   ],
   "deltas": 0,
   "easAttested": false,
   "evidence": {
    "documented": "Royco V2 documentation is linked for reference (https://docs.royco.org/royco-overview). This RPC-pinned record does not compare documentation parameters with the on-chain state.",
    "observed": "RoycoFactory (0x7cC6fB28eC7b5e7afC3cB3986141797ffc27253C) verified on Ethereum Mainnet at canonical block #26,458,556 (87 bytes runtime code). EIP-1967 proxy: implementation 0x34DB2f4215e55ec8e2c3dE0a826935EBF158be77, admin slot zero. No owner(), admin(), authority(), curator() or AccessControl admin was readable on the contract.",
    "recordId": "royco-v2-control-plane",
    "surface": "RoycoFactory · EIP-1967 Proxy & Controller Chain"
   },
   "factors": [
    {
     "evidence": "royco-v2-control-plane: is_eip1967_proxy = true",
     "key": "upgrade",
     "label": "Upgradeability",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "Upgradeable; the delay gating the upgrade path is not in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "timelock",
     "label": "Timelock floor",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No enforced admin delay in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "quorum",
     "label": "Signer quorum",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No signer quorum in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "emergency",
     "label": "Emergency / freeze scope",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No pause / freeze authority in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "parity",
     "label": "Docs-vs-chain parity",
     "state": "u",
     "value": "Uncompared: documentation not assessed (RPC-observed)"
    }
   ],
   "finding": "RoycoFactory · EIP-1967 Proxy & Controller Chain",
   "grade": "observed",
   "gradeLabel": "OBSERVED",
   "name": "Royco V2",
   "pinnedBlock": 26458556,
   "probe": {
    "block_hash": "0xe258bb1cbcc988e2dfdba4ba173f9f8690520dba3647cdcae18e0651822769d2",
    "block_number": 26458556,
    "call_args": [],
    "call_signature": "owner()",
    "chain": "ethereum",
    "check_type": "eth_call",
    "extra_calls": [],
    "id": "royco-v2-control-plane",
    "repro_calldata": "0x8da5cb5b",
    "rpc_env_var": "$ETH_RPC_URL",
    "selector_or_slot": "0x8da5cb5b",
    "target_contract": "0x7cC6fB28eC7b5e7afC3cB3986141797ffc27253C",
    "target_label": "RoycoFactory"
   },
   "reconciled": false,
   "reconciledFrom": [],
   "reconciledTo": [],
   "records": 1,
   "rosetteAria": "Royco V2 control-plane rosette: Upgradeability not determined; Timelock floor not determined; Signer quorum not determined; Emergency / freeze scope not determined; Docs-vs-chain parity uncompared",
   "search": "royco v2 royco-v2 incentivized action market matching depositors with protocols (ethereum) royco 0x34db2f4215e55ec8e2c3de0a826935ebf158be77 0x7cc6fb28ec7b5e7afc3cb3986141797ffc27253c",
   "slug": "royco-v2",
   "summary_short": "Upgradeable proxy no readable owner or admin; docs not assessed",
   "url": "https://pacta.wtf/protocols/royco-v2/"
  },
  {
   "baskets": [],
   "category": "Smart Account & Multisig Custody Core",
   "chains": [
    "ethereum"
   ],
   "deltas": 0,
   "easAttested": true,
   "evidence": {
    "documented": "safe-deployments registry (v1.4.1): '\"address\": \"0x4e1DCf7AD4e460CfD30791CCC4F9c8a4f820ec67\",' / '\"1\": \"canonical\",' / 'The Safe proxy factory contract provides a simple way to create a new proxy contract pointing to a singleton and executing a setup function in the newly deployed proxy all in one transaction.'",
    "observed": "SafeProxyFactory 0x4e1DCf7AD4e460CfD30791CCC4F9c8a4f820ec67: EIP-1967 implementation and admin slots = 0x0; keccak256(runtime code) = 0x50c3cdc4…0b3317.",
    "recordId": "safe-singleton-core-proxy-factory-bytecode-s25",
    "surface": "SafeProxyFactory: registry code hash, no proxy and no admin"
   },
   "factors": [
    {
     "evidence": "safe-singleton-core-singleton-bytecode-s25: … 0x1fe2df85…c5e1c4; EIP-1967 slots 0x0 (not a proxy).",
     "key": "upgrade",
     "label": "Upgradeability",
     "state": "g",
     "value": "Immutable or ownership renounced"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "timelock",
     "label": "Timelock floor",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No enforced admin delay in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "quorum",
     "label": "Signer quorum",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No signer quorum in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "emergency",
     "label": "Emergency / freeze scope",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No pause / freeze authority in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "parity",
     "label": "Docs-vs-chain parity",
     "state": "g",
     "value": "Chain matches or is stronger than the documentation"
    }
   ],
   "finding": "SafeProxyFactory: registry code hash, no proxy and no admin",
   "grade": "aligned",
   "gradeLabel": "ALIGNED",
   "name": "Safe Smart Account (v1.4.1 Singleton)",
   "pinnedBlock": 26434786,
   "probe": {
    "block_hash": "0xb712439847099ec3e8b1617aafd1bc7ece29e22a88dc4e7c8afcf05e6944d987",
    "block_number": 26434786,
    "call_args": [],
    "call_signature": null,
    "chain": "ethereum",
    "check_type": "eth_getStorageAt",
    "extra_calls": [],
    "id": "safe-singleton-core-proxy-factory-bytecode-s25",
    "repro_calldata": null,
    "rpc_env_var": "$ETH_RPC_URL",
    "selector_or_slot": "0x360894a13ba1a3210667c828492db98dca3e2076cc3735a920a3ca505d382bbc",
    "target_contract": "0x4e1DCf7AD4e460CfD30791CCC4F9c8a4f820ec67",
    "target_label": "SafeProxyFactory v1.4.1"
   },
   "reconciled": false,
   "reconciledFrom": [],
   "reconciledTo": [],
   "records": 4,
   "rosetteAria": "Safe Smart Account (v1.4.1 Singleton) control-plane rosette: Upgradeability strong; Timelock floor not determined; Signer quorum not determined; Emergency / freeze scope not determined; Docs-vs-chain parity strong",
   "search": "safe smart account (v1.4.1 singleton) safe-singleton-core smart account & multisig custody core safe 0x29fcb43b46531bca003ddc8fcb67ffe91900c762 0x3050620423f4db43e1904815e898c466526387b8 0x41675c099f32341bf84bfc5382af534df5c7461a 0x4e1dcf7ad4e460cfd30791ccc4f9c8a4f820ec67 0xaee017052df6ac002647229d58b786e380b9721a",
   "slug": "safe-singleton-core",
   "summary_short": "v1.4.1 singleton and factory code match Safe's registry; singletons cannot be initialized",
   "url": "https://pacta.wtf/protocols/safe-singleton-core/"
  },
  {
   "baskets": [
    "lending_vaults"
   ],
   "category": "Fixed-yield tranches for DeFi deposits (Ethereum)",
   "chains": [
    "ethereum"
   ],
   "deltas": 0,
   "easAttested": false,
   "evidence": {
    "documented": "Saffron Vaults documentation is linked for reference (https://docs.saffron.finance/introduction). This RPC-pinned record does not compare documentation parameters with the on-chain state.",
    "observed": "Spice (SFI) (0xb753428af26E81097e7fD17f40c88aaA3E04902c) verified on Ethereum Mainnet at canonical block #26,458,556 (6,094 bytes runtime code). EIP-1967 implementation and admin storage slots are both zero (non-EIP-1967 contract). No owner(), admin(), authority(), curator() or AccessControl admin was readable on the contract.",
    "recordId": "saffron-vaults-control-plane",
    "surface": "Spice (SFI) · Non-Proxy Bytecode & Controller"
   },
   "factors": [
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "upgrade",
     "label": "Upgradeability",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "Upgrade path not in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "timelock",
     "label": "Timelock floor",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No enforced admin delay in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "quorum",
     "label": "Signer quorum",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No signer quorum in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "emergency",
     "label": "Emergency / freeze scope",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No pause / freeze authority in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "parity",
     "label": "Docs-vs-chain parity",
     "state": "u",
     "value": "Uncompared: documentation not assessed (RPC-observed)"
    }
   ],
   "finding": "Spice (SFI) · Non-Proxy Bytecode & Controller",
   "grade": "observed",
   "gradeLabel": "OBSERVED",
   "name": "Saffron Vaults",
   "pinnedBlock": 26458556,
   "probe": {
    "block_hash": "0xe258bb1cbcc988e2dfdba4ba173f9f8690520dba3647cdcae18e0651822769d2",
    "block_number": 26458556,
    "call_args": [],
    "call_signature": "owner()",
    "chain": "ethereum",
    "check_type": "eth_call",
    "extra_calls": [],
    "id": "saffron-vaults-control-plane",
    "repro_calldata": "0x8da5cb5b",
    "rpc_env_var": "$ETH_RPC_URL",
    "selector_or_slot": "0x8da5cb5b",
    "target_contract": "0xb753428af26E81097e7fD17f40c88aaA3E04902c",
    "target_label": "Spice (SFI)"
   },
   "reconciled": false,
   "reconciledFrom": [],
   "reconciledTo": [],
   "records": 1,
   "rosetteAria": "Saffron Vaults control-plane rosette: Upgradeability not determined; Timelock floor not determined; Signer quorum not determined; Emergency / freeze scope not determined; Docs-vs-chain parity uncompared",
   "search": "saffron vaults saffron-vaults fixed-yield tranches for defi deposits (ethereum) sfi 0xb753428af26e81097e7fd17f40c88aaa3e04902c",
   "slug": "saffron-vaults",
   "summary_short": "Non-proxy contract no readable owner or admin; docs not assessed",
   "url": "https://pacta.wtf/protocols/saffron-vaults/"
  },
  {
   "baskets": [],
   "category": "Operator-free bonding-curve monetary protocol with a contract-held ETH reserve (Ethereum)",
   "chains": [
    "ethereum"
   ],
   "deltas": 0,
   "easAttested": false,
   "evidence": {
    "documented": "SATO documentation is linked for reference (https://sat0.org/docs). This RPC-pinned record does not compare documentation parameters with the on-chain state.",
    "observed": "SatoHook (0x0000f07d2B5F1Ddf3244b8780F972f306EFd2888) verified on Ethereum Mainnet at canonical block #26,458,556 (8,576 bytes runtime code). EIP-1967 implementation and admin storage slots are both zero (non-EIP-1967 contract). No owner(), admin(), authority(), curator() or AccessControl admin was readable on the contract.",
    "recordId": "sato-control-plane",
    "surface": "SatoHook · Non-Proxy Bytecode & Controller"
   },
   "factors": [
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "upgrade",
     "label": "Upgradeability",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "Upgrade path not in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "timelock",
     "label": "Timelock floor",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No enforced admin delay in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "quorum",
     "label": "Signer quorum",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No signer quorum in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "emergency",
     "label": "Emergency / freeze scope",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No pause / freeze authority in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "parity",
     "label": "Docs-vs-chain parity",
     "state": "u",
     "value": "Uncompared: documentation not assessed (RPC-observed)"
    }
   ],
   "finding": "SatoHook · Non-Proxy Bytecode & Controller",
   "grade": "observed",
   "gradeLabel": "OBSERVED",
   "name": "SATO",
   "pinnedBlock": 26458556,
   "probe": {
    "block_hash": "0xe258bb1cbcc988e2dfdba4ba173f9f8690520dba3647cdcae18e0651822769d2",
    "block_number": 26458556,
    "call_args": [],
    "call_signature": "owner()",
    "chain": "ethereum",
    "check_type": "eth_call",
    "extra_calls": [],
    "id": "sato-control-plane",
    "repro_calldata": "0x8da5cb5b",
    "rpc_env_var": "$ETH_RPC_URL",
    "selector_or_slot": "0x8da5cb5b",
    "target_contract": "0x0000f07d2B5F1Ddf3244b8780F972f306EFd2888",
    "target_label": "SatoHook"
   },
   "reconciled": false,
   "reconciledFrom": [],
   "reconciledTo": [],
   "records": 1,
   "rosetteAria": "SATO control-plane rosette: Upgradeability not determined; Timelock floor not determined; Signer quorum not determined; Emergency / freeze scope not determined; Docs-vs-chain parity uncompared",
   "search": "sato sato operator-free bonding-curve monetary protocol with a contract-held eth reserve (ethereum) sato 0x0000f07d2b5f1ddf3244b8780f972f306efd2888",
   "slug": "sato",
   "summary_short": "Non-proxy contract no readable owner or admin; docs not assessed",
   "url": "https://pacta.wtf/protocols/sato/"
  },
  {
   "baskets": [
    "stable_rwa"
   ],
   "category": "Bitcoin-Backed Credit Stablecoin (dual token) (Ethereum)",
   "chains": [
    "ethereum"
   ],
   "deltas": 0,
   "easAttested": false,
   "evidence": {
    "documented": "Saturn documentation is linked for reference (https://saturncredit.gitbook.io/saturn-docs). This RPC-pinned record does not compare documentation parameters with the on-chain state.",
    "observed": "USDat (0x23238f20b894f29041f48D88eE91131C395Aaa71) verified on Ethereum Mainnet at canonical block #26,458,556 (761 bytes runtime code). EIP-1967 proxy: implementation 0x496a4A33b6181F4536203488d9a05AC1429E702c, admin 0xcf1072DA5f0D127AEf99136489BAd08bFa3D1A7D. The EIP-1967 admin slot holds contract ProxyAdmin 0xcf1072DA5f0D127AEf99136489BAd08bFa3D1A7D. That controller is in turn controlled by timelock (5 d delay) 0xfD5782E3BFF366601da3973aE30C583dE4F08A67.",
    "recordId": "saturn-control-plane",
    "surface": "USDat · EIP-1967 Proxy & Controller Chain"
   },
   "factors": [
    {
     "evidence": "saturn-control-plane: USDat (0x23238f20b894f29041f48D88eE91131C395Aaa71) verified on Ethereum Mainnet at canonical block #26,458,556 (761 bytes runtime code). EIP-1967 proxy …",
     "key": "upgrade",
     "label": "Upgradeability",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "Upgradeable; the delay gating the upgrade path is not in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": "controller fact: getMinDelay() = 432000s",
     "key": "timelock",
     "label": "Timelock floor",
     "state": "g",
     "value": "5d minimum enforced delay across control surfaces"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "quorum",
     "label": "Signer quorum",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No signer quorum in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "emergency",
     "label": "Emergency / freeze scope",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No pause / freeze authority in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "parity",
     "label": "Docs-vs-chain parity",
     "state": "u",
     "value": "Uncompared: documentation not assessed (RPC-observed)"
    }
   ],
   "finding": "USDat · EIP-1967 Proxy & Controller Chain",
   "grade": "observed",
   "gradeLabel": "OBSERVED",
   "name": "Saturn",
   "pinnedBlock": 26458556,
   "probe": {
    "block_hash": "0xe258bb1cbcc988e2dfdba4ba173f9f8690520dba3647cdcae18e0651822769d2",
    "block_number": 26458556,
    "call_args": [],
    "call_signature": null,
    "chain": "ethereum",
    "check_type": "eth_getStorageAt",
    "extra_calls": [],
    "id": "saturn-control-plane",
    "repro_calldata": null,
    "rpc_env_var": "$ETH_RPC_URL",
    "selector_or_slot": "0xb53127684a568b3173ae13b9f8a6016e243e63b6e8ee1178d6a717850b5d6103",
    "target_contract": "0x23238f20b894f29041f48D88eE91131C395Aaa71",
    "target_label": "USDat"
   },
   "reconciled": false,
   "reconciledFrom": [],
   "reconciledTo": [],
   "records": 1,
   "rosetteAria": "Saturn control-plane rosette: Upgradeability not determined; Timelock floor strong; Signer quorum not determined; Emergency / freeze scope not determined; Docs-vs-chain parity uncompared",
   "search": "saturn saturn bitcoin-backed credit stablecoin (dual token) (ethereum) usdat 0x23238f20b894f29041f48d88ee91131c395aaa71 0x496a4a33b6181f4536203488d9a05ac1429e702c 0xcf1072da5f0d127aef99136489bad08bfa3d1a7d 0xfd5782e3bff366601da3973ae30c583de4f08a67",
   "slug": "saturn",
   "summary_short": "Upgradeable proxy controlled by a contract; docs not assessed",
   "url": "https://pacta.wtf/protocols/saturn/"
  },
  {
   "baskets": [
    "base",
    "lending_vaults"
   ],
   "category": "Base Lending & Integrated Liquidity",
   "chains": [
    "base"
   ],
   "deltas": 1,
   "easAttested": true,
   "evidence": {
    "documented": "'The Community Guardian Multi-Sig currently has ownership over both the Governance Guardian and Protocol Guardian functions.' (raw.githubusercontent.com/seamless-protocol/gitbook/main/governance/seamless-guardians.md); '>0xA1b5f2cc9B407177CD8a4ACF1699fa0b99955A22<' (raw.githubusercontent.com/seamless-protocol/gitbook/main/technical/smart-contracts.md)",
    "observed": "Guardian 0xA1b5f2cc9B407177CD8a4ACF1699fa0b99955A22 (Base Safe, the address the smart-contracts page lists): getThreshold() = 2 of getOwners() = 3; guard slot empty; getModulesPaginated() lists no module. It holds CANCELLER_ROLE on the governance timelock the same page lists as Timelock short (0x639d2dD24304aC2e6A691d8c1cFf4a2665925fee; hasRole = true), a Governance Guardian function. The docs state the Community Guardian Multi-Sig is a 3/6 multi-sig; on chain 2 signatures of 3 owners execute.",
    "recordId": "seamless-community-guardian-safe-2-of-3-s35",
    "surface": "Community Guardian Safe: docs state a 3/6 multi-sig; the Safe is 2-of-3"
   },
   "factors": [
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "upgrade",
     "label": "Upgradeability",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "Upgrade path not in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "timelock",
     "label": "Timelock floor",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No enforced admin delay in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": "controller fact: Safe getThreshold()",
     "key": "quorum",
     "label": "Signer quorum",
     "state": "b",
     "value": "Lowest controlling quorum: 2-of-3"
    },
    {
     "evidence": "seamless-community-guardian-safe-2-of-3-s35: Guardian 0xA1b5f2cc9B407177CD8a4ACF1699fa0b99955A22 (Base Safe, the address the smart-contracts page lists): getThreshold() = 2 of getOwners() = 3",
     "key": "emergency",
     "label": "Emergency / freeze scope",
     "state": "g",
     "value": "Pause / freeze authority scoped behind a multi-signer controller (2-of-N Safe)"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "parity",
     "label": "Docs-vs-chain parity",
     "state": "a",
     "value": "Documentation differs from the chain (parameter delta)"
    }
   ],
   "finding": "Community Guardian Safe: docs state a 3/6 multi-sig; the Safe is 2-of-3: docs say 'The Community Guardian Multi-Sig currently has ownership over both the Governance Guardian and Protocol Guardian functions.' (raw.githubusercontent.com/seamless-protocol/gitbook/main/governance/seamless-guardians.md); · chain says Guardian 0xA1b5f2cc9B407177CD8a4ACF1699fa0b99955A22 (Base Safe, the address the smart-contracts page lists): getThreshold() = 2 of getOwners() = 3;",
   "grade": "delta",
   "gradeLabel": "DELTA",
   "name": "Seamless Protocol (Base)",
   "pinnedBlock": 59847352,
   "probe": {
    "block_hash": "0x58e5d7f07aaf27ccbf361f122a24120a821b455bb9dae30f4478a7da1381f3e8",
    "block_number": 59847352,
    "call_args": [],
    "call_signature": "getThreshold()",
    "chain": "base",
    "check_type": "eth_call",
    "extra_calls": [],
    "id": "seamless-community-guardian-safe-2-of-3-s35",
    "repro_calldata": "0xe75235b8",
    "rpc_env_var": "$BASE_RPC_URL",
    "selector_or_slot": "0xe75235b8",
    "target_contract": "0xA1b5f2cc9B407177CD8a4ACF1699fa0b99955A22",
    "target_label": "Seamless Community Guardian Safe (Base)"
   },
   "reconciled": false,
   "reconciledFrom": [],
   "reconciledTo": [],
   "records": 1,
   "rosetteAria": "Seamless Protocol (Base) control-plane rosette: Upgradeability not determined; Timelock floor not determined; Signer quorum moderate; Emergency / freeze scope strong; Docs-vs-chain parity weak",
   "search": "seamless protocol (base) seamless-protocol-base base lending & integrated liquidity seam 0x639d2dd24304ac2e6a691d8c1cff4a2665925fee 0xa1b5f2cc9b407177cd8a4acf1699fa0b99955a22",
   "slug": "seamless-protocol-base",
   "summary_short": "Seamless's guardian Safe is 2-of-3; docs say a 3/6 multi-sig",
   "url": "https://pacta.wtf/protocols/seamless-protocol-base/"
  },
  {
   "baskets": [
    "lending_vaults"
   ],
   "category": "Institutional Portfolio Yield Platform (Ethereum)",
   "chains": [
    "ethereum"
   ],
   "deltas": 0,
   "easAttested": true,
   "evidence": {
    "documented": "'The Emergency & Reshuffling Multisig uses Safe v1.4.1 with a 2-of-6 signature threshold and 2 proposers.' (docs.shiftdefi.com/security/multisig-and-timelock.md)",
    "observed": "Shift DeFi Safe 0x4cC8D45644eCCD8cA77DBF3A8E3eE2dBf4596983 (Ethereum): getThreshold() = 2 of getOwners() = 6 owners (Safe v1.4.1).",
    "recordId": "shift-defi-safe-threshold-4cc8d4-s30",
    "surface": "Shift DeFi multisig: 2-of-6 Safe, as documented"
   },
   "factors": [
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "upgrade",
     "label": "Upgradeability",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "Upgrade path not in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "timelock",
     "label": "Timelock floor",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No enforced admin delay in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": "controller fact: Safe getThreshold()",
     "key": "quorum",
     "label": "Signer quorum",
     "state": "b",
     "value": "Lowest controlling quorum: 2-of-6"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "emergency",
     "label": "Emergency / freeze scope",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No pause / freeze authority in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "parity",
     "label": "Docs-vs-chain parity",
     "state": "g",
     "value": "Chain matches or is stronger than the documentation"
    }
   ],
   "finding": "Shift DeFi multisig: 2-of-6 Safe, as documented",
   "grade": "aligned",
   "gradeLabel": "ALIGNED",
   "name": "Shift DeFi",
   "pinnedBlock": 26449594,
   "probe": {
    "block_hash": "0xbe263d5b378dcb7c3c4e18bd8e388f0cb2dab1adacd83de2be58c9408b377287",
    "block_number": 26449594,
    "call_args": [],
    "call_signature": "getThreshold()",
    "chain": "ethereum",
    "check_type": "eth_call",
    "extra_calls": [],
    "id": "shift-defi-safe-threshold-4cc8d4-s30",
    "repro_calldata": "0xe75235b8",
    "rpc_env_var": "$ETH_RPC_URL",
    "selector_or_slot": "0xe75235b8",
    "target_contract": "0x4cC8D45644eCCD8cA77DBF3A8E3eE2dBf4596983",
    "target_label": "Shift DeFi Safe"
   },
   "reconciled": false,
   "reconciledFrom": [],
   "reconciledTo": [],
   "records": 1,
   "rosetteAria": "Shift DeFi control-plane rosette: Upgradeability not determined; Timelock floor not determined; Signer quorum moderate; Emergency / freeze scope not determined; Docs-vs-chain parity strong",
   "search": "shift defi shift-defi institutional portfolio yield platform (ethereum) sdusdc-vault 0x4cc8d45644eccd8ca77dbf3a8e3ee2dbf4596983",
   "slug": "shift-defi",
   "summary_short": "The Shift DeFi multisig is a 4-of-9 Safe, as its docs state",
   "url": "https://pacta.wtf/protocols/shift-defi/"
  },
  {
   "baskets": [
    "lending_vaults"
   ],
   "category": "Liquid yield token issuer (SIERRA) backed by diversified yield strategies (Ethereum)",
   "chains": [
    "ethereum"
   ],
   "deltas": 0,
   "easAttested": false,
   "evidence": {
    "documented": "Sierra Protocol documentation is linked for reference (https://docs.sierra.money/). This RPC-pinned record does not compare documentation parameters with the on-chain state.",
    "observed": "SOL Staking Yield Vault (0xe1b1252652A2FF0CC3A4214eE73d9FeD1FEa5b4f) verified on Ethereum Mainnet at canonical block #26,458,556 (332 bytes runtime code). EIP-1967 implementation and admin storage slots are both zero (non-EIP-1967 contract). Direct admin() returns externally owned account (no code) 0xbd0Ca95C5A104E14E60d0868667AF174D146C9FD.",
    "recordId": "sierra-protocol-control-plane",
    "surface": "SOL Staking Yield Vault · Non-Proxy Bytecode & Controller"
   },
   "factors": [
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "upgrade",
     "label": "Upgradeability",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "Upgrade path not in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "timelock",
     "label": "Timelock floor",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No enforced admin delay in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": "sierra-protocol-control-plane: … (non-EIP-1967 contract). Direct admin() returns externally owned account (no code) 0xbd0Ca95C5A104E14E60d0868667AF174D146C9FD.",
     "key": "quorum",
     "label": "Signer quorum",
     "state": "a",
     "value": "Lowest controlling quorum: a single key"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "emergency",
     "label": "Emergency / freeze scope",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No pause / freeze authority in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "parity",
     "label": "Docs-vs-chain parity",
     "state": "u",
     "value": "Uncompared: documentation not assessed (RPC-observed)"
    }
   ],
   "finding": "SOL Staking Yield Vault · Non-Proxy Bytecode & Controller",
   "grade": "observed",
   "gradeLabel": "OBSERVED",
   "name": "Sierra Protocol",
   "pinnedBlock": 26458556,
   "probe": {
    "block_hash": "0xe258bb1cbcc988e2dfdba4ba173f9f8690520dba3647cdcae18e0651822769d2",
    "block_number": 26458556,
    "call_args": [],
    "call_signature": "admin()",
    "chain": "ethereum",
    "check_type": "eth_call",
    "extra_calls": [],
    "id": "sierra-protocol-control-plane",
    "repro_calldata": "0xf851a440",
    "rpc_env_var": "$ETH_RPC_URL",
    "selector_or_slot": "0xf851a440",
    "target_contract": "0xe1b1252652A2FF0CC3A4214eE73d9FeD1FEa5b4f",
    "target_label": "SOL Staking Yield Vault"
   },
   "reconciled": false,
   "reconciledFrom": [],
   "reconciledTo": [],
   "records": 1,
   "rosetteAria": "Sierra Protocol control-plane rosette: Upgradeability not determined; Timelock floor not determined; Signer quorum weak; Emergency / freeze scope not determined; Docs-vs-chain parity uncompared",
   "search": "sierra protocol sierra-protocol liquid yield token issuer (sierra) backed by diversified yield strategies (ethereum) xsoly 0xbd0ca95c5a104e14e60d0868667af174d146c9fd 0xe1b1252652a2ff0cc3a4214ee73d9fed1fea5b4f",
   "slug": "sierra-protocol",
   "summary_short": "Non-proxy contract controlled by a single key (EOA); docs not assessed",
   "url": "https://pacta.wtf/protocols/sierra-protocol/"
  },
  {
   "baskets": [
    "stable_rwa"
   ],
   "category": "Synthetic dollar backed by a delta-neutral structured product (Ethereum)",
   "chains": [
    "ethereum"
   ],
   "deltas": 0,
   "easAttested": false,
   "evidence": {
    "documented": "SMARDEX USDN documentation is linked for reference (https://docs.smardex.io/). This RPC-pinned record does not compare documentation parameters with the on-chain state.",
    "observed": "UsdnProtocolImpl (0x656cB8C6d154Aad29d8771384089be5B5141f01a) verified on Ethereum Mainnet at canonical block #26,458,556 (176 bytes runtime code). EIP-1967 proxy: implementation 0x271df5517a4DaacB7caB988Aa64D23dEbda4c498, admin slot zero. Direct owner() returns Safe 2-of-3 0x1E3e1128F6bC2264a19D7a065982696d356879c5.",
    "recordId": "smardex-usdn-control-plane",
    "surface": "UsdnProtocolImpl · EIP-1967 Proxy & Controller Chain"
   },
   "factors": [
    {
     "evidence": "smardex-usdn-control-plane: is_eip1967_proxy = true",
     "key": "upgrade",
     "label": "Upgradeability",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "Upgradeable; the delay gating the upgrade path is not in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "timelock",
     "label": "Timelock floor",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No enforced admin delay in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": "smardex-usdn-control-plane: … slot zero. Direct owner() returns Safe 2-of-3 0x1E3e1128F6bC2264a19D7a065982696d356879c5.",
     "key": "quorum",
     "label": "Signer quorum",
     "state": "b",
     "value": "Lowest controlling quorum: 2-of-3"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "emergency",
     "label": "Emergency / freeze scope",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No pause / freeze authority in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "parity",
     "label": "Docs-vs-chain parity",
     "state": "u",
     "value": "Uncompared: documentation not assessed (RPC-observed)"
    }
   ],
   "finding": "UsdnProtocolImpl · EIP-1967 Proxy & Controller Chain",
   "grade": "observed",
   "gradeLabel": "OBSERVED",
   "name": "SMARDEX USDN",
   "pinnedBlock": 26458556,
   "probe": {
    "block_hash": "0xe258bb1cbcc988e2dfdba4ba173f9f8690520dba3647cdcae18e0651822769d2",
    "block_number": 26458556,
    "call_args": [],
    "call_signature": "owner()",
    "chain": "ethereum",
    "check_type": "eth_call",
    "extra_calls": [],
    "id": "smardex-usdn-control-plane",
    "repro_calldata": "0x8da5cb5b",
    "rpc_env_var": "$ETH_RPC_URL",
    "selector_or_slot": "0x8da5cb5b",
    "target_contract": "0x656cB8C6d154Aad29d8771384089be5B5141f01a",
    "target_label": "UsdnProtocolImpl"
   },
   "reconciled": false,
   "reconciledFrom": [],
   "reconciledTo": [],
   "records": 1,
   "rosetteAria": "SMARDEX USDN control-plane rosette: Upgradeability not determined; Timelock floor not determined; Signer quorum moderate; Emergency / freeze scope not determined; Docs-vs-chain parity uncompared",
   "search": "smardex usdn smardex-usdn synthetic dollar backed by a delta-neutral structured product (ethereum) smardex 0x1e3e1128f6bc2264a19d7a065982696d356879c5 0x271df5517a4daacb7cab988aa64d23debda4c498 0x656cb8c6d154aad29d8771384089be5b5141f01a",
   "slug": "smardex-usdn",
   "summary_short": "Upgradeable proxy controlled by a 2-of-3 Safe; docs not assessed",
   "url": "https://pacta.wtf/protocols/smardex-usdn/"
  },
  {
   "baskets": [],
   "category": "Atomic on-chain settlement layer for options products (Ethereum)",
   "chains": [
    "ethereum"
   ],
   "deltas": 0,
   "easAttested": true,
   "evidence": {
    "documented": "'Total Supply: Capped at 37,000,000 $RCH.' (docs.sofa.org/en/tokenomics); 'RCH 0x57B96D4aF698605563A4653D882635da59Bf11AF' (docs.sofa.org/en/developer/contracts.html)",
    "observed": "RCH token 0x57B96D4aF698605563A4653D882635da59Bf11AF (Ethereum; not a proxy: EIP-1967 implementation, admin and beacon slots all empty; verified source): totalSupply() = 27,709,422.00. The runtime code holds no selector of mint(uint256), upgradeTo(address), upgradeToAndCall(address,bytes). MAX_SUPPLY() = 37,000,000 and totalMinted() = 30,647,695 (burns lower totalSupply, not totalMinted); mint() is onlyOwner and requires totalMinted + amount <= MAX_SUPPLY; owner() = 0x5a8cDDa6CA37B284b32eF8D513Ef71Ddac553270, a MerkleAirdrop contract.",
    "recordId": "sofa-rch-supply-capped-37m-s34",
    "surface": "RCH: mint capped at MAX_SUPPLY = 37,000,000 (totalMinted)"
   },
   "factors": [
    {
     "evidence": "sofa-rch-supply-capped-37m-s34: RCH token 0x57B96D4aF698605563A4653D882635da59Bf11AF (Ethereum; not a proxy: EIP-1967 implementation, admin and beacon slots all empty; verified source) …",
     "key": "upgrade",
     "label": "Upgradeability",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "Upgradeable; the delay gating the upgrade path is not in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "timelock",
     "label": "Timelock floor",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No enforced admin delay in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "quorum",
     "label": "Signer quorum",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No signer quorum in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "emergency",
     "label": "Emergency / freeze scope",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No pause / freeze authority in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "parity",
     "label": "Docs-vs-chain parity",
     "state": "g",
     "value": "Chain matches or is stronger than the documentation"
    }
   ],
   "finding": "RCH: mint capped at MAX_SUPPLY = 37,000,000 (totalMinted)",
   "grade": "aligned",
   "gradeLabel": "ALIGNED",
   "name": "SOFA.org",
   "pinnedBlock": 26453551,
   "probe": {
    "block_hash": "0x51e9967ffd6a84012d0dad44204d523b8ac43928e69de2801d2e72dbf8767129",
    "block_number": 26453551,
    "call_args": [],
    "call_signature": "totalSupply()",
    "chain": "ethereum",
    "check_type": "eth_call",
    "extra_calls": [],
    "id": "sofa-rch-supply-capped-37m-s34",
    "repro_calldata": "0x18160ddd",
    "rpc_env_var": "$ETH_RPC_URL",
    "selector_or_slot": "0x18160ddd",
    "target_contract": "0x57B96D4aF698605563A4653D882635da59Bf11AF",
    "target_label": "RCH token"
   },
   "reconciled": false,
   "reconciledFrom": [],
   "reconciledTo": [],
   "records": 1,
   "rosetteAria": "SOFA.org control-plane rosette: Upgradeability not determined; Timelock floor not determined; Signer quorum not determined; Emergency / freeze scope not determined; Docs-vs-chain parity strong",
   "search": "sofa.org sofa-org atomic on-chain settlement layer for options products (ethereum) rch 0x57b96d4af698605563a4653d882635da59bf11af 0x5a8cdda6ca37b284b32ef8d513ef71ddac553270",
   "slug": "sofa-org",
   "summary_short": "RCH minting is capped at 37,000,000, as documented",
   "url": "https://pacta.wtf/protocols/sofa-org/"
  },
  {
   "baskets": [],
   "category": "Bitcoin Reserve / Wrapped BTC",
   "chains": [
    "ethereum"
   ],
   "deltas": 0,
   "easAttested": true,
   "evidence": {
    "documented": "docs.solv.finance/llms-full.txt: 'The admin privileges for upgrades are assigned to a Gnosis Safe multi-signature address ... The timelock mechanism will be added to further enhance security by introducing a delay between the upgrade proposal and execution.'",
    "observed": "SolvBTC is a beacon proxy: EIP-1967 beacon slot = UpgradeableBeacon 0xFc335FdA7E6a33329A83F4d5F578eC7d8A43DC4A (implementation() = 0xA4b6cf2BAaA235ab7Fe10EADB84b82460165B38F), whose owner() = SolvBTCFactory 0x443628281E4f3E5b5A5D029B9a0D13900ae41578 (getBeacon('Solv BTC') = that beacon). The factory's admin() = TimelockController 0xfd4B809AD88db6Ca9dbB295A4B9d23bB0093f497 (pendingAdmin() = 0) with getMinDelay() = 259200s (3d); governor() = the 3-of-5 Safe 0x0c2Bc4d2698820e12E6eBe863E7b9E2650CD5b7D (pendingGovernor() = 0), which holds the timelock's PROPOSER_ROLE, EXECUTOR_ROLE and CANCELLER_ROLE but not DEFAULT_ADMIN_ROLE (held by the timelock itself; EXECUTOR_ROLE not open). Verified source pinned to runtime code: SolvBTCFactory is a Sourcify exact_match and every beacon-mutating path (setImplementation -> upgradeTo, transferBeaconOwnership, importBeacon) and transferAdmin is onlyAdmin, while onlyGovernor only deploys new beacon proxies; the timelock (SolvTimelock is OpenZeppelin v5.0.0 TimelockController, fully verified on Blockscout, not on Sourcify) reverts schedule when delay < getMinDelay() and only lets itself call updateDelay.",
    "recordId": "solv-solvbtc-upgrade-beacon-3d-timelock-s17",
    "surface": "SolvBTC beacon upgrades behind a 3d TimelockController (docs: timelock 'will be added')"
   },
   "factors": [
    {
     "evidence": "solv-solvbtc-upgrade-beacon-3d-timelock-s17: governor() = the 3-of-5 Safe 0x0c2Bc4d2698820e12E6eBe863E7b9E2650CD5b7D (pendingGovernor() = 0), which holds the timelock's PROPOSER_ROLE, EXECUTOR_ROLE and …",
     "key": "upgrade",
     "label": "Upgradeability",
     "state": "g",
     "value": "Upgradeable behind a ≥48h delay (3d)"
    },
    {
     "evidence": "controller fact: getMinDelay() = 259200s",
     "key": "timelock",
     "label": "Timelock floor",
     "state": "g",
     "value": "3d minimum enforced delay across control surfaces"
    },
    {
     "evidence": "solv-solvbtc-owner-3of5-safe-s17: … (0x7A56E1C57C7475CCf742a1832B028F0456652F97).owner() = 3-of-5 Safe 0x0c2Bc4d2698820e12E6eBe863E7b9E2650CD5b7D; …",
     "key": "quorum",
     "label": "Signer quorum",
     "state": "g",
     "value": "Lowest controlling quorum: 3-of-5"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "emergency",
     "label": "Emergency / freeze scope",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No pause / freeze authority in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "parity",
     "label": "Docs-vs-chain parity",
     "state": "g",
     "value": "Chain matches or is stronger than the documentation"
    }
   ],
   "finding": "SolvBTC beacon upgrades behind a 3d TimelockController (docs: timelock 'will be added'): docs say docs.solv.finance/llms-full.txt: 'The admin privileges for upgrades are assigned to a Gnosis Safe multi-signature address ... · chain says SolvBTC is a beacon proxy: EIP-1967 beacon slot = UpgradeableBeacon 0xFc335FdA7E6a33329A83F4d5F578eC7d8A43DC4A (implementation() = 0xA4b6cf2BAaA235ab7Fe10EADB84b82460165B38F), whose owner() = SolvBTCFactory 0x443628281E…",
   "grade": "protective",
   "gradeLabel": "PROTECTIVE",
   "name": "Solv Protocol (SolvBTC)",
   "pinnedBlock": 26418060,
   "probe": {
    "block_hash": "0x8914f5134a4488a812b61c1c7f479c3082d80f6fbe2f181abb9e5ef4ff973f3c",
    "block_number": 26418060,
    "call_args": [],
    "call_signature": "owner()",
    "chain": "ethereum",
    "check_type": "eth_call",
    "extra_calls": [],
    "id": "solv-solvbtc-owner-3of5-safe-s17",
    "repro_calldata": "0x8da5cb5b",
    "rpc_env_var": "$ETH_RPC_URL",
    "selector_or_slot": "0x8da5cb5b",
    "target_contract": "0x7A56E1C57C7475CCf742a1832B028F0456652F97",
    "target_label": "Solv SolvBTC"
   },
   "reconciled": false,
   "reconciledFrom": [],
   "reconciledTo": [],
   "records": 2,
   "rosetteAria": "Solv Protocol (SolvBTC) control-plane rosette: Upgradeability strong; Timelock floor strong; Signer quorum strong; Emergency / freeze scope not determined; Docs-vs-chain parity strong",
   "search": "solv protocol (solvbtc) solv-protocol-solvbtc bitcoin reserve / wrapped btc solvbtc solv 0x0c2bc4d2698820e12e6ebe863e7b9e2650cd5b7d 0x443628281e4f3e5b5a5d029b9a0d13900ae41578 0x7a56e1c57c7475ccf742a1832b028f0456652f97 0xa4b6cf2baaa235ab7fe10eadb84b82460165b38f 0xfc335fda7e6a33329a83f4d5f578ec7d8a43dc4a 0xfd4b809ad88db6ca9dbb295a4b9d23bb0093f497",
   "slug": "solv-protocol-solvbtc",
   "summary_short": "Beacon upgrades already wait 3 days in a timelock the docs say will be added",
   "url": "https://pacta.wtf/protocols/solv-protocol-solvbtc/"
  },
  {
   "baskets": [
    "lending_vaults"
   ],
   "category": "Automated vaults seeking yields while mitigating risk (Ethereum)",
   "chains": [
    "ethereum"
   ],
   "deltas": 0,
   "easAttested": true,
   "evidence": {
    "documented": "'It should be noted that a MultiSig is used to manage the Registry and PriceRouter smart contracts.' (sommelier-finance.gitbook.io/llms-full.txt)",
    "observed": "Registry 0x2Cbd27E034FEE53f79b607430dA7771B22050741 and Price Router 0x138a6d8c49428D4c71dD7596571fbd4699C7D3DA (Ethereum, the Cellars V2 infrastructure table): owner() = the Operations Timelock 0xaDa78a5E01325B91Bc7879a63c309F7D54d42950 (OpenZeppelin TimelockController, verified; getMinDelay() = 259,200 s), on which the Operations Multisig 0x7340D1FeCD4B64A4ac34f826B21c945d44d7407F holds PROPOSER_ROLE and EXECUTOR_ROLE (hasRole = true). The Multisig is a Safe: getThreshold() = 2 of getOwners() = 2; guard slot empty; getModulesPaginated() lists no module.",
    "recordId": "sommelier-registry-pricerouter-multisig-timelock-s36",
    "surface": "Registry / PriceRouter: Operations Multisig via a 3-day timelock"
   },
   "factors": [
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "upgrade",
     "label": "Upgradeability",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "Upgrade path not in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": "sommelier-registry-pricerouter-multisig-timelock-s36: observed_delay_seconds = 259200",
     "key": "timelock",
     "label": "Timelock floor",
     "state": "g",
     "value": "3d minimum enforced delay across control surfaces"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "quorum",
     "label": "Signer quorum",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No signer quorum in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "emergency",
     "label": "Emergency / freeze scope",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No pause / freeze authority in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "parity",
     "label": "Docs-vs-chain parity",
     "state": "g",
     "value": "Chain matches or is stronger than the documentation"
    }
   ],
   "finding": "Registry / PriceRouter: Operations Multisig via a 3-day timelock",
   "grade": "aligned",
   "gradeLabel": "ALIGNED",
   "name": "Sommelier",
   "pinnedBlock": 26455787,
   "probe": {
    "block_hash": "0x4fa7e0b166d674666a68121cfde1ecd9d61d03f101c4fe20f2081610e9f91316",
    "block_number": 26455787,
    "call_args": [],
    "call_signature": "owner()",
    "chain": "ethereum",
    "check_type": "eth_call",
    "extra_calls": [],
    "id": "sommelier-registry-pricerouter-multisig-timelock-s36",
    "repro_calldata": "0x8da5cb5b",
    "rpc_env_var": "$ETH_RPC_URL",
    "selector_or_slot": "0x8da5cb5b",
    "target_contract": "0x2Cbd27E034FEE53f79b607430dA7771B22050741",
    "target_label": "Sommelier Registry (Cellars V2)"
   },
   "reconciled": false,
   "reconciledFrom": [],
   "reconciledTo": [],
   "records": 1,
   "rosetteAria": "Sommelier control-plane rosette: Upgradeability not determined; Timelock floor strong; Signer quorum not determined; Emergency / freeze scope not determined; Docs-vs-chain parity strong",
   "search": "sommelier sommelier automated vaults seeking yields while mitigating risk (ethereum) somm 0x138a6d8c49428d4c71dd7596571fbd4699c7d3da 0x2cbd27e034fee53f79b607430da7771b22050741 0x7340d1fecd4b64a4ac34f826b21c945d44d7407f 0xada78a5e01325b91bc7879a63c309f7d54d42950",
   "slug": "sommelier",
   "summary_short": "Sommelier's Registry and PriceRouter are managed by its multisig, as documented",
   "url": "https://pacta.wtf/protocols/sommelier/"
  },
  {
   "baskets": [],
   "category": "L1 Canonical Bridge (token deposits) (Ethereum)",
   "chains": [
    "ethereum"
   ],
   "deltas": 1,
   "easAttested": true,
   "evidence": {
    "documented": "'In the highly unlikely event that the Gateway or the Sonic chain is down for 14 consecutive days, users are able to reclaim their bridged assets on Ethereum.' (docs.soniclabs.com/llms-full.txt)",
    "observed": "Sonic Gateway TokenDeposit 0xa1E2481a9CD0Cb0447EeB1cbc26F1b3fff3bec20 (Ethereum): UUPS proxy, implementation 0xAdE2eF0101278fe11490F2EE2aaD7915a094ADe9. In its verified source, fetchDeadStatus() marks the bridge dead (unlocking withdrawals and deposit cancels while dead) only once the StateOracle's lastUpdateTime is older than TIME_UNTIL_DEAD = 200 days; the runtime code read at this pin holds that constant (17,280,000 s) and no 14-day constant. exitAdministrator() = 0x7390251Bf35AA7eA7C196fc4750bd5d6c5918329 (the mechanism is off while it is zero; the owner sets it). _authorizeUpgrade is onlyOwner, and owner() = 0x9Fe65a5418850015a9D8ad3Ca50d6a0B9769FbE0, a 3-of-4 Safe, so the period can be changed by an upgrade. Not dead at this pin (deadState zero; StateOracle 0xB7e8CC3F5FeA12443136f0cc13D81F109B2dEd7f lastUpdateTime 1795109183).",
    "recordId": "sonic-gateway-fail-safe-200-days-s31",
    "surface": "Fail-safe recovery: bridge declared dead after 200 days offline (docs: 14 days, immutable)"
   },
   "factors": [
    {
     "evidence": "sonic-gateway-fail-safe-200-days-s31: Sonic Gateway TokenDeposit 0xa1E2481a9CD0Cb0447EeB1cbc26F1b3fff3bec20 (Ethereum): UUPS proxy, implementation 0xAdE2eF0101278fe11490F2EE2aaD7915a094ADe9. In its …",
     "key": "upgrade",
     "label": "Upgradeability",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "Upgradeable; the delay gating the upgrade path is not in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "timelock",
     "label": "Timelock floor",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No enforced admin delay in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": "sonic-gateway-fail-safe-200-days-s31: … 0x9Fe65a5418850015a9D8ad3Ca50d6a0B9769FbE0, a 3-of-4 Safe, so the period can be changed …",
     "key": "quorum",
     "label": "Signer quorum",
     "state": "g",
     "value": "Lowest controlling quorum: 3-of-4"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "emergency",
     "label": "Emergency / freeze scope",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No pause / freeze authority in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "parity",
     "label": "Docs-vs-chain parity",
     "state": "a",
     "value": "Documentation differs from the chain (parameter delta)"
    }
   ],
   "finding": "Fail-safe recovery: bridge declared dead after 200 days offline (docs: 14 days, immutable): docs say 'In the highly unlikely event that the Gateway or the Sonic chain is down for 14 consecutive days, users are able to reclaim their bridged assets on Ethereum.' (docs.soniclabs.com/llms-full.txt) · chain says Sonic Gateway TokenDeposit 0xa1E2481a9CD0Cb0447EeB1cbc26F1b3fff3bec20 (Ethereum): UUPS proxy, implementation 0xAdE2eF0101278fe11490F2EE2aaD7915a094ADe9.",
   "grade": "delta",
   "gradeLabel": "DELTA",
   "name": "Sonic Gateway",
   "pinnedBlock": 26450616,
   "probe": {
    "block_hash": "0xd2df7ccb74a6772b51a5597c8f144f5cfae362efeabf193ecfc7c80f8ff37c35",
    "block_number": 26450616,
    "call_args": [],
    "call_signature": "exitAdministrator()",
    "chain": "ethereum",
    "check_type": "eth_call",
    "extra_calls": [],
    "id": "sonic-gateway-fail-safe-200-days-s31",
    "repro_calldata": "0xb703ca85",
    "rpc_env_var": "$ETH_RPC_URL",
    "selector_or_slot": "0xb703ca85",
    "target_contract": "0xa1E2481a9CD0Cb0447EeB1cbc26F1b3fff3bec20",
    "target_label": "Sonic Gateway TokenDeposit (Ethereum)"
   },
   "reconciled": false,
   "reconciledFrom": [],
   "reconciledTo": [],
   "records": 1,
   "rosetteAria": "Sonic Gateway control-plane rosette: Upgradeability not determined; Timelock floor not determined; Signer quorum strong; Emergency / freeze scope not determined; Docs-vs-chain parity weak",
   "search": "sonic gateway sonic-gateway l1 canonical bridge (token deposits) (ethereum) sonic 0x7390251bf35aa7ea7c196fc4750bd5d6c5918329 0x9fe65a5418850015a9d8ad3ca50d6a0b9769fbe0 0xa1e2481a9cd0cb0447eeb1cbc26f1b3fff3bec20 0xade2ef0101278fe11490f2ee2aad7915a094ade9 0xb7e8cc3f5fea12443136f0cc13d81f109b2ded7f",
   "slug": "sonic-gateway",
   "summary_short": "Sonic Gateway's fail-safe opens after 200 days offline, not the documented 14",
   "url": "https://pacta.wtf/protocols/sonic-gateway/"
  },
  {
   "baskets": [
    "base",
    "lending_vaults"
   ],
   "category": "Spot crypto index tokens (SSI) with basis yield (Base)",
   "chains": [
    "base"
   ],
   "deltas": 0,
   "easAttested": true,
   "evidence": {
    "documented": "'SOSO was originally deployed as an ERC-20 token on Ethereum and subsequently made available on Base through the official Base bridge.' (sosovalue-white-paper.gitbook.io/sosovalue-whitepaper/8.-tokennomics/8.3-soso-token-cross-chain-architecture.md)",
    "observed": "SOSO token (Base) 0x624e2e7fDc8903165F64891672267AB0FCB98831 (Base; not a proxy: EIP-1967 implementation, admin and beacon slots all empty; verified source): totalSupply() = 73,536,304.93. The runtime code holds no selector of mint(uint256), upgradeTo(address), upgradeToAndCall(address,bytes). OptimismMintableERC20: BRIDGE() = 0x4200000000000000000000000000000000000010 (Base's canonical L2StandardBridge) and REMOTE_TOKEN() = 0x76A0e27618462bDAC7a29104bdcfFf4E6BFCea2D, the Ethereum SOSO the page lists; mint and burn are onlyBridge, so Base supply moves only through the canonical bridge.",
    "recordId": "sosovalue-soso-base-canonical-bridge-mint-s33",
    "surface": "Base SOSO: mint/burn only by the canonical L2StandardBridge"
   },
   "factors": [
    {
     "evidence": "sosovalue-soso-base-canonical-bridge-mint-s33: SOSO token (Base) 0x624e2e7fDc8903165F64891672267AB0FCB98831 (Base; not a proxy: EIP-1967 implementation, admin and beacon slots all empty; verified source) …",
     "key": "upgrade",
     "label": "Upgradeability",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "Upgradeable; the delay gating the upgrade path is not in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "timelock",
     "label": "Timelock floor",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No enforced admin delay in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "quorum",
     "label": "Signer quorum",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No signer quorum in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "emergency",
     "label": "Emergency / freeze scope",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No pause / freeze authority in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "parity",
     "label": "Docs-vs-chain parity",
     "state": "g",
     "value": "Chain matches or is stronger than the documentation"
    }
   ],
   "finding": "Base SOSO: mint/burn only by the canonical L2StandardBridge",
   "grade": "aligned",
   "gradeLabel": "ALIGNED",
   "name": "SoSoValue Basis",
   "pinnedBlock": 59699598,
   "probe": {
    "block_hash": "0x2f1913093955cab789adde23d44cae9905a757de878fbe6e589477a88e66cb0f",
    "block_number": 59699598,
    "call_args": [],
    "call_signature": "totalSupply()",
    "chain": "base",
    "check_type": "eth_call",
    "extra_calls": [],
    "id": "sosovalue-soso-base-canonical-bridge-mint-s33",
    "repro_calldata": "0x18160ddd",
    "rpc_env_var": "$BASE_RPC_URL",
    "selector_or_slot": "0x18160ddd",
    "target_contract": "0x624e2e7fDc8903165F64891672267AB0FCB98831",
    "target_label": "SOSO token (Base)"
   },
   "reconciled": false,
   "reconciledFrom": [],
   "reconciledTo": [],
   "records": 1,
   "rosetteAria": "SoSoValue Basis control-plane rosette: Upgradeability not determined; Timelock floor not determined; Signer quorum not determined; Emergency / freeze scope not determined; Docs-vs-chain parity strong",
   "search": "sosovalue basis sosovalue-basis spot crypto index tokens (ssi) with basis yield (base) soso 0x4200000000000000000000000000000000000010 0x624e2e7fdc8903165f64891672267ab0fcb98831 0x76a0e27618462bdac7a29104bdcfff4e6bfcea2d",
   "slug": "sosovalue-basis",
   "summary_short": "Base SOSO is minted only by the official Base bridge, as documented",
   "url": "https://pacta.wtf/protocols/sosovalue-basis/"
  },
  {
   "baskets": [
    "base",
    "stable_rwa"
   ],
   "category": "Decentralized Credit & Liquidity",
   "chains": [
    "base",
    "ethereum"
   ],
   "deltas": 0,
   "easAttested": true,
   "evidence": {
    "documented": "Sky 48-hour Governance Security Module (GSM) delay and Spark SubDAO proxy ownership.",
    "observed": "GSM_PAUSE_PROXY.delay() = 172800s (48 hours); Spark PoolAddressesProvider (0x02C3eA4e34C0cBd694D2adFa2c690EECbC1793eE) owner() = 0x3300f198988e4C9C63F75dF86De36421f06af8c4 (SPARK_PROXY).",
    "recordId": "spark-sky-gsm-pause-delay",
    "surface": "Sampled PoolAddressesProvider Owner & GSM Delay"
   },
   "factors": [
    {
     "evidence": "spark-susdc-base-uups-as-documented-s36: sUSDC 0x3128a0F7f0ea68E7B7c9B00AFa7E41045828e858 (Base, the address the sUSDC page lists): ERC-1967 implementation slot = …",
     "key": "upgrade",
     "label": "Upgradeability",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "Upgradeable; the delay gating the upgrade path is not in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": "spark-sky-gsm-pause-delay: GSM_PAUSE_PROXY.delay() = 172800s (48 hours); Spark PoolAddressesProvider …",
     "key": "timelock",
     "label": "Timelock floor",
     "state": "g",
     "value": "2d minimum enforced delay across control surfaces"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "quorum",
     "label": "Signer quorum",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No signer quorum in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "emergency",
     "label": "Emergency / freeze scope",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No pause / freeze authority in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "parity",
     "label": "Docs-vs-chain parity",
     "state": "g",
     "value": "Chain matches or is stronger than the documentation"
    }
   ],
   "finding": "Sampled PoolAddressesProvider Owner & GSM Delay",
   "grade": "aligned",
   "gradeLabel": "ALIGNED",
   "name": "Spark / Sky",
   "pinnedBlock": 59903224,
   "probe": {
    "block_hash": "0xe62ad2969617ad07c23bec298c3d5e197ea7c3084f7f66c90d2eb51d04c6273e",
    "block_number": 26401638,
    "call_args": [],
    "call_signature": "delay()",
    "chain": "ethereum",
    "check_type": "eth_call",
    "extra_calls": [],
    "id": "spark-sky-gsm-pause-delay",
    "repro_calldata": "0x6a42b8f8",
    "rpc_env_var": "$ETH_RPC_URL",
    "selector_or_slot": "0x6a42b8f8",
    "target_contract": "0xbE286431454714F511008713973d3B053A2d38f3",
    "target_label": "GSM_PAUSE_PROXY"
   },
   "reconciled": false,
   "reconciledFrom": [],
   "reconciledTo": [],
   "records": 2,
   "rosetteAria": "Spark / Sky control-plane rosette: Upgradeability not determined; Timelock floor strong; Signer quorum not determined; Emergency / freeze scope not determined; Docs-vs-chain parity strong",
   "search": "spark / sky spark-sky decentralized credit & liquidity usds susds dai sky mkr spk 0x02c3ea4e34c0cbd694d2adfa2c690eecbc1793ee 0x3128a0f7f0ea68e7b7c9b00afa7e41045828e858 0x3300f198988e4c9c63f75df86de36421f06af8c4 0x56072c95faa701256059aa122697b133aded9279 0x6acc02ddd82206a44ff4ec13977e63d1a29c7723 0x6b175474e89094c44da98b954eedeac495271d0f 0x833589fcd6edb6e08f4c7c32d4f71b54bda02913 0xa3931d71877c0e7a3148cb7eb4463524fec27fbd 0xbe286431454714f511008713973d3b053a2d38f3 0xc13e21b648a5ee794902342038ff3adab66be987 0xdc035d45d973e3ec169d2276ddab16f1e407384f",
   "slug": "spark-sky",
   "summary_short": "Addresses provider owner and governance delay match the docs",
   "url": "https://pacta.wtf/protocols/spark-sky/"
  },
  {
   "baskets": [
    "lending_vaults"
   ],
   "category": "Curated fixed-rate vaults with automated rollovers (Base)",
   "chains": [
    "ethereum"
   ],
   "deltas": 0,
   "easAttested": true,
   "evidence": {
    "documented": "'MetaVault contracts use a proxy pattern — the addresses below are the proxy addresses that users and integrators should interact with.' (dev.spectra.finance/docs/metavaults/deployed-contracts.md)",
    "observed": "Spectra MetaVaults TransparentUpgradeableProxy 0x16b28223b607B4D90e2eC628fdC1a0AD9Ee1f6B8 (Ethereum): EIP-1967 implementation slot = 0x47a9B7E7E1bf368D2e0f3053Dde9270DD8E48eEA, admin slot = 0xf300d5032D7F607f1C5a54BA70b93bAA62172f20; upgradeable (EIP-1967 implementation + admin slot (transparent proxy)).",
    "recordId": "spectra-metavaults-upgradeability-16b282-s30",
    "surface": "Spectra MetaVaults TransparentUpgradeableProxy: upgradeable (proxy admin), as documented"
   },
   "factors": [
    {
     "evidence": "spectra-metavaults-upgradeability-16b282-s30: Spectra MetaVaults TransparentUpgradeableProxy 0x16b28223b607B4D90e2eC628fdC1a0AD9Ee1f6B8 (Ethereum): EIP-1967 implementation slot = …",
     "key": "upgrade",
     "label": "Upgradeability",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "Upgradeable; the delay gating the upgrade path is not in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "timelock",
     "label": "Timelock floor",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No enforced admin delay in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "quorum",
     "label": "Signer quorum",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No signer quorum in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "emergency",
     "label": "Emergency / freeze scope",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No pause / freeze authority in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "parity",
     "label": "Docs-vs-chain parity",
     "state": "g",
     "value": "Chain matches or is stronger than the documentation"
    }
   ],
   "finding": "Spectra MetaVaults TransparentUpgradeableProxy: upgradeable (proxy admin), as documented",
   "grade": "aligned",
   "gradeLabel": "ALIGNED",
   "name": "Spectra MetaVaults",
   "pinnedBlock": 26449594,
   "probe": {
    "block_hash": "0xbe263d5b378dcb7c3c4e18bd8e388f0cb2dab1adacd83de2be58c9408b377287",
    "block_number": 26449594,
    "call_args": [],
    "call_signature": null,
    "chain": "ethereum",
    "check_type": "eth_getStorageAt",
    "extra_calls": [],
    "id": "spectra-metavaults-upgradeability-16b282-s30",
    "repro_calldata": null,
    "rpc_env_var": "$ETH_RPC_URL",
    "selector_or_slot": "0x360894a13ba1a3210667c828492db98dca3e2076cc3735a920a3ca505d382bbc",
    "target_contract": "0x16b28223b607B4D90e2eC628fdC1a0AD9Ee1f6B8",
    "target_label": "Spectra MetaVaults TransparentUpgradeableProxy"
   },
   "reconciled": false,
   "reconciledFrom": [],
   "reconciledTo": [],
   "records": 1,
   "rosetteAria": "Spectra MetaVaults control-plane rosette: Upgradeability not determined; Timelock floor not determined; Signer quorum not determined; Emergency / freeze scope not determined; Docs-vs-chain parity strong",
   "search": "spectra metavaults spectra-metavaults curated fixed-rate vaults with automated rollovers (base) spectra 0x16b28223b607b4d90e2ec628fdc1a0ad9ee1f6b8 0x47a9b7e7e1bf368d2e0f3053dde9270dd8e48eea 0xf300d5032d7f607f1c5a54ba70b93baa62172f20",
   "slug": "spectra-metavaults",
   "summary_short": "The MetavaultsRegistry proxy is upgradeable (proxy admin), as its docs state",
   "url": "https://pacta.wtf/protocols/spectra-metavaults/"
  },
  {
   "baskets": [
    "base"
   ],
   "category": "Fantasy football player-share trading settled on match performance (Base)",
   "chains": [
    "base"
   ],
   "deltas": 0,
   "easAttested": false,
   "evidence": {
    "documented": "Sport.fun documentation is linked for reference (https://docs.sport.fun/en/). This RPC-pinned record does not compare documentation parameters with the on-chain state.",
    "observed": "Sport.fun (0x16EE7ecAc70d1028E7712751E2Ee6BA808a7dd92) verified on Base Mainnet at canonical block #60,070,202 (141 bytes runtime code). EIP-1967 proxy: implementation 0x14ad363A292a2d837dFf864556663ec9Fa958Cb6, admin slot zero. No owner(), admin(), authority(), curator() or AccessControl admin was readable on the contract.",
    "recordId": "sport-fun-control-plane",
    "surface": "Sport.fun · EIP-1967 Proxy & Controller Chain"
   },
   "factors": [
    {
     "evidence": "sport-fun-control-plane: is_eip1967_proxy = true",
     "key": "upgrade",
     "label": "Upgradeability",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "Upgradeable; the delay gating the upgrade path is not in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "timelock",
     "label": "Timelock floor",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No enforced admin delay in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "quorum",
     "label": "Signer quorum",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No signer quorum in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "emergency",
     "label": "Emergency / freeze scope",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No pause / freeze authority in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "parity",
     "label": "Docs-vs-chain parity",
     "state": "u",
     "value": "Uncompared: documentation not assessed (RPC-observed)"
    }
   ],
   "finding": "Sport.fun · EIP-1967 Proxy & Controller Chain",
   "grade": "observed",
   "gradeLabel": "OBSERVED",
   "name": "Sport.fun",
   "pinnedBlock": 60070202,
   "probe": {
    "block_hash": "0x01b3f5dcecb67c63ba33350ec6942563f6b8a0d8ca9b4f69a752844a5bab4a20",
    "block_number": 60070202,
    "call_args": [],
    "call_signature": "owner()",
    "chain": "base",
    "check_type": "eth_call",
    "extra_calls": [],
    "id": "sport-fun-control-plane",
    "repro_calldata": "0x8da5cb5b",
    "rpc_env_var": "$BASE_RPC_URL",
    "selector_or_slot": "0x8da5cb5b",
    "target_contract": "0x16EE7ecAc70d1028E7712751E2Ee6BA808a7dd92",
    "target_label": "Sport.fun"
   },
   "reconciled": false,
   "reconciledFrom": [],
   "reconciledTo": [],
   "records": 1,
   "rosetteAria": "Sport.fun control-plane rosette: Upgradeability not determined; Timelock floor not determined; Signer quorum not determined; Emergency / freeze scope not determined; Docs-vs-chain parity uncompared",
   "search": "sport.fun sport-fun fantasy football player-share trading settled on match performance (base) fun 0x14ad363a292a2d837dff864556663ec9fa958cb6 0x16ee7ecac70d1028e7712751e2ee6ba808a7dd92",
   "slug": "sport-fun",
   "summary_short": "Upgradeable proxy no readable owner or admin; docs not assessed",
   "url": "https://pacta.wtf/protocols/sport-fun/"
  },
  {
   "baskets": [
    "eth_lst_lrt"
   ],
   "category": "Distributed Validator Infrastructure",
   "chains": [
    "ethereum"
   ],
   "deltas": 0,
   "easAttested": true,
   "evidence": {
    "documented": "docs.ssv.network (governance): 'The first is execution of governance functions controlled by the governance multisig.' / smart contracts: 'SSV DAO Treasury 0xb35096b074fdb9bBac63E3AdaE0Bbde512B2E6b6'",
    "observed": "SSVNetwork 0xDD9BC35aE942eF0cFa76930954a156B3fF30a4E1: owner() = SSV DAO Treasury 0xb35096b074fdb9bBac63E3AdaE0Bbde512B2E6b6, a 5-of-9 Safe (v1.3.0, no modules); pendingOwner() = 0; SSVNetworkViews 0xafE830B6Ee262ba11cce5F32fDCd760FFE6a66e4 has the same owner(); both are UUPS proxies (empty EIP-1967 admin slot).",
    "recordId": "ssv-network-dao-multisig-owns-network-s21",
    "surface": "SSVNetwork and SSVNetworkViews owner: the DAO governance multisig"
   },
   "factors": [
    {
     "evidence": "ssv-network-dao-multisig-owns-network-s21: both are UUPS proxies (empty EIP-1967 admin slot).",
     "key": "upgrade",
     "label": "Upgradeability",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "Upgradeable; the delay gating the upgrade path is not in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "timelock",
     "label": "Timelock floor",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No enforced admin delay in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": "ssv-network-dao-multisig-owns-network-s21: … 0xb35096b074fdb9bBac63E3AdaE0Bbde512B2E6b6, a 5-of-9 Safe (v1.3.0, no modules); pendingOwner() …",
     "key": "quorum",
     "label": "Signer quorum",
     "state": "g",
     "value": "Lowest controlling quorum: 5-of-9"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "emergency",
     "label": "Emergency / freeze scope",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No pause / freeze authority in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "parity",
     "label": "Docs-vs-chain parity",
     "state": "g",
     "value": "Chain matches or is stronger than the documentation"
    }
   ],
   "finding": "SSVNetwork and SSVNetworkViews owner: the DAO governance multisig",
   "grade": "aligned",
   "gradeLabel": "ALIGNED",
   "name": "SSV Network",
   "pinnedBlock": 26427612,
   "probe": {
    "block_hash": "0x1c5ef52eb0b586e49da2a11dc9f905cae4125008dc814d6781f53a142f6555ac",
    "block_number": 26427612,
    "call_args": [],
    "call_signature": "owner()",
    "chain": "ethereum",
    "check_type": "eth_call",
    "extra_calls": [],
    "id": "ssv-network-dao-multisig-owns-network-s21",
    "repro_calldata": "0x8da5cb5b",
    "rpc_env_var": "$ETH_RPC_URL",
    "selector_or_slot": "0x8da5cb5b",
    "target_contract": "0xDD9BC35aE942eF0cFa76930954a156B3fF30a4E1",
    "target_label": "SSVNetwork (UUPS proxy)"
   },
   "reconciled": false,
   "reconciledFrom": [],
   "reconciledTo": [],
   "records": 2,
   "rosetteAria": "SSV Network control-plane rosette: Upgradeability not determined; Timelock floor not determined; Signer quorum strong; Emergency / freeze scope not determined; Docs-vs-chain parity strong",
   "search": "ssv network ssv-network distributed validator infrastructure ssv 0xafe830b6ee262ba11cce5f32fdcd760ffe6a66e4 0xb35096b074fdb9bbac63e3adae0bbde512b2e6b6 0xdd9bc35ae942ef0cfa76930954a156b3ff30a4e1",
   "slug": "ssv-network",
   "summary_short": "SSVNetwork owner is the DAO governance multisig, as documented",
   "url": "https://pacta.wtf/protocols/ssv-network/"
  },
  {
   "baskets": [
    "lending_vaults",
    "stable_rwa"
   ],
   "category": "Stablecoin yield from funding-rate arbitrage on crypto exchanges, paid to stakers (Ethereum)",
   "chains": [
    "ethereum"
   ],
   "deltas": 0,
   "easAttested": false,
   "evidence": {
    "documented": "StableHodl documentation is linked for reference (https://docs.stablehodl.com/). This RPC-pinned record does not compare documentation parameters with the on-chain state.",
    "observed": "stake_pool (0x109D3042a3c682F94107b3818e93b3aDE2A47544) verified on Ethereum Mainnet at canonical block #26,458,556 (170 bytes runtime code). EIP-1967 proxy: implementation 0xc34DF695167aA2F9571976fFD5e3E0E95A53E470, admin slot zero. No owner(), admin(), authority(), curator() or AccessControl admin was readable on the contract.",
    "recordId": "stablehodl-control-plane",
    "surface": "stake_pool · EIP-1967 Proxy & Controller Chain"
   },
   "factors": [
    {
     "evidence": "stablehodl-control-plane: is_eip1967_proxy = true",
     "key": "upgrade",
     "label": "Upgradeability",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "Upgradeable; the delay gating the upgrade path is not in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "timelock",
     "label": "Timelock floor",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No enforced admin delay in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "quorum",
     "label": "Signer quorum",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No signer quorum in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "emergency",
     "label": "Emergency / freeze scope",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No pause / freeze authority in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "parity",
     "label": "Docs-vs-chain parity",
     "state": "u",
     "value": "Uncompared: documentation not assessed (RPC-observed)"
    }
   ],
   "finding": "stake_pool · EIP-1967 Proxy & Controller Chain",
   "grade": "observed",
   "gradeLabel": "OBSERVED",
   "name": "StableHodl",
   "pinnedBlock": 26458556,
   "probe": {
    "block_hash": "0xe258bb1cbcc988e2dfdba4ba173f9f8690520dba3647cdcae18e0651822769d2",
    "block_number": 26458556,
    "call_args": [],
    "call_signature": "owner()",
    "chain": "ethereum",
    "check_type": "eth_call",
    "extra_calls": [],
    "id": "stablehodl-control-plane",
    "repro_calldata": "0x8da5cb5b",
    "rpc_env_var": "$ETH_RPC_URL",
    "selector_or_slot": "0x8da5cb5b",
    "target_contract": "0x109D3042a3c682F94107b3818e93b3aDE2A47544",
    "target_label": "stake_pool"
   },
   "reconciled": false,
   "reconciledFrom": [],
   "reconciledTo": [],
   "records": 1,
   "rosetteAria": "StableHodl control-plane rosette: Upgradeability not determined; Timelock floor not determined; Signer quorum not determined; Emergency / freeze scope not determined; Docs-vs-chain parity uncompared",
   "search": "stablehodl stablehodl stablecoin yield from funding-rate arbitrage on crypto exchanges, paid to stakers (ethereum) stablehodl 0x109d3042a3c682f94107b3818e93b3ade2a47544 0xc34df695167aa2f9571976ffd5e3e0e95a53e470",
   "slug": "stablehodl",
   "summary_short": "Upgradeable proxy no readable owner or admin; docs not assessed",
   "url": "https://pacta.wtf/protocols/stablehodl/"
  },
  {
   "baskets": [
    "eth_lst_lrt"
   ],
   "category": "Liquid Staking",
   "chains": [
    "ethereum"
   ],
   "deltas": 1,
   "easAttested": true,
   "evidence": {
    "documented": "staderlabs.gitbook.io/ethereum states 'The Manager multisig is a 3-of-5 and is tasked with maintaining the protocol' and specifies a 7-day minimum delay on contract upgrades.",
    "observed": "Manager Safe (0xAAfb31780e4b9c95Bc920e388f4925A874cd07AF) getThreshold() = 3, getOwners().length = 6 (3-of-6 Gnosis Safe); ETHx (0xA35b1B31Ce002FBF2058D22F30f95D405200A15b) EIP-1967 admin slot = ProxyAdmin (0x67B12264Ca3e0037Fc7E22F2457b42643a04C86e), owner() = TimelockController (0x1112D5C55670Cb5144BF36114C20a122908068B9, getMinDelay() = 604800s / 7d, PROPOSER_ROLE held by 6-of-9 Community Safe 0x45B977CeCB9Dfaa17dFcBa88826ef684b8489fF6), which also holds DEFAULT_ADMIN_ROLE on ETHx and StaderConfig (0x4ABEF2263d5A5ED582FC9A9789a41D85b68d69DB); ETHx MINTER_ROLE held by StakePoolsManager (0xcf5EA1b38380f6aF39068375516Daf40Ed70D299), totalSupply = 58,434.16 ETHx (18 dec).",
    "recordId": "stader-ethx-manager-safe-and-timelock",
    "surface": "Manager Safe Quorum & 7-Day TimelockController Admin Path"
   },
   "factors": [
    {
     "evidence": "stader-ethx-manager-safe-and-timelock: ETHx (0xA35b1B31Ce002FBF2058D22F30f95D405200A15b) EIP-1967 admin slot = ProxyAdmin (0x67B12264Ca3e0037Fc7E22F2457b42643a04C86e), owner() = TimelockController …",
     "key": "upgrade",
     "label": "Upgradeability",
     "state": "g",
     "value": "Upgradeable behind a ≥48h delay (7d)"
    },
    {
     "evidence": "controller fact: getMinDelay() = 604800s",
     "key": "timelock",
     "label": "Timelock floor",
     "state": "g",
     "value": "7d minimum enforced delay across control surfaces"
    },
    {
     "evidence": "stader-ethx-manager-safe-and-timelock: … getThreshold() = 3, getOwners().length = 6 (3-of-6 Gnosis Safe); ETHx (0xA35b1B31Ce002FBF2058D22F30f95D405200A15b) …",
     "key": "quorum",
     "label": "Signer quorum",
     "state": "g",
     "value": "Lowest controlling quorum: 3-of-6"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "emergency",
     "label": "Emergency / freeze scope",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No pause / freeze authority in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "parity",
     "label": "Docs-vs-chain parity",
     "state": "a",
     "value": "Documentation differs from the chain (parameter delta)"
    }
   ],
   "finding": "Safe threshold: docs say 3-of-5 · chain says 3-of-6",
   "grade": "delta",
   "gradeLabel": "DELTA",
   "name": "Stader Labs (ETHx)",
   "pinnedBlock": 26403676,
   "probe": {
    "block_hash": "0xf4246ca23c4c38d520de16080a11b5186d04c8242b2c85edcb04c455d291c3ae",
    "block_number": 26403676,
    "call_args": [],
    "call_signature": "getThreshold()",
    "chain": "ethereum",
    "check_type": "eth_call",
    "extra_calls": [],
    "id": "stader-ethx-manager-safe-and-timelock",
    "repro_calldata": "0xe75235b8",
    "rpc_env_var": "$ETH_RPC_URL",
    "selector_or_slot": "0xe75235b8",
    "target_contract": "0xAAfb31780e4b9c95Bc920e388f4925A874cd07AF",
    "target_label": "Stader Manager Safe"
   },
   "reconciled": false,
   "reconciledFrom": [],
   "reconciledTo": [],
   "records": 1,
   "rosetteAria": "Stader Labs (ETHx) control-plane rosette: Upgradeability strong; Timelock floor strong; Signer quorum strong; Emergency / freeze scope not determined; Docs-vs-chain parity weak",
   "search": "stader labs (ethx) stader-labs-ethx liquid staking ethx sd 0x1112d5c55670cb5144bf36114c20a122908068b9 0x45b977cecb9dfaa17dfcba88826ef684b8489ff6 0x4abef2263d5a5ed582fc9a9789a41d85b68d69db 0x67b12264ca3e0037fc7e22f2457b42643a04c86e 0xa35b1b31ce002fbf2058d22f30f95d405200a15b 0xaafb31780e4b9c95bc920e388f4925a874cd07af 0xcf5ea1b38380f6af39068375516daf40ed70d299",
   "slug": "stader-labs-ethx",
   "summary_short": "Manager Safe: docs 3-of-5 · chain 3-of-6",
   "url": "https://pacta.wtf/protocols/stader-labs-ethx/"
  },
  {
   "baskets": [
    "eth_lst_lrt"
   ],
   "category": "Liquid staking derivatives across chains (Ethereum)",
   "chains": [
    "ethereum"
   ],
   "deltas": 0,
   "easAttested": false,
   "evidence": {
    "documented": "Stafi documentation is linked for reference (https://docs.stafi.io/). This RPC-pinned record does not compare documentation parameters with the on-chain state.",
    "observed": "StaFi (FISToken) (0xef3A930e1FfFFAcd2fc13434aC81bD278B0ecC8d) verified on Ethereum Mainnet at canonical block #26,458,556 (9,840 bytes runtime code). EIP-1967 implementation and admin storage slots are both zero (non-EIP-1967 contract). No owner(), admin(), authority(), curator() or AccessControl admin was readable on the contract.",
    "recordId": "stafi-control-plane",
    "surface": "StaFi (FISToken) · Non-Proxy Bytecode & Controller"
   },
   "factors": [
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "upgrade",
     "label": "Upgradeability",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "Upgrade path not in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "timelock",
     "label": "Timelock floor",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No enforced admin delay in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "quorum",
     "label": "Signer quorum",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No signer quorum in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "emergency",
     "label": "Emergency / freeze scope",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No pause / freeze authority in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "parity",
     "label": "Docs-vs-chain parity",
     "state": "u",
     "value": "Uncompared: documentation not assessed (RPC-observed)"
    }
   ],
   "finding": "StaFi (FISToken) · Non-Proxy Bytecode & Controller",
   "grade": "observed",
   "gradeLabel": "OBSERVED",
   "name": "Stafi",
   "pinnedBlock": 26458556,
   "probe": {
    "block_hash": "0xe258bb1cbcc988e2dfdba4ba173f9f8690520dba3647cdcae18e0651822769d2",
    "block_number": 26458556,
    "call_args": [],
    "call_signature": "owner()",
    "chain": "ethereum",
    "check_type": "eth_call",
    "extra_calls": [],
    "id": "stafi-control-plane",
    "repro_calldata": "0x8da5cb5b",
    "rpc_env_var": "$ETH_RPC_URL",
    "selector_or_slot": "0x8da5cb5b",
    "target_contract": "0xef3A930e1FfFFAcd2fc13434aC81bD278B0ecC8d",
    "target_label": "StaFi (FISToken)"
   },
   "reconciled": false,
   "reconciledFrom": [],
   "reconciledTo": [],
   "records": 1,
   "rosetteAria": "Stafi control-plane rosette: Upgradeability not determined; Timelock floor not determined; Signer quorum not determined; Emergency / freeze scope not determined; Docs-vs-chain parity uncompared",
   "search": "stafi stafi liquid staking derivatives across chains (ethereum) fis 0xef3a930e1ffffacd2fc13434ac81bd278b0ecc8d",
   "slug": "stafi",
   "summary_short": "Non-proxy contract no readable owner or admin; docs not assessed",
   "url": "https://pacta.wtf/protocols/stafi/"
  },
  {
   "baskets": [
    "lending_vaults"
   ],
   "category": "Liquid Lockers & Yield Strategies",
   "chains": [
    "ethereum"
   ],
   "deltas": 2,
   "easAttested": true,
   "evidence": {
    "documented": "docs.stakedao.org (timelock): 'Stake DAO's core contracts are protected by a governance timelock that enforces a 48-hour delay on all protocol changes.' and 'A proposer submits the operation with a minimum 48-hour delay'",
    "observed": "ProtocolTimelock 0xb27afc7844988948FBd6210AeF4E1362bC2d8E6a: getMinDelay() = 432000s (5 days). It owns the ProtocolController 0x2d8BcE1FaE00a959354aCD9eBf9174337A64d4fb; the Governance Safe 0xB0552b6860CE5C0202976Db056b5e3Cc4f9CC765 holds PROPOSER_ROLE; OpenZeppelin TimelockController (Sourcify exact match).",
    "recordId": "stake-dao-protocol-timelock-min-delay-5d-s22",
    "surface": "Protocol changes wait 5 days, longer than the documented 48 hours"
   },
   "factors": [
    {
     "evidence": "stake-dao-timelock-owns-protocol-controller-s22: … 0xb27afc7844988948FBd6210AeF4E1362bC2d8E6a; pendingOwner() = 0; not a proxy (Sourcify exact match); the timelock's …",
     "key": "upgrade",
     "label": "Upgradeability",
     "state": "g",
     "value": "Immutable or ownership renounced"
    },
    {
     "evidence": "controller fact: getMinDelay() = 432000s",
     "key": "timelock",
     "label": "Timelock floor",
     "state": "g",
     "value": "5d minimum enforced delay across control surfaces"
    },
    {
     "evidence": "stake-dao-timelock-executor-permissioned-s22: … 0xB0552b6860CE5C0202976Db056b5e3Cc4f9CC765 (3-of-5, Safe v1.3.0, 3 modules enabled) holds …",
     "key": "quorum",
     "label": "Signer quorum",
     "state": "g",
     "value": "Lowest controlling quorum: 3-of-5"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "emergency",
     "label": "Emergency / freeze scope",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No pause / freeze authority in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "parity",
     "label": "Docs-vs-chain parity",
     "state": "a",
     "value": "Documentation differs from the chain (parameter delta)"
    }
   ],
   "finding": "Timelock delay: docs say 2 d · chain says 5 d",
   "grade": "delta",
   "gradeLabel": "DELTA",
   "name": "Stake DAO",
   "pinnedBlock": 26429396,
   "probe": {
    "block_hash": "0x3fb83aa053c26ac6b98d634858da1b3c23bb65bae7a12f8f14d72d8273e16d71",
    "block_number": 26429396,
    "call_args": [
     "0xd8aa0f3194971a2a116679f7c2090f6939c8d4e01a2a8d7e41d55e5351469e63",
     "0x0000000000000000000000000000000000000000"
    ],
    "call_signature": "hasRole(bytes32,address)",
    "chain": "ethereum",
    "check_type": "eth_call",
    "extra_calls": [],
    "id": "stake-dao-timelock-executor-permissioned-s22",
    "repro_calldata": "0x91d14854d8aa0f3194971a2a116679f7c2090f6939c8d4e01a2a8d7e41d55e5351469e630000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000",
    "rpc_env_var": "$ETH_RPC_URL",
    "selector_or_slot": "0x91d14854",
    "target_contract": "0xb27afc7844988948FBd6210AeF4E1362bC2d8E6a",
    "target_label": "Stake DAO ProtocolTimelock"
   },
   "reconciled": false,
   "reconciledFrom": [],
   "reconciledTo": [],
   "records": 4,
   "rosetteAria": "Stake DAO control-plane rosette: Upgradeability strong; Timelock floor strong; Signer quorum strong; Emergency / freeze scope not determined; Docs-vs-chain parity weak",
   "search": "stake dao stake-dao liquid lockers & yield strategies sdt vesdt 0x2d8bce1fae00a959354acd9ebf9174337a64d4fb 0xb0552b6860ce5c0202976db056b5e3cc4f9cc765 0xb27afc7844988948fbd6210aef4e1362bc2d8e6a 0xf930ebbd05ef8b25b1797b9b2109ddc9b0d43063",
   "slug": "stake-dao",
   "summary_short": "Timelock: docs 2 days · chain 5 days; Treasury Safe 3-of-5, not 4-of-7",
   "url": "https://pacta.wtf/protocols/stake-dao/"
  },
  {
   "baskets": [
    "eth_lst_lrt"
   ],
   "category": "Liquid Staking (LINK)",
   "chains": [
    "ethereum"
   ],
   "deltas": 0,
   "easAttested": true,
   "evidence": {
    "documented": "docs.stake.link (security and audits): '48-hour timelock. Actions executed by the multisig go through the GovernanceTimelock , which gives the community time to review pending changes.'",
    "observed": "GovernanceTimelock 0xb72d8F5213b3E52FAf13Aa074b03C4788e78349F: getMinDelay() = 172800 (48 hours); owner() of StakingPool / stLINK 0xb8b295df2cd735b15BE5Eb419517Aa626fc43cD5, PriorityPool, WithdrawalPool, FundFlowController, RebaseController, OperatorVCS and CommunityVCS; PROPOSER / CANCELLER = the multisig 0xB351EC0FEaF4B99FdFD36b484d9EC90D0422493D.",
    "recordId": "stake-link-governance-timelock-48h-s20",
    "surface": "GovernanceTimelock delay: 48 hours"
   },
   "factors": [
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "upgrade",
     "label": "Upgradeability",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "Upgrade path not in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": "controller fact: getMinDelay() = 172800s",
     "key": "timelock",
     "label": "Timelock floor",
     "state": "g",
     "value": "2d minimum enforced delay across control surfaces"
    },
    {
     "evidence": "controller fact: Safe getThreshold()",
     "key": "quorum",
     "label": "Signer quorum",
     "state": "g",
     "value": "Lowest controlling quorum: 6-of-8"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "emergency",
     "label": "Emergency / freeze scope",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No pause / freeze authority in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "parity",
     "label": "Docs-vs-chain parity",
     "state": "g",
     "value": "Chain matches or is stronger than the documentation"
    }
   ],
   "finding": "GovernanceTimelock delay: 48 hours",
   "grade": "aligned",
   "gradeLabel": "ALIGNED",
   "name": "stake.link",
   "pinnedBlock": 26425374,
   "probe": {
    "block_hash": "0xfa22e277760f1df7134b0af20499d6305ee4e017219a917a61a78aa76e89382d",
    "block_number": 26425374,
    "call_args": [],
    "call_signature": "getMinDelay()",
    "chain": "ethereum",
    "check_type": "eth_call",
    "extra_calls": [],
    "id": "stake-link-governance-timelock-48h-s20",
    "repro_calldata": "0xf27a0c92",
    "rpc_env_var": "$ETH_RPC_URL",
    "selector_or_slot": "0xf27a0c92",
    "target_contract": "0xb72d8F5213b3E52FAf13Aa074b03C4788e78349F",
    "target_label": "stake.link GovernanceTimelock (owner of StakingPool, PriorityPool, WithdrawalPool)"
   },
   "reconciled": false,
   "reconciledFrom": [],
   "reconciledTo": [],
   "records": 3,
   "rosetteAria": "stake.link control-plane rosette: Upgradeability not determined; Timelock floor strong; Signer quorum strong; Emergency / freeze scope not determined; Docs-vs-chain parity strong",
   "search": "stake.link stake-link liquid staking (link) stlink sdl 0x4852e48215a4785ee99b640caced5378cc39d2a4 0x8753c00d1a94d04a01b931830011d882a3f8cc72 0xac12290b097f6893322f5430627e472131fbc1b5 0xb351ec0feaf4b99fdfd36b484d9ec90d0422493d 0xb72d8f5213b3e52faf13aa074b03c4788e78349f 0xb8b295df2cd735b15be5eb419517aa626fc43cd5",
   "slug": "stake-link",
   "summary_short": "Governance timelock delay is 48 hours, as documented",
   "url": "https://pacta.wtf/protocols/stake-link/"
  },
  {
   "baskets": [
    "eth_lst_lrt",
    "lending_vaults"
   ],
   "category": "Omnichain liquid staking token with rebalanced validator yield (Ethereum)",
   "chains": [
    "ethereum"
   ],
   "deltas": 0,
   "easAttested": true,
   "evidence": {
    "documented": "'**Maximum Token Supply** | 1,000,000,000' (docs.stakestone.io/stakestone/additionals/tokenomics.md)",
    "observed": "STO token 0x1D88713b483A8E45cfF0e5CD7c2e15E5Fab4534d (Ethereum; not a proxy: EIP-1967 implementation, admin and beacon slots all empty; verified source): totalSupply() = 1,000,000,000. The runtime code holds no selector of mint(address,uint256), mint(uint256), upgradeTo(address), upgradeToAndCall(address,bytes). Its only mint is the internal one at construction.",
    "recordId": "stakestone-sto-max-supply-1b-s34",
    "surface": "STO (Ethereum) supply: 1,000,000,000, no mint function"
   },
   "factors": [
    {
     "evidence": "stakestone-sto-max-supply-1b-s34: STO token 0x1D88713b483A8E45cfF0e5CD7c2e15E5Fab4534d (Ethereum; not a proxy: EIP-1967 implementation, admin and beacon slots all empty; verified source) …",
     "key": "upgrade",
     "label": "Upgradeability",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "Upgradeable; the delay gating the upgrade path is not in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "timelock",
     "label": "Timelock floor",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No enforced admin delay in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "quorum",
     "label": "Signer quorum",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No signer quorum in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "emergency",
     "label": "Emergency / freeze scope",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No pause / freeze authority in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "parity",
     "label": "Docs-vs-chain parity",
     "state": "g",
     "value": "Chain matches or is stronger than the documentation"
    }
   ],
   "finding": "STO (Ethereum) supply: 1,000,000,000, no mint function",
   "grade": "aligned",
   "gradeLabel": "ALIGNED",
   "name": "StakeStone STONE",
   "pinnedBlock": 26453551,
   "probe": {
    "block_hash": "0x51e9967ffd6a84012d0dad44204d523b8ac43928e69de2801d2e72dbf8767129",
    "block_number": 26453551,
    "call_args": [],
    "call_signature": "totalSupply()",
    "chain": "ethereum",
    "check_type": "eth_call",
    "extra_calls": [],
    "id": "stakestone-sto-max-supply-1b-s34",
    "repro_calldata": "0x18160ddd",
    "rpc_env_var": "$ETH_RPC_URL",
    "selector_or_slot": "0x18160ddd",
    "target_contract": "0x1D88713b483A8E45cfF0e5CD7c2e15E5Fab4534d",
    "target_label": "STO token"
   },
   "reconciled": false,
   "reconciledFrom": [],
   "reconciledTo": [],
   "records": 1,
   "rosetteAria": "StakeStone STONE control-plane rosette: Upgradeability not determined; Timelock floor not determined; Signer quorum not determined; Emergency / freeze scope not determined; Docs-vs-chain parity strong",
   "search": "stakestone stone stakestone-stone omnichain liquid staking token with rebalanced validator yield (ethereum) sto 0x1d88713b483a8e45cff0e5cd7c2e15e5fab4534d",
   "slug": "stakestone-stone",
   "summary_short": "STO is fully minted at its 1B maximum on Ethereum, as documented",
   "url": "https://pacta.wtf/protocols/stakestone-stone/"
  },
  {
   "baskets": [
    "eth_lst_lrt"
   ],
   "category": "Liquid Staking Infrastructure",
   "chains": [
    "ethereum"
   ],
   "deltas": 0,
   "easAttested": true,
   "evidence": {
    "documented": "docs.stakewise.io/docs/oracles/intro ('currently 6 of 11 Oracles'), docs/fees/intro ('5% fee on the rewards accumulated by osETH'), and docs/ostoken/how-ostoken-works ('liquidation threshold is set to 92% LTV').",
    "observed": "Sampled Keeper (0x6B5815467da09DaA7DC83Db21c9239d98Bb487b5) totalOracles() = 11, rewardsMinOracles() = 6, validatorsMinOracles() = 6 (6-of-11 oracle signature quorum); osETH (0xf1C9acDc66974dFB6dEcB12aA385b9cD01190E38) owner() = 0x0000000000000000000000000000000000000000, totalSupply = 148,452.02 osETH (18 dec); OsTokenVaultController (0x2A261e60FB14586B474C208b1B7AC6D0f5000306) feePercent() = 500 (5%), totalAssets = 160,753.18 ETH; OsTokenConfig (0x287d1e2A8dE183A8bf8f2b09Fa1340fBd766eb59) getConfig(0x0000000000000000000000000000000000000000) = (1.01e18, 0.92e18, 0.90e18) (90% mint LTV, 92% liquidation threshold).",
    "recordId": "stakewise-v3-oseth-oracle-quorum-and-ltv",
    "surface": "Sampled Keeper Oracle Quorum, osETH Fee & LTV Configuration"
   },
   "factors": [
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "upgrade",
     "label": "Upgradeability",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "Upgrade path not in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "timelock",
     "label": "Timelock floor",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No enforced admin delay in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": "controller fact: Safe getThreshold()",
     "key": "quorum",
     "label": "Signer quorum",
     "state": "g",
     "value": "Lowest controlling quorum: 4-of-7"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "emergency",
     "label": "Emergency / freeze scope",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No pause / freeze authority in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "parity",
     "label": "Docs-vs-chain parity",
     "state": "g",
     "value": "Chain matches or is stronger than the documentation"
    }
   ],
   "finding": "Sampled Keeper Oracle Quorum, osETH Fee & LTV Configuration",
   "grade": "aligned",
   "gradeLabel": "ALIGNED",
   "name": "StakeWise V3 (osETH)",
   "pinnedBlock": 26438867,
   "probe": {
    "block_hash": "0xf4246ca23c4c38d520de16080a11b5186d04c8242b2c85edcb04c455d291c3ae",
    "block_number": 26403676,
    "call_args": [],
    "call_signature": "rewardsMinOracles()",
    "chain": "ethereum",
    "check_type": "eth_call",
    "extra_calls": [],
    "id": "stakewise-v3-oseth-oracle-quorum-and-ltv",
    "repro_calldata": "0x7386749e",
    "rpc_env_var": "$ETH_RPC_URL",
    "selector_or_slot": "0x7386749e",
    "target_contract": "0x6B5815467da09DaA7DC83Db21c9239d98Bb487b5",
    "target_label": "StakeWise V3 Keeper"
   },
   "reconciled": false,
   "reconciledFrom": [],
   "reconciledTo": [],
   "records": 2,
   "rosetteAria": "StakeWise V3 (osETH) control-plane rosette: Upgradeability not determined; Timelock floor not determined; Signer quorum strong; Emergency / freeze scope not determined; Docs-vs-chain parity strong",
   "search": "stakewise v3 (oseth) stakewise-v3-oseth liquid staking infrastructure oseth swise 0x0000000000000000000000000000000000000000 0x144a98cb1cdbb23610501fe6108858d9b7d24934 0x287d1e2a8de183a8bf8f2b09fa1340fbd766eb59 0x2a261e60fb14586b474c208b1b7ac6d0f5000306 0x6b5815467da09daa7dc83db21c9239d98bb487b5 0xf1c9acdc66974dfb6decb12aa385b9cd01190e38",
   "slug": "stakewise-v3-oseth",
   "summary_short": "Keeper oracle quorum, osETH fee and LTV settings match the docs",
   "url": "https://pacta.wtf/protocols/stakewise-v3-oseth/"
  },
  {
   "baskets": [],
   "category": "Cross-chain Liquidity / Bridge",
   "chains": [
    "ethereum"
   ],
   "deltas": 0,
   "easAttested": true,
   "evidence": {
    "documented": "stargateprotocol.gitbook.io governance model: 'From time to time, a vote may require a change to the Stargate protocol or its treasury that requires action via multisig.'; V2 README: 'A Planner is a trusted entity that can allocate credit between chains off chain'; 'Fees within the Stargate protocol are dynamic, and are set by the AI Planning Module on a per pathway basis.'",
    "observed": "StargatePoolUSDC (0xc026395860Db2d07ee33e05fE50ed7bD583189C7).owner() = OneSig 0xBE634B030FEAaB661300667EaF82510a3a025413 (threshold() = 5 of 7 signers, VERSION() = 0.0.1, Sourcify exact_match: executes threshold-signed Merkle roots carrying only an expiry, no delay); TokenMessaging (0x6d6620eFa72948C5f68A3C8646d58C00d3f4A980) and Treasurer (0x1041D127b2d4BC700F0F563883bC689502606918) owner() = the same OneSig. getAddressConfig() planner = 0xe37f7c80ceD04c4F243C0Fd04A5510D663CB88b5 (an EOA) = TokenMessaging.planner() = FeeLibV1USDC (0x52B35406CB2FB5e0038EdEcFc129A152a1f74087).owner(); status() = 1. Context, not compared: the docs' StargateDAO multisig 0x65bb797c2B9830d891D87288F029ed8dACc19705 (3-of-5 Safe) is not the owner of these V2 contracts.",
    "recordId": "stargate-v2-onesig-5of7-owner-planner-fees-s18",
    "surface": "V2 pool, TokenMessaging & Treasurer owner = 5-of-7 OneSig multisig; planner sets fees"
   },
   "factors": [
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "upgrade",
     "label": "Upgradeability",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "Upgrade path not in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "timelock",
     "label": "Timelock floor",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No enforced admin delay in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": "stargate-v2-onesig-5of7-owner-planner-fees-s18: … 0xe37f7c80ceD04c4F243C0Fd04A5510D663CB88b5 (an EOA) = TokenMessaging.planner() = FeeLibV1USDC …",
     "key": "quorum",
     "label": "Signer quorum",
     "state": "a",
     "value": "Lowest controlling quorum: a single key"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "emergency",
     "label": "Emergency / freeze scope",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No pause / freeze authority in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "parity",
     "label": "Docs-vs-chain parity",
     "state": "g",
     "value": "Chain matches or is stronger than the documentation"
    }
   ],
   "finding": "V2 pool, TokenMessaging & Treasurer owner = 5-of-7 OneSig multisig; planner sets fees",
   "grade": "aligned",
   "gradeLabel": "ALIGNED",
   "name": "Stargate V2",
   "pinnedBlock": 26421541,
   "probe": {
    "block_hash": "0xfc2e93c53812cd390b29924a4e217bd4f75d77725bd2882968fb5b087a17150d",
    "block_number": 26421541,
    "call_args": [],
    "call_signature": "owner()",
    "chain": "ethereum",
    "check_type": "eth_call",
    "extra_calls": [],
    "id": "stargate-v2-onesig-5of7-owner-planner-fees-s18",
    "repro_calldata": "0x8da5cb5b",
    "rpc_env_var": "$ETH_RPC_URL",
    "selector_or_slot": "0x8da5cb5b",
    "target_contract": "0xc026395860Db2d07ee33e05fE50ed7bD583189C7",
    "target_label": "StargatePoolUSDC"
   },
   "reconciled": false,
   "reconciledFrom": [],
   "reconciledTo": [],
   "records": 1,
   "rosetteAria": "Stargate V2 control-plane rosette: Upgradeability not determined; Timelock floor not determined; Signer quorum weak; Emergency / freeze scope not determined; Docs-vs-chain parity strong",
   "search": "stargate v2 stargate-v2 cross-chain liquidity / bridge stg stargate 0x1041d127b2d4bc700f0f563883bc689502606918 0x52b35406cb2fb5e0038edecfc129a152a1f74087 0x65bb797c2b9830d891d87288f029ed8dacc19705 0x6d6620efa72948c5f68a3c8646d58c00d3f4a980 0xbe634b030feaab661300667eaf82510a3a025413 0xc026395860db2d07ee33e05fe50ed7bd583189c7 0xe37f7c80ced04c4f243c0fd04a5510d663cb88b5",
   "slug": "stargate-v2",
   "summary_short": "Pools and treasurer are owned by a 5-of-7 multisig, as documented",
   "url": "https://pacta.wtf/protocols/stargate-v2/"
  },
  {
   "baskets": [],
   "category": "ZK Rollup Canonical Bridge (STRK token) (Ethereum)",
   "chains": [
    "ethereum"
   ],
   "deltas": 0,
   "easAttested": false,
   "evidence": {
    "documented": "Starknet Bridge documentation is linked for reference (https://docs.starknet.io/). This RPC-pinned record does not compare documentation parameters with the on-chain state.",
    "observed": "StarkNet Token (0xCa14007Eff0dB1f8135f4C25B34De49AB0d42766) verified on Ethereum Mainnet at canonical block #26,458,556 (11,561 bytes runtime code). EIP-1967 implementation and admin storage slots are both zero (non-EIP-1967 contract). No owner(), admin(), authority(), curator() or AccessControl admin was readable on the contract.",
    "recordId": "starknet-bridge-control-plane",
    "surface": "StarkNet Token · Non-Proxy Bytecode & Controller"
   },
   "factors": [
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "upgrade",
     "label": "Upgradeability",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "Upgrade path not in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "timelock",
     "label": "Timelock floor",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No enforced admin delay in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "quorum",
     "label": "Signer quorum",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No signer quorum in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "emergency",
     "label": "Emergency / freeze scope",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No pause / freeze authority in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "parity",
     "label": "Docs-vs-chain parity",
     "state": "u",
     "value": "Uncompared: documentation not assessed (RPC-observed)"
    }
   ],
   "finding": "StarkNet Token · Non-Proxy Bytecode & Controller",
   "grade": "observed",
   "gradeLabel": "OBSERVED",
   "name": "Starknet Bridge",
   "pinnedBlock": 26458556,
   "probe": {
    "block_hash": "0xe258bb1cbcc988e2dfdba4ba173f9f8690520dba3647cdcae18e0651822769d2",
    "block_number": 26458556,
    "call_args": [],
    "call_signature": "owner()",
    "chain": "ethereum",
    "check_type": "eth_call",
    "extra_calls": [],
    "id": "starknet-bridge-control-plane",
    "repro_calldata": "0x8da5cb5b",
    "rpc_env_var": "$ETH_RPC_URL",
    "selector_or_slot": "0x8da5cb5b",
    "target_contract": "0xCa14007Eff0dB1f8135f4C25B34De49AB0d42766",
    "target_label": "StarkNet Token"
   },
   "reconciled": false,
   "reconciledFrom": [],
   "reconciledTo": [],
   "records": 1,
   "rosetteAria": "Starknet Bridge control-plane rosette: Upgradeability not determined; Timelock floor not determined; Signer quorum not determined; Emergency / freeze scope not determined; Docs-vs-chain parity uncompared",
   "search": "starknet bridge starknet-bridge zk rollup canonical bridge (strk token) (ethereum) strk 0xca14007eff0db1f8135f4c25b34de49ab0d42766",
   "slug": "starknet-bridge",
   "summary_short": "Non-proxy contract no readable owner or admin; docs not assessed",
   "url": "https://pacta.wtf/protocols/starknet-bridge/"
  },
  {
   "baskets": [
    "lending_vaults"
   ],
   "category": "Morpho v1 Curator Vault Suite (USDC, USDT, PYUSD)",
   "chains": [
    "ethereum"
   ],
   "deltas": 0,
   "easAttested": true,
   "evidence": {
    "documented": "Steakhouse on the Morpho forum (linked from the docs): 'The new guardians will be the following: - [steakUSDC](https://app.aragon.org/#/daos/ethereum/steakusdc-guardian.dao.eth/dashboard)' / 'Veto Mechanism: Seeking to provide depositors with even more control over their funds and curated vaults, Steakhouse introduced the Aragon DAO guardian to enable vault depositors to veto critical actions made by the curator.'",
    "observed": "steakUSDC 0xBEEF01735c132Ada46AA9aA4c54623cAA92A64CB (MetaMorpho, Sourcify exact match): guardian() = 0xaa0500198B4425DfC4E272FbE42C8E64E21fc03d, the Aragon DAO that steakusdc-guardian.dao.eth resolves to; no pending guardian; steakUSDT 0xbEef047a543E45807105E51A8BBEFCc5950fcfBa and steakPYUSD 0xbEEF02e5E13584ab96848af90261f0C8Ee04722a have their own guardian DAOs (0xaeC761545Fd135db6d04D27C92BCB3951668c67F, 0xCcFd0E9CEC732fb839fadDeCc72B6154530bC90f).",
    "recordId": "steakhouse-financial-ethereum-steakusdc-guardian-aragon-s24",
    "surface": "steakUSDC guardian: its own Aragon DAO (steakusdc-guardian.dao.eth), as announced"
   },
   "factors": [
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "upgrade",
     "label": "Upgradeability",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "Upgrade path not in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": "steakhouse-financial-ethereum-steakusdc-timelock-7d-s24: observed_delay_seconds = 604800",
     "key": "timelock",
     "label": "Timelock floor",
     "state": "g",
     "value": "7d minimum enforced delay across control surfaces"
    },
    {
     "evidence": "steakhouse-financial-ethereum-vaults-owner-safe-5-of-10-s24: … 0x827e86072B06674a077f592A531dcE4590aDeCdB (3-of-9).",
     "key": "quorum",
     "label": "Signer quorum",
     "state": "g",
     "value": "Lowest controlling quorum: 3-of-9"
    },
    {
     "evidence": "steakhouse-financial-ethereum-steakusdc-guardian-aragon-s24: steakUSDC 0xBEEF01735c132Ada46AA9aA4c54623cAA92A64CB (MetaMorpho, Sourcify exact match): guardian() = 0xaa0500198B4425DfC4E272FbE42C8E64E21fc03d, the Aragon DAO …",
     "key": "emergency",
     "label": "Emergency / freeze scope",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "Pause / freeze authority present; its holder is not determined"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "parity",
     "label": "Docs-vs-chain parity",
     "state": "g",
     "value": "Chain matches or is stronger than the documentation"
    }
   ],
   "finding": "steakUSDC guardian: its own Aragon DAO (steakusdc-guardian.dao.eth), as announced",
   "grade": "aligned",
   "gradeLabel": "ALIGNED",
   "name": "Steakhouse Financial (Ethereum)",
   "pinnedBlock": 26433001,
   "probe": {
    "block_hash": "0xa058ec92ccf0024822a76097f183d8e2d344d56e9539038c857e0cdaaa0ee5a7",
    "block_number": 26433001,
    "call_args": [],
    "call_signature": "guardian()",
    "chain": "ethereum",
    "check_type": "eth_call",
    "extra_calls": [],
    "id": "steakhouse-financial-ethereum-steakusdc-guardian-aragon-s24",
    "repro_calldata": "0x452a9320",
    "rpc_env_var": "$ETH_RPC_URL",
    "selector_or_slot": "0x452a9320",
    "target_contract": "0xBEEF01735c132Ada46AA9aA4c54623cAA92A64CB",
    "target_label": "Steakhouse USDC (steakUSDC) MetaMorpho vault"
   },
   "reconciled": false,
   "reconciledFrom": [],
   "reconciledTo": [],
   "records": 4,
   "rosetteAria": "Steakhouse Financial (Ethereum) control-plane rosette: Upgradeability not determined; Timelock floor strong; Signer quorum strong; Emergency / freeze scope not determined; Docs-vs-chain parity strong",
   "search": "steakhouse financial (ethereum) steakhouse-financial-ethereum morpho v1 curator vault suite (usdc, usdt, pyusd) steakusdt steakpyusd steakusdc steakhouse 0x0a0e559bc3b0950a7e448f0d4894db195b9cf8dd 0x79864900a4d34fb7907de9fe404758de5a4956de 0x827e86072b06674a077f592a531dce4590adecdb 0xaa0500198b4425dfc4e272fbe42c8e64e21fc03d 0xaec761545fd135db6d04d27c92bcb3951668c67f 0xbeef01735c132ada46aa9aa4c54623caa92a64cb 0xbeef02e5e13584ab96848af90261f0c8ee04722a 0xbeef047a543e45807105e51a8bbefcc5950fcfba 0xccfd0e9cec732fb839faddecc72b6154530bc90f",
   "slug": "steakhouse-financial-ethereum",
   "summary_short": "steakUSDC guardian is its own Aragon DAO, as announced",
   "url": "https://pacta.wtf/protocols/steakhouse-financial-ethereum/"
  },
  {
   "baskets": [
    "base",
    "lending_vaults"
   ],
   "category": "Curated vault lending USDC across allowlisted Morpho Blue markets (Base)",
   "chains": [
    "base"
   ],
   "deltas": 0,
   "easAttested": true,
   "evidence": {
    "documented": "'Seeking to provide depositors with even more control over their funds and curated vaults, Steakhouse introduced the Aragon DAO guardian to enable vault depositors to veto critical actions made by the curator.' (www.steakhouse.financial/docs/risk-management/monitoring/vault-setup-and-controls)",
    "observed": "Steakhouse Prime USDC (Base) MetaMorphoV1_1 0xBEEFE94c8aD530842bfE7d8B397938fFc1cb83b2 (Base): guardian() = 0x894d59017Ed0F8dcd8f2B6e89a3C26eF76876D33 (a contract).",
    "recordId": "steakhouse-prime-usdc-base-guardian-s28",
    "surface": "Steakhouse Prime USDC (Base) MetaMorphoV1_1: a guardian is configured, as documented"
   },
   "factors": [
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "upgrade",
     "label": "Upgradeability",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "Upgrade path not in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": "steakhouse-prime-usdc-base-timelock-delay-s28: observed_delay_seconds = 604800",
     "key": "timelock",
     "label": "Timelock floor",
     "state": "g",
     "value": "7d minimum enforced delay across control surfaces"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "quorum",
     "label": "Signer quorum",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No signer quorum in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": "steakhouse-prime-usdc-base-guardian-s28: Steakhouse Prime USDC (Base) MetaMorphoV1_1 0xBEEFE94c8aD530842bfE7d8B397938fFc1cb83b2 (Base): guardian() = 0x894d59017Ed0F8dcd8f2B6e89a3C26eF76876D33 (a …",
     "key": "emergency",
     "label": "Emergency / freeze scope",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "Pause / freeze authority present; its holder is not determined"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "parity",
     "label": "Docs-vs-chain parity",
     "state": "g",
     "value": "Chain matches or is stronger than the documentation"
    }
   ],
   "finding": "Steakhouse Prime USDC (Base) MetaMorphoV1_1: a guardian is configured, as documented",
   "grade": "aligned",
   "gradeLabel": "ALIGNED",
   "name": "Steakhouse Prime USDC (Base)",
   "pinnedBlock": 59025642,
   "probe": {
    "block_hash": "0x8fc618f8e02aa1fd1c3bcf1300fd25e40291a0fcde351bd39ad8cb61781d5e12",
    "block_number": 59025642,
    "call_args": [],
    "call_signature": "guardian()",
    "chain": "base",
    "check_type": "eth_call",
    "extra_calls": [],
    "id": "steakhouse-prime-usdc-base-guardian-s28",
    "repro_calldata": "0x452a9320",
    "rpc_env_var": "$BASE_RPC_URL",
    "selector_or_slot": "0x452a9320",
    "target_contract": "0xBEEFE94c8aD530842bfE7d8B397938fFc1cb83b2",
    "target_label": "Steakhouse Prime USDC (Base) MetaMorphoV1_1"
   },
   "reconciled": false,
   "reconciledFrom": [],
   "reconciledTo": [],
   "records": 2,
   "rosetteAria": "Steakhouse Prime USDC (Base) control-plane rosette: Upgradeability not determined; Timelock floor strong; Signer quorum not determined; Emergency / freeze scope not determined; Docs-vs-chain parity strong",
   "search": "steakhouse prime usdc (base) steakhouse-prime-usdc-base curated vault lending usdc across allowlisted morpho blue markets (base) steakusdc 0x894d59017ed0f8dcd8f2b6e89a3c26ef76876d33 0xbeefe94c8ad530842bfe7d8b397938ffc1cb83b2",
   "slug": "steakhouse-prime-usdc-base",
   "summary_short": "Steakhouse Prime USDC (Base) changes wait a 7-day timelock, as documented",
   "url": "https://pacta.wtf/protocols/steakhouse-prime-usdc-base/"
  },
  {
   "baskets": [
    "base",
    "lending_vaults"
   ],
   "category": "Curated Lending Vault (MetaMorpho)",
   "chains": [
    "base"
   ],
   "deltas": 0,
   "easAttested": true,
   "evidence": {
    "documented": "steakhouse.financial/docs/llms-full.txt: 'Steakhouse vaults 7-day timelocks (above the minimum, protocol-enforced 3-day timelock)'.",
    "observed": "Steakhouse USDC (steakUSDC, 0xbeeF010f9cb27031ad51e3333f9aF9C6B1228183) on Base: timelock() = 604800s (7d); asset() = USDC (0x833589fCD6eDb6E08f4c7C32D4f71b54bdA02913); MORPHO() = 0xBBBBBbbBBb9cC5e90e3b3Af64bdAF62C37EEFFCb; owner() = 5-of-10 Safe 0x0A0e559bc3b0950a7e448F0d4894db195b9cf8DD; curator() = 3-of-9 Safe 0x827e86072B06674a077f592A531dcE4590aDeCdB; totalAssets() = 102,512,832.83 USDC. Context, not compared with documentation: guardian() = 0x9e0FdDDa790651E6a05CD2dE69e624B94C04eAf5 has no contract code (eth_getCode = 0x on Base and on Ethereum at #26,418,060) and nonce 0 on Base; the docs say guardians are 'typically onchain Aragon multisigs ... When they're not, it's usually because a commercial distribution partner has taken on that role' and list this vault with partner Coinbase; chain state does not show who holds it.",
    "recordId": "steakhouse-usdc-base-timelock-7d-s17",
    "surface": "MetaMorpho timelock() = 7d (604800s)"
   },
   "factors": [
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "upgrade",
     "label": "Upgradeability",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "Upgrade path not in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": "steakhouse-usdc-base-timelock-7d-s17: observed_delay_seconds = 604800",
     "key": "timelock",
     "label": "Timelock floor",
     "state": "g",
     "value": "7d minimum enforced delay across control surfaces"
    },
    {
     "evidence": "steakhouse-usdc-base-timelock-7d-s17: … 0x9e0FdDDa790651E6a05CD2dE69e624B94C04eAf5 has no contract code (eth_getCode = 0x on Base and on Ethereum …",
     "key": "quorum",
     "label": "Signer quorum",
     "state": "a",
     "value": "Lowest controlling quorum: a single key"
    },
    {
     "evidence": "steakhouse-usdc-base-timelock-7d-s17: totalAssets() = 102,512,832.83 USDC. Context, not compared with documentation: guardian() = 0x9e0FdDDa790651E6a05CD2dE69e624B94C04eAf5 has no contract code …",
     "key": "emergency",
     "label": "Emergency / freeze scope",
     "state": "a",
     "value": "Pause / freeze authority held by a single key"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "parity",
     "label": "Docs-vs-chain parity",
     "state": "g",
     "value": "Chain matches or is stronger than the documentation"
    }
   ],
   "finding": "MetaMorpho timelock() = 7d (604800s)",
   "grade": "aligned",
   "gradeLabel": "ALIGNED",
   "name": "Steakhouse USDC MetaMorpho (Base)",
   "pinnedBlock": 57635450,
   "probe": {
    "block_hash": "0x78ddbdca540b630c823e1c79dcadbfc25dd957c60d1396f4c6b60f11f67a164f",
    "block_number": 57635450,
    "call_args": [],
    "call_signature": "timelock()",
    "chain": "base",
    "check_type": "eth_call",
    "extra_calls": [],
    "id": "steakhouse-usdc-base-timelock-7d-s17",
    "repro_calldata": "0xd33219b4",
    "rpc_env_var": "$BASE_RPC_URL",
    "selector_or_slot": "0xd33219b4",
    "target_contract": "0xbeeF010f9cb27031ad51e3333f9aF9C6B1228183",
    "target_label": "Steakhouse USDC (steakUSDC) vault on Base"
   },
   "reconciled": false,
   "reconciledFrom": [],
   "reconciledTo": [],
   "records": 1,
   "rosetteAria": "Steakhouse USDC MetaMorpho (Base) control-plane rosette: Upgradeability not determined; Timelock floor strong; Signer quorum weak; Emergency / freeze scope weak; Docs-vs-chain parity strong",
   "search": "steakhouse usdc metamorpho (base) steakhouse-usdc-metamorpho-base curated lending vault (metamorpho) steakusdc steakhouse metamorpho 0x0a0e559bc3b0950a7e448f0d4894db195b9cf8dd 0x827e86072b06674a077f592a531dce4590adecdb 0x833589fcd6edb6e08f4c7c32d4f71b54bda02913 0x9e0fddda790651e6a05cd2de69e624b94c04eaf5 0xbbbbbbbbbb9cc5e90e3b3af64bdaf62c37eeffcb 0xbeef010f9cb27031ad51e3333f9af9c6b1228183",
   "slug": "steakhouse-usdc-metamorpho-base",
   "summary_short": "MetaMorpho vault timelock is 7 days, as documented",
   "url": "https://pacta.wtf/protocols/steakhouse-usdc-metamorpho-base/"
  },
  {
   "baskets": [],
   "category": "Off-chain compute for automated liquidity strategies (Ethereum)",
   "chains": [
    "ethereum"
   ],
   "deltas": 0,
   "easAttested": false,
   "evidence": {
    "documented": "Steer Protocol documentation is linked for reference (https://app.steer.finance/docs). This RPC-pinned record does not compare documentation parameters with the on-chain state.",
    "observed": "SteerPeriphery (0xCEBF1A54A9Ce703FC80967760b5A6cbDb4111099) verified on Ethereum Mainnet at canonical block #26,458,556 (2,004 bytes runtime code). EIP-1967 proxy: implementation 0xAc7D3A933c44b4D4bad6D5F0685900482E0d995E, admin 0xEB2D829FFbE494FC6535b0E4EB807EFd4b6BF0Bd. The EIP-1967 admin slot holds contract ProxyAdmin 0xEB2D829FFbE494FC6535b0E4EB807EFd4b6BF0Bd. That controller is in turn controlled by Safe 2-of-5 0x570cE31D1309bb145DD3736B48c7328cc13f7e85.",
    "recordId": "steer-protocol-control-plane",
    "surface": "SteerPeriphery · EIP-1967 Proxy & Controller Chain"
   },
   "factors": [
    {
     "evidence": "steer-protocol-control-plane: SteerPeriphery (0xCEBF1A54A9Ce703FC80967760b5A6cbDb4111099) verified on Ethereum Mainnet at canonical block #26,458,556 (2,004 bytes runtime code). EIP-1967 …",
     "key": "upgrade",
     "label": "Upgradeability",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "Upgradeable; the delay gating the upgrade path is not in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "timelock",
     "label": "Timelock floor",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No enforced admin delay in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": "steer-protocol-control-plane: … controller is in turn controlled by Safe 2-of-5 0x570cE31D1309bb145DD3736B48c7328cc13f7e85.",
     "key": "quorum",
     "label": "Signer quorum",
     "state": "b",
     "value": "Lowest controlling quorum: 2-of-5"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "emergency",
     "label": "Emergency / freeze scope",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No pause / freeze authority in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "parity",
     "label": "Docs-vs-chain parity",
     "state": "u",
     "value": "Uncompared: documentation not assessed (RPC-observed)"
    }
   ],
   "finding": "SteerPeriphery · EIP-1967 Proxy & Controller Chain",
   "grade": "observed",
   "gradeLabel": "OBSERVED",
   "name": "Steer Protocol",
   "pinnedBlock": 26458556,
   "probe": {
    "block_hash": "0xe258bb1cbcc988e2dfdba4ba173f9f8690520dba3647cdcae18e0651822769d2",
    "block_number": 26458556,
    "call_args": [],
    "call_signature": null,
    "chain": "ethereum",
    "check_type": "eth_getStorageAt",
    "extra_calls": [],
    "id": "steer-protocol-control-plane",
    "repro_calldata": null,
    "rpc_env_var": "$ETH_RPC_URL",
    "selector_or_slot": "0xb53127684a568b3173ae13b9f8a6016e243e63b6e8ee1178d6a717850b5d6103",
    "target_contract": "0xCEBF1A54A9Ce703FC80967760b5A6cbDb4111099",
    "target_label": "SteerPeriphery"
   },
   "reconciled": false,
   "reconciledFrom": [],
   "reconciledTo": [],
   "records": 1,
   "rosetteAria": "Steer Protocol control-plane rosette: Upgradeability not determined; Timelock floor not determined; Signer quorum moderate; Emergency / freeze scope not determined; Docs-vs-chain parity uncompared",
   "search": "steer protocol steer-protocol off-chain compute for automated liquidity strategies (ethereum) steer 0x570ce31d1309bb145dd3736b48c7328cc13f7e85 0xac7d3a933c44b4d4bad6d5f0685900482e0d995e 0xcebf1a54a9ce703fc80967760b5a6cbdb4111099 0xeb2d829ffbe494fc6535b0e4eb807efd4b6bf0bd",
   "slug": "steer-protocol",
   "summary_short": "Upgradeable proxy controlled by a 2-of-5 Safe; docs not assessed",
   "url": "https://pacta.wtf/protocols/steer-protocol/"
  },
  {
   "baskets": [
    "lending_vaults"
   ],
   "category": "Risk-tranching protocol splitting yield into senior and junior tranches (Ethereum)",
   "chains": [
    "ethereum"
   ],
   "deltas": 0,
   "easAttested": true,
   "evidence": {
    "documented": "'**Operational Multisig** * 2-of-3 Gnosis Safe' (docs.strata.markets/technical-documentation/contracts-details.md)",
    "observed": "Strata Markets Safe 0x4be3749a0F6557b8fd98F3967e859DbD7C694eF4 (Ethereum): getThreshold() = 2 of getOwners() = 3 owners (Safe v1.4.1).",
    "recordId": "strata-markets-safe-threshold-s28",
    "surface": "Strata Markets multisig: 2-of-3 Safe, as documented"
   },
   "factors": [
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "upgrade",
     "label": "Upgradeability",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "Upgrade path not in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "timelock",
     "label": "Timelock floor",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No enforced admin delay in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": "controller fact: Safe getThreshold()",
     "key": "quorum",
     "label": "Signer quorum",
     "state": "b",
     "value": "Lowest controlling quorum: 2-of-3"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "emergency",
     "label": "Emergency / freeze scope",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No pause / freeze authority in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "parity",
     "label": "Docs-vs-chain parity",
     "state": "g",
     "value": "Chain matches or is stronger than the documentation"
    }
   ],
   "finding": "Strata Markets multisig: 2-of-3 Safe, as documented",
   "grade": "aligned",
   "gradeLabel": "ALIGNED",
   "name": "Strata Markets",
   "pinnedBlock": 26441165,
   "probe": {
    "block_hash": "0x5182be2c61af5f48ed2ec43d3c177dedad257c4e966a7e384120829de73901d9",
    "block_number": 26441165,
    "call_args": [],
    "call_signature": "getThreshold()",
    "chain": "ethereum",
    "check_type": "eth_call",
    "extra_calls": [],
    "id": "strata-markets-safe-threshold-s28",
    "repro_calldata": "0xe75235b8",
    "rpc_env_var": "$ETH_RPC_URL",
    "selector_or_slot": "0xe75235b8",
    "target_contract": "0x4be3749a0F6557b8fd98F3967e859DbD7C694eF4",
    "target_label": "Strata Markets Safe"
   },
   "reconciled": false,
   "reconciledFrom": [],
   "reconciledTo": [],
   "records": 1,
   "rosetteAria": "Strata Markets control-plane rosette: Upgradeability not determined; Timelock floor not determined; Signer quorum moderate; Emergency / freeze scope not determined; Docs-vs-chain parity strong",
   "search": "strata markets strata-markets risk-tranching protocol splitting yield into senior and junior tranches (ethereum) srusde 0x4be3749a0f6557b8fd98f3967e859dbd7c694ef4",
   "slug": "strata-markets",
   "summary_short": "Strata Markets changes wait a 2-day timelock, as documented",
   "url": "https://pacta.wtf/protocols/strata-markets/"
  },
  {
   "baskets": [
    "base",
    "lending_vaults"
   ],
   "category": "Omnichain ERC-7579 Vault & Yield Infrastructure",
   "chains": [
    "base"
   ],
   "deltas": 0,
   "easAttested": true,
   "evidence": {
    "documented": "'| Primary strategist updates | 7 days |' (docs.superform.xyz/security.md); 'These addresses are the same on both Ethereum and Base.' (docs.superform.xyz/deployment-addresses.md)",
    "observed": "Superform SuperVaultAggregator 0x10AC0b33e1C4501CF3ec1cB1AE51ebfdbd2d4698 (Base, not a proxy; Sourcify-verified, runtime match): the primary-manager change proposal sets effectiveTime = block.timestamp + _MANAGER_CHANGE_TIMELOCK (7 days) and the min-update-interval proposal + _PARAMETER_CHANGE_TIMELOCK (3 days); the runtime code read at this pin holds the 604,800 s and 259,200 s constants once each. UPKEEP_WITHDRAWAL_TIMELOCK() = 86,400 s (the page's 24-hour upkeep withdrawal). SuperGovernor 0xB5396ef2bF8CA360cEB4166b77AFb2bed20e74d4 (same deployment page) holds its own 7-day TIMELOCK on fee changes.",
    "recordId": "superform-base-manager-change-timelock-7d-s32",
    "surface": "Primary manager change: 7-day timelock (604,800 s); interval changes 3 days"
   },
   "factors": [
    {
     "evidence": "superform-base-manager-change-timelock-7d-s32: … 0x10AC0b33e1C4501CF3ec1cB1AE51ebfdbd2d4698 (Base, not a proxy; Sourcify-verified, runtime match): …",
     "key": "upgrade",
     "label": "Upgradeability",
     "state": "g",
     "value": "Immutable or ownership renounced"
    },
    {
     "evidence": "superform-base-manager-change-timelock-7d-s32: observed_delay_seconds = 604800",
     "key": "timelock",
     "label": "Timelock floor",
     "state": "g",
     "value": "7d minimum enforced delay across control surfaces"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "quorum",
     "label": "Signer quorum",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No signer quorum in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "emergency",
     "label": "Emergency / freeze scope",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No pause / freeze authority in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "parity",
     "label": "Docs-vs-chain parity",
     "state": "g",
     "value": "Chain matches or is stronger than the documentation"
    }
   ],
   "finding": "Primary manager change: 7-day timelock (604,800 s); interval changes 3 days",
   "grade": "aligned",
   "gradeLabel": "ALIGNED",
   "name": "Superform Core v2 (Base)",
   "pinnedBlock": 59653624,
   "probe": {
    "block_hash": "0x984d5efdee77a9e8ab0d5b8eb5bba2a230cdcadc268f35f6c77f4a629b13a305",
    "block_number": 59653624,
    "call_args": [],
    "call_signature": "UPKEEP_WITHDRAWAL_TIMELOCK()",
    "chain": "base",
    "check_type": "eth_call",
    "extra_calls": [],
    "id": "superform-base-manager-change-timelock-7d-s32",
    "repro_calldata": "0xf00e2f88",
    "rpc_env_var": "$BASE_RPC_URL",
    "selector_or_slot": "0xf00e2f88",
    "target_contract": "0x10AC0b33e1C4501CF3ec1cB1AE51ebfdbd2d4698",
    "target_label": "Superform SuperVaultAggregator (Base)"
   },
   "reconciled": false,
   "reconciledFrom": [],
   "reconciledTo": [],
   "records": 1,
   "rosetteAria": "Superform Core v2 (Base) control-plane rosette: Upgradeability strong; Timelock floor strong; Signer quorum not determined; Emergency / freeze scope not determined; Docs-vs-chain parity strong",
   "search": "superform core v2 (base) superform-v2-base omnichain erc-7579 vault & yield infrastructure superform supervaults 0x10ac0b33e1c4501cf3ec1cb1ae51ebfdbd2d4698 0xb5396ef2bf8ca360ceb4166b77afb2bed20e74d4",
   "slug": "superform-v2-base",
   "summary_short": "Superform's primary-strategist changes on Base wait 7 days, as documented",
   "url": "https://pacta.wtf/protocols/superform-v2-base/"
  },
  {
   "baskets": [
    "lending_vaults"
   ],
   "category": "Concentrated-liquidity automated market maker built on Algebra protocol contracts (Ethereum)",
   "chains": [
    "ethereum"
   ],
   "deltas": 0,
   "easAttested": false,
   "evidence": {
    "documented": "Supernova CL documentation is linked for reference (https://docs.supernova.xyz/). This RPC-pinned record does not compare documentation parameters with the on-chain state.",
    "observed": "AlgebraFactory (0x44B7fBd4D87149eFa5347c451E74B9FD18E89c55) verified on Ethereum Mainnet at canonical block #26,458,556 (10,874 bytes runtime code). EIP-1967 implementation and admin storage slots are both zero (non-EIP-1967 contract). Direct owner() returns Safe 4-of-8 0xB73494c3FB46Bf5cFC08f32A704fa180110d9226.",
    "recordId": "supernova-cl-control-plane",
    "surface": "AlgebraFactory · Non-Proxy Bytecode & Controller"
   },
   "factors": [
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "upgrade",
     "label": "Upgradeability",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "Upgrade path not in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "timelock",
     "label": "Timelock floor",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No enforced admin delay in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": "supernova-cl-control-plane: … contract). Direct owner() returns Safe 4-of-8 0xB73494c3FB46Bf5cFC08f32A704fa180110d9226.",
     "key": "quorum",
     "label": "Signer quorum",
     "state": "g",
     "value": "Lowest controlling quorum: 4-of-8"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "emergency",
     "label": "Emergency / freeze scope",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No pause / freeze authority in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "parity",
     "label": "Docs-vs-chain parity",
     "state": "u",
     "value": "Uncompared: documentation not assessed (RPC-observed)"
    }
   ],
   "finding": "AlgebraFactory · Non-Proxy Bytecode & Controller",
   "grade": "observed",
   "gradeLabel": "OBSERVED",
   "name": "Supernova CL",
   "pinnedBlock": 26458556,
   "probe": {
    "block_hash": "0xe258bb1cbcc988e2dfdba4ba173f9f8690520dba3647cdcae18e0651822769d2",
    "block_number": 26458556,
    "call_args": [],
    "call_signature": "owner()",
    "chain": "ethereum",
    "check_type": "eth_call",
    "extra_calls": [],
    "id": "supernova-cl-control-plane",
    "repro_calldata": "0x8da5cb5b",
    "rpc_env_var": "$ETH_RPC_URL",
    "selector_or_slot": "0x8da5cb5b",
    "target_contract": "0x44B7fBd4D87149eFa5347c451E74B9FD18E89c55",
    "target_label": "AlgebraFactory"
   },
   "reconciled": false,
   "reconciledFrom": [],
   "reconciledTo": [],
   "records": 1,
   "rosetteAria": "Supernova CL control-plane rosette: Upgradeability not determined; Timelock floor not determined; Signer quorum strong; Emergency / freeze scope not determined; Docs-vs-chain parity uncompared",
   "search": "supernova cl supernova-cl concentrated-liquidity automated market maker built on algebra protocol contracts (ethereum) supernova 0x44b7fbd4d87149efa5347c451e74b9fd18e89c55 0xb73494c3fb46bf5cfc08f32a704fa180110d9226",
   "slug": "supernova-cl",
   "summary_short": "Non-proxy contract controlled by a 4-of-8 Safe; docs not assessed",
   "url": "https://pacta.wtf/protocols/supernova-cl/"
  },
  {
   "baskets": [
    "stable_rwa"
   ],
   "category": "Institutional RWA / Tokenized Funds",
   "chains": [
    "ethereum"
   ],
   "deltas": 0,
   "easAttested": true,
   "evidence": {
    "documented": "docs.superstate.com/investors/smart-contracts.md states 'At time of writing, fees are set to 0 and only USDC is supported.'",
    "observed": "Sampled USTB (0x43415eB6ff9DB7E26A15b704e7A3eDCe97d31C4e) supportedStablecoins(0xA0b86991c6218b36c1d19D4a2e9Eb0cE3606eB48) returns sweep destination 0x774AE279c21B6a17a6E2BD5ab5398FF98F398807 and subscription fee = 0 for USDC; USTB totalSupply = 39,459,575.14 USTB (6 dec), USCC (0x14d60E7FDC0D71d8611742720E4C50E7a974020c) totalSupply = 4,066,680.13 USCC (6 dec).",
    "recordId": "superstate-ustb-uscc-fee-and-usdc-alignment",
    "surface": "Sampled USDC Subscription Fee & Fund Supply Alignment"
   },
   "factors": [
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "upgrade",
     "label": "Upgradeability",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "Upgrade path not in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "timelock",
     "label": "Timelock floor",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No enforced admin delay in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "quorum",
     "label": "Signer quorum",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No signer quorum in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "emergency",
     "label": "Emergency / freeze scope",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No pause / freeze authority in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "parity",
     "label": "Docs-vs-chain parity",
     "state": "g",
     "value": "Chain matches or is stronger than the documentation"
    }
   ],
   "finding": "Sampled USDC Subscription Fee & Fund Supply Alignment",
   "grade": "aligned",
   "gradeLabel": "ALIGNED",
   "name": "Superstate (USTB / USCC)",
   "pinnedBlock": 26403676,
   "probe": {
    "block_hash": "0xf4246ca23c4c38d520de16080a11b5186d04c8242b2c85edcb04c455d291c3ae",
    "block_number": 26403676,
    "call_args": [
     "0xA0b86991c6218b36c1d19D4a2e9Eb0cE3606eB48"
    ],
    "call_signature": "supportedStablecoins(address)",
    "chain": "ethereum",
    "check_type": "eth_call",
    "extra_calls": [],
    "id": "superstate-ustb-uscc-fee-and-usdc-alignment",
    "repro_calldata": "0xbf7d9119000000000000000000000000a0b86991c6218b36c1d19d4a2e9eb0ce3606eb48",
    "rpc_env_var": "$ETH_RPC_URL",
    "selector_or_slot": "0xbf7d9119",
    "target_contract": "0x43415eB6ff9DB7E26A15b704e7A3eDCe97d31C4e",
    "target_label": "Superstate USTB"
   },
   "reconciled": false,
   "reconciledFrom": [],
   "reconciledTo": [],
   "records": 1,
   "rosetteAria": "Superstate (USTB / USCC) control-plane rosette: Upgradeability not determined; Timelock floor not determined; Signer quorum not determined; Emergency / freeze scope not determined; Docs-vs-chain parity strong",
   "search": "superstate (ustb / uscc) superstate-ustb-uscc institutional rwa / tokenized funds ustb uscc 0x14d60e7fdc0d71d8611742720e4c50e7a974020c 0x43415eb6ff9db7e26a15b704e7a3edce97d31c4e 0x774ae279c21b6a17a6e2bd5ab5398ff98f398807 0xa0b86991c6218b36c1d19d4a2e9eb0ce3606eb48",
   "slug": "superstate-ustb-uscc",
   "summary_short": "USDC subscription fee and fund supply match the docs",
   "url": "https://pacta.wtf/protocols/superstate-ustb-uscc/"
  },
  {
   "baskets": [],
   "category": "Concentrated-liquidity swap pools with tick-range LP positions (Ethereum)",
   "chains": [
    "ethereum"
   ],
   "deltas": 0,
   "easAttested": true,
   "evidence": {
    "documented": "'Any changes within the core team's purview must pass the Operations Multisig with at least three signatures.' (docs.sushi.com/dao/governance); '[EvmChainId.ETHEREUM]: '0x19b3eb3af5d93b77a5619b047de0eed7115a19e7'' (raw.githubusercontent.com/sushi-labs/sushi/master/src/evm/config/features/operations-multisig.ts); 'ETHEREUM 0xbaceb8ec6b9355dfc0269c18bac9d6e2bdc29c4f' (docs.sushi.com/contracts/clamm)",
    "observed": "SushiSwap V3 factory 0xbACEB8eC6b9355Dfc0269C18bac9d6E2Bdc29C4F (Ethereum, the clAMM deployments page; not a proxy): owner() = 0xCd03e2e276F6EEdD424d41314437531F665187b9, a V3Manager (verified source: createFeeTier, setFactoryOwner, setProtocolFee, setMaker, doAction and setTrusted are onlyOwner; applyProtocolFee and collectFees are open to owner-set trusted callers) whose owner() = 0x19B3Eb3Af5D93b77a5619b047De0EED7115A19e7, the Ethereum Operations Multisig the official SDK lists. That Safe: getThreshold() = 3 of getOwners() = 5; guard slot empty; getModulesPaginated() lists no module: at least three signatures, as documented.",
    "recordId": "sushiswap-v3-factory-operations-multisig-s35",
    "surface": "V3 factory owner = V3Manager owned by the Operations Multisig (3-of-5)"
   },
   "factors": [
    {
     "evidence": "sushiswap-v3-factory-operations-multisig-s35: … (Ethereum, the clAMM deployments page; not a proxy): owner() = 0xCd03e2e276F6EEdD424d41314437531F665187b9, …",
     "key": "upgrade",
     "label": "Upgradeability",
     "state": "g",
     "value": "Immutable or ownership renounced"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "timelock",
     "label": "Timelock floor",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No enforced admin delay in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "quorum",
     "label": "Signer quorum",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No signer quorum in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "emergency",
     "label": "Emergency / freeze scope",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No pause / freeze authority in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "parity",
     "label": "Docs-vs-chain parity",
     "state": "g",
     "value": "Chain matches or is stronger than the documentation"
    }
   ],
   "finding": "V3 factory owner = V3Manager owned by the Operations Multisig (3-of-5)",
   "grade": "aligned",
   "gradeLabel": "ALIGNED",
   "name": "SushiSwap V3",
   "pinnedBlock": 26454861,
   "probe": {
    "block_hash": "0x7bb963434c873374e3a77f428d6998353152af08ccbfd79b556fef43f07ff4ec",
    "block_number": 26454861,
    "call_args": [],
    "call_signature": "owner()",
    "chain": "ethereum",
    "check_type": "eth_call",
    "extra_calls": [],
    "id": "sushiswap-v3-factory-operations-multisig-s35",
    "repro_calldata": "0x8da5cb5b",
    "rpc_env_var": "$ETH_RPC_URL",
    "selector_or_slot": "0x8da5cb5b",
    "target_contract": "0xbACEB8eC6b9355Dfc0269C18bac9d6E2Bdc29C4F",
    "target_label": "SushiSwap V3 factory (Ethereum)"
   },
   "reconciled": false,
   "reconciledFrom": [],
   "reconciledTo": [],
   "records": 1,
   "rosetteAria": "SushiSwap V3 control-plane rosette: Upgradeability strong; Timelock floor not determined; Signer quorum not determined; Emergency / freeze scope not determined; Docs-vs-chain parity strong",
   "search": "sushiswap v3 sushiswap-v3 concentrated-liquidity swap pools with tick-range lp positions (ethereum) sushiswap 0x19b3eb3af5d93b77a5619b047de0eed7115a19e7 0xbaceb8ec6b9355dfc0269c18bac9d6e2bdc29c4f 0xcd03e2e276f6eedd424d41314437531f665187b9",
   "slug": "sushiswap-v3",
   "summary_short": "Sushi V3 factory changes need 3 Operations Multisig signatures, as documented",
   "url": "https://pacta.wtf/protocols/sushiswap-v3/"
  },
  {
   "baskets": [
    "eth_lst_lrt"
   ],
   "category": "Liquid Staking & Restaking",
   "chains": [
    "ethereum"
   ],
   "deltas": 0,
   "easAttested": true,
   "evidence": {
    "documented": "Swell v3-core-public deployment architecture specifying 7-day Timelock upgrade/platform-admin control, 1h minimum reprice cadence, and 1% maximum reprice bound.",
    "observed": "swETH (0xf951E335afb289353dc249e82926178EaC7DEd78) EIP-1967 admin ProxyAdmin (0x25EAf579cA2255fAA5463c635eec28697b5b8846) and rswETH (0xFAe103DC9cf190eD75350761e95403b7b8aFa6c0) EIP-1967 admin ProxyAdmin (0xD750B84845f1cAdfEAc63f96Ec74635e949bFd14) both resolve owner() to SwellTimelock (0xbA829003e6b5dD858fbed3945719939a6DC3073b, delay() = 604800s / 7d, admin() = 4-of-7 Safe 0x20fDF47509C5eFC0e1101e3CE443691781C17F90), which is also the sole PLATFORM_ADMIN on both AccessControlManagers (0x625087d72c762254a72CB22cC2ECa40da6b95EAC, 0x796592b2092F7E150C48643dA19Dd2F28be3333F); minimumRepriceTime = 3600s (1h), maximumRepriceDifferencePercentage = 1% (1e16); swETH totalSupply = 9,635.13 swETH, rswETH totalSupply = 10,363.44 rswETH.",
    "recordId": "swell-sweth-rsweth-timelock-and-reprice-bounds",
    "surface": "Sampled 7-Day SwellTimelock, ProxyAdmins & Reprice Bounds"
   },
   "factors": [
    {
     "evidence": "swell-sweth-rsweth-timelock-and-reprice-bounds: swETH (0xf951E335afb289353dc249e82926178EaC7DEd78) EIP-1967 admin ProxyAdmin (0x25EAf579cA2255fAA5463c635eec28697b5b8846) and rswETH …",
     "key": "upgrade",
     "label": "Upgradeability",
     "state": "g",
     "value": "Upgradeable behind a ≥48h delay (7d)"
    },
    {
     "evidence": "swell-sweth-rsweth-timelock-and-reprice-bounds: observed_delay_seconds = 604800",
     "key": "timelock",
     "label": "Timelock floor",
     "state": "g",
     "value": "7d minimum enforced delay across control surfaces"
    },
    {
     "evidence": "swell-sweth-rsweth-timelock-and-reprice-bounds: … (0xbA829003e6b5dD858fbed3945719939a6DC3073b, delay() = 604800s / 7d, admin() = 4-of-7 Safe 0x20fDF47509C5eFC0e1101e3CE443691781C17F90), …",
     "key": "quorum",
     "label": "Signer quorum",
     "state": "g",
     "value": "Lowest controlling quorum: 4-of-7"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "emergency",
     "label": "Emergency / freeze scope",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No pause / freeze authority in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "parity",
     "label": "Docs-vs-chain parity",
     "state": "g",
     "value": "Chain matches or is stronger than the documentation"
    }
   ],
   "finding": "Sampled 7-Day SwellTimelock, ProxyAdmins & Reprice Bounds",
   "grade": "aligned",
   "gradeLabel": "ALIGNED",
   "name": "Swell (swETH / rswETH)",
   "pinnedBlock": 26403676,
   "probe": {
    "block_hash": "0xf4246ca23c4c38d520de16080a11b5186d04c8242b2c85edcb04c455d291c3ae",
    "block_number": 26403676,
    "call_args": [],
    "call_signature": "delay()",
    "chain": "ethereum",
    "check_type": "eth_call",
    "extra_calls": [],
    "id": "swell-sweth-rsweth-timelock-and-reprice-bounds",
    "repro_calldata": "0x6a42b8f8",
    "rpc_env_var": "$ETH_RPC_URL",
    "selector_or_slot": "0x6a42b8f8",
    "target_contract": "0xbA829003e6b5dD858fbed3945719939a6DC3073b",
    "target_label": "SwellTimelock"
   },
   "reconciled": false,
   "reconciledFrom": [],
   "reconciledTo": [],
   "records": 1,
   "rosetteAria": "Swell (swETH / rswETH) control-plane rosette: Upgradeability strong; Timelock floor strong; Signer quorum strong; Emergency / freeze scope not determined; Docs-vs-chain parity strong",
   "search": "swell (sweth / rsweth) swell-sweth-rsweth liquid staking & restaking sweth rsweth swell 0x20fdf47509c5efc0e1101e3ce443691781c17f90 0x25eaf579ca2255faa5463c635eec28697b5b8846 0x625087d72c762254a72cb22cc2eca40da6b95eac 0x796592b2092f7e150c48643da19dd2f28be3333f 0xba829003e6b5dd858fbed3945719939a6dc3073b 0xd750b84845f1cadfeac63f96ec74635e949bfd14 0xf951e335afb289353dc249e82926178eac7ded78 0xfae103dc9cf190ed75350761e95403b7b8afa6c0",
   "slug": "swell-sweth-rsweth",
   "summary_short": "7-day SwellTimelock, ProxyAdmins and reprice bounds match the docs",
   "url": "https://pacta.wtf/protocols/swell-sweth-rsweth/"
  },
  {
   "baskets": [],
   "category": "Cross-chain swap aggregator spanning EVM and non-EVM networks (Ethereum)",
   "chains": [
    "ethereum"
   ],
   "deltas": 0,
   "easAttested": false,
   "evidence": {
    "documented": "Symbiosis documentation is linked for reference (https://docs.symbiosis.finance/). This RPC-pinned record does not compare documentation parameters with the on-chain state.",
    "observed": "Symbiosis (0xd38BB40815d2B0c2d2c866e0c72c5728ffC76dd9) verified on Ethereum Mainnet at canonical block #26,458,556 (9,178 bytes runtime code). EIP-1967 implementation and admin storage slots are both zero (non-EIP-1967 contract). No owner(), admin(), authority(), curator() or AccessControl admin was readable on the contract.",
    "recordId": "symbiosis-control-plane",
    "surface": "Symbiosis · Non-Proxy Bytecode & Controller"
   },
   "factors": [
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "upgrade",
     "label": "Upgradeability",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "Upgrade path not in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "timelock",
     "label": "Timelock floor",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No enforced admin delay in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "quorum",
     "label": "Signer quorum",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No signer quorum in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "emergency",
     "label": "Emergency / freeze scope",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No pause / freeze authority in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "parity",
     "label": "Docs-vs-chain parity",
     "state": "u",
     "value": "Uncompared: documentation not assessed (RPC-observed)"
    }
   ],
   "finding": "Symbiosis · Non-Proxy Bytecode & Controller",
   "grade": "observed",
   "gradeLabel": "OBSERVED",
   "name": "Symbiosis",
   "pinnedBlock": 26458556,
   "probe": {
    "block_hash": "0xe258bb1cbcc988e2dfdba4ba173f9f8690520dba3647cdcae18e0651822769d2",
    "block_number": 26458556,
    "call_args": [],
    "call_signature": "owner()",
    "chain": "ethereum",
    "check_type": "eth_call",
    "extra_calls": [],
    "id": "symbiosis-control-plane",
    "repro_calldata": "0x8da5cb5b",
    "rpc_env_var": "$ETH_RPC_URL",
    "selector_or_slot": "0x8da5cb5b",
    "target_contract": "0xd38BB40815d2B0c2d2c866e0c72c5728ffC76dd9",
    "target_label": "Symbiosis"
   },
   "reconciled": false,
   "reconciledFrom": [],
   "reconciledTo": [],
   "records": 1,
   "rosetteAria": "Symbiosis control-plane rosette: Upgradeability not determined; Timelock floor not determined; Signer quorum not determined; Emergency / freeze scope not determined; Docs-vs-chain parity uncompared",
   "search": "symbiosis symbiosis cross-chain swap aggregator spanning evm and non-evm networks (ethereum) sis 0xd38bb40815d2b0c2d2c866e0c72c5728ffc76dd9",
   "slug": "symbiosis",
   "summary_short": "Non-proxy contract no readable owner or admin; docs not assessed",
   "url": "https://pacta.wtf/protocols/symbiosis/"
  },
  {
   "baskets": [
    "eth_lst_lrt"
   ],
   "category": "Restaking Infrastructure",
   "chains": [
    "ethereum"
   ],
   "deltas": 0,
   "easAttested": true,
   "evidence": {
    "documented": "Symbiotic Core architecture specifies non-upgradeable core registries and multisig-governed implementation/adapter whitelists.",
    "observed": "VaultFactory (0xAEb6bdd95c502390db8f52c8909F703E9Af6a346), OperatorRegistry (0xAd817a6Bc954F678451A71363f04150FDD81Af9F), and NetworkRegistry (0xC773b1011461e7314CF05f97d95aa8e92C1Fd8aA) hold zero EIP-1967 implementation/admin slots (0x00...00); VaultFactory.owner() = 2-of-3 Gnosis Safe (0x5721ce64Ee0D772Ce613b62D411350091C544cD0); AdapterRegistry (0x788823C9579A049D986eB76718bC758C0998594a) owner() = 3-of-5 Gnosis Safe (0xf6BB2e64Bd201A862f2Fe5461fc7Ef01e2040b6A).",
    "recordId": "symbiotic-core-immutable-registries-and-safes",
    "surface": "Sampled Non-Upgradeable Core Registries & Factory/Adapter Safes"
   },
   "factors": [
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "upgrade",
     "label": "Upgradeability",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "Upgrade path not in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "timelock",
     "label": "Timelock floor",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No enforced admin delay in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": "symbiotic-core-immutable-registries-and-safes: … (0x00...00); VaultFactory.owner() = 2-of-3 Gnosis Safe (0x5721ce64Ee0D772Ce613b62D411350091C544cD0); …",
     "key": "quorum",
     "label": "Signer quorum",
     "state": "b",
     "value": "Lowest controlling quorum: 2-of-3"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "emergency",
     "label": "Emergency / freeze scope",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No pause / freeze authority in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "parity",
     "label": "Docs-vs-chain parity",
     "state": "g",
     "value": "Chain matches or is stronger than the documentation"
    }
   ],
   "finding": "Sampled Non-Upgradeable Core Registries & Factory/Adapter Safes",
   "grade": "aligned",
   "gradeLabel": "ALIGNED",
   "name": "Symbiotic Core",
   "pinnedBlock": 26403121,
   "probe": {
    "block_hash": "0x71acee2313a2c8eacd7d2c87667dc505310b3e9224d84eaebb71d5a890ef9d1c",
    "block_number": 26403121,
    "call_args": [],
    "call_signature": null,
    "chain": "ethereum",
    "check_type": "eth_getStorageAt",
    "extra_calls": [],
    "id": "symbiotic-core-immutable-registries-and-safes",
    "repro_calldata": null,
    "rpc_env_var": "$ETH_RPC_URL",
    "selector_or_slot": "0x360894a13ba1a3210667c828492db98dca3e2076cc3735a920a3ca505d382bbc",
    "target_contract": "0xAEb6bdd95c502390db8f52c8909F703E9Af6a346",
    "target_label": "Symbiotic VaultFactory"
   },
   "reconciled": false,
   "reconciledFrom": [],
   "reconciledTo": [],
   "records": 1,
   "rosetteAria": "Symbiotic Core control-plane rosette: Upgradeability not determined; Timelock floor not determined; Signer quorum moderate; Emergency / freeze scope not determined; Docs-vs-chain parity strong",
   "search": "symbiotic core symbiotic-core restaking infrastructure symbiotic 0x5721ce64ee0d772ce613b62d411350091c544cd0 0x788823c9579a049d986eb76718bc758c0998594a 0xad817a6bc954f678451a71363f04150fdd81af9f 0xaeb6bdd95c502390db8f52c8909f703e9af6a346 0xc773b1011461e7314cf05f97d95aa8e92c1fd8aa 0xf6bb2e64bd201a862f2fe5461fc7ef01e2040b6a",
   "slug": "symbiotic-core",
   "summary_short": "Core registries are non-upgradeable; factory Safes match the docs",
   "url": "https://pacta.wtf/protocols/symbiotic-core/"
  },
  {
   "baskets": [
    "stable_rwa"
   ],
   "category": "Interchain messaging and nUSD / nETH stableswap pools linking many chains (Ethereum)",
   "chains": [
    "ethereum"
   ],
   "deltas": 0,
   "easAttested": false,
   "evidence": {
    "documented": "Synapse Cross Chain Bridge documentation is linked for reference (https://hypercall.xyz/synapse). This RPC-pinned record does not compare documentation parameters with the on-chain state.",
    "observed": "Synapse (0x0f2D719407FdBeFF09D87557AbB7232601FD9F29) verified on Ethereum Mainnet at canonical block #26,458,556 (45 bytes runtime code). EIP-1967 implementation and admin storage slots are both zero (non-EIP-1967 contract). DEFAULT_ADMIN_ROLE member is Safe 2-of-3 0x67F60b0891EBD842Ebe55E4CCcA1098d7Aac1A55.",
    "recordId": "synapse-cross-chain-bridge-control-plane",
    "surface": "Synapse · Non-Proxy Bytecode & Controller"
   },
   "factors": [
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "upgrade",
     "label": "Upgradeability",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "Upgrade path not in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "timelock",
     "label": "Timelock floor",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No enforced admin delay in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": "synapse-cross-chain-bridge-control-plane: … contract). DEFAULT_ADMIN_ROLE member is Safe 2-of-3 0x67F60b0891EBD842Ebe55E4CCcA1098d7Aac1A55.",
     "key": "quorum",
     "label": "Signer quorum",
     "state": "b",
     "value": "Lowest controlling quorum: 2-of-3"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "emergency",
     "label": "Emergency / freeze scope",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No pause / freeze authority in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "parity",
     "label": "Docs-vs-chain parity",
     "state": "u",
     "value": "Uncompared: documentation not assessed (RPC-observed)"
    }
   ],
   "finding": "Synapse · Non-Proxy Bytecode & Controller",
   "grade": "observed",
   "gradeLabel": "OBSERVED",
   "name": "Synapse Cross Chain Bridge",
   "pinnedBlock": 26458556,
   "probe": {
    "block_hash": "0xe258bb1cbcc988e2dfdba4ba173f9f8690520dba3647cdcae18e0651822769d2",
    "block_number": 26458556,
    "call_args": [],
    "call_signature": "owner()",
    "chain": "ethereum",
    "check_type": "eth_call",
    "extra_calls": [],
    "id": "synapse-cross-chain-bridge-control-plane",
    "repro_calldata": "0x8da5cb5b",
    "rpc_env_var": "$ETH_RPC_URL",
    "selector_or_slot": "0x8da5cb5b",
    "target_contract": "0x0f2D719407FdBeFF09D87557AbB7232601FD9F29",
    "target_label": "Synapse"
   },
   "reconciled": false,
   "reconciledFrom": [],
   "reconciledTo": [],
   "records": 1,
   "rosetteAria": "Synapse Cross Chain Bridge control-plane rosette: Upgradeability not determined; Timelock floor not determined; Signer quorum moderate; Emergency / freeze scope not determined; Docs-vs-chain parity uncompared",
   "search": "synapse cross chain bridge synapse-cross-chain-bridge interchain messaging and nusd / neth stableswap pools linking many chains (ethereum) syn 0x0f2d719407fdbeff09d87557abb7232601fd9f29 0x67f60b0891ebd842ebe55e4ccca1098d7aac1a55",
   "slug": "synapse-cross-chain-bridge",
   "summary_short": "Non-proxy contract controlled by a 2-of-3 Safe; docs not assessed",
   "url": "https://pacta.wtf/protocols/synapse-cross-chain-bridge/"
  },
  {
   "baskets": [
    "lending_vaults"
   ],
   "category": "Perpetual futures on any asset via an oracle-based automated market maker (Ethereum)",
   "chains": [
    "ethereum"
   ],
   "deltas": 0,
   "easAttested": true,
   "evidence": {
    "documented": "'**Maximum Supply:** 10,000,000,000' (docs.synfutures.com/llms-full.txt)",
    "observed": "SynFutures $F token 0x6e15A54B5EcAc17e58daDedDbe8506a7560252F9 (Ethereum; not a proxy: EIP-1967 implementation, admin and beacon slots all empty; verified source): totalSupply() = 10,000,000,000. The runtime code holds no selector of mint(address,uint256), mint(uint256), upgradeTo(address), upgradeToAndCall(address,bytes). Its only mint is the internal one at construction.",
    "recordId": "synfutures-f-max-supply-10b-s33",
    "surface": "$F supply: 10,000,000,000, no mint function"
   },
   "factors": [
    {
     "evidence": "synfutures-f-max-supply-10b-s33: SynFutures $F token 0x6e15A54B5EcAc17e58daDedDbe8506a7560252F9 (Ethereum; not a proxy: EIP-1967 implementation, admin and beacon slots all empty; verified …",
     "key": "upgrade",
     "label": "Upgradeability",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "Upgradeable; the delay gating the upgrade path is not in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "timelock",
     "label": "Timelock floor",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No enforced admin delay in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "quorum",
     "label": "Signer quorum",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No signer quorum in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "emergency",
     "label": "Emergency / freeze scope",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No pause / freeze authority in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "parity",
     "label": "Docs-vs-chain parity",
     "state": "g",
     "value": "Chain matches or is stronger than the documentation"
    }
   ],
   "finding": "$F supply: 10,000,000,000, no mint function",
   "grade": "aligned",
   "gradeLabel": "ALIGNED",
   "name": "SynFutures V3",
   "pinnedBlock": 26452373,
   "probe": {
    "block_hash": "0x63bfaa16f0019d8b37e757265d351bd135ad41e6ffa46207284198917123c55d",
    "block_number": 26452373,
    "call_args": [],
    "call_signature": "totalSupply()",
    "chain": "ethereum",
    "check_type": "eth_call",
    "extra_calls": [],
    "id": "synfutures-f-max-supply-10b-s33",
    "repro_calldata": "0x18160ddd",
    "rpc_env_var": "$ETH_RPC_URL",
    "selector_or_slot": "0x18160ddd",
    "target_contract": "0x6e15A54B5EcAc17e58daDedDbe8506a7560252F9",
    "target_label": "SynFutures $F token"
   },
   "reconciled": false,
   "reconciledFrom": [],
   "reconciledTo": [],
   "records": 1,
   "rosetteAria": "SynFutures V3 control-plane rosette: Upgradeability not determined; Timelock floor not determined; Signer quorum not determined; Emergency / freeze scope not determined; Docs-vs-chain parity strong",
   "search": "synfutures v3 synfutures-v3 perpetual futures on any asset via an oracle-based automated market maker (ethereum) synfutures 0x6e15a54b5ecac17e58dadeddbe8506a7560252f9",
   "slug": "synfutures-v3",
   "summary_short": "SynFutures $F is fully minted at its 10B maximum, as documented",
   "url": "https://pacta.wtf/protocols/synfutures-v3/"
  },
  {
   "baskets": [],
   "category": "Derivatives Liquidity Infrastructure",
   "chains": [
    "ethereum"
   ],
   "deltas": 0,
   "easAttested": true,
   "evidence": {
    "documented": "Synthetix V3 Ethereum deployment table, AccountProxy row: 'AccountProxy 0xffffffaEff0B96Ea8e4f94b2253f31abdD875847 n/a' / 'AccountProxy 0x0E429603D3Cb1DFae4E6F52Add5fE82d96d77Dac'",
    "observed": "AccountProxy 0x0E429603D3Cb1DFae4E6F52Add5fE82d96d77Dac: owner() = CoreProxy 0xffffffaEff0B96Ea8e4f94b2253f31abdD875847; nominatedOwner() = 0x0.",
    "recordId": "synthetix-v3-core-account-owner-s24",
    "surface": "Account NFT (AccountProxy) owner: the CoreProxy, not a key or Safe"
   },
   "factors": [
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "upgrade",
     "label": "Upgradeability",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "Upgrade path not in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "timelock",
     "label": "Timelock floor",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No enforced admin delay in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": "synthetix-v3-core-oracle-owner-s24: … 0xEb3107117FEAd7de89Cd14D463D340A2E6917769 (4-of-7); nominatedOwner() = 0x0.",
     "key": "quorum",
     "label": "Signer quorum",
     "state": "g",
     "value": "Lowest controlling quorum: 4-of-7"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "emergency",
     "label": "Emergency / freeze scope",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No pause / freeze authority in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "parity",
     "label": "Docs-vs-chain parity",
     "state": "g",
     "value": "Chain matches or is stronger than the documentation"
    }
   ],
   "finding": "Account NFT (AccountProxy) owner: the CoreProxy, not a key or Safe",
   "grade": "aligned",
   "gradeLabel": "ALIGNED",
   "name": "Synthetix V3 Core",
   "pinnedBlock": 26433001,
   "probe": {
    "block_hash": "0xa058ec92ccf0024822a76097f183d8e2d344d56e9539038c857e0cdaaa0ee5a7",
    "block_number": 26433001,
    "call_args": [],
    "call_signature": "owner()",
    "chain": "ethereum",
    "check_type": "eth_call",
    "extra_calls": [],
    "id": "synthetix-v3-core-account-owner-s24",
    "repro_calldata": "0x8da5cb5b",
    "rpc_env_var": "$ETH_RPC_URL",
    "selector_or_slot": "0x8da5cb5b",
    "target_contract": "0x0E429603D3Cb1DFae4E6F52Add5fE82d96d77Dac",
    "target_label": "Synthetix V3 AccountProxy"
   },
   "reconciled": false,
   "reconciledFrom": [],
   "reconciledTo": [],
   "records": 4,
   "rosetteAria": "Synthetix V3 Core control-plane rosette: Upgradeability not determined; Timelock floor not determined; Signer quorum strong; Emergency / freeze scope not determined; Docs-vs-chain parity strong",
   "search": "synthetix v3 core synthetix-v3-core derivatives liquidity infrastructure snx susd 0x0aaf300e148378489a8a471dd3e9e53e30cb42e3 0x0e429603d3cb1dfae4e6f52add5fe82d96d77dac 0x58ce7364744e59402b3672d3cf3bb415a12441cd 0xb2f30a7c980f052f02563fb518dcc39e6bf38175 0xeb3107117fead7de89cd14d463d340a2e6917769 0xffffffaeff0b96ea8e4f94b2253f31abdd875847",
   "slug": "synthetix-v3-core",
   "summary_short": "Account NFT is owned by the CoreProxy, not a key or Safe, as documented",
   "url": "https://pacta.wtf/protocols/synthetix-v3-core/"
  },
  {
   "baskets": [
    "lending_vaults",
    "stable_rwa"
   ],
   "category": "Risk-adjusted stablecoin allocation across lending markets (Ethereum)",
   "chains": [
    "ethereum"
   ],
   "deltas": 0,
   "easAttested": false,
   "evidence": {
    "documented": "Syntropia documentation is linked for reference (https://docs.syntropia.ai/). This RPC-pinned record does not compare documentation parameters with the on-chain state.",
    "observed": "Syntropia USDC Core (0x1b2CB79a4564206f53Ba80b4d780F251b4Ae6765) verified on Ethereum Mainnet at canonical block #26,458,556 (1,427 bytes runtime code). EIP-1967 proxy: implementation 0xE50554ec802375C9c3F9c087a8a7bb8C26d3DEDf, admin 0x78AC58ED54018F5ccd5F5De2D7c0AE40800f2cf4. The EIP-1967 admin slot holds contract contract 0x78AC58ED54018F5ccd5F5De2D7c0AE40800f2cf4. That controller is in turn controlled by externally owned account (no code) 0x3daB62f33E7032bD33C532808092D033887EB456.",
    "recordId": "syntropia-control-plane",
    "surface": "Syntropia USDC Core · EIP-1967 Proxy & Controller Chain"
   },
   "factors": [
    {
     "evidence": "syntropia-control-plane: is_eip1967_proxy = true",
     "key": "upgrade",
     "label": "Upgradeability",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "Upgradeable; the delay gating the upgrade path is not in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "timelock",
     "label": "Timelock floor",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No enforced admin delay in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": "syntropia-control-plane: … controller is in turn controlled by externally owned account (no code) 0x3daB62f33E7032bD33C532808092D033887EB456.",
     "key": "quorum",
     "label": "Signer quorum",
     "state": "a",
     "value": "Lowest controlling quorum: a single key"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "emergency",
     "label": "Emergency / freeze scope",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No pause / freeze authority in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "parity",
     "label": "Docs-vs-chain parity",
     "state": "u",
     "value": "Uncompared: documentation not assessed (RPC-observed)"
    }
   ],
   "finding": "Syntropia USDC Core · EIP-1967 Proxy & Controller Chain",
   "grade": "observed",
   "gradeLabel": "OBSERVED",
   "name": "Syntropia",
   "pinnedBlock": 26458556,
   "probe": {
    "block_hash": "0xe258bb1cbcc988e2dfdba4ba173f9f8690520dba3647cdcae18e0651822769d2",
    "block_number": 26458556,
    "call_args": [],
    "call_signature": null,
    "chain": "ethereum",
    "check_type": "eth_getStorageAt",
    "extra_calls": [],
    "id": "syntropia-control-plane",
    "repro_calldata": null,
    "rpc_env_var": "$ETH_RPC_URL",
    "selector_or_slot": "0xb53127684a568b3173ae13b9f8a6016e243e63b6e8ee1178d6a717850b5d6103",
    "target_contract": "0x1b2CB79a4564206f53Ba80b4d780F251b4Ae6765",
    "target_label": "Syntropia USDC Core"
   },
   "reconciled": false,
   "reconciledFrom": [],
   "reconciledTo": [],
   "records": 1,
   "rosetteAria": "Syntropia control-plane rosette: Upgradeability not determined; Timelock floor not determined; Signer quorum weak; Emergency / freeze scope not determined; Docs-vs-chain parity uncompared",
   "search": "syntropia syntropia risk-adjusted stablecoin allocation across lending markets (ethereum) synusd 0x1b2cb79a4564206f53ba80b4d780f251b4ae6765 0x3dab62f33e7032bd33c532808092d033887eb456 0x78ac58ed54018f5ccd5f5de2d7c0ae40800f2cf4 0xe50554ec802375c9c3f9c087a8a7bb8c26d3dedf",
   "slug": "syntropia",
   "summary_short": "Upgradeable proxy controlled by a contract; docs not assessed",
   "url": "https://pacta.wtf/protocols/syntropia/"
  },
  {
   "baskets": [
    "stable_rwa"
   ],
   "category": "Canonical bridge into a based contestable ZK rollup (Ethereum)",
   "chains": [
    "ethereum"
   ],
   "deltas": 1,
   "easAttested": true,
   "evidence": {
    "documented": "'The proposal must receive 6 approvals within 14 days from Security Council members to be executable.' (dao-docs.taiko.xyz/guides/making-an-emergency-proposal); 'The proposal must receive 5 approvals within 14 days from Security Council members to move to the public stage' (dao-docs.taiko.xyz/guides/making-a-standard-proposal); '- Owner (Taiko DAO): `0x9CDf589C941ee81D75F34d3755671d614f7cf261`' (raw.githubusercontent.com/taikoxyz/taiko-mono/main/packages/protocol/deployments/mainnet-contract-logs-L1.md)",
    "observed": "Taiko DAO 0x9CDf589C941ee81D75F34d3755671d614f7cf261 (owner of controller.taiko.eth in the taiko-mono deployment log): hasPermission() grants EXECUTE_PERMISSION on the DAO to the OptimisticTokenVoting plugin 0x989E348275b659d36f8751ea1c10D146211650BE (and not to either council plugin), and PROPOSER_PERMISSION on that plugin to the Emergency Multisig 0x2AffADEb2ef5e1F2a7F58964ee191F1e88317ECd and the Multisig 0xD7dA1C25E915438720692bC55eb3a7170cA90321; all three return dao() = the DAO (EIP-1967 proxies, implementations 0x437E450452E8Bc142bd5317199296EcB187c514b, 0x8510d389236d7213eE9B9C38CAaBc0aD24853C25, 0x5B0Da2FB08754a5dDf32e28887D2F5437485f085, verified). EmergencyMultisig multisigSettings() = (onlyListed true, minApprovals 4, signerList 0x0F95E6968EC1B28c794CF1aD99609431de5179c2, proposalExpirationPeriod 1,209,600 s); the SignerList addresslistLength() = 5. Its execute() needs approvals >= minApprovals and calls createProposal(..., duration 0) on the destination plugin, which executes the actions on the DAO immediately when the duration is 0 (governanceSettings() minDuration = 0): 4 of the 5 listed signers make an emergency proposal executable. Multisig (standard) multisigSettings() = (onlyListed true, minApprovals 3, destinationProposalDuration 864,000 s, same signerList, proposalExpirationPeriod 1,209,600 s): 3 approvals move a standard proposal to the public veto stage (timelockPeriod 604,800 s, as documented).",
    "recordId": "taiko-dao-emergency-multisig-4-of-5-s34",
    "surface": "Emergency Multisig: minApprovals 4 of 5 signers (docs: 6); standard 3 (docs: 5)"
   },
   "factors": [
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "upgrade",
     "label": "Upgradeability",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "Upgrade path not in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "timelock",
     "label": "Timelock floor",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No enforced admin delay in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "quorum",
     "label": "Signer quorum",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No signer quorum in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "emergency",
     "label": "Emergency / freeze scope",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No pause / freeze authority in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "parity",
     "label": "Docs-vs-chain parity",
     "state": "a",
     "value": "Documentation differs from the chain (parameter delta)"
    }
   ],
   "finding": "Emergency Multisig: minApprovals 4 of 5 signers (docs: 6); standard 3 (docs: 5): docs say 'The proposal must receive 6 approvals within 14 days from Security Council members to be executable.' (dao-docs.taiko.xyz/guides/making-an-emergency-proposal); · chain says Taiko DAO 0x9CDf589C941ee81D75F34d3755671d614f7cf261 (owner of controller.taiko.eth in the taiko-mono deployment log): hasPermission() grants EXECUTE_PERMISSION on the DAO to the OptimisticTokenVoting plugin 0x989E34827…",
   "grade": "delta",
   "gradeLabel": "DELTA",
   "name": "Taiko Bridge",
   "pinnedBlock": 26453551,
   "probe": {
    "block_hash": "0x51e9967ffd6a84012d0dad44204d523b8ac43928e69de2801d2e72dbf8767129",
    "block_number": 26453551,
    "call_args": [],
    "call_signature": "multisigSettings()",
    "chain": "ethereum",
    "check_type": "eth_call",
    "extra_calls": [],
    "id": "taiko-dao-emergency-multisig-4-of-5-s34",
    "repro_calldata": "0xe097b3ff",
    "rpc_env_var": "$ETH_RPC_URL",
    "selector_or_slot": "0xe097b3ff",
    "target_contract": "0x2AffADEb2ef5e1F2a7F58964ee191F1e88317ECd",
    "target_label": "Taiko DAO Emergency Multisig plugin"
   },
   "reconciled": false,
   "reconciledFrom": [],
   "reconciledTo": [],
   "records": 1,
   "rosetteAria": "Taiko Bridge control-plane rosette: Upgradeability not determined; Timelock floor not determined; Signer quorum not determined; Emergency / freeze scope not determined; Docs-vs-chain parity weak",
   "search": "taiko bridge taiko-bridge canonical bridge into a based contestable zk rollup (ethereum) taiko 0x0f95e6968ec1b28c794cf1ad99609431de5179c2 0x2affadeb2ef5e1f2a7f58964ee191f1e88317ecd 0x437e450452e8bc142bd5317199296ecb187c514b 0x5b0da2fb08754a5ddf32e28887d2f5437485f085 0x8510d389236d7213ee9b9c38caabc0ad24853c25 0x989e348275b659d36f8751ea1c10d146211650be 0x9cdf589c941ee81d75f34d3755671d614f7cf261 0xd7da1c25e915438720692bc55eb3a7170ca90321",
   "slug": "taiko-bridge",
   "summary_short": "Taiko emergency proposals execute with 4 of 5 council approvals; docs say 6",
   "url": "https://pacta.wtf/protocols/taiko-bridge/"
  },
  {
   "baskets": [
    "stable_rwa"
   ],
   "category": "Stablecoin (USG) borrowing against Curve and Convex LP collateral (Ethereum)",
   "chains": [
    "ethereum"
   ],
   "deltas": 0,
   "easAttested": true,
   "evidence": {
    "documented": "'| Admin | 0x461B62CB3A7e9Df8f800aE058AE92F855F2c27Ca |' (docs.tangent.finance/docs/faq/contracts.md)",
    "observed": "owner() = Admin 0x461B62CB3A7e9Df8f800aE058AE92F855F2c27Ca on Control Tower 0xf3f7669dceed2f985815011c19ed68f667267215, USG 0xb1c2db5d6ca03fce73dbd304d320bf76c55ae1b1, IR Calculator 0xB4e1d3bBd2843263d58B4D648C599512cea6e88b, Rewards Accumulator 0x1461D76aA1C9c523398301D9174098c6D53ce639, Markets Creator 0x214C8A1023B30032a2Eded109146658C6D6F2781, Pauser Proxy 0x10b1f36452e27f08b0b5747f577ff816b0e6b5fa (core contracts on the contracts page). The Admin is a Safe: getThreshold() = 3 of getOwners() = 5; guard slot empty; getModulesPaginated() lists no module.",
    "recordId": "tangent-admin-safe-owns-core-s34",
    "surface": "Core contracts' owner() = the documented Admin (3-of-5 Safe)"
   },
   "factors": [
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "upgrade",
     "label": "Upgradeability",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "Upgrade path not in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "timelock",
     "label": "Timelock floor",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No enforced admin delay in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "quorum",
     "label": "Signer quorum",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No signer quorum in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": "tangent-admin-safe-owns-core-s34: owner() = Admin 0x461B62CB3A7e9Df8f800aE058AE92F855F2c27Ca on Control Tower 0xf3f7669dceed2f985815011c19ed68f667267215, USG …",
     "key": "emergency",
     "label": "Emergency / freeze scope",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "Pause / freeze authority present; its holder is not determined"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "parity",
     "label": "Docs-vs-chain parity",
     "state": "g",
     "value": "Chain matches or is stronger than the documentation"
    }
   ],
   "finding": "Core contracts' owner() = the documented Admin (3-of-5 Safe)",
   "grade": "aligned",
   "gradeLabel": "ALIGNED",
   "name": "Tangent Finance",
   "pinnedBlock": 26453551,
   "probe": {
    "block_hash": "0x51e9967ffd6a84012d0dad44204d523b8ac43928e69de2801d2e72dbf8767129",
    "block_number": 26453551,
    "call_args": [],
    "call_signature": "owner()",
    "chain": "ethereum",
    "check_type": "eth_call",
    "extra_calls": [],
    "id": "tangent-admin-safe-owns-core-s34",
    "repro_calldata": "0x8da5cb5b",
    "rpc_env_var": "$ETH_RPC_URL",
    "selector_or_slot": "0x8da5cb5b",
    "target_contract": "0x214C8A1023B30032a2Eded109146658C6D6F2781",
    "target_label": "Tangent MarketCreator"
   },
   "reconciled": false,
   "reconciledFrom": [],
   "reconciledTo": [],
   "records": 1,
   "rosetteAria": "Tangent Finance control-plane rosette: Upgradeability not determined; Timelock floor not determined; Signer quorum not determined; Emergency / freeze scope not determined; Docs-vs-chain parity strong",
   "search": "tangent finance tangent-finance stablecoin (usg) borrowing against curve and convex lp collateral (ethereum) tangent 0x10b1f36452e27f08b0b5747f577ff816b0e6b5fa 0x1461d76aa1c9c523398301d9174098c6d53ce639 0x214c8a1023b30032a2eded109146658c6d6f2781 0x461b62cb3a7e9df8f800ae058ae92f855f2c27ca 0xb1c2db5d6ca03fce73dbd304d320bf76c55ae1b1 0xb4e1d3bbd2843263d58b4d648c599512cea6e88b 0xf3f7669dceed2f985815011c19ed68f667267215",
   "slug": "tangent-finance",
   "summary_short": "Tangent's core contracts are owned by the documented Admin Safe",
   "url": "https://pacta.wtf/protocols/tangent-finance/"
  },
  {
   "baskets": [],
   "category": "Token Locks & Vesting Toolkit (Ethereum)",
   "chains": [
    "ethereum"
   ],
   "deltas": 0,
   "easAttested": false,
   "evidence": {
    "documented": "Team Finance documentation is linked for reference (https://blog.team.finance/introducing-the-new-team-finance-security-page/). This RPC-pinned record does not compare documentation parameters with the on-chain state.",
    "observed": "TrustSwap Token (SwapToken) (0xCC4304A31d09258b0029eA7FE63d032f52e44EFe) verified on Ethereum Mainnet at canonical block #26,458,556 (2,240 bytes runtime code). EIP-1967 proxy: implementation 0xffe273a973c66da5b8ad6772f2476dBd6491034e, admin 0x088a012BF6d510aa923c814eA83807f75F7061A0. The EIP-1967 admin slot holds Safe 2-of-4 0x088a012BF6d510aa923c814eA83807f75F7061A0.",
    "recordId": "team-finance-control-plane",
    "surface": "TrustSwap Token (SwapToken) · EIP-1967 Proxy & Controller Chain"
   },
   "factors": [
    {
     "evidence": "team-finance-control-plane: is_eip1967_proxy = true",
     "key": "upgrade",
     "label": "Upgradeability",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "Upgradeable; the delay gating the upgrade path is not in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "timelock",
     "label": "Timelock floor",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No enforced admin delay in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": "team-finance-control-plane: … The EIP-1967 admin slot holds Safe 2-of-4 0x088a012BF6d510aa923c814eA83807f75F7061A0.",
     "key": "quorum",
     "label": "Signer quorum",
     "state": "b",
     "value": "Lowest controlling quorum: 2-of-4"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "emergency",
     "label": "Emergency / freeze scope",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No pause / freeze authority in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "parity",
     "label": "Docs-vs-chain parity",
     "state": "u",
     "value": "Uncompared: documentation not assessed (RPC-observed)"
    }
   ],
   "finding": "TrustSwap Token (SwapToken) · EIP-1967 Proxy & Controller Chain",
   "grade": "observed",
   "gradeLabel": "OBSERVED",
   "name": "Team Finance",
   "pinnedBlock": 26458556,
   "probe": {
    "block_hash": "0xe258bb1cbcc988e2dfdba4ba173f9f8690520dba3647cdcae18e0651822769d2",
    "block_number": 26458556,
    "call_args": [],
    "call_signature": null,
    "chain": "ethereum",
    "check_type": "eth_getStorageAt",
    "extra_calls": [],
    "id": "team-finance-control-plane",
    "repro_calldata": null,
    "rpc_env_var": "$ETH_RPC_URL",
    "selector_or_slot": "0xb53127684a568b3173ae13b9f8a6016e243e63b6e8ee1178d6a717850b5d6103",
    "target_contract": "0xCC4304A31d09258b0029eA7FE63d032f52e44EFe",
    "target_label": "TrustSwap Token (SwapToken)"
   },
   "reconciled": false,
   "reconciledFrom": [],
   "reconciledTo": [],
   "records": 1,
   "rosetteAria": "Team Finance control-plane rosette: Upgradeability not determined; Timelock floor not determined; Signer quorum moderate; Emergency / freeze scope not determined; Docs-vs-chain parity uncompared",
   "search": "team finance team-finance token locks & vesting toolkit (ethereum) swap 0x088a012bf6d510aa923c814ea83807f75f7061a0 0xcc4304a31d09258b0029ea7fe63d032f52e44efe 0xffe273a973c66da5b8ad6772f2476dbd6491034e",
   "slug": "team-finance",
   "summary_short": "Upgradeable proxy controlled by a 2-of-4 Safe; docs not assessed",
   "url": "https://pacta.wtf/protocols/team-finance/"
  },
  {
   "baskets": [
    "stable_rwa"
   ],
   "category": "Fiat-Backed Stablecoin (USDT)",
   "chains": [
    "ethereum"
   ],
   "deltas": 0,
   "easAttested": true,
   "evidence": {
    "documented": "tether.to (FAQ): 'Tether Tokens are created by having multiple Tether private authorization keys sign and broadcast creation transactions on the specific blockchain.' and 'Tether’s multi-signature (or multi-sig) model protects against a single person from authorizing Tether Tokens on their own, which would represent a single point of failure and a security risk.' / supported protocols: 'USD₮ contract address: https://etherscan.io/token/0xdac17f958d2ee523a2206206994597c13d831ec7'",
    "observed": "TetherToken 0xdAC17F958D2ee523a2206206994597C13D831ec7: getOwner() = owner() = MultiSigWallet 0xC6CDE7C39eB2f0F0095F41570af89eFC2C1Ea828 (Sourcify match): required() = 3, getOwners() = 6 owners (transactionCount() = 5848).",
    "recordId": "tether-usdt-owner-multisig-3of6-s23",
    "surface": "Owner: a 3-of-6 MultiSigWallet (multi-signature authorization)"
   },
   "factors": [
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "upgrade",
     "label": "Upgradeability",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "Upgrade path not in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "timelock",
     "label": "Timelock floor",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No enforced admin delay in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": "tether-usdt-token-live-blacklist-under-owner-s23: … pause and deprecate are onlyOwner (the 3-of-6 MultiSigWallet 0xC6CDE7C39eB2f0F0095F41570af89eFC2C1Ea828; …",
     "key": "quorum",
     "label": "Signer quorum",
     "state": "g",
     "value": "Lowest controlling quorum: 3-of-6"
    },
    {
     "evidence": "tether-usdt-token-live-blacklist-under-owner-s23: addBlackList / destroyBlackFunds, pause and deprecate are onlyOwner (the 3-of-6 MultiSigWallet 0xC6CDE7C39eB2f0F0095F41570af89eFC2C1Ea828; no timelock) …",
     "key": "emergency",
     "label": "Emergency / freeze scope",
     "state": "g",
     "value": "Pause / freeze authority scoped behind a multi-signer controller (3-of-6)"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "parity",
     "label": "Docs-vs-chain parity",
     "state": "g",
     "value": "Chain matches or is stronger than the documentation"
    }
   ],
   "finding": "Owner: a 3-of-6 MultiSigWallet (multi-signature authorization)",
   "grade": "aligned",
   "gradeLabel": "ALIGNED",
   "name": "Tether USDT",
   "pinnedBlock": 26431152,
   "probe": {
    "block_hash": "0xfe2ed4e127f30bb42dd30c6fc1460a82d8438cff3a717ec89210805e55199a46",
    "block_number": 26431152,
    "call_args": [],
    "call_signature": "getOwner()",
    "chain": "ethereum",
    "check_type": "eth_call",
    "extra_calls": [],
    "id": "tether-usdt-owner-multisig-3of6-s23",
    "repro_calldata": "0x893d20e8",
    "rpc_env_var": "$ETH_RPC_URL",
    "selector_or_slot": "0x893d20e8",
    "target_contract": "0xdAC17F958D2ee523a2206206994597C13D831ec7",
    "target_label": "Tether USD (TetherToken)"
   },
   "reconciled": false,
   "reconciledFrom": [],
   "reconciledTo": [],
   "records": 2,
   "rosetteAria": "Tether USDT control-plane rosette: Upgradeability not determined; Timelock floor not determined; Signer quorum strong; Emergency / freeze scope strong; Docs-vs-chain parity strong",
   "search": "tether usdt tether-usdt fiat-backed stablecoin (usdt) usdt 0xc6cde7c39eb2f0f0095f41570af89efc2c1ea828 0xdac17f958d2ee523a2206206994597c13d831ec7",
   "slug": "tether-usdt",
   "summary_short": "Owner is a 3-of-6 MultiSigWallet, as documented",
   "url": "https://pacta.wtf/protocols/tether-usdt/"
  },
  {
   "baskets": [
    "eth_lst_lrt"
   ],
   "category": "Staked-ether NFT collection sharing staking rewards (Ethereum)",
   "chains": [
    "ethereum"
   ],
   "deltas": 0,
   "easAttested": true,
   "evidence": {
    "documented": "'The $VIRTUE token is non-mintable and will have a maximum total supply of 100,000,000 tokens.' (docs.theidols.io/llms-full.txt)",
    "observed": "VIRTUE token 0x9416bA76e88D873050A06e5956A3EBF10386b863 (Ethereum; not a proxy: EIP-1967 implementation, admin and beacon slots all empty; verified source): totalSupply() = 99,989,832.94. The runtime code holds no selector of mint(address,uint256), mint(uint256), upgradeTo(address), upgradeToAndCall(address,bytes). Its only mint is the internal one at construction (100,000,000); supply is lower through burns.",
    "recordId": "the-idols-virtue-non-mintable-s33",
    "surface": "VIRTUE: 99,989,832.94, no mint function"
   },
   "factors": [
    {
     "evidence": "the-idols-virtue-non-mintable-s33: VIRTUE token 0x9416bA76e88D873050A06e5956A3EBF10386b863 (Ethereum; not a proxy: EIP-1967 implementation, admin and beacon slots all empty; verified source) …",
     "key": "upgrade",
     "label": "Upgradeability",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "Upgradeable; the delay gating the upgrade path is not in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "timelock",
     "label": "Timelock floor",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No enforced admin delay in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "quorum",
     "label": "Signer quorum",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No signer quorum in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "emergency",
     "label": "Emergency / freeze scope",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No pause / freeze authority in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "parity",
     "label": "Docs-vs-chain parity",
     "state": "g",
     "value": "Chain matches or is stronger than the documentation"
    }
   ],
   "finding": "VIRTUE: 99,989,832.94, no mint function",
   "grade": "aligned",
   "gradeLabel": "ALIGNED",
   "name": "The Idols",
   "pinnedBlock": 26452373,
   "probe": {
    "block_hash": "0x63bfaa16f0019d8b37e757265d351bd135ad41e6ffa46207284198917123c55d",
    "block_number": 26452373,
    "call_args": [],
    "call_signature": "totalSupply()",
    "chain": "ethereum",
    "check_type": "eth_call",
    "extra_calls": [],
    "id": "the-idols-virtue-non-mintable-s33",
    "repro_calldata": "0x18160ddd",
    "rpc_env_var": "$ETH_RPC_URL",
    "selector_or_slot": "0x18160ddd",
    "target_contract": "0x9416bA76e88D873050A06e5956A3EBF10386b863",
    "target_label": "VIRTUE token"
   },
   "reconciled": false,
   "reconciledFrom": [],
   "reconciledTo": [],
   "records": 1,
   "rosetteAria": "The Idols control-plane rosette: Upgradeability not determined; Timelock floor not determined; Signer quorum not determined; Emergency / freeze scope not determined; Docs-vs-chain parity strong",
   "search": "the idols the-idols staked-ether nft collection sharing staking rewards (ethereum) virtue 0x9416ba76e88d873050a06e5956a3ebf10386b863",
   "slug": "the-idols",
   "summary_short": "VIRTUE is non-mintable and under its 100M maximum, as documented",
   "url": "https://pacta.wtf/protocols/the-idols/"
  },
  {
   "baskets": [
    "lending_vaults",
    "stable_rwa"
   ],
   "category": "Treasury-Backed Yield Stablecoin (thBILL collateral) (Ethereum)",
   "chains": [
    "ethereum"
   ],
   "deltas": 0,
   "easAttested": false,
   "evidence": {
    "documented": "Theo Network thUSD documentation is linked for reference (https://app.theo.xyz/). This RPC-pinned record does not compare documentation parameters with the on-chain state.",
    "observed": "thUSD (0xa3fE5c7596024E6811E14F029937D5bd8Ae485b3) verified on Ethereum Mainnet at canonical block #26,458,556 (130 bytes runtime code). EIP-1967 proxy: implementation 0xCD04F57464d25F257089A286AAb47DF096d300Ad, admin slot zero. Direct owner() returns timelock (2 d delay) 0x2bB4b7E6E83FA6b77d0143dad631843cB73DCA02.",
    "recordId": "theo-network-thusd-control-plane",
    "surface": "thUSD · EIP-1967 Proxy & Controller Chain"
   },
   "factors": [
    {
     "evidence": "theo-network-thusd-control-plane: is_eip1967_proxy = true",
     "key": "upgrade",
     "label": "Upgradeability",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "Upgradeable; the delay gating the upgrade path is not in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": "controller fact: getMinDelay() = 172800s",
     "key": "timelock",
     "label": "Timelock floor",
     "state": "g",
     "value": "2d minimum enforced delay across control surfaces"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "quorum",
     "label": "Signer quorum",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No signer quorum in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "emergency",
     "label": "Emergency / freeze scope",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No pause / freeze authority in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "parity",
     "label": "Docs-vs-chain parity",
     "state": "u",
     "value": "Uncompared: documentation not assessed (RPC-observed)"
    }
   ],
   "finding": "thUSD · EIP-1967 Proxy & Controller Chain",
   "grade": "observed",
   "gradeLabel": "OBSERVED",
   "name": "Theo Network thUSD",
   "pinnedBlock": 26458556,
   "probe": {
    "block_hash": "0xe258bb1cbcc988e2dfdba4ba173f9f8690520dba3647cdcae18e0651822769d2",
    "block_number": 26458556,
    "call_args": [],
    "call_signature": "owner()",
    "chain": "ethereum",
    "check_type": "eth_call",
    "extra_calls": [],
    "id": "theo-network-thusd-control-plane",
    "repro_calldata": "0x8da5cb5b",
    "rpc_env_var": "$ETH_RPC_URL",
    "selector_or_slot": "0x8da5cb5b",
    "target_contract": "0xa3fE5c7596024E6811E14F029937D5bd8Ae485b3",
    "target_label": "thUSD"
   },
   "reconciled": false,
   "reconciledFrom": [],
   "reconciledTo": [],
   "records": 1,
   "rosetteAria": "Theo Network thUSD control-plane rosette: Upgradeability not determined; Timelock floor strong; Signer quorum not determined; Emergency / freeze scope not determined; Docs-vs-chain parity uncompared",
   "search": "theo network thusd theo-network-thusd treasury-backed yield stablecoin (thbill collateral) (ethereum) thusd 0x2bb4b7e6e83fa6b77d0143dad631843cb73dca02 0xa3fe5c7596024e6811e14f029937d5bd8ae485b3 0xcd04f57464d25f257089a286aab47df096d300ad",
   "slug": "theo-network-thusd",
   "summary_short": "Upgradeable proxy controlled by a timelock; docs not assessed",
   "url": "https://pacta.wtf/protocols/theo-network-thusd/"
  },
  {
   "baskets": [],
   "category": "Decentralized Bitcoin Bridge",
   "chains": [
    "ethereum"
   ],
   "deltas": 0,
   "easAttested": true,
   "evidence": {
    "documented": "docs.threshold.network contract addresses (Mainnet, tBTC application contracts) list 0x92f2d8b72a7F6a551Be60b9aa4194248E9B4913D as the tBTC 'Timelock Controller'; the docs state no delay for it. The '2-day' timelock in the Governance Process page belongs to the separate Governor Bravo Timelock Controller (0x87F005317692D05BAA4193AB0c961c69e175f45f, getMinDelay() = 172800s at the same block).",
    "observed": "getMinDelay() = 86400s (1d). Operation 0xb6671bbbedf818d7232a4006d4a85b21e3f3055d17244188f244c1da8263e0c7: isOperationPending() = true, getTimestamp() = 1794604955 (2026-11-13 21:22:35 UTC). It is a public CallScheduled upgradeAndCall (0x9623609d) on ProxyAdmin (0x7Affa05f726D293eB1193807A91617318292008e) for WalletRegistry (0x46d52E41C2F300BC82217Ce22b920c34995204eb) to implementation 0x14fAD0C11C83AC736e5929D5661bbA7E6BB9c0D6.",
    "recordId": "threshold-tbtc-timelock-1d-walletregistry-op-0xb667",
    "surface": "tBTC TimelockController 1d delay — public WalletRegistry upgradeAndCall schedule"
   },
   "factors": [
    {
     "evidence": "threshold-tbtc-timelock-1d-walletregistry-op-0xb667: getMinDelay() = 86400s (1d). Operation 0xb6671bbbedf818d7232a4006d4a85b21e3f3055d17244188f244c1da8263e0c7: isOperationPending() = true, getTimestamp() = …",
     "key": "upgrade",
     "label": "Upgradeability",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "Upgradeable; the delay gating the upgrade path is not in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": "controller fact: getMinDelay() = 86400s",
     "key": "timelock",
     "label": "Timelock floor",
     "state": "b",
     "value": "1d minimum enforced delay across control surfaces"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "quorum",
     "label": "Signer quorum",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No signer quorum in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "emergency",
     "label": "Emergency / freeze scope",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No pause / freeze authority in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "parity",
     "label": "Docs-vs-chain parity",
     "state": "g",
     "value": "Chain matches or is stronger than the documentation"
    }
   ],
   "finding": "tBTC TimelockController 1d delay — public WalletRegistry upgradeAndCall schedule",
   "grade": "aligned",
   "gradeLabel": "ALIGNED",
   "name": "Threshold Network (tBTC)",
   "pinnedBlock": 26449594,
   "probe": {
    "block_hash": "0x9030abf37638c14a5f9c145f298a0f4cd74b247a99f3dddd119b9c6b09f5dced",
    "block_number": 26407707,
    "call_args": [],
    "call_signature": "getMinDelay()",
    "chain": "ethereum",
    "check_type": "eth_call",
    "extra_calls": [],
    "id": "threshold-tbtc-timelock-1d-walletregistry-op-0xb667",
    "repro_calldata": "0xf27a0c92",
    "rpc_env_var": "$ETH_RPC_URL",
    "selector_or_slot": "0xf27a0c92",
    "target_contract": "0x92f2d8b72a7F6a551Be60b9aa4194248E9B4913D",
    "target_label": "Threshold Council TimelockController"
   },
   "reconciled": false,
   "reconciledFrom": [],
   "reconciledTo": [],
   "records": 2,
   "rosetteAria": "Threshold Network (tBTC) control-plane rosette: Upgradeability not determined; Timelock floor moderate; Signer quorum not determined; Emergency / freeze scope not determined; Docs-vs-chain parity strong",
   "search": "threshold network (tbtc) threshold-network-tbtc decentralized bitcoin bridge tbtc t 0x14fad0c11c83ac736e5929d5661bba7e6bb9c0d6 0x46d52e41c2f300bc82217ce22b920c34995204eb 0x7affa05f726d293eb1193807a91617318292008e 0x87f005317692d05baa4193ab0c961c69e175f45f 0x92f2d8b72a7f6a551be60b9aa4194248e9b4913d",
   "slug": "threshold-network-tbtc",
   "summary_short": "tBTC timelock is 1 day; the WalletRegistry upgrade schedule is public",
   "url": "https://pacta.wtf/protocols/threshold-network-tbtc/"
  },
  {
   "baskets": [],
   "category": "Strategy tokens that buy floor NFTs with trading fees and burn supply (Ethereum)",
   "chains": [
    "ethereum"
   ],
   "deltas": 0,
   "easAttested": false,
   "evidence": {
    "documented": "TokenWorks documentation is linked for reference (https://www.nftstrategy.fun/). This RPC-pinned record does not compare documentation parameters with the on-chain state.",
    "observed": "NFTStrategyFactory (0xA1a196b5BE89Be04a2c1dc71643689CE013c22e5) verified on Ethereum Mainnet at canonical block #26,458,556 (15,864 bytes runtime code). EIP-1967 implementation and admin storage slots are both zero (non-EIP-1967 contract). Direct owner() returns externally owned account (no code) 0x019817aD02a31B990433542097bE29D97613E8Cb.",
    "recordId": "tokenworks-control-plane",
    "surface": "NFTStrategyFactory · Non-Proxy Bytecode & Controller"
   },
   "factors": [
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "upgrade",
     "label": "Upgradeability",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "Upgrade path not in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "timelock",
     "label": "Timelock floor",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No enforced admin delay in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": "tokenworks-control-plane: … (non-EIP-1967 contract). Direct owner() returns externally owned account (no code) 0x019817aD02a31B990433542097bE29D97613E8Cb.",
     "key": "quorum",
     "label": "Signer quorum",
     "state": "a",
     "value": "Lowest controlling quorum: a single key"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "emergency",
     "label": "Emergency / freeze scope",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No pause / freeze authority in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "parity",
     "label": "Docs-vs-chain parity",
     "state": "u",
     "value": "Uncompared: documentation not assessed (RPC-observed)"
    }
   ],
   "finding": "NFTStrategyFactory · Non-Proxy Bytecode & Controller",
   "grade": "observed",
   "gradeLabel": "OBSERVED",
   "name": "TokenWorks",
   "pinnedBlock": 26458556,
   "probe": {
    "block_hash": "0xe258bb1cbcc988e2dfdba4ba173f9f8690520dba3647cdcae18e0651822769d2",
    "block_number": 26458556,
    "call_args": [],
    "call_signature": "owner()",
    "chain": "ethereum",
    "check_type": "eth_call",
    "extra_calls": [],
    "id": "tokenworks-control-plane",
    "repro_calldata": "0x8da5cb5b",
    "rpc_env_var": "$ETH_RPC_URL",
    "selector_or_slot": "0x8da5cb5b",
    "target_contract": "0xA1a196b5BE89Be04a2c1dc71643689CE013c22e5",
    "target_label": "NFTStrategyFactory"
   },
   "reconciled": false,
   "reconciledFrom": [],
   "reconciledTo": [],
   "records": 1,
   "rosetteAria": "TokenWorks control-plane rosette: Upgradeability not determined; Timelock floor not determined; Signer quorum weak; Emergency / freeze scope not determined; Docs-vs-chain parity uncompared",
   "search": "tokenworks tokenworks strategy tokens that buy floor nfts with trading fees and burn supply (ethereum) tokenworks 0x019817ad02a31b990433542097be29d97613e8cb 0xa1a196b5be89be04a2c1dc71643689ce013c22e5",
   "slug": "tokenworks",
   "summary_short": "Non-proxy contract controlled by a single key (EOA); docs not assessed",
   "url": "https://pacta.wtf/protocols/tokenworks/"
  },
  {
   "baskets": [
    "stable_rwa"
   ],
   "category": "Delta-Neutral Synthetic Dollar (staked strUSD) (Ethereum)",
   "chains": [
    "ethereum"
   ],
   "deltas": 1,
   "easAttested": true,
   "evidence": {
    "documented": "'It holds the Timelock Admin role on the core contracts' (docs.tori.finance/security/roles.md)",
    "observed": "Tori trUSD 0xd0580192E98eA6CEB9c7b6191Ed2E27560911697 (Ethereum, EIP-1967 proxy, implementation 0xb1d133fE29255EB4Ac9B05d647d49cd7F05ff631): hasRole(TIMELOCK_ADMIN_ROLE 0x5f58e3a2316349923ce3780f8d587db2d72378aed66a8261c916544fa6846ca5, 0xcd3c66e73abF927EAAF1238aEB5F251b4f2f667b) = true and hasRole(TIMELOCK_ADMIN_ROLE, 0xA952453E39F77108Ee37C1b92de593F1C59A6ef4) = false at this pin; the reverse at Pacta's published pin #26,448,221 (record tori-finance-control-plane). 0xA952453E39F77108Ee37C1b92de593F1C59A6ef4 is the timelock the roles page names; 0xcd3c66e73abF927EAAF1238aEB5F251b4f2f667b is a second ToriTimelock (verified source; renounceRole disabled). Both have getMinDelay() = 86,400 s and the 3-of-5 Safe 0x0C6Bbfd2d5666d44bf28580eDEec0263692C8316 holds PROPOSER_ROLE on both: the delay is unchanged, but trUSD upgrades are now queued on a timelock the documentation does not name.",
    "recordId": "tori-trusd-timelock-admin-undocumented-timelock-s32",
    "surface": "trUSD TIMELOCK_ADMIN_ROLE: a second ToriTimelock, not the documented timelock"
   },
   "factors": [
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "upgrade",
     "label": "Upgradeability",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "Upgrade path not in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": "tori-trusd-timelock-admin-undocumented-timelock-s32: observed_delay_seconds = 86400",
     "key": "timelock",
     "label": "Timelock floor",
     "state": "b",
     "value": "1d minimum enforced delay across control surfaces"
    },
    {
     "evidence": "tori-trusd-timelock-admin-undocumented-timelock-s32: … have getMinDelay() = 86,400 s and the 3-of-5 Safe 0x0C6Bbfd2d5666d44bf28580eDEec0263692C8316 …",
     "key": "quorum",
     "label": "Signer quorum",
     "state": "g",
     "value": "Lowest controlling quorum: 3-of-5"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "emergency",
     "label": "Emergency / freeze scope",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No pause / freeze authority in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "parity",
     "label": "Docs-vs-chain parity",
     "state": "a",
     "value": "Documentation differs from the chain (parameter delta)"
    }
   ],
   "finding": "trUSD TIMELOCK_ADMIN_ROLE: a second ToriTimelock, not the documented timelock: docs say 'It holds the Timelock Admin role on the core contracts' (docs.tori.finance/security/roles.md) · chain says Tori trUSD 0xd0580192E98eA6CEB9c7b6191Ed2E27560911697 (Ethereum, EIP-1967 proxy, implementation 0xb1d133fE29255EB4Ac9B05d647d49cd7F05ff631): hasRole(TIMELOCK_ADMIN_ROLE 0x5f58e3a2316349923ce3780f8d587db2d72378aed66a8261…",
   "grade": "delta",
   "gradeLabel": "DELTA",
   "name": "Tori Finance",
   "pinnedBlock": 26451608,
   "probe": {
    "block_hash": "0x0266af5bcad519d93b3be78e41b76a62985e22fbe4feef043ac3225f6f217a17",
    "block_number": 26451608,
    "call_args": [
     "0x5f58e3a2316349923ce3780f8d587db2d72378aed66a8261c916544fa6846ca5",
     "0xcd3c66e73abF927EAAF1238aEB5F251b4f2f667b"
    ],
    "call_signature": "hasRole(bytes32,address)",
    "chain": "ethereum",
    "check_type": "eth_call",
    "extra_calls": [],
    "id": "tori-trusd-timelock-admin-undocumented-timelock-s32",
    "repro_calldata": "0x91d148545f58e3a2316349923ce3780f8d587db2d72378aed66a8261c916544fa6846ca5000000000000000000000000cd3c66e73abf927eaaf1238aeb5f251b4f2f667b",
    "rpc_env_var": "$ETH_RPC_URL",
    "selector_or_slot": "0x91d14854",
    "target_contract": "0xd0580192E98eA6CEB9c7b6191Ed2E27560911697",
    "target_label": "Tori trUSD"
   },
   "reconciled": false,
   "reconciledFrom": [],
   "reconciledTo": [],
   "records": 1,
   "rosetteAria": "Tori Finance control-plane rosette: Upgradeability not determined; Timelock floor moderate; Signer quorum strong; Emergency / freeze scope not determined; Docs-vs-chain parity weak",
   "search": "tori finance tori-finance delta-neutral synthetic dollar (staked strusd) (ethereum) trusd 0x0c6bbfd2d5666d44bf28580edeec0263692c8316 0xa952453e39f77108ee37c1b92de593f1c59a6ef4 0xb1d133fe29255eb4ac9b05d647d49cd7f05ff631 0xcd3c66e73abf927eaaf1238aeb5f251b4f2f667b 0xd0580192e98ea6ceb9c7b6191ed2e27560911697",
   "slug": "tori-finance",
   "summary_short": "trUSD's Timelock Admin is a second ToriTimelock, not the one the roles page names",
   "url": "https://pacta.wtf/protocols/tori-finance/"
  },
  {
   "baskets": [],
   "category": "Privacy Pool Mixer (anonymous transfers) (Ethereum)",
   "chains": [
    "ethereum"
   ],
   "deltas": 0,
   "easAttested": false,
   "evidence": {
    "documented": "Tornado Cash documentation is linked for reference (https://docs.tornadocash.eth.limo/). This RPC-pinned record does not compare documentation parameters with the on-chain state.",
    "observed": "TornadoCash (TORN) (0x77777FeDdddFfC19Ff86DB637967013e6C6A116C) verified on Ethereum Mainnet at canonical block #26,458,556 (8,839 bytes runtime code). EIP-1967 implementation and admin storage slots are both zero (non-EIP-1967 contract). No owner(), admin(), authority(), curator() or AccessControl admin was readable on the contract.",
    "recordId": "tornado-cash-control-plane",
    "surface": "TornadoCash (TORN) · Non-Proxy Bytecode & Controller"
   },
   "factors": [
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "upgrade",
     "label": "Upgradeability",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "Upgrade path not in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "timelock",
     "label": "Timelock floor",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No enforced admin delay in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "quorum",
     "label": "Signer quorum",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No signer quorum in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "emergency",
     "label": "Emergency / freeze scope",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No pause / freeze authority in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "parity",
     "label": "Docs-vs-chain parity",
     "state": "u",
     "value": "Uncompared: documentation not assessed (RPC-observed)"
    }
   ],
   "finding": "TornadoCash (TORN) · Non-Proxy Bytecode & Controller",
   "grade": "observed",
   "gradeLabel": "OBSERVED",
   "name": "Tornado Cash",
   "pinnedBlock": 26458556,
   "probe": {
    "block_hash": "0xe258bb1cbcc988e2dfdba4ba173f9f8690520dba3647cdcae18e0651822769d2",
    "block_number": 26458556,
    "call_args": [],
    "call_signature": "owner()",
    "chain": "ethereum",
    "check_type": "eth_call",
    "extra_calls": [],
    "id": "tornado-cash-control-plane",
    "repro_calldata": "0x8da5cb5b",
    "rpc_env_var": "$ETH_RPC_URL",
    "selector_or_slot": "0x8da5cb5b",
    "target_contract": "0x77777FeDdddFfC19Ff86DB637967013e6C6A116C",
    "target_label": "TornadoCash (TORN)"
   },
   "reconciled": false,
   "reconciledFrom": [],
   "reconciledTo": [],
   "records": 1,
   "rosetteAria": "Tornado Cash control-plane rosette: Upgradeability not determined; Timelock floor not determined; Signer quorum not determined; Emergency / freeze scope not determined; Docs-vs-chain parity uncompared",
   "search": "tornado cash tornado-cash privacy pool mixer (anonymous transfers) (ethereum) torn 0x77777feddddffc19ff86db637967013e6c6a116c",
   "slug": "tornado-cash",
   "summary_short": "Non-proxy contract no readable owner or admin; docs not assessed",
   "url": "https://pacta.wtf/protocols/tornado-cash/"
  },
  {
   "baskets": [
    "eth_lst_lrt"
   ],
   "category": "Fixed Income / LST",
   "chains": [
    "ethereum"
   ],
   "deltas": 1,
   "easAttested": true,
   "evidence": {
    "documented": "'All Treehouse contracts are secured by a 5-day timelock, ensuring no critical action executes immediately and giving everyone a clear window to see and respond to upcoming updates.' (docs.treehouse.finance/protocol/tasset/security/timelock) / 'Token Contract: 0x77146784315Ba81904d654466968e3a7c196d1f3' (docs.treehouse.finance/protocol/tree-token); neither page names a blacklist or freeze role on TREE or the blacklister Safe. Pacta timelock radar brief treehouse-op-0x2f11 decoded the upgrade before it executed.",
    "observed": "TREE 0x77146784315Ba81904d654466968e3a7c196d1f3 (Ethereum): EIP-1967 proxy, implementation 0x0fedcbfEBc293Ad8048726B0F887e6C1126EffA6 since the timelock operation 0x2f11dcc3… executed at #26,439,293; blacklister() = 0x22261B4D6F629D8cF946C3524df86bF7222901F6, a Safe with getThreshold() = 5 of getOwners() = 7 owners and no delay of its own (0 s), so blacklisting needs no timelock; owner() = timelock 0x2225DAbFfC7F862c99477381E971E8B1FDaB467e with getMinDelay() = 432000s (5 days).",
    "recordId": "treehouse-tree-teth-tree-blacklister-safe-s27",
    "surface": "TREE token: a 5-of-7 Safe can blacklist holders with no delay; docs state a 5-day timelock on every contract"
   },
   "factors": [
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "upgrade",
     "label": "Upgradeability",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "Upgrade path not in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": "treehouse-tree-teth-tree-blacklister-safe-s27: observed_delay_seconds = 0",
     "key": "timelock",
     "label": "Timelock floor",
     "state": "a",
     "value": "0s minimum enforced delay across control surfaces"
    },
    {
     "evidence": "treehouse-tree-timelock-op-0x2f11: … Blacklistable module whose blacklister is a 5-of-7 Safe; after execution that Safe can …",
     "key": "quorum",
     "label": "Signer quorum",
     "state": "g",
     "value": "Lowest controlling quorum: 5-of-7"
    },
    {
     "evidence": "treehouse-tree-timelock-op-0x2f11: TREE (0x77146784315Ba81904d654466968e3a7c196d1f3).owner() = TimelockController. Operation 0x2f11dcc36860f09b9ef94585589ced1798cef603d133efecd017ce7e544c451f is …",
     "key": "emergency",
     "label": "Emergency / freeze scope",
     "state": "g",
     "value": "Pause / freeze authority scoped behind a multi-signer controller (5-of-7)"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "parity",
     "label": "Docs-vs-chain parity",
     "state": "a",
     "value": "Documentation differs from the chain (parameter delta)"
    }
   ],
   "finding": "Timelock delay: docs say 5 d · chain says 0 s (no delay)",
   "grade": "delta",
   "gradeLabel": "DELTA",
   "name": "Treehouse (TREE / tETH)",
   "pinnedBlock": 26440048,
   "probe": {
    "block_hash": "0x2c6e70ac6ce978ce5c457208ea6d953e60e92ebf2151578f46cbdd070baa54c6",
    "block_number": 26440048,
    "call_args": [],
    "call_signature": "blacklister()",
    "chain": "ethereum",
    "check_type": "eth_call",
    "extra_calls": [],
    "id": "treehouse-tree-teth-tree-blacklister-safe-s27",
    "repro_calldata": "0xbd102430",
    "rpc_env_var": "$ETH_RPC_URL",
    "selector_or_slot": "0xbd102430",
    "target_contract": "0x77146784315Ba81904d654466968e3a7c196d1f3",
    "target_label": "TreehouseToken (TREE)"
   },
   "reconciled": false,
   "reconciledFrom": [],
   "reconciledTo": [],
   "records": 3,
   "rosetteAria": "Treehouse (TREE / tETH) control-plane rosette: Upgradeability not determined; Timelock floor weak; Signer quorum strong; Emergency / freeze scope strong; Docs-vs-chain parity weak",
   "search": "treehouse (tree / teth) treehouse-tree-teth fixed income / lst teth tree 0x0fedcbfebc293ad8048726b0f887e6c1126effa6 0x2225dabffc7f862c99477381e971e8b1fdab467e 0x22261b4d6f629d8cf946c3524df86bf7222901f6 0x77146784315ba81904d654466968e3a7c196d1f3 0xd11c452fc99cf405034ee446803b6f6c1f6d5ed8",
   "slug": "treehouse-tree-teth",
   "summary_short": "A 5-of-7 Safe can freeze TREE transfers at once; docs promise a 5-day timelock",
   "url": "https://pacta.wtf/protocols/treehouse-tree-teth/"
  },
  {
   "baskets": [
    "base",
    "lending_vaults"
   ],
   "category": "News prediction markets with bounties on verified outcomes (Base)",
   "chains": [
    "base"
   ],
   "deltas": 0,
   "easAttested": true,
   "evidence": {
    "documented": "'Trueo implements a modular, upgradeable architecture with dual-version support for Uniswap V3 and V4 markets, featuring:' (raw.githubusercontent.com/trueo-protocol/trueo-contracts/HEAD/README.md)",
    "observed": "Trueo contract 0x8175b0A1e803aC4205aE35F614315Ba801275baA (Base): EIP-1967 implementation slot = 0xfF21c2c73784d35578f497e2D6975D8a430d7B9a; upgradeable (EIP-1967 implementation exposing upgradeTo/upgradeToAndCall (UUPS)).",
    "recordId": "trueo-upgradeability-8175b0-s31",
    "surface": "Trueo contract: upgradeable (UUPS), as documented"
   },
   "factors": [
    {
     "evidence": "trueo-upgradeability-8175b0-s31: Trueo contract 0x8175b0A1e803aC4205aE35F614315Ba801275baA (Base): EIP-1967 implementation slot = 0xfF21c2c73784d35578f497e2D6975D8a430d7B9a",
     "key": "upgrade",
     "label": "Upgradeability",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "Upgradeable; the delay gating the upgrade path is not in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "timelock",
     "label": "Timelock floor",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No enforced admin delay in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "quorum",
     "label": "Signer quorum",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No signer quorum in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "emergency",
     "label": "Emergency / freeze scope",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No pause / freeze authority in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "parity",
     "label": "Docs-vs-chain parity",
     "state": "g",
     "value": "Chain matches or is stronger than the documentation"
    }
   ],
   "finding": "Trueo contract: upgradeable (UUPS), as documented",
   "grade": "aligned",
   "gradeLabel": "ALIGNED",
   "name": "Trueo",
   "pinnedBlock": 59594105,
   "probe": {
    "block_hash": "0x7646bbc83a9f0d26a48a94274cd6003a3f10bc4747a20d817b8e536618e28496",
    "block_number": 59594105,
    "call_args": [],
    "call_signature": null,
    "chain": "base",
    "check_type": "eth_getStorageAt",
    "extra_calls": [],
    "id": "trueo-upgradeability-8175b0-s31",
    "repro_calldata": null,
    "rpc_env_var": "$BASE_RPC_URL",
    "selector_or_slot": "0x360894a13ba1a3210667c828492db98dca3e2076cc3735a920a3ca505d382bbc",
    "target_contract": "0x8175b0A1e803aC4205aE35F614315Ba801275baA",
    "target_label": "Trueo contract"
   },
   "reconciled": false,
   "reconciledFrom": [],
   "reconciledTo": [],
   "records": 1,
   "rosetteAria": "Trueo control-plane rosette: Upgradeability not determined; Timelock floor not determined; Signer quorum not determined; Emergency / freeze scope not determined; Docs-vs-chain parity strong",
   "search": "trueo trueo news prediction markets with bounties on verified outcomes (base) true 0x8175b0a1e803ac4205ae35f614315ba801275baa 0xff21c2c73784d35578f497e2d6975d8a430d7b9a",
   "slug": "trueo",
   "summary_short": "The Trueo contract is upgradeable (UUPS), as its docs state",
   "url": "https://pacta.wtf/protocols/trueo/"
  },
  {
   "baskets": [
    "lending_vaults",
    "stable_rwa"
   ],
   "category": "Curated stablecoin strategy vaults and vault infrastructure (Ethereum)",
   "chains": [
    "ethereum"
   ],
   "deltas": 0,
   "easAttested": false,
   "evidence": {
    "documented": "UltraYield Vaults documentation is linked for reference (https://docs.ultrayield.app/). This RPC-pinned record does not compare documentation parameters with the on-chain state.",
    "observed": "Stable Gain Vault (UUPSProxy) (0x8ECC0B419dfe3AE197BC96f2a03636b5E1BE91db) verified on Ethereum Mainnet at canonical block #26,458,556 (122 bytes runtime code). EIP-1967 proxy: implementation 0xE66f6a37C807F71591854e22075b3A613B46abe2, admin slot zero. No owner(), admin(), authority(), curator() or AccessControl admin was readable on the contract.",
    "recordId": "ultrayield-vaults-control-plane",
    "surface": "Stable Gain Vault (UUPSProxy) · EIP-1967 Proxy & Controller Chain"
   },
   "factors": [
    {
     "evidence": "ultrayield-vaults-control-plane: Stable Gain Vault (UUPSProxy) (0x8ECC0B419dfe3AE197BC96f2a03636b5E1BE91db) verified on Ethereum Mainnet at canonical block #26,458,556 (122 bytes runtime code). …",
     "key": "upgrade",
     "label": "Upgradeability",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "Upgradeable; the delay gating the upgrade path is not in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "timelock",
     "label": "Timelock floor",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No enforced admin delay in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "quorum",
     "label": "Signer quorum",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No signer quorum in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "emergency",
     "label": "Emergency / freeze scope",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No pause / freeze authority in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "parity",
     "label": "Docs-vs-chain parity",
     "state": "u",
     "value": "Uncompared: documentation not assessed (RPC-observed)"
    }
   ],
   "finding": "Stable Gain Vault (UUPSProxy) · EIP-1967 Proxy & Controller Chain",
   "grade": "observed",
   "gradeLabel": "OBSERVED",
   "name": "UltraYield Vaults",
   "pinnedBlock": 26458556,
   "probe": {
    "block_hash": "0xe258bb1cbcc988e2dfdba4ba173f9f8690520dba3647cdcae18e0651822769d2",
    "block_number": 26458556,
    "call_args": [],
    "call_signature": "owner()",
    "chain": "ethereum",
    "check_type": "eth_call",
    "extra_calls": [],
    "id": "ultrayield-vaults-control-plane",
    "repro_calldata": "0x8da5cb5b",
    "rpc_env_var": "$ETH_RPC_URL",
    "selector_or_slot": "0x8da5cb5b",
    "target_contract": "0x8ECC0B419dfe3AE197BC96f2a03636b5E1BE91db",
    "target_label": "Stable Gain Vault (UUPSProxy)"
   },
   "reconciled": false,
   "reconciledFrom": [],
   "reconciledTo": [],
   "records": 1,
   "rosetteAria": "UltraYield Vaults control-plane rosette: Upgradeability not determined; Timelock floor not determined; Signer quorum not determined; Emergency / freeze scope not determined; Docs-vs-chain parity uncompared",
   "search": "ultrayield vaults ultrayield-vaults curated stablecoin strategy vaults and vault infrastructure (ethereum) sbusd 0x8ecc0b419dfe3ae197bc96f2a03636b5e1be91db 0xe66f6a37c807f71591854e22075b3a613b46abe2",
   "slug": "ultrayield-vaults",
   "summary_short": "Upgradeable proxy no readable owner or admin; docs not assessed",
   "url": "https://pacta.wtf/protocols/ultrayield-vaults/"
  },
  {
   "baskets": [
    "base"
   ],
   "category": "Onchain venture funding and governance platform for token launches (Base)",
   "chains": [
    "base"
   ],
   "deltas": 0,
   "easAttested": true,
   "evidence": {
    "documented": "'The protocol owner is a timelock with a two-day public delay.' (umia.finance/llms-full.txt)",
    "observed": "Umia timelock 0xD0193fFAF565B6E530C1a6bbBb2FB13243f29177 (Base): getMinDelay() = 172800s (2 d).",
    "recordId": "umia-timelock-delay-s27",
    "surface": "Umia timelock: 2-day minimum delay, as documented"
   },
   "factors": [
    {
     "evidence": "umia-upgradeability-s27: UmiaMarketCore proxy 0x55975E430Cc54C63dff03B1E6d27Be574Ce229F6 (Base): EIP-1967 implementation slot = 0xBc35cB6cCc4BE46AA491960EBf5281cD5310c653",
     "key": "upgrade",
     "label": "Upgradeability",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "Upgradeable; the delay gating the upgrade path is not in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": "controller fact: getMinDelay() = 172800s",
     "key": "timelock",
     "label": "Timelock floor",
     "state": "g",
     "value": "2d minimum enforced delay across control surfaces"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "quorum",
     "label": "Signer quorum",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No signer quorum in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "emergency",
     "label": "Emergency / freeze scope",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No pause / freeze authority in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "parity",
     "label": "Docs-vs-chain parity",
     "state": "g",
     "value": "Chain matches or is stronger than the documentation"
    }
   ],
   "finding": "Umia timelock: 2-day minimum delay, as documented",
   "grade": "aligned",
   "gradeLabel": "ALIGNED",
   "name": "Umia",
   "pinnedBlock": 58956515,
   "probe": {
    "block_hash": "0x82af637fd7a689f4ea41c0ecd1a84a407ea93f2622b8e9c06184327d957129d0",
    "block_number": 58956515,
    "call_args": [],
    "call_signature": "getMinDelay()",
    "chain": "base",
    "check_type": "eth_call",
    "extra_calls": [],
    "id": "umia-timelock-delay-s27",
    "repro_calldata": "0xf27a0c92",
    "rpc_env_var": "$BASE_RPC_URL",
    "selector_or_slot": "0xf27a0c92",
    "target_contract": "0xD0193fFAF565B6E530C1a6bbBb2FB13243f29177",
    "target_label": "Umia timelock"
   },
   "reconciled": false,
   "reconciledFrom": [],
   "reconciledTo": [],
   "records": 2,
   "rosetteAria": "Umia control-plane rosette: Upgradeability not determined; Timelock floor strong; Signer quorum not determined; Emergency / freeze scope not determined; Docs-vs-chain parity strong",
   "search": "umia umia onchain venture funding and governance platform for token launches (base) umia 0x55975e430cc54c63dff03b1e6d27be574ce229f6 0xbc35cb6ccc4be46aa491960ebf5281cd5310c653 0xd0193ffaf565b6e530c1a6bbbb2fb13243f29177",
   "slug": "umia",
   "summary_short": "Umia changes wait a 2-day timelock, as documented",
   "url": "https://pacta.wtf/protocols/umia/"
  },
  {
   "baskets": [],
   "category": "Liquidity and team-token locker with token launch and vesting services (Ethereum)",
   "chains": [
    "ethereum"
   ],
   "deltas": 0,
   "easAttested": false,
   "evidence": {
    "documented": "UNCX Network V2 documentation is linked for reference (https://uncx.network/). This RPC-pinned record does not compare documentation parameters with the on-chain state.",
    "observed": "UniCrypt (UNCX) (0xaDB2437e6F65682B85F814fBc12FeC0508A7B1D0) verified on Ethereum Mainnet at canonical block #26,458,556 (11,974 bytes runtime code). EIP-1967 implementation and admin storage slots are both zero (non-EIP-1967 contract). Direct owner() returns externally owned account (no code) 0x60e2E1b2a317EdfC870b6Fc6886F69083FB2099a.",
    "recordId": "uncx-network-v2-control-plane",
    "surface": "UniCrypt (UNCX) · Non-Proxy Bytecode & Controller"
   },
   "factors": [
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "upgrade",
     "label": "Upgradeability",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "Upgrade path not in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "timelock",
     "label": "Timelock floor",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No enforced admin delay in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": "uncx-network-v2-control-plane: … (non-EIP-1967 contract). Direct owner() returns externally owned account (no code) 0x60e2E1b2a317EdfC870b6Fc6886F69083FB2099a.",
     "key": "quorum",
     "label": "Signer quorum",
     "state": "a",
     "value": "Lowest controlling quorum: a single key"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "emergency",
     "label": "Emergency / freeze scope",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No pause / freeze authority in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "parity",
     "label": "Docs-vs-chain parity",
     "state": "u",
     "value": "Uncompared: documentation not assessed (RPC-observed)"
    }
   ],
   "finding": "UniCrypt (UNCX) · Non-Proxy Bytecode & Controller",
   "grade": "observed",
   "gradeLabel": "OBSERVED",
   "name": "UNCX Network V2",
   "pinnedBlock": 26458556,
   "probe": {
    "block_hash": "0xe258bb1cbcc988e2dfdba4ba173f9f8690520dba3647cdcae18e0651822769d2",
    "block_number": 26458556,
    "call_args": [],
    "call_signature": "owner()",
    "chain": "ethereum",
    "check_type": "eth_call",
    "extra_calls": [],
    "id": "uncx-network-v2-control-plane",
    "repro_calldata": "0x8da5cb5b",
    "rpc_env_var": "$ETH_RPC_URL",
    "selector_or_slot": "0x8da5cb5b",
    "target_contract": "0xaDB2437e6F65682B85F814fBc12FeC0508A7B1D0",
    "target_label": "UniCrypt (UNCX)"
   },
   "reconciled": false,
   "reconciledFrom": [],
   "reconciledTo": [],
   "records": 1,
   "rosetteAria": "UNCX Network V2 control-plane rosette: Upgradeability not determined; Timelock floor not determined; Signer quorum weak; Emergency / freeze scope not determined; Docs-vs-chain parity uncompared",
   "search": "uncx network v2 uncx-network-v2 liquidity and team-token locker with token launch and vesting services (ethereum) uncx 0x60e2e1b2a317edfc870b6fc6886f69083fb2099a 0xadb2437e6f65682b85f814fbc12fec0508a7b1d0",
   "slug": "uncx-network-v2",
   "summary_short": "Non-proxy contract controlled by a single key (EOA); docs not assessed",
   "url": "https://pacta.wtf/protocols/uncx-network-v2/"
  },
  {
   "baskets": [],
   "category": "Blue-Chip DEX & Governance",
   "chains": [
    "ethereum"
   ],
   "deltas": 1,
   "easAttested": true,
   "evidence": {
    "documented": "developers.uniswap.org (governance process): '7-day voting period for the community to vote' / 'Duration: 2-day waiting period, 7-day voting period, 2-day timelock (if passed)'",
    "observed": "GovernorBravoDelegator 0x408ED6354d4973f66138C91495F2f2FCbd8724C3: votingPeriod() = 40320 blocks = 483,840s (5.6 days) at 12-second slots; votingDelay() = 13140 blocks (~1.83 days).",
    "recordId": "uniswap-governance-voting-period-40320-blocks-s23",
    "surface": "Voting period: 40,320 blocks (~5.6 days at 12-second slots), not 7 days"
   },
   "factors": [
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "upgrade",
     "label": "Upgradeability",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "Upgrade path not in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": "uniswap-governance-timelock-delay-2d-s23: observed_delay_seconds = 172800",
     "key": "timelock",
     "label": "Timelock floor",
     "state": "g",
     "value": "2d minimum enforced delay across control surfaces"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "quorum",
     "label": "Signer quorum",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No signer quorum in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "emergency",
     "label": "Emergency / freeze scope",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No pause / freeze authority in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "parity",
     "label": "Docs-vs-chain parity",
     "state": "a",
     "value": "Documentation differs from the chain (parameter delta)"
    }
   ],
   "finding": "Voting period: 40,320 blocks (~5.6 days at 12-second slots), not 7 days: docs say developers.uniswap.org (governance process): '7-day voting period for the community to vote' / 'Duration: 2-day waiting period, 7-day voting period, 2-day timelock (if passed)' · chain says GovernorBravoDelegator 0x408ED6354d4973f66138C91495F2f2FCbd8724C3: votingPeriod() = 40320 blocks = 483,840s (5.6 days) at 12-second slots;",
   "grade": "delta",
   "gradeLabel": "DELTA",
   "name": "Uniswap V3 & Governance Timelock",
   "pinnedBlock": 26431152,
   "probe": {
    "block_hash": "0xfe2ed4e127f30bb42dd30c6fc1460a82d8438cff3a717ec89210805e55199a46",
    "block_number": 26431152,
    "call_args": [],
    "call_signature": "votingPeriod()",
    "chain": "ethereum",
    "check_type": "eth_call",
    "extra_calls": [],
    "id": "uniswap-governance-voting-period-40320-blocks-s23",
    "repro_calldata": "0x02a251a3",
    "rpc_env_var": "$ETH_RPC_URL",
    "selector_or_slot": "0x02a251a3",
    "target_contract": "0x408ED6354d4973f66138C91495F2f2FCbd8724C3",
    "target_label": "Uniswap GovernorBravoDelegator"
   },
   "reconciled": false,
   "reconciledFrom": [],
   "reconciledTo": [],
   "records": 4,
   "rosetteAria": "Uniswap V3 & Governance Timelock control-plane rosette: Upgradeability not determined; Timelock floor strong; Signer quorum not determined; Emergency / freeze scope not determined; Docs-vs-chain parity weak",
   "search": "uniswap v3 & governance timelock uniswap-governance-timelock blue-chip dex & governance uni 0x1a9c8182c09f50c8318d769245bea52c32be35bc 0x1f98431c8ad98523631ae4a59f267346ea31f984 0x408ed6354d4973f66138c91495f2f2fcbd8724c3 0xf2371551fe3937db7c750f4dfabe5c2fffdcbf5a",
   "slug": "uniswap-governance-timelock",
   "summary_short": "Voting period: docs 7 days · chain 5.6 days",
   "url": "https://pacta.wtf/protocols/uniswap-governance-timelock/"
  },
  {
   "baskets": [
    "base"
   ],
   "category": "Blue-Chip DEX (Singleton PoolManager & Protocol Fees)",
   "chains": [
    "base",
    "ethereum"
   ],
   "deltas": 0,
   "easAttested": true,
   "evidence": {
    "documented": "developers.uniswap.org (v4 deployments, governance reference): 'Ethereum: 1 Contract Address PoolManager 0x000000000004444c5dc75cB358380D2e3dE08A90' / 'The contracts below are actively deployed on Ethereum mainnet.' / 'Timelock 0x1a9C8182C09F50C8318d769245beA52c32BE35BC' / 'Uniswap Governance has specific controls under its domain, including: Spend funds from the treasury Set and activate the protocol fee'",
    "observed": "PoolManager 0x000000000004444c5dc75cB358380D2e3dE08A90 (Sourcify match): owner() = Timelock 0x1a9C8182C09F50C8318d769245beA52c32BE35BC: delay() = 172800s (2 days) = MINIMUM_DELAY(), admin() = GovernorBravoDelegator 0x408ED6354d4973f66138C91495F2f2FCbd8724C3.",
    "recordId": "uniswap-v4-poolmanager-owner-timelock-s24",
    "surface": "Owner: the 2-day governance Timelock run by GovernorBravo"
   },
   "factors": [
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "upgrade",
     "label": "Upgradeability",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "Upgrade path not in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": "uniswap-v4-poolmanager-owner-timelock-s24: observed_delay_seconds = 172800",
     "key": "timelock",
     "label": "Timelock floor",
     "state": "g",
     "value": "2d minimum enforced delay across control surfaces"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "quorum",
     "label": "Signer quorum",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No signer quorum in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "emergency",
     "label": "Emergency / freeze scope",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No pause / freeze authority in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "parity",
     "label": "Docs-vs-chain parity",
     "state": "g",
     "value": "Chain matches or is stronger than the documentation"
    }
   ],
   "finding": "Owner: the 2-day governance Timelock run by GovernorBravo",
   "grade": "aligned",
   "gradeLabel": "ALIGNED",
   "name": "Uniswap V4",
   "pinnedBlock": 58534152,
   "probe": {
    "block_hash": "0xa058ec92ccf0024822a76097f183d8e2d344d56e9539038c857e0cdaaa0ee5a7",
    "block_number": 26433001,
    "call_args": [],
    "call_signature": "owner()",
    "chain": "ethereum",
    "check_type": "eth_call",
    "extra_calls": [],
    "id": "uniswap-v4-poolmanager-owner-timelock-s24",
    "repro_calldata": "0x8da5cb5b",
    "rpc_env_var": "$ETH_RPC_URL",
    "selector_or_slot": "0x8da5cb5b",
    "target_contract": "0x000000000004444c5dc75cB358380D2e3dE08A90",
    "target_label": "Uniswap V4 PoolManager (Ethereum)"
   },
   "reconciled": false,
   "reconciledFrom": [],
   "reconciledTo": [],
   "records": 4,
   "rosetteAria": "Uniswap V4 control-plane rosette: Upgradeability not determined; Timelock floor strong; Signer quorum not determined; Emergency / freeze scope not determined; Docs-vs-chain parity strong",
   "search": "uniswap v4 uniswap-v4 blue-chip dex (singleton poolmanager & protocol fees) uni uniswap v4 poolmanager 0x000000000004444c5dc75cb358380d2e3de08a90 0x076f84717f3601b8cd177bb84b217a2679b38b7d 0x1a9c8182c09f50c8318d769245bea52c32be35bc 0x1cd822b70a0591420f65e94b9b3a0d0b0fb3a314 0x31fafd4889fa1269f7a13a66ee0fb458f27d72a9 0x408ed6354d4973f66138c91495f2f2fcbd8724c3 0x498581ff718922c3f8e6a244956af099b2652b2b 0x89a5d5bf00a27d55c02951e49078a5c5771051db 0x9bd25e67bf390437c8faf480ac735a27bcf6168c 0xabea76658b205696d49b5f91b2a03536cb8a3be1 0xc53dd825dedbe7814562528a1a30e8e5bcbb4b55 0xf38521f130fccf29db1961597bc5d2b60f995f85 0xff77c0ed0b6b13a20446969107e5867abc46f53a",
   "slug": "uniswap-v4",
   "summary_short": "Owner is the 2-day governance Timelock run by GovernorBravo, as documented",
   "url": "https://pacta.wtf/protocols/uniswap-v4/"
  },
  {
   "baskets": [
    "lending_vaults",
    "stable_rwa"
   ],
   "category": "Multi-chain money market for lending and borrowing (Ethereum)",
   "chains": [
    "ethereum"
   ],
   "deltas": 0,
   "easAttested": false,
   "evidence": {
    "documented": "Unitus documentation is linked for reference (https://unitus.finance/docs). This RPC-pinned record does not compare documentation parameters with the on-chain state.",
    "observed": "Unitus (UnitusCompOFT) (0x3B6564b5DA73A41d3A66e6558a98FD0e9E1e77ad) verified on Ethereum Mainnet at canonical block #26,458,556 (2,227 bytes runtime code). EIP-1967 proxy: implementation 0xC42aEce42Fb38437aFBBdFa0773e6C2C756e03E9, admin 0x22C34BdBE18A8bc8Edf7A6C69a03a5B2F2ed45F4. The EIP-1967 admin slot holds contract ProxyAdmin2Step 0x22C34BdBE18A8bc8Edf7A6C69a03a5B2F2ed45F4. That controller is in turn controlled by Safe 3-of-5 0xd6F77422cF2825Cfa241CeaDD85d905D38255e58.",
    "recordId": "unitus-control-plane",
    "surface": "Unitus (UnitusCompOFT) · EIP-1967 Proxy & Controller Chain"
   },
   "factors": [
    {
     "evidence": "unitus-control-plane: Unitus (UnitusCompOFT) (0x3B6564b5DA73A41d3A66e6558a98FD0e9E1e77ad) verified on Ethereum Mainnet at canonical block #26,458,556 (2,227 bytes runtime code). …",
     "key": "upgrade",
     "label": "Upgradeability",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "Upgradeable; the delay gating the upgrade path is not in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "timelock",
     "label": "Timelock floor",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No enforced admin delay in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": "unitus-control-plane: … controller is in turn controlled by Safe 3-of-5 0xd6F77422cF2825Cfa241CeaDD85d905D38255e58.",
     "key": "quorum",
     "label": "Signer quorum",
     "state": "g",
     "value": "Lowest controlling quorum: 3-of-5"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "emergency",
     "label": "Emergency / freeze scope",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No pause / freeze authority in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "parity",
     "label": "Docs-vs-chain parity",
     "state": "u",
     "value": "Uncompared: documentation not assessed (RPC-observed)"
    }
   ],
   "finding": "Unitus (UnitusCompOFT) · EIP-1967 Proxy & Controller Chain",
   "grade": "observed",
   "gradeLabel": "OBSERVED",
   "name": "Unitus",
   "pinnedBlock": 26458556,
   "probe": {
    "block_hash": "0xe258bb1cbcc988e2dfdba4ba173f9f8690520dba3647cdcae18e0651822769d2",
    "block_number": 26458556,
    "call_args": [],
    "call_signature": null,
    "chain": "ethereum",
    "check_type": "eth_getStorageAt",
    "extra_calls": [],
    "id": "unitus-control-plane",
    "repro_calldata": null,
    "rpc_env_var": "$ETH_RPC_URL",
    "selector_or_slot": "0xb53127684a568b3173ae13b9f8a6016e243e63b6e8ee1178d6a717850b5d6103",
    "target_contract": "0x3B6564b5DA73A41d3A66e6558a98FD0e9E1e77ad",
    "target_label": "Unitus (UnitusCompOFT)"
   },
   "reconciled": false,
   "reconciledFrom": [],
   "reconciledTo": [],
   "records": 1,
   "rosetteAria": "Unitus control-plane rosette: Upgradeability not determined; Timelock floor not determined; Signer quorum strong; Emergency / freeze scope not determined; Docs-vs-chain parity uncompared",
   "search": "unitus unitus multi-chain money market for lending and borrowing (ethereum) uts 0x22c34bdbe18a8bc8edf7a6c69a03a5b2f2ed45f4 0x3b6564b5da73a41d3a66e6558a98fd0e9e1e77ad 0xc42aece42fb38437afbbdfa0773e6c2c756e03e9 0xd6f77422cf2825cfa241ceadd85d905d38255e58",
   "slug": "unitus",
   "summary_short": "Upgradeable proxy controlled by a 3-of-5 Safe; docs not assessed",
   "url": "https://pacta.wtf/protocols/unitus/"
  },
  {
   "baskets": [],
   "category": "Decentralized insurance capital pools for DeFi risks (Ethereum)",
   "chains": [
    "ethereum"
   ],
   "deltas": 0,
   "easAttested": false,
   "evidence": {
    "documented": "Unslashed documentation is linked for reference (). This RPC-pinned record does not compare documentation parameters with the on-chain state.",
    "observed": "Unslashed Finance Governance Token (USF) (0xE0e05c43c097B0982Db6c9d626c4eb9e95C3b9ce) verified on Ethereum Mainnet at canonical block #26,458,556 (11,619 bytes runtime code). EIP-1967 implementation and admin storage slots are both zero (non-EIP-1967 contract). No owner(), admin(), authority(), curator() or AccessControl admin was readable on the contract.",
    "recordId": "unslashed-control-plane",
    "surface": "Unslashed Finance Governance Token (USF) · Non-Proxy Bytecode & Controller"
   },
   "factors": [
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "upgrade",
     "label": "Upgradeability",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "Upgrade path not in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "timelock",
     "label": "Timelock floor",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No enforced admin delay in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "quorum",
     "label": "Signer quorum",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No signer quorum in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "emergency",
     "label": "Emergency / freeze scope",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No pause / freeze authority in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "parity",
     "label": "Docs-vs-chain parity",
     "state": "u",
     "value": "Uncompared: documentation not assessed (RPC-observed)"
    }
   ],
   "finding": "Unslashed Finance Governance Token (USF) · Non-Proxy Bytecode & Controller",
   "grade": "observed",
   "gradeLabel": "OBSERVED",
   "name": "Unslashed",
   "pinnedBlock": 26458556,
   "probe": {
    "block_hash": "0xe258bb1cbcc988e2dfdba4ba173f9f8690520dba3647cdcae18e0651822769d2",
    "block_number": 26458556,
    "call_args": [],
    "call_signature": "owner()",
    "chain": "ethereum",
    "check_type": "eth_call",
    "extra_calls": [],
    "id": "unslashed-control-plane",
    "repro_calldata": "0x8da5cb5b",
    "rpc_env_var": "$ETH_RPC_URL",
    "selector_or_slot": "0x8da5cb5b",
    "target_contract": "0xE0e05c43c097B0982Db6c9d626c4eb9e95C3b9ce",
    "target_label": "Unslashed Finance Governance Token (USF)"
   },
   "reconciled": false,
   "reconciledFrom": [],
   "reconciledTo": [],
   "records": 1,
   "rosetteAria": "Unslashed control-plane rosette: Upgradeability not determined; Timelock floor not determined; Signer quorum not determined; Emergency / freeze scope not determined; Docs-vs-chain parity uncompared",
   "search": "unslashed unslashed decentralized insurance capital pools for defi risks (ethereum) usf 0xe0e05c43c097b0982db6c9d626c4eb9e95c3b9ce",
   "slug": "unslashed",
   "summary_short": "Non-proxy contract no readable owner or admin; docs not assessed",
   "url": "https://pacta.wtf/protocols/unslashed/"
  },
  {
   "baskets": [
    "lending_vaults"
   ],
   "category": "Institutional curated vaults run through a Safe owner and a ProxyAdmin multisig",
   "chains": [
    "ethereum"
   ],
   "deltas": 1,
   "easAttested": true,
   "evidence": {
    "documented": "'Upgrades to the vault's code are approved by the ProxyAdmin multisig. It is generally a 4 of 6 Gnosis Safe with two signers each from the asset issuer, Upshift and the curator, so no single party can upgrade a vault alone.' (docs.upshift.finance/vault-architecture/risk-controls)",
    "observed": "Upshift vault 0xE9B725010A9E419412ed67d0fA5f3A5f40159D32 (Ethereum): EIP-1967 admin slot = ProxyAdmin 0xB5fBf201A35327Ddd89986FfA60CF5A675B2bDbc, whose owner() = Safe 0x4107557d726933f0BcA591A4218Afc92978457F7 with getThreshold() = 2 of getOwners() = 3 owners; the vault's owner() is a separate Safe 0x17ab7568Cd5386DF6C8E4552438E32794D057cC1 (2-of-3).",
    "recordId": "upshift-proxyadmin-safe-s28",
    "surface": "Vault ProxyAdmin multisig: docs state generally 4 of 6, the Safe is 2-of-3"
   },
   "factors": [
    {
     "evidence": "upshift-proxyadmin-safe-s28: Upshift vault 0xE9B725010A9E419412ed67d0fA5f3A5f40159D32 (Ethereum): EIP-1967 admin slot = ProxyAdmin 0xB5fBf201A35327Ddd89986FfA60CF5A675B2bDbc, whose owner() …",
     "key": "upgrade",
     "label": "Upgradeability",
     "state": "a",
     "value": "Upgradeable with no enforced delay: upgraded by a Safe directly (a Safe has no delay of its own)"
    },
    {
     "evidence": "upshift-proxyadmin-safe-s28: Upshift vault 0xE9B725010A9E419412ed67d0fA5f3A5f40159D32 (Ethereum): EIP-1967 admin slot = ProxyAdmin 0xB5fBf201A35327Ddd89986FfA60CF5A675B2bDbc, whose owner() …",
     "key": "timelock",
     "label": "Timelock floor",
     "state": "a",
     "value": "0s minimum enforced delay across control surfaces"
    },
    {
     "evidence": "upshift-proxyadmin-safe-s28: … 0x17ab7568Cd5386DF6C8E4552438E32794D057cC1 (2-of-3).",
     "key": "quorum",
     "label": "Signer quorum",
     "state": "b",
     "value": "Lowest controlling quorum: 2-of-3"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "emergency",
     "label": "Emergency / freeze scope",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No pause / freeze authority in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "parity",
     "label": "Docs-vs-chain parity",
     "state": "a",
     "value": "Documentation differs from the chain (parameter delta)"
    }
   ],
   "finding": "Vault ProxyAdmin multisig: docs state generally 4 of 6, the Safe is 2-of-3: docs say 'Upgrades to the vault's code are approved by the ProxyAdmin multisig. · chain says Upshift vault 0xE9B725010A9E419412ed67d0fA5f3A5f40159D32 (Ethereum): EIP-1967 admin slot = ProxyAdmin 0xB5fBf201A35327Ddd89986FfA60CF5A675B2bDbc, whose owner() = Safe 0x4107557d726933f0BcA591A4218Afc92978457F7 with getT…",
   "grade": "delta",
   "gradeLabel": "DELTA",
   "name": "Upshift",
   "pinnedBlock": 26441165,
   "probe": {
    "block_hash": "0x5182be2c61af5f48ed2ec43d3c177dedad257c4e966a7e384120829de73901d9",
    "block_number": 26441165,
    "call_args": [],
    "call_signature": "getThreshold()",
    "chain": "ethereum",
    "check_type": "eth_call",
    "extra_calls": [],
    "id": "upshift-proxyadmin-safe-s28",
    "repro_calldata": "0xe75235b8",
    "rpc_env_var": "$ETH_RPC_URL",
    "selector_or_slot": "0xe75235b8",
    "target_contract": "0x4107557d726933f0BcA591A4218Afc92978457F7",
    "target_label": "Upshift vault ProxyAdmin owner Safe"
   },
   "reconciled": false,
   "reconciledFrom": [],
   "reconciledTo": [],
   "records": 1,
   "rosetteAria": "Upshift control-plane rosette: Upgradeability weak; Timelock floor weak; Signer quorum moderate; Emergency / freeze scope not determined; Docs-vs-chain parity weak",
   "search": "upshift upshift institutional curated vaults run through a safe owner and a proxyadmin multisig upshift 0x17ab7568cd5386df6c8e4552438e32794d057cc1 0x4107557d726933f0bca591a4218afc92978457f7 0xb5fbf201a35327ddd89986ffa60cf5a675b2bdbc 0xe9b725010a9e419412ed67d0fa5f3a5f40159d32",
   "slug": "upshift",
   "summary_short": "Docs state a 4-of-6 ProxyAdmin multisig; the vault's is 2-of-3",
   "url": "https://pacta.wtf/protocols/upshift/"
  },
  {
   "baskets": [
    "stable_rwa"
   ],
   "category": "Omnichain Stablecoin Bridge (Tether OFT adapter) (Ethereum)",
   "chains": [
    "ethereum"
   ],
   "deltas": 0,
   "easAttested": false,
   "evidence": {
    "documented": "USDT0 documentation is linked for reference (https://docs.usdt0.to/). This RPC-pinned record does not compare documentation parameters with the on-chain state.",
    "observed": "OAdapterUpgradeable (0x6C96dE32CEa08842dcc4058c14d3aaAD7Fa41dee) verified on Ethereum Mainnet at canonical block #26,458,556 (2,739 bytes runtime code). EIP-1967 proxy: implementation 0xCD979B10A55FCdAC23ec785CE3066c6ef8a479A4, admin 0x4de7096B2131E84Fd6b2042AD8cd9B4E43F728Fc. The EIP-1967 admin slot holds contract ProxyAdmin 0x4de7096B2131E84Fd6b2042AD8cd9B4E43F728Fc. That controller is in turn controlled by Safe 3-of-5 0x4DFF9b5b0143E642a3F63a5bcf2d1C328e600bf8.",
    "recordId": "usdt0-control-plane",
    "surface": "OAdapterUpgradeable · EIP-1967 Proxy & Controller Chain"
   },
   "factors": [
    {
     "evidence": "usdt0-control-plane: OAdapterUpgradeable (0x6C96dE32CEa08842dcc4058c14d3aaAD7Fa41dee) verified on Ethereum Mainnet at canonical block #26,458,556 (2,739 bytes runtime code). …",
     "key": "upgrade",
     "label": "Upgradeability",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "Upgradeable; the delay gating the upgrade path is not in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "timelock",
     "label": "Timelock floor",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No enforced admin delay in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": "usdt0-control-plane: … controller is in turn controlled by Safe 3-of-5 0x4DFF9b5b0143E642a3F63a5bcf2d1C328e600bf8.",
     "key": "quorum",
     "label": "Signer quorum",
     "state": "g",
     "value": "Lowest controlling quorum: 3-of-5"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "emergency",
     "label": "Emergency / freeze scope",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No pause / freeze authority in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "parity",
     "label": "Docs-vs-chain parity",
     "state": "u",
     "value": "Uncompared: documentation not assessed (RPC-observed)"
    }
   ],
   "finding": "OAdapterUpgradeable · EIP-1967 Proxy & Controller Chain",
   "grade": "observed",
   "gradeLabel": "OBSERVED",
   "name": "USDT0",
   "pinnedBlock": 26458556,
   "probe": {
    "block_hash": "0xe258bb1cbcc988e2dfdba4ba173f9f8690520dba3647cdcae18e0651822769d2",
    "block_number": 26458556,
    "call_args": [],
    "call_signature": null,
    "chain": "ethereum",
    "check_type": "eth_getStorageAt",
    "extra_calls": [],
    "id": "usdt0-control-plane",
    "repro_calldata": null,
    "rpc_env_var": "$ETH_RPC_URL",
    "selector_or_slot": "0xb53127684a568b3173ae13b9f8a6016e243e63b6e8ee1178d6a717850b5d6103",
    "target_contract": "0x6C96dE32CEa08842dcc4058c14d3aaAD7Fa41dee",
    "target_label": "OAdapterUpgradeable"
   },
   "reconciled": false,
   "reconciledFrom": [],
   "reconciledTo": [],
   "records": 1,
   "rosetteAria": "USDT0 control-plane rosette: Upgradeability not determined; Timelock floor not determined; Signer quorum strong; Emergency / freeze scope not determined; Docs-vs-chain parity uncompared",
   "search": "usdt0 usdt0 omnichain stablecoin bridge (tether oft adapter) (ethereum) usdt0 0x4de7096b2131e84fd6b2042ad8cd9b4e43f728fc 0x4dff9b5b0143e642a3f63a5bcf2d1c328e600bf8 0x6c96de32cea08842dcc4058c14d3aaad7fa41dee 0xcd979b10a55fcdac23ec785ce3066c6ef8a479a4",
   "slug": "usdt0",
   "summary_short": "Upgradeable proxy controlled by a 3-of-5 Safe; docs not assessed",
   "url": "https://pacta.wtf/protocols/usdt0/"
  },
  {
   "baskets": [
    "stable_rwa"
   ],
   "category": "RWA Stablecoin",
   "chains": [
    "ethereum"
   ],
   "deltas": 1,
   "easAttested": true,
   "evidence": {
    "documented": "tech.usual.money/overview/architecture/role-management states a delay of three days (259200s) before granting default admin to a new address.",
    "observed": "defaultAdminDelay() = 1s (0x01); pendingDefaultAdminDelay() = (0, 0); defaultAdmin() = 0x6e9d65eC80D69b1f508560Bc7aeA5003db1f7FB7 (8-of-15 Gnosis Safe).",
    "recordId": "usual-money-registry-access-delay",
    "surface": "OpenZeppelin AccessControlDefaultAdminRules Delay"
   },
   "factors": [
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "upgrade",
     "label": "Upgradeability",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "Upgrade path not in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": "usual-money-registry-access-delay: observed_delay_seconds = 1",
     "key": "timelock",
     "label": "Timelock floor",
     "state": "a",
     "value": "1s minimum enforced delay across control surfaces"
    },
    {
     "evidence": "usual-money-registry-access-delay: … 0x6e9d65eC80D69b1f508560Bc7aeA5003db1f7FB7 (8-of-15 Gnosis Safe).",
     "key": "quorum",
     "label": "Signer quorum",
     "state": "g",
     "value": "Lowest controlling quorum: 8-of-15"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "emergency",
     "label": "Emergency / freeze scope",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No pause / freeze authority in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "parity",
     "label": "Docs-vs-chain parity",
     "state": "a",
     "value": "Documentation differs from the chain (parameter delta)"
    }
   ],
   "finding": "Timelock delay: docs say 3 d · chain says 1 s",
   "grade": "delta",
   "gradeLabel": "DELTA",
   "name": "Usual Money (USD0 / USD0++)",
   "pinnedBlock": 26401725,
   "probe": {
    "block_hash": "0xec3820f0a9db32c01728e66f78dc1958e410269e1077fd1db53df4fbce2ad7a1",
    "block_number": 26401725,
    "call_args": [],
    "call_signature": "defaultAdminDelay()",
    "chain": "ethereum",
    "check_type": "eth_call",
    "extra_calls": [],
    "id": "usual-money-registry-access-delay",
    "repro_calldata": "0xcc8463c8",
    "rpc_env_var": "$ETH_RPC_URL",
    "selector_or_slot": "0xcc8463c8",
    "target_contract": "0x0D374775E962c3608B8F0A4b8B10567DF739bb56",
    "target_label": "RegistryAccess"
   },
   "reconciled": false,
   "reconciledFrom": [],
   "reconciledTo": [],
   "records": 1,
   "rosetteAria": "Usual Money (USD0 / USD0++) control-plane rosette: Upgradeability not determined; Timelock floor weak; Signer quorum strong; Emergency / freeze scope not determined; Docs-vs-chain parity weak",
   "search": "usual money (usd0 / usd0++) usual-money-usd0-usd0 rwa stablecoin usd0 usd0++ usual 0x0d374775e962c3608b8f0a4b8b10567df739bb56 0x6e9d65ec80d69b1f508560bc7aea5003db1f7fb7",
   "slug": "usual-money-usd0-usd0",
   "summary_short": "Timelock delay: docs 3 days · chain 1 second",
   "url": "https://pacta.wtf/protocols/usual-money-usd0-usd0/"
  },
  {
   "baskets": [
    "lending_vaults"
   ],
   "category": "DeFi Vault Platform (BoringVault lens) (Ethereum)",
   "chains": [
    "ethereum"
   ],
   "deltas": 0,
   "easAttested": false,
   "evidence": {
    "documented": "Veda documentation is linked for reference (https://docs.veda.tech/). This RPC-pinned record does not compare documentation parameters with the on-chain state.",
    "observed": "ArcticArchitectureLens (0x5232bc0F5999f8dA604c42E1748A13a170F94A1B) verified on Ethereum Mainnet at canonical block #26,458,556 (3,470 bytes runtime code). EIP-1967 implementation and admin storage slots are both zero (non-EIP-1967 contract). No owner(), admin(), authority(), curator() or AccessControl admin was readable on the contract.",
    "recordId": "veda-control-plane",
    "surface": "ArcticArchitectureLens · Non-Proxy Bytecode & Controller"
   },
   "factors": [
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "upgrade",
     "label": "Upgradeability",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "Upgrade path not in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "timelock",
     "label": "Timelock floor",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No enforced admin delay in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "quorum",
     "label": "Signer quorum",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No signer quorum in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "emergency",
     "label": "Emergency / freeze scope",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No pause / freeze authority in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "parity",
     "label": "Docs-vs-chain parity",
     "state": "u",
     "value": "Uncompared: documentation not assessed (RPC-observed)"
    }
   ],
   "finding": "ArcticArchitectureLens · Non-Proxy Bytecode & Controller",
   "grade": "observed",
   "gradeLabel": "OBSERVED",
   "name": "Veda",
   "pinnedBlock": 26458556,
   "probe": {
    "block_hash": "0xe258bb1cbcc988e2dfdba4ba173f9f8690520dba3647cdcae18e0651822769d2",
    "block_number": 26458556,
    "call_args": [],
    "call_signature": "owner()",
    "chain": "ethereum",
    "check_type": "eth_call",
    "extra_calls": [],
    "id": "veda-control-plane",
    "repro_calldata": "0x8da5cb5b",
    "rpc_env_var": "$ETH_RPC_URL",
    "selector_or_slot": "0x8da5cb5b",
    "target_contract": "0x5232bc0F5999f8dA604c42E1748A13a170F94A1B",
    "target_label": "ArcticArchitectureLens"
   },
   "reconciled": false,
   "reconciledFrom": [],
   "reconciledTo": [],
   "records": 1,
   "rosetteAria": "Veda control-plane rosette: Upgradeability not determined; Timelock floor not determined; Signer quorum not determined; Emergency / freeze scope not determined; Docs-vs-chain parity uncompared",
   "search": "veda veda defi vault platform (boringvault lens) (ethereum) veda 0x5232bc0f5999f8da604c42e1748a13a170f94a1b",
   "slug": "veda",
   "summary_short": "Non-proxy contract no readable owner or admin; docs not assessed",
   "url": "https://pacta.wtf/protocols/veda/"
  },
  {
   "baskets": [
    "lending_vaults"
   ],
   "category": "Automated yield-aggregation pools with strategy rotation (Ethereum)",
   "chains": [
    "ethereum"
   ],
   "deltas": 1,
   "easAttested": true,
   "evidence": {
    "documented": "'Multisig is a contract where n people vote on transaction before it gets executed. The Vesper multisig has 5 signers and requires 3 yes votes for a transaction to execute.' (docs.vesper.finance/vesper-pools-and-strategies/vespers-modular-pool-architecture)",
    "observed": "Vesper governor Safe 0x9520b477Aa81180E6DdC006Fc09Fb6d3eb4e807A (Ethereum): getThreshold() = 3 of getOwners() = 6 owners (Safe v1.3.0); governor() of the Vesper pools 0xd1C117319B3595fbc39b471AB1fd485629eb05F2, 0x3aEd4dd0b5ba616156Fa352274670c18D2Ec2A81, 0x025a05f1967521806BB4c8a10Ba4b8c00A794F65 is this Safe, which is also the published controller of the VSP token record.",
    "recordId": "vesper-v1-governor-safe-s28",
    "surface": "Pool governor multisig: docs state 3 of 5 signers, the Safe is 3-of-6"
   },
   "factors": [
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "upgrade",
     "label": "Upgradeability",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "Upgrade path not in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "timelock",
     "label": "Timelock floor",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No enforced admin delay in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": "controller fact: Safe getThreshold()",
     "key": "quorum",
     "label": "Signer quorum",
     "state": "g",
     "value": "Lowest controlling quorum: 3-of-6"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "emergency",
     "label": "Emergency / freeze scope",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No pause / freeze authority in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "parity",
     "label": "Docs-vs-chain parity",
     "state": "a",
     "value": "Documentation differs from the chain (parameter delta)"
    }
   ],
   "finding": "Pool governor multisig: docs state 3 of 5 signers, the Safe is 3-of-6: docs say 'Multisig is a contract where n people vote on transaction before it gets executed. · chain says Vesper governor Safe 0x9520b477Aa81180E6DdC006Fc09Fb6d3eb4e807A (Ethereum): getThreshold() = 3 of getOwners() = 6 owners (Safe v1.3.0);",
   "grade": "delta",
   "gradeLabel": "DELTA",
   "name": "Vesper V1",
   "pinnedBlock": 26441165,
   "probe": {
    "block_hash": "0x5182be2c61af5f48ed2ec43d3c177dedad257c4e966a7e384120829de73901d9",
    "block_number": 26441165,
    "call_args": [],
    "call_signature": "getThreshold()",
    "chain": "ethereum",
    "check_type": "eth_call",
    "extra_calls": [],
    "id": "vesper-v1-governor-safe-s28",
    "repro_calldata": "0xe75235b8",
    "rpc_env_var": "$ETH_RPC_URL",
    "selector_or_slot": "0xe75235b8",
    "target_contract": "0x9520b477Aa81180E6DdC006Fc09Fb6d3eb4e807A",
    "target_label": "Vesper governor Safe"
   },
   "reconciled": false,
   "reconciledFrom": [],
   "reconciledTo": [],
   "records": 1,
   "rosetteAria": "Vesper V1 control-plane rosette: Upgradeability not determined; Timelock floor not determined; Signer quorum strong; Emergency / freeze scope not determined; Docs-vs-chain parity weak",
   "search": "vesper v1 vesper-v1 automated yield-aggregation pools with strategy rotation (ethereum) vsp 0x025a05f1967521806bb4c8a10ba4b8c00a794f65 0x3aed4dd0b5ba616156fa352274670c18d2ec2a81 0x9520b477aa81180e6ddc006fc09fb6d3eb4e807a 0xd1c117319b3595fbc39b471ab1fd485629eb05f2",
   "slug": "vesper-v1",
   "summary_short": "Docs state a 3-of-5 Vesper multisig; the governor Safe is 3-of-6",
   "url": "https://pacta.wtf/protocols/vesper-v1/"
  },
  {
   "baskets": [
    "lending_vaults",
    "stable_rwa"
   ],
   "category": "CDP issuing VUSD and vetBTC against yield-bearing reserves (Ethereum)",
   "chains": [
    "ethereum"
   ],
   "deltas": 0,
   "easAttested": true,
   "evidence": {
    "documented": "'**Upgradeable proxy patterns** using ERC-7201 namespaced storage for safe upgrade paths' (docs.vetro.org/llms-full.txt)",
    "observed": "VETRO contract 0xDaD503f8B9d42bb7af3AfC588358D30163e4416F (Ethereum): EIP-1967 implementation slot = 0x07Ee70DFd5a74d4a038Ff6AAE1d31Ca2C71F4DF1, admin slot = 0x83B2435d9A30b7463B3Ba997ba47a14B73149e2A; upgradeable (EIP-1967 implementation + admin slot (transparent proxy)).",
    "recordId": "vetro-upgradeability-dad503-s30",
    "surface": "VETRO contract: upgradeable (proxy admin), as documented"
   },
   "factors": [
    {
     "evidence": "vetro-upgradeability-dad503-s30: VETRO contract 0xDaD503f8B9d42bb7af3AfC588358D30163e4416F (Ethereum): EIP-1967 implementation slot = 0x07Ee70DFd5a74d4a038Ff6AAE1d31Ca2C71F4DF1, admin slot = …",
     "key": "upgrade",
     "label": "Upgradeability",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "Upgradeable; the delay gating the upgrade path is not in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "timelock",
     "label": "Timelock floor",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No enforced admin delay in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "quorum",
     "label": "Signer quorum",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No signer quorum in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "emergency",
     "label": "Emergency / freeze scope",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No pause / freeze authority in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "parity",
     "label": "Docs-vs-chain parity",
     "state": "g",
     "value": "Chain matches or is stronger than the documentation"
    }
   ],
   "finding": "VETRO contract: upgradeable (proxy admin), as documented",
   "grade": "aligned",
   "gradeLabel": "ALIGNED",
   "name": "VETRO",
   "pinnedBlock": 26449594,
   "probe": {
    "block_hash": "0xbe263d5b378dcb7c3c4e18bd8e388f0cb2dab1adacd83de2be58c9408b377287",
    "block_number": 26449594,
    "call_args": [],
    "call_signature": null,
    "chain": "ethereum",
    "check_type": "eth_getStorageAt",
    "extra_calls": [],
    "id": "vetro-upgradeability-dad503-s30",
    "repro_calldata": null,
    "rpc_env_var": "$ETH_RPC_URL",
    "selector_or_slot": "0x360894a13ba1a3210667c828492db98dca3e2076cc3735a920a3ca505d382bbc",
    "target_contract": "0xDaD503f8B9d42bb7af3AfC588358D30163e4416F",
    "target_label": "VETRO contract"
   },
   "reconciled": false,
   "reconciledFrom": [],
   "reconciledTo": [],
   "records": 1,
   "rosetteAria": "VETRO control-plane rosette: Upgradeability not determined; Timelock floor not determined; Signer quorum not determined; Emergency / freeze scope not determined; Docs-vs-chain parity strong",
   "search": "vetro vetro cdp issuing vusd and vetbtc against yield-bearing reserves (ethereum) vetro 0x07ee70dfd5a74d4a038ff6aae1d31ca2c71f4df1 0x83b2435d9a30b7463b3ba997ba47a14b73149e2a 0xdad503f8b9d42bb7af3afc588358d30163e4416f",
   "slug": "vetro",
   "summary_short": "The VETRO StakingVault proxy is upgradeable (proxy admin), as its docs state",
   "url": "https://pacta.wtf/protocols/vetro/"
  },
  {
   "baskets": [],
   "category": "Cross-chain interoperability bridge of a wide-area network chain (Ethereum)",
   "chains": [
    "ethereum"
   ],
   "deltas": 0,
   "easAttested": false,
   "evidence": {
    "documented": "Wan Bridge documentation is linked for reference (https://bridge.wanchain.org/docs). This RPC-pinned record does not compare documentation parameters with the on-chain state.",
    "observed": "CrossProxy (0xfCeAAaEB8D564a9D0e71Ef36f027b9D162bC334e) verified on Ethereum Mainnet at canonical block #26,458,556 (2,179 bytes runtime code). EIP-1967 implementation and admin storage slots are both zero (non-EIP-1967 contract). Direct owner() returns contract GroupApprove 0xA1223a59a55eAad135BCe9F513181C388072cC71.",
    "recordId": "wan-bridge-control-plane",
    "surface": "CrossProxy · Non-Proxy Bytecode & Controller"
   },
   "factors": [
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "upgrade",
     "label": "Upgradeability",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "Upgrade path not in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "timelock",
     "label": "Timelock floor",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No enforced admin delay in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "quorum",
     "label": "Signer quorum",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No signer quorum in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "emergency",
     "label": "Emergency / freeze scope",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No pause / freeze authority in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "parity",
     "label": "Docs-vs-chain parity",
     "state": "u",
     "value": "Uncompared: documentation not assessed (RPC-observed)"
    }
   ],
   "finding": "CrossProxy · Non-Proxy Bytecode & Controller",
   "grade": "observed",
   "gradeLabel": "OBSERVED",
   "name": "Wan Bridge",
   "pinnedBlock": 26458556,
   "probe": {
    "block_hash": "0xe258bb1cbcc988e2dfdba4ba173f9f8690520dba3647cdcae18e0651822769d2",
    "block_number": 26458556,
    "call_args": [],
    "call_signature": "owner()",
    "chain": "ethereum",
    "check_type": "eth_call",
    "extra_calls": [],
    "id": "wan-bridge-control-plane",
    "repro_calldata": "0x8da5cb5b",
    "rpc_env_var": "$ETH_RPC_URL",
    "selector_or_slot": "0x8da5cb5b",
    "target_contract": "0xfCeAAaEB8D564a9D0e71Ef36f027b9D162bC334e",
    "target_label": "CrossProxy"
   },
   "reconciled": false,
   "reconciledFrom": [],
   "reconciledTo": [],
   "records": 1,
   "rosetteAria": "Wan Bridge control-plane rosette: Upgradeability not determined; Timelock floor not determined; Signer quorum not determined; Emergency / freeze scope not determined; Docs-vs-chain parity uncompared",
   "search": "wan bridge wan-bridge cross-chain interoperability bridge of a wide-area network chain (ethereum) wan 0xa1223a59a55eaad135bce9f513181c388072cc71 0xfceaaaeb8d564a9d0e71ef36f027b9d162bc334e",
   "slug": "wan-bridge",
   "summary_short": "Non-proxy contract controlled by a contract; docs not assessed",
   "url": "https://pacta.wtf/protocols/wan-bridge/"
  },
  {
   "baskets": [
    "lending_vaults"
   ],
   "category": "Peer-to-peer escrow for pre-market token and points trades (Ethereum)",
   "chains": [
    "ethereum"
   ],
   "deltas": 1,
   "easAttested": true,
   "evidence": {
    "documented": "'Your deposited funds will be sent to and stored in an escrow secured by **an immutable smart contract,**' (docs.whales.market/llms-full.txt)",
    "observed": "Whales Market TransparentUpgradeableProxy 0x1eCdB32e59e948C010a189a0798C674a2d0c6603 (Ethereum): EIP-1967 implementation slot = 0x623620b3Eff4e1A30e9f1154f88198Ab26952EeB, admin slot = 0xeB5E772919661F455619A4cABd9B2b64715505E6; upgradeable (EIP-1967 implementation + admin slot (transparent proxy)).",
    "recordId": "whales-market-upgradeability-s28",
    "surface": "Whales Market TransparentUpgradeableProxy: docs describe it as immutable, but it is an upgradeable proxy"
   },
   "factors": [
    {
     "evidence": "whales-market-upgradeability-s28: Whales Market TransparentUpgradeableProxy 0x1eCdB32e59e948C010a189a0798C674a2d0c6603 (Ethereum): EIP-1967 implementation slot = …",
     "key": "upgrade",
     "label": "Upgradeability",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "Upgradeable; the delay gating the upgrade path is not in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "timelock",
     "label": "Timelock floor",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No enforced admin delay in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "quorum",
     "label": "Signer quorum",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No signer quorum in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "emergency",
     "label": "Emergency / freeze scope",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No pause / freeze authority in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "parity",
     "label": "Docs-vs-chain parity",
     "state": "a",
     "value": "Documentation differs from the chain (parameter delta)"
    }
   ],
   "finding": "Whales Market TransparentUpgradeableProxy: docs describe it as immutable, but it is an upgradeable proxy: docs say 'Your deposited funds will be sent to and stored in an escrow secured by **an immutable smart contract,**' (docs.whales.market/llms-full.txt) · chain says Whales Market TransparentUpgradeableProxy 0x1eCdB32e59e948C010a189a0798C674a2d0c6603 (Ethereum): EIP-1967 implementation slot = 0x623620b3Eff4e1A30e9f1154f88198Ab26952EeB, admin slot = 0xeB5E772919661F455619A4cABd9B2b64…",
   "grade": "delta",
   "gradeLabel": "DELTA",
   "name": "Whales Market",
   "pinnedBlock": 26441165,
   "probe": {
    "block_hash": "0x5182be2c61af5f48ed2ec43d3c177dedad257c4e966a7e384120829de73901d9",
    "block_number": 26441165,
    "call_args": [],
    "call_signature": null,
    "chain": "ethereum",
    "check_type": "eth_getStorageAt",
    "extra_calls": [],
    "id": "whales-market-upgradeability-s28",
    "repro_calldata": null,
    "rpc_env_var": "$ETH_RPC_URL",
    "selector_or_slot": "0x360894a13ba1a3210667c828492db98dca3e2076cc3735a920a3ca505d382bbc",
    "target_contract": "0x1eCdB32e59e948C010a189a0798C674a2d0c6603",
    "target_label": "Whales Market TransparentUpgradeableProxy"
   },
   "reconciled": false,
   "reconciledFrom": [],
   "reconciledTo": [],
   "records": 1,
   "rosetteAria": "Whales Market control-plane rosette: Upgradeability not determined; Timelock floor not determined; Signer quorum not determined; Emergency / freeze scope not determined; Docs-vs-chain parity weak",
   "search": "whales market whales-market peer-to-peer escrow for pre-market token and points trades (ethereum) whales 0x1ecdb32e59e948c010a189a0798c674a2d0c6603 0x623620b3eff4e1a30e9f1154f88198ab26952eeb 0xeb5e772919661f455619a4cabd9b2b64715505e6",
   "slug": "whales-market",
   "summary_short": "Docs call Whales Market immutable, but an upgradeable proxy sits on chain",
   "url": "https://pacta.wtf/protocols/whales-market/"
  },
  {
   "baskets": [
    "stable_rwa"
   ],
   "category": "Undercollateralized credit lines for named borrowers (Ethereum)",
   "chains": [
    "ethereum"
   ],
   "deltas": 0,
   "easAttested": false,
   "evidence": {
    "documented": "Wildcat Protocol documentation is linked for reference (https://docs.wildcat.finance/). This RPC-pinned record does not compare documentation parameters with the on-chain state.",
    "observed": "WildcatArchController (0xfEB516d9D946dD487A9346F6fee11f40C6945eE4) verified on Ethereum Mainnet at canonical block #26,458,556 (8,724 bytes runtime code). EIP-1967 implementation and admin storage slots are both zero (non-EIP-1967 contract). Direct owner() returns Safe 3-of-5 0xC15bE5214978d1fc509ECdd4f9D5BC067C94D9Ae.",
    "recordId": "wildcat-protocol-control-plane",
    "surface": "WildcatArchController · Non-Proxy Bytecode & Controller"
   },
   "factors": [
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "upgrade",
     "label": "Upgradeability",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "Upgrade path not in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "timelock",
     "label": "Timelock floor",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No enforced admin delay in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": "wildcat-protocol-control-plane: … contract). Direct owner() returns Safe 3-of-5 0xC15bE5214978d1fc509ECdd4f9D5BC067C94D9Ae.",
     "key": "quorum",
     "label": "Signer quorum",
     "state": "g",
     "value": "Lowest controlling quorum: 3-of-5"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "emergency",
     "label": "Emergency / freeze scope",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No pause / freeze authority in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "parity",
     "label": "Docs-vs-chain parity",
     "state": "u",
     "value": "Uncompared: documentation not assessed (RPC-observed)"
    }
   ],
   "finding": "WildcatArchController · Non-Proxy Bytecode & Controller",
   "grade": "observed",
   "gradeLabel": "OBSERVED",
   "name": "Wildcat Protocol",
   "pinnedBlock": 26458556,
   "probe": {
    "block_hash": "0xe258bb1cbcc988e2dfdba4ba173f9f8690520dba3647cdcae18e0651822769d2",
    "block_number": 26458556,
    "call_args": [],
    "call_signature": "owner()",
    "chain": "ethereum",
    "check_type": "eth_call",
    "extra_calls": [],
    "id": "wildcat-protocol-control-plane",
    "repro_calldata": "0x8da5cb5b",
    "rpc_env_var": "$ETH_RPC_URL",
    "selector_or_slot": "0x8da5cb5b",
    "target_contract": "0xfEB516d9D946dD487A9346F6fee11f40C6945eE4",
    "target_label": "WildcatArchController"
   },
   "reconciled": false,
   "reconciledFrom": [],
   "reconciledTo": [],
   "records": 1,
   "rosetteAria": "Wildcat Protocol control-plane rosette: Upgradeability not determined; Timelock floor not determined; Signer quorum strong; Emergency / freeze scope not determined; Docs-vs-chain parity uncompared",
   "search": "wildcat protocol wildcat-protocol undercollateralized credit lines for named borrowers (ethereum) wildcat 0xc15be5214978d1fc509ecdd4f9d5bc067c94d9ae 0xfeb516d9d946dd487a9346f6fee11f40c6945ee4",
   "slug": "wildcat-protocol",
   "summary_short": "Non-proxy contract controlled by a 3-of-5 Safe; docs not assessed",
   "url": "https://pacta.wtf/protocols/wildcat-protocol/"
  },
  {
   "baskets": [
    "lending_vaults"
   ],
   "category": "Market-maker curated vault lending WBTC through adapters (Ethereum)",
   "chains": [
    "ethereum"
   ],
   "deltas": 0,
   "easAttested": true,
   "evidence": {
    "documented": "'| Curator | [Safe Multisig 3/6](https://etherscan.io/address/0x4687e45bb5518a995913a24bb2816fe2031d74d8) |' (armitage.wintermute.com/llms-full.txt)",
    "observed": "Wintermute Confidential WBTC (Ethereum) Safe 0x4687E45bB5518a995913a24BB2816fe2031d74D8 (Ethereum): getThreshold() = 3 of getOwners() = 6 owners (Safe v1.4.1); it controls VaultV2 0x3d5EcCb62974178236A768A7ef14D3ce468Fbe91.",
    "recordId": "wintermute-confidential-wbtc-ethereum-safe-threshold-3d5ecc-s28",
    "surface": "Wintermute Confidential WBTC (Ethereum) multisig: 3-of-6 Safe, as documented"
   },
   "factors": [
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "upgrade",
     "label": "Upgradeability",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "Upgrade path not in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "timelock",
     "label": "Timelock floor",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No enforced admin delay in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": "controller fact: Safe getThreshold()",
     "key": "quorum",
     "label": "Signer quorum",
     "state": "g",
     "value": "Lowest controlling quorum: 3-of-6"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "emergency",
     "label": "Emergency / freeze scope",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No pause / freeze authority in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "parity",
     "label": "Docs-vs-chain parity",
     "state": "g",
     "value": "Chain matches or is stronger than the documentation"
    }
   ],
   "finding": "Wintermute Confidential WBTC (Ethereum) multisig: 3-of-6 Safe, as documented",
   "grade": "aligned",
   "gradeLabel": "ALIGNED",
   "name": "Wintermute Confidential WBTC (Ethereum)",
   "pinnedBlock": 26441165,
   "probe": {
    "block_hash": "0x5182be2c61af5f48ed2ec43d3c177dedad257c4e966a7e384120829de73901d9",
    "block_number": 26441165,
    "call_args": [],
    "call_signature": "getThreshold()",
    "chain": "ethereum",
    "check_type": "eth_call",
    "extra_calls": [],
    "id": "wintermute-confidential-wbtc-ethereum-safe-threshold-3d5ecc-s28",
    "repro_calldata": "0xe75235b8",
    "rpc_env_var": "$ETH_RPC_URL",
    "selector_or_slot": "0xe75235b8",
    "target_contract": "0x4687E45bB5518a995913a24BB2816fe2031d74D8",
    "target_label": "Wintermute Confidential WBTC (Ethereum) Safe"
   },
   "reconciled": false,
   "reconciledFrom": [],
   "reconciledTo": [],
   "records": 1,
   "rosetteAria": "Wintermute Confidential WBTC (Ethereum) control-plane rosette: Upgradeability not determined; Timelock floor not determined; Signer quorum strong; Emergency / freeze scope not determined; Docs-vs-chain parity strong",
   "search": "wintermute confidential wbtc (ethereum) wintermute-confidential-wbtc-ethereum market-maker curated vault lending wbtc through adapters (ethereum) armcwbtc 0x3d5eccb62974178236a768a7ef14d3ce468fbe91 0x4687e45bb5518a995913a24bb2816fe2031d74d8",
   "slug": "wintermute-confidential-wbtc-ethereum",
   "summary_short": "The Wintermute Confidential WBTC (Ethereum) multisig is a 4-of-7 Safe, as its docs state",
   "url": "https://pacta.wtf/protocols/wintermute-confidential-wbtc-ethereum/"
  },
  {
   "baskets": [
    "lending_vaults"
   ],
   "category": "Single-sided supercharger vaults lending to a proactive market maker (Ethereum)",
   "chains": [
    "ethereum"
   ],
   "deltas": 0,
   "easAttested": false,
   "evidence": {
    "documented": "WOOFi Earn documentation is linked for reference (https://woofi.com/docs). This RPC-pinned record does not compare documentation parameters with the on-chain state.",
    "observed": "Wootrade Network (0x4691937a7508860F876c9c0a2a617E7d9E945D4B) verified on Ethereum Mainnet at canonical block #26,458,556 (4,011 bytes runtime code). EIP-1967 implementation and admin storage slots are both zero (non-EIP-1967 contract). No owner(), admin(), authority(), curator() or AccessControl admin was readable on the contract.",
    "recordId": "woofi-earn-control-plane",
    "surface": "Wootrade Network · Non-Proxy Bytecode & Controller"
   },
   "factors": [
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "upgrade",
     "label": "Upgradeability",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "Upgrade path not in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "timelock",
     "label": "Timelock floor",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No enforced admin delay in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "quorum",
     "label": "Signer quorum",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No signer quorum in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "emergency",
     "label": "Emergency / freeze scope",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No pause / freeze authority in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "parity",
     "label": "Docs-vs-chain parity",
     "state": "u",
     "value": "Uncompared: documentation not assessed (RPC-observed)"
    }
   ],
   "finding": "Wootrade Network · Non-Proxy Bytecode & Controller",
   "grade": "observed",
   "gradeLabel": "OBSERVED",
   "name": "WOOFi Earn",
   "pinnedBlock": 26458556,
   "probe": {
    "block_hash": "0xe258bb1cbcc988e2dfdba4ba173f9f8690520dba3647cdcae18e0651822769d2",
    "block_number": 26458556,
    "call_args": [],
    "call_signature": "owner()",
    "chain": "ethereum",
    "check_type": "eth_call",
    "extra_calls": [],
    "id": "woofi-earn-control-plane",
    "repro_calldata": "0x8da5cb5b",
    "rpc_env_var": "$ETH_RPC_URL",
    "selector_or_slot": "0x8da5cb5b",
    "target_contract": "0x4691937a7508860F876c9c0a2a617E7d9E945D4B",
    "target_label": "Wootrade Network"
   },
   "reconciled": false,
   "reconciledFrom": [],
   "reconciledTo": [],
   "records": 1,
   "rosetteAria": "WOOFi Earn control-plane rosette: Upgradeability not determined; Timelock floor not determined; Signer quorum not determined; Emergency / freeze scope not determined; Docs-vs-chain parity uncompared",
   "search": "woofi earn woofi-earn single-sided supercharger vaults lending to a proactive market maker (ethereum) woo 0x4691937a7508860f876c9c0a2a617e7d9e945d4b",
   "slug": "woofi-earn",
   "summary_short": "Non-proxy contract no readable owner or admin; docs not assessed",
   "url": "https://pacta.wtf/protocols/woofi-earn/"
  },
  {
   "baskets": [],
   "category": "OP Stack L2 Canonical Bridge (dispute-game anchor state) (Ethereum)",
   "chains": [
    "ethereum"
   ],
   "deltas": 0,
   "easAttested": false,
   "evidence": {
    "documented": "World Chain Bridge documentation is linked for reference (https://docs.world.org/). This RPC-pinned record does not compare documentation parameters with the on-chain state.",
    "observed": "AnchorStateRegistry (0x90BB48fe3310499Db36437dCAE642F721e32d094) verified on Ethereum Mainnet at canonical block #26,458,556 (2,059 bytes runtime code). EIP-1967 proxy: implementation 0x8F40Cc98D694AB986F026C5383A181FCc9B6B281, admin 0xd7405BE7f3e63b094Af6C7C23D5eE33Fd82F872D. The EIP-1967 admin slot holds contract ProxyAdmin 0xd7405BE7f3e63b094Af6C7C23D5eE33Fd82F872D. That controller is in turn controlled by Safe 3-of-6 0xA4fB12D15Eb85dc9284a7df0AdBC8B696EdbbF1d.",
    "recordId": "world-chain-bridge-control-plane",
    "surface": "AnchorStateRegistry · EIP-1967 Proxy & Controller Chain"
   },
   "factors": [
    {
     "evidence": "world-chain-bridge-control-plane: AnchorStateRegistry (0x90BB48fe3310499Db36437dCAE642F721e32d094) verified on Ethereum Mainnet at canonical block #26,458,556 (2,059 bytes runtime code). …",
     "key": "upgrade",
     "label": "Upgradeability",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "Upgradeable; the delay gating the upgrade path is not in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "timelock",
     "label": "Timelock floor",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No enforced admin delay in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": "world-chain-bridge-control-plane: … controller is in turn controlled by Safe 3-of-6 0xA4fB12D15Eb85dc9284a7df0AdBC8B696EdbbF1d.",
     "key": "quorum",
     "label": "Signer quorum",
     "state": "g",
     "value": "Lowest controlling quorum: 3-of-6"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "emergency",
     "label": "Emergency / freeze scope",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No pause / freeze authority in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "parity",
     "label": "Docs-vs-chain parity",
     "state": "u",
     "value": "Uncompared: documentation not assessed (RPC-observed)"
    }
   ],
   "finding": "AnchorStateRegistry · EIP-1967 Proxy & Controller Chain",
   "grade": "observed",
   "gradeLabel": "OBSERVED",
   "name": "World Chain Bridge",
   "pinnedBlock": 26458556,
   "probe": {
    "block_hash": "0xe258bb1cbcc988e2dfdba4ba173f9f8690520dba3647cdcae18e0651822769d2",
    "block_number": 26458556,
    "call_args": [],
    "call_signature": null,
    "chain": "ethereum",
    "check_type": "eth_getStorageAt",
    "extra_calls": [],
    "id": "world-chain-bridge-control-plane",
    "repro_calldata": null,
    "rpc_env_var": "$ETH_RPC_URL",
    "selector_or_slot": "0xb53127684a568b3173ae13b9f8a6016e243e63b6e8ee1178d6a717850b5d6103",
    "target_contract": "0x90BB48fe3310499Db36437dCAE642F721e32d094",
    "target_label": "AnchorStateRegistry"
   },
   "reconciled": false,
   "reconciledFrom": [],
   "reconciledTo": [],
   "records": 1,
   "rosetteAria": "World Chain Bridge control-plane rosette: Upgradeability not determined; Timelock floor not determined; Signer quorum strong; Emergency / freeze scope not determined; Docs-vs-chain parity uncompared",
   "search": "world chain bridge world-chain-bridge op stack l2 canonical bridge (dispute-game anchor state) (ethereum) world 0x8f40cc98d694ab986f026c5383a181fcc9b6b281 0x90bb48fe3310499db36437dcae642f721e32d094 0xa4fb12d15eb85dc9284a7df0adbc8b696edbbf1d 0xd7405be7f3e63b094af6c7c23d5ee33fd82f872d",
   "slug": "world-chain-bridge",
   "summary_short": "Upgradeable proxy controlled by a 3-of-6 Safe; docs not assessed",
   "url": "https://pacta.wtf/protocols/world-chain-bridge/"
  },
  {
   "baskets": [
    "base"
   ],
   "category": "Cross-Chain Messaging (Guardian-Attested Core Bridge)",
   "chains": [
    "base",
    "ethereum"
   ],
   "deltas": 0,
   "easAttested": true,
   "evidence": {
    "documented": "wormhole.com/docs (guardians / security): 'Once a sufficient delegate quorum is reached or once Guardians independently observe the event, signatures accumulate until the required 13-of-19 quorum is achieved.' / 'Some chains (such as Ethereum and Solana) are secured by all 19 Guardians.' / 'The Core Contract does not distinguish between chains with direct observation and delegated chains; it verifies only that a valid 13-of-19 VAA has been produced.'",
    "observed": "Wormhole core 0x98f3c9e6E3fAce36bAAd05FE09d375Ef1464288B: getCurrentGuardianSetIndex() = 7; getGuardianSet(7) = 19 keys, expirationTime 0; quorum(19) = 13.",
    "recordId": "wormhole-core-ntt-eth-guardian-quorum-s25",
    "surface": "Messages need 13 of the 19 guardians (guardian set 7)"
   },
   "factors": [
    {
     "evidence": "wormhole-core-ntt-eth-upgrade-governance-s25: Wormhole core 0x98f3c9e6E3fAce36bAAd05FE09d375Ef1464288B: EIP-1967 implementation = 0x3c3d457f1522D3540AB3325Aa5f1864E34cBA9D0",
     "key": "upgrade",
     "label": "Upgradeability",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "Upgradeable; the delay gating the upgrade path is not in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "timelock",
     "label": "Timelock floor",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No enforced admin delay in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "quorum",
     "label": "Signer quorum",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No signer quorum in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": "wormhole-core-ntt-eth-upgrade-governance-s25: upgrades only through submitContractUpgrade with a governance message signed by the current guardian set's quorum.",
     "key": "emergency",
     "label": "Emergency / freeze scope",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "Pause / freeze authority present; its holder is not determined"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "parity",
     "label": "Docs-vs-chain parity",
     "state": "g",
     "value": "Chain matches or is stronger than the documentation"
    }
   ],
   "finding": "Messages need 13 of the 19 guardians (guardian set 7)",
   "grade": "aligned",
   "gradeLabel": "ALIGNED",
   "name": "Wormhole Core (NTT)",
   "pinnedBlock": 58641783,
   "probe": {
    "block_hash": "0xb712439847099ec3e8b1617aafd1bc7ece29e22a88dc4e7c8afcf05e6944d987",
    "block_number": 26434786,
    "call_args": [
     "0x7"
    ],
    "call_signature": "getGuardianSet(uint32)",
    "chain": "ethereum",
    "check_type": "eth_call",
    "extra_calls": [],
    "id": "wormhole-core-ntt-eth-guardian-quorum-s25",
    "repro_calldata": "0xf951975a0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000007",
    "rpc_env_var": "$ETH_RPC_URL",
    "selector_or_slot": "0xf951975a",
    "target_contract": "0x98f3c9e6E3fAce36bAAd05FE09d375Ef1464288B",
    "target_label": "Wormhole Core (Ethereum)"
   },
   "reconciled": false,
   "reconciledFrom": [],
   "reconciledTo": [],
   "records": 4,
   "rosetteAria": "Wormhole Core (NTT) control-plane rosette: Upgradeability not determined; Timelock floor not determined; Signer quorum not determined; Emergency / freeze scope not determined; Docs-vs-chain parity strong",
   "search": "wormhole core (ntt) wormhole-core-ntt cross-chain messaging (guardian-attested core bridge) wormhole ntt guardian 0x3c3d457f1522d3540ab3325aa5f1864e34cba9d0 0x98f3c9e6e3face36baad05fe09d375ef1464288b 0xbebdb6c8ddc678ffa9f8748f85c815c556dd8ac6 0xfc0d459b8c299095dee743645caac8ed3f9abc4d",
   "slug": "wormhole-core-ntt",
   "summary_short": "Messages and upgrades need 13 of 19 guardians on Ethereum and Base, as documented",
   "url": "https://pacta.wtf/protocols/wormhole-core-ntt/"
  },
  {
   "baskets": [
    "eth_lst_lrt"
   ],
   "category": "Canonical Bridge Staking Token (multi-chain) (Ethereum)",
   "chains": [
    "ethereum"
   ],
   "deltas": 0,
   "easAttested": true,
   "evidence": {
    "documented": "'There are currently 15 Bridge Governors, of which 8-of-15 are required to pass a proposal.' (docs.gnosischain.com/bridges/management); '0x4aa42145Aa6Ebf72e164C9bBC74fbD3788045016' (docs.gnosischain.com/bridges/About%20Token%20Bridges/xdai-bridge)",
    "observed": "Bridge Governor Multisig 0x42F38ec5A75acCEc50054671233dfAC9C0E7A3F6 (Ethereum Safe, the address the page gives): getThreshold() = 8 of getOwners() = 15; guard slot empty; getModulesPaginated() lists no module. Its 15 owners are exactly the 15 Ethereum governor addresses the page lists (none missing, none extra). The xDAI Bridge contract 0x4aa42145Aa6Ebf72e164C9bBC74fbD3788045016 (EternalStorageProxy, implementation 0x257bDD093Cab1Bd39eBF837dCB60f33d031d7d49) returns this Safe for both owner() and upgradeabilityOwner().",
    "recordId": "gnosis-bridge-governor-safe-8-of-15-s34",
    "surface": "Bridge Governor Safe: 8-of-15, owners = the 15 documented governors"
   },
   "factors": [
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "upgrade",
     "label": "Upgradeability",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "Upgrade path not in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "timelock",
     "label": "Timelock floor",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No enforced admin delay in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": "controller fact: Safe getThreshold()",
     "key": "quorum",
     "label": "Signer quorum",
     "state": "g",
     "value": "Lowest controlling quorum: 8-of-15"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "emergency",
     "label": "Emergency / freeze scope",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No pause / freeze authority in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "parity",
     "label": "Docs-vs-chain parity",
     "state": "g",
     "value": "Chain matches or is stronger than the documentation"
    }
   ],
   "finding": "Bridge Governor Safe: 8-of-15, owners = the 15 documented governors",
   "grade": "aligned",
   "gradeLabel": "ALIGNED",
   "name": "xDAI Stake Bridge",
   "pinnedBlock": 26453551,
   "probe": {
    "block_hash": "0x51e9967ffd6a84012d0dad44204d523b8ac43928e69de2801d2e72dbf8767129",
    "block_number": 26453551,
    "call_args": [],
    "call_signature": "getThreshold()",
    "chain": "ethereum",
    "check_type": "eth_call",
    "extra_calls": [],
    "id": "gnosis-bridge-governor-safe-8-of-15-s34",
    "repro_calldata": "0xe75235b8",
    "rpc_env_var": "$ETH_RPC_URL",
    "selector_or_slot": "0xe75235b8",
    "target_contract": "0x42F38ec5A75acCEc50054671233dfAC9C0E7A3F6",
    "target_label": "Gnosis Bridge Governor Multisig (Ethereum)"
   },
   "reconciled": false,
   "reconciledFrom": [],
   "reconciledTo": [],
   "records": 1,
   "rosetteAria": "xDAI Stake Bridge control-plane rosette: Upgradeability not determined; Timelock floor not determined; Signer quorum strong; Emergency / freeze scope not determined; Docs-vs-chain parity strong",
   "search": "xdai stake bridge xdai-stake-bridge canonical bridge staking token (multi-chain) (ethereum) stake 0x257bdd093cab1bd39ebf837dcb60f33d031d7d49 0x42f38ec5a75accec50054671233dfac9c0e7a3f6 0x4aa42145aa6ebf72e164c9bbc74fbd3788045016",
   "slug": "xdai-stake-bridge",
   "summary_short": "The Gnosis bridge governor Safe is 8-of-15 with the 15 listed governors, as documented",
   "url": "https://pacta.wtf/protocols/xdai-stake-bridge/"
  },
  {
   "baskets": [
    "base",
    "stable_rwa"
   ],
   "category": "Delta-neutral synthetic dollar backed by hedged positions (Base)",
   "chains": [
    "base"
   ],
   "deltas": 0,
   "easAttested": false,
   "evidence": {
    "documented": "XSY documentation is linked for reference (https://yieldpoint.io/). This RPC-pinned record does not compare documentation parameters with the on-chain state.",
    "observed": "Unity (UTY) (0xBA515304d8153c4b162dC79f867E152DF9c127eb) verified on Base Mainnet at canonical block #60,070,202 (122 bytes runtime code). EIP-1967 proxy: implementation 0xF2F6E1a62d3d1f0efB01C28e485f1dC8B173cE2B, admin slot zero. Direct owner() returns Safe 3-of-4 0xB237EB3c71a0f351BD121b0C467248473fbC2ccA.",
    "recordId": "xsy-control-plane",
    "surface": "Unity (UTY) · EIP-1967 Proxy & Controller Chain"
   },
   "factors": [
    {
     "evidence": "xsy-control-plane: is_eip1967_proxy = true",
     "key": "upgrade",
     "label": "Upgradeability",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "Upgradeable; the delay gating the upgrade path is not in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "timelock",
     "label": "Timelock floor",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No enforced admin delay in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": "xsy-control-plane: … slot zero. Direct owner() returns Safe 3-of-4 0xB237EB3c71a0f351BD121b0C467248473fbC2ccA.",
     "key": "quorum",
     "label": "Signer quorum",
     "state": "g",
     "value": "Lowest controlling quorum: 3-of-4"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "emergency",
     "label": "Emergency / freeze scope",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No pause / freeze authority in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "parity",
     "label": "Docs-vs-chain parity",
     "state": "u",
     "value": "Uncompared: documentation not assessed (RPC-observed)"
    }
   ],
   "finding": "Unity (UTY) · EIP-1967 Proxy & Controller Chain",
   "grade": "observed",
   "gradeLabel": "OBSERVED",
   "name": "XSY",
   "pinnedBlock": 60070202,
   "probe": {
    "block_hash": "0x01b3f5dcecb67c63ba33350ec6942563f6b8a0d8ca9b4f69a752844a5bab4a20",
    "block_number": 60070202,
    "call_args": [],
    "call_signature": "owner()",
    "chain": "base",
    "check_type": "eth_call",
    "extra_calls": [],
    "id": "xsy-control-plane",
    "repro_calldata": "0x8da5cb5b",
    "rpc_env_var": "$BASE_RPC_URL",
    "selector_or_slot": "0x8da5cb5b",
    "target_contract": "0xBA515304d8153c4b162dC79f867E152DF9c127eb",
    "target_label": "Unity (UTY)"
   },
   "reconciled": false,
   "reconciledFrom": [],
   "reconciledTo": [],
   "records": 1,
   "rosetteAria": "XSY control-plane rosette: Upgradeability not determined; Timelock floor not determined; Signer quorum strong; Emergency / freeze scope not determined; Docs-vs-chain parity uncompared",
   "search": "xsy xsy delta-neutral synthetic dollar backed by hedged positions (base) uty 0xb237eb3c71a0f351bd121b0c467248473fbc2cca 0xba515304d8153c4b162dc79f867e152df9c127eb 0xf2f6e1a62d3d1f0efb01c28e485f1dc8b173ce2b",
   "slug": "xsy",
   "summary_short": "Upgradeable proxy controlled by a 3-of-4 Safe; docs not assessed",
   "url": "https://pacta.wtf/protocols/xsy/"
  },
  {
   "baskets": [
    "lending_vaults"
   ],
   "category": "Yield Aggregation Vaults",
   "chains": [
    "ethereum"
   ],
   "deltas": 1,
   "easAttested": true,
   "evidence": {
    "documented": "yearn-devdocs security overview previously noted governance was not behind a timelock (live deployment enforces stricter 7-day TimelockController).",
    "observed": "governance() = 0x88Ba032be87d5EF1fbE87336B7090767F367BF73 (TimelockController, getMinDelay() = 604800s / 7 days); getDaddy() = 0xFEB4acf3df3cDEA7399794D0869ef76A6EfAff52 (6-of-9 ychad.eth Safe); getBrain() = 0x16388463d60FFE0661Cf7F1f31a7D658aC790ff7 (3-of-6 Safe).",
    "recordId": "yearn-v3-role-manager-timelock",
    "surface": "Sampled RoleManager.governance() Timelock Wiring"
   },
   "factors": [
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "upgrade",
     "label": "Upgradeability",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "Upgrade path not in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": "controller fact: getMinDelay() = 604800s",
     "key": "timelock",
     "label": "Timelock floor",
     "state": "g",
     "value": "7d minimum enforced delay across control surfaces"
    },
    {
     "evidence": "yearn-v3-role-manager-timelock: … 0x16388463d60FFE0661Cf7F1f31a7D658aC790ff7 (3-of-6 Safe).",
     "key": "quorum",
     "label": "Signer quorum",
     "state": "g",
     "value": "Lowest controlling quorum: 3-of-6"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "emergency",
     "label": "Emergency / freeze scope",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No pause / freeze authority in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "parity",
     "label": "Docs-vs-chain parity",
     "state": "a",
     "value": "Documentation differs from the chain (parameter delta)"
    }
   ],
   "finding": "Timelock delay: docs say 0 s (no delay) · chain says 7 d",
   "grade": "delta",
   "gradeLabel": "DELTA",
   "name": "Yearn V3",
   "pinnedBlock": 26441165,
   "probe": {
    "block_hash": "0x5182be2c61af5f48ed2ec43d3c177dedad257c4e966a7e384120829de73901d9",
    "block_number": 26441165,
    "call_args": [],
    "call_signature": "getOwners()",
    "chain": "ethereum",
    "check_type": "eth_call",
    "extra_calls": [],
    "id": "yearn-v3-ychad-safe-signers-s28",
    "repro_calldata": "0xa0e67e2b",
    "rpc_env_var": "$ETH_RPC_URL",
    "selector_or_slot": "0xa0e67e2b",
    "target_contract": "0xFEB4acf3df3cDEA7399794D0869ef76A6EfAff52",
    "target_label": "yChad Governance Safe"
   },
   "reconciled": false,
   "reconciledFrom": [],
   "reconciledTo": [],
   "records": 2,
   "rosetteAria": "Yearn V3 control-plane rosette: Upgradeability not determined; Timelock floor strong; Signer quorum strong; Emergency / freeze scope not determined; Docs-vs-chain parity weak",
   "search": "yearn v3 yearn-v3 yield aggregation vaults yfi 0x16388463d60ffe0661cf7f1f31a7d658ac790ff7 0x6f2a8ee9452ba7d336b3fba03cac27f7818aead6 0x88ba032be87d5ef1fbe87336b7090767f367bf73 0xb3bd6b2e61753c311efbcf0111f75d29706d9a41 0xfeb4acf3df3cdea7399794d0869ef76a6efaff52",
   "slug": "yearn-v3",
   "summary_short": "Docs list a yChad signer who is no longer on the 6-of-9 Safe",
   "url": "https://pacta.wtf/protocols/yearn-v3/"
  },
  {
   "baskets": [],
   "category": "Impermanent-Loss-Free Leveraged AMM Liquidity (Ethereum)",
   "chains": [
    "ethereum"
   ],
   "deltas": 0,
   "easAttested": true,
   "evidence": {
    "documented": "'reserve + totalSupply equals 1,000,000,000. Nobody can add a new minter, because the token has no owner.' (docs.yieldbasis.com/user/governance/yb-token)",
    "observed": "YB token 0x01791F726B4103694969820be083196cC7c045fF (Ethereum; not a proxy: EIP-1967 implementation, admin and beacon slots all empty; verified source): totalSupply() = 760,625,378.82. The runtime code holds no selector of mint(uint256), upgradeTo(address), upgradeToAndCall(address,bytes). reserve() = 239,374,621.18, and reserve() + totalSupply() = 1,000,000,000 exactly. owner() is the zero address; set_minter and transfer_ownership are owner-only and renounce_ownership() removed the deployer's minter role, so no minter can be added (existing minter memberships are not enumerable).",
    "recordId": "yield-basis-yb-renounced-reserve-1b-s33",
    "surface": "YB: owner() zero; reserve + supply = 1,000,000,000"
   },
   "factors": [
    {
     "evidence": "yield-basis-yb-renounced-reserve-1b-s33: YB token 0x01791F726B4103694969820be083196cC7c045fF (Ethereum; not a proxy: EIP-1967 implementation, admin and beacon slots all empty; verified source) …",
     "key": "upgrade",
     "label": "Upgradeability",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "Upgradeable; the delay gating the upgrade path is not in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "timelock",
     "label": "Timelock floor",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No enforced admin delay in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "quorum",
     "label": "Signer quorum",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No signer quorum in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "emergency",
     "label": "Emergency / freeze scope",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No pause / freeze authority in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "parity",
     "label": "Docs-vs-chain parity",
     "state": "g",
     "value": "Chain matches or is stronger than the documentation"
    }
   ],
   "finding": "YB: owner() zero; reserve + supply = 1,000,000,000",
   "grade": "aligned",
   "gradeLabel": "ALIGNED",
   "name": "Yield Basis",
   "pinnedBlock": 26452373,
   "probe": {
    "block_hash": "0x63bfaa16f0019d8b37e757265d351bd135ad41e6ffa46207284198917123c55d",
    "block_number": 26452373,
    "call_args": [],
    "call_signature": "totalSupply()",
    "chain": "ethereum",
    "check_type": "eth_call",
    "extra_calls": [],
    "id": "yield-basis-yb-renounced-reserve-1b-s33",
    "repro_calldata": "0x18160ddd",
    "rpc_env_var": "$ETH_RPC_URL",
    "selector_or_slot": "0x18160ddd",
    "target_contract": "0x01791F726B4103694969820be083196cC7c045fF",
    "target_label": "YB token"
   },
   "reconciled": false,
   "reconciledFrom": [],
   "reconciledTo": [],
   "records": 1,
   "rosetteAria": "Yield Basis control-plane rosette: Upgradeability not determined; Timelock floor not determined; Signer quorum not determined; Emergency / freeze scope not determined; Docs-vs-chain parity strong",
   "search": "yield basis yield-basis impermanent-loss-free leveraged amm liquidity (ethereum) yb 0x01791f726b4103694969820be083196cc7c045ff",
   "slug": "yield-basis",
   "summary_short": "YB ownership is renounced and reserve plus supply is 1B, as documented",
   "url": "https://pacta.wtf/protocols/yield-basis/"
  },
  {
   "baskets": [
    "lending_vaults",
    "stable_rwa"
   ],
   "category": "Tokenized asset-management products for stablecoin yield (Ethereum)",
   "chains": [
    "ethereum"
   ],
   "deltas": 0,
   "easAttested": false,
   "evidence": {
    "documented": "YieldFi documentation is linked for reference (https://docs.yield.fi/). This RPC-pinned record does not compare documentation parameters with the on-chain state.",
    "observed": "YieldFi yUSD (YToken) (0x19Ebd191f7A24ECE672ba13A302212b5eF7F35cb) verified on Ethereum Mainnet at canonical block #26,458,556 (793 bytes runtime code). EIP-1967 proxy: implementation 0x5bf44d32260AeE6b807c490e92eF0481D15Ab493, admin 0xE26E1D2ae51dcB89E382CA7400b080e6632117B9. The EIP-1967 admin slot holds contract contract 0xE26E1D2ae51dcB89E382CA7400b080e6632117B9. That controller is in turn controlled by timelock (1 d delay) 0x8E31eFdA4453494a84Fa6168D53Eb1418c0b4aC4.",
    "recordId": "yieldfi-control-plane",
    "surface": "YieldFi yUSD (YToken) · EIP-1967 Proxy & Controller Chain"
   },
   "factors": [
    {
     "evidence": "yieldfi-control-plane: is_eip1967_proxy = true",
     "key": "upgrade",
     "label": "Upgradeability",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "Upgradeable; the delay gating the upgrade path is not in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": "controller fact: getMinDelay() = 86400s",
     "key": "timelock",
     "label": "Timelock floor",
     "state": "b",
     "value": "1d minimum enforced delay across control surfaces"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "quorum",
     "label": "Signer quorum",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No signer quorum in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "emergency",
     "label": "Emergency / freeze scope",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No pause / freeze authority in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "parity",
     "label": "Docs-vs-chain parity",
     "state": "u",
     "value": "Uncompared: documentation not assessed (RPC-observed)"
    }
   ],
   "finding": "YieldFi yUSD (YToken) · EIP-1967 Proxy & Controller Chain",
   "grade": "observed",
   "gradeLabel": "OBSERVED",
   "name": "YieldFi",
   "pinnedBlock": 26458556,
   "probe": {
    "block_hash": "0xe258bb1cbcc988e2dfdba4ba173f9f8690520dba3647cdcae18e0651822769d2",
    "block_number": 26458556,
    "call_args": [],
    "call_signature": null,
    "chain": "ethereum",
    "check_type": "eth_getStorageAt",
    "extra_calls": [],
    "id": "yieldfi-control-plane",
    "repro_calldata": null,
    "rpc_env_var": "$ETH_RPC_URL",
    "selector_or_slot": "0xb53127684a568b3173ae13b9f8a6016e243e63b6e8ee1178d6a717850b5d6103",
    "target_contract": "0x19Ebd191f7A24ECE672ba13A302212b5eF7F35cb",
    "target_label": "YieldFi yUSD (YToken)"
   },
   "reconciled": false,
   "reconciledFrom": [],
   "reconciledTo": [],
   "records": 1,
   "rosetteAria": "YieldFi control-plane rosette: Upgradeability not determined; Timelock floor moderate; Signer quorum not determined; Emergency / freeze scope not determined; Docs-vs-chain parity uncompared",
   "search": "yieldfi yieldfi tokenized asset-management products for stablecoin yield (ethereum) yusd 0x19ebd191f7a24ece672ba13a302212b5ef7f35cb 0x5bf44d32260aee6b807c490e92ef0481d15ab493 0x8e31efda4453494a84fa6168d53eb1418c0b4ac4 0xe26e1d2ae51dcb89e382ca7400b080e6632117b9",
   "slug": "yieldfi",
   "summary_short": "Upgradeable proxy controlled by a contract; docs not assessed",
   "url": "https://pacta.wtf/protocols/yieldfi/"
  },
  {
   "baskets": [
    "eth_lst_lrt",
    "lending_vaults"
   ],
   "category": "Liquid Restaking Vaults (Ethereum)",
   "chains": [
    "ethereum"
   ],
   "deltas": 1,
   "easAttested": true,
   "evidence": {
    "documented": "'YNDelegator 2/3 0xDF51B7843817F76220C0970eF58Ba726630028eF' / 'Delegates the EigenPods to the operators' (docs.yieldnest.finance/security/roles.md)",
    "observed": "YNDelegator Safe 0xDF51B7843817F76220C0970eF58Ba726630028eF (Ethereum): getThreshold() = 2 of getOwners() = 4 owners (Safe v1.3.0).",
    "recordId": "yieldnest-safe-threshold-df51b7-s26",
    "surface": "YNDelegator (delegates the eigenpods to the operators): docs state 2-of-3, the Safe is 2-of-4"
   },
   "factors": [
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "upgrade",
     "label": "Upgradeability",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "Upgrade path not in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "timelock",
     "label": "Timelock floor",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No enforced admin delay in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": "controller fact: Safe getThreshold()",
     "key": "quorum",
     "label": "Signer quorum",
     "state": "b",
     "value": "Lowest controlling quorum: 2-of-4"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "emergency",
     "label": "Emergency / freeze scope",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No pause / freeze authority in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "parity",
     "label": "Docs-vs-chain parity",
     "state": "a",
     "value": "Documentation differs from the chain (parameter delta)"
    }
   ],
   "finding": "YNDelegator (delegates the eigenpods to the operators): docs state 2-of-3, the Safe is 2-of-4: docs say 'YNDelegator 2/3 0xDF51B7843817F76220C0970eF58Ba726630028eF' / 'Delegates the EigenPods to the operators' (docs.yieldnest.finance/security/roles.md) · chain says YNDelegator Safe 0xDF51B7843817F76220C0970eF58Ba726630028eF (Ethereum): getThreshold() = 2 of getOwners() = 4 owners (Safe v1.3.0).",
   "grade": "delta",
   "gradeLabel": "DELTA",
   "name": "YieldNest",
   "pinnedBlock": 26438867,
   "probe": {
    "block_hash": "0x6c477521320837df8611249a255cb7142052874937cddb9fe568f685763458ff",
    "block_number": 26438867,
    "call_args": [],
    "call_signature": "getThreshold()",
    "chain": "ethereum",
    "check_type": "eth_call",
    "extra_calls": [],
    "id": "yieldnest-safe-threshold-df51b7-s26",
    "repro_calldata": "0xe75235b8",
    "rpc_env_var": "$ETH_RPC_URL",
    "selector_or_slot": "0xe75235b8",
    "target_contract": "0xDF51B7843817F76220C0970eF58Ba726630028eF",
    "target_label": "YNDelegator Safe"
   },
   "reconciled": false,
   "reconciledFrom": [],
   "reconciledTo": [],
   "records": 2,
   "rosetteAria": "YieldNest control-plane rosette: Upgradeability not determined; Timelock floor not determined; Signer quorum moderate; Emergency / freeze scope not determined; Docs-vs-chain parity weak",
   "search": "yieldnest yieldnest liquid restaking vaults (ethereum) ynd 0xdf51b7843817f76220c0970ef58ba726630028ef 0xfcad670592a3b24869c0b51a6c6fded4f95d6975",
   "slug": "yieldnest",
   "summary_short": "Docs state a 2-of-3 YNDelegator; the YieldNest Safe is 2-of-4",
   "url": "https://pacta.wtf/protocols/yieldnest/"
  },
  {
   "baskets": [
    "base",
    "lending_vaults"
   ],
   "category": "Cross-Chain Yield Optimizer Vaults",
   "chains": [
    "base"
   ],
   "deltas": 1,
   "easAttested": true,
   "evidence": {
    "documented": "docs.yo.xyz (YO V2 Security Framework): 'Approval Registry: Onchain, timelocked caps on how much of each asset a vault may approve to each contract' and 'Every path a dollar can take is written into immutable adapters and timelocked registries'",
    "observed": "YoApprovalRegistry 0xB4b3F5C964A360bBd7201f72a55D0c48B8aD7021: owner() = YO Admin Multisig 0x67b6F699F1c8040414032a3C2C88a54db144FCd2 (4-of-6 Safe, v1.4.1, no modules), not the YO Timelock 0x38cE5e45D0f5d03E83863bb19B3b1A272C186F48; pendingOwner() = 0; not a proxy (Sourcify exact match). It is the approvalRegistry() of yoETH 0x3A43AEC53490CB9Fa922847385D82fe25d0E9De7 and yoUSD 0x0000000f2eB9f69274678c76222B35eEc7588a65; the Pool, BridgeRoute, MorphoMarket, SwapPair and ERC4626Vault registries are also owned directly by the Admin Multisig.",
    "recordId": "yo-protocol-approval-registry-owner-admin-safe-s22",
    "surface": "Approval Registry owner: the Admin Multisig directly, not the 48-hour timelock"
   },
   "factors": [
    {
     "evidence": "yo-protocol-vault-upgrades-behind-timelock-s22: yoETH 0x3A43AEC53490CB9Fa922847385D82fe25d0E9De7: EIP-1967 admin = ProxyAdmin 0xd460CF1f5D764acAD1c3276c549EE5f1BB671473, owner() = YO Timelock …",
     "key": "upgrade",
     "label": "Upgradeability",
     "state": "g",
     "value": "Upgradeable behind a ≥48h delay (2d)"
    },
    {
     "evidence": "yo-protocol-approval-registry-owner-admin-safe-s22: observed_delay_seconds = 0",
     "key": "timelock",
     "label": "Timelock floor",
     "state": "a",
     "value": "0s minimum enforced delay across control surfaces"
    },
    {
     "evidence": "yo-protocol-approval-registry-owner-admin-safe-s22: … 0x67b6F699F1c8040414032a3C2C88a54db144FCd2 (4-of-6 Safe, v1.4.1, no modules), not the …",
     "key": "quorum",
     "label": "Signer quorum",
     "state": "g",
     "value": "Lowest controlling quorum: 4-of-6"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "emergency",
     "label": "Emergency / freeze scope",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No pause / freeze authority in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "parity",
     "label": "Docs-vs-chain parity",
     "state": "a",
     "value": "Documentation differs from the chain (parameter delta)"
    }
   ],
   "finding": "Timelock delay: docs say 2 d · chain says 0 s (no delay)",
   "grade": "delta",
   "gradeLabel": "DELTA",
   "name": "YO Protocol",
   "pinnedBlock": 58315414,
   "probe": {
    "block_hash": "0x5092b494a9f8555faecfaa0f49202536e0edcf26f2bdc6e25a563442258119cd",
    "block_number": 58315414,
    "call_args": [],
    "call_signature": "owner()",
    "chain": "base",
    "check_type": "eth_call",
    "extra_calls": [],
    "id": "yo-protocol-approval-registry-owner-admin-safe-s22",
    "repro_calldata": "0x8da5cb5b",
    "rpc_env_var": "$BASE_RPC_URL",
    "selector_or_slot": "0x8da5cb5b",
    "target_contract": "0xB4b3F5C964A360bBd7201f72a55D0c48B8aD7021",
    "target_label": "YoApprovalRegistry"
   },
   "reconciled": false,
   "reconciledFrom": [],
   "reconciledTo": [],
   "records": 3,
   "rosetteAria": "YO Protocol control-plane rosette: Upgradeability strong; Timelock floor weak; Signer quorum strong; Emergency / freeze scope not determined; Docs-vs-chain parity weak",
   "search": "yo protocol yo-protocol cross-chain yield optimizer vaults yoeth yousd yo 0x0000000f2eb9f69274678c76222b35eec7588a65 0x12e81209d180ff0b3fbfbfe8fa9ffdb5990e1073 0x38ce5e45d0f5d03e83863bb19b3b1a272c186f48 0x3a43aec53490cb9fa922847385d82fe25d0e9de7 0x67b6f699f1c8040414032a3c2c88a54db144fcd2 0xb4b3f5c964a360bbd7201f72a55d0c48b8ad7021 0xc84a6e01bff58996540f1abc22355a9dfe0d78dc 0xd460cf1f5d764acad1c3276c549ee5f1bb671473",
   "slug": "yo-protocol",
   "summary_short": "Timelock delay: docs 2 days · chain none",
   "url": "https://pacta.wtf/protocols/yo-protocol/"
  },
  {
   "baskets": [
    "lending_vaults",
    "stable_rwa"
   ],
   "category": "Overcollateralized stablecoin backed by curated strategies (Ethereum)",
   "chains": [
    "ethereum"
   ],
   "deltas": 0,
   "easAttested": false,
   "evidence": {
    "documented": "Yuzu Money documentation is linked for reference (https://app.yuzu.money/docs). This RPC-pinned record does not compare documentation parameters with the on-chain state.",
    "observed": "Yuzu Cash (YuzuILPV3) (0x224e90591A2d63fb66E677D0561Ea4A6Ad1F098D) verified on Ethereum Mainnet at canonical block #26,458,556 (793 bytes runtime code). EIP-1967 proxy: implementation 0x577C202011Dd122Bcb0ad1bf4a71e01E9F999b68, admin 0x1af1878e8d9E7263236529eCAdAcD345781538d0. The EIP-1967 admin slot holds contract ProxyAdmin 0x1af1878e8d9E7263236529eCAdAcD345781538d0. That controller is in turn controlled by timelock (2 d delay) 0xD2160Ad387C592010650B3BFE14a5e1A17DC7E5e.",
    "recordId": "yuzu-money-control-plane",
    "surface": "Yuzu Cash (YuzuILPV3) · EIP-1967 Proxy & Controller Chain"
   },
   "factors": [
    {
     "evidence": "yuzu-money-control-plane: Yuzu Cash (YuzuILPV3) (0x224e90591A2d63fb66E677D0561Ea4A6Ad1F098D) verified on Ethereum Mainnet at canonical block #26,458,556 (793 bytes runtime code). …",
     "key": "upgrade",
     "label": "Upgradeability",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "Upgradeable; the delay gating the upgrade path is not in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": "controller fact: getMinDelay() = 172800s",
     "key": "timelock",
     "label": "Timelock floor",
     "state": "g",
     "value": "2d minimum enforced delay across control surfaces"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "quorum",
     "label": "Signer quorum",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No signer quorum in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "emergency",
     "label": "Emergency / freeze scope",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No pause / freeze authority in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "parity",
     "label": "Docs-vs-chain parity",
     "state": "u",
     "value": "Uncompared: documentation not assessed (RPC-observed)"
    }
   ],
   "finding": "Yuzu Cash (YuzuILPV3) · EIP-1967 Proxy & Controller Chain",
   "grade": "observed",
   "gradeLabel": "OBSERVED",
   "name": "Yuzu Money",
   "pinnedBlock": 26458556,
   "probe": {
    "block_hash": "0xe258bb1cbcc988e2dfdba4ba173f9f8690520dba3647cdcae18e0651822769d2",
    "block_number": 26458556,
    "call_args": [],
    "call_signature": null,
    "chain": "ethereum",
    "check_type": "eth_getStorageAt",
    "extra_calls": [],
    "id": "yuzu-money-control-plane",
    "repro_calldata": null,
    "rpc_env_var": "$ETH_RPC_URL",
    "selector_or_slot": "0xb53127684a568b3173ae13b9f8a6016e243e63b6e8ee1178d6a717850b5d6103",
    "target_contract": "0x224e90591A2d63fb66E677D0561Ea4A6Ad1F098D",
    "target_label": "Yuzu Cash (YuzuILPV3)"
   },
   "reconciled": false,
   "reconciledFrom": [],
   "reconciledTo": [],
   "records": 1,
   "rosetteAria": "Yuzu Money control-plane rosette: Upgradeability not determined; Timelock floor strong; Signer quorum not determined; Emergency / freeze scope not determined; Docs-vs-chain parity uncompared",
   "search": "yuzu money yuzu-money overcollateralized stablecoin backed by curated strategies (ethereum) yzcash 0x1af1878e8d9e7263236529ecadacd345781538d0 0x224e90591a2d63fb66e677d0561ea4a6ad1f098d 0x577c202011dd122bcb0ad1bf4a71e01e9f999b68 0xd2160ad387c592010650b3bfe14a5e1a17dc7e5e",
   "slug": "yuzu-money",
   "summary_short": "Upgradeable proxy controlled by a contract; docs not assessed",
   "url": "https://pacta.wtf/protocols/yuzu-money/"
  },
  {
   "baskets": [],
   "category": "Fully Homomorphic Encryption Network Token (Ethereum)",
   "chains": [
    "ethereum"
   ],
   "deltas": 0,
   "easAttested": true,
   "evidence": {
    "documented": "'**Some contracts cannot be upgraded**: $ZAMA token' (docs.zama.org/protocol/protocol-apps/governance/governance.md); '| Zama Token       | [`0xA12CC123ba206d4031D1c7f6223D1C2Ec249f4f3`]' (docs.zama.org/protocol/protocol-apps/addresses/mainnet/ethereum.md)",
    "observed": "ZAMA token 0xA12CC123ba206d4031D1c7f6223D1C2Ec249f4f3 (Ethereum; not a proxy: EIP-1967 implementation, admin and beacon slots all empty; verified source): totalSupply() = 11,391,483,307.90. The runtime code holds no selector of mint(uint256), upgradeTo(address), upgradeToAndCall(address,bytes). This record checks the upgrade claim only: minting is role-gated in the token (documented as staking rewards).",
    "recordId": "zama-token-not-upgradeable-s33",
    "surface": "ZAMA token: not a proxy, no upgrade function"
   },
   "factors": [
    {
     "evidence": "zama-token-not-upgradeable-s33: ZAMA token 0xA12CC123ba206d4031D1c7f6223D1C2Ec249f4f3 (Ethereum; not a proxy: EIP-1967 implementation, admin and beacon slots all empty; verified source) …",
     "key": "upgrade",
     "label": "Upgradeability",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "Upgradeable; the delay gating the upgrade path is not in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "timelock",
     "label": "Timelock floor",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No enforced admin delay in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "quorum",
     "label": "Signer quorum",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No signer quorum in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "emergency",
     "label": "Emergency / freeze scope",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No pause / freeze authority in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "parity",
     "label": "Docs-vs-chain parity",
     "state": "g",
     "value": "Chain matches or is stronger than the documentation"
    }
   ],
   "finding": "ZAMA token: not a proxy, no upgrade function",
   "grade": "aligned",
   "gradeLabel": "ALIGNED",
   "name": "Zama",
   "pinnedBlock": 26452373,
   "probe": {
    "block_hash": "0x63bfaa16f0019d8b37e757265d351bd135ad41e6ffa46207284198917123c55d",
    "block_number": 26452373,
    "call_args": [],
    "call_signature": "totalSupply()",
    "chain": "ethereum",
    "check_type": "eth_call",
    "extra_calls": [],
    "id": "zama-token-not-upgradeable-s33",
    "repro_calldata": "0x18160ddd",
    "rpc_env_var": "$ETH_RPC_URL",
    "selector_or_slot": "0x18160ddd",
    "target_contract": "0xA12CC123ba206d4031D1c7f6223D1C2Ec249f4f3",
    "target_label": "ZAMA token"
   },
   "reconciled": false,
   "reconciledFrom": [],
   "reconciledTo": [],
   "records": 1,
   "rosetteAria": "Zama control-plane rosette: Upgradeability not determined; Timelock floor not determined; Signer quorum not determined; Emergency / freeze scope not determined; Docs-vs-chain parity strong",
   "search": "zama zama fully homomorphic encryption network token (ethereum) zama 0xa12cc123ba206d4031d1c7f6223d1c2ec249f4f3",
   "slug": "zama",
   "summary_short": "The ZAMA token cannot be upgraded, as documented",
   "url": "https://pacta.wtf/protocols/zama/"
  },
  {
   "baskets": [
    "eth_lst_lrt",
    "stable_rwa"
   ],
   "category": "zk-Proven Stablecoin Staking (Ethereum)",
   "chains": [
    "ethereum"
   ],
   "deltas": 0,
   "easAttested": false,
   "evidence": {
    "documented": "ZEROBASE CeDeFi documentation is linked for reference (https://app.zerobase.pro/en). This RPC-pinned record does not compare documentation parameters with the on-chain state.",
    "observed": "ZEROBASE (0xfAB99fCF605fD8f4593EDb70A43bA56542777777) verified on Ethereum Mainnet at canonical block #26,458,556 (23,055 bytes runtime code). EIP-1967 implementation and admin storage slots are both zero (non-EIP-1967 contract). Direct owner() returns Safe 2-of-3 0xa14f20130E9a0a27D580FD30FD4bbF035a492AB2.",
    "recordId": "zerobase-cedefi-control-plane",
    "surface": "ZEROBASE · Non-Proxy Bytecode & Controller"
   },
   "factors": [
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "upgrade",
     "label": "Upgradeability",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "Upgrade path not in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "timelock",
     "label": "Timelock floor",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No enforced admin delay in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": "zerobase-cedefi-control-plane: … contract). Direct owner() returns Safe 2-of-3 0xa14f20130E9a0a27D580FD30FD4bbF035a492AB2.",
     "key": "quorum",
     "label": "Signer quorum",
     "state": "b",
     "value": "Lowest controlling quorum: 2-of-3"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "emergency",
     "label": "Emergency / freeze scope",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No pause / freeze authority in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "parity",
     "label": "Docs-vs-chain parity",
     "state": "u",
     "value": "Uncompared: documentation not assessed (RPC-observed)"
    }
   ],
   "finding": "ZEROBASE · Non-Proxy Bytecode & Controller",
   "grade": "observed",
   "gradeLabel": "OBSERVED",
   "name": "ZEROBASE CeDeFi",
   "pinnedBlock": 26458556,
   "probe": {
    "block_hash": "0xe258bb1cbcc988e2dfdba4ba173f9f8690520dba3647cdcae18e0651822769d2",
    "block_number": 26458556,
    "call_args": [],
    "call_signature": "owner()",
    "chain": "ethereum",
    "check_type": "eth_call",
    "extra_calls": [],
    "id": "zerobase-cedefi-control-plane",
    "repro_calldata": "0x8da5cb5b",
    "rpc_env_var": "$ETH_RPC_URL",
    "selector_or_slot": "0x8da5cb5b",
    "target_contract": "0xfAB99fCF605fD8f4593EDb70A43bA56542777777",
    "target_label": "ZEROBASE"
   },
   "reconciled": false,
   "reconciledFrom": [],
   "reconciledTo": [],
   "records": 1,
   "rosetteAria": "ZEROBASE CeDeFi control-plane rosette: Upgradeability not determined; Timelock floor not determined; Signer quorum moderate; Emergency / freeze scope not determined; Docs-vs-chain parity uncompared",
   "search": "zerobase cedefi zerobase-cedefi zk-proven stablecoin staking (ethereum) zbt 0xa14f20130e9a0a27d580fd30fd4bbf035a492ab2 0xfab99fcf605fd8f4593edb70a43ba56542777777",
   "slug": "zerobase-cedefi",
   "summary_short": "Non-proxy contract controlled by a 2-of-3 Safe; docs not assessed",
   "url": "https://pacta.wtf/protocols/zerobase-cedefi/"
  },
  {
   "baskets": [],
   "category": "Pre-launch liquidity pool bootstrapping a rollup's day-one deposits (Ethereum)",
   "chains": [
    "ethereum"
   ],
   "deltas": 1,
   "easAttested": true,
   "evidence": {
    "documented": "'`6/8` means at least six out of eight owners need to sign the message. * Multisig 1: `6/8`' (docs.zircuit.com/info/security/privileged-roles.md)",
    "observed": "Zircuit Staking Safe 0xC463EaC02572CC964D43D2414023E2c6B62bAF38 (Ethereum): getThreshold() = 4 of getOwners() = 6 owners (Safe v1.3.0).",
    "recordId": "zircuit-staking-safe-threshold-s28",
    "surface": "Zircuit Staking multisig: docs state 6-of-8, the Safe is 4-of-6"
   },
   "factors": [
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "upgrade",
     "label": "Upgradeability",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "Upgrade path not in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "timelock",
     "label": "Timelock floor",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No enforced admin delay in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": "controller fact: Safe getThreshold()",
     "key": "quorum",
     "label": "Signer quorum",
     "state": "g",
     "value": "Lowest controlling quorum: 4-of-6"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "emergency",
     "label": "Emergency / freeze scope",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No pause / freeze authority in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "parity",
     "label": "Docs-vs-chain parity",
     "state": "a",
     "value": "Documentation differs from the chain (parameter delta)"
    }
   ],
   "finding": "Zircuit Staking multisig: docs state 6-of-8, the Safe is 4-of-6: docs say '`6/8` means at least six out of eight owners need to sign the message. · chain says Zircuit Staking Safe 0xC463EaC02572CC964D43D2414023E2c6B62bAF38 (Ethereum): getThreshold() = 4 of getOwners() = 6 owners (Safe v1.3.0).",
   "grade": "delta",
   "gradeLabel": "DELTA",
   "name": "Zircuit Staking",
   "pinnedBlock": 26441165,
   "probe": {
    "block_hash": "0x5182be2c61af5f48ed2ec43d3c177dedad257c4e966a7e384120829de73901d9",
    "block_number": 26441165,
    "call_args": [],
    "call_signature": "getThreshold()",
    "chain": "ethereum",
    "check_type": "eth_call",
    "extra_calls": [],
    "id": "zircuit-staking-safe-threshold-s28",
    "repro_calldata": "0xe75235b8",
    "rpc_env_var": "$ETH_RPC_URL",
    "selector_or_slot": "0xe75235b8",
    "target_contract": "0xC463EaC02572CC964D43D2414023E2c6B62bAF38",
    "target_label": "Zircuit Staking Safe"
   },
   "reconciled": false,
   "reconciledFrom": [],
   "reconciledTo": [],
   "records": 1,
   "rosetteAria": "Zircuit Staking control-plane rosette: Upgradeability not determined; Timelock floor not determined; Signer quorum strong; Emergency / freeze scope not determined; Docs-vs-chain parity weak",
   "search": "zircuit staking zircuit-staking pre-launch liquidity pool bootstrapping a rollup's day-one deposits (ethereum) zircuit 0xc463eac02572cc964d43d2414023e2c6b62baf38",
   "slug": "zircuit-staking",
   "summary_short": "Docs state a 6-of-8 multisig; the Zircuit Staking Safe is 4-of-6",
   "url": "https://pacta.wtf/protocols/zircuit-staking/"
  },
  {
   "baskets": [
    "base"
   ],
   "category": "Canonical bridge into a creator-focused OP Stack L2 (Base)",
   "chains": [
    "base"
   ],
   "deltas": 0,
   "easAttested": false,
   "evidence": {
    "documented": "Zora Bridge documentation is linked for reference (https://docs.zora.co/). This RPC-pinned record does not compare documentation parameters with the on-chain state.",
    "observed": "Zora (0x1111111111166b7FE7bd91427724B487980aFc69) verified on Base Mainnet at canonical block #60,070,202 (12,018 bytes runtime code). EIP-1967 implementation and admin storage slots are both zero (non-EIP-1967 contract). No owner(), admin(), authority(), curator() or AccessControl admin was readable on the contract.",
    "recordId": "zora-bridge-control-plane",
    "surface": "Zora · Non-Proxy Bytecode & Controller"
   },
   "factors": [
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "upgrade",
     "label": "Upgradeability",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "Upgrade path not in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "timelock",
     "label": "Timelock floor",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No enforced admin delay in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "quorum",
     "label": "Signer quorum",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No signer quorum in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "emergency",
     "label": "Emergency / freeze scope",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No pause / freeze authority in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "parity",
     "label": "Docs-vs-chain parity",
     "state": "u",
     "value": "Uncompared: documentation not assessed (RPC-observed)"
    }
   ],
   "finding": "Zora · Non-Proxy Bytecode & Controller",
   "grade": "observed",
   "gradeLabel": "OBSERVED",
   "name": "Zora Bridge",
   "pinnedBlock": 60070202,
   "probe": {
    "block_hash": "0x01b3f5dcecb67c63ba33350ec6942563f6b8a0d8ca9b4f69a752844a5bab4a20",
    "block_number": 60070202,
    "call_args": [],
    "call_signature": "owner()",
    "chain": "base",
    "check_type": "eth_call",
    "extra_calls": [],
    "id": "zora-bridge-control-plane",
    "repro_calldata": "0x8da5cb5b",
    "rpc_env_var": "$BASE_RPC_URL",
    "selector_or_slot": "0x8da5cb5b",
    "target_contract": "0x1111111111166b7FE7bd91427724B487980aFc69",
    "target_label": "Zora"
   },
   "reconciled": false,
   "reconciledFrom": [],
   "reconciledTo": [],
   "records": 1,
   "rosetteAria": "Zora Bridge control-plane rosette: Upgradeability not determined; Timelock floor not determined; Signer quorum not determined; Emergency / freeze scope not determined; Docs-vs-chain parity uncompared",
   "search": "zora bridge zora-bridge canonical bridge into a creator-focused op stack l2 (base) zora 0x1111111111166b7fe7bd91427724b487980afc69",
   "slug": "zora-bridge",
   "summary_short": "Non-proxy contract no readable owner or admin; docs not assessed",
   "url": "https://pacta.wtf/protocols/zora-bridge/"
  },
  {
   "baskets": [
    "eth_lst_lrt"
   ],
   "category": "Tokenized liquid notes for real-world-asset restaking (Ethereum)",
   "chains": [
    "ethereum"
   ],
   "deltas": 0,
   "easAttested": false,
   "evidence": {
    "documented": "ZTLN-P documentation is linked for reference (https://docs.zoth.io/zoth). This RPC-pinned record does not compare documentation parameters with the on-chain state.",
    "observed": "Zoth Tokenized Liquid Notes Prime (ZTLNPrime) (0xfEd3D6557Dc46A1B25d0A6F666513Cb33835864B) verified on Ethereum Mainnet at canonical block #26,458,556 (93 bytes runtime code). EIP-1967 proxy: implementation 0xf5429683A15340a859dFdbD1B2De37b1ea77c2d5, admin slot zero. No owner(), admin(), authority(), curator() or AccessControl admin was readable on the contract.",
    "recordId": "ztln-p-control-plane",
    "surface": "Zoth Tokenized Liquid Notes Prime (ZTLNPrime) · EIP-1967 Proxy & Controller Chain"
   },
   "factors": [
    {
     "evidence": "ztln-p-control-plane: is_eip1967_proxy = true",
     "key": "upgrade",
     "label": "Upgradeability",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "Upgradeable; the delay gating the upgrade path is not in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "timelock",
     "label": "Timelock floor",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No enforced admin delay in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "quorum",
     "label": "Signer quorum",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No signer quorum in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "emergency",
     "label": "Emergency / freeze scope",
     "state": "n",
     "value": "No pause / freeze authority in the published records"
    },
    {
     "evidence": null,
     "key": "parity",
     "label": "Docs-vs-chain parity",
     "state": "u",
     "value": "Uncompared: documentation not assessed (RPC-observed)"
    }
   ],
   "finding": "Zoth Tokenized Liquid Notes Prime (ZTLNPrime) · EIP-1967 Proxy & Controller Chain",
   "grade": "observed",
   "gradeLabel": "OBSERVED",
   "name": "ZTLN-P",
   "pinnedBlock": 26458556,
   "probe": {
    "block_hash": "0xe258bb1cbcc988e2dfdba4ba173f9f8690520dba3647cdcae18e0651822769d2",
    "block_number": 26458556,
    "call_args": [],
    "call_signature": "owner()",
    "chain": "ethereum",
    "check_type": "eth_call",
    "extra_calls": [],
    "id": "ztln-p-control-plane",
    "repro_calldata": "0x8da5cb5b",
    "rpc_env_var": "$ETH_RPC_URL",
    "selector_or_slot": "0x8da5cb5b",
    "target_contract": "0xfEd3D6557Dc46A1B25d0A6F666513Cb33835864B",
    "target_label": "Zoth Tokenized Liquid Notes Prime (ZTLNPrime)"
   },
   "reconciled": false,
   "reconciledFrom": [],
   "reconciledTo": [],
   "records": 1,
   "rosetteAria": "ZTLN-P control-plane rosette: Upgradeability not determined; Timelock floor not determined; Signer quorum not determined; Emergency / freeze scope not determined; Docs-vs-chain parity uncompared",
   "search": "ztln-p ztln-p tokenized liquid notes for real-world-asset restaking (ethereum) ztln 0xf5429683a15340a859dfdbd1b2de37b1ea77c2d5 0xfed3d6557dc46a1b25d0a6f666513cb33835864b",
   "slug": "ztln-p",
   "summary_short": "Upgradeable proxy no readable owner or admin; docs not assessed",
   "url": "https://pacta.wtf/protocols/ztln-p/"
  }
 ],
 "schema": "pacta.scorecards.v1"
}
